Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Trevayne has politely asked for a sticky post to be put up for people to be able to talk about Steam.Here it is.

Comments

SirSteveX

Is that not what discord is for?

Víctor Sanjose

Yeah, also is there much to discuss? It's coming next month, as soon as Blue has finished digesting and is only mildly drunk from new Year's Eve.

MS

As for me I dont have discord on my phone and really dont ever use it. I guess ill have to check it out

Trevayne

There is a discord? If so, could someone please post a link/invite?

Trevayne

Thank you Blue Fishcake. Now that we have finished reading Mechs, Maidens, and Macaroons, I was hoping to talk about Steam some more. If you have a discord I would be happy to talk about it there. I think a post like this one is still a good idea to allow people to see that Steam 3 is coming. I am rereading the first 64 chapters and I think there is a lot to talk about.

Trevayne

For examples of things I would like to ask about, about how many airships are there in general, and in the Royal Navy in particular? I remember a chapter (29) that listed the RN as 35 ships, 19 actual RN and 16 Crown Duchy vassal ships. Then a later chapter (57) shows about 30 RN ships which are lured away from the capital while the Crown Duchy ships are getting destroyed by the subships. These two chapters contradict each other. For that matter, how significant was the loss of the ten subships committed by the Lunites? From the epilogue/chapter 64, it seemed that the Lunite ruler was annoyed but not despondent. That suggests they didn't represent more than 5% of the Lunite fleet. That in turn suggests the Lunites have 200-250 ships, so the Solites should have about as many. If the two great powers have about 500 ships, I expect Lindholm has about 200 and the rest of the world (Free orcs not on Lindholm, the Dwarven enclaves, the wood elves) have about 100-200 air ships between them.

Trevayne

Replying to Victor - IMHO there is still a lot to talk about. Especially parts of the background that were not fleshed out. Once the new chapters start coming, we will be talking about their contents and may be distracted from talking about that background.

Trevayne

Something else that would be amusing is more additional scenes. Events that I know happened, but they occurred off screen. Things like 1) Janet Ashfield finding out her son and his team are the new national heroes who just saved the capital. 2) Olivia and Aunt Karla find out the same thing. 3) Countess Greygrass (Marline's mother) finding out her daughter may have gotten a mithril core. 4) Marline's aunts finding out where he hid their mithril core. There are lots of possibilities. While like the rest of us, I prefer Blue to work on the main story, some of these might work as palette cleansers.

Matt Bradock

Can't wait to get some Steampunk action again. William is by far my favourite character by Blue, and not only due to the very unusual background. Especially with the subtle hints that his sanity/personality is not unaffected by being Harrowed. The tech itself is also interesting, especially the progression. Like, for example, a jet engine is actually far less complex than an internal combustion engine. It has less moving parts and its output is controlled purely by the amount of fuel added, no carburetor, no predetermined fuel-air mixture, no compression cycle, no ignition timing. The main problem with it, is the metallurgy required, and the production technology - like forming the turbine discs out of a single piece of metal. Which requirements are entirely bypassed by mage-smiths who simply shape the material into form without any industrial equipment and precision tools needed, or reinforce it against heat or tension using magic. Securing resources is also an interesting aspect - why did oil have to be synthetized? If the world is as old as Earth, with similar tectonics, there should be natural deposits of coal, potassium nitrate (saltpeter) deposits on sea bird nesting islands or in bat-infested caves (guano), sulphur deposits around vulcanic areas... Training some alchemists into actual chemists should be an interesting sub-arc on its own.

Trevayne

I expect the reason he didn't go for jets is that they are clearly different from normal shards. He could make Corsair-Ms that are outwardly almost identical to Corsair-Cs. That allowed him to train his pilots without even hinting that the actual Corsairs (the Cs) were significantly different and did not use a shard or even any aether at all.

Matt Bradock

Yup, but now the cat's out of the bag and it can't be stuffed back in there. Everyone with 2 functioning brain cells and minimal knowledge about shards already knows whatever those are, they don't function even remotely the same way conventional Shards do.

Trevayne

Yes, but that wasn't true until now. He can start working on jets if he needs them, but I think he needs more Corsairs in the near future than he needs jets in a few years. Especially since while he is doing mass production in local terms, he is only getting about two shards per week. He has to do the final inspection/defect fixing himself. The only complete to the last detail set of plans is the one in his head.

Trevayne

Interesting question for the future, assuming William's side wins and he is made a Duke taking the Blackstone duchy, will it get renamed? Maybe he becomes the Duke of Redwater? I am not sure if the benefits of keeping the local nomenclature are not outweighed by the benefits of convincing people things are changing and renaming the Duchy.

Groo

I can't Waite for quad 50s on oxen drawn carts.

Trevayne

Certainly possible, but I think they are more likely to be moved by airship. Maybe use a cart for local positioning, but if they want to put it on top of say a mooring tower, they might as well not bother with the oxen. This whole society is fascinating because it combines magic-punk aircraft with Renaissance era technology. They have airships and horse-drawn carriages, but no railroads or even primitive cars.

Trevayne

Interesting thought, I wonder what the first jets will look like? My guess is he skips past the Meteor and Me-262, to go straight to a second generation jet like the F-86 or the Hawker Hunter. He doesn't need supersonic speed, but single engine jets will be easier for him to make than twin engine aircraft.

