Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

“What a load of bollocks,” Olzenya muttered as the princess’s speech finished from her position on the Jellyfish’s command chair – having given the order for them to launch corsairs mere minutes ago.

William didn’t disagree. Even while trying to extort her fellow countrymen in a feigned heartfelt plea to join her little band of traitors, the princess still managed to sound unbearably above it all.

Well, at least now we know why she was back in the city, he thought. And how the North is justifying their attack.

They had a princess in their corner – and through it a semi-legitimate reason for rebelling. Still, annoying as that was, he couldn’t help grinning.

Because this whole situation was perfect.

He grabbed the radio. “Trojan Horse. Start advancing now. Full speed.”

The radio crackled, the slightly muffled sound of one of Yelena’s royal guards coming through. “Say again, Command Two? Advance?”

William nodded, repeating, “Advance. Full speed. Then evacuate as planned.”

There was a pause, long enough for him to get a little worried, before his radio chirped again.

“…Confirmed, Command Two. Ship advancing.”

William didn’t like the delay there. The guardswoman had likely been getting confirmation from ‘Command One’ before she moved. He also noted that she’d not confirmed that she was planning to evacuate either. Which meant his orders could yet theoretically be reversed.

At great personal risk to the guardswoman in question.

He sighed as he stood at the railing of the Jellyfish’s bridge – ignoring the looks he was getting from Olzenya in the command throne. This was at least part of why he would have preferred to make this whole thing radio controlled. Unfortunately, while he could accomplish a lot with his tech, he couldn’t perform ‘magic’. And unfortunately for him a mithril core did require a mage to be present if it was going to keep producing aether. Less so than a shard core, which would shut off after eight minutes without prompting, but a full sized ship core would still only continue working for a few hours before it needed to once more be prompted to work by a mage.

And unfortunately for him, no one had known when the attack would start, which meant Yelena’s chosen bodyguard had been sitting in the Trojan’s Horse engine room in a diving suit all night - hooked up to the mother of all oxygen tanks.

Fortunately she only needed be? close to the core to activate it, rather than actively touching the thing. Because that would have required some part of her skin be bare – and the stuff she was currently literally swimming in would do nasty things to living flesh with enough exposure.

He grabbed the radio again as he watched the undership keep flying towards the enemy fleet. “Admiral Tyana, if you would please order the fleet to arc some shots towards our ‘defecting ship’?”

“I-” The voice returned, the woman on the other end likely thrown off guard by the presence of her sister and the sudden advance of the lynchpin of their plan. “Are you insane? You’re asking us to shoot at that thing!? This wasn’t the plan!”

William shrugged. “This is the new plan. The better plan. One only possible thanks to your sisters rather inane plea for us all to go traitor. Alas, one of our ships has clearly taken up her offer and now needs to be brought down before it can join with our enemies.”

A muffled sound of frustration came through the line.“Lord Redwater. Boy. You realize one of our ships breaking ranks might well have encouraged others to do the same? You could have just started a full scale defection in our ranks amongst the… weaker willed part of the fleet.”

Huh, he supposed he might. It wasn’t like the fleet knew about the plan – beyond the fact that they planned to retreat. And if that was going to happen, some ships would need to be part of a sacrificial rear-guard action.

With that possibility in mind, he supposed it wasn’t entirely impossible that Solanna’s plea might have found fertile ground amidst some of the royal fleet. And by letting his ship ‘go first’, well, it might have encouraged others.

“I had total faith in the loyalty of our Royal Navy,” he said eventually.

“I’m sure.” Tyana sighed. “And if a shot penetrates our defecting ship – over the capital?”

He scoffed. “It was originally an undership – and you saw how well armored they are. From this angle I consider it unlikely we’ll be able to get any kind of penetration - just so long as you don’t use any enchanted munitions.”

He watched as the ‘Trojan Horse’ continued flying towards the enemy fleet, the bulbous submarine shaped vessel chugging along under the power of its two side mounted propellers. Not terribly fast though - which made sense given just how weighed down it was.

Tyana continued. “…My sister is aboard one of those Northern ships. I know my own feelings on what I want to do about that traitor, but at least I need to get confirmation from-”

“Do as he asks,” Yelena’s voice came over the line – the woman choosing to remain silent until now. “She’s chosen her side. At least now we know why Blackstone and New Haven always seemed to know what was going on in the palace. Your sister must have had contacts amongst the staff.”

Despite her blasé words, there was no missing the… sadness in Yelena’s voice.

Tyana didn’t verbally respond, but in mere seconds a series of flags were raised on the hull of her command ship and the royal fleet opened fire as their ‘traitorous ally’.

Again, fortunately the well-armored undership had been given enough time to get some range, and most royal navy ships had few if any front-facing cannons compared to their broadsides. He watched as cannon shots arced out and did relatively little beyond plink off the armored hull.

At first.

Because a few went for the obvious weak points of the propellers, and sure enough, one was quickly knocked out of commission. At a decent range at that.

“There’s no denying that the Royal Navy’s well drilled,” he murmured.

The Trojan Horse swerved slightly, thrown off course, and now practically drifting.

…Two-thirds of the way to the enemy fleet.

It was rather unfortunate that they’d not been able to communicate to the fleet for them to shoot, but only to make it look good.

Fortunately, the ship had made it far enough for his needs – and was only drifting closer still as inertia carried it forward. It was… pretty much clear of the capital now.

“Come on, take the bait,” William muttered as he stared at the motionless ships of the Northern fleet. “That’s an entirely new ship for you. With an entire core inside. Maybe even shard cores as well. I know you have to want it. It'll even provide some legitimacy to your propped up idiot.”

The original plan had called for the royal fleet to retreat after exchanging a few shots while the shards remained in close proximity rather than rushing ahead to clash between the fleets as was the norm – at which point the Trojan Horse to suffer ‘engine trouble’ and fall behind once clear of the city. At which point it would have been boarded in passing.

This though? This was so much better though, as he watched with glee as the forward elements of both enemy fleets moved forward - clearly intending to wrap protectively around the ‘defector’ as they exchanged long-range cannon fire with the royal navy.

It was all he could do not to dance about with glee as the battle started in earnest.

-------------

Tala stood and watched from aboard the Brimstone as the battle started, both fleets firing probing shots at each other. At this range, they were unlikely to accomplish much unless they got a lucky hit on the propellers.

As had happened to the ship that had tried to defect from the royal navy.

Even now, the forward elements of the Blackstone and New Haven Fleets were coming alongside and above it.

“Are you sure this is wise?” the young woman asked.

Something was off. The royal navy were firing at the undership, but the shards they had remained on standby, hovering around their own fleet in formation. It was for that reason that the Northern Fleets were doing likewise, not quite yet ready to make the first move in earnest.

“The princess is whining that she wants that ship,” Elanore Blackstone said casually from her position on the command throne. “And I don’t disagree. It’s unexpected, but even one ship from the royal fleet defecting is a political boon for us.”

Tala understood that, she did, but something still felt strange to her.

“And the ship still hasn’t communicated at all?” she asked.

Even if it didn’t have a communication orb aboard, there were still the signaling flags, but those remained steadfastly down.

Her mother turned to eye her. “Girl, there’s every chance there’s a mutiny going on aboard that vessel right now. I doubt the entire crew is onboard with this little loyalty shift. Void, I’d put even odds on the fact that two women are currently fighting to death on the comm station.”

“I’d take those odds,” the ship’s XO murmured.

“I know you would, you reprobate.” Elanore grinned at her old comrade in arms.

Tala remained silent, staring out at the enemy formation that still refused to move even as it exchanged fire with the ships that had moved to escort the defector back towards the Northern formation.

And she could see it. Easily amidst the more conventional designs.

The Jellyfish.

And the planes that had been launched from it – nearly thirty all told, ten more than the Brimstone, the pride of the Northern fleet – weren’t hovering. For some reason they were going in circles.

Part of William’s new ‘aetherless’ shards, she thought.

Solanna had spoken about them, but much like most of the information the milksop relayed, it was almost entirely bereft of actually useful intelligence. Unfortunately, their own contacts in the capital hadn’t known much more.

