Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

“I think Piper’s crying,” Olivia opined from her position on the back of the wagon.

William stopped in the act of loading up said wagon to wipe the sweat from his brow and aim a gimlet eye at his younger sibling.

“She’s not…” he started to mutter as he turned back toward where the Alchemist’s guild were undergoing their own evacuation, before pausing. “Ah, it seems you’re right.”

Indeed, the dwarven master alchemist clearly had tears streaming down her eyes as she oversaw the draining of one of the massive silos attached to her guild’s headquarters. Not that she was alone in doing so.

The general mood of the entire group of alchemists she was overseeing could best be described as… melancholy. Sufficiently so that the many peasant labourers who’d been roped in to helping them load up their wagons looked extremely uncomfortable as they worked.

“…I’ll talk to her later,” William said as he shook his head, turning back to his own task.

Technically, he had people for this sort of thing, but given he was in the process of emptying his own small personal laboratory, he’d thought it only right to see to it personally.

Nor was he strictly alone in the task. His sister had volunteered to help him – though that had thus far mostly consisted of her sitting in the wagon while occasionally making pithy comments.

…Which he could live with.

The last thing I need is for her to touch something ‘delicate’ and blow her hand off, he thought as he looked down at the prototype proximity fuses in the box he’d just grabbed.

And his other helper…

“You doing ok there, Verity? You’re looking a little red,” he asked as he turned to his other helper. “We can stop for a break if you want?”

He’d certainly not complain if they did. It was still midmorning, so it wasn’t too hot out yet, but moving so many boxes had caused him to work up a sweat. The shirt he was wearing was practically plastered to his torso already – and he idly gripped the hem to use the sodden garment as an impromptu fan to cool his torso.

“No!” His teammate said instantly, despite the redness in her face as she glanced over at him. “I m-mean, I’m fine with continuing if you are. This isn’t anything compared to working on the farm.”

Willaim shrugged after he brought the sodden garment up to wipe his face. “Alright, but if you do need to stop, feel free to tell me. I know you’ve already helped spent a few hours helping your family move today.”

“S-sure!”

He nodded, satisfied.

It went without saying that Verity’s family would be coming South with them. Ignoring her relationship with him, as free orcs the Capital just wouldn’t be safe for them if the Blackstones or New Haven took over.

Fortunately, the former-slaves were a pragmatic bunch, and while Verity had said they were a little saddened about having to abandon the plot of land that had only just been allocated to them – at least once it had been explained to them that Yelena was abandoning the capital, because that most definitely wasn’t common knowledge yet - they also saw the writing on the wall and were happy to have an ‘out’.

“I understand where she’s coming from,” Olivia said.

“Verity?” he asked.

“Olivia!?” the orc gasped.

“Piper!” the half-elf grunted, sending both them a scathing look before continuing. “It just seems like such a waste. You spent months building all this and now you say you’re going to be burning most of it!”

Again, that wasn’t common knowledge either. His name had soared amongst the people of Redwater during his short tenure as their lord, given how many jobs and how much wealth he’d brought into the small county while he was building up his workshops and production lines.

Never mind elevating many of the girls to pilots-at-arms.

Still, there was a decent chance those feelings might turn a little sour for those being left behind once they realized he was going to be burning everything he couldn’t take with him when he left. Essentially leaving them worse off than when he’d first arrived – because he was taking a number of their village’s skilled craftsmen with him.

Yeah, I can’t see them taking that well, he thought.

For that reason the evacuation plans were being conveyed to those who he’d be bringing with him in batches. Going from most important to least important. Of which the Alchemists stood at the top.

Yelena was undoubtedly doing the same thing on a larger scale in the capital itself. The secret would come out eventually, one way or another, but for the moment the fact that most of the nation didn’t even know a threat was coming helped a lot. As did the fact that the recent attack meant ships and wagons were nearly constantly shipping things in and out of the city.

“Maybe. The fact of the matter is that we can’t bring everything,” he grunted.

The reality was that that they only had so much transport capacity. The Jellyfish’s bays were already full of Corsairs – some of which were still undergoing repair after being shot down during the fight over the capital, and Yelena had offered him some cargo space and berthing on a few of her royal navy ships, it wasn’t nearly enough for him to bring everything he wanted.

Which made sense given that they were also warships and as such didn’t have that much cargo space either – and that Yelena needed most of what was there for her own transport needs. With that said, that she’d still set aside some of that precious space for him was a powerful statement of how much she valued his future contributions to her cause in and of itself.

Fortunately for both of them, there were other means of transport available.

While invention of airships had left their ocean-bound cousins almost completely in the dust where military power was concerned, most of this world’s trade was still moved using maritime vessels.

Of course, they’re still not as fast as airships, so anything we want to be safe during the trip will need to be sent well in advance of the Northern fleet’s arrival, he thought. Which means they’ll have to be on the boats in the next four days. Anything after that runs the risk of being captured.

Because the Royal Navy wouldn’t be protecting them. That would require them to engage in a fighting retreat all the way down the coast.

…Though that might happen anyway, given that Yelena was leery of being seen to abandon the capital without any kind of fight whatsoever. As it stood, the plan was for the navy to engage the Northern fleet’s forward most elements before fleeing at all speed once they ‘realized’ they were outnumbered.

Tyana had not been in favor of that plan at all given that she couldn’t guarantee that her fleet would be able to successfully disengage without suffering losses.

He shook his head. He could worry about all of that in a day or two. For the moment his focus was on getting out what he could while he could.

And for today, that meant as much fuel and ammunition as he could reasonably move. Enough that the Jellyfish wouldn’t be totally useless if they had to fight another engagement before he got his new production lines up.

“Perhaps it seems like that,” he said. “But it won’t take nearly as long to get things running the second time. The tools and the buildings? We’ll be able to replace them easily enough. No, the most important part of my operation is the people - and they’re coming with us.”

Again, magic came in clutch when it came to bootstrapping a production line. You could quite easily skip the bit where you needed to make the tools to make the tools you’d actually need.

So long as you had mages of sufficient skill and familiarity with those tools.

“Will they come with you though? I mean, these are their homes, aren’t they?” His younger sister looked pensive. “I know I miss home.”

“Well it’s a good thing we’re headed back that way then.” He smiled. “And as for my workers? Well, hopefully they’ll see the wisdom in coming with us.”

Because he wouldn’t be giving them a choice in the matter. Anyone that worked on the Corsairs or the Jellyfish knew too much to be left behind. To that end, he was prepared to ‘sweeten the deal’ by offering berthing for their families as well as a significant cash bonus for anyone that came with them – as well as the promise that they would be coming back eventually and that any property they owned would be returned to them at that time no matter who moved in during the interim.

He had that authority as the lord of the land.

And if anyone declines anyway? he thought. Well, I’m sure Yelena could offer me the services of some royal marines.

He’d once declined the services of said marines because their loyalty was foremost to the queen and not him or the land he owned. And it was for that reason he’d call on their services now instead of his own ‘homegrown’ troops. The last thing he wanted was to divide their loyalties by forcing them to essentially kidnap their own neighbors.

Again though, hopefully it won’t come to that, he thought.

Not least of all because anyone he did bring with him using that method he likely wouldn’t be able to trust on any of his future production lines.

In that regard, might be simpler to not waste transport space on them at all, he considered. We just have to ensure they’re near the silo when it’s time for it to be deny it to the enemy. Maybe frame it as a farewell party of some kind?

Then he’d say it was an accident.

Or better yet, enemy sabotage!

He paused.

Perhaps though that was too much? It seemed like too much. Even if it was an elegant solution.

He’d speak to Marline about it before doing anything. He’d promised the whole team that he’d let them ‘vet’ his future actions now that his harrowed nature was out and this seemed like the sort of thing that nearly crossed the line.

Maybe.

Idly tuning out Verity and Olivia’s quiet conversation on whether or not his many workers would choose to join him on their exodus south, he turned toward the nearby silo and many workers scurrying about the base of it.

The massive metal structure was still hard at work, continuously pumping out Corsair fuel into metal barrels via a pipe. Barrels which would would in turn be transported by horse-drawn wagon to the docks and loaded onto a waiting ship.

And seeing the two things side by side, he found himself struck by how anachronistick the whole thing looked. By how anachronistic this whole world was. Things like basic chemistry remained miles behind their equivelants on Earth during the same rough time period, yet when it came to other things like plumbing or ventilation, the locals were almost close to the tech level of the first and second world wars.

Hell, they had welding tools!

