Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

So this week’s Favorite TV moment is going to have a very different tone from last week’s. First off, I would like to thank each and every one of you for not spoiling what was about to happen in the next episode after what I wrote next week. And I don’t just mean blatantly spoil. I mean saying anything like “oh my god…..wait until next week….” and so on and so forth. Must’ve been hard to keep that all to yourselves. 

Okay, so when I was deciding about which moment to pick, I was town between two moments but they were in the same episode. If Rory and Amy’s rooftop moment happened in any other episode, I am almost positive it would take the cake but this week has to go to the graveyard sequence. Just after you think everything is okay, it gets completely torn away in an instant. 

The brilliance in my opinion of this episode is the fact that the writers were very clear on letting you know what was going to happen. We see Rory’s name on a grave fairly early on. The fact that I saw that earlier in the episode and all I could do was try to convince myself of all of the ways he could get out of it. Unlike the majority of you, I did not know this was definitely Amy and Rory’s last episode so the overwhelming emotions at the end just hit me like a bus. 

If it’s not enough to lose Rory, we now have to face the fact that we’re going to lose Amy as well. It’s almost as soon as she figures it out that she decides she wants to risk everything and try to be with Rory. No matter what, she needs to risk it. Seeing Amy’s journey on this show has been absolutely lovely. She seemed to be a bit confused in the beginning of the show about who she was and who she was meant to be. Like many of us are at one point and time in our lives. I could certainly relate. But I do think it was very fitting that all she had to do was make this decision within a “blink of an eye” and she had no problem doing that. She kept her eyes on the angel long enough to say her goodbyes and then left to go be with Rory. 

Now if that’s not enough heartbreak for us all, I will now move on to the subject of Amy and The Doctor. I may have liked other companions more than Amy (only a handful tho, she’s pretty high on my list) but I did not love any Doctor/Companion relationship as much as Amy and The Doctor. I fell in love at the “11th Hour” and haven’t stopped. Amy and her “imaginary friend” have been through so much together. I also believe they have both grown because of one another. The Doctor opened his heart to Amy and Rory. They were his family. Him losing both of them at the same time is just absolutely tragic and it kills me to think about it. 

I must say, I’m not looking forward to seeing him grieve. But at the same time, I hope we see some of it. I gotta say Amy and Rory will be a very tough act to follow. I do not know what this new companion will bring or when we will meet them but I really do hope I love them as well. 

In this reaction, I wasn’t just mourning the loss of two beloved characters that got taken away so suddenly from me. I was also mourning what could possibly be the end of my favorite era of Doctor Who. I hope you all know what I mean when I say that. I’m not going to go in hating the next companion because they aren’t Amy or Rory like so many people think I will. But when The Doctor, Amy and Rory (and River at times) were together, I was just ecstatic to watch the next episode which was a feeling I didn’t really have in previous seasons. I really do hope that feeling stays with me as I journey on. 

Alrighty this is long enough. I rambled a bit too much. At the end of it all…..The Doctor, Amy and Rory were pure magic on screen and I loved every single second of it. Now I’m going to drown my sorrows in a bottle of vodka. Cheers. 

Files

Previews only

Sesska's Favorite TV Moment of the Week (9/17-9/23)

P.O. Box Information: Sesskasays P.O. Box 43441 Fayetteville, NC 28309 Patreon for Full Reactions, Movie Reactions & More!: https://www.patreon.com/sesskasays Twitter: https://twitter.com/sesskasays

Comments

Stephen Ray

That relationship really was special. That's what made it so sad. You knew that Amy and Rory were going to be fine, but the Doctor was crushed. He lost his family.

Opti_Frog

My eyes actually burned a bit reading that. I wouldn't blame you if you wanted to take a week or two off from DW reactions. For me, you hit the nail on the head with what you said about the Doctor/Companion relationship concerning the first two and a half seasons of the Moffat era. It's what cemented DW as my favourite tv show. Your love for 11, Amy, Rory and River is also why you have become my favourite DW reactor. I'm certain Doctor Who will continue to surprise you in all sorts of ways, good and bad. And even though the era of the Ponds is over, i'm sure all of us who are on this journey with you are excited for things to come. In fact, you know what? I think your best DW reactions are ahead of you. You might be done reacting to my favourite companions, but i still have to wait for your reactions to my top three (possibly even top five) episodes ever.

Janel Rodriguez

Oooh. Jan, could you PM me with what your those 3-5 favorite episodes are that you mentioned above? I have a few coming up, too.

Opti_Frog

I would, if i could figure out how to PM on patreon. It seems reluctant to let me. In fact, i don't think it's possible to PM other patreons, only creators.

