Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Star Trek TNG 6×05 Full Reaction

Full Reaction You are now able to stream the full reaction directly from this website. Alternatively, you can download it to your computer using the button underneath the video player. You must provide your own footage to watch alongside the full reactions.

Comments

Thomas Corp

Never fails: you sit down for Next Gen, and there’s a knock at the door. Did catch the cut, but it sounds like the audio lined up well, so it’s cool, Jess, no worries. Start by addressing the solving of the mystery as to where you knew the one lady from: You said Rat Race, which made me say, “...Ah.” I’ve never seen that film. Seen and quite like the original film It’s a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World. Never seen Rat Race, sorry to say. ...Probably about Kathy Bates as Squirrel Lady being pure cinema, though. Give ya that one. Now onto the rather interesting and quite creepy episode. Your description of “fucking terrifying” sounds about right. Says something when it unsettles as it does as you enjoy watching scary shit. And it takes a lot to scare me; I love the sensation. So, I get the way you describe that love of watching scary shit, and I understand the significance of this getting under the skin. First, we start with poetry night. If I’m being honest, Data’s poetry is actually quite good, and nice to hear you say that you felt that it wasn’t half bad. Geordi does offer the genuine compliment of the wordplay is clever, which I heard said wordplay, and complimented, “That’s pretty damn good, actually.” You expressed love for it as well, which is great. Everyone else in the crew struggles. I fail to see why as Data’s poetry is nowhere near as bad as Vogon poetry, which, as we know, is the third worst poetry in the universe. The second worst is that of the Azgoths of Khria, especially their poet master, Grunthos the Flatulent’s poem Ode to a Small Lump of Green Putty I Found in My Armpit One Midsummer Morning. All of which pales to the worst poetry in the universe, being, of course, by Paula Nancy Millstone Jennings of 37 Wasp Villas, Greenbridge, Essex. We agree on being obsessed with Ode to Spot, Jess; I wanted to hear the whole thing. Sweet of Geordi to offer constructive criticism, though. Alarm bells do get set off with something going on when Riker’s in the perpetual state of exhaustion. Yes, they do a good job of stretching out the mystery. Riker is just wanting help and solutions. Smart move to set up the Geordi alarm clock, as you put it. Dad and I had a similar system years ago to help get used to the earlier shifts at work. Love how you chimed in on the sleep aid talk. You mention about how what you do before bed affects sleep. Yes and no, I suppose, though I can’t really talk. I once had three cups of coffee past midnight, and slept like a baby, so I can’t offer much in the way of sleep aids. ...I find drinking helps, more for the muscle relaxant. The Freudian nightmare of my brain, on the other hand, no idea how to help that have nicer sleeping time. Now, whilst we’re on the subject, can we talk about the adorable romantic subtext of Picard sharing with Beverly his dear Aunt Adele’s patented sleep remedy? Can’t really add much to the hair care business as that’s mostly all gone. Do need to keep the beard shampooed and combed though. And I agree with you on things you don’t want to hear your barber say when you pay a visit. Gets stranger still when even Data loses time. Adore that he doesn’t blink when Geordi points out the discrepancy, and then he checks the logs, and is very nonplussed. Both of us are proud of Riker, and the others for going to talk to Deanna when shit gets weird. Love Deanna really getting concerned when Riker reports his reaction to the console as he’s the third person to report something like that, hence it’s enemy action. And I get the logic. The first crew member tells her what’s going on, weird though it is; it sounds like an isolated incident. The second crew member goes through the same thing, strange coincidence. Riker talks, and now she knows some shit is afoot. I got really into the group brainstorming/comparing notes in reconstructing what they remembered. It gets more and more concerning. I should think so as the table/chair thing looks like a Goldfinger meets Marathon Man setup. Which all looks and sounds better than the overarching plotline of the second half of season ten of American Horror Story. Christ, that was some of the worst shit of television that I’ve ever seen in my life. The clicking noises unsettle the crew, which makes sense as that’s a shared trait with the crew: They don’t like hearing noises, especially when there ain’t supposed to be any. Figured it’d unnerve you a mite as well. You likened it to the Xenomorphs. Got some Predator vibes myself, but both sound about right. Beverly makes you the captain of the terrified boat, as you describe it, when she discovers that the aliens severed Riker’s arm and reattached it. That got the rather glorious scream from you, and me, it made me dryly quip if I were in Riker’s shoes, “Didn’t even buy me a drink.” They brainstorm and come up with the plan to stop all this nightmarish madness. Love again, the faith, trust, and confidence that Picard has. Namely, he asks Beverly if she can come up with something to keep Riker conscious when being taken the next time. Beverly notes theoretically yes, but it could prove risky. Riker says that he’ll accept the risk. Picard assesses that’s good enough for him, and he gives the “Make it so.” green light. Riker got the damn thing done with saving himself and his fellow crewmember. Geordi surmises his modified signal is to blame, so he makes adjustments and advises the warning be given. Love how you reacted to Data suggesting that perhaps these aliens were simply curious. I love Jonathan selling it how Riker is very firmly rejecting that theory. All in all, creepy as SHIT episode, that you provided a very terrific reaction to, Jess, thank you.

