Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content


Files

Previews only

Doctor Who 9x10 Full Reaction!! - Google Drive

Comments

Geordie Joe

"The Doctor is no longer here, you are stuck with me" - that line still sends a shiver down the spin

Vincent van Heukelum

While I find it a very good episode, I do think the BBC shouldn't have made Clara extra reckless in the last few episodes, I feel they wanted to make her death more her own fault and less of a unfortunate result of the trap. And she deserved more after all that time where she was making sure he didn't get reckless.

YungAtHart

Whether you liked Clara as a companion or not, she owned up to her actions and accepted the responsibility and consequences without blaming anyone else. She continued her legacy of saving the Doctor to the best of her ability even unto death, which she met with as much dignity and grace as the situation allowed. If for nothing else, she deserves respect for that.

Stephen Ray

Yes, that is Shuri. Great reaction. I had wondered whether you would be more emotional over the old man than Clara. I'm glad you can appreciate the relationship Clara and 12 had. She is my favourite companion.

Bug Duck Energy

First time rewatching Face the Raven since it aired, and perhaps it was the company of Jess, but i enjoyed it much more than the first time. There are great smaller stories, but i remember being quite disinterested in this one. Rigsy is a pretty meh character to return and Me never really lived up to my hopes for her. But the Diagon Alley of DW is a pretty neat idea, the symbolism of the raven is used to great effect and whatever people think of the next two episodes, Face the Raven is a great, GREAT setup. Also, i totally missed the post credit scene the first time. And so, we say good bye to one of the most divisive companions of modern Who. Clara didn't really click with me until season 8, and to me it's clear she upped her acting when Peter became the Doctor. They have the chemistry of Karen and Matt but a different energy. I grew to really, really like her and i'm happy Face the Raven gave her and the Doctor a great farewell scene. Yes, next week is going to be very interesting indeed. General audiences: What? Fans of the show: OMGWTFCOPTER

Will

I think I loved Clara ever since she went off the deep end after losing Danny. That was obviously a really terrible thing she did (or tried to do), but I could relate to her being willing to tear the world apart to try to save somebody she loved.

Dave Ford

Yes, I'm currently being told off on Twitter for the fact that next week's episode got a relatively poor response from viewers when it aired - like it's my fault!

Dr Matt

“I feel like we might get some really great acting out of Peter in the next couple of episodes”. Oh boy.

Ana Decaprio

I really like your point about her going full circle - from expressing her fear of death to facing death bravely. I also like your thoughts about 12 and Clara's relationship - how it's come a long way. Seeing these two people who care so much about each other separate (even if I don't like Clara) breaks my heart. Cuz it's not about me. It's about them. 2 people are separating; and that's always heartbreaking to me. Another thing I got out of it was: Clara tried to be the Doctor, but she isn't the Doctor. And that will be the end of her.

Stephen Ray

Every regeneration is a reminder that being the Doctor can be fatal to the Doctor, too. Maybe she missed that lesson because 11 died of old age.

Steven Cooper

Another great reaction to a pivotal episode. I loved the ambition of this story -- it aims to make Clara's end a true tragedy in the literary sense, meaning that end must come about as a direct consequence of a flaw in her character, namely the overconfidence and recklessness that has been growing during her time with the Doctor. There are a few rough edges in the scripting: it's a bit too obvious that the long sequence with the man being executed for theft is there solely as exposition, to make sure we understand the raven's nature and power. (He's not even given a name, being credited only as "Chronolock Guy", so the attempted pathos at his fate falls rather flat.) More importantly, the plotting at the end is a little too arbitrary in the way the story contrives to ensure that Clara has no way out. For rather vague reasons, she can't now pass the death-mark to someone else even if they volunteer, and neither can Ashildr remove it now that its original victim no longer has it, since the change in the raven's contract has somehow "cut [her] out of the deal." As seen in previous companion departure stories like "The Angels Take Manhattan", the Doctor is such a powerful and capable character that the show sometimes strains to find a believable way to permanently separate a companion from him. But if we go along with the story's contention that there is no other possible outcome, then Capaldi and Coleman shine in that amazing climactic scene. Part of the reason the ending is so powerful is Murray Gold's music -- I think his work on these final season 9 episodes must rank at or near the top of his entire ten seasons' worth of music for the show. Apart from obvious (but beautifully done) touches like the wistful melody of Clara's theme making a couple of telling appearances in a quiet rendition for piano, I loved his treatment of the inexorable slow march that accompanies Clara's final moments and soars to a climax as the raven strikes her (mercifully covering her dying scream). Ingeniously, this theme had been introduced earlier in the scene (at the point where she finally accepts her fate and begins looking beyond her imminent demise, ordering the Doctor not to take revenge) in a subdued, half-speed version, thereby giving the whole long sequence a musical progression alongside the dramatic one. Also very fine is the last poignant harmonic change, as the music resolves to a moment of quiet peace over the final shot looking down at her body lying on the ground.

Stephen Ray

Once I found out the Season 9 soundtrack had finally been released, I couldn't enter my credit card information fast enough. It was so good!

Stephen Ray

My question is did someone edit out the title of the episode? I don't know how she's getting her episodes, but I remember that Mark edited The Day of the Doctor credits, and I know the title had been spoiled. If so, thank you. If not, lucky coincidence.