Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Star Trek TNG 6×07 Full Reaction

Full Reaction You are now able to stream the full reaction directly from this website. Alternatively, you can download it to your computer using the button underneath the video player. You must provide your own footage to watch alongside the full reactions. Download Full Reaction (3.3 GB)

Comments

Thomas Corp

Thought I wouldn’t be getting to this until later today as there’s a family party I’m going to. But the timeline of plans changed ever so slightly, departure time-wise, so I get this in earlier than I anticipated. Last week, there was the terrible weather, so I get the dangerous game being played. I could hear the rumbly tumblys, quite ominous. Fun episode to watch. An episode that’s either liked or loathed, depending on who you ask, though I imagine that there’s at least some middle ground. Ron Moore HATES it. Me, I quite like it, quoting Picard’s line about bowing to the absurd. Great how you followed that advice and just had a good time with it as I knew that you would. This is in a sweet spot for you, as you put it: Fun, yet with some good dramatic themes. Reminds me of one big reason why Déjà Q is my favorite episode of the show. Did not think that I’d have as much to say about it as I do. Makes sense that you vaguely recall the images of this episode. Saw this one a fair amount years ago. We have one hell of a squad this week. Great words that you had about the unique dynamic. Guinan gives Picard shit for spending the entire time in the cave. Made me snap, “What’s wrong with that!?” Seriously, what is so awful about that?! Picard was enjoying himself! Let the man indulge in his autistic hyperfixations! For fuck’s sake!! “We all relax in different ways.” Like you said. Likewise, the heart goes out to Ro when she tries to downplay her interest in botany. Michelle did very good work of you heard her enthusiasm, which she then tries to play off as no big deal. Appreciate your stance of encouragement, vis-à-vis leisure activities. Fun moment when you briefly worry about the loss of a crew, but it turns out that they are now kids. Loved the look on your face there. I relate to Picard getting thrown by his voice. Gets a laugh at how your takeaway is that Picard has hair. Lucky bastard. Wonderful when Picard does have the nice moment of indulging in the small joy of running his hand through his hair again. That would be the jarring yet nice thing of having hair on your head again. In my case, the beardless face, plus no longer having every last inch of me covered with hair as Gaston would say would feel odd in addition to being thrown by having your hair back. All the cast for the younger characters are all so excellent. They do quickly address the potential dangers of Picard remaining in command if the condition worsens. Beverly was the only one who could have gotten him to stand down as she did. They wanted to kill me with the beyond sweet scene that Beverly had with Picard. Adore everything about the writing there, and your own reaction and assessment was wonderful. Appreciate how you champion that Beverly is right as she practically always is. Later, Deanna has the very lovely scene of encouraging Picard to potentially take advantage of the opportunity. She is jumping the gun just a smidge, as you observed, granted. You and me both of definitely placing if overthinking was an Olympic sport. Deanna does impart the nice sentiment: the chance to have a second childhood. The idea isn’t bad. Except for the fact that people are gone. A lot of people. Some of them being gone before I turned twelve. On top of how by the time that I was twelve, my parents had divorced; the year following, Dad had the injury that led me to be essentially a primary caregiver. So, I get Ro’s sentiment of that period of time is not the warmest and fuzziest in several respects. Though as Guinan notes, there were still good times that one would be agreeable to reliving. The voice in my head also observes that reliving childhood in a world that has greater autism awareness, plus my own better understanding than thirty years ago wouldn’t be too bad, made me reply, “That’s true.” Figured you’d greatly invest in the Ro and Guinan dynamic. Great it is how you largely side with both of them in equal measure. Their friendship is sweet. Guinan’s not ENTIRELY incorrect about the quiet ones. You mentioned overall that you landed more on the Ro side of it. Kind of figured that one. As mentioned, I’d be somewhere between how Picard and Ro handled this. Just great to hear your perspectives on this, Jess. As you quickly clocked, Keiko has the hardest time of it, great how you said, “I feel ya.” to O’Brien. You feel Keiko’s fear of potentially losing the family life that she has. And you don’t begrudge O’Brien’s reluctance about the fear of marital intimacy, and wise of you to stop trying to describe it further. Love how they avoid the discomfort by largely addressing it head on, because it did needed to be addressed, as you described it. Keiko keeps going about things, no problem. Yet O’Brien has to tactfully point out, “When I said, “No problem.”, what I meant was, “No. Problem.”, right after Colm perfectly sells O’Brien’s dilemma via the physical acting. Which makes you both laugh and cringe as you concede that you can’t offer the poor couple a good solution. Nor were you prepared to really dive into the dilemma. Stings for both of us when Molly doesn’t recognize her mom. O’Brien is such a duine uasal with how he handles that, and it does warm the heart seeing him be such a good dad.

