Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

How POV Tanya-centric do you prefer a story?

  • I prefer no Tanya POV like in your HOTD Fic 45
  • I prefer Tanya to be the central POV but with many other POVs (BattleTech, AYGGOT) 297
  • I prefer Tanya to the bulk of the words written be from her POV, but having occasional guest POVs is fine 150
  • I'd like to see a Tanya only POV story 5
  • 2026-11-17
  • 497 votes
{'title': 'How POV Tanya-centric do you prefer a story?', 'choices': [{'text': 'I prefer no Tanya POV like in your HOTD Fic', 'votes': 45}, {'text': 'I prefer Tanya to be the central POV but with many other POVs (BattleTech, AYGGOT) ', 'votes': 297}, {'text': 'I prefer Tanya to the bulk of the words written be from her POV, but having occasional guest POVs is fine', 'votes': 150}, {'text': "I'd like to see a Tanya only POV story", 'votes': 5}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 17, 17, 16, 26, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 497}

Content

Yes another poll, we'll be doing a few of these this week! I'm actually curious as to where people fall on this. Obviously all the Tanya crossovers will have Tanya be the main focus, but a question does come up as to what people prefer in terms how central are Tanya's POV. From one extreme we have a story like the Inevitable Dance where there is no MC POV at the other end we have stories like Jim Butcher's Dresden Files where the only POV (not counting side books) is from the protagonist's perspective.

Again, non-binding. Just curious what people are vibbing with.

Comments

Dylan

Multiple povs is the best because then you get to see what people think of and react to her nonsense, and the misunderstanding field

Admiral Edward

My favourite parts are when other characters are severely misunderstanding or underestimating Tanya.

Enkelados

I like occasional POV switches. But the problem is, they make the plot crawl to a stop. I feel like between one in twenty chapters and one in ten chapters is a good balance for my tastes.

Dustin Michael Baker

If you had an option for both no Tanya pov or all Tanya pov I would have chosen that. Fully one or the other.

General Black

Other povs help us understand the plot as Tanya is a very unreliable narrator and dense as a brick.

Sean T

It kinda depends on the scope of the story and where the plots moving. In the HOTD one it works since for most of it while Tanya has influence on the plot the ones actually moving it forwards are mostly other people. In something like the defiance of the fall one Tanya needs more direct povs since she's driving the story.

D3ad0s

You know, we have a bunch of your stories with mixed POVs and one HOTD where there is no Tanya POV. Thus I vote for your take on a Tanya only POV story, to see how you would handle it ;)

Mark Arth

Despite preferring her to be the majority of the POVs, I still enjoy HOTD a lot. I enjoy it because it is novel to not have her POV, but I don't think it would be enjoyable if every story was like that. And even with HOTD being entirely other people's POV the story is still firmly centered around Tanya. She lives rent free in all their minds lol

Bat

I always think the world becomes more fleshed out from multiple povs in reaction to other characters and situations.

Akel

^this^.

Prizzma

Tanya in Dresden file, yes please!

Sean

I like understanding her thought process but you do a good job of incorporating external povs in a way that enhances her actions and stays true to the crossover. Like the defiance of the fall ff is popular, but if you never did a Zac pov it wouldn't feel as in-world as your story does. As much as we all dislike Zac he's a central character that needs some screentime.

Santakat

Depends on artistic direction. HOTD is wonderful, but was clearly written to show a story unfolding that Tanya is involved in, but never directly from her POV. In a more traditional Tanya story I would prefer that her POV take up the majority of the narrative.

Ramsisuno

Personally I almost always prefer a singular POV with occasional alternative POVs sprinkled in. In that respect, your HOTD fiction is definitely an exception and not the rule from how much I enjoy it. That having been said, how many POVs depends heavily on the kinda story you're trying to tell, so i don't think there really is an overarching answer. DOTF and AYGGOT work well with plenty of POVs because the side characters are huge in that story, whereas Tanya Sedai does better with a more Tanya centric POV imo, not because the side characters have less character, but just because the plot is much more closely tied to Tanya herself.

leopard eye

I'm going with option one because it's sometimes so much fun to guess what Tanya is thinking and how she misunderstands the situation. Thought it would not work for all your stories.

Flinxie

I mostly like the pov to stay with the main reason I'm reading, but other POV are really fun. That being said, HOTD is sublime, and it's one of my favorites so what do I know.

Poops

I like everything

that girl

Why is there no option for mostly not Tanya but occasionally jumping into her head?

Mystearical

Love the HOTD story but the one gripe I have with it is the lack of Tanya POVs. IMO the best is something like how Worm did it, where the story is entirely from Taylor's POV but there are regular interludes from other characters.

Arkeus

'i love all of those options in different stories' has my vote

Eleyvie

HOTD is awesome, but it works so good because other fics do not use that approach, so we can use them to approximate what Tanya is really thinking in HOTD. Without outside context HOTD would be pretty weird I think.

Robert Hinshaw

I like the variety of your POV choices. Your House of the Dragon was really fun once I got used to the pov choice, so I'd be willing to read another story like that if the mood struck you.

Lilly’s of The Void

I love POV’s that aren’t Tanya especially if they add to the story POV’s that I can’t see why they are in the story tend to drag on for me. But I mostly prefer mainly Tanya.