They did know that the Jellyfish had been instrumental in defeating the force that attacked the capital and that it had armaments capable of crippling the attacking ships. Her mother claimed said attack had been a result of Yelena expending large amounts of her enchanted munition stockpile, but Tala was worried that her one time fiancée had-

A thunderous roar shattered the air, the world tilting violently as a shockwave slammed into the Brimstone like the fist of an angry god. Tala was hurled backward, her body crashing against a brass railing with bone-jarring force. Glass exploded inward from the bridge's forward windows, shards raining down like glittering knives as alarms blared to life across the command deck.

She hit the deck hard, the metallic tang of blood filling her mouth where she'd bitten her tongue. For a disorienting moment, everything was chaos - shouts, the groan of stressed metal, and the acrid scent of smoke and ozone.

"Status report!" Elanore Blackstone's voice cut through the din like a whip, the duchess already hauling herself up from her command throne, her face a mask of fury and focus.

Tala likewise clambered to her feet, ignoring the protests of her bruised ribs, and staggered to the shattered viewport. What she saw made her blood run cold.

 The defector ship - the bulbous, armored hulk that had drifted so enticingly into their midst - was simply... gone.

Vanished in a plume of fire, debris and oily black smoke that hung in the air like a malevolent cloud. The vessels that had closed in to escort it, the forward elements of both the Blackstone and New Haven fleets, fared little better. Two were split open like overripe fruit, their hulls venting flames and aether as they listed drunkenly before plummeting toward the ground far below. Others, slightly farther out, were scarred and smoking, their formations shattered - ships veering erratically to avoid collisions as the shards scattered in panic.

Tyana reached up, rubbing at a sharp sting on her forehead, her fingers coming away slick with blood. She wiped it away with a snarl, her gaze lifting to the distant silhouette of the Jellyfish, still hovering smugly amid the royal fleet.

Redwater, she thought. This was your doing wasn’t it!?

She didn’t know how, but she knew it was him. It was just like… when the enchanting shed exploded the night before the match that had damn near ruined her life.

As if on cue, the royal fleet began to pivot – and for a moment Tala feared they were going to attack their now disarrayed formation – but rather than advance, the enemy ships wheeled into a coordinated retreat southward.

"Mother," Tala said, turning to Elanore, her voice steady despite the pounding in her skull. "They’re retreating.”

“Aye,” the woman grunted, eyes clear despite her own injuries as she listened to the steady stream of reports from her own comm officer. “Even with this… most of our rear elements are fine. It’d be bloody, but we could still beat them.”

That made Tala’s heart leap. “Then should we pursue?”

The Blackstone duchess considered it for a few moments, before she cursed under her breath, a string of colorful oaths that would have made a dockside sailor blush.

"No," she spat finally. "We stop here. Assess damage, make repairs. They get to escape today."

Tala almost argued, before she found herself properly listening to the steady stream of reports from the rest of the fleet. Decent chunks of the fleet were untouched, but the most consistent damage being reported from those that weren’t came from the side propellers.

Which made a grim sort of sense. Unlike the armored hulls of the ship, the whirling blades responsible for propulsion were exposed and quite vulnerable.

Half the fleet would be limping now – if it could move all.

Any kind of pursuit would risk the Royal Navy doubling back and picking them off piecemeal.

No, her mother was right. They needed to stop and make repairs. Fortunately, the capital had the facilities they’d need to do exactly that – even if she was sure the Queen had attempted to scuttle them before her clearly planned exodus.

Rubbing more blood from her eyes, she cursed again, louder this time, and spun back to glare at the dwindling form of the Jellyfish on the horizon.

They’d won the first round, but this war had only just begun – and eventually, William Redwater was going to run out of tricks.

And when he did, Tala Blackstone would be there. With a sharp stick in hand and the will to use it.

Comments

O

First

Ember

Respectable bit of subterfuge, and half the enemy fleet taking either serious mobility hits or kills is insane. If William has any long range torpedoes I'd send them now.

Skulldragon7

"Tyana almost argued" I think this might be solara instead since tyana is the sister who didn't become a traitor

O

Well played

Matt Ober

chapter 69..........NICE

Trevayne

Thanks for another great chapter. Amusing to see Tala's hope spring eternal. I don't think we will get to see it, but I would like to see the next conversation between the northern leaders and their figurehead, especially since she is too foolish to realize that being a puppet is the best that she can hope for.

Skulldragon7

It is now "Talya almost argued" lol Edit: finding a few other instances of tyana instead of tala as well

Trevayne

This was a chapter offering a lot of information. It confirmed that both fleets (Blackstone and New Haven) are here at the capital. It also shows Eleanor Blackstone as a good commander, thinking and realizing her fleet would end up scattered if she responded to her anger and ordered an immediate pursuit. Only two airships have been wrecked, but given the size of the explosion, lots have suffered blast damage. Most of that damage was to exposed propellers on the side facing the blast. That means they can't pursue as a fleet. The faster units might catch up, but they would be separated from the slower airships and exposed to defeat in detail. The interesting question is whether the guardswoman got away. She could have gotten the ship moving, set multiple delay fuses and dived to safety using a maneuver suit. She would need to an invisibility potion to conceal her departure. She could have added insult to injury if she pulled the core just before she left.

ImMoralMage

Thanks for the two chapters! That many losses for the Blackstone/New haven fleet is a very nice opening move for William. Can't wait till next week.

FireStar

Hell yeah, I love it when someone with no reason to be in command fucks up the enemy's plan for you.

Andrew Lechner

So, this chapter 4. When is chapter one going up on r/hfy and royalroad?

Trevayne

Thinking some more about this bombship, we know that the northerners have suffered two destroyed airships with damage to about half of the rest, but one key item wasn't mentioned. How many of their shards just got wrecked? Any that were nearby are probably destroyed. Those farther away probably took varying amounts of damage, depending on their orientation. If they were pointed at the bombship when it exploded, they probably did OK. If they were hit by the blast from the side, they may well have structural damage. If hit from above, it might well have ripped the wings off. Suddenly having to deal with superior numbers of RN shards, is another good reason why the Blackstones elected not to pursue. Especially since they can see 30 or so of the Corsairs that destroyed the Lunite raiding force.

Trevayne

To be picky, it is chapter 5. The last of the old chapters was 64. The first release was 65 & 66. Last week was 67. This release is 68 & 69.

Lurkemancer

There's a lot of mixups there with names starting with a T... All of which should be Tala, I'm pretty sure.

Lurkemancer

Specifically: "Tyana reached up, rubbing at a sharp sting" ""Mother," Tyana said, turning to Elanore," "Talya almost argued, before she found herself" These should all be Tala.

Jacob

That first paragraph was a little unclear in terms of readability. While reading it, at first I thought the princess was among those on the deck of the jellyfish. It wasn't clear to me that she was broadcasting or whatever from somewhere else and everyone was listening from the bridge. Especially since we've only seen orb-com's be only point-to-point so far.

Trevayne

It said in the previous chapter that the Princess was using magical loudspeakers mounted on the hull of the airship she was on to project her voice over all three fleets and the city. She was not using orb-coms.

Trevayne

It looks like all have been fixed except "Tyana reached up...

Found&Lost

Probably next week. The chapter numbers are less relevant than release times. There's 3 patreon tiers so the fourth week after the top tier patreon release is when it goes public

Lurkemancer

On less correctional notes... I wonder how many of the shipyards are booby-trapped... I mean, William certainly had his hands mostly full with making the ship fit for purpose, but who knows. He might have had time to rig up a few makeshift explosives, making most attempts at looting the not yet destroyed facilities a fool's errand. Or at least PTSD inducing enough that most people would prefer not risking securing more than a few facilies. Though it's interesting to see that all the way back in the first book, it was Tala herself to almost get herself killed in putting her hands where they didn't belong. Also, Eleanore Blackstone should start listening to her daughter a bit more. This is like 2 for 2 where she calls major problems to the forefront BEFORE they become an issue, and not dismissing her intuition would have saved a lot of lives. The one thing I do wonder, however, is if the mission was a suicidal one or not... I mean, it probably was, but I'm hoping it's not one of the trio who we at least got to learn a bit of back in book two.