And as for things like iron or steel production? Well, he’d been to the smelting plants just inside the capital, and he could definitively say that its output was absurdly far ahead of what it should have been. Yes, the process involved a lot of mages, but that didn’t mean the base ingenuity behind the process was slacking either.

“Even so!” Olivia continued turning back to him. “You know you wouldn’t have needed to go along with any of this if you’d gone with mother’s plan. There wouldn’t even be a war!”

She said that last part rather emphatically. Which he thought was good. He didn’t doubt her ambitions played some small role in her bringing this up, but for the most part he was rather sure she was more interested in avoiding the coming conflict.

The recent attack on the capital… well, it seemed to have brought some things into perspective for his quite sheltered sister.

That being the, well, ‘human cost’ of war. Something that had been all too abstract for her before now.

He also knew that she still cared for Tala and was worried about her…

…Also, it was rather fortunate that Verity was read in on his mother’s whole plan to engage in a little tacit treason, otherwise that outburst might have made things awkward. Which Olivia knew. His sister might have had something of a gossipy nature, but she wasn’t a total idiot.

She’d spilled things to him in the past because she trusted him – and while that had certainly come back to bite her in the ass, he couldn’t say she’d been necessarily foolish to trust her family.

At least in the abstract.

“Yes,” he agreed. “There likely wouldn’t be two Northern fleets baring down on us if I’d gone with mother’s plan. And we might well have avoided a civil war entirely in favor of a fairly bloodless coup.”

If he’d married Tala, and then they’d installed Olivia as the countess of Summerfield, he couldn’t see Southshore siding with the Crown against three other duchies. The North could do it because they had an incredibly outsized military, but as a southern house, there would have been little Southshore could have achieved beyond keeping the now traitorous House Summerfield navy occupied while Southshore and New Haven crushed the Royal Navy in a two on one fight. No, they’d be forced to side with the rebels – and faced with four duchies, there’d be little Yelena could have done but surrender.

Again, this was all theoretical, but he could see it playing out that way with some reasonable certainty.

And in the process, his house would get to become a duchy and he’d be married to the heir of the most powerful duchy in the nation – if not part of the new royal family, assuming that was the route the Blackstones intended to go down.

“But at what cost?” he continued. “We’d avoid a civil war, but all the free orcs in Lindholm would likely be stripped of their citizenship and forced back into slavery.” He made sure to look his younger sibling in the eye. “Including Verity here.”

The half-elf’s eyes widened a little as she glanced at the silent green skinned woman. Clearly, she’d realized she’d put her foot in it. She’d also likely not been thinking about that. Just that a war might be avoided.

She made a complicated expression. He knew she liked his team – with perhaps the notable exception of Bonnlyn.

He continued. “It’s good you’ve learned the cost of war. I’m proud of you, sister. But you also have to realize, there’s a cost to not fighting too. Perhaps we could have avoided this most recent attack on Blicland if we’d surrendered to the Lunites years ago when they called on us to rejoin the ‘Empire’. But then we’d just as likely be stuck in an endless war with the Solites.”

As he said that, he realized that his sibling hadn’t been read into the fact that the enemy behind the most recent surprise attack had definitely been Lunites.

Shit, maybe she wasn’t the only one with loose lips?

He continued anyway, ignoring the way her eyes had widened.

“And perhaps there wouldn’t be a war coming if I’d married Tala, we’d made you a duchess and then forced Yelena to surrender without a fight.” He sent Verity an apologetic glance. “But then there’s a decent chance we’d be fighting slave rebellions for the rest of time, at least once ‘Queen Blackstone’ started insisting that all the currently free orcs in the South needed to be put back in chains too.”

“You would,” Verity promised quietly. “I’m… not going back.”

He smiled, proud of her. She’d come a long way. Then he turned back to his sister.

“Unfortunately, conflict is a reality of life. You put two people in a room and they’re going to have differing opinions on how to do things. And unfortunately, when each side refuses to bend to words, they’re going to resort to other methods.”

Olivia stared at him, but it was Verity who spoke. “That’s… pretty bleak, William.”

Really? He didn’t think so. It simply was what it was. War was diplomacy by other means. That held true across worlds and dimensions apparently.

He shrugged, remaining focused on Olivia. “The best you can do, that any of us can do; is to hold to what you believe is right even if that means fighting for it - and hope that when your time is up, you go to the grave confident that you made the right choices.”

Olivia stared at him for a moment, before glancing away.

“Well in that case, I still think this is all a waste. If you’re going to fight, can’t you at least use all this for something? Instead of just burning it.”

Ah, she was being petulant now because she didn’t want to admit her big bro had said something super profound and cool. He smiled.

“Like what?” he asked.

She shook her head. “I don’t know? Set a trap or something?”

He laughed. “How? It’s a bit difficult to set a trap for an enemy that’s going to be floating nearly two kilometres off the ground when they arrive.”

“You could use bait, like you did with Al’Hundra?” Verity said.

Olivia squawked. “Wait, what do you mean like with Al’Hundra!?”

William shook his head.

He supposed the concepts were thematically similar. The enemy fleet had been two kilometers up. Al’Hundra had been a few hundred meters below sea level.

Unfortunately, Al’Hundra had been an animal. A very large, very old, very majestic and ancient animal – prior to him blowing her ass through her brain – but still just an animal.

And while he didn’t hold too high an opinion of Tala’s mother, she wasn’t an animal. At least in terms of intelligence. Morally it was a different story. So even if he created some kind of… ballast ballon, he didn’t think she’d be lured in by something as simple as a bunch of fish guts.

Besides, even if he could think of something to bait her with, there’d be no way she’d be dumb enough to…

He paused as a thought occurred to him.

“Olivia, you’re a genius!” he shouted, making both women jump.

Though not for long, as Olivia jumped down from the wagon to grab his shirt. “I know that! What I don’t know is why my big brother was apparently baiting a god-beast! Why were you anywhere near a god-beast!? Did the queen put you up to it!?”

--------------------

“No, I refuse.”

It hadn’t taken him much time at all to get an audience with Yelena at the Academy – the Queen’s current base of operations given the almost complete destruction of the palace during the attack. They were actually in the headmaster’s office currently, and he’d been allowed a private meeting. Which was good, given this plan very much relied on the utmost secrecy.

As such, the only people present were Griffith, Yelena and Tyana. He supposed it might have been possible that Solanna might have been allowed to attend, but the spoiled princess had apparently already fucked off out of the city again.

To which he could only say good riddance.

“You’ve barely even heard me out.” He most definitely didn’t whine.

The queen shook her head tiredly from behind her desk. “And that was enough for me to veto this insanity outright.”

“It would work.”

“Perhaps.” Yelena pursed her lips. “But only because it’s insane, unprecedented, and only marginally less scandalous than inviting the entirety of the North to negotiations here in the capital and poisoning them all.”

“It violates none of the rules of war,” he pointed out.

“Only because no one’s ever thought to do it before!”

“Because most people lack imagination.”

“Because most people aren’t…” she paused trailing off.

“Harrowed? Perhaps a little mad?” he chuckled, ignoring the slight wince of Griffith at the reminder of exactly what he was.

Which hurt a little. They’d not exactly had a chance to sit down and talk, given about everything that was going on. And that conversation was long past due.

That wasn’t his focus right now though.

“I was trying to be polite,” Yelena said tiredly. “But yes. All of the above.”

He leaned back. “It’d work though. And it’s not a warcrime the first time. And it’s not like any of our competition is in a position to repeat the feat. We’re pretty much the only people that can.”

“We’re not in that position though,” Griffith said slowly. “We need every resource we can get. And you’re suggesting we squander one of our most valuable.”

He found it funny that they were speaking in euphemisms now. As if saying the proper words was somehow taboo.

“Use,” said an unexpected voice. “If we come out ahead in this exchange, then we squander nothing.”

“Tyana!” Yelena looked betrayed as she stared up at her admiral daughter. “You’re going to go along with this!?”

The admiral’s expression was cool, as she glanced between a now beaming William and her tired looking mother. “I’m a navy woman, mother. More than that, I’m an admiral. I deal in assets gained and lost. That’s my bread and butter. And what your boy is suggesting here… well, I wouldn’t see it coming and I doubt that bitch Eleanor will either. It’s… unprecedented.”

“Because it’s insane!” Yelena didn’t quite yell, but it was a close thing – and served to highlight the bags around her eyes.

The woman looked tired. Which he didn’t blame her for. Not that she was the only one in the room to look that way, but she certainly looked the worst. He had to wonder just how many meetings she’d already had this morning alone. And that was ignoring the massive pile of paperwork on her desk.

