The Secret Art of World Dodging (Patreon)
Content
I like to listen to various podcasts when I work. Often, they range between anything from the history of music, bands, and musicians, to creepypastas and strange events that have happened over history.
But one of those things that come up in my playlist are about world-building. 9 out of 10 times those world-building podcasts have something to do with TTRPGS, rather than the building blocks that writers use. But they almost always have something in common: They try to teach you how to skip most of the work to build upon your world.
Advice like "How to bring the gods into your worlds without having to do all the minute detail" or "How to build a believable person in your world without having to have pages of background".
While, for the work-weary soul, especially in today's society, I can get why this is an appealing genre of advice, I personally had one question pop into my head every time one of these podcasts came up: "Why?"
Why would you want to skip the fine details? Why would you want to bypass the interesting bits of lore and depth that a world or it's people can bring? Why would you want efficiency in creating a believable world when a reader of your work doesn't want to skip the prose to get to the ending? Why miss out on getting to know your headspace and those that occupy it?
Why bypass joyful immersion in what you want to create?
It intrigued me, and I recognized a pattern in it. It didn't matter what book genre, or more aptly, what game-system these videos were about, it was always about "Hey, you don't want to sit and do hours of prep on this shit. Your readers/players aren't going to ever need to know it, so why bother?"
The Dust of Ages
I'm very much of the opposite mind when it comes to creating a world and it's people. My duty isn't just to the reader or players, it's to the world I'm creating. I've always been like this. I have reams of material, that are now sadly forgotten, about worlds. cultures, people, gods, technology, and beliefs of those who inhabit my strange head-spaces.
Invariably, the advice given might be something like this: "When creating a figure in the history of your world, nobody needs or wants to hear about what they enjoyed eating. They don't want to hear about what God(s) they worshipped unless that's relevant to the story, and they don't want to know what their personal office look(ed) like until it's time to loot it, and even then.. Don't write out details other than vague overviews of what's in that office"
I don't know exactly when this advice started becoming more prevailing. When I started in games back in the day, I would often see everything from NPC's to items to rooms and towns detailed out in almost obsessively meticulous detail. Right down to the coins buried in an urn in the back yard by the tree.
I don't know if it's an attention span thing, or a cultural shift, but in terms of RPG's I do know that it was a shift away from "Well, where are you searching?" to "Just roll a perception check, and I'll tell you what you find".
But here's the thing.. I don't like being robbed of the joy I get out of creating the life and world that these people are a part of. I don't want to simply bypass what other's find tedious. Perhaps it's my neurodivergent mind, my love of obsessive little details, but I get into creating much like I do getting into reading. If I could, I'd pour a fine port, sit by the fire, and absolutely melt into the act of creating a breathing world or life within it. It's a part of the joy I personally get out of the process. It's not a burden, it's part of the game for me. Walking to the plate isn't considered faffing about, and I don't want an Uber to drive me the 10 feet from the dugout.
Wherein it's all Cardboard
Often, I find that the creators, be they singular or part of a collective, that take time to write out parts of their universe, have far richer spaces. I find that I become more invested in a book that has a preamble about one character's adventures in discovering that part of the world than I do a simple 'stat block' and 'designers blurb about what you might want to shove in there'.
Efficiency is often a tradeoff. Yes, some people aren't afforded the time in their busy lives to devote hours to writing books or game sessions (Seriously, though, writers are often better about actually WRITING than game designers are). Efficiency tends to be tied to needing to get something done in a certain time-frame. I get that. I also understand that my down-time of sketching and doing art/writing is probably vastly different from someone who just wants to come home, relax, and throw Andor on the screen to watch it.
But that kind of nails it right there: Time Crunch. The belief that something must be completed and ready to go within a certain time frame. While that's understandable, I think it jolts the ability to flesh things out. I personally don't have much advice I could even give to help in that way, other than: Be okay with improvisation.
Some of the best writing I've done was while throwing rails onto the tracks in front of me while I was moving. Be it in writing ideas with others, or running game sessions. I'd have lots of notes, but sometimes someone would mention something and suddenly the world would change. Efficiency doesn't have to be about 'not immersing' yourself, it can be by just allowing what you are creating to breathe, and become malleable.
Going back and editing your world is part of the fun. I hope others can do just that. Take the parts that change and expound upon them. I love hearing about worlds, and people. Yes, I'm interested in what they like to eat. I'm interested in the clutter in that office, and the lovingly carved box given to them by their daughter before they tragically passed away. By the slight scratches at the edges when the man in question would curl his fingers, dragging nails in anguish across it's surface while weeping in her memory.
No, I don't have to write that all out to read aloud to 'players', but I can mention those scratches, and perhaps set a letter or two to his late daughter in amidst his belongings.
I realize this post was a bit of a ramble, but it was on my mind lately. I've heard a couple more podcasts about 'trimming the fat' of game sessions in the last couple of days as my playlist wanders along, and while they're actually excellent in their advice, I hope in some way it's not setting a normalcy to think of a world more as a product than it is a space for one's mind to run free.
That's my hope, at least.
-T.J.