Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Chapter 41

Brienne shouldn’t be alive. She took stock of her injuries as she warily looked at the man… the thing that had saved her. The air was still cold, yet no vapors came from him. Why a wight would drive back other wights and save her made her muddled thoughts congeal. It was too much for the moment, so she focused on what she could.

Her hand had been partially burned. It hurt terribly, which she counted as, mayhaps, a good sign. It could still grip things properly. Her shoulder was deeply bruised and her neck was quite stiff. She had taken a blow to the head at some point and one of her knees hurt every time she took a step. The small cave with its small fire allowed for warmth to gather, but the memory of the bitterest cold of her life still seemed to crowd upon her.

“Who are you?” Brienne eventually asked.

“A brother of the Night’s Watch,” replied the creature. His voice was like leaves scraping across stones, almost too thin to sound like a man’s.

Once… perhaps.

“Your name?”

The thing did not answer. Brienne waited for an answer before asking again. Still no answer.

“I must thank you for saving me. You and your steed, both. I am Brienne of Tarth. I would have answers for what happened.”

The heavily cowled man looked at her.

“I can lead you back to the Wall. But if you want answers, then you must do a boon in return.”

Brienne’s heart clenched. Her duty had been to serve her Lord Renly and learn what was transpiring north of the Wall. It was not the most important task of her life. But she could not blindly accept such an agreement.

“What is the boon? My house is sworn to Lord Renly Baratheon. I can accept a reasonable request, but nothing that would violate my oaths or my honor.”

The silence deepened.

“I can lead you to where you find answers. It won’t be me that gives them, but another.”

Brienne was frustrated. Yes, this… man or thing had rescued her. Astride a giant elk, he had smashed away the grasping claws of the dead. She shuddered at the memory. Near the end she had seen that the recently slain Erryk was one of them. But at the same time, he was not trustworthy at all. Where did her duty lay? Possible further answers, or should she take what she had already learned and make it back to the Manderly ships?

“Did… did any of the others make it? I know Ser Guyard was trying to get to the horses to retreat.”

The figure shrugged.

Brienne suppressed a groan. Making it back to the ships would take more than a day, and if the wights were still out there, there was little hope of doing so alone. Somehow she doubted the great elk would consent to being ridden by her.

Slim chance, but a choice. He wants me for something, but I can think of little that would be worse than being torn apart by wights.

“I can make no guarantees, but I will go to this other who has answers about what is taking place here.” 

“Rest, it will not be a swift journey. I will see that you come to no harm while you sleep.” 

Strangely enough, Brienne believed him.

***

Robert rolled over, satisfied and deliciously weary. Raya murmured her own delight. A whore she might be, but knowing how young ladies thought was something that just seemed natural for women. Both Myrcella and Sansa had enjoyed their gifts.

With Sansa, he hadn’t been sure at first. She seemed almost wary of it. The way she had hesitated after putting it on had crushed him. Sansa had opened her mouth and it was like a crushing weight had descended on Robert’s chest. The gift that he had been so proud of was not something she liked?

I shouldn’t have worried. It was just Sansa being Sansa.

He recalled how she closed her mouth and her eyes welled with unshed tears as she looked away from him.

“’Tis… ‘tis more than I imagined. I feel unworthy of it, but thank you, Your Grace. It is beyond a wonder.”

The weight had lifted and Robert had known profound joy as Ned’s daughter had embraced him. Both of the girls oohed over how it looked on each other. The girl’s wolf seemed very confused by her master’s outpouring of emotion, for Sansa was always tightly wound within herself.

Just like Ned. Even in victory he kept that long face. Gods, he really needed to learn to live. Not every waking moment must be dedicated to solemn duty!

Since then, the affairs of state had wearied him considerably. It was no wonder a man might grow sick having to tolerate the heat and ponderous nothings from his council. The new Grand Maester, Gormon Tyrell, was proving less ponderous than Pycelle had been, but it was still a wretched experience hearing his small council talk of counting coppers endlessly.

Kevan was proving less adept at finding coin than Littlefinger had been. He was raising the cost of doing things, such as even having people pay coin to cross the gates. Robert knew that would put a damper on his planned tourney. The smallfolk of the city were also restless as the new master of coin tried to extract more for the treasury.

When he complained to Sansa she had talked about how there were always trade-offs. It seemed Littlefinger had borrowed so heavily to pay for excess that Robert had demanded. Something that was never truly sustainable and now measures had to be put in place that were unpopular. It was greatly aggrieving to him. No wonder his constitution had plagued him of late.

“You normally wish to partake more than once, my king.”

Robert ran his hands down her pale skin. She ran hot, but even so he found himself adoring the sensation.

“Not tonight. I require my strength for the morrow.”

“What is tomorrow?” 

“Court. A number of decisions must be made. My brother tires me, but Sansa pointed out something to me that has made me reconsider.”

“Mmm, the wolf girl, I’ve seen her beast. It frightens people at times; I wonder if it might be happier in a place less crowded. Maybe a section of the godswood.” 

“No, she’s right where she should be,” Robert said firmly. “In any event, Sansa has spoken well of Stannis, to my surprise. Even compares his sense of honor to that of her father’s.”

“I thought you said they were at odds?” Raya questioned.

“Oh, they are, but she says that his refusal to give in to what my brother views as a lie makes him consistent. And consistency in a ruler is much better than someone who is more… ah, the word, mercurial I think she used. With Renly clamoring to make it clear who the Lord Regent would be if I were to fall… well perhaps Stannis would be ideal if we could come to terms regarding my children. She thinks he would make a fine Lord Regent in such an event.”

