Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Special thanks to Massgamer for their editing help!

Chapter 49

"Your uncle's plan to duel Ser Gregor seems risky. I'd not see you in tears when we might expect happy word from your father soon," Renly said gallantly.

Arianne laughed. Many men would be enchanted by the way her bosom moved when she did so, but Renly was not most men.

"Do not underestimate him. He is the greatest spear in Dorne."

"And the Mountain is even stronger than me," Renly reminded. 

It was no idle boast. He knew he had the famed Baratheon strength. He also knew that the people cared over much for such matters, even more than a glib tongue, which was why he ensured that his physicality could be matched by few.

Save for the Clegane brothers and the Umbers, there were few who could match the size and strength of Robert of old and himself, who many claimed looked just like him in face and body. Jaime Lannister had been one of the most skilled knights in memory, but in this one area, Renly knew he had him beat.

He was also dangerously fast and one of the best riders in the realm. 

Some, like Yohn Royce, were taller than him, but he was a narrow man and Renly felt he could probably hurl him, armor and all. In the duels and wars of Westeros, your strength mattered a great deal. Being able to slam past someone's guard, throw them to the earth, and then knife them in the eye or under the gorget required great strength. Renly did not think Oberyn was weak, but he was certainly not someone who could resist being thrown.

"He's liable to get himself killed and lead your people to hate me by extension of being Robert's brother. I tell you, Oberyn stands no chance."

"Is that so?" Oberyn's voice was barely above a whisper. "Care to take to the yard and see?"

Renly was a trained warrior, but only middling with the sword and lance. Arianne looked amused and eager. Renly's cheeks pinked as he remembered some of the barbs Robert had sent his way when he was unhorsed.

"I am not the Mountain, but if you wish to spar we can. There are too many eyes here, let us go beyond the Red Keep to one of the privately housed ones. Ser Loras will be done with his duties for the day and can join us in a bell or two."

He doubted he would beat Oberyn, despite his strength and youth. But if he could even come close, then Arianne wouldn't lose her uncle, because he would see just how difficult it was to face someone stronger than you. Loras frowned when he heard the news but said little.

Oberyn chose to fight with a blunted spear against Renly's two-handed tourney sword.

"Is that all you intend to wear against the Mountain?"

"Anything more will slow me down. It will stop the tips of a slash, but should I be struck fully by his attacks, I will be on my back even in plate."

Which is the point, you arrogant fool. A fight against Ser Gregor only ends one way.

Renly advanced and swung. Oberyn just slid back and Renly followed. He backed up in a circle and made Renly chase him. Loras called out to fight with honor and Arianne laughed. Renly went to feint and then came at the Prince of Dorne with a sudden charge. Oberyn moved as fast as his namesake and, somehow, was on the other side of Renly and striking with the blunted spear into the back of his leg. The blow was pulled, but even so it caused him to limp for a moment.

"If that was the Mountain, he would now be tickled and would begin to slow."

Does he mean by blood loss, or poison?

He didn't ask and chose to fight more carefully. Oberyn was patient for a moment or two, and then used his superior reach to taunt Renly, jabbing in with thrusts toward his helm and then his body. The thrusts at the body could not go through the breastplate, even if it wasn't blunted, but Oberyn was deceptively strong for a man so slender.

Renly batted away a poke to the head and, with his sword out of position, Oberyn pushed in and looked as if he meant to shove him with his shoulder, which would have gone badly for him. But instead he spun away at the last second, the spear bashing against the side of Renly's knee. The armor held, but the blow sent shivers up his body, and the next strike caught him flat footed.

It was a humiliating affair; he couldn't ever catch the Red Viper, but the blunt stings from his spear found him easily enough. His ears were ringing fiercely by the time he raised his hand and yielded.

"As my brother would say, seven fucking hells, Oberyn. I haven't been beat around the yard like that since I was a boy."

Loras looked angry. Renly signaled Loras not to protest on his behalf, but his lover pushed forward.

"You fought like a coward. Come face me in the yard."

