Truth or Dare (Original Modern) (Patreon)

(Every character depicted in the story below is a consenting legal adult over the age of 18)

Poll Winner

Themes: Big Dick, Foursome, Fucked Silly

Summary: When Ryan reveals to Kelly, his first girlfriend, that he’s never played Truth or Dare, Kelly immediately tells him to cancel his plans and join her along with her friends Barbara and Dawn. He goes easy until Kelly makes the cardinal mistake of questioning his masculinity. Provoked and given permission to indulge in his deepest desires, things get very intense very quickly.

-x-X-x-

“Alright, Truth or Dare?”

“Dare~”

“Uhh… I dare you to jump up and down on one foot?”

“Come on Ryan! You can do better than that! Be a man and make things spicy!”

At the eager looks from her two friends, Ryan starts to suspect that there was an ulterior motive behind Kelly’s desire to get him to play Truth or Dare with her, Barbara, and Dawn.

It had all started innocuously enough. He and his girlfriend Kelly had been texting back and forth when the topic of Truth or Dare had come up and Ryan had offhandedly mentioned that he’d never played it before. Kelly had promptly freaked out, at least as much as one can over text, and told him to call all his plans for the evening because she was going to get her friends to join them and they were going to play.

Ryan hadn’t really thought it was all that serious, but it wasn’t like he had plans outside of spending time with her anyways, so he’d gone along with it.

And so here they were, having a bit of an impromptu ‘sleepover’ with all three girls dressed in loose fitting, slightly skimpy pajama tops and soft-looking pajama bottoms while he was just in a shirt and some gym shorts. And they’d been playing Truth or Dare for about thirty minutes now.

The thing is… it was like the girls had been waiting for something. Their own dares and requests for the truth hadn’t been anything too odd or out there, but whenever it was his turn, they looked at him expectantly… almost impatiently.

Only now, as Kelly pouts at his latest ‘dare’ and calls out his masculinity, does Ryan actually start to realize what’s happening here… and what they might want from him. He looks between his brunette girlfriend, Barbara the red head, and Dawn the blonde… and sees a glint in all of their eyes that he never would have picked up on without Kelly’s ‘hinting’.

Did they seriously want him to… do something with this opportunity? Or was he misreading the situation? Well, one thing was for sure, he wasn’t letting Kelly’s comment about ‘being a man’ pass by.

“Fine! I dare you to makeout with Barbara. Right here. Ten seconds minimum. Lots of tongue.”

Kelly’s eyes widen and so do Barbara’s as they share a glance. But just when Ryan thinks he might have overstepped… the brunette leans over, grabs the red head by her face, and begins kissing her. Ryan’s own face starts to grow hot as he watches them makeout for a lot longer than ten seconds, more like an entire minute, and there’s plenty of tongue to be had.

When they finally pull apart, Kelly gives him a wicked grin.

“That’s more like it~”

From there, things get a bit more… debauched. The Truths start to become about sexual preferences and Ryan quickly learns that all three girls are bisexual. The Dares start to be… well, lewd for sure, with Dawn having to take off her top entirely and expose her tits. All three of them give him an expectant stare at that and Ryan… Ryan doesn’t look away. He soaks in Dawn’s tits, letting himself enjoy the view as he starts to understand the game a bit better.

Until finally…

“Alright Barbara, Truth or Dare?”

Barbara bites her lower lip, glances down at his crotch meaningfully, and then looks him right in the eye.

“Dare~”

Ryan doesn’t hesitate.

“I dare you to suck my cock.”

Dawn gasps while Kelly grins. Barbara, meanwhile… doesn’t hesitate, all but lunging forward out of her seated position and crawling over on her hands and knees. She quickly pulls his cock out of his shorts and lets out a delighted gasp.

“Ooh… you’re just as big as Kelly promised~”

She then proceeds to stuff it in her mouth right then and there, proving once and for all that this whole night wasn’t really about Truth or Dare in the slightest… it was all a paper thin excuse for Kelly to get him in a foursome with two of her hot friends.

As Kelly and Dawn both crawl over as well, Ryan gives his girlfriend a deadpan stare.

“You know, you didn’t have to do all of this if you wanted me to fuck Barbara and Dawn. You could have just asked.”

Kelly grins crookedly and shrugs sheepishly.

“Where’s the fun in that?”

Right… admittedly, Ryan can’t exactly find it in himself to disagree with her. Especially not when Dawn has moved over to Barbara’s arched backside and has pulled down her pajama bottoms and panties over her shapely ass and to her knees. Before proceeding to lean forward and bury her face in Barbara’s no doubt drooling cunt.

The red head moans as the blonde gets to work and those moans send reverberations up the length of Ryan’s cock, making him shudder in enjoyment. Meanwhile, Kelly yanks her own top off, freeing her beautiful breasts from their confines so she can move behind him and hug him from behind, rubbing her tits into his back.

Ryan groans, hand atop Barbara’s head and his own head tilted back in enjoyment. The game of Truth or Dare is pretty much completely forgotten at this point, so he just enjoys Barbara’s efforts until finally, he can hold back no longer.

“Fuck… here it comes!”

Barbara gags a bit on his cock, gurgling as he cums in her mouth right there on the spot. She swallows what she can before pulling back and letting him cum all over her face with the rest of his load. By the time he’s done, Ryan is panting a bit… but Kelly reaches down and around and strokes his cock, keeping him rock hard as Barbara leans back and sits on her haunches, licking around her mouth.

Of course, this displaces Dawn… who clearly doesn’t mind because she quickly crawls past Barbara.

“My turn!”

Ryan arches a brow at the eager, bubbly blonde, while Kelly just laughs.

“So insatiable, Dawn! You can’t wait to have this big fat cock buried inside of you, can you?”

