Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

People are going to say I'm hating but really I'm still having a very good time with the show

Files

Was Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood a defining show or maybe...

People are gonna say that I am hating but really it's only a couple problems. NEW VIDEO ON PATREON: https://www.patreon.com/Overanalyzing Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood also. #fullmetalalchemist #fullmetalalchemistbrotherhood

Comments

Scoobert

I really enjoy hearing your thoughts on this show because you match a lot of my thoughts, then we also disagree on somethings. Maybe I disagree because I've done like 4 rewatches of the show, 2 in the past year! I also don't think I should explain myself on this yet, and instead let you finish the show out so that there's no potential spoilers. Looking forward to the last one!

Sandwitch_Dude

About Father, some things you were questioning about were explained in his origin episode. He's the result of an experiment using Hohenheim's blood, thus explains his human-like attitude in his dwarf days. What the experiment was isn't explained, but I'm guessing it involves alchemy since it was a thing back when Xerxes was still alive and he knows a shit-ton about it. Father's body is also a philosopher's stone consisting of half the Xerxian lives that were sacrificed in exchange for immortality. Hohenheim has the other half. He also used Hohenheim's blood to create a body for himself.

JJ Fly

Looks like the frequency of videos is going up, it must make a difference when he's watching a show he actually likes instead of Solo Levelling and MHA. Nobody recommend any more bad anime, let's keep the streak alive. I hadn't noticed how often they do the thing where the fights have a moment where the characters reveal they'd planned something the whole time, but for some reason that never bothered me, and it still doesn't. I suppose they just really like those big reveal moments. If anything, it's the way they sometimes reveal it so clunkily that bothers me more, like when Mustang is halfway through burning Lust to crisp and the two are just having a conversation about exactly how he's killing her. There's a couple of things I think you've missed that aren't spoilers, so I'll mention them here just so you're not still confused about it going into the final episodes. The reason that Ed figured out the countrywide transmutation circle was by joining up places where the government ordered mass bloodshed, like Ishval and Liore, that's why Kimblee had to spill all that blood at Briggs. The flashback episode shows the same thing happening in Xerxes. The reason they all know about the promised day is because of that secret chain of communication, even if it mostly happens in that one episode. Greed has insider knowledge and Hohenheim seems to know what's up, so they're both the source of the information and the other characters are sharing it from there on. Other than that, you're right that what exactly will happen on the promised day is still pretty much a mystery, even to the main characters. Also, I didn't say anything in the Frieren video, but I did like what you said about looking at new shows you wouldn't have otherwise considered, even after you got burned by Solo Levelling. I hope you keep giving different types of shows a chance, especially now FMA is coming to a close and you're probably going to be looking at even more shows. Next time you ask for recommendations I'll try to push the boat out a bit further with my suggestions. Anyway, keep up the overanalyzing. I always look forward to these videos.

Cristyan Warner

Im sure you've already started DanDaDan because of what you said at the end, but I don't envision you liking that at all

Dutch Letters

Envy didn’t have anything to do with the fiasco in the mining town. That was actually Edward but told from the deluded perspective of the person who was actually taking advantage of the miners.

Dutch Letters

What are we suggesting next then? Hunter X Hunter? Death Note? Stein’s Gate? Neon Genesis Evangelion?

Redoran

I think Orb: on the Movements of the Earth would be great

JJ Fly

I don't know if he's even looking for recommendations at the moment, but next time he asks I'll probably go for some deeper cuts or older shows, since he mostly seems to be doing the newer, popular shows.

Tyler

Did you get copyright struck? It says the video is Private.