Oberyn laughed. "Oh, I've wanted to dance with you for some time," the man gave a slow wink and his paramour laughed. 

Ellaria Sand was a bastard, but she freely came and went as she pleased. None in King's Landing would offend the Red Viper over her seating beside him at any high table. Renly should have probably felt outraged or alarmed, but since he was getting in bed with the Martells anyway, that Oberyn had guessed Loras preferred men over women was likely no matter. That was the wisdom of the Tyrell plan for Loras; for as a member of the Kingsguard, the inclinations of a third son could cause little issue.

Loras is jealous of women who he knows I will not love. I cannot imagine the level of anger he would display if he knew I thought it might be interesting to spend time wrestling with Oberyn in some other fashion. 

Loras's flesh had turned as bright as a melon and he practically quivered in his armor, not from being a craven, but from rage.

"Please, we are all friends here, Renly stated. “Ser Loras, you are of the Kingsguard, and Prince Oberyn is a doughty fighter. I’m sure the ladies would like to see the two of you in the yard and he seems agreeable. With your tourney sword, ser."

The young knight spoke under his breath, accepted a one-handed blade, and then took up a shield as well. Oberyn waited in the center of the ring and the spar began.

Renly was a bit ashamed to realize just how much faster and more skilled the knight who was once his squire was. He must have looked like a lumbering buffoon by comparison, like his brother when he was deep in his cups.

The duel between Oberyn and Loras was far different than his own. Loras rushed Oberyn and was relentless in his assault. The Dornish man could not easily retreat from the younger knight as he had done with Renly. When Oberyn jabbed at his head, Loras tilted it to avoid it while still coming forward. When Oberyn tried to push him back, the shield came around and knocked the spear aside.

The clack of wood on tourney sword, shield, and armor continued with a furious precision that made Renly's jaw drop. Loras came in close, cutting off Oberyn, but the wily Prince of Dorne was not undone. As Loras came almost chest to chest, Oberyn used the haft of his spear to push him back while slipping a leg behind his foe's foot. The shove and trip took Loras to the ground, but he immediately rolled with the momentum and rose to his feet in one smooth motion despite his armor. As he was rising, Oberyn’s spear was slamming down at him, but was knocked aside by his blade.

Oberyn laughed. "Good, good! Your brother's claims of your skill were true!"

The battle continued, and Arianne moved closer to him.

"Shall we wager on the outcome?"

"What do you have in mind, my lady?"

"If my uncle wins, allow me to show you another ‘sport’ we enjoy in Dorne."

Renly took her meaning, but was not sure what to say. He could appreciate her beauty, but it did not raise his ardor. He could perform as necessary, thinking of other things, but it would be difficult to hide the fact he was not enamored with her charms.

In for a groat… 

"My lady, it is said your uncle lies with both men and women."

"Yes, and I myself have enjoyed the charms of women. My uncle's tastes do not make him any less a warrior."

"Obviously," Renly said with a smile as he rubbed what would no doubt turn into a bruise. "That is not why I bring it up. You are beautiful, Lady Arianne, but unlike your uncle, I do not enjoy the taste of both men and women."

She blinked, but she was not stupid. She understood quickly.

"Ah… I trust that it won't be an issue to get me with child?"

He shook his head. "No, but I hope you won't take offense if I take you with my eyes closed."

As they spoke, a loud clang interrupted them and they returned to the fight itself. Oberyn had knocked aside Ser Loras's sword and the younger knight was breathing heavily while Oberyn, despite this being his second bout, seemed less worn.

“I yield. Well fought, ser," Loras complimented him.

"You know your way around a sword," Oberyn said with a slight smirk.

Renly smiled at what he assumed was a deliberate jest, though Loras may have missed it.

“I would pay good coin to see you face my brother, Garlan Tyrell. With the Kingslayer dead, you two may well be among the two greatest warriors in Westeros."

Renly approached with a laugh on his lips. "You are a member of the Kingsguard! You don't have any coin!"

The jest earned a laugh from Oberyn, but an annoyed look from Loras.

