Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Which companion exit was the toughest for you to watch? 

Comments

Dylan Cooper

All of them hurt me, but Rose's initial exit in Doomsday was the first time a TV show broke my heart and I'll always remember it. Amy and Rory's come very close though.

Anonymous

I sobbed so damn much watching Rose's exit in Doomsday but I also did watching Amy and Rory's. I have to give it to Rose, Amy and Rory come in at an incredibly close second though.

Monty Magpie

I'd say Donna because at least all the others still retained their memories of travelling with The Doctor.

Harry Utton

In my opinion Donnas 'death' was the hardest to deal with. She went from someone who visited other worlds and discovered her true self, to a person who took life for granted. It just makes me so sad, it's like the real Donna died there and then. At least the others were able to live their full lives with the memories of the Doctor and amazing adventures they went on.

Firefly24601

Amy and Rory's departure was so traumatic for me. I couldn't rewatch that episode for the longest time. Only when your turn to watch it was coming up, did I watch it again. I wanted to be more familiar with what happened aurally, so I could follow then plot as you watched. I still have a hard time listening to "Together or Not At All" by Murray Gold, which was the song playing when they leapt from the building.

Stephen Holloran

Donna was hardest in terms of losing her identity and memories of the doctor after maturing so much but the way amy and rorys end played out packed a massive punch and was weaved into the storylines of season 5 / 6 and seven ...

Opti_Frog

I was sadder when Rose returned than when she left.

Dave van der Kuyp

Amy and Rory ended up happy together. Donna just lost everything that made her like herself. Also.. Donna's grandpa, kills me.

Dave Ford

Donna, by far the worst - getting forced mind-wiped against her will was horrific. There should have been another way - something clearly Moffat didn't appreciate either..

JojoInSpace

This was difficult for me. Because while I think that Donna has the overall worst fate, and Amy and Rory were the companions I was saddest to see go, the companion exit that affected me the most was Rose. It was the only one I wasn't spoiled about when it was going to come, I was still very young and new to Doctor Who, I was lying up at night binge-watching, and then Doomsday happened. I cried for ages (at like, two in the morning) and then all the way to school next day. It's not the one that affects me most on rewatch (that's Amy & Rory) or the one I think is most tragic (Donna). Rose isn't even in my top three companions, but I still haven't had that emotional a reaction to any companion exit since, though I've had plenty of emotional reactions.

JojoInSpace

But Karen and Arthur were the actors I had the toughest time to see go - because they were both so wonderful, and their relationship with Matt was amazing. Check out some behind the scenes stuff with them at some point, because it's hilarious. They're such a family, on and off stage.

Michael Morand

Fun fact! When the Doctor was reading the afterword from Amy while they filmed his face reading Karen was also sitting next to Matt reading the passages for him. If you see some footage of it from afar you can see after a while Matt starts to cry. It’s one of the hardest things to watch. Similar situation when Billie and David filmed Doomsday. Make sure to check out P.S. before you continue. Great conclusion.

Stephen Ray

I was a bit torn between Donna and the Ponds. It was the Doctor's heartbreak that cements it as the saddest departure. Martha departed on her own terms, and Rose isn't even in my top 5 nuWho companions.

Ana Decaprio

I love that song. It's one of the most beautiful. Not in a sad way, but beautiful to me knowing how far they would go for each other - that true love.

Ana Decaprio

Amy and Rory's departure still makes me cry every time I watch it, but the saddest for me is Rose because they were in love with each other and had to be separated. Amy and Rory got to spend the rest of the lives together, so that's happy. Rose and 10 didn't. Watching the despair on both their faces when his hologram gets disconnected, is heartbreaking and it's something I hate rewatching. So that one hurts me the most. Martha was heartbroken when she left the Doctor, even though she got over him and found happiness. Oddly, Donna's memory wipe doesn't bother me because "ignorance is bliss." I know it's sad that she'll never know the happiness she had and the confidence she gained, but she doesn't know that. She gets to go on living her happy life (hopefully it is happy). I think the hardest ones for the Doctor are Rose and Amy and Rory. Donna is close, but I think he loves Amy more than Donna.

Christopher Hird

After thinking about it between Donna and Amy and Rory I have to say Donna as amy and Rory still lived a long life together as you can see by their gravestone with all of their memory's were as with Donna losing all her memories of her time with him makes it feel like it was all for nothing, she cant even die with the memory's and knowing all the good she did around the universe