The whore hesitated for a moment, the movement of her hand down toward the lower half of his body halted.

Robert wasn't sure whether he should command her to continue or tell her to leave off. Before he could truly decide, he drifted into sleep.

***

Margaery looked at Sansa and was surprised by her state. Her dress was fine, her hair well brushed, but she looked overly weary and distracted. Her normally-well composed face, showing naught but smiles or neutrality, was oddly twitchy.

“Is aught amiss, Sansa? You seem distracted.”

Sansa’s blue eyes met Margaery’s gaze.

“I have been working with Lord Tyrion on using Myrish lenses to allow those with poor eyesight to still be able to see effectively. I admit, when I launched this endeavor I did not expect it to take up so much time.”

Margaery looked intrigued. “Truly? I have an uncle who complains bitterly that books are writ too small. Could that help him?”

Sansa nodded with a bright smile on her face. “Absolutely, that is their purpose. It is worthy work; it is just time consuming. Within less than a year we will have multiple different versions of varying strength that will allow all but those with the worst eyesight to read anything they wished.”

Margaery took her hands in hers. “That is incredible! Your wits are always a marvel.”

The younger girl’s smile faded. “Would that were true,” she said with bitterness.

“What’s that?”

Sansa shook her head. “Nothing I wish to speak of, just that no one is above making errors of judgement.”

I’ve learned that Sansa often hints at things. What is she trying to tell me?

Her grandmother was beginning to respect Sansa, but still felt that the Starks had ruined her with her bluntness. Margaery disagreed, but she was done arguing with her sharp-tongued grandmother. It was a different time. Robert a different king. The man was direct; no wonder he would listen to others who matched that candor.

Changing the subject, Margaery asked Sansa what she thought of the potential match of Lord Renly and Lady Arianne. Sansa hesitated for a long moment before answering. That too was odd, normally her responses never held such a pause.

“It is an odd match given Dorne’s previous royal marriage. Bringing the Martells back into the fold is wise, but the timing is interesting. Yes, Lord Renly has only recently begun seeking a wife in earnest, but still might cause the king to be wary.”

Margery understood well what Sansa was suggesting. Robert was not yet forty, but he was not healthy. Excess drink could age a man beyond the years he’d lived and once Robert was gone, Renly could easily bring up the issue of Tommen and Myrcella’s heritage. With Stannis still removed from the line of succession that would mean Lord Renly could become King Renly.

Renly wouldn’t harm Robert, but when the day dawned where Robert was no more, he could easily make a bid for the crown. He assumes my family would support him. Combine that with Dorne…

“He can hardly blame his brother for following his commands. His Grace said that Renly must wed. Now he seems to be serious. But still, ‘tis quite early. Perhaps they will mislike each other.”

Sansa’s face twisted. “I doubt she’s come all this way for nothing. I am curious, Margaery, why hasn’t your eldest brother wed?”

“You’ll have to ask my father. In truth… Willas would be a fine match for any lady, but his injury has some lords look at him as a lesser. My father will not deign to have him wed beneath his station, which gives few options. With Garlan already wed, it is not as urgent. Though I do worry about Leonette. She has yet to quicken with child.”

Sansa pursed her lips. “Sometimes that is the way of things, sometimes it isn’t even the woman’s fault either.”

Margaery laughed. Sansa had such unusual thoughts sometimes.

“Returning to Arianne, I wonder how she will like the court.” She lowered her voice. “I’ve heard a story or two about her.”

Sansa shrugged. “There was a story or two about you and others about me here in court. Stories could be true, or they could be not. I’d not hold them against her, regardless. Though I must wonder if she is of the same opinion of her father about His Grace.”

Margaery tilted her head a bit, signaling her curiosity.

“Doran Martell no doubt despises His Grace for calling his dead kin ‘dragonspawn’ and refusing for justice to be done. If Arianne does not hold that same grudge, given she was younger than ten when it all came to pass, why wait to become the queen when Robert passes?”

Her eyes widened. “You don’t mean… you think she might mean to seduce Robert?”

Sansa took a sip from her cup. “I don’t mean anything, other than that the possibility may exist. I don’t know her at all. It is just something I wonder from time to time as to what will occur. What happens to the claim I had early assumed Arianne may want to press as Renly’s wife, if His Grace were to remarry and have more children?”

“Does he wish to remarry?”

“Not at the moment, no. But he is young yet, but it also creates another situation where Tommen’s ascension could be cut short if he has a half-brother. The situation is still worryingly unresolved and can turn in many different directions. I’d prefer to live in less interesting times, myself.”

Margaery laughed. “Oh, but that would be no fun!”

Sansa gave her a momentary look of disgust before smoothing her face and apologizing.

“I’m sorry, I’m poor company. I should go, but we should invite Arianne to join us for one of these gatherings when she arrives.”

Oh I intend to!

***

Something was wrong. But whenever Arya tried to ask about why they weren’t doing any of their normal warg activities, Sansa cut her off before she could even finish her thought. A sharp shake of her head and a direct glance before brushing it off. It didn’t make sense.

Does she think we are being watched?

Arya considered that, but she had mastered partial slipping and had borrowed Nymeria’s senses and couldn’t detect anyone, by smell or hearing. She couldn’t understand why Sansa wouldn't even talk about it. There were so many important things to do! The passageways around the Red Keep were exciting to explore as Ser Pounce. Now it seemed like it had just been pushed to the side. The only other thing she got out of Sansa was a whispered request to ‘be good.’ Whenever she tried to ask any additional questions the sharp look returned.