Green0Photon

Can you add a N/A option? The reality is that it depends on the story. I think the HOTD is high art for no Tanya POV. But the Defiance of the Fall fic would be much worse if it was no Tanya POV. Or also worse if it was only Tanya POV (but not by much). Vs the Battletech one needs both. So I just care about what the author thinks would be most peak art. I'll vote for no POV just cause your HOTD fic is a treasure cause of that, even though idk if it would be good for any other fic

Alatoic

I really like to read other points of view about what is Tanya doing, how she is see by others or her actions, directly or indirectly. Also to advance the plot and see what other people are doing if far places.

Hooli4ss

Yea , wish HOTD was had a little bit of option B…but that’s the story that got me here ,it’s a great read.

Bowack

I think other POVs provide something that Tanya's perspective doesn't despite her's being entertaining. Also it allows for drama farming when people dis her in their narrations and cause 50 pages of discussion on SB.

Flowering

Multiple POVs are great. I think the biggest issue with going heavy into Tanya-centric narration is that you can end up being too self-similar and lose some originality, considering number of fics you have going. After all Tanya is a pretty fixed character, and already on her third life, and unless you write her encountering some crazy traumatic situations there's only so much character development she can reasonably go through. Other POVs give the story a good shake.

Slowchoke

Unrelated but every time I see HOTD it makes me think of Highschool of the Dead and I get excited for a Tanya zombie apocalypse story!

Gornyetch

I think it's fun to see how other people are (mis)interpreting Tanya's actions and motives. I love your HOTD fic, but do think the "no Tanya POV at all" worked so well because it was a divergence from the norm. I wouldn't like that pattern for all your stories.

Trololokiller97

I honestly enjoy all of your chosen POV's. So I'm not voting

Ven

I just like all your stories lol. I think you strike the right balance between each of the POVs. Even though I voted for the second option, I still love HOTD since it’s just such a unique way to tell the story!

Ekamilia

Despite my preference being main Tanya POV with many other supporting POV’s, I think the way you did HOTD is super well done (possibly my fav of your stories). Not for every story, but it totally works for that one. Only having 1 POV or limited POV’s isn’t my preference as it feels limiting.

Alice Coleman

It was a struggle for me to determine which one I prefer .ultimately I like them all a lot! Thanks a ton for all the hard work can’t wait for more

Gaerdir

Voted for Tanya as central but many POVs, but echoing the general sentiment of others here - the POV is less important to me compared to her being the main character. Personally, I think my enjoyment of the stories drops more when there’s an extended sequence of chapters where it appears things are happening, but she’s not doing things. I’m a fan of all of these worlds (some I learnt about first from your stories) but I read the Tanya stories for Tanya 😬 Stories that don’t involve her, I’m probably more open minded 😂

Old Hammer

Personally I have to say multiple POVs with Tanya as main is probably my favorite in general but I honestly wouldn’t mind seeing more like HOTD. The HOTD story is probably my favorite overall and the unique way it has the reader react to what Tanya does through the eyes of others. (though it is honestly difficult to rate your stories as I have enjoyed all of them thus far)

santhinal

Both the 2nd and third option are great and no Tanya PoV is okay on occasion but not as a common thing. Tanya PoV only is a HORRIBLE idea however. Half the fun of Tanya fics/ the actual story is how people react to her.

Wiggin

Personal opinion: the draw of a good Youjo Senki fic is the disconnect between Tanya and everyone else. This usually works best with multiple PoVs, but clever writing can get around that. The HotD fic works without ever having a Tanya viewpoint by leaning on the readers' knowledge of the source material; we can see the difference between Tanya's actions and how she's perceived without ever seeing her PoV.

Obiwan

I voted for not POV because I've always enjoyed how that affects storytelling involving out of context characters, but it obviously isn't always best. It would be a detriment to something like your doft or wot fic where her response to learning about the setting is a part of the enjoyment. In a rather generic fantasy setting like asoiaf though it adds to the enjoyment by not seeing inside her head.

Hooli4ss

Bruh , I thought it was just me 😂

TuscanKB

Tanya as a central POV with many other POV's is the best of both worlds and gives me the two main things I want in this fandom. A big part of my enjoyment of Tanya fics comes from the dichotomy of her "misunderstanding field". Tanya believing all her actions and thoughts are reasonable and logical while everyone else sees something completely different. All the while we the audience are looking down at this begging for more because it really is entertaining.

Mitzee

For me POV matters less then who is the main subject of the story for a given chapter. in Inevitable Dance you do a great job of making most POVs somehow relate to Tanya's actions. And there are rarer times mostly in other authors stories when a POV from Tanya is more about the story of someone else then it is her story. I tend to prefer in Tanya fanfic crossovers that the story be about Tanya, and don't care so much whether it's told from Tanya's POV or another characters. The fun of it for me comes from seeing how Tanya adapts to a new world and how her unique mind drives her along.

Dmitry Gumin

Contrast between her PoV and the others PoV is what wins the day. Humor, etc. Long live the field of misunderstanding.

Edward-James Ryan

I think it really depends on the crossover and how well I know it for my preference if I know it well like HOTD then no Tanya POV can be very interesting but I also enjoy seeing her POV or working as a framing device for something I'm unfamiliar with like DOF or WOT but I also think only Tanya POV would miss a lot of the interesting parts of a Tanya fic