He really has become moody since becoming a member of the Kingsguard. 

"The Mountain is still a huge beast, but now I am not so certain of your defeat, Prince Oberyn. I will no longer hector you with my hopefully soon-to-be bride."

Oberyn looked at him and then at Arianne, and then shrugged. He took Ellaria's hand and kissed it. "Then this was a fruitful day indeed. Now, unless you care to join Ellaria and me in bed, it is time to say farewell."

A tempting thought… perhaps in the future.

***

I smiled as Marwyn of the Citadel was announced. Tyrion was busy assisting his Uncle Kevan with his duties as master of coin and my own schedule was difficult to manage. Tyrion essentially having two jobs made timing this awkward, plus I was rather eager to chat with Marwyn as the only maester who had been interested in seeing the proofs of the Alchemists’ Guild.

"Lady Sansa," he bowed, "Lord Tyrion tells me you are quite curious about magic and the mysteries he seeks to unearth." He paused. "He also tells me that the king views you as his own daughter, and that those you favor tend to rise high."

"I am very much interested in magic. Now that I know that sorcery is real, I must know its limits. As to Lord Tyrion's comments, well, I can only say that His Grace believes, perhaps truly, that Visha saved his life when the Kingslayer attempted to slay him. That gratitude for her has transferred to me since she is my direwolf."

He took a seat and glanced with curiosity at Visha before returning his eyes to me. He looked most unlike a normal maester. His nose had been broken a time or two, and he was muscled like a trained knight. He set a large satchel he was carrying carefully down beside him.

"You are confident, as is the king. I believe sorcery is real, but simply because that much is true, does not mean you were the victim of it."

I waved aside the remark.

"There's no need to debate that topic. Lord Tyrion's purpose is to gather all the knowledge we know of magic from the Citadel, and then test what is truly magical and what is just folklore and exaggeration. You have been identified as someone who may have a unique perspective and is willing to dig into the data… the… observations from the Alchemists’ Guild. What say you on the subject of sorcery?"

Marwyn appraised me for a moment, and then nodded.

"The seasons wax and wane. Summer can last a scant few years, or for over a decade. Winters are even more extreme based on our records. And of course there is the Long Night." He inhaled and provided the practiced delivery he had no doubt given a hundred times already. "I see no reason why magic cannot be the same. There are too many accounts by countless historians to put it all up to silly smallfolk tales. The Wall exists, along with many other constructions that seem impossible. Magic, outside of the rare few places of the world that still carry its trace, appears in hibernation. Not dead, not gone, but no longer particularly active." He smiled. "The Citadel would just call it dead, but I've been to Asshai by the Shadow. Magic still stirs strongly there, and in other places too."

I quirked an eyebrow.

"To clarify, the Citadel believes magic once existed but now is no more?"

He waved his hand. "There are differing opinions, and if you listen to the ilk that I am with you will find eight different viewpoints quoted from thirty different works. Their intent is to bore the king and say nothing of substance. Some maesters truly do believe sorcery once existed, others think it was all superstition. It matters not; they are both wrong. Magic exists, even to this day, though it is but a shadow of what it once was."

Plausible conjecture that whatever powers magic may not always be present. Five confirmed wargs, and Rickon no doubt is one too, making six, in one generation? When in the last several there has been no hint of it within the Stark line? The theory isn't bad. 

"What kind of magic do you think exists?"

"In Asshai I saw true seaming. Not the tricks of drugs, hazes, and sleight of hand. That I can confirm firsthand, though I know not how to practice the art myself. The sorcery that seems most prevalent is that of divining the future through blood, flames, and dreams."

Great… 

"Evidence?" I asked.

"In the past, there was ample, why…"

"I'm familiar with the Targaryen Conquest tale," I said dismissively, but before I could continue my thought, he interrupted.

"Forgive me, Lady Stark, but you don't believe it to be true? We have writings from that era, we know Daenys the Dreamer predicted the Doom before it occurred."