Thomas Corp

Then the Ferengi fuckery begins, making you note, “Boy, that escalated quickly.” You can tell that the Ferengi plotline was thrown in to pad the episode out as of course the brilliance of Beverly and Geordi figured out the solution to the technobabble fountain of youth fast. (Because of course they fucking did.) Shame as the topics they were diving into could have sustained a full episode. As it is, the Ferengi fuckery is hilarious, and we get the always great Tracey Walter again, here playing Berik, so I don’t mind. Couldn’t tell if Berik was herding the crew to the transporter, but when Geordi’s part of the group, you do remind Berik of the Sesskasays playbook, vis-à-vis anti-Geordi behavior, by warning, “Hold it! Jess kind of likes this one, Bob. Leave him be.” Lurin proves a rather despicable Ferengi, and I rather enjoyed that. Lurin’s got a point about kids being on the ship. Fantastically badass when our squad teams up with Alexander and the other children to get shit done. “Rally the kids!”, as you delightfully put it. Sweet concern that you had for Alexander’s toy. One concern I’d have in Picard, Ro, Guinan, and Keiko’s place is minding my language. Can just see myself in Picard’s shoes, sounding like Joe Pesci and not remembering all the kids nearby. The day gets saved and then before the week is out, you have angry parents knocking on the door to yell at you because their kid came home and asked, “What’s a fuckass?”. Keiko and Picard have the sweet moment of the moment of concern for Molly. Picard does suffer the small embarrassment of throwing the tantrum to get in touch with Riker. I so love everything about that scene. It leaves us with the wonderful mental image of Sir Patrick Stewart, esteemed Shakespearean thespian, acting out this tantrum, and you cackle every time. Of course, Jess, you got such a good laugh out of that part. You feel for Berik, and advise him, “Bob, just let the boy see his old man.” Love Riker’s silent, “What th- ...Ooooh, right.” realization of Picard’s game. The two men do great work in the surreptitious planning. They almost slip with the “Number One” bit, though they recover fast, and it helps that Berik appreciates the sentiment of “Number one guy.” I cackle at the looks that both Picard and Riker have, with Riker practically screaming, “We are never fucking talking about this again, Captain.”, and Picard dryly responding, “No arguments there, Number One.” I knew that we’d somewhat match in reactions to those scenes. Love how it’s never fully clarified if Riker was spouting technobabble bullshit to stall, or if the computer systems are that pedantic and complex. Or both. Slick either way. The kids worked in fucking shit up. If I were them, I’d definitely troll the Ferengis by yelling at one point, “Tag! You’re it!”, just as they did. Beverly, Geordi, and O’Brien start to work on getting the squad back to normal. Picard tests it first, and they are successful. And you see poor Picard silently mourning the loss of his hair as he is bald again. Oh, I feel your pain, Jean-Luc. And we end on the one very sweet scene of Ro taking just a little bit more time to experience the simple pleasures of childhood, and she and Guinan warm all our hearts. Your words afterward were sublime, Jess. Lovely reaction to see before I’m off to the family party, thank you.

Geordie Joe

A goofy light-hearted Star Trek episode to help take your mind off things. Just what the doctor ordered.

