Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 531578725.mp4

Downloads

Content

Hey guys, here is an exclusive interview with Hunter Kozak, who was the Utah Vally University student that was debating Charlie Kirk during his unfortunate assassination. Due to its news relevance, this will be posted onto YouTube shortly but I wanted to make sure all of you guys got it first.

FYI - we’ve not forgotten our patrons and will be unleashing a psychotic torrent of premium content in the coming days and weeks. I have filmed every single day for the past month in several countries and cities, shot multiple 5Casts and have captured footage that I am perhaps, the most ‘stoked on’ of anything that we’ve ever shot. 

I’m also seriously having second thoughts about the upcoming C5 Carnival tour in light of what happened in Utah. I know that I’m not a political reactionary in the Charlie Kirk sense, but seeing someone shot like that, in broad daylight, surrounded by unsuspecting fans and supporters, is something that deeply affected me and I could easily see something going wrong on tour - God forbid. 

Anyways, I hope you guys enjoy this documentary. As mentioned, been shooting non-stop and left a Pete Buttigieg Interview from NYC the morning Charlie was killed, learned of the event while connected to plane wifi, landed in LAX, then boarded a new fight to SLC without even leaving the terminal, after which I conducted my interview with Hunter Kozak at 1:30 a.m. at his apartment in Utah, around twelve hours after the shooting.

Also working on a new book and trying to learn how to use synth equipment to make my own music so we don’t have to keep scoring our docs with ‘royalty free cinematic documentary music’ from YouTube. 

Best,

Andrew Callaghan

Fri Sep 12 2025

Files

Comments

Elliot Acosta

Based, dude probably had a great view

Kayvte

Second :(

Candelario Calderon

I was wondering where you’ve been! Thanks for covering this stuff.

Inverse Alien

amazing... ch5 always has the goods

LilPoppinfresh

Videos and news coverage has been great, keep it up man.

Alex Palomo

Thank you for all that you do Andrew and Channel 5 Team.

Eric Piggot

Cheers Andrew, thanks for not forgetting about us!

Bree

My jaw freaking dropped when I read this notification. Excellent

Charles Frum

AC hardest working man in the news biz

Sean Bradley

Please don’t cancel the carnival. Keep inside, hire quality security. Can’t wait to see yall in ATL.

Twitchard Music

not gonna lie i was about to unsub today… Andrew, you doing too much homie, spreading yourself too thin! pay someone to create music for you. theres thousands of qualified people, and youll be the supporting the community that supports you

James Degregorio

I mean you were recently targeted in a lawsuit by Melania trump, I would stay tf home for a minute too, shit man.

WhiskeyNeon

Don't let fear keep the carnival from happening!

C

Don't cancel the carnival - no one wants to hurt you because you humanize, not divide.

Matthew Jackson

indoor city arena style tour is much safer. but you do what you got to do.

Matthew Jackson

hope to see you in tacoma with my homies!

John Fix

Sad to hear him mention that his brother had been in a school shooting situation. That's America today.

Bandito Exe

Wow. The future is bleak

Juncal

Like... Damn man, just hats off

Austin Armstrong

I paused the video for a minute and now I can't watch the rest. The screen just says to "sign in to prove you're not a bot" but there's no way to do that. Nothing clickable works. Probably some kind of Patreon issue. Anyone know how to resolve?

Bandito Exe

Also right when this happened my Boss was jumping up and down with joy saying how happy he was. Almost 60 year old man. Sad

Owen Ritondo

Thank you for getting this done so fast!

Lucas Alonso

i was mid watch and it just vanished

B

Lots of love and support for Channel 5, bringing actual news to the people

Trev

Much appreciated big dowg. I hope you don’t cancel the tour but understand if you do. Keep on keepin on.

Carlos

Interesting how a white guy getting shot leads to white people calling for coming together and kumbaya. Fuck that and fuck charlie kirk. The whole "we need to come together as a community" ok great start by denouncing Tump's rhetoric and language against minority communities and his political opposition. But they wont. btw, I live in Utah, went to UVU, and ain' t no chance in hell those racist bros flying MAGA flags and hating on brown people around here are shaming me into any sort of sadness for this clown.

typical Ed

There should definitely be a follow up to this considering that the shooter was identified and arrested

David Pratt

Great interview. Sorry that Hunter had to experience that so up close and personal. Also, love the flag line up. Just a minor note, when US flag hung vertically, the blue should be in the upper left corner.

Dopameanie

It's interesting how adjusted people are to the current political environment - the blue shirt man described George Floyd and Jan 6 as less than "real" civil dispute. Don't get me wrong, of course it can get a lot worse, but I mean... They seem like relatively severe civil disputes to me.

mercywarhol

Thank you for the update

jamie medley

Great interview, really hope this guy gets some help to deal with this.

Coolie

Great conversation

Cassin

Thanks for the updates. Looking forward to seeing the new stuff soon.

Saurav Rao

i'm certainly not happy about this, i'm not sympathetic to charlie either. but i'm scared of the blowback from this. what really sucks is we don't get to make out kirk for the astroturfed grifter and fraud that he was in life. he will be canonized for a while now, and that's not a good outcome for liberals in the US.

Pat

Looking forward to seeing the hard work you're putting in Andrew. Glad you're on top of things.

May

love to andrew, everyone on this episode had such interesting things to say hope the right kind of news can and should help on the mental of both political bubbles to come out of this with better and healthier thoughts

Benny

I would like to hear more about Hunter's (or anyone's) political journey from right to left (or left to right). I don't hear enough of those stories -- there's like an implicit idea floating around that everyone is always and forever on one side of the political spectrum or the other. Hearing about people's journeys would also normalize the possibility of having a journey.

hrdkik

the hope for your input given the recent event finally pushed me to become a patron, this blew me away even given my expectations. excited for the future, great work as always.

David McCoy

Wow Andrew is leveling up in his journalism. He’s also been the GOAT but he’s about to become a household name.

Dewey

This is the most human thing I've seen put out about this. Thank you for the nuance.

