Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 594399300.mp4

Downloads

Content

Hey guys,

Here's an interview with Nick, who produced the highest-engaged piece of digital journalism content of the past ten years.

AC

Files

Comments

Torridy

Just released haven't watched it yet, fucking Nick Shirley racist who doesn't care about actual fraud.

Jason Reynolds

THIS is why I pay for Andrew's patreon. Thank you sir.

jrhntr

Nick Shirley’s bullshit “journalism” is the reason Renee Good was murdered

Braden

Hes a fraud

wayne

Thanks for what you do bro!

Chad williams

Having adults allow people to just record my children seems very in line with Trump these days.

ZY

Come on AC. You and this rage bait guy have nothing in common. He is a propaganda mouth piece for the regime.

wayne

Nicks a fraud tho. He sold himself for sure. Just like that cam higby kid

Ronnie Brewington

“They wouldn’t let me see kids” is so crazy. Most daycares you have to register online

Tony S

This is neither independent or journalism.

josh e

4 minutes in he's just not addressing what your saying to him and questions you have. That Somali fraud shit is wild and glad it brought to light but I dont like this guy. Listened to him on another show too

josh e

He seems like he's on the right path but needs to learn some stuff still. Hope you dropped him some game

Wystan

Hilarious to me he’s talking about how the DNC pays the independent pundits harping on his reporting when he has made multiple propaganda videos for foreign powers

Psxo

Nick Shirley is a fucking fraud and the reason all this bs is happening in Minnesota. "Can me and these masked men come and record the children" like gtfoh

Chris

Commissioner of children. Why does no one press him on that? Theres no commissioner of children. Ask him what that is. Does he mean the DHS? Commissioner of children sounds like a PBS show.

Cameron Toy

Bro is not firing on all cylinders I’ll say that much.

Dylan Kay

Hats off to independent journalists, fully support asking questions

Patrick MacKillop

This dude sucks. Regardless of anything else it's like listening to Shawn Ryan or Shapiro. Boring as fuck. Andrew can't make this kid cool.

zigzagmo

when andrew asked if mormons don’t call themselves mormon anymore because of south park i died

n8raid

4:33 : "-- That's a really good question" When you just concede the point you were trying to make because lil bruh missing the forest for the trees ... Keep it up AC and team ❤️

Ahmet U

Man, hats off to you Andrew. I think I would've gotten up and left the room after he said billionaires don't want to be taxed an extra 5% because then that would mean they wouldn't be able to pay their employees as much.

bigchiefcrazysmoke

3:33 is the word learning really misspelled on their sign?

Wystan

How do I gain credibility among the right? Be racist lmao

crys7al

I mean it shouldnt be surprising that when people of the Administration share it advantageously it becomes super viral. In this political climate and world, why would I want people to have a clear view of peoples' babies? If I were a caretaker or parent in general, or who is especially not a not white person, people like Nick Shirley could be showing up with an obtuse agenda. Why is he targeting Minnesota? Is it because they empathetically took in more Somali people than other states? Or is it because Tim Walz has been strategically demonized for doing amazing things with a one seat majority like tax rebates for working class, 12 weeks paid family leave, 12 weeks paid sick leave, red flag laws for guns, sectorial bargaining for nursing home workers, free public college under 80k, and much more. I was a cynical teenager once. If you are a cynical teenager of any age, you need to question what ideological side is beckoning you and why.

justin

Thank you for doing this interview and respectfully pushing back on his claims and video!

Ronnie Brewington

And nothing will happen to him. The right is a death movement at this point

Amir Saifi

How inarticulate is this kid? And lmao at his cope with Andrew not saying enough about Charlie Kirk???

n8raid

Edit: this guys is cooked lmao. Okay, why does he refuse to say the lady's name, but says "thats who I was referring to earlier" like a minute later... I'm suddenly so suspicious of this guy lol wut. Doesn't make his reporting entirely false, but it's like he's hiding something

poorlord

You are being pretty generous calling it journalism.

Liz

If my first generalized thought about Somalis was really positive and grateful would he call me a liar?

