Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello my patrons! I'm a huge fan of the open source Greaseweazle project: It allows you to read and write so many disk formats as it can read/write the flux information directly from the drive.

What it could never do is act an interactive diagnostic tool for disk drives. I decided to try to fix that by adding an interactive mode to allow you to better troubleshooting problematic and broken disk drives.

If you have one of these boards handle, I'd love it if people could test out what I've done and see if it works for you. (So far, I'm the only person to have tested this out.)

Thanks for all your support!

Direct link: https://youtu.be/nSxDOpwYLVM

Files

I turned the Greaseweazle into an powerful disk diagnostic tool

Flaky floppy drives is a constant when working with retro computers. Here's a new software for the Greaseweazle that turns it into an amazing tool to help troubleshoot drives. 0:00 Intro 1:18 Greaseweazle Basics 13:53 GW-DIAG 32:32 Troubleshooting a Panasonic JU-475 41:49 Troubleshooting a Shugart SA-400 -- Links GW-DIAG: https://github.com/misterblack1/greaseweazle/tree/diag Adrian's Digital Basement ][ (Second Channel) https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCbtwi4wK1YXd9AyV_4UcE6g Support the channel on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/adriansdigitalbasement My GitHub repository: https://github.com/misterblack1?tab=repositories --- Instructional videos My video on chip removal without damage: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQVjwPsVFd8 --- Music Intro music and other tracks by: Nathan Divino @itsnathandivino

Comments

Joseph Krajacic

Pretty sweet utility. I recently created a terminal user interface for Greaseweazle. Because I primarily run linux and there is no good GUI for Greaseweazle for linux. I will see what it takes to make this run in linux and add support for it to my TUI. If you want to check out that project it runs on Windows Mac and Linux. https://github.com/n9tax/lubeshop

Mark Dymek

there’s a way to get around all of this. Don’t use floppy disks!!! 🤪

Mark Dymek

should be trivial to add support for linux a python program.

Chris Platts

Very neat indeed! My GW’s inside a 3D-printed enclosure with 3.5 and 5.25 drives that I *think* are good, so it’ll be cool to test those with this. Now I’m wondering how I can add a 34-pin connector, break out the power connectors, and a switch to disable the internal drives so I can plug in random drives for testing! (or I could just get another Greaseweazle I suppose!)

Lily Finley

I can't test it because I'm on Linux but it seems cool. I suspect cross platform support would be required if you wanted to contribute back to the main repo.

Mark Dymek

i am working on a mac/linux port.

David Hatt

It’s nice to get some floppy drive nostalgia but it’s videos like this that make me realise just how much I’ve yet to learn about the technology. What an amazing wealth of knowledge you have! Meanwhile, I’m suspecting that many of us retro nerds have moved to Linux because of disillusionment and frustration over what a hot mess Windows has become and how we want to go back to having more control over what our computers do!

MrHammond

My Greaseweazle is at my best friend's place so he can archive his 5¼" floppies as his last computer with floppy controller died a couple of years ago... I used it to archive my Amiga disks, very surprised that after more than 30 years, they were still working perfectly! And wow, 30 000 µS step delay, that's huge, I remember that on the Amiga it was by default 3000 µS, but there were utilities to tweak those values to speed up seeking and reduce noise levels. With my 5¼" drive (that was just used as a regular 80-track 880 kB drive, the Amiga OS saw no difference with 3½" floppies), I could even lower it below 2000 µS, the built-in 3½" drive was not that fast however... Those utilities also stopped the annoying clicking, at least if the drive did not try to step further back when the track 0 sensor was activated. Which leads me to the Disk Change signal: you need to send a head step signal for it to change after inserting a disk, otherwise it doesn't change to low. But when removing the disk it should go back immediately to high. This is to prevent that the system misses a disk change when it happens quickly between checks. That's also why the Amiga drives step regularly when no disk is inserted. The early drives could knock when passing track 0 like Commodore 64 and Apple II drives. But as far as I know, this was only implemented on 3½" drives, my 5¼" Amiga drive had some extra circuity and used the sensor that spins up the motor when inserting a disk, unfortunatly no sensor on the lever... Maybe later 5¼" drives supported proper disk change detection?

Sourceror

Have GW with some untested 5.25 PC88 disk drives. Will give it a go and report back.

Adrian's Digital Basement

Someone send in in a pull request for the Mac/Linux support. It's been updated on the repo, testing would be greatly appreciated if you have a moment.

Adrian's Digital Basement

Yeah I think something like this would be super helpful .. a little all in one box and the breakout cable. Already it supports up to 4 drives using the Shugard drive select standards, so you don't even really need a switch -- PC disk drives with a fixed DS1 will just show up as "Drive 1" when connected to a straight through cable.

Adrian's Digital Basement

Someone has sent in a pull request for Linux/Mac support which I have merged. If you have a GW, could you give it a try and see if it works for you?

Adrian's Digital Basement

The DC signal doesn't seem to work on my GW hardware, even using an Amiga drive.. although I didn't do much testing to be honest. It always seems to read high (if I recall) no matter what. But more testing is likely needed and I just didn't have time, especially as DC isn't used on anything other than the Amiga so it was low priority.

MrHammond

Interesting... You're right of course that for the GW, the DC signal not of any use... Funny is: before you showed the GW, I tried to build something like that myself with an Arduino. Of course, controlling the drive is easy, for reading the raw data, I found the Arduino to be too slow... I was particularly interested to see if I could figure out and understand how to read the raw flux data. Anyway, I have only one working non-laptop floppy drive, that's a NEC FD1231T, a bog-standard PC drive from 2008 without any jumpers to set. It fully supports the Amiga-style disk change signalling, I thought actually it was part of the Shugart standard, not something propriety from Commodore or the Amiga... Interesting detail for that drive: it also supports 300/360 RPM switching, although it is a 3½" drive...

Adrian's Digital Basement

It would be nice to know if it actually worked of course because of the importance to the Amiga, but this tool was just something I was using for these piles of broken drives I have so it wasn't something I put much effort into.

Mark Dymek

i cant figure out how to reply? did they change it? it used to be a option in the menu. Adrian i’ve looked at the shell script and it’s clever. using a shell as a middle man to set up everything then run the code directly. my approach would be to write a posix native app that just runs i don’t need any of this. you can decide which you think is better. i have a part time job now and i have another project im working on so ill try to work on this asap.

Mark Dymek

ah i have to press the little speech bubble. that’s intuitive🤪🤪🤪

Sourceror

Can confirm my Mac works.

Sourceror

Tested it. With a proper IBM / DOS formatted disk it works as advertised on a Mac. With a PC88 disk it fails reading (S0/15 in red). Probably because of all the weird sector formats, like track 0 with 16 sectors and track 1..39 with 5 sectors. For checking if the drive works I'll use a regular DOS floppy. Great tool!

Adrian's Digital Basement

Ah yes ok good. I only really ever tested it with IBM MSDOS formatted disks. Does a IBM PC type disk with OK in that PC88 drive? I know really nothing at all about PC88 drives and don't have any. (Or if I do, I don't know it.)

Adrian's Digital Basement

Ultimately a compiled app might be better too -- much easier for people versus the python scripts, so feel free to fork and then host that. Let me know the link.

Sourceror

The Nec PC-88 drive is a regular Teac 55-GFR. It formats IBM MFM tracks with weird sector layouts. That’s why I have a Greaseweazle to be able to read the raw flux. A normal PC cannot handle this.

Adrian's Digital Basement

Yeah I can see that -- luckily someone put in a pull request and Mac and Linux support is now there.