Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content


Files

Previews only

Doctor Who 9x12 Full Reaction! - Google Drive

Comments

Dave Ford

Took the afternoon off work! And this lands 2 mins before I need to get on the bus home. Nooooo :-)

Einar Sigurðsson

I love this episode, and the feels are just too much

Dave Ford

Fantastic! Okay - to answer your question - I think it's safe to say that different bits of my brain have different feelings about this episode - I can fully understand those who think that Moffat as devalued the emotional punch of Face the Raven by this trick of inserting time just before she dies - I get that - though I'm less of a fan of the idea that Moff doesn't like death and won't kill companions off - and even if that is true, so what? On the other hand - we've got show runner sticking two fingers up to RTD and what he did to Donna - which is wonderful. Not only that, but the companion has survived the finale in a way that is definitively not the victim. I personally feel this is important and when this happened, this literally got was a fist in the air moment. I'm more conflicted about the Red Herring that is the Hybrid. I suspect that many fans were disappointed to find that that (and, frankly, the who return to Gallifrey) was nothing more than a big fat McGuffin and the real plot of this episode was about rescuing Clara. Personally, I'm impressed that it was done, but also appreciative that it's a bait and switch - especially coming straight in from that final scene of Heaven Sent. And, then, there's also the bit of my hind-brain that excited about the two attractive young immortals flying off together to have sexy adventures in Space and Time together. Big Finish will probably get around to telling those stories one day after Massie William's schedule free's up a bit, no doubt. Over all - and almost entirely because the Doctor this time didn't get to violate his companion - I really enjoyed it.

Bug Duck Energy

Once again, first time rewatching since it aired, and i think that my views on this episode might have flipped slightly, and i have a newfound appreciation of it. There is almost no story here, whatsoever. Practically the whole episode is a character piece. My guess is that is why it gets so much flak. If Clara is a character you have no investment in at all, or you don't like an evolving narrative about the Doctor, or you must have a "proper" story, this must be an awful watch. But as a Doctor/Clara character piece, for me it succeeds brilliantly. Face the Raven had a lovely farewell, but this episode did something else. It cast my mind back through all of Clara's time with the Doctor and beyond! And by doing that it got me more emotional. Capaldi mentioning Amy and Rory is such precious moment.

Bug Duck Energy

I'm sure there is a fanfic somewhere out there where Clara and Me join up with Jenny for the sexiest adventure ever. Go on then, Big Finish.

Sovotchka

Thank you for this :). I love this episode, but I can understand people who dislike it, especially people who already don't enjoy Clara. To me, this story and 12 & Clara overall feel very messy, very real. A lot of really bad decisions, or good intentions gone wrong, and that makes it very relatable to me. Iike how both show a certain recklessness that hurts them (and I do think Clara will hurt much more when she eventually has to go back), and both have to face thr consequences for their actions. I also enjoy (sadistically) seeing the doctor be wrong about something important, and I like it when the rage comes out, he feels so ancient then (like Ten in Family of Bllod or your Honey in The Beast Below). I will say that even though I love Clara, and I really love this episode, I would not want to learn any stories about Clara's "happy adventures" in the Tardis, I feel that would not be right. And no matter what anyone thinks about the story, Rachel Talalay's directing in both this and Heaven Sent is so great; there are so many beautiful shots <3.

Will

Clara was my favourite, and Face The Raven traumatized me for *two whole weeks*, which is perhaps long enough. ;) I still find Clara's ending to still be really sad though. Her 'real life' is over. She's never going to see her family again (I keep thinking of her poor grandmother), do her job again, or any normal stuff. She's got a little 'wiggle room', but that damn raven is still waiting for her, and who knows how long that could really last, with the laws of time pulling her back to face her destiny? She's still really only got one heartbeat left.

Luke

Thanks for the reaction as always Jess :) This is honestly one of my favorite episodes of Who. Twelve and Clara's relationship is so special to me. I also love how Clara's arc of 'becoming' the doctor in a sense (Mummy, Flatline) culminates with her getting her own TARDIS and companion , albeit briefly. Capaldi's delivery of 'I have a duty of care' destroys me xD Enjoy your break :)

Will

I agree about their relationship being beautiful in the end. I thought this episode was quite good, but I really enjoyed the Doctor/Clara emotional bits.

Ian Smith

There's really a lot that I like about this episode. I enjoy the cheeky way that the plot flashes back and forth;the fact that,for the first time in ages, there's no overblown Finale - just three people in a TARDIS discussing the importance of remembering;and the cute little reveal that all new Tardis' off the Gallefreyan production line have the same plain white interior :). Btw,I may be wrong,but I think 'never cruel or cowardly' was originally a Third Doctor saying...? Anyway,enjoy your holiday!!

Sovotchka

It's simple, that's very true. I never made that connection, but I actually prefer quiet endings :).

Paul Hayes

Quite often when I revisit episodes I didn't previously enjoy through your reactions I end up liking them a lot more than I did. Sadly that didn't happen this time, but I did enjoy at least watching your reactions to it, as always.