Trevayne

Another interesting point from my reread is that apparently the Blackstones were seriously discounting William. The discussion in chapter 50 between Tala and her mother indicates that they think Olivia is dead, probably killed by William. In chapter 64, Eleanor Blackstone tells Tala that the Jellyfish and its shards saved the day. Both of these indicate the Blackstones had not bothered to put any agents in Redwater. That means they don't really have any clue about what they are going to run into beyond what was reported by their agents in the capital. It also makes me wonder if William will get to hold Tala as a prisoner. One of the scenes I would like to see is Tala's reaction to seeing Olivia alive and well in Redwater. She might actually be forced to admit she was wrong about something and to wonder about what else she and her family got wrong.

Trevayne

Thanks for the discord link. The Steam topics looked underutilized. I will try to make amends.

Trevayne

On a separate note, I was rereading chapter 55 and wondering if Marline and Piper also got to see a vision of Earth in the process of making their geases. I am guessing no for Marline and yes for Piper. The only reason she hasn't proclaimed that she is the high priestess of William the God of Technology is that he asked her not too. I am really looking forward to the Queen's reaction to his dreamscape of Earth. Thinking some more about the Queen, I think William is once again being overly pessimistic. He tells Xela that the Queen would never agree to creating an orc homeland because it would mean giving up territory. I think Yelena is smarter than that. Right now, the proposed orc homeland is territory that the Blackstones have been trying to conquer for centuries and failing. It is Lindholmian territory simply because it is on the same large island. I doubt very much that the Queen has ever received much in the way of tax revenues from it. Given that William might be surprised when the Queen agrees to a semi-autonomous orc homeland. Her reason for doing this is she is getting nothing from the territory now except orc raiders that periodically attack the Blackstones. Offer them a peace deal where they get their current home areas and are not attacked there in exchange for not attacking any of the non-orcish territories. She is still getting next to nothing from the orc areas, but now she might get more from the Sunlands because they aren't having their stuff burnt down and the peasants killed every few years. Granted, for this to work the orcs would also have to agree to stop attacking. I think the more pragmatic ones have accepted that they aren't getting all of Lindholm back.

Brian Roger

Obviously they must be combined. Maybe he'll even get promoted. He will become the Prince of Blackwater!

karl grimm

I am wondering if there is any way to get a map of the area. It looks like a war or two will be coming. Wars are often determined by geography so a better idea of where everyone is might be good.

Matt Bradock

Possibly Hunter, F-86, MiG-15, the thing about jet engines is, you have less moving parts to work with than the ICE. The assembly has to be more precise and the materials more advanced, but it's less complex than a classic internal combustion engine of the same power. Material science was the biggest hurdle to overcome, the Me-262 only had an engine lifetime of 50 hours due to heat and torsion stress. But if you can magically reinforce mundane materials, material science is suddenly a lot less important.

Trevayne

That is actually an interesting question. Are all the House Names aligned with the family names? Are they required to be aligned? IIRC the British might have a title, say Earl of Salisbury. When the title was created, the family name was probably also Salisbury, but then an Earl commits treason and is attained and the title goes into abeyance until the monarch issues some other person, say Ralph Doe, the title of Earl of Salisbury, so now he is Lord Ralph Doe, the earl of Salisbury. Getting back to this story, the main character's name was William Ashfield. He was originally in line to inherit the family title as Count of Ashfield, but was then disinherited in favor of Olivia. He then received the title of Count of Redwater when the title and landholding was awarded to him by the Queen. Did that change his legal name? Is he William Redwater, Count of Redwater or is he still William Ashfield, Count of Redwater? This matters because I am curious if William will be William Ashfield, Duke of Blackstone: William Redwater, Duke of Blackstone; or William Blank, Duke of Blank?

Trevayne

On a completely different note, I am very much looking forward to seeing how Blue gets William and the rest of his team to go back to school for third year. He is going to be the Duke of Blackstone (or whatever it gets called) and will have his hands busy trying to settle the war between the orcs and the humans. Unless he can find somebody utterly reliable up there to serve as a deputy, I don't see how he doesn't spend the next year up there. Maybe he can take a yearlong sabbatical to get the North steady and then go back? He would still be a third year, but behind his previous class who would now be the fourth years. This of course ignores the other problem that he has to manage his R&D projects and production. Sending him back to Blicland is like telling Bill Gates that Microsoft is an interesting company, but you really need to go back to Harvard and get your degree.

karl grimm

I’m wondering if they are even going back to school at this point. Maybe Billy Boy just says fudge it and recruits them into his army for a big war arc. Against the Elves or the Rebels or both.

karl grimm

I always had the impression that the Lunites or Solites could take them out if they were ready to eat the cost and not worry about the other elves getting involved. We know every noble house has at least one airship but some of them are old and worthless.

Trevayne

I agree. I think he is not going to be able to continue his education for at least a year, and by then he has probably learned more by doing.

Trevayne

Replying to karl grimm - Pretty much. Every mention has been how the main thing keeping Lindholm safe is that the Lunites and Solites tie each other down. I doubt they have used more than about 60 ships for each of their previous attempts and they retreat after losing 10 or so. The most recent attempt with the ten underships and 12 diversionary airships was a largescale raid intended to grab the kraken slayer and possibly capture the Queen and extract a ransom for her. The underships were expendable, the diversionary force wasn't and it fled. I think both factions have over 200 airships, possibly as many as 300. They can afford to split off a group of 50-60 every so often and try for Lindholm, but they can't afford to take heavy losses. If the other side didn't exist, I think those 200-300 ships would crush Lindholm. Or at least would have. If enough of William's innovations get into use, even that might not be enough to take Lindholm.

