Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Star Trek TNG 5×25 Full Reaction

Full Reaction You are now able to stream the full reaction directly from this website. Alternatively, you can download it to your computer using the button underneath the video player. You must provide your own footage to watch alongside the full reactions.

Comments

Jenny Chalek

I can't wait to see you react to this one. It my second favorite episode.

Josef Schiltz

My favourite episode. Wonderful. Never to have loved, with any reciprocity, or be loved, this episode always, without fail, has me bawling my eyes out. It is a wonderful episode, but I know. that I do not appreciate it without a certain amount of self-torture. I am without further words on this. The music is beautiful and there is a suite which is based around the tune that Picard plays on the Ressikan flute. Definitely one of the best Trek episodes ever made.

The Bill Podcast

Outstanding reaction and analysis, as always 🙏🖖

Ryan

Quite a journey this episode has been on in fan reception. When it first aired it was hailed as one of the show's best, and you'll still find some people arguing that, but there's also been a slowly but surely growing contingent against it, some even calling it a low point for the entire franchise (and this when Profit and Lace or Four and a Half Vulcans exist). Mostly it tends to come down on how much you're willing to buy into Roddenberry's original "It's about the ideas" ethos, and the more personal stories of these characters don't matter much compared to grander sci-fi concepts that leave you thinking about how it applies to the real world. And given how much you've made clear your own stance on that, this response isn't much of a surprise. The writer Morgan Gendel won a Hugo Award for it, the first for the franchise in 22 years since The City on the Edge of Forever. And while he didn't turn on it to nearly the same extent as Harlan Ellison, he has expressed regret at being so excited about the basic concept that he never stopped to consider the psychological impact this experience would have, and how monstrous it could come off to subject an unwitting person to it. I also have my own beef with him for his horrible verging on "in name only" Dresden Files show. The show would even take some steps later on to show how Picard is still deeply affected by it, but that doesn't really count when considering the episode itself. One other big issue I had was by halfway through, the twist was about as easy to see coming as the one person we don't actually see being killed in gruesome detail being Jigsaw's new apprentice. But at least the journey getting there has some big interest involved, managing to make its environmentalist point without ever having the Thirteenth Doctor directly preach to the camera like I very much remember was happening a lot on TV at this time. Also a very nice touch to have the official spell out that they pretty much have to keep the inevitable extinction secret so everyone doesn't spend their remaining time in total chaos, before he goes off to find anyone breaking the Good Samaritan Law. And I'm always down for seeing more Richard Riehle. Hopefully Batai had time to finish his jump to conclusions mat, or at least let Richard Kimble escape to find Tomalak. I really liked the episode the first time I saw it, but the more I think about it over the years, the lesser it gets, as this is simply not a story designed for close scrutiny. But if you can resist doing that, it's still a great time.

Josef Schiltz

The Eleventh Doctor to Amelia Pond; "We're all stories in the end, so make it a good one."

