Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

A Matter of Life and Death (1946)

Full Reaction You can either stream the Full reaction below using the embedded video player, otherwise you can click the 'Download' button which will take you directly to Google Drive, enabling you to save the video to your computer instead. You must provide your own footage to watch alongside the full reactions.

Comments

Paul Flux

I'm so glad that you liked this movie. It was one of my late mother's favourites, and I remember being mesmerised by it when I first saw it as a child.

Thomas Corp

One of the greatest movies of all time. It’s in my top twenty favorites. My favorite Powell and Pressburger picture. It’s my pick for favorite of 1946, and that’s said with complete apology to The Best Years of Our Lives as the latter film is unquestionably the deserved win for best picture at that year at the Oscars, which says a lot given how crowded the year was. Put my criterion blu-ray of this on twice to get ready for this. Not that I need the excuse as I could watch this film any day of the week. But to share it with you, Jess, is a particularly wonderful excuse to see this film again. I see the print you had was the criterion print, very nice. I take the blame for you reacting to the trailer for this as I was the one to request that you react to the trailer way back when so as to put it on the polls. I thought this would be a film that you would greatly appreciate. I rewatched the video to refresh the memory of your initial assessment from said trailer. A lovely, lovely thing to see that you loved this film, Jess. Your chief description: “Inspired”, that’s a good word choice. This whole thing is such a sumptuous visual feast. Knew you were going to make a comment on the plot of this starting the day before your birthday. David Niven makes for the strong lead in this to no one’s surprise. Kim Hunter, likewise, is wonderful. Peter and June, having the connection over the final conversation. As you say, a nice fantasy blossoms in that last moment that you take succor in. Good note how the initial mistake is shown from the perspective of Heaven. Nice moment of Richard Attenborough sensing that Heaven will spare no expense in helping set up an island with your dear beloved Betty. The people running the place do put Peter through it as they’re quite insistent on taking him upstairs. All of this is less strange for him than the streaker at the Oscars, incidentally enough. June becomes a staunch ally and wishes to be with him. Certainly, it’s better than getting stuck with hearing “Hey STELLA!!” every night. They have Frank on their side, played by Roger Livesey. Man’s surely a reader. You made the comment, “That’s a lot of books.”, and I did get a little testy, asking, “What’s wrong with that!?” And his assessment of the mundane versus the fantastic is great. Terrific words you had about the love for the tug and pull of what’s real or not in this film. How Frank assesses that even if it is all in Peter’s mind, it’s no less real. And sad though it is that he dies, great it is that he becomes Peter’s man for the trial. Love how you caught Chekov’s treacherous road, asking if he was going to die, to which, I dryly noted, “Not yet.” It was later quite something seeing your reaction to Frank’s death, and how you called it too early. Just like you said, Jess, you’re so smart. Peter also has support from his bestie, Bob, his number one guy. Sweet how Bob struck up the friendship with the one angel played by the legendary Kathleen Byron being wonderful as always. Quite the withering glare that she has. Thankfully, she’s on the side of the angels. Imagine that look on a villain; it’d be one of the most terrifying images in cinema history. Haha, YEEESH. And amusingly enough, not the last time Kathleen features in a World War II film that has a central message of does a man deserve the special treatment and the questions of that and how what’s been given, he must earn this. Then there’s your favorite. I had suspected that you would be obsessed with Marius Goring in this film. Man is fantastic in this as the heavenly