"Sure, and how many others had predicted a Doom and it never took place? Or perhaps Daenys Targaryen sensed something amiss with what the other Valyrian families were doing. Or perhaps she looked into the study of smoking mountains and predicted their eruption in the way that would convince her family. Many possibilities, but none can be proven. What I ask is, have you proof, someone who claims the ability to see the future, whom you can put before us, and have them demonstrate something simple.

"Simple?" he asked with an amused expression.

"Aye, the simplest. Predict to me what I will do with a cup. Tell me said prediction, and then we will see if the future can be predicted by my action."

He blinked owlishly. "That's not a very good test. Nor is that the way prophecy functions. Lady Stark, magic is not a tool like a plow. It is a sword with no hilt, it is dangerous, mysterious, and not to be trifled with. Prophecy is like a treacherous woman…" he trailed off, unsure for a moment.

I laughed. "I know the saying, Gorghan of Old Ghis had a way with words that our king might appreciate. This is His Grace, King Robert Baratheon's court, Marwyn, you should trust that simple words, no matter how crude, will not cause me offense. I am a scholar."

He chuckled ruefully. "Aye, so it appears. You are very well read, outside of the Citadel Library I would not have expected any such text to mention Gorghan. But be that as it may, prophecy is not something you can simply test. It is something that has been borne out, though not in ways we can always expect."

I sighed. "All right, so we'll add that to the list of dross that can't be tested. What other forms of magic do you think we can observe, and therefore use the powers of observation and study to prove or disprove of."

Marwyn frowned, looked as if he wished to object, and then slowly nodded.

"You wish for proof? I show this to you in secret, for I know you are high in King Robert's esteem and seem to have little respect for the grey sheep. I have absconded with Citadel property. They have been collecting these artifacts for many years, and they thought them inert. Here, let me show you why I know magic is real beyond historical record, but in exchange you must swear by the old gods not to inform the Citadel that I have it. You are Lord Stark's daughter; I will trust your word."

I gave my word. I was not one to care at all for the gods, but being honest allowed for agreements. I would need a good reason to break my word, and if I did I would do so in a way that could not be traced back to me.

Or silence the person I gave my word to, but only if I believe they were a threat. 

I watched with interest as he undid the clasps on his bag and removed a tall, slender rod. The glittering black glass was about three feet in length and had edges that made him hold it carefully, lest the obsidian it was made from cut him.

"This is a glass candle. With it, one can see into far off places. For example, I saw that you had a chocolate pudding of sorts to finish your meal with the king. It looked as if the flavor was too sweet for Myrcella, as I noticed she did not finish hers."

My eyes widened. It was possible he had obtained that information from the servants who carried the dishes, but the odds of such infiltration had become much less likely as I had tested everyone who handled their food.

"Show me how it works."

***

"These terms are a load of pig swill. He claims to trust your word, and yet demands we come unarmed?" Jon said with disgust. "No trusting these savages."

Ser Rodrik was nodding as well. "Aye, Lord Umber has the right of it. There must be some scheme afoot here."

Ned agreed that something was going on, but he could not determine what. Mance Rayder wanted a face-to-face with Ned Stark on neutral ground, unarmed. Mance claimed he would come alone and Ned could bring two companions, but all must be without arms. Ned's companions could check Mance before Ned even came in sight to see he had honored his word.

This is maddening. He trusts me at my word, otherwise even two unarmed men could just kill him. But if he trusts me at my word, why does he not come and meet with me himself? What is his game? 

Having recently been in the south, he knew that sometimes, people just wished to unbalance a rival. Set the stage for a conversation where the other party is uncomfortable or worried. But would a wildling do that? The stipulation that none could be within half a league was another truly strange one.

"What could it be?" Ned asked.

Qhorin gave a slight shrug. The Night's Watch ranger did not like this much either.

"Mance is clever. We must consider what he gains by giving these terms, especially if we do not agree with them. Are we frozen in place while we dicker over this meeting’s timing and conditions while he moves more wildlings in place for an attack? 'Tis a guess, my lord, but the only one I see."

"And if I attend? Do you expect treachery?"

