The Limitations of Belladonna's Sad Parable (Patreon)
Content
How can the cinema depict that which seemingly is too horrible to show? How can one coherently depict things like rape, genocide, murder, without exploiting such topics and making us banal to the ethical breach which they reveal? How can an aesthetic approach have a positive ethical effect?
What immediately comes to mind are two contrasting approaches – one which, in not wanting to flinch from the horrors of this world, strives to show them in a blunt and unromanticized manner – the exercise of style turns against itself into anti-style, a pure Bazinian exercise where the horror being shown is meant to be confrontational with what the audience is used to seeing; by not flinching from the subject matter, these films take on a documentary quality, examining events from the detached lens of a surveillance camera instead of a storytelling camera – by showing dehumanization in a dehumanized way, the ineffable power of these horrors becomes comprehensible to the mind, if not digestible to the heart.
The second approach is the cinema of metaphor – the use of implication to suggest things which the filmmaker believes cannot or should not be shown. We are shown scenarios and images which may suggest murder or rape, but the actual display of such an event is absent, and often is represented by images which poetically evoke our imaginations to fill in the blanks of what is happening – instead of a person being killed, we see a vase shattering, or a garbage can being emptied. These metaphorical images become loaded with significance, and allow the horrors to be connected with apparently unrelated things – by diffusing horror into a muted and networked set of associations, we’re allowed the emotional space to be shocked and appalled, and we’re also drawn to consider the broader implications of such things – a woman being sexually assaulted can be contrasted with systems of political power or climate change. Instead of a Bazinian immanent depth to what is directly occurring before our eyes, this Eisensteinian approach creates a dialectical wholeness that deals with the structure of an image’s form rather than the immediate details of the image itself – one concerns itself with the small picture, the other with the big picture.

Belladonna of Sadness represents a third approach – not reliant on metaphor or directness, but mythology. There is very real rape being portrayed in Belladonna – the film wastes no time in depicting such a thing as being an intrinsically apocalyptic act for the victim, an apocalypse which gradually spreads and engulfs the world around her – Belladonna’s individual suffering becomes the destruction of the society which made her suffer such a terrible experience.
Her story takes the form of a fantasy parable, well-suited to animation – the emotional reality is concurrent with the physical/spiritual reality. Belladonna is raped by a powerful mortal man, then is afterwards raped by Satan himself – one is shown as a destructive act, the second is shown as an act of rapture and transformation, her mutation into a supernatural witch who presides over plagues and orgiastic anarchy – when she’s burned at the stake during the ending, all of the spectating peasants faces transform into reflections of hers, showing that her anguish is so potent that it represents a universal discontent among the oppressed which would later bloom into the French Revolution – with women at the forefront, revolting against feudal patriarchy.
To say that this is… broad, at best, is to admit the truth. Belladonna of Sadness cares more for extravagant psychedelia, equal parts Ralph Bakshi and Aubrey Beardsley, than it cares for the implications of rape and systemic sexual violence against women. Not that every movie has to be the Bazinian approach where it’s all gritty and horrifying, but the lack of commitment here is indicative of a glib attitude, I think. Sexual violence in Belladonna of Sadness is depicted with grotesque out-sized images which are one-step removed from actual animated pornography – the poetic veneer of the animation itself is a sort of false poetry, a half-step between analogy and titillation. I don’t find much wrong with the conception of the story itself – there’s not any objectionable stances here that I could pick up on – but the leering artistry here leaves one either feeling awash in the groovy wave of 70s aesthetics, or somewhat indifferent to the proceedings.

I fall into the latter camp – Belladonna of Sadness is has maybe problems that I feel are endemic to the weird sub-genre of ‘adult animation’ which flourished in the 70s and 80s and has essentially become extinct… perhaps for a reason? Not that animation itself cannot handle topics such as sexual assault, I think that’s ridiculous to say, but given the usual parameters of Western and Eastern animation are somewhat puerile – most of which is aimed at creating fantasy worlds and children’s entertainment – can that approach be equally applied to making an animated film like Belladonna? I wonder if a different sensibility is required – when I watch Satoshi Kon’s Perfect Blue, I think that film strikes a good balance between engaging in the limitless pictorial beauty of animation while still telling a compelling story that doesn’t feel cheap or immature – Belladonna doesn’t have that assuredness, and thus impresses rather than compels. There's a bravery it has in aesthetic splendor, but it doesn't have the thematic bravery to make that splendor impactful, and the direction leans heavily on medieval tapestry-styled tableaus and still frames, which minimize the boldness of what's being depicted -- I'm not sure a film about the cruel consequences of rape should look so soft and free-flowing, there's a discrepancy of form and content here.
Much like Bakshi’s entire oeuvre, I see Belladonna as being a sort of awkward stepping stone between the expendable novelty status of early 20thcentury animation and the increasingly complex and rigorous artistry of later directors like Miyazaki and Satoshi Kon and Oshii – it’s not its fault that it’s caught in the gawky adolescence of animation as an artform, but I think it does limit the insight that one may gain from it outside of a historical perspective.
(Requested by Selena, a Patron. Thanks Selena!)
Files
Previews only