Jamie Martin

Respect to this guy, and I empathize with the fact that he's likely suffering trauma and in shock, but I strongly disagree with the framing of this as a "violent left" problem. I hate him saying "Trump could be cracking down on the violent left", and that the right is "justified" in their anger, and that he's one of the "few" people on the left who care about life or humanity. That's nonsense. Especially considering he's getting death threats from angry conservatives who think he's partly responsible for his death. You uploaded a TikTok video and people were shitty, yes.. that's pretty standard. You'll find some of the worst comments on the internet on short-form video sites. The Hospital vigil bros were upset about some comments left on local news websites, which are arguably even worse. Social media is designed to be divisive and to get us to be outraged, angry, and to click as much as possible. It's also incredibly easy to manipulate and AstroTurf. You would have been able to find the same disgusting comments after the Minnesota politicians were shot. Charlie Kirk himself made fun of the attempted murder of the Pelosis. Whatever garbage you see on those websites isn't an accurate representation of any group of people, and this capitulation plays into their whole misplaced narrative.

who, me

Interesting interview. But the undertone of both-siderism to me felt questionable. Political violence in the US OVERWHELMINGLY comes from the far right. It does nobody any good pretending that this is somehow a general left/right issue of radicalization. It is not. When it turns out that this far right racist Charlie Kirk was shot by some groyper who was simply even further right and even more radical, will that be a major talking point?

Miki

Ginormous appreciation for Channel 5 ppl. Once again, unbelievably quick yet the most sensible & insightful interviews. Too brilliant. Proud to be a Patreon member.

Frank Norton

We can’t be a country that murders people we disagree with.

holly

Thanks, much respect for being an airport madman to get this done.

Carlos

Honestly Frank, the point is becoming increasingly moot. No one is saying you should be able to shoot people you disagree with. What i'm saying is that the people who are charlie kirk supporters are ONLY saying these things when its beneficial to their preferred outcomes. Its not genuine for "the other side". What they're saying is "well now that this guy is dead you guys need to agree with us and let us do whatever we want" with zero introspection (i.e. others need to come together, not them). Its a sentiment i have zero empathy for. I'm also saying Charlie Kirk had it coming (again not saying he SHOULD have been shot).

Ciggarettesandwich

Dawg I'm super excited to see the doc you keep teasing on dieing languages. My great grandmother grew up speaking a mix of Ojibwe cree and French called michif. She was taken from her home and placed in an Indian school and beat for speaking her language. Growing up it always felt like everyone just wants to forget that happened, I'm excited to see your doc so maybe people can see how native communities are still effected today by our countries past policies

who, me

Exactly. Plus, it's not like the shooter is even confirmed to be on the "left", except by Trump et. al., with no evidence whatsoever. He may well turn out to be a far right groyper who thought this Kirk dude just shouldnt even talk to "the libs".

Carlos

Also we can't be in a country that demonizes/dehumanizes people with disagree with and advocates for their mistreatment and marginalization - yet the folks claiming your claim of "we can't be in a country that murders people we disagree with" have no issue systematically dehumanizing entire groups of people. Again, zero sympathy from me for them.

Kasey

Putting this on YouTube was the right choice. Way too important to not give it the widest audience possible.

WHAMblitz

It is the right thing to humanize the loss of life due to violence yet unfortunately time and time again terminally online right leaning people and their spokesmen such as Kirk mocked and cheered tragedies while actively pushing for harmful and racist ideals as a pass time. I won't celebrate or grieve his death although it rubs me the wrong way when the ending conversation is always pitted as "Both sides" whenever it hits home for the Right when that's not the reality

Ian Be

The NATO flag kinda ruins it for me.

Andrew

Great interview. Sin of certainty in gunna start using that.

Nancy

Damn. Would ..uhh give birth to see that jubilee video with Andrew

Lewis Dean

Cheers for this video Andrew & team. Can't say I agree with everything the guy said but he handled this interview better than I would have been able to in his position so I found it all very insightful nonetheless. Love from the UK.

cheesenut

These are the affects of trumpism. This is what happens when there are no values. And trump brought that into the mainstream. This is what we've all talked about over the years. Its destroyed all aspects of life. Thats authoritarianism. We chose it. Everyone is feeling. So that the only positive.

Olivia

This is wild Andrew, so quick to get an interview! It’s surprising how composed he was considering what he witnessed so recently. Stay safe out there.

Lewis Dean

Modern Western politics let this happen. I think Trump is the worst individual amongst the group but a lot of major parties in the West have swing right over the past decade. I live in the UK and right now we're going through a political upheaval because the historically left-wing party (Labour) has become an ineffective and complacent husk of its former self; much like the democrats in America.

jpfdiv

Was just thinking about what the last person to debate him would think. Leave it to Channel 5.

sebastian

The right finally got a reason to be a victim

Tom Roe

That one young man in front of the school sign had some good points, nice to see some people still have their heads about them.

Spy Emerson

Andrew please take care of yourself and team. We need you more than a tour

Jon

Thanks for grinding and locking in for us player!

bpds00

Channel 5 4L

josh e

I dont think you have anything to worry about doing the tour. You speak to people much more respectfully and civil then he did. I think he was very devicive which you are the opposite of.

Matt Sturbate

Woah, he's about the same height. That's crazy.

Jamie Martin

@Frank Nobody is saying you should murder those you disagree with, holy shit.

Dirty Larry

Not going to lie, I for real though I hope Andrew stays safe out there after all of this shit.

Trev

Out of curiosity, what did you disagree with?

Austin Hodson

He didn't deserve it, but I have no empathy for him.

Joe Pera

Its nice to see that man still smile and laugh after what is honestly a life altering experience. I hope we find out the truth to why this guy did it and more about him because its starting look as if they're scrubbing his digital footprint the same way the guy from Butler PA was digitally erased and not much info can be found about him.

Hailsssssss

Excited to hear the synth background music you're whipping up

Allyson

This is really bad, I had to give up on it. The vast majority of gun violence is from the right, the vast majority of violent and hateful rhetoric is from the right. 'Both sides-ing' this is awful. What about the Democrats who were recently assassinated, where was all the outcry and vigils? Where were your videos about this? If I'm wrong and you made them I'm happy to be corrected.

Jonathan Benjamin

Can't wait to see the new content! Stayed blessed C5 team! Thank you for the work you do!