Thomas Corp

Rather bizarre twist of fate that between Darth Maul and this, Darth Maul astonishingly enough comes across as the more cheerful time of things. That’s in the running for oddest sentences in the history of mankind. Yeah, as of this point, top two favorite episodes for both of us, Déjà Q and The Perfect Mate for me, The Next Phase and Disaster for you, check. Fun times sharing all four episodes, and last week, sharing with you your favorite was rather special, Jess. Now for some fun times this week, with, oh... Surprising that it seemed unknown to you, as this one tends to be famous, even if one hasn’t seen the show. Then again, you express familiarity with the aesthetic, so I’d wager you’ve seen this before, just very long ago. One thing for sure, you correctly deduced that the whole ordeal goddamn fucks up Picard’s head to an obscene degree. (A minor detail that the writers slightly overlooked.) Looks like Deanna picked the wrong week to go on vacation. The whole thing is bananas, crackers, and nuts. (And apples, oranges, kiwis, all that.) It does indeed test that old expression that always fluctuates between being truthful and bullshit. Figured that it would put you through it. Watching this again, I thought of you, saying, “Oh, she’ll be using words with this one.” This is a fairly universally beloved episode; hailed as one of the best of the best of the franchise. Unsurprisingly, our dear Sir Patrick Stewart lists this one as one he’s particularly proud of. Kicks off with a start when they find the probe, Picard is knocked out, and the fun begins. Stressful for the crew. Much though you sympathize with Riker and Worf, you side with Beverly when she notes that doing anything to the probe could potentially be fatal to Picard, likening it to how if you’ve been stabbed by a knife, pulling the blade will have disastrous results. Beverly is proven right when attempting to sever the beam nearly kills Picard. Christ, Gates makes me sob when she performs the moment that shows how Beverly was holding down a lot of fear and anguish that when Picard’s doing well again, she lets out a brief, quiet sob. Geordi does the most as he does with figuring out where the probe came from, good man, Geordi. We get a subtle yet very massive compliment to Alyssa and her skill if Beverly has her by her side when trying to get her Jean-Luc back. Great guest cast. You mentioned that Margot Rose looked familiar. There are a few places you might recognize her from. You certainly know the great character actor Richard Riehle, a delight to see him. You feel Picard’s confusion. They ran with the idea of amnesia after Batai talked Picard into the idea. Understandable that he could talk Picard into that as Batai has people skills; he is good at dealing with people. Knowing you, and knowing how you feel about consent, I anticipated certain reactions. Your face was great when you learned about the passage of time with Picard experiencing the Heaven Sent/Interstellar time. He does strike up the nice friendship with Batai. Lead to many fun times at dinner where Batai can regale Picard with plenty of tales such as his story of that very memorable weekend where he and his men arrested Felix and Oscar three separate times for three separate crimes that neither Felix nor Oscar were guilty of. Though he was nice enough to make sure that they got to their kids’ wedding on time whilst praying to God that he never saw either of them ever again. Sweet how Picard takes up the flute. Picard defending that he’s not brooding, he’s immersed in his music. For it helps him think, yet the real surprise is that he enjoys it so much. It’s like they’re holding a mirror to my soul. One odd plus would be the time to learn how to play well. I could try taking up the euphonium again. On the other hand, as my brother notes about himself as well, lips are practically amber at this point, so it might not go so well. You KNOW that I snapped a little bit when Eline made mention of Picard, in all the stories he’s told, never mentions anyone who loves him as she does. Specifically, I snapped, “Uh, excuse me, madame, such a woman exists!! Her name happens to be Beverly!!!” Which now perfectly complements the perfect expression you had, followed by your own retort, “Ok, all right, well, Beverly might disagree. *fierce as fuck finger snap* Ok?” Love that. The tear for Geordi would make up for last episode, true, great touch, Jess. We both had similar reactions about Picard building the nursery, rather than the porch. Probably for the best that Picard didn’t build the porch as he’d build the whole damn thing by himself. I mean, the Roberts boy would carry some wood for him, but that’s all. And it’d demonstrate that old Jean-Luc is the worst damn carpenter; I doubt there’d be a straight angle on the whole goddamn porch.

