Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Every writer I've talked to has told me that I need to break this giant book into a trilogy. I've already written this book in III Acts, and this chapter is the end of Act I, so I would love to hear your thoughts on what you've read so far and whether you would be okay or furious with me ending a book here.One of the major issues with publishing this book as one book is that it's too long to have it printed through normal means, so it will likely never come out in print.

Chapter 43

Autumn's End

Time passed and seasons changed. As the end of Autumn approached, Tobias stood in the sect's training ground ready to share his final findings. There were many improvements he could make to how they trained, but those improvements would be minor and tedious, and Tobias had no interest or need to be a part of that research.

The disciples sat in rows depending on seniority, giving him their full attention. They knew their training under him was over and were showing him the highest respect they could.

Tobias cupped his hands before him and bowed. "Magistrate Finch thanks the disciples of Cloud Sect for their assistance with his research."

The disciples cupped their hands and returned the bow.

Tobias flicked open his folding fan and tucked his empty hand behind his back. "I know that many of you consider our time together to have been fortuitous. However, what we have done here will not only improve you but fundamentally change the cultivation world. Through your hard work, we have proven that building muscle up to the peak of the foundation realm makes expanding and strengthening body meridians faster and easier. You should all be very proud of this."

Tobias turned to a small group of the grotesquely muscular disciples. They were so bulbous that they struggled to care for themselves, requiring servants to assist them with many of their physical needs.

"We have also proven that there is an absolute maximum for how effective building muscle is and that to go beyond this point causes meridian instability."

Tobias snapped his fan closed, signalling for the others to copy his following actions, before cupping his hands and bowing to the grotesquely proportioned men.

"We pay our respects to those who have taken harm to prevent others from harm." Tobias rose from the bow. "Had you not agreed to this training, the elders who will attempt to lower disciples' chi density through other means might have done irreparable harm to them."

The massive disciples did their best to return the bow, but their arms were so large that they could not make their hands meet to cup them. After this final meeting, they would go directly to chi chi-saturated cultivation chambers to correct their meridian instability. Access had been granted because of their personal sacrifice.

Tobias turned his gaze towards the main group. "Here is what I have learned with your help. The stomach meridian passively draws in chi from its surroundings, before moving it down multiple pathways to the next meridians in the body meridian network. During this transition, some of the chi leaks from the pathways, changing its nature so that it can infuse the surrounding bones, muscles, and organs. This infusion reinforces and changes the body, allowing it to adapt more quickly and become stronger. However, this chi density also applies pressure to the greater body meridians, making it more difficult for them to expand and strengthen. The amount of chi leaking from these pathways is proportional to the size and strength of the meridians, so is the pressure placed on the greater body meridians. This is irrespective of one's cultivation, divinity and talent. Reductions in the body's chi density can successfully reduce the difficulty of expanding and strengthening greater body meridians. This can be achieved by increasing the amount of muscle a body possesses. This reduction in difficulty is irrespective of one's cultivation, divinity, or talent.

Furthermore, the body possesses a natural limiter, an inability to easily adapt once the additional muscle begins harming body meridians. This limiter can be overcome through excessive strength training to build muscle, but it is not advised because it causes meridian instability, as the chi density in the body helps to maintain the structure of body meridians as they are expanded and strengthened. Because of this, it is advisable to stop attempting to grow muscle once muscle growth has drastically reduced. The effectiveness of this body cultivation method will enable even a cultivator at the end of their natural path to expand and strengthen their greater body meridians by no less than one-third. For those not at the end of their natural path, it can increase the speed they expand and strengthen these meridians by no less than a factor of four."

The lowest increase in size and strength of the greater body meridians among those at the end of their natural path was actually a little over 50%. However, Tobias wanted to be realistic. There were cultivators out there who lacked the disciple's abilities and training. The same went for the factor of four estimate for speed. The slowest disciple had seen an increase of a factor of six, and the highest had seen an increase of a factor of fifteen.

These higher numbers did not matter as the base numbers he supplied indicated that this would be the preferred method, naturally expanding and strengthening the greater body meridians going forward.

Tobias motioned to Lingling, encouraging her to begin handing out the manuals he'd prepared. The looks of surprise and the chuckling that followed indicated he'd chosen the correct name.

The Weary Disciple Body Cultivation Manual would eventually be known throughout The Three Kingdoms and become the first step for any cultivator on the path to body cultivation.