Deciding that something had to be done, she talked to Jory.

“Jory, Sansa is acting strange. Has she been bothered by something?”

“She seems wearier than usual. But, my lady, have you tried just asking her?”

Arya gave him a look. “Of course I’ve tried. She just shushes me! But you are the captain of her guard.”

Jory gave a brief laugh. “Your father’s guard, just temporarily assigned to keep her safe.”

This isn’t helping.

Arya sighed. “I’m going to go visit the prince and princess.”

Jory bowed his head slightly and followed her along with Harwin. It was always two guards at a minimum these days. Myrcella was finishing some needlework and was happy to see her. Arya narrowed her eyes at the flash of gold and red at her wrist. That was just like the one Sansa wore and ever since she had started wearing it she had not wanted to warg.

“Princess Myrcella, can I see your bracelet?”

The princess nodded. “It’s very pretty. Sansa has one just like it. Oh, I’m sorry, did you want one too? Father got it for her since she’s supposed to marry into our family if your father agrees. But I’m sure if you ask you can get one too!” 

Arya calmed the princess down. She didn’t want something like that. But she did want to examine it.

Nothing out of the ordinary, but she wasn’t sure what she was looking for. She didn’t dare put it on, though, because she liked slipping her skin into Nymeria at times. After pretending to love it, she handed it back.

“My sister seems not herself recently. Did something happen when I wasn’t around?”

Myrcella shook her head. “No, not that I can think of.”

Arya left her and then questioned Tommen, but he was even less helpful. She returned to her room with Nymeria and wondered what she should do. She felt that it had to be something about the bracelet her sister had received. Sansa didn’t wear much jewelry, she had started wearing some silver pieces, but nothing so fancy as with a gemstone. Now she was wearing it and suddenly didn’t want to talk or skinchange?

It has to be it, and if it’s not… Well, I’ll think of something else.

As night fell and Sansa went to bed, Arya forced herself to stay awake. When Sansa’s breathing eased, Arya slowly and carefully sat up.

Swift as a deer. Quiet as a shadow.

The bed did not so much as creak. She looked at Visha, who had even more sensitive ears than Sansa. With a small smile she eased toward the dire wolf and gently woke the beast. Arya whispered softly to it.

“Be very quiet. I don’t mean Sansa any harm.” 

Visha looked at her for several long seconds and then closed her eyes. Arya took that as permission and slowly, carefully crept next to the second bed in the room.

Calm as still water.

Arya wasn’t sure why she had to slow her racing heart. All she was going to do was remove the bracelet. It was trivial. The memory of when Sansa had drawn her blade when Arya had leaped at her from hiding made her pause. If her sister awoke to someone trying to take something off her wrist would she react and stab before seeing who it was?

Fear cuts deeper than swords.

If she did, Arya would be ready to dart away. But for now, she wasn’t going to let worry stay her hand. Sansa’s breathing stayed even as Arya slowly positioned herself to undo the clasp in one smooth motion. Arya took a breath, held it, and then moved with all the grace she had learned from Syrio.

The bracelet opened and Sansa awoke.

***

I must admit that it had been quite the nasty trick. When the king’s bracelet was fastened around my wrist I instantly knew some other will was attempting to worm its way through mine. That was infuriating, of course, but easily dealt with. Or so I thought.

Breaking out of whatever sort of geas was child’s play. I didn’t even think it would do more than subconsciously influence someone, but like with my contest with the other skinchanger, how does one measure willpower? Maybe regular people would be subsumed by what I felt was just a nagging feeling that I should be kinder toward Stannis, be disgusted by Tommen, and never remove this piece of jewelry.

But as I thought to remove it, I felt it. Some sort of unseen connection between that action and Robert’s vitality. Even thinking about it caused him to turn pale. His eyes lost focus and a tremor appeared. I decided not to take it off and he instantly looked better.

What is this?

I tested it again. Merely intending to take it off caused the instantaneous worsening of Robert's health. Somehow the bracelet, likely the blood under the gemstone, had created some sort of magical link between the influence of it and the king’s health. If I were to snap the spell, I feared it might kill the king, and then who knows what would happen.

Instead, I had gushed about how wonderful it was and hid my earlier expression behind the idea that I wasn’t worthy of the bauble. From there I grew very, very paranoid and wondered how I could fix the issue. What was infuriating was that I suspected I was also being watched. I had no way of knowing if that was true or not, and the golden piece seemed to act on intention rather than someone observing and fiddling with a ‘Robert health knob’ but still.

After that day I resolved not to give away any more of my secrets in case that truly was what was happening. I could still warg, but a full-blown warg required me to be in a safe place since I was dead to the world while fully skin slipping. I still did so from the confines of a privy. It worked just fine, hopefully the momentary lapse of consciousness, if I was being watched, would be thought of some sort of fainting spell or just a really bad number two moment.

I kept my mind as blank as I could around those trigger thoughts, except when around the king. There, whenever I attempted to think of ways to get out of this predicament, I would notice his vitality was being leeched. If even planning would trigger Robert’s decline in health, then I was probably screwed. At some point I would just have to bite the bullet and snap the spell and then murder the most likely culprit.

Melisandre. So those old tales and fables of blood magic and foul sorcery from Asshai weren’t just sailors’ tales and xenophobic views of the far east of Essos. It does make me wonder if there are other avenues toward recreating my second life’s magic.

