The Margins of Artistry (Patreon)
Content
The more films I see, the more my positive love for cinema intermixes with hatred, vice versa, each becoming undistinguished and melded. Films I once despised become devoted favorites, and favorites become tinged with the tarrying eye of developed critical faculty, so that one begins to adore the flaws in a picture as much as they do the strengths – the admiration grows deeper past the notion of surface accomplishment. With an origami crane, one you unfold it to understand how it is made and how it functions, you have in a sense demystified the majesty of what it takes to create it, and it becomes a routine matter of applied craft which then your inspiration can be applied to – I could make a crane in my sleep, but when I do origami nowadays, I almost always steer my hands towards folding paper various dinosaurs or crabs instead, that’s how I maintain my interest. The same principle of self-challenge has long taken over my cinephilia – there’s always another mountain to climb, another masterpiece to see, another forgotten gem amidst the rubble, another filmography to complete, another re-evaulation, more, always more. My family is full of depraved addicts, and I thankfully acquired one which isn’t as taxing on my physical body, if not my mind?
A case: His Girl Friday. My first Howard Hawks film, before I knew who Howard Hawks even was. Hawks is the classical benchmark for auteurism and thus has been long secured as a beloved artist and one of the three most well-seen directors of Hollywood’s Golden Age – to read those books from the 60s and 70s by authors like Robin Wood or Peter Bogdanovich is bound to make one feel the weight of historical progress. We’ve gone from ‘Who the hell is Howard Hawks?’ to having four of his masterpieces in the Criterion Collection – he’s far from a forgotten figure at this point due to the efforts of those who were so damn anxious that he would be forgotten, and for that, we should be thankful.
Yet I watch His Girl Friday now with a more suspicious eye – was it always this much of a theatre piece when I first saw it? It’s of course adapted from a smash-hit play by Ben Hecht and Charles MacArthur, two darling luminaries of the Golden Age, and I object to my own dogmatic aversion to theatre in cinema – His Girl Friday is cinema in every which way you can conceive of it, mostly due to Hawks’ insistence on careful invisible cutting and his blocking of actors in unique arrays to express the drama clearly to the audience. The film is darkly funny, clever, and Rosalind Russell and Cary Grant feel like the quintessential movie stars while you’re watching it. Nothing I can say will besmirch this classy entertainment.
Everything has a legacy, however. Hawks, while making the film, deliberately set out to make it feature the fastest dialogue in any picture – I’m not sure that record has ever been beaten. The overlapping lines from several different actors here make this a clear predecessor to Robert Altman’s hyper-naturalistic performances in his own films – my own first encounter with this sort of thing was with Ridley Scott’s Alien, as the crew of the Nostromo are constantly jabbering and speaking past each other to the point of frequent incoherence, and it’s doubtful whether even the most attentive viewer could see His Girl Friday once and claim to have caught every single aside. His Girl Friday contains no musical score, either – the voices would drown out the tunes, and Hawks was wise to cut to the chase, as the music in his films usually serves as fodder for montages or in-character sing-songing as in Rio Bravo’s ‘My Rifle, My Pony, and Me’. Several Hitchcock films would later also have no musical score, and it’s a much more common practice nowadays in the era of constant needle-drops and temp scoring.
I brush up against what I really mean to critique, because what that is is a subtle thing, not to be directly named in polite company, hard to put your finger on, if you’d even want to – what stood out during this latest watch was how glib the film is, how self-conscious of itself it was. Not merely mannered – although it also is that – but certainly playing on the actor’s awareness of their medium, as Cary Grant makes offhand references to Archie Leach, his own birth name, as well as describing Ralph Bellamy’s character Bruce Baldwin in these certain terms: “He looks like that fellow in the movies, you know, Ralph Bellamy!" All of these antics are played into the anarchic spirit of the film and are perfectly fine and fun, little in-jokes for film fanatics and eagle-eared audience members.
