Feuillade/Lang/Hitchcock on Presence (Patreon)
Content
The line of relation in a certain tradition of cinema is not the linear progression of one, two, three, but rather two, one, three – the world here begins with relation, conceals into monism, reveals into a triad, and finally, becomes something much stranger.
An explanation via the cinemas of Feuillade, Lang, Hitchcock:
Feuillade’s navigation of his world contains two central components which orbit each other – particulars and contexts, humans and tapestry, agents and agency, the actual and the potential. In Les Vampires and Fantomas, the players are arranged in proscenium space which presents a semi-realistic milieu in the manner of stage backdrops – a desk is a desk, but the desk has no particular depth or contouring, no curvature. A woman sits on a desk and a contest is formed – not a third object, but a displacement of the space of the woman and the desk – the desk ceases to be itself, the woman is no longer a woman, and an absence is created.

This dualistic relationalism allows for surprise and mischief – sudden transfigurations of the frame are possible, raw emergence which cannot be achieved with subjective camera movement. We watch an extended scene of several men talking in a curtained room, we see them leave the room, assuming the action of the scene is over – but instead, a black-figured thief emerges from behind the previously static curtains, and walks over to steal something in the room. We are thrown into a space where relations are always in flux because there is no hierarchy within the image, everything is presented with equal potency – the men talking form one kind of activity, and the room itself is also active, asserting its presence through random and unexpected fluctuations – its relative placidity conceals a negative space in which new forms can be born from the pregnancy of stillness.
Feuillade’s cinematic world is a space and its negation, a space of clear presence and a space of absence which is also an abscess of meaning – the non-existence of forms is not the lack of forms here, but the dissolution of individual figures into a collative silence. Absence itself is able to exert presence because it, at any point in the film, can burst forth with unseen elements which have not been telegraphed in advance – this is a world of pure anarchy, a war of all-against-all, of figures battling their environment’s capacity for emergence which could upset the relations of an already-existing presence – one person could become two persons by a figure leaping down from a balcony, or two persons could become one as a body is hidden in a chest and melds into the ambiguous semi-presence of the environment. By flattening the image into two relations which are constantly in flux, Feuillade’s cinema is a cinema which always holds the potential for continuation, as theoretically anything can happen within these spaces – the quality of newness is standardized, transformed from ‘the next part of a sequence’ into ‘the unseen of what is being seen’ – this, to my mind, is the definition of a pure and infinite cinema, a cinema without borders or boundaries.
Fritz Lang brings secular monism into cinema, a kind of occult materialism which manifests as conspiracy – all his movies operate on the emanationist model derived from theology, models which depend on first principles – principles which Lang is always at pains to conceal, as the centers of his universes are dubious demiurges whose personal flaws seem to reflect the systemic flaws which extend thus from them – it is a semi-Lovecraftian view that holds his films together, a notion that the truth of existence is too horrible and singular to ever face directly, and thus the paranoiac’s quest for the truth is one which leads to annihilation or an equally-arbitrary divinization.
Mabuse is naturally the preeminent master of ceremonies here and provides the formula for Lang’s monistic oeuvre – Mabuse himself exerts a hypnotic control over all he surveys, navigates upper and lower class society, surrounds himself with lackeys and minions who accomplish his will on his behalf, his own legion of dirty angels – Mabuse extends in all directions and scenes, and his spectral presence is never not felt even when he is not physically visible, it’s the inversion of Feuillade in a very basic sense – Feuillade had force, counter-force, move, block, climb, fall, a basic realism which contended with a context that possessed a forever war between the legions of order and chaos, presence and absence, no real winner in sight, a love of conflict itself. Lang’s form of presence via absence is eternal in an absolutist way – even when Mabuse goes insane and is locked up, he still remains at the center of Lang’s cinema, a cinema governed by a mad god – in The Testament of Dr. Mabuse, he is literally a ghost, there is no man behind the curtain, the conspiracy is created by a destroyed man who, in becoming a spirit, is able to be everywhere in the film without being directly present – this is a presence which, far from being at war with absence and potentiality, actually is only able to fully become omni-present by dispersing itself into the potentiality of absence – Mabuse the Man dies in a mocking fashion so that Mabuse the Notion may mold men’s minds freely, unfettered by physical law.