Theo Rosenberg

Good interview but I really wish you would’ve called him out on more of his bs. Like when he said Trump has lost money when actually he increase his net worth by billions. Come on😭

Evian Rave

Did Nick's team have to vet you guys before you were allowed to do the interview? Were you screened by security? Funny he thinks he can just go visit a daycare and record strangers' children without doing the same.

Sicarius

Man I kinda agree with him on investigating fraud, but he really digs himself a deep hole in this video. He claims he's not politically motivated, then reiterates every single right wing talking point. He claims he's not racist, or islamophobic, then reiterates several racist and just incorrect statistics. Also not really willing to give any concessions that his video has inaccuracies. Disappointed. I knew nothing about him besides the fraud video and this video.

Carlos

Andrew interviewing Nick Shirley is like putting an MMA fighter in the ring with quadriplegic hahaha. This guy is...something else... His "journalism" is tailored for one thing - clicks. He's also too dense to understand how his content has been used by the administration to accelerate their agenda.

Matt Sturbate

Crazy seeing everyone covering their eyes and ears and retreating to their echo chambers in these comments.

Andy Kuhlman

Dead eyed muck raking accidental regime mouthpiece Chauncey the Gardeners his way into the zeitgeist. It took way to long and way too many unchallenged statements for this to get adversarial. Well it was an interview at least.

Ronnie Brewington

What good points? If he has good points so do rusty nails

Dro mastrr

Holy fuck this dude is so slow it hurts

Nolan

Damn this boy is slow.

Theo Rosenberg

Still watching, bro is actually brain dead

crys7al

Its sad that kids like this with this degree or ambition just get entirely fleeced and taken advantage of for social media snowball effect clout. You want to save the country millions? Investigate health insurance companies lil bro

Wystan

The fact that he is accusing you of supporting milk toast democrats by being left leaning truly shows his naivety in all things politics outside of the democrat/republican binary

Greg Thornton

Andrew continues to be the Columbo of interviewers. Masterful tactic to get this guy to reveal over and over that he is in fact racist and just wrong on basically everything.

crys7al

You dont need sleeper cell contracts for social media content creators when skeptic gullible uneducated populace are greased to believe skeptic gullible uneducated creators. The rightwing content pipeline flywheel has always been in effect in this regard, it requires $0 and the viewers dropping out of school

Sylv

Ordinarily I feel like you really nail the appropriate amount of push back and letting people hang themselves. This time though I think you underdid it a bit, let too much slide, shoulda pushed back a little more on some of this bro. This guy is literally regarded.

B B

I wanted andrew to ask about his lil trip to Israel a bit before that video dropped

Jason Reynolds

I hope you intentionally misspelled the word "retarded" because that's hilarious.

Robert Booth

You conceded way to much about the blue state red state thing. To say there are no nice cities is just wild Andrew.

Dro mastrr

Do you want us to acknowledge the few correct takes he had versus the multitude of stupid things he said? Sure fraud is probably real and an issue, but his rationale for why fraud happens, and his entire concept of how the country even operates from billionaires to migrants is literally some of the most brain dead shit I have ever listened to.

Sylv

Ah its a semi-common "slang" for it on platforms you aint supposed to say it haha.

Rafael

In the words of Tim Dillon, “We wish him well”

Ben dufour

It's embarrassing that you even had to interview this clown.

Dro mastrr

Gotta find common ground somewhere to have a real dialogue

Rachel

Multiple things can be true at once. Browsing comments and there seems to be alot of allegiance and snarky lean which blows. Hating doesn't get shift the tide.

Wystan

He’s not “platformed” through this. Like C5 says in the description, Nick made the most viewed expose in the modern era. I’m happy for the interview because it hammers home what kind of intelligence the administration is so unapologetically pushing

Bruce Deal

The housing discussion is shows how stupid this kid is lol

Malcolm Fairbanks

Tighten up! Nick Shirley. Thanks for standing on business, Andrew.

josh e

Wow this dude was rough. You handled him well. If you pushed harder he would gotten too mad, he was already starting to lose it and he stopped actually listening to what you were saying about 2 mins in.

Jeremy Dolan

This kid cannot answer a single question and sounds like he has a middle school education. How was Israel Nick?

Max B

did kid fuck stupid

Jeremy Dolan

You can tell Andrew is skeptical come on lol.