Tobias watched as the chuckling slowly spread as each disciple was let in on the joke. They had all worked painstakingly hard for him, and they all found the thought of others suffering as much as they had amusing.

Once the last of the manuals was handed out and the laughter died down, Tobias motioned for silence and folded his hands behind his back. "This concludes our training together. Starting tomorrow, you will return to training under the elders of Cloud Sect. The manual you hold has everything you need to make progress without my assistance. However, should you need advice anytime before the New Year Festival, my door in the state assignment hall is open to all of you. You may return to your duties."

The disciples rose to their feet, and Disciple Pon stepped forward. He cupped his hands before him. In one motion, every other disciple did the same.

"We thank Magistrate Finch for his assistance on our journey to immortality," they spoke as one. "We recognise the debt that is owed."

As one, they bowed, bending below the waist, offering the highest respect they could without kowtowing. It was a gesture of gratitude from students to a beloved teacher.

Tobias returned their bow with the bow of a teacher to a valued student, accepting the respect that was offered.

None of the disciples before him were claimed by the elders. None of them had any backing. None of them were ever going to be core disciples. Everything they had achieved was achieved through hard work. For many in the foundation realm, this had been the first assistance they had received in decades. The sect expected them to thrive or fail on their own. Tobias knew that this was a waste of their potential.

***

Xu Ling put down her copy of the Weary Disciple Body Cultivation Manual, having groaned through the entire training section of the manual as she remembered the intense physical training she had undergone. Her body was now slightly toned, with a bit more muscle. Despite her grumbling, Tobias knew she was quite happy with the change.

Xu Ling rolled from her stomach to her back and rose to a sitting position, moving the cushions she'd been resting her head on in his viewing room, under her backside.

Tobias smiled. "What do you think?"

Xu Ling scowled. "It's brilliant and I hated every moment I spent reading it."

Tobias chuckled. "Because it reminded you of training?"

Her eyes narrowed. "Don't make me beat you with the strength you gave me."

Tobias smirked. "Is that any way to speak to your master?"

Xu Ling picked up another cushion and threw it at him.

Tobias caught the cushion and tossed it aside. "I've finalised the next series of cultivation exercises for when you're ready to move onto energy meridian opening."

Initiate realm cultivation was significantly more complex than the mortal realm cultivation, and it had taken Tobias longer than he expected to categorise everything in his library for the Lee Clan to develop the next exercises she needed.

Tobias had even postponed categorising techniques to save time and was glad he had.

The cultivation world considered anything a cultivator did with chi or spiritual energy that didn't improve their cultivation to be a technique. The only distinction they made was whether techniques were offensive, defensive, mobility, or utility, despite there being apparent differences between certain types of techniques within these distinctions. Unravelling that mess and creating something coherent to build exercises with would likely take him a couple of years and require him to write several books.  

Xu Ling flopped onto her back and groaned. "You're a monster. All you do is make me train."

Tobias winced at the accusation.

Since they'd perform the master servant ritual, Tobias had been pushing her quite hard. He'd been pushing himself just as hard, but there wasn't really a need for him to push her as hard as he was pushing himself, besides a concern that he might not be there to see her training to the end.

Xu Ling was making steady progress, progress that was much faster than he assumed it would be. Even with his improved intellect, her learning speed was still superior to his. That, more than anything he'd been told, finally made him accept there was something to being a prodigy, something that went beyond having divinity so high it couldn't be tested.

Lingling was still working through the first set of exercises. In the same time, Xu Ling had learned all three methods, progressed through meridian cleansing, and body meridian expanding and was close to finishing the methods for strengthening. She would soon be working on energy meridians, and Tobias didn't believe she would find that any more difficult than she had found anything else.

In the beginning, she made the same mistakes his sister had made. However, those mistakes were overcome more quickly. Every test he'd run said she wasn't more talented or intelligent than other cultivators. Instead, it appeared that her practice was more effective.

Tobias had only figured this out because her father had been diligently recording her and his sister's progress. Based on the data, Xu Ling seemed to gain as much experience from performing an exercise once as his sister did from performing the same exercise twenty-eight times.

There weren't enough subjects to conduct a comprehensive study, but the findings suggested that the matter requires further investigation.

