Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

 In the world of biohacking and citizen science, there's a growing propensity for spending all your time making tools, especially through the use of garbage starting material. This is often framed as "opening access" but in reality it's still just garbage. The other issue is that if you spend all your time making these garbage tools, you never end up getting things done, and the repeatability of whatever you've done is much lower.  So in this video I discuss my thoughts on this, the times I've made this mistake and call on those in the community to instead shift the focus to a conversation about which things are worth buying, which are worth buying used and fixing, and which are actually worth building. 

Files

Previews only

It's turtles all the way down, and the turtles are made of garbage - A problem with Biohacking

In the world of biohacking and citizen science, there's a growing propensity for spending all your time making tools, especially through the use of garbage starting material. This is often framed as "opening access" but in reality it's still just garbage. The other issue is that if you spend all your time making these garbage tools, you never end up getting things done, and the repeatability of whatever you've done is much lower. So in this video I discuss my thoughts on this, the times I've made this mistake and call on those in the community to instead shift the focus to a conversation about which things are worth buying, which are worth buying used and fixing, and which are actually worth building. Trash flavored trash article: http://theantisense.com/2018/09/26/biohacking-trash-flavored-trash/ _________________________________________________________________ Support the show: Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thethoughtemporium Store: https://www.redbubble.com/people/chironex/shop _________________________________________________________________ My Social Media Pages: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thethoughtemporium/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thethoughtemporium/ Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/TTEchironex Website: http://thethoughtemporium.com/ _________________________________________________________________ As always, thanks to my awesome Patrons for helping to make these video possible. Special thanks to: Al Dass Alexander Halbleib Alexandre Castlenine Alexandre Guhur Anatoly Bazarov Anita Fowler Austin Morris Ben Davis Ben Krasnow Ben Reay Bennet Huch besenyeim BioQuisitive Cataract Bumblesnatch Evan wood Jennifer Jase Smith Jim Mussared John De Witt Jonas Abreu Jonathan Anderson Justin Hendryx Kevin Comerford kn0tsin Kolvenik Larry Leon Schutte Michael Chatzidakis Michael Gregg Morten Ericson narvutar1324 Nicolas Pourtalé Noah Pedersen Oliver orotusso Patryk Wycech Paul Emmerich Paul Richmond Rauni Simon Hallam Skave Rat Tom Bullock Vasilis

Comments

Simon Hallam

I can relate, and struggle with this *all the time*, sometimes diving deep down a rabbit hole for days at a time before either making a better and more elegant or cheaper tool, and sometimes poking my head out of the rabbit hole with the question “what the hell am I doing this for, JUST BUY IT!” Your goal to be more cognizant up front is a great one, and it will be interesting to see how often over time your desire and passion to want to make your own tool overrides what often takes me days into a project to realize. The idea of sharing is great also, I want to embrace it, but... what if you were a person who is super particular about their tools? How does one let go of that annoyance when you go to grab the angle grinder only to find that the person before left it in a totally messed up state, and you have to spend hours cleaning it up, or waiting for a replacement part to fix it? I wanted to share a blog post I wrote about balancing money and passion when determining project focus, it seems tenuously relevant but also felt weird about looking like I might be trying to advertise my blog in your messenger thread, but then I remembered that I actually include a link to your Patreon in that very article and talk about how your work inspires me, so it seems more like closing a feedback loop than self aggrandizement :) <a href="https://simonhallam.com/2018/08/10/what-dont-we-get/" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://simonhallam.com/2018/08/10/what-dont-we-get/</a>

Simon Hallam

What do you think it is about the cheap but powerful pump laser that prevents your quantum entanglement experiment from working? Poor beam collimation? Short coherence length? I can’t picture why either of these would cause the experiment not to work. It seems more likely to be an issue of alignment, (stability or fine control to get that angle just right) or that the unconverted portion of your pump beam is massively drowning out your entangled output, right? I know, I know, easy to say in a message, difficult to address in the lab :/

thethoughtemporium

I'm glad you enjoyed the video! As to letting go, the way I go over it was by education basically. If people leave a mess, grab them by the ear metaphoricaly and show them how the fucked up and how to do it better and then hold them to that standard. I'll happily front the cost of people making mistakes if they're learning. If they should know better, I'll express that to their face rather than keep it bottled up and let it just annoy me. Not in an aggressive way, but in an assertive one. It's taken time to learnt he balance of how to handle that. And most people are open to learning how to be better. That's a great post! And thanks for plugging the patreon. Greatly appreciated. As to the laser, it's a combination of all of the above. Because I couldn't focus it properly due to poor beam quality, I couldn't get things properly lined up. I did a long range test to see the true beam shape and it's a really long rectangle. It's super bad. The IR laser on the other hand focuses to a pattern of like 8 dots which is super aweful.

BioQuisitive

Great video m8. I'm in that boat of not much money or time, often i'm better off buying second hand and keeping my eyes open for deals like cheap/free -80s or similar. I'm thinking of making a BSC2 cabinet as were trying to get into mammalian cell cultures now at the space. I was considering buying a second hand one, but we have a set space with which to put it. SO for me, that is going to have to be a build project. After that an OD600 spec and nanodrop is on the list of things i hope to either obtain/build. Hopefully i'm lucky and come across cheap/second hand or maybe even free. Keep the videos coming, and thanks for the link to your buddies paper.