"I can't right say for certain, but it isn't his way to kill under parley. The wildlings are savage, aye, but they keep to some of the old ways, Mance more than most. Truth be told, killing you doesn't do much for him. You have sons and kin to avenge you."

Ned weighed his options. Refusal would be easy, but if the worst should occur, then the Seven Kingdoms would know never to accept terms with wildlings again. He tried to view the situation through Mance's eyes to see what he could gain. Killing the 'Lord of Winterfell' would increase his reputation, but for what purpose? He was already King-Beyond-the-Wall and, as best as Qhorin could make of the situation, only a few holdouts, men like Craster had been, remained.

"I'll agree to his terms. The Greatjon and Qhorin will join me. Ser Rodrik has command until I return, and if I fall he is to retreat back to the Wall and gather the full might of the North and all the men Robert can spare and avenge me."

There were more protests. Of course there were, but Ned had decided. On the following day he rode out to the spot of his choosing, per their agreement, and waited. If the man brought a hidden weapon, Ned remained confident that the three of them could still best him. The Greatjon was only matched by the Mountain in size and Qhorin was an experienced warrior.

Nor would I acquit myself poorly. 

When the lone figure appeared, Qhorin was sent ahead alone and searched him. Thoroughly. Ned could hear laughter from the man as the ranger completed his task. The Half-Hand signaled that all was well and they approached.

Ned found himself surprised to see that the man was rather ordinary. His eyes were drawn to his patched cloak of red silk and Night's Watch black wool more than the middling height and slender build of the man who styled himself a king. His hair was long and mostly gray, and his face had the lines of a laughter of a life spent in merriment. It was oddly disquieting; the man would be at home in any inn and holdfast feast hall.

"I have come, Mance Rayder. While we are under the banner of peace, I will do you no harm. If you can provide me useful information on who is raising the wights and it leads to them being brought to justice and the threat ended, once it is done I will return to the south and leave you and yours in peace so long as you do not assault the Wall."

"Lord Stark, an honor. I trust you are well?"

Ned let out a foggy breath.

"I've not come here to bandy words with you. By all rights, I should be hunting you down for your many crimes. And yet, I am inclined to show mercy if you can give us the information we seek. Will you answer my questions?"

"I might, but I have a problem. If I give you what you want, it won't be enough. You won't do what I ask, so it comes down to what can we possibly offer each other that doesn't end with more flesh for the army of the dead?"

Ned narrowed his eyes. "You claim there is an army?"

Mance smiled. "More or less. Stark, you mean to threaten me to get what you want. You claim you can slay the tens of thousands I have gathered with your army. Mayhaps your castle-forged steel will prove superior, but it won't stop the dead from coming for you. It'd only make matters worse."

"The little man talks like a southerner," the Greatjon snarled.

"Hah, no one's called me that before. Did you know, Lord Umber, the free folk think all you kneelers are southerners? But I've said my piece. If you want more, let us learn if you can bend and do what may be impossible."

"And that is?"

"Let us south of your Wall before the Long Night comes."

Comments

Ramsisuno

And Tansa's back!

Cristi R

That's a stupid negotiation tactic. No way can Ned agree without solid proof which Mance hasn't provided. I suspect the timing of Marwyn's arrival is not random, so what will Sansa see with the candle ?

Dai

"Renly did think Oberyn was weak, but he was certainly not someone who could resist being thrown." "Renly took her meaning, but was not sure what to say. He could appreciate her beauty, but it did raise his ardor." Think these two parts are missing a 'not'?

1one

Glad to see some warg content coming in, thanks for the chapter

OdaoistOd

Well I guess Tansa will see the army of the dead with the glass.... that is the only way I see Ned allowing them to move because Mance has no proff. Other option is that Tansa sees Ned dying to the dead..... Also I think that it was wise from Renly to come clean to Arianne about his preferences so it doesn cause conflict later.