As those thoughts crossed his mind, Tobias realised he was being unfair to Xu Ling. He was treating her only as his first disciple, not as his friend.

"You're right. I am pushing you too hard. However, there isn't much to do in Cloud City until my shopping and entertainment district is completed, so how about we visit my friend Patriarch Lee?"

Xu Ling sat up. "With or without my father?"

"That will be up to him."

Xu Ling had been his guest for long enough that it wasn't considered improper for them to visit Tobias's friend alone. She was also a cultivator, which offered her more freedom. However, that freedom was limited by her status as Xu Feng's daughter and heir. She was supposed to act above reproach. But she was also Tobias's first disciple, so that gave her a little more freedom, too.

Xu Ling grinned and leapt to her feet, racing out of the room to badger her father into allowing their outing.

Tobias went to the other room, composed a quick letter, and passed it off to his servants to deliver to the courier when the end-of-day manuscripts arrived.

The Lee Clan was still translating his library and making increasingly faster progress. Patriarch Lee was doing everything in his power to ensure Tobias had what he needed for further insights, which were now coming more frequently.

Tobias stopped by his sister's bedroom on his way back.

She was seated on a cushion in the centre of the room, practising her cultivation exercises. Xu Ling's rapid progress had warped Lingling's perception of what cultivators typically achieved, and she had thrown herself into her studies. Tobias had tried to point out the age difference and brought up numerous times that Xu Ling was a prodigy, but she hadn't listened.

Lingling opened her eyes as he entered.

Tobias smiled at his sister. "Would you like to visit the local patriarchs of the Great Clans with me? I need to deliver the manual and manuscript I created, and having you there will open up your marriage prospects if things don't work out with the Lee Clan"

Lingling considered the offer. "Will this be a formal meeting?"

"No. It will be a social visit."

"Do I have to visit the Lee Clan?"

"No. Xu Ling and I are going to do that."

"I'll come with you." Lingling reached behind her and picked up her copy of the Weary Disciple's Body Cultivation Manual. "I have a question about your body cultivation method."

"Is there something you don't understand?"

"There is, but I actually have a question about something that's not in here."

Tobias frowned. "What's not in there?"

"You don't mention whether or not growing muscle helps open and cleanse body meridians."

"I do, but indirectly. On the second page, there is a line that states growing muscle is unnecessary before the initiate realm."

Lingling scowled. "That's too vague. It doesn't explain why it wasn't necessary."

"The twelve greater body meridians are spaced far enough apart that they don't generate enough chi density to affect the opening and cleansing of each other. This only changes after opening and cleansing the greater meridians, which creates enough pressure to open and cleanse the lesser body meridians."

"That makes sense, but why isn't it in here?"

"You don't need to understand that to practice my body cultivation method."

"Oh."

"What's your other question?"

Lingling frowned. "I understand why opening and cleansing the greater meridians causes the lesser meridians to open and be cleansed, but I don't understand why expanding and strengthening the greater meridians cause the lesser ones to change, too."

"That's because the nature of the chi travelling through the body meridian network changes as you expand and strengthen your greater body meridians. This change enriches the chi within you, allowing it to nourish your lesser body meridians, enabling them to adapt. This adaptation causes them to mimic the greater body meridians by expanding and growing stronger."

"That doesn't make sense. Your manual stated that meridians are the entry points for chi into the body meridian network. How can something that is travelling through the network affect something outside it?"

"Ah, I see where you're confused. You've misunderstood the terminology used in the manual."

"I have?"

"Yes. Your body meridian network is the term cultivators use to collectively refer to all your body meridian pathways. Pathways are the channels that carry chi between two body meridians. These pathways can be between both greater and lesser meridians. It doesn't matter what sort. The only body meridian that actually allows chi to enter your body meridian network is your stomach meridian. This is because the stomach meridian has the ability to break down foreign contaminants and filter them out, preventing them from corrupting the body. The rest of your body meridians alter chi and facilitate its movement through your pathways, depending on how they've been expanded or strengthened."

"You should explain that in your guide. I didn't understand it."

"That's because you're not an initiate realm cultivator. You haven't studied cultivation to the extent that those who read this manual will have."

"You keep telling me that cultivators don't understand cultivation, that they just blindly follow tradition. Why would they know more than I do?"

Tobias groaned because Lingling was right. He'd made an assumption that he shouldn't have. "I'm going to have to write a manuscript that explains all this."