Again, he was reminded of the show of faith inherent in her almost immediately agreeing to meet with him when he messaged her.

…Even if she seemed determined to dismiss his incredible idea outright just because it was a little taboo.

He felt for her a little. Soon they’d be abandoning her seat of power - and with that fact she likely felt like everything was slipping away from her. She was desperate for some measure of control - and that meant holding hard to what symbols of power she had left.

Unfortunately, if she wanted to win this war, that had to change.

“The line between insanity and genius is measured only in success,” he pointed out lightly.

Yelena sighed, and while her head didn’t quite hit her desk, it was a close run thing.

“If we do this, I want to take the assets required to do it out of your share of our current bounty,” she said quietly. “I can’t be the one seen to approve this.”

That was fine by him. He couldn’t hold onto all of it anyway. He was only a count, so he would have needed to ‘sell’ it back to the Crown eventually.

“Done!” William grinned. “Does that also mean I get all the credit afterwards?”

He had been fine with muddying the water regarding his technological contributions to the cause thus far, but when it came to military feats? Well, he wanted them all.

“Infamy, more like,” Yelena said. “You’re welcome to it.”

George didn’t share her pessimism. This was going to be great. Sure, William had started off this week worried they wouldn’t have enough time before the Northern fleets got here. Now… now they couldn’t get here fast enough.

He couldn’t wait!

Comments

Found&Lost

Only a day late not bad!

LtDan

Rig some of the extra cores to blow?

Blue Fishcake

The moral of the story is, as ever, never to trust me :D

22junk

I’m glad Olivia is finally being confronted with the hard moral implications of everything going on around her instead of just the practical dangers. Not least of all because anyone he did bring with him using that method he likely wouldn’t be able to trust anyone on any of his future production lines. Is that second “anyone” a typo?

Ember

Considering the several mentions of war crimes, Im thinking this is going to be a case of false surrender along side a health amount of booby traps, I can't wait!!!

22junk

When the atom bomb was being developed many of the scientists on the project were afraid that they would set the planet's atmosphere on fire. Even if he could figure out how to release a core's stored energy all at once it might be better for Will to stick to technology that he knows the exact repercussions of.

ImMoralMage

William "its not a war crime the first time" redwater. Is he using the load of kraken scales as bait i can't see them using a core or a shard.. hmm. I cant wait either

O

Why do I feel like he is going to use the cores as bait?

ImMoralMage

Ohh I didn't even think of a false surrender that's good!

LtDan

Man was just considering blowing up his own people and blaming it on Northern sabotage - I don't think a lack of knowledge of all possible consequences is going to stop him.

Vash

They gonna blow up the fucking palace...

MS

I read that in Williams voice. Lol

Andrew Lechner

Well, I was half wrong. He definitely did indeed decide to do something insane though. So what "Warcrime" is William planning? Presumably setting a bomb somewhere the Blackstones have to land?

Blue Fishcake

Lunites/Yelena kind of already beat them to it...

Vash

Oh. Right. Well whatever it is. Warcrimes!

Kaywye

I hereby name William Redwater a honorary Canadian. We know all about war crimes not being crimes the first time. Lol

James Ryan Bell

Not a war crime the first time is always how you gotta do it. Let's just hope he doesn't start mixing up agent orange or white phosphorus anytime soon.

Admiralthrawnbar

The cores are probably the bait at least. They're both incredibly valuable, while also being entirely useless in the current conflict.

Trevayne

Good update with lots of food for thought. Very interesting to get some insights into industrial production. It looks like they have figured out how to use magic to boost iron and steel production. Most of the non magic tech is still medieval, but they have managed welding tools. At a guess, something like oxy-acetylene welding since they do have a good understanding of pipes, plumbing, and gas storage/ transport.

Trevayne

Half a day, it looks like it showed up around 9 am on the East Coast and the last on time version would have been about nine hours earlier.

Trevayne

That is actually an interesting question. Do they have the concept of the laws of war and a just war? How many "international" wars have the countries of this world fought? I think the only thing I have seen condemned as some kind of violation was a chemical attack mentioned in the second book that was blamed on outlaws. Even though one of the elven factions (Lunites IRRC) got an advantage from it. Edit: No, it was the Solites that got the advantage from the chemical attack.

Trevayne

I suppose what he could do is sabotage whatever he has for a mooring. The Crown Vassal airships were destroyed because they were moored to skyport towers. When the Lunites appeared, they shot at the towers and brought them down, destroying up to four moored airships with each tower.

Trevayne

I suppose William could booby trap his own manor. Unlike Yelena's destroyed palace, it wasn't blown up earlier.

O

Wow. That sarcasm hurts.

Trevayne

It will be interesting to see how he does that. IIRC mithril cores are roughly spherical metallic rocks about the size of a bowling ball. Unless he leaves a big sign saying "Cores here", how do they serve as bait? I suppose he could have a big vault in his manor and his people could be told that yes, he was given say three of the seven Lunite cores recovered from the attack and that they were being stored in the manor's vault. The Blackstones would have to investigate because cores are that valuable, even though they would find it very hard to believe that William (or anybody else) would be careless enough to leave cores behind.

AceHW

is William actually oblivious that he's providing a show, or is he pretending to be oblivious? That plus what happened with them like last chapter (or was it the chapter before that), and William is being a tease, whether he fully realizes it or not. He also should tell her at some point that he had sex with one of her aunts or whatever, if that was the case.

AceHW

I'd like to see wholesome William and Olivia stuff, such as hugging and telling her at least one secret of his (or a bit of insight into the way he thinks, and her reaction of what she thinks about that), things like that. and continuing to be a good sibling

Trevayne

I doubt he wants to expend his own people in a false surrender. They have to be able to get away, unless he has some actual suicide volunteers. I could see an elderly person who doesn't think they will live to the end of this war deciding that they could "surrender" and lead the northerners straight to a bomb. Thinking about it, what he could do is have the northerners catch up to one of his ships towing a disabled airship. The tow line "breaks" and the disabled airship is left behind. The northerners board and capture the disabled airship and find out the hard way that there is a saboteur on board in a concealed compartment. The saboteur waits until there is at least one Northern airship alongside and sets a five minute fuse to detonate explosives. They use those minutes to escape by free falling and then using their maneuver suit.

Trevayne

I know just how you feel.

Trevayne

Err, pretty sure he is oblivious. They are all working very hard to pack up stuff that was never really intended to be packed up. I doubt William built his facilities expecting to evacuate them. Right up until the Lunite attack less than two weeks ago he thought they still had another year before the Blackstones started the civil war. As for aunts, I don't think he has had sex with any of Olivia's aunts, because they are all his aunts too. While this culture has a pretty positive attitude towards sex, I doubt they go that far.

Trevayne

I agree. I expect William is actually being even more tolerant than usual because he can see that she is now getting to see the consequences of the politics that she has been involved in. He tried showing her before with the fake kidnapping, but this is real.

Trevayne

I don't think we have seen any evidence yet that cores can explode. We know they do produce aether gas under high pressures, but I don't remember any references to cores actually exploding. They certainly seem to survive airship crashes in one piece. The problem with using cores as bait is that a big sign saying "Mithril Core Storage this way" would be very suspicious. If you just have a strongly built building without the sign, that is more likely.

AceHW

> it’s not a warcrime the first time He said the line! Lmao

AceHW

> “The line between insanity and genius is measured only in success,” he pointed out lightly. nice

Trevayne

Agreed. Thinking about it, one of the few ways I could see William coming up with a war winning potential weapon is to have the trailing ship fleeing ahead of and above the Northern pursuers while dispensing a cloud of nerve gas. Given that it would probably kill everyone on the ground below, along with the Northern airship crews, hopefully he isn't doing that.

Trevayne

Fake surrenders work in ground combat because the war criminals can just retreat afterwards. They are a lot more complicated here because after taking some casualties, the remaining Northerners just kill the war criminals and may no longer accept surrenders.

Trevayne

Interesting thought, now that the Civil War has broken out, I expect he can now answer Olivia's question about why he went anywhere near Al'Hundra. She is smart, so she will probably figure it out as soon as he starts explaining. She already knows that he had something to do with the Kraken Slayer because he told her he invented the flash bang and spellbolt and that they were related. She should already know that her brother can lie to her if it is important enough and she would know why thus would be important enough.

Trevayne

Interesting question, we see that William has developed prototype proximity fuses. However proximity fuses for what? Has he figured out how to make an enchanted aether cannon ball go off early or are they intended for conventional artillery? I suppose it is possible that they are intended for use on HVARs to make them better suited as anti-shard weapons, but I think they would work even better in say 120 mm AA guns.