So far, the compulsion itself wasn’t dire outside of the maddening inability to make plans. Being nicer to Stannis had just taken on the form of letting him be the heir again. While his trust in the evil witch was bad, he at least seemed to take seriously the threat facing my father in the north, which meant he probably would be a better king than Renly would for the purposes of gathering aid. Being disgusted by Tommen didn’t change any of my plans, because why would distaste matter? It wasn’t as if I was championing him as the heir because I liked him. It was just business.

Maybe I’d make an exception for my family, but I don’t allow fondness and personal feelings to make me do foolish things.

The rub was what else would take place and if other demands could be stacked on the existing ones. Fortunately, it seemed I wouldn’t have to worry about that.

When I woke to see Arya hovering over me, bracelet it in hand my first instinct was concern. Would someone else removing the cursed jewelry trigger a catastrophic medical event for Robert? I had no way of knowing, and no time to spare.

“GUARDS! The king is in danger!”

Arya scrambled back, surprised.

“Don’t touch that! Put it under the pillow and don’t let anyone come in and take it. There’s some spell upon it. We might also be under magical surveillance, but right now my concern is the king.”

Arya just gaped at me while my guards asked what was wrong.

“No time! To the king, now!” I commanded and they fell in line.

Since we were ensconced within the Royal Apartments, it wasn’t as if the king was far from us. A bell began to ring and more shouts went up. Ser Loras was in front of the king’s bedroom with a quartet of Baratheon guards.

“Check on the king, now.” I snapped and Loras looked at me with a furrowed brow while the guards opened the door.

“What’s the meaning of this?” Robert asked as he stumbled to his feet. A dark-haired whore stirred sleepily beside him.

“A maester needs to check on you, but this may have been a false alarm.”

Ser Loras gathered his wits. “Do you think he was poisoned? Away from him,” he commanded the whore.

“Mind your tongue,” the king snapped in defense of his bed partner. “Seven hells!” Robert cried as he realized he was naked and I was now in the room with him. He grabbed a blanket and covered himself. “What is going on, Sansa? What’s this talk of poison?”

I shook my head. “Not poison, but something potentially worse.”

The whore was gathering her belongings. I couldn’t help but notice how pretty she was. It seemed that Robert still longed for my dead Aunt Lyanna, since she looked quite similar to the statue of Lyanna in the crypts of Winterfell.

“Speak!” Loras demanded and Robert snapped at him again. Poor guy.

“It was sorcery. Your brother’s witch from Essos.”

“I thought you said she was a charlatan?”

“So I thought, but I can think of no other culprit for this. Please order the arrest of your brother and Lady Melisandre.”

Robert nodded. “Go, see to it,” he commanded as more guards arrived. He then asked me to explain what was going on.

I eyed the other guards, the whore, Ser Loras.

“Perhaps it would be best if we wait for the maester and with fewer ears about. I come with speculation, not with certainty.”

“Too much of that these days,” Robert muttered.

Loras opened his mouth again. “Your Grace, you are ordering the arrest of your brother on the say so of a girl not yet ten-and-three. She’s roused the whole holdfast by this point. And it seems that you are quite well.”

Robert again defended me and said that he wished to hear what I had to say. As some of the guards exited the chamber, Visha growled and I was on guard immediately.

Why had she growled?

I borrowed her sense of smell and realized the whore had left with the guards and my eyes had glossed over her. She wasn’t invisible per se, but for some strange reason I must not have focused.

“What was the lady’s name who was here?” I asked.

Robert looked confused for a moment. “Oh, uh,” he scratched at the back of his neck. “She’s kept me company as of late.”

“After Lady Melisandre arrived?”

The king furrowed his brow. “Yes, now that you mention it.”

“Please order her arrest as well, go Ser Loras, find her quickly.”

Robert nodded, but for the fourth time Loras put his foot in his mouth, again. “My place is here by your side, Your Grace.”

“GO DAMN YOU,” Robert roared. “But see that she comes to no harm or I’ll give it to you tenfold.”

Robert turned to me. “Sansa, I trust you, but I will need to hear what your reasoning for all this is.”

I marshaled my thoughts, fully able to consider things without worrying about the impact of them and explained to him what had occurred. It was a shortened version of my thoughts, but essentially anytime I would even consider trying to remove his gift, give counsel that supported Tommen or harmed Stannis, it would cause him to have a physical reaction. Somehow my obedience to the inbuilt commands that came with the jewelry was linked to his health. I then explained how Arya removed it while I slept because she thought I had been acting off since wearing it.

Robert was skeptical, but as the hours and the night progressed, things began to be clear. Especially since there was no sign of Melisandre or Raya even as the Red Keep was sealed. Never one to miss a chance to kill two birds with one stone, I suggested that there must be some sort of hidden exit from the Red Keep. This would allow my ‘discovery’ of the tunnels and the creepy tongueless children to be explained.

More clarity occurred when Robert confessed to his memories being a bit fuzzy as well, but he was sure that it had been Raya who had suggested the matching bracelets for Myrcella and myself. He recalled speaking some words and taking part in a smallfolk tradition of pouring a bit of his blood in the recess of the gem.

“I remember a fire… and… words, a sense of rightness. I just wanted to make you and Myrcella happy. Ladies like jewels and belonging and Raya made it sound like it was a regular thing…” he trailed off sheepishly.

