Poll #493 - How should I lay this book out?
- 5e Splat Book 42
- 5e Campaign Book 34
- Just Passing Through 11
- 2e "Boxed Set" 17
- LORE FOR DAYS 7
- idgaf, Dave, do whatever you want 9
Hello, my dearest Patrons,
I'm about to kick off writing Broadsword #26, Guide to the Negative Energy Plane. I'm trying to decide the best format for this book and what information to include. I have a few ideas on how I want to split it up. Below, I've listed sort of my favorite formats from the history of D&D. Pick the format you like best.
This organizational method usually puts a rough introduction of lore, then player options, GM options, an adventure or two, and a bestiary. It's relatively balanced on all fronts. The last Broadsword more or less followed this path. Examples include Van Richten's Guide to Ravenloft and Acquisitions Incorporated.
This style is mostly lore-driven, with lots and lots of tables. It tends to be rules agnostic or OSR. A lot of OSR books such as Into the Wyrd and Wild and Ultraviolet Grasslands uses it use this format.
These are about 80% adventure, and then just a little bit of mechanical information and maybe 1-2 new backgrounds or subclasses. Nearly all 5e campaign books fit this mold.
Although it will still be a book (boxed sets kinda went the way of the dodo), these were usually divided into multiple books and supplements. There was usually a player's guide that had info for the players to read and then a GM's guide for the GM to read. Occasionally, an adventure was tossed in there or a monster book. The Dark Sun boxed set and Ravenloft boxed sets were like these.
This is another format that hasn't been seen since 1e/2e, but it's basically just a monstrous book of lore lore lore. The old Volo's Guides were like these.