Feuillade’s back-and-forth anarchy gives way to Lang’s monopoly of ideology – he makes non-Mabuse films which nevertheless feature Mabuse’s spectre in them, the spectre of the law, the mob, the state, the system of control and surveillance and tyranny which subjects everything to a monolithic will. His protagonists fall bit-by-bit into the terrible truth that their world is controlled by an insane maniac – they follow the odd coincidences, the traces of evidence, the path of hints and back alleys where power moves, arteries in the body of the prima-fascist, and they are always shattered by this quest – Rancho Notorious ends in broken hearts and betrayal, the only rational response to living in an irrational Langian world is to murder, temporarily escape, or go mad – his monism leaves no room for anything in his films to remain pure or untainted. Even the pure maiden of Metropolis is perverted into a satanic robot – nothing in his world is able to leave the iron boundaries that he sets up for it, and every conflict is a false skirmish of fools who are all being controlled by outside powers. In Feuillade, at least the game was afoot – but there is no game to be played in Lang, it’s permanently fatalist to the core.
Hitchcock arrives at a dilution of both by providing a means from escaping the infinite regress of Feuillade or the mono-mania of Lang – Hitchcock conflates the presence-of-absence with the viewer itself, and turns his audience into the Langian god who presides over the squirming Feuilladian ants of the silver screen. It’s an ingenious cop-out – in Hitchcock, there’s always a guiltless party caught between two warring elements, usually spies vs. spies or police vs. criminals or men vs. women, but we aren’t placed within that war, we’re always perceiving it from a perceive within the film itself, this voyeuristic party. Hitchcock creates a cinema-within-cinema by doing this – just think of James Stewart’s hobbled gaze in Rear Window, who sets himself up as a human surveillance camera within his apartment and regards the action from without instead of from within.

But Hitchcock does a great gag here – he always crashes the party of his ‘innocent’ parties. Firstly, they’re rarely saints and often are jerks of some description, even perverted. We are always identifying with a prejudiced eye, so what we see ends up being an image of a character’s thought, which is really Hitchcock’s thought – this is the privileged Langian perspective of a god, but now instead of that god being within the film, he is both inside it and outside it, outside with us in the audience, and as he is half-detached from the events occurring, we are half-responsible for what we’re seeing.
Hitchcock defers cinema from being an act of display – the events on the screen are occurring in their own spaces – to being an act of morality – the events on the screen are occurring for the viewer. This is why all his films are filed to the brim with psycho-babble and leering and unfulfilled desires and whatever – by psychoanalyzing these third party perspective characters, he really is diagnosing the viewer, diagnosing Lang’s mad god as it were.
But what about cinema itself? This is my problem with where Hitchcock took things – so much of mainstream cinema afterwards has been about managing the perception of the audience, trying to trick them or surprise them or tell them some truth in a didactic fashion by implicating them in a storytelling capacity, which is why now so much of movie culture is about taste cultivation and cultural chauvinism. If you like THIS, you’re a bad person, if you like THAT, you’re perverted, and then we have the other part which then inverts and tries to make those labels into identities which one can be proud of… which doesn’t really do anything, in the final analysis, but shift the discussion back on the other foot. And then no one’s really talking about cinema, but about our relations and perceptions of cinema – cinema becomes a space for non-cinematic observation. By making his films about his audience, Hitchcock fed into a kind of solipsistic narcissism that has no reference point for anything but its own action – and in the end, a movie gets reduced to a series of signifers and references, and we lose the presence of a film’s world by becoming that film’s absence, by becoming its void.
That’s only one of the answers to what Hitchcock did, though. Feuillade made the cinema about dynamism, Lang made it about ideology, and Hitchcock made it about perception of those things – but cinema is just as much about the perception of the camera as it is about the perception of the audience. To reduce cinema to its human terms is to miss out on the fact that cinema has a machine component, a non-human part which intersects with the human – what if Hitchcock, instead of making his films about controlling and flattering his audience, used the same techniques to distance us from what was going on – voyeurism involves the principle of interest, the drawing of the gaze to a particular thing for a particular purpose, but the opposite of that would be spreading the gaze to no element above the other elements and allow us to re-enter the world of Feuillade, but in a more advanced way – the world of the cinema would cease to be self-conscious, and would spread that consciousness into all the corners of the frame in an egalitarian fashion. Just as Hitchcock linked up the mind of the viewer to the perspective of the cinema, you could also de-couple the mind and perspective and produce a whole new style which radically reconfigures the origins of filmmaking itself away from the presence-absence dualism and towards a space of pure presence-as-such – and artists like Rivette, Antonioni, Tarkovsky, and Tsai Ming-Liang took this prompt and ran with it.
This is the origin of slow cinema, and despite my disinterest in Hitchcock, he is the one who opened the path for this type of film to exist; his example gave birth to counter-examples.

(Requested by SpyKids3D, thanks Spy!)
Files
Previews only