Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Excited to see the completed images. It's a very tough choice.

I'm completely torn >.< The more korean style one I'm pretty sure I could push into a style like witch busters. Yet the more japanese styled one lacks some experience, they went too detailed for the test page, I doubt they can keep that level of detail up and produce it quickly.

PS they were given the same prompt and I'm not even sure if I want to do right to left or left to right.

Files

Comments

Alex Hoshell

I like #1’s art the best but #2’s composition better

DJ Johnson

Ugh then 2 would be better since they can pump it out faster then 1 personally I prefer 1.

GhostPhil

I personally prefer #1 over #2 in terms of the art. Especially the faces and they feel more dynamic

Ron N

Definitely #1

vardic d

I prefer Style #1. I have also come to the realization that I'm probably going to buy these despite my dislike of the Manga writing style. If you end up not doing the reversed writing style, you're definitely getting more of my money.

Bri

Personally I agree 1 would probably take longer for releases but you could happily invest in it knowing it would be worth the wait whereas 2 isn't good enough to hold my attention for anything more than initial interest

Bruce_Sentar

My secret plan for world domination includes getting an anime one day. There's a pretty big temptation to translate it and shove it into the japanese market. But I could always flip the pages for that. The back of every manga book I've look at lately just has one of these pages and I used the concept for a test since it only had one character.

Kaizen

#1 looks better

Konrad

I’d go with the one that looks better even if it takes an extra month or two I’d definitely aim for the one the looks the best. And the general consensus so far seems like #1.

Sinful Cyanide

I strongly prefer the way the first one looks

Eric Gonyea

i like #1 over #2 personally but I agree that to maintain that quality of work could slow things down

vardic d

Seeing some of your stuff as an anime would be amazing.

El Jefe

#1 all the way *nods*

Frank Carr

#1 is way better. I would pick it up even though I'm not into the Saving Supervillains story at all. As for #2, I would not pick that up as I really do not like that art style. The inking and shading are not good enough in my opinion. Also, I do not like the composition or the background. The artist for #2 may have more experience, but his backgrounds are boring.

George

#1 seems much stronger!

Hugo Kater

The first one looks better.

Tikerusey

I might be going against the flow... but I think 2 looks better. 1 is too detailed, that could be overwhelming in big fighting scenes.

Joe.L

#1 the style is much better, it will take longer but it will be worth it.

Direwolf1618

I honestly have no idea how you pick.

Kconraw

I like #1 more and agree with some if the other comments. If you came out with a manga in #1 style, I'd most likely get it since it's one of your series. If it came out in #2, I wouldn't even bother cuz I just don't like the style.

Sdff

#1 has better eyes, and #2 has a more professional background look. Not an Artist, but having read thousands of comics and some manga #2 looks almost like a weird inbetween style for the facial layouts of the girl in front. Otherwise the #2 background is actually preferable to me given it more easily shows scale and civil place. While some may not like that #2's background is "unstylized", the actually "correct" usage of perspective should allow easier storytelling for more complex archs in the story. If your story skips too much perspective in the pictures, than it becomes confusing to differentiate partial frames of characters battling. Overly styleized backgrounds can cause disorientation between whose cape, or arm a punch would be in a clasic Avenger's style 20+ characters fighting in one frame panel. I still sort of pick #1 though, because #2 has a weird face.

Christopher Clark

I have to stick with 1. Then again with as much manga as I own I may be a little Biased towards the Japanese style over the Korean style