"Why not add it to this one?"

"That manual is about muscle growth and its effects on body cultivation. If I add too much unrelated information, I'll confuse the reader, so it's better to create a manuscript that teaches them what they need to know before they read that manual."

Lingling nodded. "Can I continue delivering skewers to the disciples?"

"You can deliver mortal meat for those in the initiate realm."

"Why not initiate realm cloud ram meat? You said they needed it."

"Now that my research is concluded, the elders are no longer funding the disciple's growth. I would have to pay for that myself, and I'm not willing to do that."

Lingling scowled. "Don't be cheap. They helped you a lot."

"Feeding them for one day would cost more than the land I bought for our family to farm."

Lingling's mouth dropped open. "How is it so expensive!"

"Cloud Sect's hunters are only allowed to kill cloud rams that have reached the peak of a realm and cannot break through to the next. This means there are only a few dozen of them wandering through the Cloud Mountains each season."

"But the disciples eat it every day."

"By the time a cloud ram reaches peak initiate realm, it is four times the size of a fully grown bull. They're enormous and take a foundation realm cultivator or a group of initiate realm cultivators to bring them down."

Lingling frowned. "Cultivator Pon is a foundation realm hunter. Can I ask him if he would like to supply the meat they need?"

"You can, but you must clearly state that it's a personal request, not something I'm endorsing. I won't have you using my name to manipulate the disciples."

Lingling grinned.

***

A few days later, Tobias led Xu Ling through Patriarch Lee's garden and stopped before the old man's table. After badgering her father relentlessly for two days, Xu Feng finally agreed to allow her to visit alone. Xu Ling didn't know, but Xu Feng had only agreed because Tobias had said he would introduce her as his first disciple. Attending a social gathering in such a way was far more acceptable.

Tobias stopped before the table and bowed. "Patriarch Lee, allow me to introduce my first disciple Xu Ling, daughter of Xu Feng, owner of the House of Sound."

Patriarch Lee cupped his fist and gave a small bow.

Xu Ling rose from her bow, turned, and then scowled at Tobias. "You didn't say you were going to introduce me as your first disciple."

Tobias was shocked by her public outburst. Tobias didn't know how powerful his friend actually was, but he knew that most cultivators were terrified by the thought of him. Her accusation was so far outside the bounds of etiquette and tradition that Tobias didn't know how to react.

Thankfully, Patriarch Lee chuckled. "You must like me to be so forthright, young lady."

Xu Ling flashed him a grin. "If you were a few thousand years younger, I would try to marry you. I see why the two of you are friends."

Patriarch Lee returned the grin. "And I see why Tobias likes you so much."

Xu Ling forgot her indignation as she took a seat at the table, motioning for Tobias to join them. "Magistrate Finch mentioned me?"

"On several occasions. He feels you are one of the few people he has met who could pursue your own dao."

Tobias finally recovered from his shock and took a seat, placing the two manuals he'd written in front of Patriarch Lee.

"Has he mentioned I'm trying to marry him?"

"He did. He was undecided on the matter, which, now that I have met you, is a strong mark against him. You're beauty lives up to its reputation."

Xu Ling smiled, accepting the compliment, before finally remembering her manners. "Xu Ling greets Patriarch Lee."

Patriarch Lee inclined his head and finally relaxed, shifting his gaze to the manuals. "Patriarch Lee greets Fairy Xu." He picked up the second manual and glanced at Tobias. "This isn't the body cultivation method you've been working on?"

"You said that the Great Clans would consider my notes on breaking down cultivation methods valuable enough to be a fair exchange for letting me permanently keep their libraries, so I formalised the information into a manual that explains how to do so. It's now simple enough that anyone should be able to understand and use my method."

Patriarch Lee thumbed through the pages. "This is more extensive than the notes you gave me."

"I've had more time to think and study. That's allowed me to refine the method to be more versatile. You'll be surprised at some of the insights you can gather with that manual. You should easily be able to create cultivation exercises for your unique techniques."

Patriarch Lee gave an excited grin. "Have you verified if these cultivation exercises work?"

"I thought your clan was working on that?"

"We are. I want to know if your experience has been different to our own."

Tobias motioned to Xu Ling. "My first disciple has made great progress in her ability to cultivate by using the exercises your clan created."