Swass-e-sois

After goosebumps the next 3 books I read were the old man and the sea, a biography of John Walsh and a paperback about the Jonestown massacre, I never slept regularly after that (sa earlier in life was masked until this past year), in grade 6 all i can remember was being absorbed by Nike and Kathy Lee Griffin kids in sweat shops and Celina Mays a 12 year old in her 8th month of pregnancy going missing without a question. It overtook me at 12, and twice again at 23, but I found great people from 25 to 35, now 40 and with MAiD in canada, the new world order i spoke to my parents at 9/11, kids are accessories, censorship is control and dishonest.

Jimmy

Solid episode.

trythinking

yea except its not though

Allyson

What's 'not'?

trythinking

the way in which you speak should not determine whether someone has grounds to murder you. thats the difference.

trythinking

comments are full of the exact thing they are talking about. unfortunately, most of andrew's audience is this insane left who still cannot see clearly. some were able to snap out of it. most are just doomed to remain in their ignorance.

soph

I don't think it's both sidesing to hold your own accountable

Allyson

What 'side' is the one who created this mess and called for the public execution of 'the left'?

higamerXD

Hey honest question, But at what point would an assassination on hitler go from a bad thing to a good thing? Genuinely, i mean it, surely in 1938 when he invaded poland that point had already passed right? Hitler was tolerated for a long time, even tho he spoke of horrible things. Now trump is sending people to actual death camps, and we are sitting here saying that all violence is bad. Why do we tolerate trump to do it anyway?

higamerXD

Andrew i would to like know, And i really mean this. Is alright if you dont answer but atleast ask yourself this: Would you say that killing hitler before the war started end up being a good thing? Or not? Trump is sending people to actual death camps, he is kidnapping old ladys from thier homes. He saying he might invade mexico or take over canada or greenland. At what point does voilence against voilent people go from bad to good? I would really want to know. I have extensively studied the history of germany and japan before the war and i would totally want to talk more about this. But to say that all political voilence is wrong, i have to disagree. Its a necessary evil. It doesnt matter if its right or wrong. What matters is the effect it will have on humanity itself. Can we really allow the most powerful nation on earth to keep becoming more and more of a dictatorship?

Odie Moses

Yall should clip the antisocial part and upload that

trythinking

when did hitler put a microphone up and invite anyone to come debate him in an open forum? trump sending people to death camps? see, this is the imaginary world leftists are living in. we want to deport illegal immigrants who are by definition all criminals, and you see it as "death camps". There just is no way to have a reasonable discourse if you literally cannot observe reality properly. Also, many of hitler's own "side" attempted to kill him numerous times. He never let anyone know where he would be, changed plans frequently, showed up late or early to speaking engagements, etc and this is how he survived those attempts. This is why he had his specialized SS which was his ideology based paramilitary personal army basically who did the majority of the mass murdering and was not the average german drafted soldier. So, to be like hitler, controlling speech and media was the actual biggest advantage they had even over technology and firepower compared to other countries fighting them. They mass produced radios to give the citizens, curated all their content into a homogenized overarching message coming from their music, entertainment, news, etc. Now, the media situation in germany far closer resembles what the left has been attempting to do for decades now, from entertainment to news they have tried to shut down opposing opinion and create a facade that appears like everyone from music to movies to leaders all agree. Right when conservatives gained back a little bit of the media narrative, people started trying to kill them for it.

trythinking

who called for the public execution of the left? i dont know what youre talking about.

Gianni Zollo

he literally covered those “other side” violent acts in this vid tho

Elton DeJohneres

Why release this whole thing about how violent the left is before we know anything about the shooter? Gotta be first to everything I guess. Pretty stupid shit.

higamerXD

Well, if you think that fugitive immigrants who run from places where they woul certainly die are by definition deserving of being send to el salvador i think that pretty fucked up. You did not even awnser if it was better or not if hitler died. So far there have been multiple assassination attempts on trump aswell. Is it not obvious yet that trump is also significantly influencing the media? He has banned some whole media companies from even attending white house speeches. I really cannot understand why you think that trump is so much better. Not to mention that trump is now the most powerful pedofile on the planet, surely you know that atleast right? The epstein connection is a big fucking deal, and epsteins connection with Israeli intresting is hard to overlook. Ghislain's dad was literally a national hero to Israel? What more does trump need to do to be seen as evil? Also, yes in Germany hitler eventually gained full control over the media, but there are very good reasons people decided to listen to him in 1919, his populist rethoric really is not so different from what trump does. And hitler also really did fix a lot of economic issues. But trump is walking the whole world in death, how can you not see that? If he really does go to war (mind you most European nations did not believe hitler would go to war for a long time) then isnt it already far too late to do anything at all?

Elton DeJohneres

He doesn’t really take a side on anything so I’m pretty sure he’s safe lmao

soph

I dont understand why so many people think holding your own accountable is wrong. If we on the left dont value human life and the potential for humans to change, we are no better than anyone else who spews hatred and violence. Hatred and violence dont have a party or political affiliation. Leftists holding other leftists accountable for our actions when we start acting hateful and violent is what makes us different from the right, who celebrate when their enemies die. The tragedy of CK's death is not that he cant be a conservative anymore. The tragedy is that his conservatism was a choice, and he had the potential to make a different one, and make a difference for good. That potential died with him, making him a martyr for MAGA. That is an L for the left.

soph

I question your auditory processing abilities if you think this is a video about how violent the left is.

soph

It would be better to meet Hitler as a child and convince him that politics are a bad career choice. If you think the answer to violence is more violence, you will never end violence.

Noah Mingus

We need a National General Strike and Workers Councils NOW!

Elton DeJohneres

They implied (Hunter and Andrew) that the shooter was a leftist.

higamerXD

Well its a little late now dont you think? I like your mind set but its not like we can time travel, its nice to protect the future but right now trump is one of if not the most dangerous person on earth. Realistically the outcome seems to be pretty bad if he follows up on what he said "there will never be another election" and all that. Political populism has no place in this world but that doesnt mean the AFD in Germany doesnt already have a 30% vote from younger people. Thats a real problemen right now. No amount of teaching children is going to help that right now. No amount of helping kids in 1936 Germany would have helped the millions of dead soldiers. Also, trumps own mother could not convince him not to go into politics, why would you be any different? Doesnt he have free will too? If his free will is to rape murder and kill then when is it right to remove him from the equation? Trump is the most powerful most dangerous pedofilie in the history of the world. What the fuck do we do about that other then anything at all thats possible? He is a monster.