Ser Barristan, who had now arrived and heard my explanation, looked at the king with raised eyebrows. “How could it be a smallfolk tradition if most smallfolk could not afford to waste coin on jewels?”

Robert growled at him, more embarrassed than angry.

I need more information on how all this magic works. I hate fumbling around in the dark. What puzzles me is if someone had the power to link someone’s vitality, their very physical health, why do it in this way? The king already seemed to be willing to let himself take part in some bizarre blood ritual, why include me at all?

With no sign of Melisandre or her accomplice, I doubted I would be getting many answers soon on that end. I was going to be very curious as to what Stannis would say and in the meantime, it was time to expand my knowledge. I was going to cast a very wide net. The Citadel needed to cough up everything they knew about the ‘higher mysteries’ that they claimed was all chicanery. I would also send word to Qarth and see if one of their ‘warlocks’ had information or could even come in person. I had also thought the alchemists of Lys were just doing poison and chemistry work, not actual magic as the rumors claimed, but they too would be another path to potentially figuring out what the hell was going on.

Fuck it, I’ll even ask the Royces about their runed armor, though I’m pretty positive that, at least, was bullshit. Not every story of magic could be true.

Author's Note: Originally the reveal was going to be the next chapter and there was going to be more 'what exactly is going on with Sansa' without her POV but it seemed a bit mean with the weekend here to keep people frustrated with a plotline that didn't get that well received. Also, just as a quick reminder, just because Sansa thinks something is true, doesn't make it true.

Comments

SlanneshSoldier69

TfTC I was indeed surprised this was resolved this chapter, but it feels good for it to have been. Honestly I know you changed it due to feedback, but an alternative thing you could do is just hold off on the chapter with thr braclet and just release them all at once. That way people calm down. There was nothing wrong with what you did and the fact Sansa was not fully mind controlled just cant go against Stanis made it much better. You could actually still do what you intended if you want. Just add an im between chapter between this one and the last one.

Green0Photon

Ok I admit I was wrong. Author is very big brain. The magic was just Melisandre being really clever in a way a protag might be. That is, I'm pretty sure it was a sort of glamour over Bobby B, possibly only from Sansa's perspective, possibly in general. Very in line with the magic system and not OP at all. No story breaking nonsense, just pure cleverness. I should've trusted the author more. I am very happy it ended after a single chapter though lol. Though I can easily imagine it being perfectly fine to last slightly longer or have run into more troubles before resolution. Yet, I'm happy that Bobby B has grown to take it seriously and handle everything properly. Now I'm very curious tbh what the original story would've looked like. Because we literally just ran into the serialization problem, that the situation was too tense to have readers receive it well unless they receive it all at once. Big oof.

Ant1h3ld

So, Melisandre was obviously Raya, which means she has her chamber locked and loaded. Any bets on who the shadow demon baby is going to be aimed at?

Green0Photon

Yeah having it be her genuinely in a dilemma where it's legit her choice to stay in the trap to prevent something bad from happening is very big brain. Although it would lessen the impact, I wonder if the previously chapter could've been written such that it's clear that Sansa still had no mind control or anything. Just that she was stuck in a dilemma. Thing is, part of the intrigue this chapter is wondering what's up with her. So idk. It does feel like the best solution in retrospect would've been to just wait and then release the three chapters at once

Bruhdude

So fun, but the pyromancers are right there and could propably know about the magic requiring sacrifice stuff, and could be there in 30 mins tops as well. Thanks for not cliffhangering as as well.

Green0Photon

So that guy who saved Brienne is Coldhands, right? Didn't realize that he and Benjen aren't the same person in books. Who could he possibly want to lead Brienne to? No way it's the Raven, right?

Jason Dixon

i really gotta wonder what mel was trying to accomplish and why it required such a nonsensical method. it just seems like no matter what her actual goal was she picked the strangest and most convoluted way to do it.

Louis Webster

Brienne going on a trip in the cold dark north with a cold navigator. Im sure nothing goes wrong there. Sansa gets put into a minor illusion and decides all magic is to be studied because never again.

Failninjaninja

Coldhands is not Benjen, I think that was a show change... honestly I don't actually remember what the show did, but he def is not Benjen in the books

Green0Photon

Yeah that's what I just realized lol, in the reverse. It's a show change. And like a lot of show changes, a dumb one, but it's what I was exposed to ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Darkarma

For a second there I thought whatever was used to make the gem was turning Robert in a yandere that'd eventually kill Tansa

Enkelados

Having no POV of sansa analyzing or fighting against the influence and only outside pov her changed behaviour felt very frustrating to read. I'm glad you decided to cut that storyline short, even of it feels a bit hasty.

BIGJOSEPHINE

Raya is obviously Varys in disguise

arnumart

But they are or were true at one time Sansa that is part of the Lovecraft horror of the world.

loyalChaos

I feel like if this wasn't resolved this quickly, and you went ahead with the slower draft, the lack of Tansa POV chapters (because you want to hide the mystery) would have made the other portions of the story seem *way* less important. Readers would overly focus on the things going on in Kings Landing, instead of also focusing on the North.