Jeff Clark

There's two things about this that I only clicked on a recent rewatch, and it makes it even more tragic. 1 - Amy and Rory are both buried right next to where they are all stood. They were there alive, together and happy and at the same time their bodies were underneath the ground and had been for years. 2 - the ages carved on the gravestone show that Amy lived alone for another 5 years after Rory died. Horrible to think of her being alone after they've been through so much together.

Jeff Clark

You guys could just post season and episode numbers (or initials of the title for specials) which wouldn't be spoilers then :)

Opti_Frog

Janel, you could always look me up on twitter or youtube, both are in my patreon profile. =)

Dave Ford

So glad you stayed away from the YT comments - so many people bouncing up and down with anticipation about Angels take Manhattan, you'd have figured out that something was going to go down for sure. I know what you mean about watching Amy grow - they make clear, from her perspective that she (and Rory) have been knocking arround with the Doctor for nearly ten years of their life. We've seen her not only fall in love with the Doctor and then Rory, but become completely settled and that's been so lovely. As for the gravestone, that's interesting. If you think about it (and I really wouldn't suggest trying to analyze the logic of a show about a magic travelling box), the reason the Doctor can't save them makes no sense at all - we're fairly sure they can leave the hotel room, so they can leave NYC? So they can wait till after 1938 and meet up with the Doctor. The gravestone does suggest one explanation for why this isn't going to happen in that it cannot - we know Rory and Amelia die in NYC in their old age. Whatever escape plan the Doc had, it wouldn't have worked. " "I was also mourning what could possibly be the end of my favorite era of Doctor Who." Well, we all do that with Doctor Who at times - I suspect you'll do that again when 11 regenerates - I do hope you still enjoy the 'new' show. (Given it's a new companian, new story arc and new dynamic, 'new' doesn't seem too strong a word). Just give it a few episodes, before making your mind up. And, Yes, Amy's story was absolutely magical. Right from her first episode which has a wonderfully magical feel to the childhood scenes especially.

Opti_Frog

Hey, Dave. Surely you're not suggesting that Amy and Rory were zapped into a hotel room that, due to the Rory induced paradox, unhappened? Whether The Doctor could travel to some point outside NY and find Amy and Rory has been a point of contention in the fandom since the episode first aired. Moffat even commented on it, but i was quite disappointed by his answer. He only adressed why the Doctor couldn't take the Tardis to NY. Here's my headcanon, my take on it. Whether The Doctor could travel to some point outside NY and find Amy and Rory is, in my opinion, a moot point. The issue is not where he can take the Tardis but whether Amy and Rory are in his future. If you know your future there is no way to change it, according to the Doctor, at least not without creating a dangerous paradox. Once the meaning of "Amelia's Last Farewell" became clear, it was set in stone as much as River's broken wrist. From the final episode of S1 Rose Tyler: "I can see everything... all that is... all that was... all that ever could be." The Doctor: "But that's what I see. All the time." In my mind, the Doctor knows that all the could-be's cease to exist once Amy says her Last Farewell. The Doctor knows she is no longer a part of his future. One could argue it's kind of the same with the Brigadier (and other companions - if the Brig was a companion - can of worms). The Doctor could go back and visit him at a point in time when the Brig was alive, but he's simply not part of the Doctor's future history.

Dave Ford

Yup, I think I'm with you on that - the headstones means that it doesn't matter what plan the Doctor (or Rory) came up with, he will die in that hotel room sometime in the mid 90's and now, thanks to Amy 'setting it in stone', with his wife who will live a few years longer. But my larger point is not thinking too hard about DW is advisable. Doubly advisable is not thinking too hard about time travel. And triply advisable is absolutely, definitely not thinking about ontological paradoxes (google it) that Stephen Moffat wrote. :-) After all, if you want to get picky about the logic, just wait for -those- two episodes in S8 (You know the two I mean...)

Opti_Frog

I agree with almost everything you say, except that Rory dies in the hotel. The hotel unhappened thanks to the suicide paradox, and never existed. According to Amy's afterword, they lived a happy life together, and P.S. shines even more light on what happened to the Ponds. If Rory was stuck in the hotel, how could they adopt Anthony in the 1940s? =) I certainly agree about the time travel. DW has never been bothered with rules or canon, and lets the time travel fit the story currently being told. I know this is frustrating for many fans, but i think it's one of the shows greatest strengths. It's a loose format for the writers instead of a straight jacket. Speaking of ontological paradoxes, have you seen Predestination (2014)? If not, i highly recommend it. Hmm. I can only think of one ep in S8. Are you sure you're not thinking of S9? XD