Dreg McGade

And this will calcify a lot of people’s views so they won’t even attempt to understand someone else’s viewpoint, thinking them potentially lethal if they express the wrong opinion. This if terrible for everyone on any side, including no side at all.

higamerXD

Imo, it doesnt matter if you are better or worse. What matter is that you dont let people murder people. 6000 mass shootings is fucking insane. There have been 23 (correction: less then 100 if you take a broader definition) in Europe total sinds like the 80. How is that not an obvious HUGE societal problem? How many people have died directly due to trumps actions with ice so far? Multiple legal us citizens have been deported. People have been shot by the police all the time. What the fuck are you talking about? The only action we can take in such extreme circumstances is extreme actions lest we let the true evil gain even more power and influence. What if trump really does invade mexico or greenland? Thousands could end up dead from it. What is the value of one life if that one life will cost a thousand more? Its a classic case of the trolley problem in its most extreme form. Do nothing and let thousands die, or take action against a regime that has no interest at all in your opinion. Something is very very very wrong here, huge sweeping changes HAVE to be made or thousands will keep dying. Do you even have any idea how unsafe general American infrastructure is? The amount of road deaths can be directly attributed to cost cutting efforts by the government. This is not a left or right or right or wrong problem, this is a everything problem.

AGM-Prism✦

One of your best pieces Andrew, amazing work

higamerXD

This is the fundamental problem with allowing any form of platform to exist for populisme, this has been an issue since the ancient greek and doing anything about it will be the single most difficult thing in human history. A lot of things are only going to get worse so long as we dont change everything our society is build upon. Understanding "limits to growth" and its newer forms has been the most sobering thing i have ever done and i recommended you learn about it too to understand the severity of the situation. 2025 is the last year of stability according to all calculated metrics. We have to do better soon or this is going to be the last thing we dint do.

higamerXD

Political voilence most commonly only comes in 2 forms. From the far right, or against the far right. One worked for the better of humanity, the other certainly not. A few rare exceptions have been leftist revolutions but those most often ended up failing due to right wing powers anyway.

higamerXD

I just want to remind everyone here about "limits to growth" if you dont know what that is i implore you to look it up and let that also influence your view on trump. We as humanity are rapidly running out of time. Funny words or kind actions wont matter by the time climate collapse fully sets in. The global situation is more dire then ever. How can we even find the time to care about the death of an influential bigoted asshole when we have so many much bigger issues that really need a lot of attention like a decade ago? I still believe in humanity but holy fuck, we need to get our priorities straight like right the fuck now. The problem isnt the left, or the right, or you or me, the problem is a lot of other things but certainly not the common people.

Monica Huettl

How were you able to get the first interview, Andrew?

3a10x12

fediverse

Bad Andy

Release the Epstein files

Ben

So now we know the shooter was a “Nick Fuentes” republican, with a MAGA family. People who were so quick to jump on the “far left”. Reflect on that.

Pb

Andrew chill with the ominous background sounds. Distracting mainstream media move

wokeface

Super well done interview. I'm sorry for the trauma this guy endured but he might be the best level headed spokesperson to be seen in the aftermath. Hope this gets a ton of eyes from both sides on YT. And Andrew, please don't burn yourself out bud.

wokeface

Yeah but some may view it as an eye for an eye. Someone down to assassinate a journalist is not rational..

wokeface

ditto, let people choose their response, emotionally manipulative soundtracks are unnecessary and erode credibility and negate trusting viewers to to draw their own conclusions from the content.

Anjuli Kumar

Idk how you find time to do everything you do. You’re awesome and you make me wanna work harder at my passions. Keep it up.

Justin B Ashley

I'm not surprised, I'm just disappointed. After watching this, whatever happens to the Democrats and 'the Left' is probably what they deserve. I hope they've planned beyond Project 2025, because the runway is clear ahead for them to do whatever they want.

Bibity bop

The trouble is that the president we have right now is different than every other politician in western democracy. The normal thing for them to do in this situation is tell everyone to calm down. But unfortunately he is stoking the flames and escalating the rhetoric even when pushed to bring the country together. This president is not a unity politician. Contrast his comments to the Utah governor

Steph

Hey Andrew does Hunter have an amazon wishlist or cashapp? Would love to send something his way for his daughter after all this. Loved the interview, thank you ❤️

soph

I definitely 100% agree with every single point you made except the fact that violence is somehow the solution to unsafe infrastructure and gun violence

soph

"it's a little late now, don't you think?" is an insane take. the internet has rotted your brain and i implore you to go outside until your brain fog has cleared enough to allow you to realize that the political state of this country is not the result of cruelty, but of actual, absolute stupidity as a result of the intentional failure of the US public school system and the systemic effort to keep poor children out of it and marginalized people enslaved and imprisoned. the solution to an education problem is not shooting people in the neck. the solution to an education problem is educating people, which is exactly what this guy was trying to do to Charlie Kirk. He was trying to educate him and convince him and his followers to change his mind in the same way that he became educated and changed his own mind. You might not believe that CK or any of his audience ever would have changed their minds, but now we'll never know. Because he got shot and became a martyr instead of getting the opportunity to become more educated in front of a public audience of uneducated Utah Mormons who definitely would have benefitted from hearing actual statistics about trans people.

cam williams

“Was” is doing some heavy lifting in that first sentence. Definitely not what his Uncle and two close friends (primary sources) have reported.

Lildim sum

Omg that one due cheerin😦😭😭😭

cam williams

So in your hypothetical time-traveling question we can reach a time before he takes power, but not a time where we can do something to enact change in a positive way? There’s no way other than violence? Shit like this does make me think “well it’s a little late now”.