messenger, our dear Conductor 71. Lovely penchant for the dramatic that he has. Smart tactic of trying to persuade Peter with chess. The temptation of some excellent games of chess would be difficult to resist. He had some great Q skill in freezing time. Love how you were worried for a second before the film told you, “Don’t worry, there’s nothing wrong with your television set.” Fun how the subtitles get in on the action if you put them on. All of Marius’s scenes were great. Love the reaction to the eyelid shot. Leads us to the big trial, featuring Farlan, played by the always terrific Raymond Massey, whom my mom adores. She particularly loves his portrayal of Lincoln, which I assume Farlan’s first name being Abraham is a nod to that, or just a fun little coincidence. My mom and I were just watching him in East of Eden a little while ago, Mom asked what is it about Raymond that’s so great, and I said, “He just is.” Frank and Farlan get off topic with the volleying comments. Love your assessment of the poking around Peter’s brain being the cause for the British wartime propaganda. Funny how we’re both of the mind of cracking Peter’s head open, we’re fine with. The needles, not so much, though I like the one stage technique of hiding the needle at the one spot. Great when you really started questioning what the posturing of the countries had to do with anything. Like you said, the poking around in the brain making everything all British wartime propaganday. Be thankful they’re not poking around my head for this; it’d look like Lang and Bergman in a swirling Tod Browning and/or James Whale looking affair. You say that it’s really the only part of the film that lost you some. It DOES, perhaps, have a bit of trouble translating well to today’s generation. But the jokes are still fantastic. Fair observation about how women don’t care to be referred to as “stock”, to be fair to Farlan, he is from over two-hundred and fifty years ago, so he’s not exactly the most forward-thinking man around. We do get back to the matter of love. It is the thesis of the debate between Frank and Farlan: Could a man could become so in love with a woman, from a single encounter? Could he daily feel a stab of hunger for her, and find nourishment in the very sight of her? I think so. But would she see through the bars of his plight and ache for him? In this case, the answer is yes. And I live; it’s the romantic in me. I did figure that knowing you, you’re not too sold on the love at first sight business. Works for a lot of Disney films. Speaking of Disney, your comments in the reaction: I can see the Fantasia comparison, now you mention it. I also loved your later “What in the Pride Rock?” remark. The fairy tale vibe of this helps here, and your words on the chance for love were very nice. How you interpreted it as Peter and June fighting for the potential for the love to flourish. I like that. I like that perspective. They win, and I always like how Farlan concedes graciously, and even complimented Frank. It helps that no one ever says that he looks like Boris Karloff, angering him to the point of employing the Melbourne Method. Ending on the so sweet note of Peter and June being happy that they’ve been given their chance. An ending that already gets a man good, and now a man’s heart swells to bursting seeing your own truly delightful reaction to it. Then there’s the funny notes you had about the Stairway to Heaven. Amusing how you got confused with the stairway in question. Memory is a funny thing sometimes. Making you even question if you saw the trailer. You did. And as you observed, it funnily enough sort of ties into the themes of what is or isn’t real. Making me wryly note, “That is an amusing coincidence.” A thing in life, as you said: The mind combines the conflicting and confusing images together, like when Peter Capaldi cycles through the Doctor’s memories and traumas before getting to that diamond wall. A beauty of a reaction, Jess. This reached the glee I had from your Dracula reaction of just so ADORING that you loved this film as you did. Thank you so, so very much for this, Jess, it is greatly treasured.