Trevayne

At a guess, a few of the shipyards are boobytrapped. I expect the simpler option is to just have agents ready to set them thoroughly on fire as the Northerners arrive. Given that the bombship had priority on explosives, I doubt they had enough to similarly trap all the shipyards. Although given what happened with the bombship, I imagine they will be very nervous about going into any intact shipyard if the rest have burned. I can see them being very suspicious about it, just because it isn't in ashes, yet.

Jacob

I missed that the previous chapter had even been posted. Just finished reading it. I withdraw my point.

Trevayne

Now we know why Yelena was so opposed to William's idea. He found a way to literally turn the heart of a noble house into a bomb. The reason they never saw it coming is no one from a noble background could conceive of destroying an airship, the heart of a noble house, as a weapon to damage an enemy. That is also why she said it had to come from his share of the loot. She could not be associated with such an attack because of the reactions of all the other nobles. He clearly doesn't have that attitude. He knows about it and can predict how others will respond, but doesn't share it.

Jacob

Eleanor Blackstone also has to consider the possibility that this wasn't the only ship that might do that. The possibility of "ship-go-boom" being opened up as a new tactic will forever change the current focus on boarding ships to take the core-room

karl grimm

I assume the ship was filled with some kind of petroleum product and some kind of oxidizer. Mabey that is left for the reader to guess or explained next chapter. For a minute I thought we would get some more fighting as the Royals tried to get in and finish off a few damaged ships quickly before retreating but I guess they are too worried about losses.

MS

I find it amusing and quite "cute" that Tala thinks she could stand up to let alone beat William.

Jacob

I'd like to think that they got out. It'd be fun to see them relating the story back to the other two guards women of the trio at some point.

Trevayne

Note that even Tala is only thinking she can do that after he runs out of tricks. She clearly has a healthy respect for his tricks.

Trevayne

All we know about it is that it had most of its crew passageways and areas filled with a somewhat corrosive and explosive liquid. That was why the guardswoman had to use a diving suit. I am curious about the chemical(s) myself, but I also understand why he doesn't name them. My own feeling is he arranged to surround the airship with a clud of fuel vapor and essentially set off a large FAE or thermobaric explosion As for attacking, it was much too risky. Remember, the combined Blackstone & New Haven fleets outnumbered the RN by around 2-1. My guess is there were roughly 60-70 Northern airships to 30-35 RN airships. Even after two northern airships were destroyed and nearly half were damaged, the North still had equal numbers in undamaged airships backed up by lots of airships with impaired maneuver but unimpaired firepower. They probably alsdo have an experience edge since most of the northerners have seen combat against the orcs (granted, that is mostly combat against shards and wyverns, but it is better than no such experience). No, the best RN move was to retreat. Especially since their best chance would be if the northerners tried to chase them, which would lead to a strung-out northern fleet that might be possible to defeat by chewing up the fragments as they caught up. Unfortunately, Eleanor was too professional to take that risk.

Trevayne

The real question now is who can best gain strength during the phony war? The RN can't attack the capital because they would be outnumbered 2-1. The Northerners could try to go after the RN, but it will be much closer to 1-1 or maybe even 1-1.5 against once the RN is joined by the airships from Southshore and Summerfield. They also have to consider that even though many of the southern duchy ships are wooden hulls with no armor, they can still be used to base shards, along with land based. The Northerners will think hard about going into a battle where they face odds of 1 to 1.5 in ships and 1 to 2 in shards. They have to count on their experience to overcome those odds and that is a big ask. The real problem is how the balance of force is shifting over time? The North probably can't do much to build their strength, but there are factors working both for and against Yelena. The problem for Yelena is the longer the North holds the capital, the more likely some of the southern duchy ships will think she is going to lose so they better defect to the north sooner rather than later. The thing working in her favor is she has mithril cores so she can build new airships. Even more importantly, she has William. The longer he can work on stuff, the more Corsairs and other things he can produce. We know he can do two Corsairs a week, but what else can he do? For example, say he creates a 90mm AA gun. Mounted on an airship, it lets that airship kill opposing airships from 3-4 times their range or even farther. He isn't doing radar fire control any time soon, but that isn't needed to hit an airship over a hundred meters long and 30 meters wide from a few miles away.

Trevayne

replying to Jacob - Yes and no. Most of the time, the boarding is by a single Marine-knight saboteur who is trying to sneak into the core room and steal the core. At worst if the target ship explodes, you lose that saboteur. Here it was so bad because the northerners sent several ships to greet/assist their side in what they thought was a boarding action. I do think saboteur attempts on the core are going to be increasingly risky, but less because the target might blow up and more because improved anti-shard weapons will make boarding an airship via a maneuver suit in combat even riskier and close to suicidal..

Luke Payne

Shame he ran out of missels, could’ve launched them on retreat. Even if most miss, a few lucky hits would take out even more airships

Trevayne

I hope the mission wasn't suicidal either. I expect William's watchers are still watching him, although they might have had their orders changed to keep him alive as the highest priority since he agreed to give the Queen all the tech at Redwater and on the Jellyfish. That means they are probably still alive since the real bloodbath was trying to keep trhe Queen alive and free during the Lunite attack. As for whether the bombship was a suicide mission, it shouldn't have been. All the guardswoman had to do was use her mage abilities to get the core producing thrust as well as lift. Then she starts closing on the northern fleet. When their ships come out to "greet the defecting ship" she waits until she thinks they are committed. She then activates 3-4 different fuses (for multiple assured detonation) and heads for a hatch. She takes an invisibility potion and freefalls away from the airship. She wants to be at least 3,000 feet away before she uses her maneuver suit thrusters to slow her descent because she knows there is going to be a really big explosion. Assuming the Queen can spare her an invisibility potion, her big risk is being hit by a fragment from the exploding airship. The other risk would be if the Northerners got suspicious and sent over some of their marine knight saboteurs to check on the situation before approaching. Given the size of the explosion, it might not kill anyships if they didn't get close, but it is still going to damage at least half of the ships. If the guardswoman really wanted to annoy the northerners, she would have pulled to core just before she left. That way, they are denied the core as well as losing the ship itself when it explodes.

Moonlightwind

Never mind Solana is indeed kind of an idiot still. I mean the whole rebellion is sort of a brains vs brawn situation to be fair. The North has more and better soldiers, with far more experience, but they’re very clearly stuck in their ways. Honestly, not to the same extent that the south and the capital can be, lulled into complacency as they are, but it’s the sort of, conservative type of complacency. Unable to conceive of things which are outside their worldview of personal experience, always ready with an explanation for what William does that fits into their convenient narrative about the world. I mean I guess I should be thankful that Tala’s goal is to kill William and not… something else given the ex-fiancé thing.

Trevayne

Yes and no. They are stuck in their ways to an extent. They have been fighting the orcs for so long that they can't even conceive of peace on any grounds except the elimination of all free orcs. They are also just like every other noble on Lindholm in that they can't conceive of someone deliberately blowing up an airship. Airships are the symbols of nobility. If you have an airship, you are a landed noble. If you don't, you may still be a noble, but no longer landed and now second or third rate at best. On the other hand, the Blackstones were the first group on Lindholm to actually build a dedicated carrier. William didn't do it, the Jellyfish is a conversion. The Blackstones also came up with their own version of magical tactical communications. Innovation like that is the opposite of complacency.

Google Google

Wait Tala was the one going into that shed and nearly blown up to pieces that is so funny😈

Trevayne

Thinking about it, Tala is correct that William will eventually run out of tricks. However, she didn't ask the other corresponding question. Will William run out of tricks before the North runs out of airships, shards, and people?

Trevayne

No, I doubt very much that Tala went into the shed. I expect she was just thinking that the two events, the explosion and the loss of the match were very close together and where things really started to go wrong for her. For that matter, it wasn't an enchanting shed, it was William's personal reserved space in the Alchemy building. That was where he mixed up black powder for the first kraken slayer. It was also where he set up some booby traps to kill anybody trying to figure out the kraken slayer.