But I see the ruin of things to come. The stageplay construction, the de-emphasis of musical score, the post-modern self-awareness of itself and its aims – all of these are elements that I despise in other films, elements which have come to dominate the American cinema in so many pernicious ways. I don’t think it’s a coincidence that His Girl Friday was the benchmark source for how Jon Favreau created the personality and interpersonal drama of Tony Stark – 2008’s Iron Man and subsequent entries in the Marvel Cinematic Universe are heavily dependent on improv, asides, fourth-wall breaking humor, the same techniques that Howard Hawks and his actors used in His Girl Friday to create a film that was exceptional were now being used to create the smarmy stylistic template for blockbusters in the 2010s and beyond, movies which I myself have made a habit of constantly decrying.
Am I a hypocrite for loving His Girl Friday while hating movies that do the exact things that it does for often the same reasons it did them? Sure. Let’s think about what Hawks represents in the American cinema – iconoclasm, adaptability, coolness, yes, but he’s also an artist of efficiency, pragmatism, and professionalism. Hawks was acutely business-minded and made films which appealed to wide audiences – outside of Cinemascope, he didn’t follow trends as much as he did follow genres. When comedies were in vogue, he made them; when he worked at Warner Bros., he made their characteristic noirs; when westerns were at their peak, he made a gaggle of them. Hitchcock always made his own perverted work even when at the behest of mogul producers, John Ford frequently went out of his way to make ‘personal’ films like The Quiet Man, Wagon Master or The Sun Shines Bright while also doing ‘commercial’ pictures like westerns. But Hawks? Hawks went with the flow and usually made everything he did have personal touches to one extent or another – even his gargantuan failures like Land of the Pharaohs feel characteristically ‘his’ in ways that surprise us. He represents the ‘craftsman’ attitude, the way that Hollywood cinema is made in this extremely atomized factory assembly line, but he still writes his signature inside each of those products that makes you value them for their superior quality and slight eccentricities.
Compare that caveman auteurism to what Iron Man and its ilk have gone on to represent – the assembly line is still there, but now there’s no personal signature, just a logo rudely stamped onto the front of each damned film, emblazoned in red and white comic panels which is supposed to communicate some sort of branded safety net. Most filmgoers in the 30s, 40s or 50s likely didn’t pay attention that they were watching a HOWARD HAWKS PICTURE of various stripes, but even the invisible artistry was artistry, and it stood the test of time, giving people their money’s worth of fun, excitement and laughter – now the factory machine of Hollywood can barely keep ahead of itself, can’t rely on a single artist to direct their mega-franchise IP, don’t want to risk their precious copyrights and trademarks on a unique vision, so the ‘craftsman’ might as well no longer exist, as there’s precious few opportunities for them to emerge from behind the morass of babylonian production woes that go into making a single MCU film, much less two or ten or twenty, including streaming spin-offs and god knows what – the other side of the auteurism coin is that a single man can be held accountable for his artwork, and whether we like it or dislike it often depends on our own perspective, not on his lack of ownership over it, which is plain to see – haters will hate, the converted will worship at the artist’s altar, as it should be. Whereas the modern Hollywood film seemingly has no one to blame for anything – no one’s in control, not even the Kevin Fieges of the world, he just manages the machine, just feeds red meat to Moloch, if it wasn’t him it would have been someone else – so what’s the point in ascribing any particular critique when there’s no particular artistry? You can only critique the basis upon which such genericized crap has been created, the material conditions of its inchoate inception.
Which brings me back around to His Girl Friday – is it my favorite Hawks? Certainly not, it’s too theatrical for me, too stagey – but I can only say that from the vantage point that I think Hawks made thirteen or fourteen masterpieces and a bunch of swell films besides, so nitpicking at that level is purely pedantic and often subject to the capricious whims of time and season. Above all, I believe the real conversation to be had is when you do have a great director with a strong body of work like Howard Hawks has – then, there are no wrong answers, only fruitful differences of inclination. That’s what separates his artistry from the vast commodity production of modern Hollywood – who ultimately cares whether Thor 3 or Thor 4 is better? It’s a race to the bottom, the level of superiority is minuscule – but with Hawks, you’re hanging out on Mount Olympus, chit-chatting among the various gods, who are appealing and appalling in the same aspect – Rio Bravo seems attractive one moment, El Dorado the next, and then there’s His Girl Friday, you’re still in love.
Files
Previews only