Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Files

Previews only

Ahsoka 1x07 Full Reaction - EA

Download Full Reaction (2.9 GB) Full Reaction You are now able to stream the full reaction directly from this website. Alternatively, you can download it to your computer using the button underneath the video player. You

Comments

Ryan

I winced so hard when you hoped this episode wouldn't have screaming. Because how can you not react that way to C-3PO making his first appearance in what I guess we can now just call the Filoni-verse? Though what I was looking forward to even more was your reaction to Xiono dissing him, and something along the lines of "You shut your whore mouth!" as Krillin would put it, which didn't disappoint. The whole scene is very obviously written around Carrie Fisher continuing to be inconsiderately unavailable, and I'm very much hoping it was designed as a bridge to actually getting a new actress for at least this period between the original and sequel trilogies. And you can't tell at all, but 3PO is actually totally CGI here, and Anthony Daniels must have been thinking more than ever "Seriously, why could this technology not have been available when I was falling over all the time in the fucking desert?" I can't believe I've never brought this up before, but Lars Mikkelson plays Stregobor in The Witcher, and in this episode the way he talks about the Jedi is especially reminiscent of that guy and elves, and it's very much a credit to his acting skill that they still come across as totally different people. After the Tenth Doctor could often get on my nerves (red hot take, I know, but I'm not ashamed at all at this point) it's a blast seeing Tennant on the receiving end of having a traveling partner who refuses to tell him the whole story and everything she's planning, and much like Daniels he's great at putting all that emotion into his voice when the immobile droid face can't help. One more thing I have to note, Shin is lucky she wasn't up against Princess Vespa, going after the hair like that.

Thomas Corp

I had suspected, Jess, you would have a sore throat following this episode. Understandable considering the opening scene, I’ll get to that in a minute. An action-packed penultimate episode for the season. There were high emotions seeing another appearance of Hayden. And I loved Ahsoka again show how she’s made peace with Anakin’s legacy, by saying, “He was a good master.” The scenes of Ezra and Sabine warm the heart, especially the great moment of them catching up. I like we get the bullet points: “Hera’s been up to this. Zeb and Kallus have been up to that. Chopper’s still Chopper keeping up with his murders and war crimes. The New Republic’s risen with Mon Mothma as Supreme Chancellor. The Galactic Empire is gone with the wind. Grand Moff Tarkin’s dead. Darth Vader’s dead. The Emperor’s dead.” (Although Sabine sounds skeptical on that last one which indicates that she must have read Dark Empire when it was first published back in ‘91 to ‘92.) “There was a fellow by the name of Moff Gideon causing trouble, but the scuttlebutt says he was killed on Mandalore, though you never know. If he is dead, that makes Grand Admiral Thrawn the last man standing, Imperial-wise.” Shame Jacen doesn’t get mentioned as I would have liked to have seen Ezra’s reaction when he learns Hera and Kanan had a kid. But then again, perhaps it works better that such a moment would be left private, reserved only for our heroes. When Ahsoka makes contact with Sabine, and you had the comment about her sticking her head out the window and giving a hearty shout, it would have been most risible, yes. The action from our heroes was great. Took a second to clock what you meant by “How very Connie”. Had a small laugh once it registered. It simultaneously warms and breaks the heart to hear your comments on Baylan. I love how you have found him fascinating, and I am again saddened that we will never see him again, at least not with Ray playing him. Ray and Ivanna sold their farewell so perfectly. I love the rematch between Baylan and Ahsoka, and how Ahsoka still can’t quite beat him. I had a laugh when you said you’d be cross with Shin if she killed Ezra and Sabine, I would be impressed by the accomplishment. I was impressed that Shin held her own rather well prior to Ahsoka arriving, and it made me laugh so hard when Shin took a little off the top of Ezra’s hair, and it infuriated you. Ezra showing off his force powers was a “Goddamn, son!” moment. Lovely to see your reaction to Ezra and Ahsoka’s reunion. Of course, a big highlight is seeing Thrawn’s excellence in action. Fantastic moment when he learns who Ahsoka’s master was, and Lars sells the moment well. Speaking of Lars, I am glad you know he’s playing Thrawn. How you see Thrawn recalls his experience working alongside both Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader, and of course he knows the truth of the two characters. And he recalls how he first learned of the favored Marg Sabl maneuver from Padmé who told him that it was created by Anakin’s padawan. Thus, he knows that for all Anakin’s other faults, he was an excellent teacher, strategery-wise, and it is lovely to see him plan everything to stall Ahsoka long enough for him to escape, and if she gets killed in the process, that will be an added bonus. Now back to the beginning of the episode. It sucks seeing Hera in the hot seat because of that Xiono fuckface. You raise the good point that some of the skepticism does make sense. On paper, the Xiono motherfucker’s got a point. And I would be more inclined to be sympathetic about that, if it wasn’t so blatantly obvious how much of a hypocrite he is. Specifically, he accuses Hera of ignoring rules to suit her own agenda when that’s exactly what he’s doing. Even when Mon Mothma tries to get him to agree that information was brought to light, and Teva chimes in about the season three finale of The Mandalorian, he blatantly ignores it. Which also means Captain Pellaeon was onto something about staying under the radar. There’s also again as Hera pointed out, he never served in the wars a day in his life, thus, she has neither time nor inclination to explain herself to a man who rises and sleeps under the blanket of freedom that she provides, and then questions the manner, in which she provides it. And I’m with her being so done with him moralizing, sitting there like a damn saint with that fucking smug smile on his stupid goddamn face. I do love the burn Hera got in towards him. You pointed out EXACTLY what I said concerning Chopper. I yelled that now I knew Xiono was that dense to leave Chopper unguarded whilst coming for his mom. Even Admiral Ozzel wouldn’t be clumsy enough to make such an error, and that man was as clumsy as he was stupid. Incidentally, I told that one to my brother who laughed and said that was being disrespectful to Admiral Ozzel, to which I laughed, and said, “It is.”