Patriarch Lee turned to Xu Ling. "How significant are these improvements?"

Xu Ling blushed. "Magistrate Finch overestimates my progress."

Patriarch Lee frowned. "How so?"

Tobias decided to answer, to help her save face. "Xu Ling has only mastered the mortal realm exercises and does not believe that this should count since they will no longer help her progress."

Patriarch Lee examined Xu Ling, sensing her cultivation. "What are you basing her progress on, then?" 

"Her ability to cultivate. Before she began, her technical ability to perform the exercises was significantly below that of her father in these aspects. They are now noticeably above his."

"Why is that relevant?"

"The vast majority of prodigies have little cultivation skill, because their divinity doesn't require them to master basic cultivation skills. Without these basic skills, they quickly reach the core realm. However, once there, their divinity is no longer enough to protect them from chi deviation. This lack of basic cultivation skill eventually leads them to produce a cataclysmic chi deviation, which either kills them or cripples their cultivation for life."

"What are you basing that assumption on?"

"The Great Clans and sects' records. They demonstrate a clear link between the speed at which a prodigy reaches the core realm and their likelihood of dying from chi deviation. This link is also replicated for those with naturally high divinity reaching the foundation realm at a younger age."

"And you believe these cultivation exercises will eliminate the chances of chi deviation."

"No, but they will drastically reduce their occurrence and indicate to the individual where their capabilities lie in relation to cultivation methods and techniques."

"If this manual does everything you promise, the Great Clans will be in your debt. This is worth significantly more than access to our general libraries and publicly protecting your family."

"A good relationship is all I need for these manuals."

Xu Ling smirked.

Patriarch Lee caught the smirk. "You have greater insights still to share."

Tobias nodded.

"Insights you don't intend to freely share."

Tobias nodded again.

Patriarch Lee glanced at the manuals. "You're giving us these now so that when the others are ready, the Great Clans and sects will know the true value of what you offer. They will also do everything in their power to make sure you and your family are protected."

Tobias nodded yet again. "Has your clan found the exercises beneficial?"

"Our new generation is progressing faster than any generation before them, and that's all I will say on the matter."

Tobias had assumed the exercises would work based on what he'd seen with his sister and Xu Ling, but they hadn't put what they were learning into practice, so he couldn't be sure. Patriarch Lee's words had confirmed that creating the second manual was worth his time and effort. That he'd taken the right actions to increase his family's security.

Tobias smiled.

Patriarch Lee returned the smile and picked up the body cultivation method Tobias had created. "Let me see what you've created."

Tobias and Xu Ling sat in silence as Patriarch Lee began to read. With his cultivation, he was able to read the manual in only a few minutes. Then he moved on to the manual for creating cultivation exercises. Unlike the pile of notes he'd been given the previous Winter, this had a formal structure that was easier to understand and implement.

Patriarch eventually put it down and met Tobia's gaze. "When you brought me your notes, there was no doubt in my mind that you would be able to convince my clan of your ongoing value. These two manuals are more than I hoped for. I promise you that within a few days, The Three Kingdoms will know that the Finch Family is under the Lee Clan's protection."

Tobias swallowed. "Will they be safe now?"

Patriarch Lee paused. "I can't promise that your enemies will leave your family alone, but I can promise you that there will always be an elder of the Lee Clan standing in their way."

"For how long?"

Patriarch Lee's gaze softened and lifted Tobias's body cultivation manual. "You do not understand what I hold in my hands, my friend. Eight thousand years from now, I will be surrounded by members of my clan who will struggle to believe that I was once friends with the man who created such a foundational body cultivation method. Children will listen with rapt attention, like their parents before them, as I share the story of our friendship. Whether my clan has to keep your family safe for decades, centuries, or millennia is of little consequence to one like myself. The youngest child in your family will die of old age before our elders give up their watch, because I will not be able to tell that story before my clan with pride if we do anything less. It is an honour and a privilege to call someone who created something so foundational my friend."

Tobias stared back, finally understanding how much different their perception of time was. Patriarch Lee intended to protect his family for centuries, not because their friendship was that strong, but because his life was so long that the commitment held a different meaning for him. Tobias's family would die of old age without ever experiencing a fiftieth of the years his friend would experience, so protecting them was not a significant commitment.

A wave of relief overwhelmed Tobias as that sank in.