Trevayne

Thinking a little more about Tala, I wonder if she has managed to do anything for her team mates? After losing the match she reflected that he mother was going to use them as scapegoats and blame them for the loss. I like Tala as a character because while she is clearly on the wrong side and needs to lose, she isn't a stereotypical bad guy with no positive features. Yes, she is racist against orcs, but she doesn't hate them because they are green, but because of all the keeps and villages the orcs have destroyed and all the humans they have killed. She just hasn't taken the next step to wonder if the orcs see humans the same way and why they might do so. I am pretty sure her mother is not redeemable and somebody needs to die for this fiasco. However, unless they want to keeping fighting going on between orcs and humans somebody needs to agree to peace. Tala is a leader for the Blackstone humans and if she can be persuaded, more may follow and make peace. Yes, William can enforce peace at swordpoint, but how stable will it be, unless he can get buy in from both sides? Yotul's POV in chapter 64 suggests the orcs might be willing to agree. William needs somebody on the Blackstone human/non-orc side to agree and Tala looks like the best candidate.

Jacob

It was likely her and/or her mother's agents that were snooping in Williams alchemy storage. Well, formerly-alive agents anyways.

Trevayne

I know quite a few people want to see Tala get wrecked along with the rest of the Blackstones. However, William is going to be their ruler and I doubt he really wants to ethnically cleanse the human population. He wants them working for him, so that he has a sizable powerbase which will get the Queen to seriously listen to his arguments. I also think he doesn't like killing people just because they disagree with him, especially when they could be working with and for him. I see Tala as being able to inform William about the North so he doesn't commit avoidable mistakes. I can see people saying “So what, what could she know that would help?” Over a decade ago I had tours in Afghanistan and Iraq. I don't really want to get into the politics, but I think most can agree that mistakes were made. They did try to learn from some of them at least. Before one of the deployments, we had a cultural lecture that tried to teach us some of the issues involved in dealing with an honor culture. As the instructor said, a typical situation that came up regularly was the US forces would get word that local X was working with the insurgents and hiding stuff for them. The initial, typical US response was to take a couple of platoons, cordon off the block where this guy lived, have a squad break down his door, grab him and everyone in the house, search him and his family in the same room, and take him away if contraband was found. If there wasn't any, apologize and leave, In the US, doing something like this would leave the person upset. It doesn't work that way in Iraq or Afghanistan. They are honor cultures and by searching the man in front of his wife and children he has been humiliated and dishonored. He is now compelled to take his gun (get one if he doesn't have one) and try to kill some Americans. If the US forces had acted with some cultural sensitivity, they would have set up the same cordon and knocked on his door. After he responds, they would ask him to sit down and have female soldiers escort his family members into another room. Then they would go ahead and search his place and himself, again arresting him if something is found. This way, if nothing is found, they then leave him in his house with his family and because they did not humiliate him in front of his spouse and children he is not compelled to try to kill some Americans and probably getting himself killed. I am not recounting this because I think the Blackstone duchy works this way. I am using this as an example of how cultural misunderstandings can get people killed and I really doubt William likes killing people because of avoidable errors. I would be astonished if nobody was killed during the occupation and transition of the Duchy to William's rule. Still, there is a big difference between 0.5%-1% losses and 10%-15% losses and I think using Tala could help keep the number to the lower end of the range.

Trevayne

Maybe. It certainly was a risky mission, but I don't think it was a kamikaze. All she had to do was keep the airship on course, set the fuses at the right moment, and abandon ship. If she had time, she could also yank the core. Then she swallows her invisibility potion and bails out and free falls a couple of thousand feet to get some distance from the blast. Then she activates her flight suit and escapes. Walk in the park, no, but not suicidal. Edit: inserted flight mention of flight suit and invisibility potion. The potion is to insure she isn't seen and shot by any alert airship gunners or shard pilots as she leaves the airship.

karl grimm

I didn't think of it before but in retrospect it's obvious that whoever went to the shed and got blown up was Talia's agent or someone she hired. After William challenged her she had to know that he was either really stupid or had something up his sleeve to win the match. She probably wanted to keep an eye on him anyway so might have known he was spending a lot of time in the alchemy lab since it wasn't exactly a secret. She was probably looking for some new potion that would give him the edge rather than the secret to gunpowder.

karl grimm

I get that having a big battle would not be a victory for the Loyalists since most of the Rebel fleet survived. It just seemed to me that the rebels were shocked and disorganized, albeit temporarily. Given that, they should be mobile enough to get in, finish off the wounded skyships and get out before they are too committed to retreat. For that matter the original plan was to trade a few shots with the Northerners then leave. It just seems like a wasted opportunity, although I suppose it's not a big deal either way.

karl grimm

The text says: Fortunately she only needed be? close to the core to activate it. I think it should be: to be close

karl grimm

Thinking about it, a good pilot should be able to land a shard even with the wings ripped off, strange as it my seem to us.

Trevayne

It might have been Tala or it could have been her mother. Either could be looking into William's alchemy lab if they though he had anything to do with the kraken slayer or the spellbolt. I agree that if it was her mother who directed it, Tala was probably aware of it. Edit: It was probably Tala's mother, not Tala. Tala's mother had a source in the p[alace who might have leaked the news about the spellbolt, which Tala did5n't find out about until the match.

Trevayne

The problem is that it is hard to get in, take out some of the damaged ships and avoid a decisive engagement. They probably could have gotten some relatively cheap kills, but they would have risked getting caught by the rest of the fleet. Especially since most of the damage was to their ability to maneuver. Unlike, say the German fleet at Jutland, airships have no torpedo equivalents that could force the enemy to turn away and keep their distance. They probably wouldn't be that useful because the enemy could see them coming and try to shoot them down or just dodge them. Given that the Northern fleets have more combat experience than the RN a d certainly more than any of the southern duchies, relying on the northern ships to be paralyzed by command confusion is unwise. For that matter, the original plan was to trade a few shots at long range and then flee. The bomb-airship was supposed to fake a breakdown and fall behind so it could be captured.

Trevayne

replying to karl grimm - Yes, a good pilot should be able to land a shard with the wings ripped off. The reason is that a shard is essentially a cross between a WW2 fighter plane and a miniature dirigible. There are a couple of caveats though. The shard has to be of a design that doesn't place too much of the aether tanks in the wings. If the aether produced by the shard is just released into the air it isn't going to provide lift and the shard will crash. the probably aren't doing much besides going down slowly because I don't think a shard with no wings has much directional control.

Katz

I also think that this with have second-degree chilling effects on attempted defections. The North will treat any would-be defector as a trap, and any would-be defector will know this and will be considerably less likely to try defecting like this. Politically, it sends a VERY poor image if your would-be puppet monarch gets a bloody nose from the first public proclamation. This was a devastating blow to legitimacy, and while politics necessarily takes a back seat to cannons, this rebellion might beas good as dead. Previously, they could do without a clear win, just waiting it out for Yelena's suppprt to erode. Now, they need at least one decisive win, because a stalemate has the potential to last inordinately long, which Eleonor does not want.

Trevayne

Replying to Katz - Eleanor may not want a long war, but it works in her favor. If she holds the capital for a year or more, Yelena will start to lose legitimacy and support. It is going to be a balancing act. The longer the stalemate goes on, the more legitimacy Yelena will lose. At the same time, that means William has more time to build Corsair and come up with new tech. If they weren't on the clock, I am pretty sure Yelena's side would win, but they can't take too long or they lose the nobles on their side.

Trevayne

Interesting thought, one of the viewpoints I would like to see is Sveta Greygrass's thoughts when she found out just why she and her fellow instructors had been training plebian pilots. We have Xela's POV back in chapter 61 or so, but by her own admission she was not as hardcore a combat pilot as Sveta and her fellow Greygrass instructor pilots.

Medical-Cyanide

Welp. I appreciate that plan William but I think it was wasted sending it up now. Should’ve had the undership set up a bit behind where the northern forces were set up and have it come up from behind. Or wait for the northern fleet to actually push up. Don’t get me wrong being able to retreat with the royal navy mostly untouched and the northern forces blooded. This felt like a partially wasted alpha strike.