Ben

Tyler Robinson, 22, the man arrested in connection with the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, comes from a MAGA family, his grandmother has revealed. Although MAGA figureheads have been quick to point fingers at the left for Kirk’s death, Tyler’s grandmother, Debbie Robinson, 69, insisted that they come from a family of Trump supporters. She spoke with Daily Mail on Friday after news of Robinson’s arrest broke. “My son, his dad, is a Republican for Trump,” Debbie told the outlet. “Most of my family members are Republican. I don’t know any single one who’s a Democrat

soph

hunters entire argument was a statistical analysis showing that most gun violence is NOT committed by trans people or leftists. but even if hunter and andrew had no idea who the shooter was, it makes sense that they would be baffled about the state of discourse in the immediate aftermath. andrew and hunter explicitly commented on the RHETORIC of people in the immediate aftermath of the shooting: how spectators on both sides were quick to politicize CK's death instead of emapthize with him and the witnesses, especially his young children. he showed clips of the media circus on both sides politicizing the shooting instead of just being a normal human about the fact that gun violence is crazy right now. he contrasted that with interviews with the people who actually witnessed the shooting at UVU, all of whom could empathize with the victim, because they were witnesses to the horror. the terminally online are too desensitized to violence, and too much of our society is terminally online. I think that is the main point they were trying to make here, not anything about the shooters identity.

Eli Gaultney

you're doing great andrew and team, keep it up. what a champ this guy was for being willing to stay up so late...but maybe it's hard to sleep after all the excitement.

cam williams

Yes, his family is, he is not. Reported by three separate people who had direct relationships with him, one being his uncle. Notice how your source didn’t address dude at all, just his family? Confirmation bias or malicious ignorance, either way it’s a bad look.

Jamesdean00

'DREW GREAT INTERVIEW GREAT CONTENT KEEP IT COMING (pause) STAY BLESSED AS ALWAYS & ITS REALLY UP YOU ABOUT THE CARNIVAL EVENT, I MEAN RAPPERS STAY BOOKING & CANCELLING EVENTS. THE FANS GET A REFUND THE VENUE PULLS THEIR INSURANCE MONEY EVERYONE GETS PAID & LAID & ITS STILL FREE CRIP MAC. ONE LOVE!

Ernesto Estrada

I’m curious why you’re placing a higher value on the uncle than the Grandma. Grannies alllllllllllllways have the tea…

zigzagmo

the actions of one do not represent the whole, let’s not be too hasty in punishing a group of people because some are violent and insane

Ernesto Estrada

I don’t think it’s about both sizing… not necessarily, it’s more about convincing everyone to agree that regardless of the societal problems that we have going on and the political problems that we have going on– there has to be a strong agreement the temperature of our current society’s bubble is too hot. Every move you make online is tracked and somehow monetized, regardless of your own choices. America is still decades behind consumer protection when compared to Europe’s privacy, protect protection laws. While every American gets monetized, including their reactions online and their watch time – they’re also forcing the entire population to spend their funds and monetize all time on the very apps and companies who are then using those funds to do stock buyback to pump their own prices — AND those funds are also being promised to the current administration in exchange for better regulation or straight up deletion of the regulations. It’s a self feeding cycle and every American is being kept in a pissed off state so that they are the most profitable, because that is when their watch times peak. Responses to post also peaks at a high anger level, so if they post something that they know is wrong they know that the post will get a certain percentage more post than usual. To defeat the system, you first understand the system. You don’t defeat the system by encouraging more Americans to die. I disagree because Charlie wish from my existence in the US to be removed – but there was no reason for him to die. RIP

Jerkelbakal

Appreciate you addressing the criticism from previous posts about the lack of content and 5casts for patrons. Was feeling butthurt because I subscribed specifically for more 5casts

Allyson

Kirk wanted public executions, after the murder many on the right called for extermination of the left. Nobody here has yet addressed that there have been numerous murders by violent right wing extremists and a tiny amount to the left but there was no video about the right mocking the death of people assassinated on the left. Most people on 'the left' said they didn't like Kirk's views but violence is never the answer, but they have cherry picked a few idiots here. Most people on the right called for violence against 'the left' after this shooting - there are not two sides. Not to mention the fact that guns are the issue here. This intent to find an opportunity to both sides this because of a small number of idiots celebrating this is abhorrent. It is no different to Trump's 'good people on both sides' comment. Here is a better way of phrasing this - from social media: "Just thinking about how the right made up an entirely fictional left wing character that resulted in so many bomb threats and the like and nobody will face consequences. But people on the left who accurately clocked the victim’s life work lost jobs." The reality is that 'the left' describes people who want an equal society. People who celebrated the death of Kirk are not 'the left' - they are just awful people. Awful people is not a political stance.

Chunky7453

Can’t believe we live in this world

Benjamin Silla

I rather want my money goes to supreme content once every second week than garbage everyday. Of course i pay to see the content but i mostly pay to support the voice of channel 5

poormr.blue

First off, my deep sympathies to Hunter as well as anyone else who witnessed the killing. It must have been deeply traumatic. I would like to offer that I think that, for the past many years, the political system has failed many people. I do believe that, essentially, it's the deteriorating effects of capitalism which is disorienting so many people. A lot of desperate, hopeless living conditions, and a lot of alienation. I do believe exploitation lies at the heart of that. That being said, the feelings which arise out of this deterioration are general. The right, including Charlie Kirk, likes to direct these discontents against certain groups of people. It's attractive for disaffected people to be told what is the cause of their problems, even if it isn't true. But the media and political establishment's sensationalism around issues like immigration and transgenderism, mixed with the ever worsening or at least stagnating material conditions, sustains the fuel for hatred, misguided as it may be. There isn't a strong enough left to counter this. Democrats are largely feckless, and though they espouse better social values, they don't do enough to address people's material conditions. And in that ineffectiveness, the door is opened for the right to take influence, especially when they so openly corral the negative energy and direct it so clearly. But it's a dirty trick because it's just playing cover for the capitalists... the most active group in worsening people's lives. Unless people's very real material conditions are acknowledged and addressed correctly, the violence and tension seen here will continue. I also believe that a real leftist movement has to be extremely principled and clear in outlining it's real opposition, who, in my opinion, are the capitalists (by this, I mean those who own the means of production, CEO's etc. , not just those who subscribe to the economic system ideologically). There will never be a serious change without addressing this. If we improve the conditions of everyone's lives, I think it only follows that the social fabric will improve.

swellpunk

Obviously Andrew engages with the people not just from a different perspective but with a different attitude than Charlie. That doesn’t change the fact that media outlets will spin Andrew’s takes to look ‘radical’. Any maga chud will just believe what Fox News tells them to believe about Andrew. So I understand the fear—it’s important to touch grass while there’s still grass to touch but even I am sometimes scared to go to large events like that as an audience.

swellpunk

Did Andrew go on jubilee?

cheesenut

You just think your better than most dont you? Hey kud your not gonna change a damn thing. We all think we will come together and change the world and we dont have much time left! Omg yummy yummy for my bummy. Your all soft kids. Soft suburban americans. Stfu

Ben

Post your source. Also, is this an admission that being “pro-fascism” is right wing if anti-fascist messaging is indicative of leftism?

