Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Poll #493 - How should I lay this book out?

  • 5e Splat Book 42
  • 5e Campaign Book 34
  • Just Passing Through 11
  • 2e "Boxed Set" 17
  • LORE FOR DAYS 7
  • idgaf, Dave, do whatever you want 9
  • 2025-02-01
  • —2025-02-08
  • 120 votes
{'title': 'Poll #493 - How should I lay this book out?', 'choices': [{'text': '5e Splat Book', 'votes': 42}, {'text': '5e Campaign Book', 'votes': 34}, {'text': 'Just Passing Through', 'votes': 11}, {'text': '2e "Boxed Set"', 'votes': 17}, {'text': 'LORE FOR DAYS', 'votes': 7}, {'text': 'idgaf, Dave, do whatever you want', 'votes': 9}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 2, 8, 19, 8, 21, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 2, 1, 18, 57, 29, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 120}

Content

Hello, my dearest Patrons,

I'm about to kick off writing Broadsword #26, Guide to the Negative Energy Plane. I'm trying to decide the best format for this book and what information to include. I have a few ideas on how I want to split it up. Below, I've listed sort of my favorite formats from the history of D&D. Pick the format you like best.

5e Splat Book

This organizational method usually puts a rough introduction of lore, then player options, GM options, an adventure or two, and a bestiary. It's relatively balanced on all fronts. The last Broadsword more or less followed this path. Examples include Van Richten's Guide to Ravenloft and Acquisitions Incorporated.

Just Passing Through

This style is mostly lore-driven, with lots and lots of tables. It tends to be rules agnostic or OSR. A lot of OSR books such as Into the Wyrd and Wild and Ultraviolet Grasslands uses it use this format.

5e Campaign Book

These are about 80% adventure, and then just a little bit of mechanical information and maybe 1-2 new backgrounds or subclasses. Nearly all 5e campaign books fit this mold.

2e Campaign Boxed Set

Although it will still be a book (boxed sets kinda went the way of the dodo), these were usually divided into multiple books and supplements. There was usually a player's guide that had info for the players to read and then a GM's guide for the GM to read. Occasionally, an adventure was tossed in there or a monster book. The Dark Sun boxed set and Ravenloft boxed sets were like these.

LORE FOR DAYS

This is another format that hasn't been seen since 1e/2e, but it's basically just a monstrous book of lore lore lore. The old Volo's Guides were like these.

Comments

James Geluso

I tend to think there are too many “player options” (particularly subclasses) already, the Negative Energy Plane really doesn’t need any. Maaaaybe spells.

Blue Infinity

I feel like the Splat Book is the best option, but with fewer player options and more LORE. I love lore but I NEED my stat blocks and adventure ideas.

Craig Johnston

I don't know why Boxed Sets died. I love(d) the format, and still have my 2e Boxed Sets.