Rob

This kid is the textbook example of "Republican tacticians used religion as a cudgel to control the minds of the voters"

Robert Booth

It was. That was probably the shadiest place of all the places he visited.

3a10x12

u take palmers out yer mouth . RIP

Rob

Meh, Andrew has always just let people speak. I think think Channel 5 is great at letting people say stupid (or sometimes smart) things -- and just airing it raw and exposing who that person is.

Evan Godfrey

Andrew, one comment on rent prices going up. Most of the housing vouchers/section 8 are now competing with the rising rent prices. Some of the vouchers for 3-4 bedroom in the Bay Area are up to $5,000-$6,000. Which also keeps the rental prices up. So there is some merit supply and demand. We do a lot of property management and I would say 80% of our clients have one rental and barely make any money with the raising taxes/insurances etc.

WickedFoxy (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-05 05:00 Hey Nick 👋 & Andrew 👋 I think I figured out why they don't deal with other races because they are Muslim and they can't touch none Muslim without getting haraam like points off their afterlife cuz we're all filthy. So that's my guess of part of the fraud which they definitely are doing, it's happening everywhere 💯.
2026-01-10 04:30

Nolan

This dumb idiot is using the first Google search results as actual facts 😆

Mattlenny

Nick Shirley has room temp IQ

Kevin Medina

Keep up the good work Andrew! This is the type of friendly debate we need. Glad you had him on despite your disagreements.

HAM HAM HAM

Andrew's spreading this boy's cheeks

Robert Booth

Agree but he wouldn’t have been “pushing back” he just needed to answer the question nick asked him.

VtheBee

that would net BILLIONS not millions

John Doe

Lol ur not changing minds in a paywalled patron comment section. Fuck this guy

Samu

Can you put this up on X to counteract his bulllll

Mattlenny

This dumb fuck doesn't know what benevolent means, he's not beating the industry plant allegations. The most useful idiot mouth piece the right has ever had

zigzagmo

bro said it’s a stereotype that mormons have multiple wives literally right after saying somali men have multiple wives. you literally can’t even make that shit up

who, me

Jesus H Christ. What a dunce.

Carlos

One more thing...I've been a resident of Utah for 60% of my life (CA the other 40%) - i grew up around kids like this. This kid has grown up sheltered in an incredibly wealthy part of Utah (Kaysville has a 145k/yr median family income)... a place that is entirely homogenized and white. Its wild to hear him act like he actually cares about the struggle of normal Americans (or even knows what a real American is) when his entire world view was formed in a vacuum of white conservatism - where everyone could afford a nice house, two cars, and have always have a social safety net in the form of the wealthiest church in history.. remember, the church he grew up in will pay your rent, car payments, utilities, clothe and feed your family (really well) anytime you're in a bind. He has had enormous privilege thanks to de facto/religious socialism and doesn't even realize his entire world view takes that for granted. This boy has no idea about the real world.

ZY

I mean if you have a white American background would you want your kid to be the one kid that doesn't know the language all the staff are speaking?

Hipsterrunoff

Thanks Andrew and team. I thought it was really interesting seeing the debate interleaved in the interview. Andrew's attempt to have a heady discussion on their industry was unfortunately over Nick's head but maybe that will change over time. The disparity between Andrew and Nick's take on Billionaire intentions and motivations was a perfect demonstration of how far from critical thinking we are. I'd love to see more content like that. Basically a Dear Kelly for someone who really thinks a Billionaire moved to Texas so they could pay their employees more. Cheers C5! Keep it up.

Sean

In the neck

ZY

Blue cities have absolutely fucked up on zoning hard the past 40 years. Minneapolis is actually a city that is taking steps to increase housing supply by ending single family zoning. Most American cities are practically empty of housing stock compared to European cities. The fix is less land devoted to car infrastructure and upzoning.

Yeah

“I hope everything you are saying is true…” “Yeah i hope so too.” Real

ZY

I mean when the VP of the US retweets you idk if C5 is bumping this guy's views much compared to that. Is kinda funny though how Andrew asks him if the thinks non-traditional media will be coopted by the powers that be and they literally points out how Nick was used to cover up the Epstein files and stoke racist rhetoric.

Rachel

Ha, not dumb enough to change minds in a comment section. Just throwing it in like everybody else.