Thomas Corp

We similarly react when seeing Picard has a daughter and son. The son named after Batai who died the year before. I would assume Joe Pesci arrived to make good on his threat, “You put my fucking money to sleep! You go get my money or I’ll put your fucking brain to sleep!” Seems that not even the great Jean-Luc Picard could stop Nicky Santoro, which... DOES track. Great structure of this of getting bits and pieces of the experience; very sweet and heartwarming moments in which the heartwarming parts are felt, albeit the unsettling feeling permeates and lingers. And yes, there is humor in comparing elderly Picard here to Patrick today who turns eighty-six in July. I felt it when Picard says about the regret of filling his daughter’s head with science rather than less serious things, and his daughter quickly calls out how he doesn’t mean that, and he concedes that he doesn’t whilst expressing sadness of burdening his children with that which they can’t change. At least Picard’s daughter gets into science; my mom would LOVE that. If by some miracle, God decides that kids are in the cards for me, it’ll be interesting when the day comes that they start expressing interest in the villains as I did when I was a boy. I’d just channel Hal, and say, “...Son/Daughter, you know once you start, there’s no turning back?” Batai grows up to be played by Patrick’s son, Daniel. Sweet scene of the son wanting to leave school to focus on music. Picard tried to put his foot down by saying, “Well, music is great. I love music. But he should finish what he started.” before acquiescing to his son’s wish. Gets really sad when Eline dies, and that’s where the cruelty that you talk about is there. Get more of that in a second. It’s also there when Picard learns that those in charge of the planet know about the planet’s doom. Makes him saddened for his grandson. It is a very sad constant in life: As has been said, “What is given may be taken away at any time. We must never let our guard down. Never take for granted that our children’s hearts beat, that they draw breath, that they walk and speak and smile, argue, play. Never forget for a moment that they may be gone.” In this case, the planet would die before the grandson could ever really live. Then comes the time for the reveal. The people of the planet finally come clean as they revise their statements. (Read, they wish to change their bullshit story.) Reasonable theory of yours. As it is, the dead planet wished to save at least something of themselves via memory, and Picard ended up carrying that burden. You now have the hot take of this being rather cruel. Said hot take has been growing in popularity in recent years, as I understand it. The episode is still loved, be clear on that. With greater awareness of certain things, yeah, fans come away thinking that this feels like Twilight Zone. I know that I would be rather horrified by being sucked into this sort of thing. And you speak well of how Picard lives those forty years of being someone entirely else and then gets snapped back into his life where only twenty-five minutes have passed. What do you suppose something like that does to a man? I do concede some fans’ thoughts that the people of the planet are desperate/they don’t exactly have plentiful options. I note too that maybe they didn’t consider the horror of the mental and emotional anguish that this would do to someone/didn’t have time to really think that one through. One part that it got me angrier and sadder than it did when I saw this years ago was when Eline died, and Patrick sells Picard’s grief. Brought to mind when my grandma (strictly speaking step-grandma, but she was my grandma) died soon to be eight years ago. That just killed my grandpa. He didn’t die until about three and a half years after that, but her death killed him. My heart sort of projected that here, and it really is horrifying and cruel putting a man through that as they did with Picard. Not to mention giving him children and grandchildren as they did. Again, maybe the people on the planet, this was the only option they had. And you and I are both very sympathetic to the idea of the planet getting to live again via memory. That part is very powerful and beautiful. The issue is that the manner in which they do that is incredibly violating, and as we’re saying, feels quite cruel. Perhaps we’re deemed to be too harsh, and again, this is a beloved episode; it’d make top twenty for me. A case where you can love something whilst freely acknowledging how fucked up it is. Picard has the long recovery ahead. When the door opened at the end, I hoped it was Beverly, or her and Deanna both. (No offense, Riker.) That last shot, Picard walking about his quarters, the talk with Riker, followed by his playing the flute telling us that he remembers everything that happened, Patrick really should have gotten some major awards just for that. Just everything about the reaction, and espccially the words used, all of it was perfect, and greatly appreciated, Jess, thank you.

DoomGuy54321

Meh, the penultimate episodes are usually quite mid. I'm sure this one will be no different. ;)

Jenny Chalek

Interesting that you thought of it as cruel. I've always thought of it as an amazing gift that Picard got. It subtly affects his whole being, adding precious and loving memories, if also grief, but that's just life. Considering Picard has always been an adventurer, I imagine he integrates it into himself by seeing it as another space adventure.

Vanessa J McNamara

My opinion is that this episode is the definition of the Star Trek mission, to seek out new lives and new civilisations. What a gift he was given, imo. That doesn’t mean I don’t value your analysis, Jess, as always

Geordie Joe

The actor playing Picard/Kamin's son is Daniel Stewart, Patrick Stewart's son in real life.