Patriarch Lee saw that he understood and turned to Xu Ling. "I expect you're about to have a lot of competition. Tobias has just become the most eligible bachelor in The Three Kingdoms."

Xu Ling scowled. "He's going to marry me. He doesn't have a choice in the matter."

Patriarch Lee chuckled. "I believe my friend would disagree."

"Once again, the magistrate doesn't have a choice in the matter."

Comments

Aaron A. Cole

I would cry if you stopped posting it here. I would be thoroughly indifferent if you ended the book here and continued posting Arc 2 as Book 2 on the normal schedule :)

Alec Barnes

In the interest of making more money you're probably going to do better with 3 books but I'm no expert. That said I and many other like me I'm sure, love a long book. I really love to see a 20+ hour book on audible especially if you have Travis narrate again. Either way I'll be buying the book/books when they're out. Thanks for the fantastic storytelling so far.

T'Ericka

I don’t care if you broke it into 3 books and book 1 ended here - however I’d be devastated if you just stopped writing & sharing the chapters. I don’t have a lot of things that bring me joy in my life right now and this is one of them

Corn

The only thing to be furious about is that now we have to wait for the next two acts to come out. Thought we were closing in on the end here but this is actually a very enjoyable read. Honestly, just do whatever is most convenient.

Bloodorange17

For whatever it's worth, I say break it into a trilogy. I want to buy the print copies! Just please don't stop posting!

Chris Fey

If this is a book split location, I'd consider inserting epilogues and prologues for each of the books to provide glimpses of where the plot is going and to build hype between books. I'd also consider a short prologue dealing with the transmigration, or right before he leaves for the magistrate test. As it was, Toby's relationship to his family really isn't addressed until several chapters, nor is it clear that his assent both provides him with a better living but also helps his parents leave serf status. (I don't think it should be significantly long, as the current "cold open" is good, its just I don't want people to be put off by Toby's initial demeanor seeming uncaring) You could even start the book with an excerpt from his manual read far in the future like Patriarchy Lee insists it will be. If his realms increase again, you can use it for each book.

Thomas

When you publish these as books, publish them all at the same time, or do not mention that the others are finished because there will be riots until the next books come out.

CherMi

I thoroughly enjoyed this book so far and it's great that there are two more arcs. It felt like an ending was coming and I was afraid we'll leave Tobias like that. My only complaint is that before the start of arc 2 there are no clear signs of what's going to happen. The marriage hangs in the air and so do plots of princes, sects, nobles and magistrates. So does Tobias' cultivation for that matter. My main issue is that Tobias hasn't made any plans for the future that I remember, aside from entertainment district and further research into cultivation, so we know his circumstances but not his intentions. So to sum up, I have no idea what's arc 2 is going to be about and it might be a problem in a book format. Looking forward to reading it though!

Tenpoundtarantula

Splitting it for when you release it is fine, as long as you keep posting act 2 :) I would say it's quite abrupt and ending though, so maybe an afterword or something similar to frame it?

MorningDawn

I will say, I've thought this was all fantastic - If this is arc one, and you keeping posting this book, I'll keep subscribing. For me, I think the end of book one feels like it was at the capture by the first crown prince. It's a real cliffhanger, based on the actions of the migistrate that had been done. What's happened after ( And I have enjoyed it!) has felt like a different book, almost like it's own thing - There's been a the escape & the reveal from the why of book one (with the second prince) & then the new ideas of how to cultivate properly, with its own interests. It could easily be a long epilouge, but that's how it feels to me - Again, thank you for writing it! I love reading about family, heroism & smart thinking when you write it.

Chris Woodward

As long as chapters keep coming out I think splitting them is definitely the way to go, assuming you release them all in the same year so no one has to wait an unreasonable amount of time.

Shain Oleson

This would be a fine break point if you are going to split the book up.for ease of publishing which I agree you should do. It just make.sense for ease of publication and likely from a monetary stand point since most people are willing to pay more for three things vs one thing even if equals out the same.

Travis Holley

This is a solid place to end the first book. It finalizes his concerns for his family safety, reaffirms the relationship with xu ling, and uses his sister to demonstrate the strides his family has taken. Nice neat package with a bow on it. Lots of little threads left lying around to keep interest for book two. This whole first book is extremely information dense, but that is your writing style across all the books you write. Normally, you will here critics talk about fallibility but you already managed that by making his enemies so much more powerful than him.