Trevayne

Long post warning Some thoughts on airship numbers. (note, quotes are indicated by ""quote"") This story has two main sections where airship numbers are discussed, chapter 29 and chapters 57-64. The first explicitly states what the RN numbers are, but the second section disagrees with it. You have to read into it, because it isn't stated explicitly, but it is still pretty clear. Here is the quote from chapter 29. ""Which would bring the Royal Navy up to thirty-five airships from thirty-two. Sixteen in the hands of Crownland countesses. Nineteen in the royal navy. …Though that assumed all three of those hulls were slated for the royal navy and one wasn’t being set aside for him. Which was unlikely given his contributions to the Crown. Just forming a new noble house and elevating him to a count in his own right wasn’t nearly enough of a reward for gaining Lindholm access to dozens of mithril cores. So, he thought. Seventeen vassal airships, eighteen royal navy ships and… assuming a standard loadout, somewhere around seventy or eighty shards. He frowned. A not insignificant short term number change, but hardly game changing. Especially given that both Northern houses would each have perhaps a little less than thirty ships to their name between their vassal houses and ducal fleets."" It states quite clearly that there are currently 32 ships in the RN and there will be 35 once the three hulls without cores get their cores. It also states there are 19 Royal Navy airships and 16 from the crown vassals (the ducal fleet of the Royal duchy and its subordinate nobles). It also suggests that the Blackstones and New Haven each have around 29 airships (a little less than 30 each) so together they outnumber the RN by nearly 2 to 1. Those numbers, however, disagree with the later numbers. The first item is in chapter 57. ""Twelve ships, she thought grimly. It wasn’t a small number - not by any stretch. Yet it was still dwarfed by the number of ships she had on hand. Even with parts of the Royal Fleet engaged in routine patrols, the capital fleet outnumbered the enemy nearly three times. Their superiority in firepower was unquestionable. A decisive victory for Lindholm was all-but assured."" This chapter states that there are 12 “pirate” (actually Lunite) air ships and that the RN outnumbers them by nearly 3-1. That to me implies that there are around 30 RN airships present, so that implies around 33-35 overall RN airships because a few are noted as being on other missions. Presumably, at least one is in the south with Princess Palmer as she tries to get the Summerfield succession handled. This number is not that different from chapter 29, except that it also explicitly states that the airships are all RN airships, there are no crown vassal airships present. They are all being sent to the capital as per this quote from chapter 57. ""Her jaw tightened as her thoughts churned. There was too much she didn’t know here. “Inform the Royal vassals of the ongoing threat,” she ordered, her tone sharp. “Order them to prepare for deployment over the capital. They’ll form the strategic reserve.” "" Looking farther down in the same chapter, we see Yotul and her undership, one of ten, emerge from the water. They immediately get ready and commence the attack. Shards are launched to deal with opposing shards while the airships attack the skydock towers. ""The Blood-Oaths forty guns fired as one – sending enchanted metal lancing through the air on flutes of aether. Near enough in timing so as to be indistinguishable, four of the other underships in their formation fired too. Each shot, enchanted through decades of mages multiplying spells on top of one another over and over, struck the support posts of both airdocks before exploding into cascades of ice, fire and lightning. Smoke and aether filled the night sky, but the beams of the light-houses in the bay managed to pierce through it. The first skydock held, either enchantment or good engineering allowing it to survive its first volley. The second did not – as Yotul watched with rising joy as the great concrete structure started to crack and then crumble. Like a child’s snow castle, it came away in clumps before it started to sag and fall, stonework dropping down into the city below as the massive structure fell – dragging with it the four airships that had been tethered there. Like fish caught on a line, they were dragged down to the ground and smashed upon it, one of the vessel’s bows splitting like dry firewood as the component parts of the ship were spread across the rubble. . . . They’d already moved onto new targets. Like the second of the five skydocks that had yet to fall. "" This part tells us that Lindholm's capital has six skydock towers, each capable of mooring up to four airships. We don't know if they are all full or not, but it certainly suggests that several were full. Assuming they were all full, that would be 24 moored to the six towers. There were some ships inflight so the overall number could be as high as 28 (24+4) or if only half of the towers were full, 16 (12 +4). We know from the next chapter that there were only four active ships that were either not moored to a skydock or escaped before they were destroyed. The nearly is incorrect, at ten to four they were certainly facing more than twice their number. ""In the background, she watched as what defenders remained airborne traded shots with the attacking fleet, but with the defenders having been reduced to just four vessels in less than an hour and now facing nearly twice their number, the defense was haphazard at best."" Two of these ships are named, the Marmaduke and the Honorable, the other two were not named. All were shot down or wrecked, the Marmaduke from having its core stolen causing it to lose power, and the Honorable was hit by three incendiary javelins (aether powered anti-ship rockets) and turned into a burning wreck that would continue to fly until the fire burned through the aether tanks. "" “Marmaduke reports that it’s lost contact with the core-room,” an Orb-Operator reported in rapid fire cadence. “Last report was two minutes ago. Core-Defender reported no less than three attackers. Captain is now reporting Marmaduke is losing pressure in all aether-bulkheads. Propellors non-functional. Core presumed missing. Captain reports that she’s likely to go down over the docks. Captain is ordering an all-hands evacuation to parachute and glider muster stations. She… she intends to go down with the ship.” . . . A burning wreck floated past the tower holding the viewing orb connected to the one she was watching, a somber testament to the ferocity of the battle. The Honorable had been struck amidships by three nearly flawless incendiary javelins launched by enemy shards in the opening moments of the battle. At least one of these projectiles had pierced the steel hull, setting the wooden framework beneath ablaze. The crew had been left with no choice but to abandon the ship as the fire raged uncontrollably. "" This tells us that the Crown Vassal fleet was between 17 and 29 airships (the two earlier numbers plus the Jellyfish, which arrived late). The lower number is compatible with the figures mentioned in chapter 29 for the Crown Vassal airships. The higher number isn't, but the bigger issue is the actual RN airships. I can't see how 19 could be described as nearly three times the strength of a Lunite force of twelve airships. In some ways, the Crown Vassal numbers are irrelevant, because except for the Jellyfish, they were all destroyed in the Lunite raid on the capital. Their might be one or two others that were under refit and couldn't get there, but the CV/Royal duchy airship force is mostly gone. The Jellyfish is the only known survivor. This is why Yelena has a problem. She still has her RN airships, along with the Jellyfish. However, the Blackstone and New Haven fleets have about sixty airships between them. That is why Yelena is retreating and abandoning the capital.

Trevayne

Long post warning (not quite so long, but still) Thoughts on shard numbers. The typical Lindholm airship carries two shards as scouts/auxilliaries and defense against opposing shards. Recently, as shards have become more prominent, some vessels have been modified to carry more shards and serve as escort or light carriers. There are also the two known carriers that have been built or converted for that primary purpose, the Brimstone of the Blackstone Fleet that carries 20 shards and the Jellyfish, the only known survivor of the Crown Vassal fleet, that carries 40 shards. As we know, the Jellyfish is the only ship to carry the new type of shard, the Corsair-C. We also know that shards are seen as a primary means of inter-house competition, both at the academy and afterwards. I think it is a safe assumption that each noble house has at least 3-4 shards. Two are assigned to its airship and there are 1-2 for training and familiarization. We know from chapter 31 that the Countess of Ashfield had an airship and at least three shards, a Drake, a Wyvern, and a Unicorn trainer. That would be five if there were two more on their airship. The basic estimate would be two shards per airship. If the RN has 35 airships that would be 70 shards. However, we know they were experimenting with carriers because the Jellyfish came to William with four shard bays. Let's assume that every first-rate fleet has at least one escort carrier with 10 shards. So, the total RN count is 34 regular airships (2 each) for 68 shards, one escort carrier with 10, and the Jellyfish with 40. That makes a total of 118 shards (68+10+40). Assuming each of the northern fleets has 30 airships, and that each is a first-rate fleet so they each have an escort carrier. The Blackstones also have their own carrier, the Brimstone. That means New Haven has 29 airships with 58 shards and their escort carrier with ten for a total of 68 shards. The Blackstone fleet has 28 airships with 56 shards, their escort carrier with ten, and the Brimstone with 20, for a total of 86 shards. Between the two fleets, the northerners should have 154 shards (86+68=154), so they outnumber the RN by about 1.3 to 1. It gets worse, because nearly all of the northern pilots have combat experience against the orcs or pirates, while the RN just has good training. Granted, this is partially offset because all of the noble house shard pilots participate in inter-house competitions. It is also offset by the fact that only the RN force has access to Corsairs and their unique capabilities. Again, this all goes to show that Yelena really didn't have any choice but to retreat from the capital. If the RN faced Blackstone and New Haven by itself, it would be seriously outnumbered. Nearly 2-1 in airships and about 1.3 to 1 in shards. The only other factor that could help Yelena is the additional ground-based shards. Chapter 58 pointed out that there were three airfields around the capital including the academy that could have launched up to sixty shards. However, due to the surprise they never got the chance and those that tried to take off were almost immediately shot down by Lunite shards that were over the airfields. Most of those shards are probably destroyed, but their cores can be used to power new shard airframes, once they are constructed.