Green0Photon

Makes sense for me. She has a limited set of magical tools, but she's also gonna be jumping to using them. Her goal is to get Sansa, her biggest obstacle she can see, out of the way of Stannis. It can't be too overt as killing her or disappearing her, otherwise Bobby B would notice and turtle up. She needs to be able to gain influence over him without anyone else subtly counteracting her. And every other male voice is too obvious, besides her and Sansa. We know she has her self glamour tied to the blood gem at her chest, so it's not much of a stretch to make something similar for Sansa to wear that works in reverse -- making her see Bobby B as worse than he is. Cause I'm pretty sure other people didn't see it. Both cause no evidence of that, but also that would run counter to the purpose of the plan. Assuming Mel actually sees Sansa as a kid, it's much of a stretch to just tie it to health alone, with anything going against her hurting that. Nothing more complicated needed to get someone to stop. It's a brilliant decision by the author imo, because it uses exactly the magic she's already known to have, just used slightly differently in a way that's very easy to assume is also allowed. It's also a very weak magic used very cleverly, putting a protag in a situation where it's all about logic and character interaction. It's exactly how you'd want to design a story -- using just the minimum amount of magic necessary to achieve story goals, instead of using OP magic everywhere. Could Mel and Stannis used a non-magic approach, instead of something more convoluted and magical? Yeah, but that's not their role in ASOIAF stories. Their role is the big hammer that doesn't play the game socially, but with magic and inflexibility. They don't come to court and play around with spies and whispering into the king's ear. Stannis only knows how to speak his mind or not at all, and the only thing Mel knows how to do is praise the Lord of Light and use magic. Everything was perfectly in character for them. 🤌

bulcsu fajszi

Actually, I am positively surprised by what you cooked up, with Robert's blood being willingly given it did make sense he was the one affected if Sansa did try to remove it. (Or was your original plan different with more complete mind control?) I think it was a good plotline, people tend to assume Tanya is hyper-competent and Mel is incompetent, but Tanya does have her blind spots while Mel is very experienced and relatively competent, just overestimates herself.

Chris

I'm now curious what the original plotline would have been like... Would probably have been a good mystery

Green0Photon

Yeah in retrospect this was a perfectly fine Tanya slip, perfect way that she'd be stuck analyzing it and not appropriately slipping a hint, perfect way that Mel would cook something up deviously simple yet complicated, that really should work but fail due to her overconfidence.

MD

"Doran Martell no doubt despises His Grace for calling his dead grandchildren ‘dragonspawn’ and refusing for justice to be done" Unless I'm mistaken weren't those his nephew/niece?

Green0Photon

Yeah if there were other KL scenes planned I'm interested in what those would've been. But if it was just other non KL scenes that would've been more of a problem. I mean, it does feel like it resolved very quick, which I'm both happy and sad about, but idk. Might've been interesting if Mel had some other temporary W arising from this, or there was something else for Bobby B to regret about. But it's still good!

Combusted_Petroleum926

I will admit, I was also a little pessimistic after the previous chapter ended as the way it did on a cliffhanger, but I'm happy that - both in a Watsonian and Doylistic perspective - the scheme from Melisandre was discovered quickly, we had a Tansa POV showing the aftermath and Bobby B was willing to trust her enough to let her explain her reasoning. TYFTC

bulcsu fajszi

I mean, Mel does have some social skills; it is not by accident that she did manage to convert many nobles and soldiers in Dragonstone. She just recognised when arriving at Robert's court that this is not going to work with the King due to Sansa unless she somehow neutralizes her/turns her to their side.

Hooli4ss

That red whore really played with the wolf and didn’t finish the job. She got one over on Tanya though , respect for the attempt . Robert looks like a real fool right now , ask Barristan lol! Knowing her she has the tools of destruction ready to unleash upon Robert himself( would be his own fault.) ! They gotta find her quick . Mel escaped but it won’t be for long , her actions have set SaTan on full alert . Maybe it’s just me but I have a feeling KingsLanding is about to see true power at work . Not only did she sound the alarm , but she made everyone move at once , that is power. Loras is about to run to his Granny for this one lol, Olenna POV on the way? Seriously though , she’s talking about bringing in warlocks , ordering the Citadel to cough up the cheese, even asking Royce for family secrets ? It’s about get real , knowledge is POWER. Shoutout to the MVP though , Arya you have learned well . “ The lone wolf dies but the pack survives .” If she wasn’t there learning from the best , Sansa would be in trouble . The influence she has on her sister showed this day . Great chapter 👌🏾 you cooked .

DatCameraMON

As someone who didn't like the last chapter because of what happened, I agree that some of the proposed solutions here would have definitely improved my opinion of it.

Dave Steele

The charm itself was surprisingly really clever of Mel. It would’ve worked damn near perfectly if it wasn’t for that meddling kid. Too bad Mr Stan is screwed. Again. This time for something he didn’t even do. What makes it even worse is that Mel’s plan would’ve likely been completely foolproof if Satan was just a really weird young girl like she (unintentionally) portrays herself to be. Unfortunately, trying to out willpower the Devil of the Rhine is a fool’s errand.

Dave Steele

They unfortunately stonewalled her previously.

a anderson

Na, punishment is due. That plot hook was good. Had my blood pumping for some drama and intrigue. Especially cause I was hoping to see some of the other side characters shine, trying to figure out what is wrong with Tansa. Next time, do a plot hook like this and leave it unresolved for like ten chapters. Let the readers suffer......I may also be a little sad/mad at not getting to see Arya, Tomeen, Marsella, and Margaery begin investigating the changes todather.

Dave Steele

Maybe Renly? Mel is stupid but she’s definitely not dumb enough to try and use it on Satan (I hope). Killing Renly would clearly make her out to be a rogue asset and might exonerate Stan.