Trevayne

A few loose ends that it would be nice to tidy up. 1) What happened to the fifty pirate ships? I expect Admiral Tyana had to let them go because she had to head back to the capital ASAP because of the subship attack. I suppose she could have taken most of her ships and left 5-6 behind to kill the pirates, but the might be needed at the capital and also might get jumped by the 12 fast Lunite ships that fled. 2) A part of that question is what happened to the Lunite ambassador who was on one of the pirate ships with her family? My guess is she gets away with the pirates, although then there is a question of what they do with her once it settles in that they were all a diversion to draw the RN away from the capital and they might all have been slaughtered. 3) What happened to Cynthia, the Lunite commando last seen running around on the surface in the capital with a sample of black powder? She might be killed or captured because she is now heavily outnumbered and capital is full of enemies. On the other hand, she might well be still trying to evade. Depending on how many survivors there were from the shot down ships, she might well be the only Lunite on Lindholm not in captivity (aside from spies and diplomats).

karl grimm

Quick reminder to Blue Fishcake in the original Sexy Space Babes you somehow forgot to include a NSFW twins scene, then again you failed to include one in Sexy Steampunk Babes. Hopefully the new season of Steampunk will provide an opportunity to correct this oversite.

Trevayne

The truly amusing thing is that the twins were trying hard to seduce him into backing their bid, but they didn't need to. William wanted to back them and didn't need to be seduced. He was just fascinated by the Basilisk and its proof that he doesn't have to do all the innovation on Lindholm. There are other people capable of thinking outside the box and inventing new concepts. If the twins had not already convinced him with the Basilisk, the orcs inventing the sub-airship certainly would have cemented the idea. Thinking about it, seeing William's tour of the Basilisk from his POV would be amusing. Was he really just oblivious and fascinated by the tech or did he realize what they were doing and chose to ignore it? Assuming he did notice, I expect he chose to ignore it because he was anticipating being summoned by the Queen and would not want to involved with the twins at the time.

Trevayne

On a different note, one of the oddest things about this setting is the divergence between military and civilian technology. The general technology level is that of a late medieval/renaissance society that has not gotten gunpowder. Transportation is by horse drawn wagon or sailing ship. Weapons are swords, spears, bows, and crossbows. However, the society also has magic and mithril cores so airships, shards, aether-powered javelins, and boltbows are present. However, they are only in military use. AFIAK, there is not a single merchant or commercial airship in existence. All aircraft, both airships and shards, are military in nature. This is a big difference from OTL. It leads to another big difference, no armies. There is no point in major ground forces because all they can do is garrison cities and locations against bandits. Without effective anti-aircraft technology, they are just targets for airships. IIRC the only ground military forces are the Royal Guards securing the palace and the capital. I am really curious about how the war between the Solites and Lunites has been indecisive for hundreds of years. Airships can travel easily over the roughest terrain. Once one side develops a relative advantage, what prevents them from going to their opponent's cities and airship building facilities and wrecking them?

Trevayne

Thinking some more about the story and its world (Yes, I spend way too much time doing that :) ), I wonder how low the population levels are? The orcs in Lindholm are effectively in the position of the Native Americans when the European settlers arrived. Somehow they have managed to hang on for centuries, when the Native Americans got steadily marginalized. That happened in OTL for several reasons, but in particular the settler populations just vastly outgrew the Native Americans and pushed them aside. In part, this was due to the Native American population crash due to multiple epidemics from European illnesses they had no immunity to. But that the settlers used European style farming to increase food production also helped. It hasn't happened on Lindholm though. The humans have been fighting the orcs for over a millennia and although pushed into the wilder portions of Blackstone, the orcs are holding on there. I expect part of the reason is that birthrates on this world are just not as high as they were on Earth. I think this is important because I think it is a key factor in making peace with the orcs. They occupy a wilderness area in the Duchy of Blackstone. There aren't any human settlers there because the orcs would have killed them. Instead, there is probably the orcish area and the human areas, with miles of borderlands between them. William could just say "I will stop raiding you and will stay out of your lands. Could you please stop raiding me?" This is an internal matter for Blackstone, so I don't think the Queen has a role. The orc areas were not providing any tax revenue anyway, so no change there.

Trevayne

Although, thinking about it, if he does go back to Blicland, I doubt any student ever will be able to top his "What I did on my Summer Vacation" essay.

karl grimm

One of Trevayne's comments made me think about how in the real world the development of gunpowder helped lead to the end of feudalism and the rise of democracy. This is obviously an oversimplification but feudalism was partially built on the rise of the knight. Consider what an investment knight represented good armor and weapons were expensive and you can't take an ordinary horse into battle. Both horse and rider needed a lot of training bottom line knights were expensive, but worth the cost in an open battle like medieval tanks. Ultimately the side with the most knights usually won. This lead to knights becoming there own class, effectively minor nobility, below the lords, but definitely above the commoners. Things started to change after the English got really into longbows. Suddenly non-nobles were killing knights. Not long afterward the British created the House of Commons. Further down the line guns came into play and knights disappeared. Guns weren't exactly cheap but were a lot cheaper than knights. They also required less training than longbows. Suddenly the side with the most guns wins. In America the citizen soldier came back, the men who picked up their weapons and left their farms when an army was needed. Similar to the the days of the old Roman Republic. When the state required that common men fight for it it instead of a small elite it was fertile ground for democracy.

karl grimm

Anyway the situation in Lindholm is even more extreme. A peasant might have a hard time fighting a knight but fighting an airship would be beyond insane. So as long as they don't do enough damage to wreck the economy they can do whatever they want to the commoners without concern. Also magic seems to flow in bloodlines further widening the gap between the Aristocracy and the commoners. It wouldn't surprise me if in some of the more isolated areas the commoners are treated only a little better than the slaves. Of course if commoners start killing Airships in non- magical aircraft things might change. Now that I'm thinking about it I wonder how long it takes to train one of the biological Wyverns the Orcs use and if you need any magic to use one.