Thomas Corp

Now we come to, as you stated, “The BEST thing that’s ever happened in Star Wars history!”. Your reaction to it being something I’ve been anticipating since I saw it. The subtitles were great in that they initially said only “droid”, but I knew the voice. I knew the fucking voice, and the excitement was great, I went, “Oh, we have a dr... That’s. That’s! THAT’S!...” And we then see C-3PO, your king, our golden boy himself, once again, played by Anthony Daniels. Upon seeing him, you IMMEDIATELY were on my mind, Jess, and I could not wait until we got to this moment. Your reaction was everything I knew it would be and then some, particularly as you noted quickly that 3PO was coming to Hera’s rescue. Filoni gave you one of the best things ever. And since you opened the video discussing hoping not to scream and cry too much, combined with said perfect reaction, this tells me that the internet fucking kept their goddamn mouths shut, and I am so happy about that. I so LOVED Anthony so PERFECTLY delivering 3PO’s lines where he imparts Leia’s message, and how so thoroughly knocks Xiono down several pegs; you can actually pinpoint the moment when you see that Xiono’s balls are in his belly looking for a safe place to hide. I KNEW you would have a strong reaction when Xiono insults 3PO by calling him a “mere droid”, I was right. I got so fucking triggered myself, both my own reaction, and just on your behalf; I went on a tangent. Days later, it was still on my mind, I was stewing, “That fuckface is LUCKY Jess isn’t watching this yet! She’ll jump through the screen with her acrylics; it’ll be like Get Carter and Kill Bill, only it’s going to be Get and Kill Xiono, and then get Carter and Bill to fucking kill him too! Seeing as she’s still watching Rebels, I might just have to fill in for her, and kick his ass so hard he’ll have to unbutton his collar to shit!” As it is, predictably, Chopper took great offense, and moved and sounded like he was prepared to fuck a trench through Xiono if not for Teva holding him back. Me, I’d have quietly encouraged our truculent friend to wait, “find that guy where he lives” as you put it and have his revenge then. I’d also encourage Chopper to have a little fun by subjecting Xiono to the Melbourne method. Good on 3PO getting Hera out of the jam, and Mon Mothma clearing Hera of the charges, leaving Xiono needing to put his big boy pants on and take the hit. And it is so nice to see 3PO and Hera get a small moment which gave you such joy, Jess, it was great to see. I give so much credit to Mon Mothma too in that after it’s done, she asks the fair and reasonable question of Hera’s personal feelings notwithstanding, the probability of the return of the Heir to the Empire. God, this reaction was perfect, and it makes me even more excited to see your reaction to the finale. It will be wonderful. Until then, Jess, thank you for the wondrous reaction.

