Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Star Trek TNG 6×09 Full Reaction

Full Reaction You are now able to stream the full reaction directly from this website. Alternatively, you can download it to your computer using the button underneath the video player. You must provide your own footage to watch alongside the full reactions.

Comments

Josef Schiltz

Well, Jess, of course your feelings towards the Exocomps are maybe almost on par with your own feelings for K9. Maybe a little positive caninomorphism towards them was happening there. As you say, you were really routing for the Exocomps. A delightful episode and reaction.

Thomas Corp

Sorry to hear that the congestion issues have flared up as of late. Well, as you said, the tear your soul out outcome didn’t really happen here. Still an emotional roller coaster of a time, all the same. Great guest character with Dr. Farallon. Leading to Geordi and Data getting good science focus. I wouldn’t feel too bad about having a tougher time following the science of it all. Mom’s a retired science teacher, and despite strong efforts, I’m not very scientifically inclined either; the autistic hyperfixations didn’t hugely latch onto that. My brother took to it a lot more. You clocked quickly a general sense of what the episode would focus on when seeing the Exocomps. As you say, this is Star Trek. Maybe it’s not Black Mirror level, but plotlines of new technology do raise a few alarm bells. We made the similar episode comparison. Yes, Farallon felt of a similar cloth as Dr. Russell from the earlier episode. Both of them stifled by stagnation, and are very motivated by scientific progress. As I quoted Dr. Wu from Jurassic Park in response to the previous episode, the problem is that all of this is less a sprint and more a marathon. And yes, it is the old thing: High risk yields high rewards, true, but there is still valid concern as Picard is wise to exhibit. Farallon is a much more likable character than Russell. Worst you could say is that she was a little haughty about her beliefs about her work and knowing what was what. And being snippy toward Geordi, which I knew would irk you some. Geordi is sharp to pick up on the one thing, and from there, Data does the work. Smart of him to talk to Beverly about it. Beverly is on speaking terms with Data. Meaning that he presumably rescued her play. GOOD. I retract my threats of violence toward Data from last week. He goes to bat for the Exocomps. Asking Data if he has any basis for a conclusion is one particularly asinine question; you’re right about that. The test seems not to yield the fruit that Data was after initially. Great moment when Farallon gets a little snide with Data about the test, Picard is VERY quick to assure Data that he felt the time was well spent, regardless of outcome. Patrick sells his line, just as Brent sells Data’s genuine gratitude for Picard’s assurance. He stuck with it and found the evidence that the Exocomps are alive. Gets tense when the drama kicks in. Picard again being very much like a Vulcan when you see him disassociate to make the sacrifice play. I kind of wanted a little more focus on Picard and Geordi being very cool customers working together. Love your own praise of the two fine gentlemen, being very much an epitome of cool under fire. “Trolley problem” is the term you were thinking of. No worries on the potentially horrible thing to say about Geordi’s life being of higher value with these proverbial train tracks. Anticipated you’d say something like that as you’ve had the singular focus once or twice. It’s cool. Data refused to stand by, and he made the smart call. Quite something when Riker yells. Jonathan and Brent do very good work there. Been loving, by the way, their podcast that I really need to sit down and listen to more of that. Sweet of Data to offer his life in sacrifice. Riker shows he’s damn good at his job by listening to Data’s concerns and comes up with the satisfactory solution that Data accepts. Love the praise you gave to Riker’s captaining. The Exocomps do save the day. Unfortunately, not all the Exocomps live as one of them had to stay behind to ensure the survival of everyone else. Prioritized the needs of the many, very Kobayashi Maru. And it’s great how Farallon takes in all that happened, and commits to taking it all to heart. Ending on the great moment when Data tells Picard how it’s the continuation of Measure of a Man. Picard went to bat for Data, and Data knew he had to do the same for the Exocomps. As Picard says, it’s very human, and your reaction to that was sweet. Also sweet was your nice little smile that you had upon learning that Beverly was training with Worf, learning how to properly wield a bat’leth. She’s the ship’s doctor, likely never sees much in the way of actual combat, yet of her own volition; she’s taking the initiative to train herself how to properly wield bladed weapons. Unlike, say, Rhaenyra Targaryen? Hmm. Neat little tidbit to learn. One other big highlight was the opening scene. Said opening scene being there for padding as the script ran short. But then again, when it has fun character moments, and it results in one iconic Geordi La Forge meme, I seriously doubt that anyone is really complaining. Much, anyway. Nice to be reminded of exactly what Geordi’s point of concurrence was in response to. And I do agree with Riker; I for one happen to like Geordi’s beard. I KNEW you would say so as well. This scene does give us the first real strike against Beverly when she expresses the negative, disparaging remarks about beards, which my love for her is that great, so I will let this slide. Once. As Riker said, the beard is an ancient and proud tradition. Dad almost always sported one. It’s been pointed out that it feels mean in Worf’s case as the beards are a cultural thing, which he even points out. Analogous to real world cultures with the same thing, which I concede that I didn’t think about that part when I watched; I was just more distracted by the anger over Beverly’s bilious bullshit about the beards. By the same token, it’s also observed that Beverly is espousing the execrable beard slander over cards and is more playfully teasing rather than being culturally insensitive, so it’s not quite as bad as it could come across. All the same, I anticipated you would have some commentary sticking up for the beards, appreciate that, Jess. Love how you were not about the bet. I also would adamantly refuse her bet as shaving hurts like fucking hell; like taking sandpaper with nails and running it across the face. Though the few times I’ve felt a straight razor did feel surprisingly pleasant. All the defense of the beards had me vigorously concurring with the men. Love how they bolt, as would I, when Picard’s order comes in. Saved by the bell. And yes, Beverly could rock any look. You are correct on that one. A strong reaction for this holiday. Loved hearing what you had to say about it. I will ENJOY hearing what you have to say about the next one. Meantime, thank you for the holiday reaction, Jess.

