Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

What is the work of art 'for'? When asking this, we inquire into the general purpose of anything in existence -- an apple exists to grow, to spread its seeds, to be eaten -- but wait, those are things an apple does, not why it does them. Quickly we are drawn into the realm of theology and metaphysics -- why does reality exist in the way it does? We assume that the 'why' in question implies a cause, and then the rest of what we are aware of is the effect -- yet what about the cause behind all other causes? If there are 'rules' in this universe', we also assume that there is some intentionality behind those rules -- and if we don't, then reality itself seems arbitrary and solipsistic. 

Let's limit ourselves merely to the question of what cinema is 'for'. Among its storied history, several answers to this have been proposed:

1. Cinema's purpose is to tell stories with juxtaposed images (and later, sound). 

2. Cinema's purpose is to educate morally and/or intellectually.

3. Cinema's purpose is to express the particular perspective of the artist or artists who create it, whatever that may entail.

4. Cinema's purpose is to create economic value for its creators. 

5. Cinema has no purpose.

6. Cinema's purpose is to document reality. 

No. 5 is par for the course of our lovely nihilist friends, who see no purpose in anything (except for frequently saying that there is no purpose in anything); No. 4 is automatically disqualified from our consideration via its vulgar bourgeois economicism; No. 1's truth depends on what we mean by 'stories' -- is filming a flower for 5 hours a 'story'? It has a beginning, middle and end, and certainly charts a process of change...; No. 2 is fine in theory, but inasmuch as existence itself is 'educational' -- education to what end...?; No. 3 is after my own heart, but who would ever admit to making a film that has nothing of their own perspective in it? If you put down the camera in any place or location, that's the perspective you're choosing, so it is technically true, but in a somewhat banal way... 

No. 6 seems the most obviously true, but in an obscure way -- cinema cannot help but document what it sees, whether that's a boardwalk pier or an M1911 or a rendering of a computer-generated feline. Again we run into the dilemma of what cinema DOES vs. what it was made FOR -- cinema documents its world in miniature pictorial duplicate, but where did that desire for documentation come from?

There is a whole history of early film that both answers and refuses our inquiry, and it's better off that we wonder at the arts more broadly -- cinema is primarily composed of images which represent something in the same way that academic painting represents scenes and the figures within them. Yet representation is just one aspect that painting has expressed -- what exactly do Kandinsky's paintings 'represent'? Shapes, lines and colors -- the basic elements of any painting, so the representation falls away and an elemental use of technique takes its place as an alternative. Cinema can also abide by this 'elemental' impulse -- the films of Brakhage, Derek Jarman's Blue, Godard's later career, the 'pure' cinema playing primarily with the starkness of images and sound, Godard's famous quote about the blood in his movies not being blood, but being 'red'...

So we have representational cinema, which documents a certain variant of consensus reality, and elemental cinema, which documents the formal basis of itself -- a cinema whose purpose lies outside itself vs. a cinema whose purpose is itself. 

Perhaps we've been going about this the wrong way -- can something have multiple purposes? Multiple causes, as well? Some would say no, but it seems evident to me that this is an idea worth exploring -- perhaps the cinema is two beasts in one, or one beast with two heads, a Ghidorah-like creature.

I consider all this because of a recent bout of cinephilic discourse surrounding the role of dialogue and drama in the cinema -- two competing arguments which correspond to our categories:

1. Cinema's goal should be to convey drama using the linguistic means (both visual and aural) available to itself.

2. Cinema's goal should be to express its subject primarily using non-linguistic means (i.e. composition and montage).

Although I have my own aesthetic preferences when it comes to this debate, I'm more interested here in how the linguistic thesis trends towards representational cinema, while the non-linguistic thesis trends towards elemental cinema -- most films find themselves stuck somewhere between these various quadrants, between theatricality vs. abstraction, documentation vs. fictionality. 

Can a film be totally theatrical, with no montage, just filming actors staging a play? With digital technology, yes, this can exist -- yet the hyper-focused 'fidelity' to the theatricality of the drama itself is an abstraction, as the camera's perspective cannot account for the many other things that take place in the theatre -- telling the person next to you that you're going to the restroom, answering a phone call, looking at your feet in boredom, etc, and even if you placed a hundred-thousand cameras inside the theatre auditorium, you would never be able to occupy every single space and perspective -- that would require rigging cameras to atoms, which, safe to say, is an impossibility.

The same goes along with abstraction -- just as even the most abstract painters have to use paint or some other medium to convey abstract forms, elemental cinema still requires an object of its gaze, a relation between the camera and what it films. Say you render your whole film in a computer -- the video file is still using frames of a digital object in relation to digital space, any edits have to be made using the interface of the video program, which necessarily isn't a vague abstraction, it is a very immediate and technical process, using the representational even while dealing with the most stripped-back elements of the craft.

What connects these two variants of cinema is the singularity of relation, the unavoidable intimacy of seeing -- wherever the camera is, whether it's in the analog or digital worlds, it cannot help but inhabit the perspective of its frame, and that perspective itself is always a choice, even if it's an unconscious or unconsidered one. 

Perhaps this guides us towards what cinema is 'for' -- cinema is for seeing, to see the world. Its purpose is not to decide what is being seen, that is what it does, but its neutral inception is to create a space in which various things can emerge into our field of view via the orientation of frame and its relation to other frames. What cinema is 'for' is not a single purpose, but for purpose-as-such to emerge into view via the image -- it is a container for purposes to exist within, a visualization of various causes which itself is acausal -- the cinema is both constantly present, yet gives way to absences and relations as they become evident to its vision -- it uses its constituent elements to represent a world outside of itself, but that world also reveals how it is already composed of cinematic elements when placed into the frame and cut together into a sequence -- the cinema is a prism through which we may search for and discover meaning both in its activity and in all of our lives.  

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.