Thomas Corp

Like I said on youtube, I had a small Emperor cackle when Jess said about hoping the screaming and crying would be light. More specifically, one of the Emperor’s chuckle cackles. I am sympathetic to what Jess was saying, just like you said, there’s no other reaction Jess would have towards seeing 3PO in this. I actually said something to the effect of, “You SHUT your WHORE mouth!!” when Xiono first started objecting to 3PO testifying. The scene being a way to avoid Carrie’s tragic unavailability is something I’ve talked about with people. You mention a bridge to recasting, one of my brother’s oldest friends, though not knocking the scene, the tip-toeing around not being able to show Leia is getting to him, and he’s hoping that they will ultimately recast. I don’t know who you’d get, personally. I did hear Lars was in The Witcher. I’ve not seen it, but I caught a picture of Lars in that, and he does have a great big bushy beard, that would hide his “High ass cheekbones” as Jess is often fond of saying, which I suspect might have a hand in not recognizing him in that. Even then, I should think the voice would be a giveaway, but again, I’ve not seen the show, so I can’t judge. No worries on your opinion of Ten. I’m more annoyed by the overwhelming worship Ten receives often to the detriment of Eleven and especially Twelve, and how angry some fans get when they hear the opinions aren’t shared. At work, I’ve gotten yelled at for saying Twelve is my Doctor, and they’ve said, “How can you have the old guy as your favorite Doctor!? How is it not Ten!?!” That’s no disrespect towards David Tennant as he is excellent as Huyang, as you observed. Yes, Shin is goddamn fortunate as all hell that she wasn’t facing off against Princess Vespa after her move chopping off hair.

Ryan

What really got me about Xiono's speech was him spitting out the word "Jedi" in a tone of "Can you believe how ridiculous this is?" I feel like the fans have long since resigned ourselves to how it makes zero sense how quickly almost every single person in the galaxy forgot that the Jedi ever existed, and we'll go along with it as long as the dichotomy isn't blatantly thrown in our faces. Which is exactly what this is doing.