Baron Von Mott

Success or failure, I have a strong feeling that whatever happens next is going to be absolutely spectacular! 😂

AceHW

No, one of Verity's aunts, on the ship, on his way to the academy the first time (near the beginning of story). it was mentioned in the story that when he met her family he recognized one of the people there as the orc lady he had sex with that time

MS

Damn i missed that!

O

The question then comes to how is he going to lure enough of the Blackstone forces to make a difference. After all, while the Blackstone would send some to investigate, I find it difficult for there to be enough to make a difference. Unless this is some kind of psychological attack.

zmessing11

Can't wait to see what kind of shenanigans George has planned for the Northerners, also hoping to see eventually what kind of reaction William's mother Janet has to her son being harrowed if she found out.

Trevayne

I just reread that part in chapter 51 and didn't see anything like that. Could you please point it out if it is in a different chapter?

Trevayne

Good question. It would be interesting seeing Janet Ashfield's reaction to the last few weeks. The raider attack on the capital, William becoming a national hero because he defeated the raiders, and then the civil war.

AceHW

I'll have to reread it later. I'm at work rn

aj0413

Oh. Hello Geneva Convention! Lmao “not a war crime the first time” indeed lmao

Trevayne

Thinking a little more about it, Countess Ashfield's reactions should be really interesting. I assume she is going to back the Queen, but given her past activities I don't think she will be that trusted. Although, if the Northerners win, are they going to let Janet Ashfield stay in charge since she backed out on their deal? She has a lot to think about now.

Trevayne

I agree that it would not be decisive. A ground storage vault is only going to get the investigating troops, possibly the airship that brought them if they were foolish enough to hover directly over it. One airship and some troops is attrition, not a decisive blow. It isn't just symbolic though, it would be inflicting actual damage on the Northern forces. They would have to do it another 50+ times for it to be decisive though.

Blue Fishcake

I'm at least ninety percent sure you're misremembering.

AceHW

Maybe so. if so, I have no idea why though.

Trevayne

It really is an interesting question as to just what constitutes a war crime in this world. I expect they are limited only by what the participants can imagine. Given that the Northerners are conducting a genocidal war of extermination against the orcs and the orcs are killing all the northerners they can get their hands on, what is war crime and what is just military business as usual. The only sign we have seen so far that some things are not legal was this mention of a chemical weapons attack from chapter 57. There was, after all, every chance that the fleet’s true target was either a Solite or Lunite city – and that it was simply gathering where it was to bypass either side’s usual coastal defenses. As for pretending to be pirates? Well, it would hardly be the first time either side of the old Empire had chosen to cloak their atrocities behind the actions of ‘rogue elements’. The gassing of Halmeshare leaps to mind, she thought. An act of horror supposedly performed by a band of outlaws who stumbled across an old imperial weapons lab. Never mind that said massacre neatly paved the way for a Solite advance into Northern Penbelle. It wasn't a Solite war crime because it was supposedly done by "outlaws". The other thing is that the whole idea of international law tends to depend on the acceptance of the existence of states. I get the distinct impression that neither the Solites nor the Lunites regard any other states as legitimate. From their perspective, they are all temporarily uncontrolled provinces of the Elven Empire that will be reclaimed as soon as they defeat their opponents and the Empire becomes a unified state on the main continent.

Trevayne

I agree that you are probably misremembering. It really wouldn't make sense. All of Verity's family are involved in working their farm. I doubt they would have one of her father's wives working as a sailor on a sailing ship when the rest of the family is on the farm. Even if it was the case, why would she be on the farm for William's visit and not on her ship?

AceHW

Maybe they could leave some damaged or fake airships someplace they would expect to find them?

AceHW

Ooh! What if he left a core or some shards and connected them to some guns (whatever air pressure powered guns from the plane), and have them be auto-fed the metal balls or whatever to shoot, and have it rotate back and forth somehow to shoot whoever, and then afterward somehow trigger an expolsion (or somebody shoots a missile from a distance)

Trevayne

The exchange between William and Yelena reminds me of something. Aside from William's fae granted knowledge, he has one other major advantage. He is the ultimate out of the box thinker in this setting because in addition to his fifteen or so years living as William Ashfield, he also remembers his life as George Statfield. Unlike everyone else in this world, George was born outside their box.

Trevayne

“Perhaps.” Yelena pursed her lips. “But only because it’s insane, unprecedented, and only marginally less scandalous than inviting the entirety of the North to negotiations here in the capital and poisoning them all.” “It violates none of the rules of war,” he pointed out. “Only because no one’s ever thought to do it before!” This suggests that there are recognized rules of war. The interesting thing is what are they? My guess is that there are two sets. The first is for conflicts where both sides are accepted as civilized. I would expect these conflicts have rules like no fake surrenders or attacks under a flag of truce. Don't just execute prisoners. Don't kill civilians for the fun of it. These rules recognize that war is nasty, but doesn't have to be as nasty as possible. The two sides are likely going to continue to exist afterwards and neither side really wants to wipe the other out. The other set of rules is that there are no rules and those are used in genocidal race wars like the Northerners vs the orcs.

Trevayne

replying to @AceHW - The problem with using guns or anything besides explosives with fragmentation items is that the Blackstones could retrieve the pieces and start to figure out some of his tech. Just seeing it in action would start giving them ideas. Explosives not so much. I agree that eventually the Blackstones will get samples of his tech. A HVAR rocket might not explode and be found after the battle on the airship, for example. However, even if they get a sample of some of his explosives, this world doesn't have the chemistry to really do much with it. Black powder for the Kraken Slayer is made of three relatively common substances (charcoal, sulfur, and salt peter/potassium nitrate), However things like TNT are not nearly as easy. About the only way I could see the Blackstones making more TNT is if there is a spell that can duplicate a chemical compound, even if the caster doesn't know what it is. Their chemistry just isn't advanced enough. And seeing the two things side by side, he found himself struck by how anachronistick the whole thing looked. By how anachronistic this whole world was. Things like basic chemistry remained miles behind their equivelants on Earth during the same rough time period, yet when it came to other things like plumbing or ventilation, the locals were almost close to the tech level of the first and second world wars.

AceHW

Trojan horse with a gift or seemingly-abandoned plane maybe?

O

Can we all take a moment to stop and thank Blue for both reading and liking all our comments. I don't know about you guys but I feel very happy and validated when they do

Trevayne

Not least of all because anyone he did bring with him using that method he likely wouldn’t be able to trust on any of his future production lines. In that regard, might be simpler to not waste transport space on them at all, he considered. We just have to ensure they’re near the silo when it’s time for it to be deny it to the enemy. Maybe frame it as a farewell party of some kind? Then he’d say it was an accident. Or better yet, enemy sabotage! He paused. Perhaps though that was too much? It seemed like too much. Even if it was an elegant solution. Glad to see William is learning to restrain some of George's more ruthless impulses. Indulging in them would be a waste. Even if he couldn't trust them on Corsairs, there are still lots of other things, like making iron from iron ore or steel plates, that they could do that wouldn't be as sensitive.

Trevayne

Agreed, even though I feel a little guilty for keeping him busy. It is his fault though, for writing such an interesting story with so much to think about and discuss.

O

True enough. Though I wouldn't be too surprised if he uses our comments to flush out the lore. Because I definitely would

AceHW

I wonder if there are any innovations William can bring about just by his memories and not needing any further harrowing on the topic, like some isekai protagonist

AceHW

Maybe blow up the enemy and blame it on the enemy somehow?

Trevayne

replying to AceHW - Damaged airships is possible, maybe some of the wrecks they can't take with them. I think Yelena intends to destroy them before she leaves. The thing about airships is that there really aren't that many of them and they last a long time. Thus they tend to be recognizable. I doubt there are more than 300-400 airships in all of Lindholm. Finding a bunch of dummy hulls would be suspicious because everyone knows how many there are. New hulls are only built to replace existing hulls or when a new core is dug up. There is no real point in having an airship without a core. It is just a big object that has to be maintained. That is why Yelena could not easily find any hulls to use her surplus cores on.

O

Character development!