Richard Smith

I thought she was shot because she drove her vehicle at an armed Federal law enforcement officer, and struck him with it, while interfering with a law enforcement operation. I don’t believe she set out to harm that officer or to get killed. I do believe she set out to be a pain the ass and provoke a reaction while her wife filmed the whole thing. She got herself into a situation where the margin for error was very low, and then she made a terrible mistake.

testing (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-05 05:00 My favorite thing about Andrew's journalism style is that he makes the person he's interviewing look extremely stupid without even trying. He doesn't have to do any gotcha moments or use any tricky words. He asks simple straight forward questions and these idiots talk themselves in circles lmaoo
2026-01-10 04:58

Richard Smith

Aw, come on. He can be a racist AND care about fraud.

K.C. Simonsen

“Do I know what’s gonna happen after I die? Yes. But will it really happen? Who knows, no one knows we’ll see” lol dude. How do unintelligent people always become famous in America, god it’s relentless. This is the shittiest timeline and the future blows

Ben Walters

What in the special needs? Edit: maga, maga is special needs. Straight up

jrhntr

Why are you putting the blame on the deceased and not the murderer? And you can believe she was an ass, but that does not justify her losing her life.

n8raid

Also living in Utah, ex mormon, and I guessed he was after he mentioned utah. It was so clear to see his missionary voice come out, the Mormon phrases "signs of the times", the tense strain in his neck because he can't entertain anything outside the narrow jo smith framework. Tough. I feel for him, I feel like he just got used by right pundits. And he is clueless like I was, and may still be lol

Richard Smith

“Donald Trump, Elon Musk, and I’ll have to get back to you on the third one.” — after naming all two billionaires he can think of. That was rough.

Ben Walters

Nah, maga doesn't get to be people again.

Ben Walters

For the record, cops aren't supposed to execute criminals either. What's your favorite part of the boot to lick?

Carlos

Yeah that mo voice of "let me tell you why i'm right" is obvious. Non exmo people don't realize the LDS church has the navy seals of salesmen. They might be dumb, clueless, and offensive, but whatever they teach you at the MTC is working. Hence why every summer sales company from solar to pest control is HQ'ed between Lehi and Springville.

Andrew Miller

Genuinely props to you for keeping your cool, I can see in some moments it was difficult to not get frustrated in this interview. Your calmness is an inspiration for anyone in any profession and will continue to serve you well as a journalist.

Cooper Carrasco

A lot of people HELP stupid people look smart by raging at them / not even letting them finish their sentences.

Senator Palpatine

"He's your savior, he's my savior, he's everybody's savior" "Thank you." T_T

rhiannon

big props to your patience on this one

K.C. Simonsen

Maybe Andrew can be like a big brother to this kid and eventually he can understand why so many people disapprove of his content and opinions. I truly don't know how you can be an adult and not understand how the tensions and perspectives in this country are bound to interact. Like, even if he's not actually racist he should understand that his actions are definitely going to come off as super racist to a lot of people. And that if you walk up to anyone with a bunch of dudes in ski masks the reaction is always going to be 'we gotta get outta here.' It's so weird how many people don't get these concepts regardless of their political beliefs.

SeeGeeArtist

I'm glad to have seen more positive details about him, despite how horridly the fraud story was "investigated".

Andrew Miller

Idk, there were moments where Nick started to get kinda hot I think Andrew was just being extra cautious of that so not to get the interview chaotic. It is all a fine line. Pete Buttigieg a lot more coolheaded and that gave space for more pushback from Andrew. Nick, not so much; gotta feel things out. At the end of the day, the cluelessness of Nick was still revealed, he brought up so many contradictions, it's not Andrew's job to attack them, it's our jobs to make our own judgments. That's what makes C5's journalism so special.

Dumblescoff

His argument about rent and home prices going up because of immigrants actually gave me a brain aneurysm. Simply repeating supply and demand like a high school student isn’t going to prove your point buddy.

Sergio Peña

It’s crazy to think because I believe his parents have had a few fraud scandals. Andrew you better get on the California fraud shit before this bozo Shirley.

Jake

Andrew, please no screenshots of AI generated text summaries. I am very pro-AI, but it doesn't have the same credibility as showing other sources.