Alatoic

I cant wait for TanSa to use the candle for a test. pretty sure she would see something. Also I believe Marwyn would be the first Southerner to know about the Stark warging, and that is a good think as he is way open minded about magic and pretty sure he would keep his mouth shout for the opportunity to learn more about it. Mance need to show proof about the dead army, what he ask is quite high, letting tens of thousands of wildlings cross the Wall would be to much for the other houses, even if he let them be in the Gift (and ask the king if its ok, pretty sure would not be a problem) but Ned must have hard proof, see the army, anything.

Breaker

It’ll be interesting to see how well Mance can play his hand. It’s an extreme ask.

Cams797

Man. Love Marwyn showing up and immediately giving up the plot of his fellow Archmaesters to the king’s favored advisor lol. Perfect. I’m thinking Sansa is about to get a rude awakening about just how real and varied magic is here. Seems that Oberyn is taking his upcoming trial by combat opportunity very seriously. He needs to, we’ve seen what happens if he isn’t focused enough. Mance isn’t pulling any punches, is he? I thought he might tease Stark about his recent visit to Winterfell. He’s gonna need some indisputable evidence of that army if he expects the kneelers to let a hundred thousand wildlings past the Wall. Great chapter. Can’t believe how short it felt lol. Thats always a fantastic sign. Looking forward to more.

Dave Steele

Prophecy is probably the worst magic in ASOIAF. Its track record of success for the subjects of it are soooooo trash.

Silver

"I can't prove any of my shit, but I want you to let all of us, your mortal enemies who had a history of pillaging your lands, to seek asylum in your lands." "Did you roll a fucking one on diplomacy?"

TheFoolishConsort

While SaTan plays a weird form of magical tryouts. Ned will have to do the hardest thing known to man... Compromise!

nugitoBambino

I don't think Sansa will be surprised about magic being real here. She's already predisposed towards it. I'd say the only thing I expect her to never give ground on is prophecy, since that's against her sensibilities and personal philosophy. really she's just asking for someone to do something they can do more than once and strip the mysticism, so I think she'll be far more excited than upset about the candle

Christian Jeffress

Hopefully Oberyn will be less flamboyant in his fight, or maybe SaTan can whisper ruthless efficiency into his ear lol. Thanks for the chapter.

Steve H

I don't know what Mance is playing at, but Mance must know there's a solid 0% chance Ned' response to this will be "Sure, I'll surrender my greatest advantage against your massive army, the Wall, by letting you and your army through the gates, and I'll slay the Night's Watch because they would never agree to that. Then when I've let a giant army loose in my lands, you can tell me whatever you claim to know about the wights." Maybe Mance was just trying to make Ned laugh with that silly joke. He does have a sense of humor, and Ned could stand to lighten up.

john

Really Tansa you won't believe in seeing the future after all you've been through? You know a being that can stop time and reincarnate you. That multiverse exist, warg, mind control and undead. Her mistakes, even from his first life, is using the knowledge and logic that he knows when confronting with something new. At this point she is not been logical anymore but arrogant that she is certain of what can and cannot exist. Remind me of the tv show characters called From.

Edward-James Ryan

I might be wrong I don't think westeros has chocolate

Hooli4ss

To see such potential like Arianne wasted on Renly is painful as hell,lol. Marwyn you stand before The Lord of Wargs , your awareness needs work my friend . Sansa might as well bring Marwyn into her services as well , lol. She learn how to work the candle , the realm will be sick foreal.Also the Wildings are acting like the North are pure cowards and fools , lol . Ned stand your ground , don’t get finessed like this.

Anon

I just hope it actually bites her in the ass and have long term consequences

Joseph Darwood

I interpreted her giving him a hard time as a way to cut through the less relevant theory stuff to get him to reveal magic that she could hypothetically replicate/use in the short term. I don't think he was ever invited to KL as a consultant or true debate partner so they could figure out the truths of magic together, I think she just wants to take the magic in his toolbox and add it to hers. That isn't to say she probably believes it, even in go work she's lwk irrational about being X, so I think prophecy and a claim like "The world is predetermined/can be predicted" probably falls into the same objectionable bucket as being X for her, regardless of if it's true or not.