Robert Nolan

I have loved the story so far and can see this as a good stopping point for the first book. My only note is that ending the book on Xu Ling being a brat feels off key for the rest of the story. I feel that he is so mature that having her acting like a bit of a spoiled child here justified all of his reservations. If you want the match to seem natural going forward she needs to sound more like an adult stating her intentions rather than a girl making demands.

Bob of Doom

It does feel like an ending of book 1. The main conflict, Tobias family’s protection, has been resolved so you can move on to focus on a new conflict

xyphion

I always wanted to ask how long it was because I didn't want it to end. That this is act one of three, made my day

Andrew Segura

This does feel like a good ending for a book 1. While I am also completely fine with a massive single book, I think the value of having it as three books is more than keeping it as a single large one.

Eli Pomerantz

I think I need to add a lot of caveats to this response I don’t buy paper backs anymore - personally I feel they take up home space I don’t have, digital copies give me access whenever I want, & my most common method of consumption is listening to audiobooks while doing menial work I don’t need to concentrate on, so perhaps I am fundamentally not qualified to answer Additionally, if I enjoy a series, and the book ends, I tend to want to binge dive immediately into the next book if it’s available - so is enough in ever going to be enough for me? A longer book just means more bang for my buck Would I buy your book as is? Absolutely, warts & spelling mistakes & all But I do feel there are some problems that make it feel incomplete, although this could be an artifact of devouring it chapter by chapter, and I will need to reread the book as a single consistent work to be certain Perhaps the biggest issue is that I don’t see a climax I can point to; Tobias’s completion of the manual? His survival of the prince’s torture? What is the poignant question and satisfying conclusion that will make this book feel complete? These are some of the more important events that I can think of, but they also kind of dryly detached, reported on after the fact with no emotional investment Which leads into my next criticism, which is that I am feeling that same sense of detachment throughout the entire book. This is somewhat necessitated by both the culture and the character, but that seems a simple surface answer. At times Tobias comes off as a little bit too perfect and robotic. On a bit of a tangent, I wasn’t the biggest fan of the vampire Vincent series because the MC felt like a Gary Stu, but the one thing I did appreciate was a good sense of story beats and your witty anachronistic humor, which I find lacking in this story (having said that, I am still enjoying this story more) I don’t want torture porn, but we see Tobias being captured, and then we see him being released, and we don’t get any of the fear and despair that he might have at almost losing his *second* life, or conversely, a burning rage at the injustice done to him. The creation of his life work that will keep him & his family in safety has no eureka moment as everything comes together, or conversely, doubt as to whether or not it could really be this simple. We see the slow progress, but we could have flashbacks to either his youth in this life or the previous where he learned hard lessons to give weight to these mountains. Other than being a risk assessment adjuster, I can’t say if what Tobias felt about his precious life, where as we get a much deeper view of the past & present familial relationships of the MC’s of all your other books. On a very minor note, I often can’t “see“ the space Tobias is in… We don’t necessarily need Tolkiens purple prose that goes on for pages, but the dearth of environment could be contributing to the bare-bones feel In summary, I like the story, but I definitely feel that it is incomplete for a first book as is Perhaps there could be a children’s tournament arc with Ling to prove the validity of his theories and on which his entire future depends on a child’s tournament; Or a courtroom scene, as instead of sending generic off screen assassins, the second, Prince instead manipulates the law and tries to get Tobias reassigned out of the reach of his protectors (perhaps this could be set up to a evil Tobias counterpart who is an advisor to the prince) & the clans need to actually assert their authority instead of the presumptive that everything worked out Or, perhaps one of those assassins does get to buy a loan, and he needs to use either his raw muscles or cleverness to barely escape death Or some traditionalist, angry at the early results, challenge Tobias to a contest that he can’t out fight, but can outthink Or a friend in trouble who he now has to risk his work to help out & step out of his comfort zone Again, please take all of this with a grain of salt as A) this is all coming from someone who is already sold on the product B) I haven’t recently reread everything C) I may not be your target audience for the question due to my digital & audio preferences

Iain Grubb

Break it into three, it deserves to be published. I just hope we keep getting the juicy chapters ^ ^

John Milster

I've absolutely loved the book and can't wait for more of it. I haven't purchased a print book in almost two decades so that doesn't affect me, but I'm REALLY hoping you're going to get Travis to do the audio book!