Trevayne

It probably takes several months to train a wyvern, although if there is a magical way to speed up the process the orcs are probably using it. I doubt you need magic to ride a wyvern, but I expect mages are more effective pilots because their magic gives them additional, longer-ranged, offensive options like lightning bolts or ice bolts.

Trevayne

Political question, IIRC Olzenya is from a Southshore House and South shore is supposed to be traditionalist. I assume if that is true, Yelena managed to keep the Southshore duchess on her side some how. Otherwise they wouldn't need the Summerfield duchy to out match Yelena three (Blackstone, New Haven, and Southshore) to two (Royal and Summerfield). Alternatively, was Olzenya supposed to be from New Haven?

Jake the L

Yelena got corsairs and guns, but Will still has modern cannons, proxy-fuse shells, and early jet engines without even leaving WWII-era tech, right? There’s also turboprops which’d be another massive jump in power and speed over radial engines Also, if he can use magic to set up a non-magic assembly line for various parts, that seems like the way to expand production

Jake the L

The swedish SAAB A-21 would’ve been more ‘conventional’ as shards go, with its rear-mounted prop, and the prop on that plane was installed with the intention of swapping it with an early turbojet. But the corsair is way more iconic, so it’s fair that Blue’d go for that instead I think the bearcat probably would’ve been a better choice, given how much easier it is to do a carrier landing without the massive nose in the way He’s really tossing his pilots into the deep end

Trevayne

He can do most of those things, but does he need to? Right now his big bottleneck is that he has to personally finish and ensure each Corsair doesn't have any defects. In particular, he has to do the engines because his head is the only place the detailed blueprints exist. Right now, I think he has to focus on getting as many Corsair-Cs as he can get. He is about to fight a major battle to break the Blackstones. As for a non-magical assembly line, maybe in a few years. The big problem there is that spies could steal the information and eventually the Lunites and Solies will have their own versions. Right now, even if they captured wrecks or even an intact version, reverse engineering it would be extremely difficult.

Jake the L

Very good point- the threat of espionage isn’t something I considered, and a menial assembly line would be a risk. A fully-automated assembly line no one ever sees, though… On a more serious note, I’m imagining modern-ish automatic cannons firing proxy-fuse will go a long way toward handling the black stones. Even if the shells are stolen, no one else seems capable of doing the mage smithing required to make a gun’s breach seal correctly at the pressures a 3-inch shell will generate Or he can just rely on fielding more planes than the Blackstones can, planes which fly higher and faster than the Blackstones’ shards. Seems like too fair a fight, though

Trevayne

The real issue for William is that he can do lots of things, but most would interfere with Corsair production. About the only thing I can think of that wouldn't is having the Alchemists invent rocket pods. Imagine a pod containing 7-10 HVARs, about a single Corsair's rocket load. Then imaging putting a pod on each side of an air ship's bow. The point their airship at the enemy and fire both pods as the close into aether cannon range.

Jake the L

That does sound very feasible. In-line with British naval rocket use during the Napoleonic era, which this feels semi-similar to (with cannons, wooden ships, few exploding shells)

Trevayne

Fully automated factories are I think at least a decade or two away. I don't know that he needs automatic cannon to fight airships. Something like a US 4"/50 naval gun from a four stacker destroyer would probably comfortably out range airship aether cannons, punch through their armor, and detonate inside. Against shards, something like a twin or quad .50 cal mount should do well, certainly better than a pivot gun.

karl grimm

Pretty sure it took longer than that to train warhorses. In addition to understanding a lot of commands, they have to be trained not to panic during the chaos of combat. In the old days I think they used to keep them near blacksmiths and butchers so loud noises and the smell of blood didn't bother them. Wyverns could be different though.

Trevayne

The really interesting thing about picking technology specifically for use ITTL is the difference in military concepts. William is picking earth technologies that were intended for the mass armies and navies of WW2. Lindholm has flying navies that are much smaller and no armies worth mentioning. For example, William could invent a ground mounted 105 mm howitzer, like the main US artillery piece of WW2, but why? There are no targets for it. I am particularly interested in this because another commenter (probably on RR) said the only impact of William's innovations would be to increase the death count. He completely misunderstood the nature of warfare on this world and assumed that introducing some WW2 technology must result in a WW2 death toll. That would be a reasonable assumption, if there were significant ground armies. Since there aren't significant ground forces, it is an idiotic assumption. Another side effect of warfare on this world is the idea of peasant levies. In Earth's feudal period, feudal lords tended to maintain forces of knights and men at arms on a permanent basis. They would supplement it with drafted peasant levies that would use spears and/or bows with minimal armor. In this world, there are no feudal levies. There is no point. Their counterparts would be the plebian enlisted personnel that help operate airships. If the average airship crew is about 200 and Lindholm has 250 airships, that is a total of only 50,000 military personnel for all factions on the island ( maybe another 10,000 or so as guards and support personnel). There is no point in mustering 200,000 peasants. What could they do to an airship except die in large numbers or surrender?

karl grimm

It seems to me that Billy's top priority is weapons that will let him win right now, other priorities will have to wait. We have already seen that he can strap his manufactured bombs onto the twins' existing airframe for big destructive effect. He can focus on the bombs while the locals do everything else and still get enough firepower to win the civil war. That's where I would put my focus, at least until the immediate threat is dealt with.

