The Anxiety of Biography (Patreon)
Content
The term 'late style' is typically used to designate a director's disintegration, literally a collapse of integration between the various parts that have held fast in the previous maturity of their career -- they gradually start working with lower budgets, the editing of their films grows more stately or chaotic, they begin to remake or repeat their own material, or they fall into being a journeyman at the whims of a particular star or a studio. But most importantly of all, a late style is a singular achievement that cannot be easily replicated (or is even seen as desirable) by the business of cinema at large -- a late Paul Schrader film is characteristically his and his alone, and no one pushes enormous digital textures as far as a late Michael Mann joint. The having of a late style is to see a director isolate themselves from the overall film ecosystem and 'specialize' in making works that speak to them and them alone -- in effect, they become esoteric artists.
In this respect, Steven Spielberg hasn't really yet had an easily legible 'late style' -- given that he was a child prodigy, the last scion of the dying Universal studio system, the inventor of New Hollywood blockbuster entertainment, and a multi-Academy Award winner, it's ridiculous to say he's been anything but a fully-mature filmmaker from the inception -- 1971's Duel is a made-for-TV picture that's more cinematic than most global releases today. Spielberg is still 77 years young with 34 features under his belt, at least half of them stone-cold classics -- he's never needed a late style because he's never gone out of style (at least as of 2024).
But it's fun to try and delineate 'periods' or 'eras' within his body of work -- but where to place them? One seems easy: Spielberg directing Jurassic Park and Schindler's List at the same time, releasing them in the same year, earning all the money with Jurassic and all the awards with Schindler's, it's one of the great Hollywood coups -- that was the moment he was forever 'canonized' to both critics and audiences.
Interestingly though, the period before that strikes one as a little unsteady, and before 1993 one could be forgiven for thinking that Spielberg had shared the fate of many of his Film Brat brethren -- after several astonishing successes from 1974-1984 and only one real failure during that decade, he seemed like an untouchable whiz-kid who cracked the secret to making money while still remaining an identifiable & artistically sound auteur, which was the great hope of many New Hollywood directors and a goal that was rarely, if ever, met with any degree of consistency -- Coppola during this period had burned out himself along with several financial bridges, De Palma had begun doing his 'one for them/one for me' strategy, and Scorsese couldn't stop swinging for the fences every single time he directed.
What Spielberg didn't have, however, was that Oscar -- some wonder that Indy tries and fails to get that golden idol in Raiders of the Lost Ark. So we enter a weird limbo period in the way that John Ford also had -- Spielberg makes Indiana Jones sequels and Hook while aiming squarely at the Academy with self-consciously 'important' pictures, Empire of the Sun being a stunningly well-made but weirdly forgotten J.G. Ballard adaptation. Spielberg's lust for an Oscar had notoriously existed ever since Jaws, but films like Empire of the Sun, The Color Purple and Always feel oddly clumsy in his hands -- how can you render the amazing roller-coster ride of Raiders of the Lost Ark (or a farce like 1941) while then turning around and trying to make a 'serious' World War II picture? His aims and his talent were mismatched, and in retrospect this 80s period looks unfocused, if never completely a failure.
The 90s was his decade to lose, if only because of Jurassic and Saving Private Ryan, two epoch-defining pictures that have aged in several curious ways -- then comes the new millennium, then comes films like Catch Me If You Can.
On the surface, this is both an archetypal Spielberg effort -- a tender family drama made slick and smooth with a buffed-out 60s sheen -- and also signals his move towards dad-core cinema -- 'based on a true story', his continued relation with Tom Hanks after Ryan, and tackling subject matters that would appear on the surface to suit other directors better -- one can easily imagine a glibly tortured Scorsese version of Catch Me If You Can, a coldly disinterested Minority Report from De Palma, the Eastwoodian quirk of Bridge of Spies or the Sorkinite droll of The Post.