K.C. Simonsen

Come on, Andrew please teach him about the Journalists' code and how important fact-checking is and why it's also in his self-interest to not just be honest but KNOW you're telling the truth. He's stuck on this idea that he exposed 10 billion dollars of fraud when no one else could but he didn't fact-check at all. I could do the same thing with a video camera but it's not right to do cuz it further erodes the peoples' trust in journalism and they're likely never going to take you seriously again. And the more 'journalists' (influencers) get it wrong, the further it divides our already violently divided country and it could very possibly completely collapse our society if we don't start fixing it and seeing each other as something other than enemies.

Chris

People born into wealth never understand how beneficial the silver spoon is; never working for someone in your life is a massive benefit afforded to you by your obviously rich parents.

rachel harris

what a little shit can’t even shout out his moms

rachel harris

doing so much mental gymnastics trying to follow his point

joseph

Nick is a right wing sound byte machine with legs. also cried when he race checked the entire crew 😭

Gormab

Nick Shirley is still stuck on the Left Vs. Right rhetoric, and fails to see the bigger picture. I hope he figures out that red or blue we are in it together against the ultra rich.

joseph

Ironically Nicks church is doing fraud as we speak. investigate the LDS my mans 🥀

Chris

Ooh man, this boy is dumb as a rock. Trump not taking a salary isn't so noble when he's spending millions on vanity projects and vacations, you dog walked him through the landlord stuff, but I do wish you pushed back on his list on billionaires a little harder with that. He's not taking a $400k salary, yet his networth has increased by $4.3 billion in a year.

Chris

Austin's current mayor is a Democrat, the mayor before him was a Democrat, and believe it or not, the mayor before him, also a Democrat. A lot of these major cities in red states skew blue. Phoenix's mayor is also a Democrat, preceded by a Democrat.

SeeGeeArtist

Somalis* not Somalians, Nick

Daniel

Seems like a decent guy. Y’all are so mean lmao. His vids are missing some finesse and care but otherwise he’s alright

Christina B

It is so hard to listen to a billionaire apologist… yeah buddy they totally have our best interests in mind. He sounds delusional.

Carlos

They’re not missing finesse. His content purposely leaves out fundamental and basic perspective and context FOR CLICKS.

Andrew Miller

I think he was just showing what nick pulled up on his phone when he asked him to show him evidence

Mike K

I'm 28 minutes thru and i cant wait til the people on youtube see how stupid this guy is

Donovan Ault

I made it to 38 minutes and I don't think I can finish. Appreciate the sit down from both of you

Jared Golian

Should’ve asked him “what’s the first thing people think of when they think of Mormonism?”. The point would’ve gone over his head but it would be satisfying to see the mental gymnastic

Amir Saifi

Trump‘s forfeited presidential salary couldn’t keep a Somalian daycare going through March

Deleted_User

Finally someone actually interviewed this kid instead of fluffing him, Channel 5 always keeps it 100

Andrew O'Connor

Brooo nooo… not this retarded little freak grifter. He doesn’t deserve your attention man. Using human suffering to shell out for billionaire parasites and acts like he’s the victim. Fuck this freak. You wasted your time with this scab. There are more important things going on. Also, “Captain Phillips” c’mon now Andrew…. Do better.

Liam McGilligan

"If they're operating legally, why would they have anything to fear?" Nick, bro...... If they're operating legally why don't they just open the doors and let us see all the kids and give the names of the kids to me and these middle-aged white guys wearing face masks?

jogrnaut

Nick out there definin' Conformation Bias and Useful Idiot. Thx for weatherin' this for us AC. It was what I expected. Like goin' in to smell a fart. You know it's gonna be bad but, god dammit, you're just curious how much.

Andrew

Man he's playing right into the Ultra riches hand - poor people blaming even poorer people.

Dan Matheson

Elon being an ethical billionaire and one of the smartest people in the world is like saying Hitler was a good guy.

J

Nick is such an idiot

J

You’re stupid

Patrick Murphy

He totally exposes his self and the cover up at the 54 mark.

Graham Heydorn

Jesus Christ he needs to read a book or sit in on one of the daycare English lessons because you cannot speak like this as a supposed serious investigative journalist. Sounds like a “smart” fifth grader.