Half Baked Cat

I like the way this went because Sansa knew something was wrong with the bracelet, but couldn't turn it down in the moment and was able to partially fight off the effects of it. And we get to have Arya come in clutch by noticing the oddness of how Sansa was acting, figure out the source, and how to resolve the problem.

Sirius

That would be so funny, everyone blaming Melisandre only to find out it’s Varys when they unmask Raya

OdaoistOd

Yeah I mean brainwashing is never well received even when well done, so while it was resolved pretty quickly it was for the best that you did so. Now let’s see they have to take the amulet from Myrcella and that should prove that something fucky was going on. And finally Arya keeps proving why it’s good to have allies that know how you operate to notice strange things happening to you.

Ramsisuno

Honestly I'm a bit annoyed with some of the other readers who had no patience and immediately started attacking you and the text just for giving the main character their first real road bump in a few minutes. I enjoyed the resolution of this plot point nonetheless, but as good as it is to accept criticism, I do hope you won't take it personally or let these things hurt your personal plans for the story in the future Now that my complaints are off my chest, Lets go Arya! I knew you could figure it out! I'm surprised to see Coldhands popping up this early into the story, even though I probably shouldn't be, and with Brienne of all people! Or at least I assume it is Coldhands. I'm so looking forward to having Arianne, Margaery, and Tansa all in the same room, Arianne is a character that I really wish we got to see more of in cannon, not to mention we will also have Oberyn, Renly, Stannis, Tyrion, Olena, and even more of the cast in Kings landing at the same time. I think this is more players all in the same place at the same time than I can think of ever happening in cannon. Edit: It occurred to me the spell linking tansa and Robert vitality together might have been what the vision of the wolf and stag burning together warned.

mistakenot

Brienne lives! At least for now. Wary of Bloodraven's intentions given how Arya got screwed over in another world. Brienne isn't a warg, so there shouldn't be the same risk, but still worried for her. Not sure I understood this line: > "She didn’t dare put it on, though, because she liked slipping her skin into Nymeria at times." Had Arya already come to the conclusion that the bracelets were interfering with warging or something? (Though we later learn from Sansa's POV that she could still warg.) > "It wasn’t as if I was championing him as the heir because I *liked* him. It was just business." "Baka!" :p I'm very interested to hear what Stannis has to say as well. I don't think Melisandre would abandon Stannis so easily, so I'm guessing she's still hiding in the city.

Christian Jeffress

So SaTan had a geas slightly affecting her mind, but she was able to push past it, as well as a connection to the intent of removing the bracelet compared to Robert’s . At least that’s the assumption. Is this just her perspective, or true? I’m just trying to make sure I’m getting exactly what happened. Lol. Still, I really love that her sister noticed right away that something was wrong with SaTan, since it is a nice way to show their growing connection. Yeah, SaTan is always bad with her emotions, but those are usually shown through action rather than any form of self admittance lol. Robert trusting her right away was fun to see, but it was also nice that it was helped along by him noticing certain odd things that had been clouded by magic before. Is it just me,or has his critical thinking skills been trained to the point of better observation? Anyway, thanks for another great chapter, and thanks for not stringing out the cliffhanger into a torturous length lol.

Silver W. King

I think this chapter would make Tansa go "I'm not asking anymore. GIVE ME YOUR KNOWLEDGE!"

Gaerdir

Awesome chapter. The cliffhanger did a great job, and this one we see Tanya’s influence completely unmasked in front of others. Going to be interesting to see the fallout in the views of the other players

Silver W. King

"Sansa gave her a momentary look of disgust before smoothing her face and apologizing." You know, I think this part perfectly describes Tansa's opinion on the whole game of thrones that Margery seems to enjoy. Tansa wishes for just normal succession and a stable realm, but everyone around her is stupid ambitious and wants to be the one to rule and so what if a few wars happen to cause that outcome. They get to be on top in the end, and damn all the chaos and lives lost. That's just smallfolk's lives spent as normal.

Paul Schaffert

And we would have gotten away with it if it weren't for those meddling kids and their dog

Mana Rope

"Chamber locked and loaded" is a choice of words that fit perfectly. Have a like.

Gornyetch

I remember contributing to the shadow baby aged/drained Stannis, which could be a factor in Robert's health in the future. I don't remember if Stannis had to be a willing part of the spell or not, which might affect if Robert being an unwitting donor matters here.

Akel

Well hell, that blew up alot faster than I thought it would. Expectations subverted. Well done!

May

Overall, I think solving the mystery of what's going on with Sansa in this chapter is an alright choice (though your original idea wasn't bad, as I have full faith you would've executed it well either way), but my one suggestion would be to maybe add one more scene before Arya's POV? As it is, it feels a bit too short, but that's just my opinion. Also, does it count as the burning wolf and stag from Melisandre's vision? Wolf being Tansa, ofc, mind-whammied, and stag Bobby B magically coerced into donating that sweet, sweet royal blood to the bracelet, and burning symbolizing Mel (let's be honest, there's no better symbol for her than that). Either way, loving the story <3 Also, love Tansa being attacked by magic and just...immediately revaluating her whole opinion about magic in Westeros and Melisandre's threat level.

Artemis1992

Yeah, Sansa was a lot more affected than she let herself believe.

Dmitry Gumin

TL;DR: Thank you for exceeding my expectations, as usual :p. I was honestly really impressed by how open you were to the feedback and the resulting adjustments. I’ve seen authors who seem to take their Patreon supporters for granted. That doesn’t mean every disagreement or criticism should result in a change, of course, but being responsive and willing to remain flexible feels like a very healthy approach to maintaining a strong Patreon community in the long term.