Ryan

Not surprising you already saw an image from this one, as it's one of the most polarizing episodes of the whole show. I have to be one of the dull people and say I've never had strong feelings about it, though the first half is way better than the second so it would have been nice if they'd committed to either approach. It's also quite nice that this was an early directing job for Leonard Nimoy's son Adam, which I'm sure was a bit of a hassle having to deal with so many child actors, but he pulls it off pretty well. And I did hear a bit of the rumblies that only hands can satisfy, but you still came in clear the whole time. It's actually kind of charming how little effort is put into explaining the central concept. This is what we wanted the episode to be about, so here's an utterly random collection of characters to be on a shuttle together so they can go through a weird space thingie that will never be explained or ever mentioned again, despite being basically easy immortality. My best guess is Keiko's mother has branched out in what her fortune cookies do. Which gets us right into the better half, where this very silly idea is played surprisingly straight and dramatic, and it actually works, even while having to deal with a very unfortunate intrusion of reality. Faced with the very hard job of finding a child actor who could believably replicate Patrick's whole vibe, they had the great on paper idea of bringing back Rene Picard's actor David Tristan Birkin, except the now 15 year old had gone through a massive growth spurt that instantly kills any attempt to portray him as a physically helpless child. The best idea they had to cover it was to put him mostly next to the giants Jonathan Frakes and Michael Dorn, but they're still less than a head taller than him. But still most of their acting is pretty great, with the notable exception of Megan Parlen as Ro, who always seems like she's in a school play and learned her lines five minutes ago. Which makes it especially weird that she seems to be the only one who stuck with acting; Brikin went into photography and the other two don't even have a Wikipedia page. Even with the acting hiccup, I love that the script is willing to dig so deep into Ro's hard childhood and why she'd have such a hard time with this, and pairing her up with Guinan, the one person you can easily believe would fully embrace this, adds a ton to it. For a while they even considered using the fact that she's last seen asking to wait a bit for the reversal to reveal she decided to stay a child, which I'm very glad they didn't go with for just all kinds of reasons. Though it might have been worth it if it included her kicking the asses of all the brats using their Lilypads to mock her botany fandom. And then there's Keiko, and while I don't quite buy she doesn't seem to realize how disturbing it would be to Miles to go all Esther Coleman on him, I appreciate a lot how the rest of the scene is written. They don't know they're in a TV show and this is inevitably going to be fixed by the end of the episode, so they need to talk about this like it might be permanent and what that means for the two of them. And of course Molly's contribution is just devastating. But then we have to get to the Ferengi, since apparently with these four people turned to children the ship is totally helpless against them. The writers argued that the only alternative was asking us to believe a bunch of kids could defeat an enemy like the Romulans, to which I'd say if those are your only choices, it's a bad story idea to begin with. I'm reminded a lot of how Vincent and the Doctor was supposed to just be a pure character piece but the BBC insisted there had to be a monster to fight. I'm having enough trouble right now expecting Steve Martin with a puppy every time the camera cuts away from Lana Turner or Edward Arnold, don't expect me to give this any slack. If you're going to do a story like this, it better have something as cool as the kids all slaughtering the bad guys while November Rain plays. And with all that time used up, of course Geordi and Beverly are able to figure out the right combination of science words, definitely aided by Beverly thinking just as much as Miles "We need to fix this or I am in very serious and weird trouble." Nice to see you got as much out of this as you did, and assuming you don't run out of energy for these like you warned might happen last week, pretty soon you'll be getting to a movie that has a similar very polarized reputation and I'm eager to see which side you end up on.

WastedPo

I've gained new appreciation for this episode through reactions. I remember when this aired, I thought it was too silly, but just about every reactor has been delighted with it, and I've come around to it. I will say, there is a funny continuity error that I just realized, in that you kind of have to pretend that there isn't a big ol' artificial heart in Picard's chest for this episode to work.

Joe Crammond

not related to the reaction but decided to upgrade my membership to EARLY Early Full Reactions! after nearly 3 years at a lower level, got the financial confidence to do so and i love your reactions so thought why not pay extra