What struck me as odd watching Catch Me this time, however, was how much of it was reflected in The Fabelmans, Spielberg's ready-made skeleton key to his entire career. Leo as Frank Abagnale Jr. is, other than Richard Dreyfuss in Close Encounters, perhaps the most identifiable director-avatar for Spielberg in his oeuvre -- which is odd, considering that Abagnale is a real person and this is (debatably) his real-life story being told on screen. Perhaps America is a simpler place that I know -- but the family dynamic in Catch Me feels suspiciously similar to Spielberg's own in Fabelmans, right down to the war hero dad, the moving around between different homes, the son being a mischievous con-artist who models his life after movies and keeps the secret of his mother's infidelity -- maybe I'm just seeing things.
But Fabelmans is specifically engineered to reflect and refract Spielberg's work as well as his life story -- is this not the ultimate proof of the auteur theory? References to Close Encounters, Indiana Jones, Saving Private Ryan -- or are they simply the 'real' elements present in Spielberg's (or Sammy's) background?
That's a bizarre notion to consider -- if Spielberg wanted to, couldn't he simply have (with Tony Kushner's help) written-in anything he wanted to into his own past? Both of his parents had passed in 2017 and 2020, so there couldn't be around to 'object', and one can think that Spielberg would only dare tell such a personal story with their absence -- but his sisters, Anne and Nancy, were credited as 'consultants' on that film, so clearly it couldn't all be made-up.
But the thought itches the back of my mind -- if he did make anything up, it's not like we'd know it, and he had 33 previous films to inflect on his own childhood, to highlight specific parts at the expense of others. I'm far from saying he's a liar, but when I watch Catch Me If You Can and I see the precociousness of Sammy Fabelman all over it, it leads me to speculate about auteurism as a lens -- if you find a pattern in the artwork, does it matter if it's unconscious or deliberate on the part of the artist?
I suppose not, as the pattern is what is seen to really matter -- I doubt many of the directors that Cahiers or Andrew Sarris heaped praise upon saw filmmaking as anything but a job, and simply did that job the way that felt best to them. But given that Spielberg has woven his autobiography into everything he's done, even into the biographies of others that he's adapted, it seems almost stupid to ask to 'separate the art from the artist' -- which we only seem to want to do if we find something disagreeable in the artist, anyway. And yet Spielberg was always thought of, at least for my generation, as a 'natural storyteller' -- the New Hollywood generation all sought to make big films which were personal and personal films which felt big, and he is the most successful marriage of those two worlds.
Maybe, far from not having one, Spielberg's always been in his 'late style' -- he is his own subject matter, he created a decades-long career, and it has so-far culminated in a self-mythologized statement of intent which retroactively makes all his films fit inside it, and once one has seen The Fabelmans, one cannot help but look for its inflections in each Spielberg picture, no matter how 'minor' it is.
It seems paradoxical and half-stupid, but also fitting, that the biggest and most iconic director of the past 60 years couldn't help but give us the tools to understand him -- no need for auteurism, no need for Cahiers, Spielberg reads himself as a text and handily provides us with his own self-image. Unlike John Ford, Spielberg has printed his own legend -- his cinema is now a cul-de-sac, an ouroboros which surrounds all Hollywood blockbusters in the mirror of one man. Perhaps this is what ultimately separates the Old Hollywood from the new -- none of those pioneers felt the need to situate themselves historically, they were who they were, the work spoke for itself, whereas a director like Spielberg feels the mandate to situate himself as the inheritor of a tradition and the trailblazer of a brave new world: his work speaks on his behalf. That self-awareness is something endemic not only to New Hollywood, but to many generations and schools of filmmakers afterward -- for better and worse, Spielberg is the grand patriarch of modern American cinema, and he isn't afraid to let us know it.
Godard called his filmmaking an extension of his film criticism -- Spielberg was never a critic, so he just made filmmaking into a reflection of his life.
Files
Previews only