May

Yeah, you're remembering it correctly: Ageon and Rhaenys were his nephew and niece respectively. Elia was his and Oberyn's sister.

Hawkin

Not sure about how quick Arya discovering the source of the problem was.

Failninjaninja

Normally Sansa would warg regularly into Anna and now she was refusing to and when Arya tried to bring it up she shot shushed, so Arya thought it might have an impact on warging if she was correct in her theory. In actuality the bracelet doesn't stop warging at all

bulcsu fajszi

Yes, I am curious to hear it as well. Did Failnininja plan Mel to achieve some real success, or was she always meant to be discovered before she could score an actual win?

Failninjaninja

Don't hype it up too much! I was modelling it after my previous cliffhanger where the event happens in Chapter A. Chapter B has no POV of the effected character. And Chapter C has us back into the head of the character. Very close to how I did Myrcella out the Moon Door. The difference would have been a few extra POVs of different people noticing something off about Sansa and a slightly different convo with Margaery. Ultimately nothing changing the direction of the story, Mel was always going to be found out.

Revan

"Social Skills" You mean a lack of modesty and the illusion of big tits.

SlanneshSoldier69

I once read a book where a villain character murdered a "main" side character and didnt get to see justice until like 4 books equivalent later... I luckily had all of them and was just speed reading through it. Author killed of some more side characters too before it was resolved.

Revan

Did said author abbreviate their name with four letters?

Dave Steele

Idek what bloodraven’s plan is at this point. Things haven’t gotten Charlie Foxtrot like AYGGOT so I don’t see him personally taking to the field like there. I honestly think he’s scared on some level. It’s one thing for a completely Out of Context problem like Tancella to pop up out of nowhere since he doesn’t know how much a threat she truly is. It’s another for someone to get close to beating him at his OWN GAME. And after doing so, she kicks the hornets nest that is the Others into making a direct appearance (with several survivors) a year early. It’ll be even more wild if Ned rather than Sam is the one to actually kill one of them. Also Brienne is kind of a wild card whose direction in the narrative I can’t even guess.

Alatoic

Glad Brianne is alive, I am sure who is her savior, so sad for him but at least he is doing good as long as possible. Thanks for making short the bracelet arc, it would have created a lot of problems as TanSa would be out of the game to long and she did not have real way to counter it. Arya was quite cleaver, knew something was wrong and act to correct the issue, really well done. And now the pay up. Tansa is not going to take the mental attack quietly. Melissandre will have to flee and I am not sure Stannis is going to get out w/o sever penalties. The good think is that with this magical attack TanSa will ask the king (and he will agree as there is proof) for tomes of magic, even a maester to know about it (dont remember his name, have red teeth for the herbs he masticate), someone from Essos maybe and I am sure the runes of they Royces work, just need to be "power up" to work again or some rune is missing (maester's tempering?) so it can auto recharge.

Paradoxez Novel Reader

Honestly, I love it. All the meticulous, carefully laid intrigues make those moments where Sansa just goes, "Fuck it, this is FUBAR situation, we ball !" and drops massive plot-reveal bombs absolutely spectacular.

Mentos

A WoW Death Knight saved Brienne! Maybe she'll become a paladin. Jokes aside, Suggestion, huh? That certainly fits Mel more than straight mind control. And Santana suspected remote viewing, as explanation for skipping wargtime. She might have to spill the beans about warging to Bobby B after this, she looks a bit crazy otherwise. Magic is horseshit to Westerosi after all.

Lolernator

Not sure what you mean by a plotline that wasnt recieved well, i think everythings been great.

Flinxie

Fuck yeah, Arya!

Cinema Man

“Doran Martell no doubt despises His Grace for calling his dead grandchildren" Doran was cracking his MAMA!!!!!!!!!????????????? Fail you gotta fix this why I read this while watching a vid about a woman finding out her shitty mother was fucking her shitty abusive fiance then husband 😭😭😭

Eleyvie

They may have stonewalled her before, but do they still wish to stonewall her when the issue can be easily interpreted as high treason and attempted regicide?

BIGJOSEPHINE

Just a question but why was Littlefinger saying the crown was after arresting him? I probably missed something but I thought he was just kicked off of the small council (or is he just lying to Lysa?)

Failninjaninja

Chapter 34: The trial proceeded. Robert questioned Jaime on who participated. He named the names of the red cloaked guardsmen, Littlefinger, Janos Slynt, and the other members of the Kingsguard who had spoken out against him.

BIGJOSEPHINE

I completely missed that thanks for answering

Gornyetch

It was nice to see Arya's training (by Syrio and Sansa) pay off

sparkc

Last sentence is key here. It annoys me immensely how safe most serials play it with their protagonists and the inability to put them through any hardship, but serials by their drip feed nature *do* exacerbate the frustration and negative feelings of such and the solution is to publish such chapters in a batch.

Maleficarum

Don’t forget that for every successful unsafe play/twist that pays off, there’s like 20 or more that do it hamfistedly or outright badly. If there’s push back against a certain trope or plot thread in a fic, and the fandom has been alive for a reasonable time, there’s a high chance someone has tried something in a general vein and done it badly enough to stick with readers. Worse still is when it’s a character alone that’s been badly done so even if they’re the most in character they’ve ever been, a badly managed plot thread regarding them can erode any trust quickly. Especially if certain Characters feel like they keep “escaping” by the skin of their teeth so a story may maintain its villain of the week