Trevayne

Replying to karl grim - I agree that his near term focus has to be on winning the war. That was why I was suggesting adopting some of the tech he is using on the Corsair to make the RN airships more effective. Things like the rockets and .50 cal machine guns, since I think both of them are simple enough that the Alchemists Guild mage-smiths can make them without William. As you point out, he can put his explosives and fuses into conventional Lindholm shells and javelins (aether powered unguided missiles). He didn't substitute his weapon for the one the Basilisk was carrying, he just removed the incendiary payload and replaced it with HE. The one drawback of doing this on RN ships is I don't know how much of a sympathetic detonation risk the usual enchanted aether cannon shells have. His HE loaded shells would definitely have that risk.

Trevayne

I expect the main reason they don't kill commoners in numbers is why? If they win in the air, those commoners are their new subjects, so why kill them? They represent a lot of the productive capacity of the land and are virtually no military threat. In some ways it is like warfare in the 1700s. The main danger to the peasants were foraging armies taking their food. That is one of the reasons why armies adopted systems of fortresses and magazines. They tended to fight at distances up to a hundred miles or so from their supply point and the peasants just went on with their lives. This year they are Austrian, next year they are Prussian. They didn't really care that much since there was not much difference from the peasant's perspective between feudal overlords.

Google Google

He might as well pull off an Oppenheimer.

Trevayne

Why? There is no need for nuclear weapons. He could probably make one given time, but why? Especially since, once the first one is used the genie is out of the bottle and others will try to copy it. Since he is almost certainly going to use magic for isotope separation, other mages could do the same.

Trevayne

We have a pretty good idea of what William is bringing to the battle. Corsairs, rockets, and .50 cal machineguns. This is what he just used against the Lunites and the Blackstones should be showing up in a week or two. He doesn't have time to invent more new stuff. The interesting question is what innovations, if any, are the Blackstones bringing? They are bigots and human supremacists, but they aren't idiots. They designed and built the first ever dedicated shard carrier, the Brimstone ( all of the others, including the Jellyfish, are conversions of existing airships). At a guess, since they are emphasising shards, maybe they have some new anti-shard weapons like multi-barrel pivot guns.

Google Google

Good point, I wasn't thinking straight . Maybe jet engines would be the next thing.

Google Google

Wait jet engines are way too complicated forget what I just said

Trevayne

Jet engines can be simple. A ramjet is arguably simpler than any other kind of aircraft engine, jet, prop, or turboprop. They jyusat have the disadvantage of needing to be accelerated to over 400 or so knots before they generate thrust. The main reason for not worrying about jets in the near future is that he has to win the war against the Blackstones first, and potentially the war against New Haven who may or may not have Solite backing. That means if it can't be done in the next month or so, worry about it after that. Right now, William needs replacement Corsairs and to fix any of the shot down ones that can be fixed. He could also use more pilots, but I expect Yelena can provide those. He also needs more fuel and ammunition, along with more shard radios.

Google Google

Sorry for my phrasing what I mean by complex I mean the precision of the blades of the jet engine. I'm also curious how fast will he start pumping out the oil and how will he keep the secret from others.

Trevayne

The thing is that yes, jet engine turbine blades are precisely manufactured to high tolerances. However, William can cheat. Assuming that he has the jet engine blueprints in his harrowed memory the way he has the Corsair engine blueprints, he can manufacture via mage-smithing a jet engine to any required tolerance. As for oil, I think he is getting it from the same sources as the Alchemist's guild. I am pretty sure they are tapping natural sources to create their magical incendiaries. William just has to have the guild process it in different ways to create something like 100 octane aviation gasoline. It helps a lot that he doesn't have hundreds of Corsair-Cs. He had forty on the Jellyfish and an unknown number of spares (probably 10-20). His production rate is about two Corsairs a week, because he has to do the finally assembly of each engine and verify the Guild magesmiths put the aircraft together properly. I have seen comments suggesting he needs several hundred or a thousand Corsairs. It would take ten years at 100 or so a year (2 per week). I don't think he needs that many and getting the fuel and ammunition for them would also be a challenge.

Alex LordThorsen

I find myself wondering what a combination internal combustion engine mithral core aircraft could achieve. If nothing else the ballasts should give crafts more altitude. Not sure what reducing the weight of a craft does to it's flight profile since I'm not a pilot.

Blue Fishcake

Effectively unlimited range would be a pretty big one. VTOL take-off capability would be another - although I could think of a way to attain that without needing a whole mithril core.

Trevayne

On a different note, does anybody else think Yelena screwed up by using the kraken slayer? Without the hulls and crews to make operational airships, all she did by killing krakens and retrieving mithril cores was assemble the single largest concentration of easily portable wealth on the planet and reveal that she had the ability to kill krakens. Granted, William also made the same error. He could have pointed out to Yelena that she really didn't want to kill krakens now. Making that point to Yelena would probably have helped his negotiations, but despite his desire to save his sister and keep his secrets he missed that one. Maybe in the next book a meeting of Yelena's cabinet could have a paragraph or two discussing this. Having Palmer bring this up would be a nice way to introduce her.