Sgt. Tibs

Honestly I wouldn't have agreed to meet with Mance under those conditions. Ned didn't even consider capture, just his death, which would be annoying as hell to deal with. There are also the skin changers he at least suspects Mance has, which would explain the 'league away' stipulation and how they'd enforce it but it also means he won't truly be alone. Now that he's there Mance wants him to agree to allow a bunch of rapists, who openly disdain his people and refuse to follow any laws, through the wall. Earning his lords eternal enmity, for the grand prize of information and the promise that their eventual deaths will become their problem. Though i'd argue them dying north of the wall would be better then letting them become a problem south of the wall. It all comes down to them kneeling.

X Blade

Finally! A wilding told Ned!

X Blade

Remind me if Sg1 from Stargate. Always so arrogant about science vs the supernatural. Bro the ori are literally ascended being of energy who collect faith energy from their worshippers!

X Blade

The only reason they were able to defeat there was a literal deus 3xmachina descended to build them the macguffin. Otherwise known as an ascended altern handing them the solution. Talking about their are no gods or supernatural shit. Bruh that shits supernatural right there! Morhafuckas were blinded by arrogance. Straight up! Ither that as expect it was a great show.

X Blade

Ugh typos and auto correct

Failninjaninja

This is Ned 'let me follow Littlefinger down a cliff face where the wrong step will have me fall to my death' Stark :0 Re-reading that scene in AGOT was wild, I had forgotten (partially because it wasn't in the TV show) what a ridiculous passage that was! Ned may actually be more impatient than Robert when it comes down to it

Sgt. Tibs

Yeah I think I was just hangry when I wrote this lol

Match

Ive never seen a roll this bad on a persuasion check, if so. LMAO

T-Dawg 2099

You'd think a guy who united the various fractious tribes beyond the Wall would be a better negotiator. As others (heh) have pointed out in previous chapters the emergence of a mutual enemy doesn't erase generations of bloodshed. No one's letting thousands of wildlings past the Wall, zombie army or not.

Generic Geneticist

Is this fic done for or are you just hyperfocusing on DOTF fic? Not a big deal since the other one has me satisfied, but it would be good to know. I DID like this one much more than the previous fic you made on GoT. It got a little weird with the romance. I get pragmatism, but I just can't imagine Tanya letting herself get into a relationship like that.

Failninjaninja

Its on Hiatus until I feel the pull for ASOIAF again, when I do I'm not 100% sure what I will work on but this is a possibility

Waldo Terry

I have to say that I am 100% behind Tanya's skepticism of prophecy. The one Rhaegar was chasing had been around for generations with no indication of being active or any useful forewarning of the others'coming when it actually came into play. At that point you may as well know nothing, as the worry over what would happen was the cause of a lot of needless grief. Prophecy at least is a power best not heeded, especially here where we've seen that there are people who had inklings of the original timeline, muddling things up even more. In reality, I am not much of a fan of the others in general either. The setting really lacks the tools to come to grips with a threat of that nature in a way that does not end up feeling contrived or a deus ex (here's the part of prophecy I like even less than the above), but that's a problem I've got with the original material rather than this story. At least here I hope that Tanya bringing in magic early and actually working with it will provide a plan that eill make for a fun and enganging confrontation with a satisfying payoff. That said, Tanya's movesin the capital, if the do pay off, may end up presenting a unified kingdom to the others at least, if maybe not all comers. The issue of current Targaryen sympathizers among the nobles hasn't come up, but with Varys making noises about Tanya's match (possibly to F!Aegon?) That is bound to show up in the near future and THAT will be a mighty hard wrinkle for her to smooth over with Robert. As soon as anyone mentions Targaryens in Robert's hearing, we lose him. For that matter, how does he square his own ancestry with his hatred of the Targs? I know that kind of hate is hardly ever rational, but it's been mentioned a couple times to Robert's face bit we don't yet know what he makes of it himself. Good thing he hardly looks valiryan 😅 Thanks for writing!