Daniel Heritage

Thanks for the chapter, to answer your questions : 1. Yes, I agree with your fellow authors. It would be wise to split the book into multiple books and have it published as a series, anything less would be wasted opportunity and a disservice to this brilliant book. 2. Yes, I would be quite cross with you if you ended things here with that chapter. It's obvious that the story is yet unfinished and still has much untapped potential, I and likely many others want to be able to read act 2 & 3 ! The imperial family needs to have it's comeuppance & the tobias' relationship with Xu Ling needs to be further explored. I'm very much looking forward to reading more of this book and later purchasing the series once it's been edited and published.

Jeff V

I can't express how thoroughly I have enjoyed the book up to this point. I rarely read a physical book anymore and buy digital. The only time length of the book matters to me is audiobooks. If an audiobook in under 11-12 hours I have to love the author or like the brief sample to justify the purchase. In terms of story, my only critique with the ending is that it doesn't feel like there is a payoff for the reader as much of a payoff for Tobias. I don't know your plans for the plot, but I feel this is lacking a hook/cliffhanger for the next book at this point such as him have, some sort of power up/ dao breakthrough or an introduction to the next struggle he is going to face. Right now this seems like a stand alone novel, which is not to diminish the quality of your writing. It just feels like there is nothing major driving him on at this point now that he and his family are safe. So if you do divide it up you might want to add something as I assume there will be some time between publications. If it is one large book this wouldn't be as necessary. That being said I will keep on reading as long as you keep on writing. Thank you for everything up to this point.

Ken WoTCom

I agree that you should split it up into a trilogy but if you're truly torn you could potentially have the audio and Kindle versions available as a box set with the physical version being three books. Perhaps Body, Mind and Soul or perhaps Initiate, Foundation and Core depending on how The story progresses.

Nicholaus

A printed book isn't something I will purchase myself, The Audiobook is what I am looking forward to! If its 3 audio books that works! However you need to split it up to make it work will be fine. suggested edit "After this final meeting, they would go directly to chi chi-saturated cultivation chambers to correct their meridian instability." remove chi, so it reads "go directly to chi-saturated cultivation chambers"

Richard

I'm stoked that this is just Act I. I'd been afraid it was going to end soon. No issues with it being split up. I'm going to second things others have said. I don't really buy physical books anymore. Given number of words it sounds like 3 audiobooks would all be a decent length so that's amazing! Seems like splitting will both increase your reach and be better financially. Increasing reach as new folks are maybe more likely to give a chance to a smaller cheaper book of an author they've never read before. Also increases the number of highly rated books you have which again might help with discovery.

Jim Smith

I believe 3 books makes more sense, because if nothing else, you're writing time is such that one gigantic book that cost $18 or $15 is less likely to be purchased than 3 at $5 or $6. There is also less likely to be momentum for you as an author, as that means a longer time between publications. If those aren't concerns I have no problem with a longer book, but as I don't normally buy physical books anymore due to space constraints and utility, it doesn't really matter to me if there is a physical version. I read Farmer 1 and 2, and it was on my phone, computer or tablet. I am a great fan of physical books, but even for series I love, it would take a lot for me to order one. Even if they have kick starters with covers, and artwork, all of which are great, I read for the story and the words, which a physical book provides, but with a bit less ease of transportation and potentially access, baring power outages. You can certainly tweak the end point, or the add in an epilogue, his families safety is important, and the protection of the clans for his family and himself is really a lot of what he wanted... that said, I don't think it had that quality of a pay off that I wanted. I know at this point, he has to want the imperial family replaced, and to increase his cultivation, and progress with Xu Ling, and it really felt more like another chapter. Maybe a stronger declaration from the Lee Patriarch, or meeting with his sister or another family member and letting them know that they finally have a greater level of protection from the Princes. It didn't feel, at least to me, like the book ended.

Sam Britton

Long time reader, first time commenter. I think 3 books makes perfect sense. That being said, this feels like a bad place to end Act I. The last few chapters have felt to me like the upswing of Act II. I personally think ending book one with Tobias returning from the palace, and healing his body, seems like a well structured end to act one. Yes this may cause some bloat for the second act, but ending book one on an emotional high seems more important. This has been my Ted talk, Sam