Trevayne

On another completely different note, one of the POVs that was missing from the book 3 epilogue (chapter 64) was the Solites' take on this. Their embassy personnel, spies, and any other Solite traders or others in the Capital had a good ground view of the battle. They would have seen the sky towers fall and the defenders shot down and the commandos land and attack the palace. They might or might not have seen the fighting at the academy, but they would have heard the strange shards and probably seen some glimpses of them. They would have definitely seen the Jellyfish's kill. I wonder what the Solite Empress makes of these reports. Will she tell New Haven to go ahead and attack with Blackstone or hold back until she gets more information. I doubt New Haven can hold. They have to see that if the Crown defeats Blackstone, they are likely to be next. For that matter, will the Solites commit airships to reinforce New Haven?

Baron Von Mott

I always enjoy Trevayne's analysis, their mini-essays are almost as interesting as the actual stories 😂

Trevayne

Thanks, I think.

Kaywye

Umm okay so, the answer to when new steampunk is coming g is next month? Gaaahhh. I get it...holidays and other assorted stuff...maybe I should take up drinking again...cause patience ain't never been strong with me. Lol

Trevayne

Since it is 28 December, Blue could you please tell us if we are looking at an early or mid-January drop for the first chapter. I am hoping for Friday the second, but will be travelling so I might not comment that fast.

Trevayne

Interesting steam question, William wants to end slavery and set up a democracy. I think he can manage the first, but is going to have a lot of trouble with the second. However, while I agree with those that say it is really hard to go from feudalism to a modern parliamentary democracy in one fell swoop, there are intermediate steps. For example, the first OTL British step towards democracy was Magna Carta. That was basically the nobles putting some limits on the crown. Since that was a medieval feudal innovation, I don't see why Lindholm could not do that. A bigger innovation would be creating a bi-cameral parliament with a house of Lords and a house of Commons. I expect that given the role of the nobility, most of the power would be with the Lords and the crown. The Commons would be a place for the non-nobles to try to get some input into the system and at least try to get their views heard but the nobility and the crown. All of this is first going to require that the crown win the upcoming civil war. Although a Magna carta equivalent might emerge during the war as a way for the Crown to appear more reasonable and thus encourage fence-sitting nobles to join the Cown's side.

Found&Lost

The issue that Yelena has isn't numbers it's quality. It's mentioned several times that several of the least threatened houses don't even have ironclads, and what they do have tends to be outdated. They're also ranging from trained to ceremonial only. Blackstone and New Haven however are almost completely veteran to elite crews and functional to state of the art ships due to the ongoing wars with the orca and fending off two invasions. Essentially the Northern Rebels are outnumbered about 3 to 2, but each of their ships can expect to defeat twice their tonnage.

Found&Lost

Counter Question, what's MILF queens plan to handle William? It's known that someone who's harrowed has a compulsion to act out their harrowed knowledge. While at the moment he's siding hard with the Queen, the fact that he keeps her at arms length would tell her that he plans to go against her in the future. She obviously can't do anything now as she needs him desperately, but she should know without a doubt that he will turn on her once he completes a certain objectives(s). So I would expect that she'll put some sleeper assassins near him, but how and when will she confront him afterwards? Will she start by asking him if he is a threat to her core motivation (protect Lindholm) in which case it might... Ease William/George into a more steady Magna Carta to constitutional monarchy, or will she be more confrontational? Remember William isn't the only player in this game. Not the only one who has a say in how things go.

O

I think we are forgetting the fact that while William can cheat. He is just one guy. At the end of the day he had hired help to make corsairs. Jet engines are another ball game for said help

Trevayne

replying to Found&Lost - Yelena's problem with what William is up to is that it is an out of context problem for her. She thinks she solved the threat to her throne by taking William's geas that neither he nor any of his descendants will ever try to sit on her throne. As a feudal monarch, she has no way of conceiving that he wants to see her throne and all of the rest of them go away. I also don't know just how desperate William is to get rid of the throne. There are several modern countries on OTL Earth that still have monarchs. Monarchs are not inherently incompatible with democracy, just the absolute monarchs. I am still expecting that he will try to go for something like Magna Carta to introduce the idea that there can be formal limits on the power of the monarchy as opposed to the informal one of the nobles rebelling if the Monarch is too dictatorial. If anything, William is Yelena's biggest ally in trying to protect Lindholm. The outside powers that might try again to conquer it all practice slavery. If he wants to get rid of it, he has to keep them away from Lindholm.

Trevayne

Yes and no. I agree that the Northern Houses have more combat experience based on their on and off fighting with the orcs. That said, the orcs have no airships they haven't captured and mainly fight with wyverns and shards, along with ground raids. IIRC the Blackstones have no more recent airship fleet combat experience than the RN does. The last big battle was against a Solite fleet trying to conquer Lindholm about 20+ years ago that provided Al Hundra with her nesting ground. They resemble the US military, which had combat experience from the Gulf War when it went into Afghanistan but quickly demonstrated it did not know how to fight a counterinsurgency war and had to relearn the lessons from Vietnam.

AceHW

What happens if he tries to make a mythril-powered land vehicle?

AceHW

What happens if he tries to directly port his plane engine systems to land vehicles instead of using proper land vehicle engines?

AceHW

What happens if he makes a hybrid land vehicle that can be powered by gas or mythril, and when he's using the gas he can definitely use the mythril for a gas gun

AceHW

So far, it seems like the mythril powered planes only use the magic smoke for air pressure. What if they actually used the magic smoke for magic somehow?