Ryan

A big favorite of mine, going back to the original dream of this franchise as a vehicle for big ideas. The Exocomps are a beautiful design, with just enough movement to let you read life into them despite the mostly rigid structure, and the floating effect has held up astoundingly well, still being 100% convincing. And of course this beautiful script bolstered by Jonathan Frakes' direction gets the full potential out of them, making us feel Data's journey however skeptical we might be at the start. The big guest star here is Ellen Bry, who you've seen as Keri Russell's mother in Mission Impossible 3, though she's best known for a very badly aged role in St. Elsewhere where all her friends instantly hate her after she kills a rapist. She gets quite a range of emotions to play here, starting from when she predictably gets very into talking to Data, and on first watch my suspicion was she'd quickly say something to him like a man whose work is his whole life is only half a man, and half his life should be a woman. But that quickly moves on to the real reason we're here, and on rewatches it's pretty neat to see how the episode plays with your expectations that this will just be a typical evil robot story before catching you off guard with how deep it actually is. Some people come to this show for the accidents and the fires, but this one's for the people who it puts something in their lives that they can't put there themselves. It's just a good thing the Exocomps are given written commands only; I'd hate to see what happens if they mixed up the words trader and traitor. Always fun to see the show go to the trouble of giving us a glimpse of these characters' lives outside what's necessary for the story, and Worf giving Beverly fighting lessons is a delightful surprise. Just keep in mind that teachers get fallen in love with, it's an occupational hazard (it would make more sense than Worf and Deanna anyway, just think how ridiculous that would be). It's a bit odd that her talk with Data doesn't bring up his own trial over this same subject, especially since he'll bring it up later with Picard, but it still gets to an interesting area over how many typical definitions for life he still doesn't meet. So his being their advocate will be like taming two birds. It just takes approaching the issue from a different angle: You know your father, but do you know your mother's husband? Farallon is easy to turn against for her attitude when the theory is brought up, but I've always figured a big part of it is the unspoken implication that if the Exocomps really are alive, she's essentially murdered a bunch of newborns with all the times she's reset them when they have too many pathways. Guilt cries out for punishment as a specific cure to a feverish conscience. But Data still has to go ahead with it, because he's seen things he knows are wrong, and how can he go back to school and keep his mind on things that are just in books, and not people living? And I love so much how his being distracted talking to Beverly is what allows for his breakthrough, such a beautiful and natural converging of character dynamics to move the story forward. The Exocomp didn't leave the tube because of the yelling, it left because of the silence. After all that, it would take quite an extreme situation for us to believe Data would be on his own in continuing to plead his case, and you can kind of feel the script bending over backwards to put Picard and Geordi in imminent danger, but it still works as you feel for everyone involved and see how they're all just trying to do the right thing here. Until finally Data's forced to put his foot down and shout "No! I will never ever turn my back on people who need me!" And of course Jonathan Frakes would direct himself coming up with the perfect answer; I know, he didn't write it, it's just a hilarious coincidence. The Exocomps demonstrate the capacity for self-sacrifice, which finally gets Farallon to see the truth about them. And it must piss Noonien Soong off so much that after all his decades of work creating artificial life, this woman does it by accident. You can only say, how does a girl like you get to be a girl like you? The Exocomps were notoriously forgotten about for decades after this episode, but in my single favorite thing about Lower Decks, it confirmed they were eventually recognized as a sentient species by the Federation, and some of them even join Starfleet, aided by upgrading themselves to be able to talk. And it also gives the ultimate proof of their sentience, that some of them are total assholes. There was also a cameo by one in Starfleet Academy, proving they survived the Burn and are still around in the 30th century. So there's your assignment, fanfic writers, don't let me down. I love this episode so much, and it was marvelous seeing you get so much out of it too.