Trevayne

Right now, the RN would be attacking at 1-2 odds in ships and 1 to 1.3 in shards, so they would lose and Yelena is executed or exiled. End of story. The bombship created some confusion and has slowed a number of airships, but it wasn't going to be a battle winner. There is no reason why the Northerners should let an unknown airship near their formation. If they had tried something like that, they just send out shards with boarders to inspect and stop the ship at a safe distance. The only reason it was this successful because the speech had just been given so it was plausible that one of Yelena's airships might try to defect. That wouldn't be that case at any other time.

Katz

I am fairly sure you are making a mistake by conflating two related, but different concepts. Tyana is musing that the CAPITAL defense fleet is outnumbering the 'pirates' 3to1. (To me 'on hand' could mean also rapid muster, not just 'available and flying right now, right this minute'). NOT the RN. She is mustering the crownland vassal fleet (which is part of the capital fleet, and would muster rapidly, as opposed to the distant southern duchies who would have a fleet of their own, but unmodernized and much farther away than less-than-a-day muster) and holding that part in strategic reserve. She is only committing the RN part of the capital defense fleet to 'battle' (actually to the lunite 'pirate' feint). The idea was strategically sound. Commit 2/3 of your force (which would still outnumber your enemy 2-1), and hold 1/3 in reserve in case of a surprise defeat where she would have to fight a second battle for the actual defense of the capital, not a battle out to sea. Moreover, this makes math sense. 29(RN)+16(Crownlands Vassals) = 45 (Capital Defense Fleet, what Tyana has 'on hand' for a battle for the capital)

Katz

No, it does really not. The only rationale for a quick civil war was to win fast and meet a potential Lunite or Solite invasion. I think this has been explicitly stated somewhere. Eleonor wants to win fast for strategic reasons. A long civil war will just invite defeat piecemeal. Winning the civil war in a protracted way only to have to kneel before the old world elves? Not on Eleonor's watch.

Trevayne

Replyuing to Katz - No, you are assuming that a prolonged war will grind down both sides. Why should it, when there is no real combat going on? Neither side is going to commit their main fleet to battle unless they think they can win. Why would they? If the war lasts a year without any any serious casualties, before Eleanor wins, why are the old world elves going to risk a bloody nose and a defeat again? This is not ground warfare with constant losses due to patrolling and skirmishing. If the airship fleets are not committed to a battle, why should Eleanor be losing airships? Why should either side commit to a battle where they know the odds are against them? The only person who might commit to battle is Yelena and that would be because she thinks she is losing vassals because the North has held the capital too long. If the North can just sit in the capital and watch Yelena's noble support drift away, why wouldn't it? Eleanor Blackstone thinks she can beat the old world elves by herself. The Blackstone fleet was the major contributor to the Lindholm victory in the last Solite attempt, so some of her confidence is understandable. This particular war happened because Eleanor seized an opportunity. It was a chance to win quickly and it didn't work because Yelena saw her coming and made the right strategic choice, to abandon the capital. She knew she was going to lose because they had twice her airship strength.

Trevayne

Replying to Katz - Err, your point is? You are saying RN has 29 ships and the Crown vassals have 16. Those are the bottom range of my numbers. However, by saying no, it looks like you are disagreeing. The purpose of my post was to give my opinion on two different numbers. The RN is explicitly identified in chapter 29 as having 35 ships, 19 RN ships and 16 Crown Vassal ships. However, these numbers do not agree with the numbers from any reasonable reading of the numbers implied by chapters 57-64. Those numbers imply 30-35 RN airships and an additional 16-28 Crown Vassal airships. OK, I think I see the issue. You seem to think Tyana had 55 airships on hand. You conclude that she really outnumbered them by almost 5-1, and not almost 3-1. This is incorrect. The plain English meaning of on hand is present or readily available. Crown Vassal airships that are hours away are not present or readily available and have no relevance to her calculations of the forces she actually has to fight the "pirate" airships with. The on-hand number is the RN ships, which should have been 30-35 for Tyana to think she outnumbered the 12 "pirate" airships by nearly 3-1. "" It wasn’t a small number - not by any stretch. Yet it was still dwarfed by the number of ships she had on hand. Even with parts of the Royal Fleet engaged in routine patrols, the capital fleet outnumbered the enemy nearly three times. Their superiority in firepower was unquestionable. A decisive victory for Lindholm was all-but assured."" This clearly indicates that the capital fleet was the bulk of the Royal Navy since it was all of it minus a few detached vessels. The capital fleet is the bulk of the RN and effectively synonymous with it. The only RN airships that aren't in the capital fleet are those on detached missions. This quote confirms that the Crown Vassal airships were not present. They are being directed to assemble over the capital to form a reserve. If she was considering them as part of her forces on hand, she would have outnumbered the "pirates" by nearly 5-1 not nearly 3-1. "" “Inform the Royal vassals of the ongoing threat,” she ordered, her tone sharp. “Order them to prepare for deployment over the capital. They’ll form the strategic reserve.” “Ma’am,” an officer asked hesitantly, “do you think we’ll need them?” “No,” she replied, her voice cool. “Which is why I want them ready. Someone’s playing a game here, and I don’t like it. Should the other shoe drop, I intend to be prepared.” ""

Overclocked

Do we know the history of the orc and human conflict? Maybe a few hundred years ago they did the usual orc thing in a fantasy setting...eating the humans or just killing them all. If that is the case, I'm not sure I'd trust an orc either lol

Trevayne

replying to Overclocked - No, we don't know the detailed history but it has been going on for a long time. IIRC there is a mention that the humans were fighting the orcs when the elves swept out with their airships to conquer the known world. Pretty sure, by this time it has been going on long enough that it doesn't really matter who did what to whom first. The aggression has continued. The orcs have been forced into living in relative wilderness. I am not at all sure if any would live there if the orcs vanished. The Blackstone humans would certainly prefer that because if the orcs disappeared, the orcs couldn't raid them. This at least suggests that they could make peace if they can stop fighting. The orcs keep what they have, maybe getting some territory to have better farmland. The humans keep most of what they have. The just have to stop killing each other. As the new duke of Blackstone, William could try to enforce that kind of deal. The problem is then enforcing the peace and getting the killing to stop.

KarmaBus

It sounds like the trojan horse ship wasn't just a shard or something - it had its own core and was substantial enough size for it breaking formation and "defecting" to be seen as potentially undermining morale. Given this, I very much doubt it would have been able to simply sneak up on the fleet from behind. The enemy aren't idiots, they'd be watching their tails. As for waiting for the Northern fleet to push up and commit, well there's the rub. In order to get them to commit without giving away that doing so is playing right into William's hands, the RN would need to commit themselves. Once engaged, things get chaotic and retreating without losing resources becomes unrealistic, especially as ships in active combat would have to take time to disengage, leaving themselves vulnerable to the enemy. If the RN got the Northerners to commit, there's no way the RN would be able to retreat without significant losses, which was why the original plan was to just turn tail immediately. Actual direct combat was never on the table for the RN here beyond a choice selection of stragglers to cover the main force's retreat (which luckily ended up just being one ship instead of a larger number.

KarmaBus

Hopefully, by the time William runs out of tricks, he will no longer need them...

Trevayne

Replying to Karmabus - I agree that if the RN got decisively engaged they would find it very hard to disengage and would have probably been destroyed. As for the Trojan horse, it was indeed a full-size airship, one of the Lunite under ships from the raid that had been assigned to William as spoils. He elected to make minimal repairs to get basic functionality and use it as a bomb.