Jack O'Brien

Super interesting, intelligent, humble guy with profound perspective and clarity in face of the recent trauma. The sort of citizen that is sorely needed. Andrew and team, keep up the good fight and the brave journalism.

Ben

MAGA was ASTOUNDINGLY quick to START the civil war rhetoric before knowing anything. Then ASTOUNDINGLY quick to DROP the Civil war rhetoric once they found out the shooter wasn’t a leftist. My neck had whiplash.

josh e

If people wanna think about eye for an eye i dont think andrew will be their target

josh e

Obviously. Thats the REASON he got killed imo not a JUSTIFICATION. again, obviously

josh e

Media spin definitely played a role in this killing, like most. I just dont think C5s stuff can be spun as easy as Charlie's stuff can be. Even with no media spin charlie was devicive and made bold statements. Andrew makes less statements and asks more questions

Elton DeJohneres

Okay I see you are dug in on this and I’m not going to go point by point, back and forth with you, agreeing and pushing back. Based on what I’ve seen, I’m pretty sure the shooter is a groyper and if Andrew had waited a few days to put this out, that information could have been included for a much more complete picture and not just some people speculating in the immediate aftermath. And yeah, I do think this is framed in a questionable, knee jerk, reactionary way. But we can disagree on that, that’s fine. Channel 5 has a diverse audience so we’re not going to agree on everything. Looking forward to the next video about the actual shooter!

Ben

Gun safety reform should be taken seriously, especially given the current climate. I believe that now is a time to utilize the Republican sentiment towards Charlie Kirk’s recent assassination, and enact common sense gun control in his name. I’m sure Republicans would be willing to work with Democrats on the issue in the name of remembering Charlie Kirk. The act can be titled the “Charlie Kirk Gun Safety Act”.

Ben

Charlie Kirk Gun Safety Act Gun safety reform should be taken seriously, especially given the current climate. I believe that now is a time to utilize the Republican sentiment towards Charlie Kirk’s recent assassination, and enact common sense gun control in his name. I’m sure Republicans would be willing to work with Democrats on the issue in the name of remembering Charlie Kirk. The act can be titled the “Charlie Kirk Gun Safety Act”.

sentient tv static

Totally get rethinking the tour. You gotta do what feels safest for you and your team. We'll keep supporting you regardless. That said, if the show still goes on I'm looking forward to seeing the Medford show in October. Keep up the good work, my dude. But put your health and wellbeing first.

Floodo1

politics is hopeless and for the easily deluded It’s up vs down not left vs right fam

kjo

Thank you for this interview. As an older Millennial, I am always shocked how EVERY young person is 1 or 2 degrees away from a mass shooting or gun violence. A big blind spot I have given my age. This person gives me hope that people can be persuaded, and find the grace to live with people with whom they disagree.

higamerXD

The shooter so far very much looks to be a right wing extremist, nazi on nazi killing is one of the more common forms of political voilence historically speaking, going back all the way to musolini

higamerXD

I get that, but what other options are left then to make space to actually discuss these ideas? The american ruling class has done everything they can to make it as hard as possible to come to a solution. I dont see many options left on the table.

higamerXD

I like this idea, but i live in the netherlands and here and in Germany far right polical groups are also rising to power rather fast. CK was very good at teaching people how to be a right wing extremist, he framed his information is a very manipulative way, with often lies and deceitful rethoric in between some actual truths. His 2nd to last sentence was "too many" in saying that trans mass shooter was a huge problem. There where 5 out of 6000. How is that education over indoctrination? Twisting the truth and manipulating public opinion is the text book way fascist rethoric comes to power, its how hitler rose to power with his nazi party. It wasnt just a magical rise to to power, it was the systematic manipulation of the truth that layed out the groundwork needed for him to have a place of power. People back then gave many of the same talking point as you do now, the netherlands had a rather big nazi party before the war broke out exactly because of how hitler said the things he said. Now we have trump doing many of the same exact things. He bombs innocent people, he killed 11 people on a boat in international waters. If any EU politician would do that they would be arrested immediately. We are so far past the point where good education is going to have an actual effect on the here and now. These voilent warmongering people do not leave any space for the truth, it is you against them. Thats how THEY want it to be, its what is most advantageous to them. It is simply not possible to try and fight back trough education when the platforms they run have millions of dollars in budget, thousands of diffrent outlets, entire media groups in their control. This isnt like 1920 germany, its far closer to 1931. If the maga movement gets their way and follows up on the claims they are making it will be the death of thousands of people. They wsnt to deport so so so many people, at this point the orders from above dictate those actions, even if the agents that do it disagree it doesnt matter anymore. I like your sentiment of education and in a perfect world that could have prevented this from happening at all. But is already happening. We are in serious dire trouble. The global economic systems are rapidly floundering under the stress of climate change, economic growth is entirely unfeasible withing about 5 to 10 years due to resources scarcity. If we dont take global action against the most problematic people sooner rather then later humanity and the whole world is doomed to extinction. The study "limits to growth" quite clearly states that 2025 is likely going to be the peak of capitalist society, most socio-economic studys around recourse scarcity sugest that extremist rethoric will only become more popular as the world situation continues to worsen. We are doing very very poorly, and some truly unimaginable things need to happen if we want to have any chance at all of still being alive 20 years from now. Its nice that you want to educate people but if everyone is dead before the end of the century under the current system then long term we need far more drastic actions then what you seem to suggest.

higamerXD

Sorry buddy, but im damn glad to never set foot in your rotten country. Im dutch and i would not touch the americas with a 20 kilometers pole due to people like you.

ProfessorPi

its interesting how the guy is all

ProfessorPi

it's interesting how the guy is all "the problem is so complicated idk how to solve it." and the problem IS complicated but we need some better way of thinking about it that applies simplifying assumptions and heurisitcs, because if nobody knows what the right move is, well, nothing will get done.

