Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Alrighty guys this is a very random but I think interesting discussion. If they were all still alive....which Baratheon brother would you want to fight for? And why? So let me know who you would choose.......Robert? Stannis? Renly? 

Comments

Karl Straba

Robert....in his prime he seemed like the best of all of them honestly..From what I've heard/read about in his days of his rebellion and what not. And I mean he did wind up on the throne too so he did something right and conquered a lot in his day.

Sesskasays

Just putting my two cents in.....Renly had Brienne. Renly wins.

Karl Straba

Brienne betrayed and murdered Renly in his own tent tho....and killed 2 of his guards on top of that....ahem ;)

Dave Ford

Renly, I think - but that might well be because we didn't get to know him enough to know how bad he'd be - certainly Robert was a drunk and had apparently ruined the finances. Stannis - too proud, too inflexible, too willing to murder his own children... Not sure what Renly's character flaws would have been... possible not good enough to survive being assassinated?

Anonymous

I think I'd have to pass on all 3 and become part of the Brotherhood without Banners

Dave Hampton

Tough question. I do not think any of them would be great. Not Robert, that is easy IMO. Renly had the love of the people and did not seem stupid, but he seemed maybe not serious enough for a realm 6 million in debt. He was going to rebel against the crown and he was having a tournament in his camp? As Cat said Robb was fighting a war, not playing at one. Stannis might have been the leader they needed to bring them back from what Robert did to the crown financially and to survive the long winter that is coming. I guess I would go with Renly with a really good Hand of the King and the help of Highgarden to help the crown get out of debt.