Saltire le Hutt

Love Hera flinging the filth back at Senator Xiono. He is what we in the UK call, a git! I kind of like him though, the actor is great at bringing across the negligence and hypocrisy that will bog down this New Republic until its too late. I love that they brought him in too for Star Wars Resistance fans, since the lead character in that series, is his son. C-3P0 showing up was a lovely moment, and they gave him a little hint of the Star Wars theme too which befits his legendary status, very nice. I love the way Mon Mothma recognises him and stands up in respect too - wonderful touch. When I first saw this, I immediately thought you'd be screaming to the high heavens Jess, and though I wasn't there to see this episode when you put it up originally - you didn't disappoint! Anyway since he's acting on behalf of Leia, he saves the day, yay! Hera has been there for them in the past, and Leia - the boss that she is - is there backing Hera! :) Haha, when Xiono is mocking the evidence from a droid, Chopper is ready to go to war!! Btw what health regime is Mon Mothma on, she hasn't aged a day in the 17 years since Andor! ;) Was not expecting holo-Anakin to show up either as Ahsoka does a technique kata. Hearing Asajj Ventress being uttered by Hayden Christensen too, feels great. God I hope Filoni can finish her story some day, she became such an iconic character. Ahsoka mentions he was a good master, true, from a certain point of view. For all my many issues with Anakin, he was always there for her and was who she needed at that time. I like how she then puts the holo recording in a box along with the rest, showing how much they mean to her. The Jedi of old would say that could be the shadow of attachment, but Ahsoka is able to balance her attachment to Anakin and her friends, as good as anyone. Huyang getting touchy about the co-ordinates being correct as they may not even be in the same galaxy as Sabine and co. I think this feels like a skit from Doctor Who for David Tennant, which is a lovely touch, even as someone like myself who doesn't watch that, it felt like it could certainly be from there. :D Did Thrawn save up all the mines from the entire Empire, as my god, there looks like millons of them! Poor Purgil being struck by them, however if they can take down Star Destroyers by banging into them, will mines affect them? They might be impervious to the mines, but Ahsoka's T-6 Jedi Shuttle, isn't and she has to do some fancy flying of her own (and she was always a fair pilot too), to escape the minefield. Even then however, she isn't out of Dodge from Thrawn yet, especially as ships then come after her. He was prepared, our dangerous blue friend! Love the moment of hesitancy from Thrawn as he realises that Ahsoka is Anakin's apprentice. He did know Anakin and worked a lot with Vader and in some canon comics and books, his keen intellect put two and two together. He knows if she was trained by him and has lasted this long after the Clone War, she will be a formidable opponent. He is smart though, trying to put her into a limited position of her choosing, to slow her down. Moving onto Ezra and Sabine where we see them catch up a bit, and you can see she feels more relaxed now having one of her adopted family back. They way they banter and riff off each other is nice, and the two actors have great chemistry making it feel like our Sabine and Ezra of old. Like the line too about Palpatine being killed as "so they say" - you can feel Dave Filoni winking at us with that one! :D Ezra being one of us when Sabine mentions Ahsoka took her on as an apprentice : "what, why, really?" :D Nice moment though when Ahsoka reaches out in the force and Sabine can sense her, she knows Ahsoka survived at least and that comforts her, and confirms she's opening up in the force. You can see Ezra recognising this part as he did with Kanan a number of times. Baylan letting Shin off the leash, he knows she's not ready, but he feels where he is going she must not follow and her ambition is driving her elsewhere. You can sense her fear as she will have to go on her own path now and make her own decisions free of her master. Kind of like Ezra's fighting style, very Shaolin monk in technique and using his gifts in the force to disable too. Its a great way to show how Jedi should perhaps fight, as Yoda once said "A Jedi uses the Force for knowledge and defense, NEVER for attack.", its a defensive style of fighting and gets the job done. All without a lightsabre at that. Kanan once said that Ezra would need to solve problems without a lightsabre, he couldn't then, but he can now. Haha Ezra being Ezra, trying to talk his way out of being encompassed. He mentions about being taken as prisoners, we are onto that old trick Ezra, we know you can escape from anything - nice nod back to all the times in Rebels though when 'Jabba' used to escape the imperial clutches! :D Ahsoka is just the best though, coming in clutch again, saving Ezra and Sabine, fighting Shin without even bothering to ignite her lightsabres. Shin you are totally outclassed my love! When the tides turn and Ahsoka offers to help her you can see the confusion on Shin's face. The first time out on her own didn't go to plan, where does she turn to next? Sabine obviously thought Ahsoka died, understandably but it will take more than a fall into a cliff to stop our girl, the Son couldn't kill her, Vader couldn't; and its too late now, Ahsoka The White is upon us, she will be a beacon of light for all as darkness once again threatens to cover the galaxy. She also repaid the favour of Ezra saving her in the WBW, by doing so here and finding him as she promised there.

Thomas Corp

A completely dense git is what Xiono is. Though yes, Nelson Lee who portrays him here is great. C-3PO coming in, heralded in by John’s theme, Mon Mothma showing respect, all so lovely. Same here with Jess being immediately on my mind upon seeing the episode. Her reaction was magnificent. Xiono clearly has a death wish when he spouts his droid slander. He’d have to take it up with Mon and get a binding resolution to keep Chopper from destroying him, which probably wouldn’t even work. Amusingly Genevieve O’Rielly is still younger than Caroline Blakiston was when Return of the Jedi was released. I loved seeing more of Hayden as Anakin. His saying Ventress has the same level of excitement as hearing Ian McDiarmid or James Earl Jones say things from the animated series. Or like when Frank Oz said Malachor. For all Anakin’s crimes and sins, he was always there for Snips. Good point about the mines. Lars selling Thrawn’s realization of who and what exactly he’s dealing with was great. The bantering between Ezra and Sabine was indeed lovely, especially that moment when Filoni winked at us, had an appreciative chuckle at that myself. Great observations about Baylan and Shin. Ezra’s defensive style was great. It reminded me of Qui-Gon some as he tended to have a similar mentality of seeking peaceful resolution and only resorting to the lightsaber when left with no alternative. The best part of Ezra trying to talk his way out of the mess was Shin’s reactions, first how she has the silent, “For real?” look, and how she bluntly gives the order to shoot after not even half a minute of listening to Ezra. I give credit to Shin, much like the Third Sister clearly not having a chance against Darth Vader, Shin still fought back. The promise fulfilled by Ahsoka was tear inducing. And now Ezra, Sabine, and Ahsoka are all set for the finale.