Trevayne

Replying to KarmaBus - Yes, although he has a lot more tricks to try. He has access to the design info for every weapon he has ever heard of from say 500 BC to the early 2000s. His problem is while he can do a great many things, he can't do them all at once. He focused on Corsairs and the associated technologies. He could have created better guns for airships, for example, but it would have slowed down the Corsair effort.

Trevayne

A really interesting question is what do Tala and her mother, along with the rest of the Northen fleets, think about what just happened. From their perspective, they just watched and experienced a massive explosion. Their next two questions should be 1) How the hell did Yelena do that? 2) Can she do it again? We understand that William arranged to have lots of explosives on the airship. Exactly what and how doesn't really matter. It could be anything from 20-30 tons of TNT to arranging for the airship to carry lots of fuel and spray it out and then detonate it as a really big FAE or thermobaric weapon. However, the only way people in this world who aren't William can make explosions is by using enchanted ammunition with multiple fireball and lightning bolt spells applied to them as enchantments. Given that, I wonder how much of the RN's enchanted ammo production had to be used to make that explosion, if they used enchanted ammo. Eleanor Blackstone and Larissa New Haven have to be asking themselves those questions right now.

Trevayne

Thinking about it, we got the initial reactions from the Blackstones. I wonder what Yelena and Tyana, not to mention William's team, thought about what just happened? Fom their perspective, this must have been something like the first nuclear test. Yelena has experience what a big explosion can do from what happened to her palace. However, I doubt very much that she nor Tyana have ever seen an airship just vanish like that, leaving two mortally wounded airships and a bunch of others with varying degrees of damage. The only people who have seen anything like this are Marcille and Marline, along with the three Corsair pilots who were tracking the airship the Basilisk shot down.

Drew Monney

I’m honestly interested in how William converts Anti-Air defenses. 1. Radar: We know that electromagnetic spectrum signals exist, since William has built point-to-point and broadcast transmitters/receivers as radios. That means that he can build a dish. Metallic objects reflect EM rays and William knows the speed of light if he knows how radios work/ reception delay. Radar basically sends a big EM pulse every few seconds and then has multiple receivers “listening” for the same frequency to be returned. By using the time between pulse to detection, you can mathematically determine how far away the reflection point is. Basically all parties involved in World War II secretly invented devices for military application of this concept during the period of 1934 to 1939. This could be further extrapolated to Sonar applications for finding “Underships” and even just generally to mapping of underground/underwater features. There’s an example in Jurassic Park where they fire a gunpowder fueled slug into a small area of the ground and then measure the shockwaves reflected to map the fossil they’re examining. This is basically what they used to do before GPR (Ground-Penetrating Radar) was invented. I imagine William’s sonar would be less sophisticated than that, but would be able to “ping” any Undership that comes within striking distance. 2. Anti-Air or Flak dedicated weapons: We know that William has gunpowder and has built large caliber repeating weapons for use on his Corsair-C. This same concept can be applied to build mounted weapons for Anti-Air use in denying the enemy access to the airspace. He also has expressed that the metallurgy of the kingdom is not far from modern, with the ability to make specific alloys and casts as needed using magic to refine the finer elements. This means he can make barrels that are strong enough to withstand the explosion pressure of larger caliber ammunition without cracking and also without having to be inches thick like a cannon. These large guns could then POSSIBLY be light enough to be airship mounted. Maybe a single stern gun or dual Stern/Bow emplacements to protect the vulnerable propellers/ shard launching bays from enemy shards. The hardest part of this concept is actually swiveling fast enough to be able to track enemies. The solution is either Hydraulics and good bearings to turn faster (William can make these. He made IC engines.), or shotgunning enough area that accuracy barely matters. 3. Self propelled munition/specialized munitions We saw the proof of concept in the previous battle for the capital when the twins rocket destroyed a full airship. Just like the upgrades from the “dumb” bombers of WWII to the rockets of today, smaller and more maneuverable ships that can launch a payload from farther away can inflict massive amounts of damage at less risk to themselves. It’s easier to rearm a plane than to replace a plane. There’s even precedent set by the twins for using enchanted/ non-William materials to achieve the desired results. I expect to see some more “ship-killer” style munitions to be spread amongst the Royal Fleet in the future. Less tactical flexibility for a single vessel, but more flexibility for the whole fleet. 4. Dedicated Aircraft Carriers Already been covered in depth with proof of efficacy. 5. Dedicated IC ground/sea vehicles. Lindholme is mostly reliant on air/sea travel for all transportation purposes. There’s mentions of ships, but there’s very little in the way of ground traffic and this is a huge logistical bottleneck. There are only so many cores/ships around and those will be relegated to military use. As far as carts/land transport, they have a limited top speed and rely on roads/infrastructure to remain efficient beyond a local area. I believe this is why most of the cities are coastal. Moving away from sails even to Steam Ships would greatly increase the speed of transporting goods and the interconnectivity of the kingdom under Williams thumb. The steam paddles would allow easier transport of goods upriver and improve logistics operations as an army could be resupplied in more inland locations without airships. As they say, “an army marches on its stomach.”

Trevayne

Lots to unpack here. 1) Radar - It would be useful, but is not currently needed. Airships do not usually conduct attacks by night, Granted, the underships did, but they had already gotten close enough radar would not have mattered. The bigger problem is while he can do it, he is also going to have to improve the electrical systems of everything it is installed on. Sonar would be more useful, but he doesn't really need active sonar, just hydrophones listening. The underships are really only useful for sneaking up on land targets. They are much worse than regular airships if the goal is to since maritime shipping. 2) AA weapons - William has created smokeless powder and .50 cal heavy machine guns. He could fairly easily create the equivalent of a 20 mm Oerlikon autocannon from WW2. He could probably also manage a 40mm Bofors gun and larger weapons. Mounting them on an airship isn't really an issue, but providing powered traverse via electrical or hydraulic means would make things harder, and is necessary for shooting effectively at shards. They can probably get by with manual traverse and elevation against airships which are slower and much larger than shards. I have suggested using something like a 90mm AA gun from WW2 or a 4"/50 gun from WW1 as anti-airship weapons to replace aether cannon. 3) Self-propelled munitions - These are not really needed. William could easily produce the WW2 Tiny Tim rockets to supplement the current 5" HVARs and he can produce better javelin (aether powered rocket) warheads. However, the main reason for standoff weapons is to avoid losses from the defenses. So far, the best anti-shard defenses in this world are friendly shards. The aether powered swivel guns used as AA guns are marginal at best. So far, we haven't seen a single example of a shard shot down by a swivel gun. They are better than nothing, but not much better. Given the lack of effective AA, the current rockets and javelin s should do well. 4) Agreed, dedicated carriers have been introduced. William has brought in the concept of a flat deck for landings and take offs. Unlike wet navy carriers, I do not think airship carriers will ever need catapults. If they have a heavily loaded shard that struggles to reach flight speed, just roll it over the side and it will reach flight speed as it falls. 5) As for surface transport, I agree that more could be done here, but mainly for civilian purposes. The concept of an army marching on its stomach is irrelevant for this world because armies don't march. In fact, we haven't seen much evidence that they even exist. The only "army" type units we have seen are guards belonging to noble houses and Yelena's Royal Guards. We know they have both infantry and cavalry components. The only other land fighters we have seen are the Lunite stormtrooper commandoes. Given that, it looks like the main uses for ground forces are garrisoning facilities and cities to provide security against raiders and conducting raids. Any army that tried to march into hostile territory would be hopelessly vulnerable to hostile airships which could bomb it into oblivion. Remember, there are no effective ground-based air defenses. The only defenses are your own shards and airships. I think civilians could use trucks, cars, and steamships, but from a military perspective they are all targets for airships.