Danny Sterling

Great work Andrew and everyone at channel 5. RELEASE THE 20v1!!! 😂

Alef Khoury

Will: “What a country!” Matt, immediately : “Jackoff Smirnoff” He’s still got it folks 🥰

Michael

Did yall even watch the video? I don't know how you could have come to this conclusion after watching it.

Michael

Right?? Poor guy still has a hospital bracelet on. I'd have a hard time staying composed and I'd honestly be scared to do any interview. This guy is brave, smart, and I look up to him. I even came away with more respect for charlie kirk as well. Despite disagreeing with Kirk on the solutions, they agreed on the issues and were willing to talk it out and consider changing their stances.

djdeutschebahn

"Royality free music from youtube" haha I thought the whole time you were making your scores from the scratch .... were dope af frfr

djdeutschebahn

The interview is top grade as always 🌐

SlipperyMarat69420

Blue shirt got his eyes open: everything else is a distraction

trythinking

thank you! yes we need more people to NOT want to come here. Yes it is rotten, tell everyone they should not come to the rotten USA please, thank you sir.

trythinking

you just are repeating all the false information without any evidence. my point was that its not trump's own people trying to kill him like was the case with hitler. You really need to study more about WW2 and nazi germany if you still cannot see why comparing that to modern USA and trump only makes you sound like a very stupid person. And you dont understand still...the messaging from nazi's was the ONLY message out there. There was no internet or independent media. Whatever you heard from the nazi party WAS all you heard. Take advantage of modern times and get some information outside of your curated leftist information chain. You at least need to learn more about actual fascism and you will be able to see why its ignorant to compare it to trump. Hitler was not voted in by a popular majority of the country, they basically tricked the retiring chancellor to name him as new chancellor thinking they could control him, but hitler immediately dissolved any way for a congress to determine laws and took all power into one branch basically. I mean, go learn more dude before trying to have this conversation.

JLo87

Good job good man

Justin B Ashley

... differing core beliefs? I watched it once, and another segment of it another time to make sure I heard it right. Hunter is literally the poster boy for the type of person the will continually walk all over. I don't think he's an idiot, or misinformed - I just think that following his pathway would be the precise intent; be docile, take the high road, and slowly let your political enemies, who have been very clear about their end goal, continue to setup the gallows and tie the noose around your necks. That is also an incredibly white opinion, coming from a big ole white dude myself. I can sit here on my ass the entire time and be fine, people who I care about, people in my community - they are being attacked today, daily, weekly, and the pace is only going to increase. To be fair, I'm not sure this interview could have been anything but what it was. Is Hunter really going to go on video a day after and say anything that is going to put a target on himself? I doubt it. The folks at Channel 5 clearly have the same sorry, so I'm inclined to believe that has a chilling effect on what was said in the interview, versus what we might say a few months down the road, once the emotion has died down and people aren't afraid to speak.

Jason Baker

Andrew, I need you to be my lawyer. I’m going to sue the Granite School District for discriminating against my mental illness. Hit me up - 801-554-8274

gosttt

bro who cares if he was a father so are literally billions of other people that means I gotta respect the bigot? " oh no he breathed oxygen how could you say that" yeah he did something humans are biologically coded to do, nothing about that means I gotta respect him, rest in piss bozo packfuccinwatch

Adirondack chair

Can I say I disagree with the take that celebrating this is antisocial and sociopathic? I think the overall feeling comes from the fact that he can't hurt anyone anymore. How many people went to sleep without fathers and mothers because of the vitriol he spewed?

Adirondack chair

Also, am I obtuse for thinking transgender rights/recognition is the LAST thing the right will ever hear someone out on? Like this seems like an ineffective hill to die on since it's an irrational fear they're fueled by on this topic. Idk, this guy kinda pissed me off.

Jason Baker

Call me Andrew…801-554-8274

The Ders

I'm sorry but the gun control defeatism is just sad. Yeah, there's a bunch of guns out there, but just being like "welp nothing we can do about it" is never going to fix anything either. I'd rather people try then just keep on chugging with the status quo and letting gun violence go unhindered

The Ders

Also, an iron front flag on the same wall as a NATO flag? Lmao plus an iron front logo showing up in two interviews now

somekindabird

Best news bc c5 doesn’t tell you what to think or how to feel…just what happens and opposing feelings, with intention for the viewers to come to their own feelings and intuitive takeaways

BREIZH

I'm going to humble myself a little : I did not feel sympathy for Charlie Kirk as an individual I now see that I've been inconsistant with my morals on this topic. I'm reminded that I'm actually capable of losing empathy towards a person, and that reminder is not pleasant. I am gratefull for it and I want to thank you both for that 👍

Pyornkrachzark

I feel so sad for right wingers and leftists who can't set aside politics and look at this from a pure human perspective. Yes Charlie Kirk was spewing hateful rhetoric but to have no empathy for him and his family is a grim reflection of society and how divided we are. The only way to move forward as a country and a human race is through empathy and constructive conversation. Thank you for everything you do Andrew and I can't wait for what you have to come

Cupid Valentino

Is there any video or audio from when it actually happened? I really don't want to see or hear it so thought i'd ask before watching

Rachel

Yes, the blurred it so you can’t see it but you will hear audio. Skip the first 30 seconds. It might be elsewhere in the video too but idk when.

J G Wentworth

Its the internet and most people don't mean the hateful comments it's just funny🤣🤣 I don't judge someone's character from their internet posts,Its just the internet📱

Stannis Baratheon

I feel the opposite after watching this. I can recognize that political violence is horrible and makes things worse while also not feeling empathy or mourning his death. I'm not going to celebrate and I'm not going to mourn, and I am not obligated to do that. I think the quote about the cost of gun violence really highlights why I feel this way. Kirk was ok with people dying for his right to own guns. But I am 100% sure he did not consider himself, his friends, or his family as one of those people. He was fine with death when he can ignore it. Kirk was a public figure and his words did have some influence on people. Those words helped justify those deaths that shouldn't have happened. I think we should treat Kirk like he wanted those faceless nameless numbers to be treated. Thoughts and prayer, then move on. Also a much simpler argument is why would I mourn someone who wanted to cause me harm? I think it might be easier to mourn or feel empathy with Kirk when you have more visible similarities with him, like height for example.

teegeebee

Agreed! That was disappointing.

teegeebee

Right?! I was shocked when he said this. Great point you brought up - imagine telling those people they ought not to celebrate fhe death of someone who encouraged the hunting of their family member. Those takes are so Frustrating.

teegeebee

I think it's totally valid for trans people, Black people, women and immigrants to be happy about the death of someone who not only meant them harm, but encouraged others to join in on their hate campaigns. CK's "beliefs" and "opinions" were the same ones that led to actual policies that hurt so many groups of people/communities. He was anti-immigration, anti-abortion, fully Islamophobic, anti-Black, despised trans people...And he made it his mission to make sure that others believed the disgusting things he believed. Just because you choose to mourn him and not look at the harm he caused while alive does not mean others have to. To police how folks react to his death is absurd. To act like death makes someone automatically redeemable and exempt from criticism is extremely irritating. It's okay to say "___ is dead and I'm actually happy about it because _____". That doesn't make you a sociopath.......