AceHW

Even though he mostly uses the magic smoke for air pressure, he could also come up with a way to pressurize air without it like airguns, or via some mechanical mechanism. He could also use excess air pressure (when it's not being used) to further pre-pressurize/pre-compress amounts of air to use later, if they have some way of storing highly pressurized air. Do they have to have some kind of air filters to keep the magic smoke from making the inside air pipes and mechanisms like the inside of a well-used chimney? (soot)

AceHW

Wouldn't the added weight from the whole gas system and the fact that a plane was made for the extra power of a gas engine make the mythril componet less viable for powering the plane by itself? Or at least a mythril shard wouldn't be as viable (need a whole core), or you'd have to build the air components like for a mythril shard plane instead of more powerful like the gas planes. oh wait, were the more powerful guns on the gas engine planes not based on air systems at all? That might make more sense

AceHW

Has anybody else bothered trying to make something other than a plane powered by a mythril shard? My understanding is that once you have one it's practically free magic smoke air pressure, right? and they already have continous-fire air guns on planes powered by mythril shard or core right? So there's no reason they couldn't have such guns powered by a mythril shard without the plane, right? is that a thing, or no because mythril shards are too expensive/rare to "waste" on something that's not a plane? have they considered pneumatic tubes like banks use? (just an example of where you might've seen them) Maybe for sending packages between certain fixed locations, or even as elevators or some such.

AceHW

I just realized: air boats. They could propel boats with a mythril shard, though they might tip the boat like a fan boat

AceHW

I wonder if mythril shards/cores could make any sense for powering a train with

AceHW

I juet thought of a way they could make money: making and selling .22 calibre and smaller airguns for small game. break-barel or multi-pump or some kind of pneumatic tank of compressed air Not that they seem to need the money, and I'm sure the new music industry will make plenty, but I'm just sayin.

AceHW

and don't forget about using the magic smoke to glide instead of a parachute in case of emergency

AceHW

He also felt the twins were too young for him, being he has the memories of a 90+ y/o and they're like what 23? He likes human bed-partners to be more like 30 (or some such)

AceHW

I'm looking forward to the geas when Queen sees a vision of the more advanced world, and when he says the reason he's so willing to swear that he doesn't intend for him or his descendants to be on the throne

AceHW

I wonder if there's some way his teacher/lover could homeschool/tutor him if she started doing fewer classes at the school (or, what's her schedule and hours like anyway?)

Trevayne

It doesn't look like they can. Magic required refined aether that has gone through a mage. Raw aether is the gas that they use for lift and gas-powered items. It is available in much greater quantities, but isn't magical.

Trevayne

The problem is that mithril cores are very valuable because they are the heart of airships. There are only two ground based mithril cores that we know of. One is in the academy powering the floats and some other stuff and the other is in the palace. They are very expensive because each of those cores is preventing a would be noble family from having an airship. That is why the more traditional nobility dislikes shards, because a mithril core can be broken down into six or so shards, but the conversion is not reversable. Every six shards is one family that can't have an airship, so can't be landed nobility.

Trevayne

Probably, but airships are more important.

Trevayne

I would like to see it too, but remember, we have only seen one dream visit to William's dreamscape, Xela's. We know that he has multiple geas agreements (Marline, all of the to mage crafters, etc). That means there is no guarantee that we will see it. Although, I think there is a chance because William might get Yelena to agree to a constitutional monarchy if she sees how Lindholm could develop. Her priority is building Lindholm's strength to maintain its independence. If she was only interested in keeping her family on the throne, she probably would not have picked the fight over abolishing slavery.

AceHW

It's gonna be interesting when the nobles realize that William's new "refined-earthblood"-powered planes are soon gonna make mythril core and mythril shard ownership matter so much less, at least as a practical matter

Trevayne

Replying to AceHW - The guns on the Corsairs are the .50 heavy machine guns that the originals were equipped with. There are shard powered Corsairs, the Corsair-Ms, that were made for training, but the Corsair-Cs have internal combustion engines and no aether powered gear at all.

Trevayne

replying to AceHW - The Corsair-Cs don't have any magic smoke. They are internal combustion only, just like the original versions on Earth. They are intended for plebian (non-magic user) pilots, so can't use aether technology.

Trevayne

Replying to AceHW - Doubtful. Griffith has a pretty full schedule during the school year and can't really serve as William's tutor. Now perhaps she might get relieved of her academy teaching duties and assigned as a full-time liaison to William once he is the new Duke of Blackstone.

AceHW

He could point to his refined-earthbood-powered planes as just one obvious example of how technology can make some aspect of the current system obsolescent and make it look quaint (who needs to care about mythril core ownership if eventually people with enough money will be able to buy planes with engines that don't need mythril cores or shards, and this makes the scarcity of mythril cores much less relevant, so now what's going to be the basis for a new noble house?), and now think how reasonably practical a fudal monarchy will be with all this technology (as seen in the world in his dream, preferably after they make the geas so she doesn't make him change it in light of new information)

Trevayne

The thing is he can't say how long it will take to fully upgrade Lindholm. Right now he is cheating via magecrafting and because he has knowledge in his head from the Fae. That is why the production rate on the Corsairs is limited to two per week. William is the only one who can do final assembly on the engines, so only two per week. Thus, while William could show her a lot. There are major limits on just how much he can make. At a guess, it could be 30-50 years before anyone else can make a Corsair.

AceHW

Personally though, based on real-life, I think the goal should definitely be no monarchy. Look at how little power the british monarchy practically has, and yet they still managed to abuse it (the then-prince/now-former-prince who was made not-a-prince because of his ties with Epstein) on further thought, I suppose a good leader (even as a monarch) can be better than a bad democratically elected leader, so maybe that's not the best reasoning, but I'll leave my earlier comment.