Dave Ford

A wonderful movie - and one made with the tensions between US service personnel and UK civilians in mind when it was made - so really quite 'political'. Like pretty much everything else Powell and Pressburger made it's a fantastically imaginatively told movie - I'd urge you to check out if you can both 'The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp' and 'The Red Shoes'. Also, wondering if the your memory of a staircase is in fact being influenced by the movie Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey (the sequel to the first Bill and Ted movie) - which rather unaccountably pays homage to A Matter of Life and Death by recreating some of the same sets, including the staircase.

Frank Shailes

Some bits inspired things in Patrick McGoohan's "The Prisoner" (Michael Powell worked on that series early on).

Ryan

You having seen the trailer puts you ahead of me, as I'd never heard of it before it showed up on the poll and was baffled that it was apparently popular enough to get the most votes of all. And I was a bit disappointed at first to see it pop up here since I've been desperately waiting for the other two winners for so long. But it didn't take long before I was completely sucked in and desperate to see things turn out okay for these people, so big thanks to everyone who played a part in bringing it to my attention. I spent so long knowing David Niven solely from the last couple decades of his work that it still kind of freaks me out every time I see him younger, just as much as CGI Patrick Stewart in X-Men Origins. And I took a while to get on board with this opening, as the whole "stiff upper lip" thing felt way too artificial especially knowing the movie's start as war propaganda. And the big irony is Niven was an actual veteran who famously took it extremely seriously to the point of refusing to ever share stories about it, so he'd definitely know how fake this all is (ironically he ended up winning an Oscar as someone who commits stolen valor). But once we get to the afterlife, all that concern faded away. I'm always a sucker for imagining what this is like, my all time favorite being the 1944 film Between Two Worlds with Sidney Greenstreet as the judge who actually ends up sending everyone to the exact same place, and whether it's Heaven or Hell depends entirely on whether they're the kind of person who likes being somewhere that being good is what's always rewarded. And this quickly jumped to close to the top of the ones I've seen, aided a lot by Kathleen Byron as a long-suffering clerk. The woman can make putting on lipstick one of the scariest things you've ever seen, and somehow she just fits here too. I also really dug the altered color scheme from what you expect, where it's the real world that's in color. Certainly a step up from A Man and a Woman, where after decades of people discussing what the meaning was behind certain scenes being in color or black and white, finally the director came out and said "Oh, we actually just ran out of black and white film and only color was available. Sorry to make you waste all that time." One of the funnier stories I came across for the Original Screenplay winners. And I read Marius Goring improvised the line about the afterlife not having Technicolor. Never heard of him before, but this had me aching to check out some of his other work. Very cool effects work whenever he sticks Peter in the Police Squad closing credits, which I'm sure were just mind-blowing back then. Very amusing to see Kim Hunter having this job, when a while later she'd be insisting flight is scientifically impossible. And even if it wasn't, where would you go? This was predictably the most I was taken out of it, and it's another time that I was quite relieved to learn it's not just my aroace brain and it's a very common view that their romance develops ridiculously fast. Seeing as many older movies as I have, I've come down on how it seems standard practice back then was just for the audience to assume every in-universe character would have the same reaction they did to certain actors. My favorite to bring up is that the central romance in Charade is especially unearned right at the start, but no one cares because you love both actors involved so much and it's a beloved classic. Will this enchanting floozy seduce this humble newsie? What's a paperboy to do? Regarding the staircase, whenever the concept is brought up, my mind goes straight to the Carrie musical. There's a full performance from 1985 available on Youtube, and it's just as much a beautiful trainwreck as you've heard, and ends with a giant stairway to the afterlife that you can hear the audience be impressed by despite the insanity they've been enduring for the last two hours. Some more very cool effects in this part with actors walking straight through the operating room doors in a single shot; contrast to Dracula 15 years earlier having to cut away for the effect of him walking through a spiderweb. And despite the rushed nature of the relationship, I still felt like it was established enough to feel like she'd be okay with the kiss, and even got a bit moved by the result. A tear, Sarah Jane? No, don't cry. While there's life, there's... I really wasn't expecting the actor we get for the prosecutor, but I always love seeing him show what a great actor he can be outside that Frankenstein makeup. Technically you can say this part really lost me too, since it feels like everything they bring up is so specific to the exact time the movie was made that a lot of times I legit have no idea what the joke is even supposed to be. Reeves would be fully justified in just saying at any time "Everything this guy says is bullshit. Thank you." But the deliveries from them both are still so engaging that I got wrapped up in the scene despite myself. It's also just a lot of fun seeing this very British production being willing to take so many hard jabs at their own country's history. It could only be better if Lugosi showed up to be his sidekick again. The one place it really does fall down is when they come so close to getting away with the white actor playing a black soldier thanks to the black and white, but then they got greedy and brought the whole jury to Earth in color. The whole time there's really little doubt how things will end up (and even if they did lose, it wouldn't be that much of a problem as long as Peter's friend can find the right mosquito). But I still felt the weight lifted off when the escalator becomes temporarily stairs, and the prosecutor can go off to steal Christmas or something. The one woman in charge seems a bit miffed at how it turned out, but just introduce her to Timothy Olyphant shows and she'll forget about it soon. I went from having no idea what this movie was, to being totally enraptured and sure I'll be seeing it plenty more times. I already found out my dad had never heard of it despite being a massive Niven fan, and we're very excited about getting together a viewing for the whole family. Again, my thanks to all who made this possible.

Paul Hayes

I always enjoy seeing this one again, and it was nice to watch it with your comments and observations, as always! I hadn't watched it properly for a long time, so it was interesting to see how comparatively little time is actually spent in the 'other place' - I'd misremembered it as being more of a 50-50 split. I know what you mean about the 'trial', although I have to admit it's actually possibly my favourite part of the film! I suppose it reflects a lot on transatlantic relations at the time, and the ways in which the two countries regarded one another. Interesting that you're firmly in the 'it's all in his head' camp. I've always been more on the other side of things.