Adirondack chair

I think making the sweeping statement that it's sociopathic disregards the ethos. He can't hurt anyone anymore.

Duterte Whitaker

You are undestumating the influence of the NRA. The $pend a ton bankrolling conservatives and centrist democrats. I think lobby reform has to happen before we can fix this, along with health care and a few other issues

DCSHYT

Charlie Kirk is like the white nipsey hustle right now low key haha end gun violence senseless violence

DCSHYT

Lmao . I feel this comment but also.. humans are actually super desensitized to the human condition that there’s a subtle lack of togetherness even in people not speaking to one another. Men do that all the time

who, me

I would love for Channel 5 to investigate the possibility that Tyler Robinson, the alleged shooter, was a groyper. This is a pretty significant question, I think, and Channel 5 might be well suited to investigate and address this.

who, me

are assuming the shooter was a leftist? coz that is anything but clear.

who, me

This is a bit, right?

Virginia Hanna

The video clips from the event are making me cry. It's so sad to see all the cheering people, happy to engage in life and debate and they're young and impressionable and it's ok that they are passionate, being 18-30 is a GREAT time to be really passionate and explore your thoughts and beliefs. Anyone can change their mind and heart, so long as it's still beating.

Virginia Hanna

It doesn't eliminate his thoughts or rhetoric! In fact, it closes a window where ppl were able to debate with him?! I don't get it. I don't get it either. I'm honestly genuinely disgusted with the punk scene I came from, it's so self destructive and gross and I have full grown adult friends that are expressing immature grotesque thoughts. I'm like, are y'all trying to impress kids online? Your own kids? WTF?

Virginia Hanna

The answer is genuine community and compassion for one another. Figuring out your own emotional disregulation and pointing the finger at yourself when you feel mad or rage or anxiety... It's not anything else, it's coming from inside of you and you can change. You will change, it's inevitable. Find a healthy community with ppl that enjoy life and are emotionally regulated. You can have more than one community. I got pink, hippies, homesteaders, outside lovers, craft groups, craft beer lovers, corny movie lovers ..... Find what you love, regulate yourself and THEN try getting more involved in politics. It feels different.

Virginia Hanna

Fuck dude. I love this guy. Jubilee and Middle ground is one of my favorite shows!!! I love it. That's hilarious that Andrew didn't work out there, that's like booking Joe Rogan.... Which in my world is a compliment, he's a great interviewer in a lot of ways. Pobody's nerfect

C. H.

Next up: Hunter x Hunter debate

keanun vanhook

The answer to last mass shootings is less segregation and less hate in the population. The government and the media outlets blatantly separate us and turn us against each other. Unity is the only answer to any society. But humans haven't been able to figure that out

oly

or like, less guns maybe?

Carlos

explain the "lol" here

Matthew O'Brien

Don't let fear stop you from doing your thing. Life has always been, and will always be, incredibly dangerous for those who live it.

keanun vanhook

The issue with that is the fact that people will 100% get them even if they aren't legally sourced, or if they are outlawed. People do what the want to do so in order for them to not want to do mass shootings is for them to not have a reason to do so. Make it more necessary to help those in need, people with mental issues need more accessible help. There are so many factors at play and so many things I could go on about

w4tty

His name was robert poulson

Mariahhw

Andrew, are you okay? Missing you

Michael Simpson

was actually just feeling this so came here to see if anything has been posted.

Andrew Hinman

Andrew don't worry about trying to learn a whole new art let me make you music🫶 -Andrew

Chiefahleaf

We are definitely in the high tide of political tension. Where anyone from any political party wants to demonize a person who has a different opinion than their own and advocating violence as the first option is sickening. We are in the age of extremist supremacy on both ends we should rather trying to communicate and understand each other to find a middle point than trying to win/lose entirely.

Jake

This was a wild interview. I really wanted to know what was being said during the shooting but couldn't keep watching the footage. Thanks for blurring it out. Nice job with all this coverage. Appreciate you and the team

Tony S

15 minutes.

kaij u

hunter really impressed me. i want to see more of the left engaging with opposing views instead of just shutting down or resorting to hate. my heart goes out to him and everyone at that rally that came to witness a debate and instead had to see a public execution. what didn’t sit right was andrew calling people without empathy for kirk’s passing anti social. i was put off by the gleeful reactions too but im not going shame myself or any minority into mourning kirk. he spread rhetoric that dehumanized people, and given the size of his following his words held real power. and maybe this is a hot take, but i notice a pattern of white, heterosexual lefties expressing the most empathy for kirk right now. i think that comes from a good place, but i ask those same people to hold back judgment toward minorities who cannot show that same empathy. we have already carried so much violence and loss that you may not even fully understand. i say this with love as im not trying to divide us further, but i think some perspective is important as we are actually the most threatened by his hateful rhetoric. thanks for this interview 🙏🏻 i can’t express enough how grateful i am for how dedicated you are to providing fair coverage of such nuanced and polarizing topics.

mxmxmx

need more of the colorful UFA cast on c5!!!

Eric Seim

Hunter is very impressive and im glad his voice was amplified in this interview

Amir Dixon

To watch this and see the right wing lean and now know all along it was a right wing killer, the silence is telling.

DeadForTaxReasons

Using a corporate funded platform to argue black pilots didn't earn their jobs is violence. The fallot from that kind of rhetoric damages families.

Dr Qua

synths rock! good luck on that endeavor. you'll have a lot of fun. check out Benn Jordan if you somehow don't already know of him