AceHW

interesting that the queen hesitated for a moment to mention he's harrowed and at least a bit mad, whereas she didn't seem to be even that much restrained before. Like she's trying to take him seriously and keep the slightest bit of politeness and not call him mad to his face til he calls her on it

AceHW

Yeah, I'd like to see the reactions of his mother, his sister, and his favorite aunt. I wonder if he should tell the three of them at the same time, or just wait til it slips one way or the other, or til they ask him about the rumor. He also needs to severely warn Olivia away from it, saying her whole mind could be erased/overwritten with the mind of a stranger, among other things. And maybe at some point he could start having group meetings with the people he trusts to talk about it and answer/respond to questions about it, and so he doesn't have to repeat the story to different people, and certain people can get details he might not've wanted to reveal to that person individually (such as his sister or mother) His harem could also be there, and even the queen would be interested in his story of when and how it happened and what it was like for him.

Trevayne

I really think this war is going to strategically resemble WW1 at sea. On one side, you have Yelena and the RN. They resemble WW1 Germany in that they have a strong fleet but the enemy's is stronger. What they have going for them is that the Blackstones and New Haven can't just take all their ships and go after them. That would mean abandoning the capital and having to fight all the land based shards based nearby as well as the RN, the ducal ships, and Jellyfish. The Blackstones/New Haven represent the WW1 British. They have a bigger navy and they have the capital. The longer they hold the capital, the more legitimacy Yelena will lose until eventually her allies abandon her. Effectively, holding the capital results in effects on Yelena's side that resemble the British blockade of Germany, Their big problem is what happens everywhere else while they are concentrated on the capital. They also have to wonder about what else William is going to come up with. The Jellyfish and the Corsairs were a nasty surprise for the Lunites. They really don't want to have their own version of that surprise.

Trevayne

I don't think he needs any further harrowing at all. The harrowing that created the current version included full information on everything from Roman era weapons like the Pilum to Vietnam era weapons like the M67 fragmentation grenade. Given the gramophone recordings, it appears to be full information on everything he ever sensed.

Trevayne

Yelena is treating him with respect because his innovations are her best chance to win the war and have herself and her family survive.

Trevayne

That is part of the reason I enjoy this series even more than his other work. William is a character from our world and we living in it know things that may be of use in the story.

AceHW

I wanna say it said he also had a bunch of wikipedia articles and like hundreds of such things burned into his memory that he basically looked up with the fae and computer terminal in his dream/mind acting like some form of the internet

AceHW

That's good, but maybe they should just agree to speak plainly sometimes, and trust that the other won't get mad and rage over some small perceived slight

AceHW

It would also be cool if they could form some kind of near-friendship eventually, or he could be some kind of consultant sometimes

Trevayne

replying to AceHW - William doesn't remember being harrowed. He just remembers waking up one day with George Statfield's memories and the additional harrowed information when he was about 3 years old. He already told Yelena and his team that he was harrowed and has been harrowed for as long as anyone has known him, although his mother and aunts may remember his as a toddler before being harrowed.

AceHW

or some way to humanize themselves to eachother, him and the queen

Trevayne

replying to AceHW - Yes, he did that, but i don't think he was harrowing himself. I think he was just trying to dig into his memories. The information was already in his head, he just needed to access it. That section is in chapter 30 IIRC.

Trevayne

The problem with William speaking really plainly to the Queen is that he has plans for the post war period. In addition to freeing the slaves, he wants a permanent settlement of the orc situation, and he wants Lindholm to be a democracy. He thinks Yelena will be opposed to both of those. Given that, he doesn't think he can tell her everything. I don't think they are quite as hard as he thinks they are. He can solve the orc issue by dedicating part of his land as a permanent orc homeland. As long as he doesn't formally try to make them independent, the crown doesn't have much to say about what he does on and with his own land. If he wants to give 20-30% to the orcs, that is his business as long as he can meet his feudal obligations. As for democracy, there are a lot of stages between a modern OTL US or British style democracy and feudalism. It took several centuries on Earth and I doubt William can get to say 21st century Britain in his lifetime. I do think he can manage something that looks like 17th or 18th century Britain with a parliament that has a House of Lords and a House of Commons while retaining a strong role for the monarch. I think he could even sell it to Yelena by pointing out that she abolished slavery to ensure that everyone's talents were better utilized, including the orcs. A parliament would help that process. It would also help avoid another civil war by making it less likely that Yelena or a future monarch gets blindsided by opposition to a policy.

Alex LordThorsen

Our world has had gentlemen's accords for hundreds of years before we ever had written down rules of war. Similar to how Britain has no written constitution.

AceHW

Do we have any idea what the literacy rates are like? I assume the slaves at least aren't taught more than their 'owners' think they need to know.

blaze87b

"It's not a warcrime the first time" Ah, finally, a man of culture. TFE's reach is long indeed

karl grimm

The words of the Great Sage travel far and wide

karl grimm

I think we have to assume that he just happened to be someone who knew a lot about history, weapons and engineering before his memories were copied.

Jacob

I'm wondering if he's thinking of inflatable "dummy" airships (possibly mined?) like Britain used during the blitz or kamikaze strikes (since mages can easily abandon their shard).

karl grimm

The Harrowed knowledge wants to be used, we know that much. I think that it's feeding their darker impulses. We have to assume that that seeing slavery and a class system as bad comes from George so it doesn't seem like George is really that callous.

karl grimm

There is a concept called "death ground" coined by Sun Tzu. Essentially it's when there is no hope of retreat or negotiation then you must fight to the death. The Orcs are on death ground and they either win or everyone they know gets killed or enslaved. They probably don't care about rules. It's often to your advantage not to put your enemy on death ground though. Based on what was said in this chapter it doesn't seem like the combatants are there yet. I guess just murdering the entire royal family would generate too many problems for the rebels. This seems to be about who has the most power not about gets to survive. Not trying to minimize the stakes, just saying there is room for negotiation and the rules of war.

karl grimm

Thanks' Blue, appreciate you reading the comments. Although I like to think some comments might help make you a little bit better of a writer

AceHW

I mean what it was like having the body of a little kid with the memories of a 90-something year old man, and then what the harrowing feels like (the knowledge wanting to be used), and what it was like for him in the other world, and the differences and similarities, and what the world without magic but with advanced technology was like, and what their society looks like from his perspective, and all kinds of things. And the different gender ratio and social differences around that. He might also have stories he could tell from when George was in the military

Trevayne

Replying to Karl Grimm - Yes, but it is much more than that. He probably was fairly well read and knew a fair amount about weapons and other things. That said, I doubt very much that it is even possible for a normal human to remember all the design information for a Corsair's engine, let alone the aircraft itself. It specifically stated he had full information about every weapon he had ever encountered either at a museum or in a book or a wiki article. On top of that, he can recreate the grooves necessary to record any music he has ever heard.

Trevayne

Kamikazes are a possibility although I hope he doesn't suggest it. I don't think he has the time to create inflatable dummy airships. I expect he could given a few months, but not in a few days and that is all the time he has before he has to leave.

AceHW

Once it becomes public knowledge that he's harrowed and he publicly admits it, is there any reason he can't or shouldn't do random lore drops from our world, and his previous life? His personal life experiences, "common knowledge", stories, myths and legends, memes and jokes, tropes, things like that

Trevayne

Replying to Karl Grimm - Yes and no. I agree that they aren't all there yet. I agree that the orcs are in death ground because they either fight or they will be killed or enslaved. The northerners aren't there yet except those fighting the orcs. The northern leaders are there. If they lose they can expect to be executed for treason. Yelena and her faction probably aren't there yet. If it looks like her side is going to lose, she could probably go into exile. Her followers would just profess loyalty to the new dynasty.

AceHW

Story time with William would be interesting to plenty of people, I'm sure. Could make it a public performance, and/or even release audio recordings on records (how long does their runtime last at most for his records? or do we pretend it doesn't matter and they last as long as we need them to, or it's left vague how many of them are in any particular set of records?)

Trevayne

Why would he want to do that and when would he have the time? There is a war on, after all. Even once they win, he will be really busy trying to fix things in his new duchy. Especially trying to settle a genocidal war that has gone on for centuries.

Trevayne

I agree that slaves probably aren't taught how to read and write. The question is do the slave masters actively forbid it. I could see newly enslaved orcs who know how to read and write teaching their fellow slaves. As for the rest of society, I expect the mages/nobles are taught, along with most of the townsfolk. Unlike most OTL aristocracy, the key isn't blood as much as it is magical ability. Since it can manifest in any person, they are probably better off with relatively widespread literacy.

Trevayne

Replying to AceHW - I agree that hearing George's version would be interesting, but he doesn't have time. He also still has things to do. The problem with William just telling everyone about George is that he still has plans and telling everybody will interfere with them. He needs to win the current war and then he has to talk with Yelena to try to find out if he is going to have to fight her in the future.