Drew Monney

As far as ground armies, my thoughts were actually more towards how it’s currently not possible to root out a guerilla campaign of Free Orcs by the Blackstones. How would they be able to fight against a guerilla campaign staged by the Queen and William? They kingdom currently don’t have the infrastructure to support a lengthy military occupation outside of major urban areas, or the logistical ability to supply occupying forces without spreading their Air Force too thinly. This leaves them vulnerable to guerrilla attacks and it is an obvious weakness in the kingdom’s military policy. As I see it, there are a few ways that William could play this: 1. Follow the Fabian Strategy as used against Hannibal Barca by the Romans in the Punic Wars and go scorched Earth on the Countryside around the Capital. Anything that you can’t defend and the rebel army could use is either taken with you back to a defensible point or destroyed. Burn fields, poison wells, set traps, etc… Retreat from direct engagements and allow the enemy to run themselves down. This strategy is tough since airships exist, allowing an army to resupply past any siege lines, around pickets, or what have you, but it seems to be the opening move of the Queen’s strategy with this battle. 2. Set up FOBs and Depots at strategic distribution points closer to how modern militaries do. Establish a beachhead and Fortify, then set up logistics to support that Fort and stage missions/strikes from there. Repeat as necessary. Island Hopping Strategy of WWII Pacific Theatre. This allows for flexibility in your planning and execution of goals, but it severely stretches your defenses. What it does well is expand the net for early warning systems/communication relays which is why I mentioned Radar. 3. Fortify like mad with chains of fortresses covered in AA guns and as Ammo depots/airfields Static Fortifications make for easy targets, so fortifying too much is generally going to be a wasted investment unless there’s a lot of time to prepare and the value of the industry at that point couldn’t be replicated elsewhere. This is why William felt so comfortable with dismantling his assembly lines. He has the tooling and knowledge to rebuild elsewhere. He can build more factories somewhere else, but he can’t replace the expertise or unique skills of his trained craftsmen cheaply or easily. 4. Overwhelming aerial Offensive followed by paratroopers assault. This is what we just saw with the aborted Lunite/Free Orc raid on the capital. We saw that the defenses are of very limited use if not scrambled or warned ahead of time and the stationary defenses were the first to go. That is why I thought of either overwhelming amounts of Flak as a counter or only ship-mounted defenses as being a better option than stationary AA guns. As far as AA guns, if ship mounted they could tap into the aether reserve to use some kind of pneumo/hydraulic system of actuators to control rotation and pitch. And yes, the steamships and trucks would work better for civilians, but that’s also a reason that they’d be important to any guerilla campaign. Airships make too tempting of a target, especially in smaller groups and can’t really sneak past anything (underships as an exception). Thoughts?

MarakEvans

Bro. If I were her, I'd demand my retirement and complain to my employer that she associates with a mad man. And if he ever comes up with something dumb or insane that requires any part of me contacting that diving suit contraption, he will have to bathe in that bear blood concoction himself before I have anything to do with it- or HIM- again. All while assuming that I'll be executed; I won't have to deal with any of his shit for the rest of my life. ... Failing my summary retirement, I just hope my employer will settle with being amused by my complaints with the... creature of her facination... and frustration.

Trevayne

On the other hand she gets bragging rights for life. She is probably the first person in history to be able to claim she destroyed two airships and damaged half a fleet by herself.

Trevayne

I expect the reason the Blackstones have not been able to root out the Free Orcs is the terrain. I expect it is a combination of forests and mountains with lots of caves. Those two features provide lots of cover from aerial observation. The orcs also have an advantage on the ground because they are bigger and stronger. That means they can march faster and can expect to win melee combats and close range ambushes. What the Blackstones need to root them out is a big ground army, but I expect they are wary of the casualties they would lose if they really tried to do that. Anything they can find from the air gets bombed or burned out. There is just a lot that they can't find, especially since nobody seems to have any long-range detection magic. IIRC the effective spell range seems to be about 100 meters, barring items like communications orbs. As for tech improvements, steam ships would be useful, as long as the noise doesn't attract krakens. Trucks are more problematic, because aside from areas nearby the cities, I expect the roads are lousy. The only things that move on land are people in wagons/carriages, people riding horses, and people on foot. Given that, I expect the roads are poor, outside say a 20-30 mile radius of a city, and shorter radii outside towns or villages. Given that the Elven Empire conquered the known world with airships, why should there be any equivalents of the Roman roads. The Romans built those to allow legions to march quickly, but if troops aren't marching, why bother? As for fortifications, I expect towns and cities have some walls, just to keep raiders from easily getting in. However, without effective AA, I doubt they are bothering to build above ground castle equivalents.

Found&Lost

Guys/gals/other I think something bad has happened to Blue, he's never late! /S 😆

Ferr

Na... we just back to normal

Trevayne

I think the goal is Friday, but while the first two chapters did get released on Friday, the next three all came out Saturday. Blue has learned though. Notice there are fewer updates about how things are going.

Found&Lost

I know. I'm just making a joke. It was strange that we got no update though.

Trevayne

Yes, or at least some mention of how things are going.

Blue Fishcake

Oh, I'm fine? Mostly I just aim for the weekend these days - with Friday being ideal. I just figured that that last chapter was released on the 22nd and was a double, so people wouldn't be too stressed when this one comes out in a few hours. :D

Lurkemancer

Blue, the "optimal" release schedule is one chapter every 6 hours. Once per weeked? A tenuously acceptable compromise. /j

Found&Lost

Weekends are expected with you. That's fine, but you *technically* have a release day on Friday. So for me personally I just check for which weekend day (or early weekday, those have happened) that I should be checking back.

Trevayne

Interesting thought, I wonder how this plays out among the rest of the nobility? Are they appalled by Yelena's willingness to blow up an airship to damage her enemies or are they impressed by her pragmatic ruthlessness? Maybe a reaction scene from one of the Summerfield countesses or perhaps Janet Ashfield. For that matter, where is the Ashfield family airship, the Indomitable. Is it mustering with Summerfield or Southshore, or is it still at home? Do we even know which duchy the Ashfields are part of? It would be really interesting if the Indomitable was one of the Crown Loyalist airships destroyed at capital. I doubt it. I think they are either a Southshore or a Summerfield county, but it certainly would be amusing if William got an orb call from his mother demanding he avenge his aunts and the Indomitable.

Lurkemancer

Given the verbiage used during William and Janet's discussion ragerding how the Queen might have figured out who Olivia's father might have been, Ashfield county is a vassal of the Summerfield duchy. Also, given the time we've had between the attack and now, if the Indomitable had been near the capital during the raid, we already would have heard of it by now. If nothing else, then through Olivia being less of a gremlin than usual. All things considered, it's likely that only the Queen's direct vassals near Lindholm were given the order to immediately mobilize, and even that was likely nothing more than a formality. And, given that Ashfield county is about an entire day away by blimp, they wouldn't be on that list.

Trevayne

Good points. I thought she wasn't in the Crown Duchy because it took William and his aunt a few days by sea to get to the Academy. It was IIRC the Crown Duchy forces that were directed to mobilize. Those were the Crown vassal ships that showed up to get wrecked by Lunites. While there might have been some too far away for various reasons, William's Jellyfish is the only known survivor, even if we don't know how many of those Crown Vassal/Duchy airships were destroyed. My estimate was between 17 and 29 Crown Vassal airships were destroyed.

MASC

I’m curious about how many shards that explosion took out as I can imagine quite a few were too close to the explosion?

Blue Fishcake

Beta readers have it. It's still nine thirty in Los Angeles, it's still Sunday!

Trevayne

That is a good question. It depends a lot on how close they were and their attitude. If they were 500 or more yards away and facing the blast, they might get out largely unaffected. If they were closer or banking or flying above or below, they probably had the wings torn off. The thing is a mithril powered shard can lose both wings and still probably float to the ground The pilot just tells the shard to keep producing aether. They will need varying amounts of repair, but the only ones actually destroyed would be those too close to the explosion and reduced to fragments, either from the direct blast or being hit by a big chunk of airship. For a rough guess, if there were ten airships and 20 shards, we know two airships were destroyed and I would guess about 4-6 wrecked shards and another 6-8 damaged. Most will be repairable over a couple of weeks, depending on how many mage crafters the North brough with them.

PostCrepusculum

Somehow, the trojan horse exploding was funny to me. I've also two editorial comments. 1. The first paragraph is a run on sentence. I stumbled over "as the princess's speech finished" as it ran on to "from her position on" 2. "Half the fleet would be limping now – if it could move all.". -> " if it could move at all"