Ryan

I saw Rat Race when it came out, and at a time when It's a Mad Mad Mad Mad World was already my favorite movie, I loved the hell out of it. And I'm now terrified of going back and having to say every 30 seconds "Wow, that's actually pretty racist." But I'll always have Rowan Atkinson's delivery of "I make a joke to help you forget how screwed you are." After the all time great last week, it was pretty inevitable that this one would be more 3.6 roentgen, not great, not terrible. But leaning fully into a horror story and actually letting us discover everything along with the characters makes for a very compelling first watch as you struggle to comprehend what all this stuff can have to do with each other (unless you were watching at the time and saw the ads that spoiled everything, which the writer was very upset about). Most of all, the discovery that Riker's arm has been removed and reattached gets me every time. I just wish they could have come up with some more unpredictable way to up the stakes rather than "This is happening to a bunch of main cast members plus Ensign Ricky, where could this be going?" Trauma specialists really hate the episode, because you NEVER interview survivors in a big group like this, which will cause them to both try to make their stories match up and try to one-up each other on who went through the worst. It's all in the name of just having a single episode's length to cram everything into, which I've also always suspected is behind that weird bit in the otherwise very effective scene of recreating the operating device, where the computer suddenly gets it exactly right just from being asked to change to metal. It's not quite creating a sentient Moriarty just from a single bad word choice, but the same spirit. And then no one on the show was happy with how the climax turned out, where after all that buildup it turns out these aliens are just...fish monks. Who the crew doesn't even get to fight, since this was meant to be setting up a whole new recurring villain which was totally dropped because everyone agreed they couldn't possibly be as effective as something like the Borg. And then Picard outright says everyone made it through okay, despite the one poor bastard who died from all his blood becoming solid. I know you love Shakespeare, but you don't have to completely copy that "no others of note" died at Agincourt. But the upside to building up a stable of great characters like this is even an episode that's overall not a winner can have some killer moments with them, and that's where Data's poetry comes in. I've talked plenty about what an autistic icon he is, and while my own writing classes in school never turned out things quite like this, I can definitely relate, and I even find it very moving that after so much rote literalism, both poems we hear end with a much more personal note which you can easily imagine a good enough writer doing deliberately. I'm actually reminded quite a bit of a childhood favorite, DH Lawrence's Whales Weep Not, which manages to just name a bunch of different whales for the most part but still make his adoration of them come through (as you might imagine, I loved seeing the opening lines pop up in The Voyage Home). I much appreciate your support of them. Not exactly what I was hoping for while having to follow up my last two movies by seeing the objective greatest actress who ever lived debasing herself in a choppy and confusing biopic where she just hams her way through and is nowhere near as good as Gillian Anderson, but there's enough good stuff here that I don't regret it, and seeing what you made of the creepier bits helped it go down a lot better.

WastedPo

I know it's part of the B-plot that the crew are required to think that Data's poetry is bad, but I unironically think it's good. Not all poetry has to be some deep thing meant to rip your guts out. Data's poetry is witty and clever, and sometimes that's all poetry needs to be. (I would also argue that the first poem which ended with the narrator and someone else just watching something in silence is legitimately poignant.)