Vortex

If I had to guess. He's going to turn that silo in to one big bomb set to trigger on some trap. Something that large I assume will flatten everything around it

Trevayne

Maybe. He will want to tell everybody to evacuate first. I really don't think he wants to kill his own people. He already accepts that they are not going to be happy because of all the infrastructure that he is about to burn.

Jacob

You're forgetting mage smiths. Give their simplicity (it's just a shaped tank, and maybe some piping for aether from a shared ground-based core) a few talented mage smiths could potentially turn one out in an afternoon. The hard part would be mining/weaponizing it, but William does have an existing stockpile to work with.

Jacob

I agree that Kamikaze would be a bad suggestion. Perhaps he's thinking a false-flag "betrayal" between New Haven and Blackstone?

Trevayne

I think you are forgetting just how big an airship is. You are talking about creating a decoy for something over a hundred meters long and 30 meters wide. Mage smiths could definitely make it, but unless he has hundreds available, it isn't happening overnight. Right now, he needs all his people loading and packing, so even if he has hundreds, I doubt they are available.

Trilobyte9364

Old fashion fire ship with extra explosion

Trevayne

Interesting question, how old is Yelena and how old are her children? We know she is an elf, so long-lived. We know her husband died around 30 years ago, so her youngest child is at least 30. Assuming her six children were roughly five years apart,that suggests she is around 80-90 depending on when she married and stated to have children. That also suggests her two oldest are around 60 and 55, which seems reasonable for a foreign affairs troubleshooter/heir and an RN Admiral.

Gjim

One war crime, please.

AceHW

I'd say that elves might grow up slower and take longer to reach adulthood, but do we know the ages of the elves in William's class/group?

Moonlightwind

"it’s not a warcrime the first time" is an insane statement to make, because like obviously he knows it *is* a warcrime since assumedly he lived through the Geneva conventions being made. So just because that particular one hasn't been done here before doesn't mean you don't know it is one. George really plays fast and loose with the morals, despite being beyond dead set on ending slavery. I do have to wonder if that was what William asked for when he Harrowed himself, a way to end slavery, since George is fanatically obsessed with it. I also really like that there is starting to be a line drawn between George and William, sort of like a split personality the more William realizes where the line between them is. Oh! and I also loved that his team has become his moral compass or external conscience, I think that's a wonderful connection to have between them. I've also seen that done with another sociopathic character, where they have another person who can help them determine right from wrong.

karl grimm

That seems imprecise, the main goal in war is to destroy the enemy's airships. If you can't do that kill their leaders or mages. I'm not sure how you would do either this way. What if he could make something the enemy would want to take inside their airship, it would have to be something valuable. I wonder if you could make a mithril core that would explode if it were used. No one would try it in the past because cores were the most valuable things in existence. Just a thought.

Trevayne

Replying to AceHW - I thought everyone in the first year was 18 or 19. I don't recall any indication that the elves like Marline and Olzenya were older chronologically.

Graves

Nothing wrong with filling your storage silos with liquefied Sarin gas, for research purposes

Trevayne

I think it depends a lot on what it is and what the local laws of war are. By current OTL standards, you could argue that using this world's magic in combat is a war crime, since one of the primary attacks is a fireball. That could be argued is equivalent to using white phosphorous. I think we can all agree that herding civilians into a death camp is a war crime, regardless of the exact means of killing. On the other hand, if country deployed a death ray that enables a trooper to fire a beam that can kill another opponent, is that a warcrime or is it just another way to kill at a distance? It is a warcrime for a naval vessel to open fire on a target while flying a flag that is not their own. Using such a flag to cross an area of ocean is a legitimate ruse de guerre aka a legal disguise. It becomes a warcrime if the warship opens fire while flying a flag other than its own. On the other hand, the concept of IFF was not invented when the treaties were written. Is spoofing IFF signals so the opponent thinks the aircraft flying towards him is friendly a war crime? Or does iut just become a warcrime if bombs are dropped before cancelling the spoofing. I don't know what the lawyers have decided or if they have even considered it. I just bring it up to point out that there are lots of areas where the laws of war are not universal. Edit: I am pretty sure that William is not talking about mass murder, torture, or rape of civilians. As for combatants, killing them is generally accepted by the laws of war. Until we see William do something that is clear a violation, I would not jump to conclusions. For another example, if William hypothetically invented a device that rendered all mithril cores within a five-hundred-mile radius inert and no longer capable of generating aether, I am pretty sure everyone on Lindholm would consider him a war criminal because he just destroyed the justification for nobility. On the other hand, he has headed off the civil war without killing anybody (all the airships would slowly sink to the ground, they wouldn't abruptly crash). Is he a war criminal?

karl grimm

I had been thinking along those lines before, but Williams statement in this chapter made me think differently. He said if he went along with his mother's plan there would have been little bloodshed. This made me think maybe this sort of thing has happened before with power being reshuffled but leaders still surviving. The argument against that might be that William expects to be given the Ashfield's land after the war, which might imply he expects them to be dead. On the gripping hand there's a difference between winning through maneuver and alliance and winning through open war. The winners might be a lot less concerned with keeping up appearances and observing niceties.

Trevayne

Replying to Karl Grimm - It depends on what gets turned into a bomb and how it is used. The Lunite raiders destroyed nearly all the Crown Vassal airship in the attack on the capital by destroying the skydocks so they dragged the attached airships into crashing on the ground. I don't know how close the fuel tower (probably some kind of distilling tower) is from the airship mooring facility, but he could put a sizable shaped charge in the mooring tower that would probably blow a hole through any airship that used it. The fueling tower might not be close enough. Although, if the goal is to kill mages, then put a bomb in the fuel silo so when mages examine it, it explodes and kills them. I expect most of their skilled personnel are mages so they are likely to be the ones trying to figure out what it does. Assuming og course that William doesn't just burn it before he leaves.

Trevayne

replying to Karl Grimm - I think the Blackstone's initial intent was for a bloodless coup with Yelena and her immediate supporters going into exile and the RN probably broken up between the Blackstones and New Haven. I don't think Blackstone wanted a big battle because anyt losses would make holding off the Solites or Lunites harder. New Haven wouldn't care as long as their ships remained intact to be ready to backstab Blackstone. I don't think it has happened before in Lindholm, but it was possible. If I remember the history, around a thousand years ago the Elven Empire swept out and conquered the known world, with the possible exception of Old Growth. around 300 or so years ago, the Empire split up between the Dark Elven (Lunites) and High Elven (Solites) factions. Lindholm became independent at that time under one of Yelena's predecessors. I don't remember any mention of any other dynasty and this is probably part of why Yelena was blindsided. She was pushing emancipating the orcs to improve Lindholm and failed to allow for the centuries of hatred for the orcs by Blackstone and New Haven. Even they were a little hesitant about rebelling. Although, thinking about it, maybe their real intentions for Yelena were not shared with their co-conspirators like the Ashfields. Yelena or her heirs alive could have been a focus for restoration efforts. It might have been simpler just to kill them all when they got the chance. However telling their allies that might have cost support.

JaxonJak

Cowabunga it be then.

Trevayne

Pretty sure even William's ruthless side would not do that because it would kill all of his people in the village around his manor. I think he expects to keep Redwater as a holding even if he wins.

Trevayne

Thinking about it, I think William needs to make sure the Alchemists have nothing to do with any POW camps he eventually sets up. I don't think Piper would go full Mechanicum and try to turn any captured Blackwoods or New Havens into servitors, but why make her have to resist the temptation? I expect she is regretting her blithe comments about how politics is ephemeral while science is immortal.

Trevayne

I am really curious about where Tala is going to wind up in all of this. One guess for the near term, she is not going to be affected by whatever surprise William comes up with. I think she is too interesting a character to kill this early. I do think there is a good chance she will witness it though. If he kills an airship in some sneaky fashion, she will see it and dislike him even more. I still think in the long run she is more flexible than her mother and not as set in her ways. I think Eleanor is going to be killed in combat or executed for treason. I think Tala is going to have to pick up the pieces. I am hoping she winds up as an advisor to William on how to avoid stepping on toes unnecessarily in his new Duchy. I doubt very much he can take over without killing people, and that is after the war. That said, there is a difference between killing 1-3% of the population and killing 15-30% of the population.