“Fuck no I can’t! Do you have any idea how long she’s been talking you up to us, Ryan? Telling us all about your huge dick and how good you make her feel when you fuck her silly?! It’s been intolerable waiting for this moment!”

Ryan flushes a bit. On the one hand, he can’t help but be proud of the praise his girlfriend is leveling his way. On the other hand, is that normal girl talk? It doesn’t feel like it… but then, nothing about this feels normal. And frankly, as Dawn shimmies out of her own bottoms and panties, leaving herself completely naked, Ryan doesn’t want to feel all that normal.

When she lays herself down in front of him and spreads her legs wide while looking up at him expectantly, Ryan chuckles and moves in. Grabbing her by the thighs, he places the head of his cock at Dawn’s slippery entrance… and gives her all of a moment to marvel at the feel of his bulbous cockhead before thrusting forward.

The blonde’s eyes widen and then roll back in her skull as she tosses her head back with a loud cry leaving her lips.

“OH FUCK!”

Ryan, meanwhile, doesn’t hesitate or slow down for even a moment once he’s inside of her. With a lust-filled growl, he buries himself deep in her cunt and quickly begins fucking her properly, so hard and fast that the sound of flesh slapping against flesh quickly begins to fill the room.

PLAP! PLAP! PLAP!

Kelly, meanwhile, is all giggles in his ear as she continues to rub her tits into his back.

“Oh yeah Ryan… give it to her. Fucking wreck her with that big fat cock of yours. Fuck her silly, just like you always do to me~”

It’s funny… Ryan had never really thought about it before. Probably because Kelly was his first girlfriend and had been his first time as well. But she always had been impressed by his cock size… and he usually did fuck her into such a stupor that they wound up going to sleep soon after. Well, if that’s what she wanted for Dawn… then fuck it.

Dawn squeals and creams herself on his cock as he picks up the pace yet again, fucking her even harder and faster. Her orgasms come quickly after that, each one leaving her more sensitive and on a bigger hair trigger than before. Until finally, with one last groan, Ryan empties his balls inside of the blonde.

By that point, her eyes are permanently rolled up in her head and her tongue is hanging out of her mouth. Ryan has done as he’s been told… and yet, he’s still rock hard. Luckily for him, Barbara is eager for her own turn and presents herself right alongside Dawn’s insensate form.

Namely, the red head gets on her hands and knees and looks back at him eagerly.

“Fucking take me, you fucking stallion! Feel free to pull my hair too, I like a little pain with my pleasure~”

Kelly laughs at that, whispering in his ear.

“She likes a lot more than a little bit of pain, Ryan. But we’ll save the whips and chains for another night~”

Ryan’s cock twitches at the thought of Barbara all tied up and at their mercy, moaning and crying out as they whip her. For the time being though he just nods and grabs her by the hips, slamming into her from behind.

He’s even less gentle than he was with Dawn, gripping hard at Barbara’s hair once he’s buried in her twat and yanking her head back. She gasps and moans as he forces her spine to arch, while at the same time driving into her again and again and once more causing lewd noises to fill the room.

SMACK! SMACK! SMACK!

“Hnnngh! S-So good! Fuck, your fat cock is SO GOOD!”

Barbara is vocal in her enjoyment of his sizable member, crying out loudly and more frequently than Dawn did. Eventually, she too experiences an explosive orgasm upon his pistoning prick… and that explosive orgasm is followed by many more, her climaxes and lewd moans filling the air.

Ryan fucks her with single minded purpose, treating her like the bitch in heat she’s acting the part of. He pulls her red hair back and reaches around to grope one of her flailing breasts, giving it a nice hard squeeze and mauling it much to her vocal enjoyment.

Eventually though, he cums inside of her as well, his third load for the evening. Frankly, he’s surprised he’s not too tired yet, even as Barbara slumps forward, face down ass up, his cum oozing out of her freshly fucked quim.

She and Dawn make for quite the sight, the former face down, the latter sprawled on her back. Both of them are completely dead to the world aside from the occasional twitch or tremble or quiver from their fucked silly bodies.

Kelly doesn’t let him stare for too long though. She tugs him around so he’s facing her and then pushes him back into a seated position so she can straddle him. Grinning, Ryan grabs his girlfriend by her hips as she impales herself on his big fat cock and wraps her legs around his waist. Her hips gyrate and they take their time with each other, moving a lot more slowly.

There’s no frantic bouncing, no plunging into her depths again and again, nothing like that. Instead they just kiss, lovingly and tenderly as Kelly moans into his lips.

Until suddenly, Ryan flips them both around and lays Kelly on her back right between her friends, pinning her in place with his cock. Her arms and legs still wrapped around his body, she looks up at him in surprise while Ryan growls playfully.

“Question my masculinity, will you? I’ll just have to give you the same treatment as your friends then~”

Kelly’s surprise morphs into pleasure as he begins to fuck her just as hard, pounding away at her pussy and making her moan up a storm.

PLAP! PLAP! PLAP!

“Ryyyyyaaan~”

Hearing his name from his girlfriend’s lips while she’s in the throes of ecstasy is music to Ryan’s ears and he lets out a lustful growl as he fucks her even harder. Until eventually Kelly’s eyes are rolled back in her head as well, her tongue sticking out of her mouth as she cums her brains out for him.

It takes longer than before for him to cum, but to be fair it is his fourth load of the night. Eventually though, he fills Kelly like he filled her friends… and then pulls back to admire the view, enjoying the sight of all three young women completely and utterly insensate because of his cock.

“Heh… this was fun, girls. We’ll have to play Truth or Dare again sometime… especially now that I fully understand how it’s done~”

-x-X-x-

Google Doc Link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1L3xoJltRMGoDNyma1fWRzj9CvhMKH6t5oqJylr_ks0M/edit?tab=t.0