Trevayne

Yes, interesting for William given the amount of people who are going to want to kill him. After all, no William, not IC engines, no problem, at least from their perspective as landed nobility.

AceHW

If he can make engines himself, then can he eventually make the factory equipment himself that other people can use to make the engines?

AceHW

Queen hopefully will protect him, if nothing else because he makes their new planes and weapons and he has the potential to continue massively advancing the technology of their whole world at least (not considering the social changes and conveniences that will come as a result of the tech)

AceHW

I wonder if just selling the engines without the rest of the aircraft wouldn't even speed up production all that much since he has to make them himself anyway but, the mythril shard versions don't need him nearly as much so his factories can make those relatively quickly assuming a supply of mythril cores and shards, right? What if he (his company?) became the military/government contractor for shard and airship frames til supply of frames catches up with the recent glut of cores from killing the kraken(s) that were obstacles to getting those cores before, then them being used to his frames will make it make evem more sense to consider anything else he wants to sell them such as accessories and optional upgrades and similar non-mythril planes. also, who sells the fuel for the gas planes? Could he set himself or an ally up as the fueling station or fuel supplier? Wait, isn't that what he did for his teammate Bonnyln (idk spelling)

AceHW

I wish he could convincingly do something with green energy. Solar might be too complicated even with magic beyond using it for heating, at least the way we do it, but maybe hydroelectric? (I did read somewhere that there was a way to get solar energy with basically a specific stack of metals melted into rods or some such, but idk how real that idea was) and could he figure out heat pumps with some non-toxic refrigerant, or a magic alternative? Nuclear would probably be too dangerous and there'd be no knowledge of its dangers

AceHW

they haven't really discovered plastics, right? Could 3D printing be a thing he could get started somehow, or would you need more computer components for that? Well, I guess there are other shop tools and such that could be made that they might not have

Trevayne

Eventually, but it will take a while. It is 200-500 years above their base non-magical tech. Mage crafting allows limited production of much higher tech items, but he has a long way to go if he wants to do things without magecrafting. Note: I am not saying it will take centuries, but I do expect it will take decades.

Trevayne

The underlying technology of the world is not fully defined, but it looks like they do everything that is high tech for this world via mage crafting. They don't have the power sources and tools to do things without mage crafting. The world is at a medieval/renaissance tech level, with transportation via sailing ships and horses aside from the aether tech airships.

Trevayne

Right now, why do they need green energy? There is no evidence that this world is producing enough energy to affect the climate at all.

Trevayne

There are lots of locations building shards/airship hulls. It is just that there really isn't anything resembling mass production. Blue hasn't specified the numbers (wisely), but the impression is that cores are found/mined about 3-4 a decade. There aren't a lot of new airships unless it is to replace an outdated existing airship. There are more new shards, but still not many because every new group of shards represents a noble family that can't be landed nobility. As for fuel, airships/regular shards don't need it. William has been getting the fuel for his Corsair-Cs from the Alchemidsts guild and the main ingredient, earthblood/crude oil from Bonnlyn's family IIRC.

AceHW

Yeah, true

Trevayne

How many cars have 2,000 horsepower engines? A Corsair engine might be adapted for a heavy vehicle like a big truck or a tank, but not a car.

Trevayne

Yelena will certainly try to protect him until they have won the civil war. After that, things get more interesting. It depends a lot on how she feels about becoming a constitutional monarch.

AceHW

Maybe something like a big double-decker bus or a train or a house-on-wheels like an RV or travel trailer? I'm also trying to imagine an armored fortress of a house on tank tracks, because that sounds interesting, though impractical outside of a literal warzone or maybe a military base that expects to get attacked

Trevayne

The problem with putting anything militarily important in a ground vehicle is that this world has no anti-aircraft defenses. Anything on the ground surface is a sitting duck. An airship can just stand off about 3-4,000 feet over the target and bomb it to bits. Thus, ground-based vehicles are just targets. The airship doesn't even need regular bombs. It can pick up 500 lb or heavier rocks and drop them from altitude. Enough rocks will wreck anything, so the airship isn't even limited by not wanting to use expensive ammunition. This will change once William introduces AA guns like the German 88mm or US 90mm guns. If airships try flying even higher, they wiull need magic to deal with the lack of oxygen at those altitudes and William can counter with bigger guns like the German 128mm or the US 120mm guns, both of which can reach up to 50,000 feet.

Trevayne

He can make mithril powered vehicles even now. Nobody would do that because mithril powered aircraft are much more valuable.

AceHW

in that world, I guess, but for example there are cars that cost as much as a house in our world, so why hasn't some rich eccentric tried to make some kind of mythril shard vehicle as a showpiece like I have so much money I can waste a mythril shard to power a land vehicle. My point being that just because it doesn't make sense in terms of money or allocation of resources doesn't mean there's nobody in the world who'd do it

ProVVoke

Because similar to fossil fuels, the alchemical fuel can only be used once and then its used up and new fuel has to be manufactured. Renewable or green or woke energy is literally just harvesting energy like harvesting crops. And why wait until the world is producing too many climate effects before starting to address it? Ounce of prevention and all that. We've literally seen how hard it is to get entrenched companies or power grids to change their ways on Earth

AceHW

Hydro power from water wheels and steam power from boiling water could be useful, and geothermal for heating or cooling, or even just running water thru black or metal pipes on the roof for hot water