Trevayne

I am curious as to how the war will go, but assuming Yelena's side wins, I am really curious about how the peace will go. Some things are obvious. Slavery is over, both because the slavers are rebels who are getting attainted and possibly executed for treason and because there were plenty of loyal orcs fighting for Yelena. After spending this much Lindholmian blood, I don't see Yelena backing down either. That means William is going to have to do the equivalent of the OTL US Reconstruction in Blackstone and unlike OTL, this time he has to get it right. At a guess, he will arrive with some troops and airships to officially take over, but then what? I figure he can buy some time with the orcs by giving them their current lands and tell them he will keep the humans out if they stop raiding. Then he can start with some tours. Take mixed groups past wreckage showing how orcs have killed humans and humans have killed orcs. Pointing out to the humans that he is not going to kill the orcs for their convenience, and if they can't learn to live together, it at least separately on their own territories, they can leave. There are at least four other duchies on Lindholm. The orcs don't have any place to go, so if push comes to shove, William will side with the orcs.

Trevayne

Thinking some more about the post war situation, William can also make progress with democracy. He is going to have several subordinate counts and other nobles that need to be confirmed or replaced. To borrow an idea from another story, he could direct that each noble establish an advisory council, with two elected representatives from each of the farmers, the townsfolk, and the subordinate nobility/gentry. This gets his people in the habit of conducting elections without immediately trying to overthrow the existing order. They would not have much power, but would be set up to serve as a management council in the Lord's absence or as a recency council if the lord is a child. The really nice thing about introducing a degree of democracy this way is that he can do it on his own authority. He isn't taking power away from his vassals, he is just telling them that they should consult with their councils. He is changing how things work in Blackstone and that is within his authority. If things work out and Blackstone is doing better, he can point to his reforms as to why they are getting better and the other nobles may considering similar ideas themselves. It will certainly give him some ammunition in arguing that Yelen should expand something like this to the rest of the duchies.

Trevayne

On a related, but different issue, I wonder what is going to happen to New Haven? The one thing I am sure of is that William isn't getting it. Yelena has already expressed reservations about William having Blackstone by conquest and Summerfield by marriage. She would not let him have a third duchy. Pretty sure she would just marry him herself first. Thinking about it, William should really reconsider his reluctance. He ought to sit down and talk with Yelena about where things are going after the war. She might be opposed to a democratic transition, or she might be open to argument. Right now, he just assumes she is opposed. I think we can all agree that if she was willing to entertain his ideas, it would be a lot easier to implement them if he was the Prince-Consort. Getting back to New Haven, I expect a thorough house cleaning there, especially if their Solite backing comes to light. The Blackstones were traitors to the monarchy, but New Haven is a traitor to the whole idea of an independent Lindholm. At a guess, maybe Yelena makes one of her children the new Duchess of New Haven. Appointing an elf would make it go over easier in a traditional elf ruled area. However, it would point out that things have changed and they aren't going back to the Elven Empire, or at least one that isn't run for and by Lindholm.

Graves

Sarin gas oxidizes very fast and would only effect his workshops, estate and the air above it. The gas wouldn't have time to reach the nearest settlements as they would be a few kilometers from his compound, it's high vapor pressure will dispers the liquid into gas extremely fast and only linger in basements where it can mostly displace all the oxygen slowing the molecules breakdown. In essence he would have a 10 to 15 min kill zone with his workshops and cellars being around 45 min. After it oxidizes there won't even be a trace of it ever being there.

karl grimm

William seems thinking in terms of one thing at a time. That said many of the weapons that Will is introducing might naturally push society more towards democracy. As it stands mages matter most in society. So much so that Verity, a slave, was allowed to attend the academy. By allowing muggles to fight on equal terms with mages he is closing the gap at lest in terms of fighting power.

karl grimm

William might have good reason to think the Queen would be opposed to democracy. It means giving up her own power after all. Also if he tells her and she is against it she will be suspicious of him going forward.

Trevayne

Yes, but he can get an idea of how she feels just by talking about his own world. Also, she has just had a civil war and might be motivated to figure out how to head off another one.

Trevayne

You are making a number of assumptions including the location of the nearest villages, thatr there is no wind on the day this happens, and that his manor would be uninhabited. He is taking his mage-crafters, not every servant working in his house. Again, I don't think he wants that kind of collateral damage. That is also assuming he can easily use alchemy to create sarin. It is somewhat more complicated a molecule than aviation gasoline or motor oil.

Trevayne

I think getting equal needs firearms, not fighter planes.

karl grimm

It's not something he really needs to worry about now anyway. It's a much bigger societal change then removing slavery. It will probably take at least a decade or two of laying the groundwork before he is ready to make that kind of a shift.

Trevayne

replying to karl grimm - I agree it is not really anything he needs to worry about now. All he is doing at present towards that goal is maintaining his independence and not marrying into the royal family. They both have to win the war with the Blackstone and New Haven duchies first.

Trevayne

Thinking some more about the chapters, do we know if the queen has exchanged geases with William yet? They agreed to do it in chapter 64, but I am not sure it has actually happened yet. It doesn't need to happen immediately, because the Yelena is in no position to start putting William's tech info to use and William doesn't need his safety net until he starts turning over technical information. Both of them certainly have lots of other things they have to do, and they get even busier once it is confirmed the northers are on the way. We know William feels it when he has an active geas. He had one with Marline, but the restrictions disappeared for him when he gave her the core. He has multiple geases with his senior mage crafters and Xela, but I don't think they place any restrictions on him. Those are just geases to keep his secrets. The upcoming deal with Yelena is the first geas since Marline that actually binds him as well as binding Yelena. The restriction he is accepting is staying off the throne of Lindholm and we know he has no problem with it because he has no intention of claiming the throne. The reason this matters is because if Yelena sees the sort of visions of William's world that Xela got to see, I would certainly expect her to ask what kind of government does it have to produce those marvels. I expect William will answer her by stating that most of the really powerful countries are democracies. While there are a few monarchies around, they are constitutional monarchies where the monarch has seriously limited power. I expect Yelena will do a lot of thinking after that. She will probably ask William more questions about his world and that will give him some idea of how she seems to feel about democracy.

Trevayne

It is sort of amusing to see just how far off the rails of an academy story this has gone. The first two books were mostly academy. There was the threat of a war with the Blackstones and New Haven in the future, but defeating Tala's team in book 1 meant that the opposition had to spend most of a year rehabilitating her. However, Blue had to have to orcs capture some airships and things started going down hill from there. The captured airships and the inability of the Blackstones to find them set up the underships as a means to resolve how and why that happened. The Blackstone ambush of the orc airships meant that Yotul had to flee with her surviving undership. She went to the Lunites, who naturally saw the opportunity to raid the capital of Lindholm to try to get the secret of the Kraken Slayer. The Lunites conducted a very successful raid on the capital, probably destroying anywhere from 20-27 Crown Vassal airships. Unfortunately for them, the one vassal airship they didn't destroy was the Jellyfish and we know how that turned out. However, the raid was successful enough that it created an opportunity for Blackstone and New Haven. The war that was supposed to be a year or two away is beginning right now. Thinking some more about this, this whole mess happened because of Yelena's greed. William used his kraken slayer device to kill Al'Hundra and get cores for himself and Marline. It was the Queen's idea to negotiate with William for more Kraken Slayers and go after the rest of the cores she could recover. This was foolish because she didn't have airships for those cores. Instead of creating a much larger RN (her probable intent), all she managed was to put a gigantic target on her back as the word spread that the Queen of Lindholm has both the single largest concentration of readily transportable wealth in the history of the planet (all those cores) and the secret to how to get even more. Don't get me wrong, I like Yelena as a character. I understand why she managed this massive error. It is hard to imagine that when you have the opportunity to gather massive wealth from the ocean, the smartest move is to just leave it alone. if she had just settled for grabbing Al'Hundra's hoard of mithril cores, she might have avoided the raid. One kraken could have died of natural causes, especially a very old one like Al'Hundra. It was killing multiple krakens that revealed that Lindholm had figured out a way to do it. That was what made Lindholm a target.

Trevayne

Interesting thought, is Blicland going to close for the duration or will it keep operating? We know that all the Blackstone and New Haven linked cadets have left. We also know that some of the others left due to fears over their safety. However, what do Blackstone and New Haven do with it? Do they just let it continue to operate, since they are trying to pretend this isn't a coup. Their fleets have supposedly arrived to provide security for the capital. Keeping the academy running might help them sell that. On the other hand, the school has a core, which could power one more airship.

