Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I've decided rather than do the great big time-sink video all at once, I will pick away at it in the background so you guys don't have to go without content for a month or more. Seems practical, especially in this all important time for my channel. So that one will come eventually, but in the mean time, you'll get more videos like this, and others I have planned.

Files

Was Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood Actually That Good, or...

Now you really gotta hear me out. NEW VIDEO ON PATREON: https://www.patreon.com/Overanalyzing Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood also. #fullmetalalchemist #fullmetalalchemistbrotherhood

Comments

Xavian Bland

Over-Analyzing Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood?! Oh how you tease us so🥹

Danny Stephens

Haven’t watched it yet but I can just smell how great this video is gonna be

Sam Burke

Well I’d watch, but it keeps asking me to sign into YouTube, which I am, but still won’t work so alas

Desert Espada

Said this in the comments of your Solo Leveling review but if you’re looking for recommendations, Delicious in Dungeon, Frieren, and Orb On the Movements of the Earth are probably my top picks I think you’d like right now And throw Mob Psycho 100 in there too, easily one of the best shows I’ve ever watched

Danny Stephens

Okay so I know you’ve probably heard this already but FMA Brotherhood was technically a remake. The original run in 2003 branched off from the manga because they caught up faster than Hiromu Arakawa could make issues. Then in Brotherhood, Arakawa collaborates with them and the first few episodes are made with the assumption that any viewer would have already seen those same episodes in 2003, so they’re condensed. Hence why Hughes doesn’t really feel fleshed out. In the original they spend a whole episode about meeting him on a train and it’s like a whole thing. I’d recommend it if you could find it somewhere! It’d also be interesting to hear your takes on the divergence of plots, because some of 03’s plot points are kind out there.

Dr. Nau 1030

If nothing else, I do hope that he finishes Brotherhood. I am not saying right away, and I am not saying it won't take some time. But I do hope that he finishes Brotherhood in its entirety.

JJ Fly

I don't think I've heard you this excited talking about a show in a good while. Korra had its moments, but this reminds me of a classic Overanlyzing Avatar epsiode in a way. I like when you dunk on shows too, but it's nice to get some positivity now and then. The fights in this show are so hit and miss for me. Some of them have great animation and choreography, but then others are just still images of two characters doing an action pose, slowly sliding over each other while the voice actors go "HAAA!" or something. Asking anime fans for recommendations is a dangerous game, you're just going to get people listing their favourites, but I'll try to suggest some ones that should at least be interesting to talk about, whether or not you actually like them: Fullmetal Alchemist - I think someone else mentioned this, but Brotherhood is actually the second adaptation. The 2003 version came out while the original manga was still getting started, so the stories end up going to completely different places pretty quickly. It could be interesting to compare the two once you finish Brotherhood. I've not seen it, but I've heard mixed opinions. Puella Magi Madoka Magica - One of my favourites. It's only 12 episodes long (plus an optional film sequel) so it'd fit this format well. It's very visually interesting and it'd take you out of the shounen genre. If you've ever vaguely heard of Sailor Moon then you've done the required reading. Sword Art Online - It's pretty universally hated, but it did kick start the last 10 years of isekai stories. It could at least be an interesting look at how the fad started and how it might have affected some of the anime you've seen that were inspired by it, or as just a cautionary tale of what not to do in a show. Frieren: Beyond Journey's End - This one pretty recently ousted Brotherhood as the number 1 anime on some big anime website. I didn't like it all that much, but you could see if you think it's worhty of the top spot, especially since you're already doing Brotherhood. Baccano! - This one has a kind of Pulp Fiction thing, where it switches between different characters but also jumps backwards and forwards in time, so that adds something interesting. Then there's the classics like Cowboy Bebop, Serial Experiments Lain, Neon Genesis Evangelion, etc. These ones have pretty much been done to death, but if you can find something worthwhile to say about them then there's plenty that every anime fan will tell you to watch. It might also be worth doing a video about some anime you watched when you were a kid, to see if it holds up at all. Anime might work better than cartoons, since they're usually more story driven, but idk maybe you were a big Xiaolin Showdown fan as a kid or something. Anyway, that's all I could think of off the top of my head. I've been loving your videos since Bato of the Water Tribe and I'm looking forward to the next one.

Jook06

if you’re doing modern stuff like solo-leveling and MHA, hearing your thoughts on jujutsu kaisen would be interesting

Justin Gregory

One time on a Livestream I donated and asked for you to watch blue eye samurai, You said you didn't like anime. It's been 3 anime videos.

Jakob Connell

My take on your question of "Why is Ed Sad after finding out that they didn't bring there mom back at all?" He wasn't sad to find this out, he was actually relieved. One thing (of many) he has tortured himself about, is how he brought his mom's soul back into a monsters body. Basically woke her up from the dead just to make her suffer for a few minutes, before causing her to die; this time by his hands. That's what he thought happened. Now this big reveal happen that he didn't actually bring her back, didn't cause her needless suffering on top of the suffering that Al went through (which he still blames himself for). I don't have the right words to describe the exact emotion he's displaying, but I know it's similar to when characters pass out after getting past a long and tough obstacle. As if all the tension they've been building up or holding onto since the start of 'x event' releases all at once. He can 100% stop blaming himself for this one thing, because he's now learned that it didn't even happen in the first place. It would be similar (although much bigger scale) to if he woke up from a comma and found out the entire transmutation incident was just a bad dream, and all the problems and self blame would disappear in an instant.