Trevayne

George didn’t share her pessimism. This was going to be great. Sure, William had started off this week worried they wouldn’t have enough time before the Northern fleets got here. Now… now they couldn’t get here fast enough. He couldn’t wait! Somebody needs to smack George. I can understand being eager to kill some Blackwood or New Haven airships, but they still have to evacuate. Even if he has come up with a cunning plan that can destroy 3-5 opposing airships, that is not going to alter the immediate outcome. The RN and allies, including the Jellyfish are still going to have to retreat. About the only way he could really defeat them is if he figured out how to make AIR-2A Genie rockets and fire them from Corsairs. Those would be close to a guaranteed one shot, 1-2 kills per weapon since they come with 1.5 kt nuclear weapons. One will definitely kill an airship if it hits. One exploding between two airships might well take both of them out. No, I am not advocating for William to literally go nuclear. I am trying to point out that there are no easy win gambits so George's glee over being able to kill a few airships is misplaced. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AIR-2_Genie

Trevayne

Thinking some more about the post war, we know that William will take over the Blackstone lands and become the Duke of Blackstone. We don't know what happens to the Duchy of New Haven. Presumably the current Duchess will be attainted so the title is removed from her and her heirs. I expect she will either be killed in combat or executed for treason. Unlike Blackstone, where Eleanor is almost certainly going to die in combat or be executed, I could see New Haven fleeing to the Solite Empire. That said, i wonder how far down the housecleaning will go? Will they remove all the current countesses and other subordinate nobles, or will they be allowed to bend the knee and reaffirm their loyalties to their new ducal overlords and the crown? I expect it depends on their actions. This opens up an interesting possibility for Olzenya. She is the sixth daughter of House Sumond, which I think is one of the counties in New Haven. After they win the war, maybe she gets the opportunity to inherit her house after her mother and sisters are attainted.

Trevayne

On a different topic, William does have another possibility besides kidnapping or killing any of his Mage crafters that doesn't want to leave Redwater with him. He could tell them, "Look, I know you are not happy about leaving your homes. That said, I can not afford to let the Blackstones get you. Since I know you are angry with me, I don't think you can work on Corsairs any more. Given that, you can work on basic tasks like steel making or iron smelting for me or you can go work for the Queen." Granted, he would have to clear this with Yelena first, but I doubt she would turn anybody away who had worked in William's Corsair production. William wouldn't mind. He wouldn't have to worry about any sabotage from them and he had already agreed to give all the Corsair info to Yelena already. Having some of his disgruntled mage crafters going into her service means that watching them is now her problem.

OfficerTroy9

Just had this realization over on the discord. Giving credit here to the one who vocalized it first

LazyKing

If he’d married Tala, and then they’d installed Olivia as the countess of Summerfield i think it should be duchess of Summerfield. Not countess.

Trevayne

Yes, I agree that is a glitch, and not the only one. If he’d married Tala, and then they’d installed Olivia as the countess of Summerfield, he couldn’t see Southshore siding with the Crown against three other duchies. The North could do it because they had an incredibly outsized military, but as a southern house, there would have been little Southshore could have achieved beyond keeping the now traitorous House Summerfield navy occupied while Southshore and New Haven crushed the Royal Navy in a two on one fight. No, they’d be forced to side with the rebels – and faced with four duchies, there’d be little Yelena could have done but surrender. I am pretty sure that is supposed to be Blackstone and New Haven, not Southshore and New Haven. Especially since it was Southshore against Summerfield in the preceding sentence.

Trevayne

Yet another interesting question, how will firearms affect this world? I expect the simple answer is they will close the gap between non-mages and mages. Mages can easily kill others with fireballs or lightning bolts. Non-mages were limited to bows and crossbows which are limited. Both can use firearms, which certainly improve the chances for non-mages. However, firearms are not nearly as versatile and can be taken away. It is much harder to take magic away from a mage. The reason I am mentioning this is a discord commenter mentioned that the only thing that could lead to democracy on Lindholm would be the widespread distribution of firearms. I disagreed saying that just having the gun toting plebes against mages would lead to a wild west situation that resembles OTL Somalia more than democracy. The problem is just like magic, being really skilled with guns requires time and funds to practice. That means a skilled gun fighter is closer to a mage than the average peasant handed a gun. On OTL Earth, large enough groups could make up for primitive weapons and/or lack of skill by grouping up. Combat between armies came down to formed units of troops firing muskets for two centuries. However, that isn't going to work on Lindholm because airships can easily wreck armies. Given that, how are guns (rifles and pistols) going to affect this world?

Trevayne

Some real estate thoughts, assuming Yelena's side wins, William is going to become the Duke of Blackstone and one of the four most powerful non-royal individuals in Lindholm. He gets the duchy and its territories. He keeps Redwater as a secondary title and holding. I doubt he will move back there, but I think he will use it as a country place when he has business near the capital. I do think he is going to need a mansion in the capital, so he doesn't have to use a hotel or stay in an apartment in the palace. He might even have one already, since the Blackstones probably had one. That one could easily have been destroyed in the Lunite attack and he might want to sell it (or what is left of it) and build something that better meets his needs. As for Blackstone, I think he is going to settle the Alchemist's guild there and that will be his research and manufacturing base. Redwater is probably too small and harder to defend in the crownlands if push comes to shove with Yelena. Note, I do not think another civil war is likely, but precautions IMHO make it even less likely.

MS

Release status? Thanks 😊

Trevayne

I am not Blue, but since it is already Saturday on the US East Coast, I am thinking Saturday or Sunday. I expect the plotting is getting difficult as it comes down to the crunch time of the Northerners arrival at the capital. That actually gets interesting. Do they actually just stay at the capital or do they try to go after Yelena and the RN? For that matter, how long before they go for nearby targets like Redwater?

Trevayne

Thinking some more about it, if the RN leaves in time, this Civil War/attempted coup is going to resemble the Phony War period in OTL WW2. The RN pulled out because it did not want to fight the Blackstone and perhaps the New Haven fleet out numbered. However, the justification for the arrival of the Blackstones and allies was the need to secure the capital. What they were hoping for was to fight and destroy the RN and capture Yelena. She would then be executed or exiled and the rest of Lindholm could pledge allegiance to its new Northern management. The excuse of securing the capital served to get the Northern fleets there, but it also ties them there because if they are chasing off after the RN, they clearly aren't securing the capital. In addition, the longer the North is "securing" the capital, the more political support Yelena can expect to lose because if she is the Queen and legitimate ruler, why doesn't she control her own capital? On the other hand, the more time she takes in Southshore/Summerfield, the more she can build up her strength. She can do that by letting William build more Corsairs and his other weapons and by repairing the derelict airships that she brough with her. These were the salvageable wrecks that could fly with a core and patched aether tanks even if they needed to be towed by another airship to move. If one is suitable, maybe they could convert it into another Jellyfish style carrier. If the ongoing loss of legitimacy wasn't an issue, Yelena would win because William can out produce the rest of Lindholm in terms of combat power. Unfortunately, Yelena cannot just hole up in the south for a couple of years while William builds an unstoppable air fleet.

Trevayne

Thinking some more about the civil war kicking off, I wonder just how many people know about the kraken slayer? William and his team know, along with Yelena and her people. Clearly, the Lunites know or they would never have tried their raid to capture it. I expect the secret can be described in multiple layers. The innermost is how to make black powder and put it in an improvised mine with contact detonators using a short delay. That is how kraken are actually killed. The next layer is that Yelena has the device and William had something to do with it. The next layer is just that there is such a device and Yelena has it. The outermost and public layer is that krakens have been dieing. All this matters because not everybody seems to have gotten the same story. The Limited raided the capital and the academy because that us where they thought they could get the secret. They clearly didn't think William knew about it or they could have tried raiding Redwater. The big question now us how much do Eleanor Blackstone and the Duchess of New Haven know? Are they going after William because they think he had something to do with the kraken slayer or is it just because he was responsible for humiliating Tala, the Blackstone heiress. Both are good reasons to go after him from the Blackstone POV, but I expect they will move faster if they think he has the secret.

James Ryan Bell

You know he is giving his Blackstone holdings to the free orcs

Trevayne

Replying to James Ryan Bell - He said he would be creating a homeland for the orcs. He did not say he was going to use all of the Blackstone lands for that purpose. I doubt he intends to stop the genocide of the orcs by genociding all the humans in the Blackstone lands.

MarakEvans

But is it a warcrime if it isn't tried?

Addeand

seeing the two things side by side, he found himself struck by how anachronistick the whole thing looked. By how anachronistic this whole world was. Things like basic chemistry remained miles behind their equivelants on Earth during the same rough time period, yet when it came to other things like plumbing or ventilation, the locals were almost close to the tech level of the first and second world wars Anachronistic and equivalents are both misspells here