Chandler Smith

I'm so curious what was cut at 39:36

Hurricane

It was painful to listen to that kid talk, and it is HORRIFYING that he has a platform that's being amplified to more people whose idea of research is twitter posts and graphs from truth social. A.C. has the patience of a saint. The saddest part of this interview is that this kid will watch himself and think he crushed it. Keep up the dope work, and thank you for giving us the opportunity to be exposed to this journalist, who aspires to be articulate.

Graham Heydorn

“I lost a lot of respect for you for going silent on Charlie Kirk.” “Did you watch the video I did on it?” “No.” “You should” “I don’t want to”

MisterQuacker

The book of Mormon isn't a real translation, Reformed Egyptian isn't real. They believe native Americans descendants of a cursed people (see 2nd Nephi 5:21-23). Mormons didn't allow temple ceremonies to be done for black Africans, "not a single drop of negro blood", they are homophobic still to this day. Mormons are not the way they appear.

Ryan Zafft

Like Andrew said; to a degree, I think I can agree with Nick on some of these problems. I can understand the frustration. But the issue is that I frequently disagree with his ‘solutions’. Ultimately, they lack depth. He seems to look at lots of these problems from a single dimension. I don’t feel like he tries to understand different perspectives, and either ignores or is unaware of certain intricacies. That is just my opinion. Which is quite frankly, absolutely meaningless. But honestly, I respect his opinion. I live in Wyoming, and I listen to people regurgitate many of the things Nick said on a daily basis. There comes a point where you can’t ignore, disregard, or belittle these opinions. It comes down to people feeling upset or frustrated about something, and the only productive way to communicate with these people is not through argument or debate, but by offering solutions, and trying to find a shared belief or value that can satisfy as many perspectives as possible. Andrew, I appreciate the hell out you because I think you try your best to do that, or at least something along those lines.

Erik

Just wow. He’s something.

nodupkey

Good work. This is exactly how people should be interviewed. Let them show you who they are and what they believe. Be informed, don't pander, and keep it groovy.

Steven Zirarusha Shyaka

Shut your whore mouth😭 wtf ofcourse ppl are gonna shit on this idiot dickhead spouting nonsense

YIMBY 4 HEAVEN

aight i probably dont needn't watch this then

SourdoughDog

This was a tough watch, just hearing the continuous misses as he tries to string together a coherent thought, dude legit seems to be cognitively stunted. Disheartening to think some could hear him speak and receive it as sensible commentary, but I suppose that is the pandering power of political influencer content. Good on you guys for keeping it level and challenging some of his bs while letting his illogic speak for itself.

Taylor Fredrickson

What's the first thing you think of when you think of a Mormon? Polygamy. Don't be afraid to say it.

Lucas de Jong

y did u take the bait from a flat-earther

MisterQuacker

Joseph Smith had 30-40 secret wives, 8 of them under the age of 18. He was 37 when he married a 14yo. The lore goes deep, many mormons express the sunk cost fallacy and refuse to admit their entire life has been a fraud. Ironic

Tony S

Cruelty is the point.

Sadie

oof u can see when he switches from regular person to puppet and starts repeating his talking points cuz he can’t keep up with a normal conversation about his reporting

shrampling

Holy shit how did Andrew manage to call himself dumb in front of one of the more dumb people I've ever watch speak on record 😂 honestly still always so impressed. Don't be afraid to say the facts ! 😂

Luis Muriel

Hey channel 5 team, this reporting is great and all but if you had not noticed (I am sure you have), the United States is currently imploding from within. Please cover more of that and how the Trump crime family is slowly dismantling American democracy in real time. I am sure your ability to function as a solvent company will be severally compromised if the country suddenly turned into 7 countries, or if nuclear war ends our civilization as we know it.

shrampling

Oh and uh also?? El Paso is blue??

ano nihme

shirley is to journalism what feces are to grand cuisine… “it’s never journalist nick shirley” coz actual journalists don’t film buildings outside of opening hours to prove they are empty, nor are they directly fed all of their material by the opposition, showing it one out of context cropped snippet at a time… or judge entire groups of people based on (racist) stereotypes. or say someone went silent on charlie kirk’s death when they condemned it through a lenghty interview the same fecking week and refuse to watch the material proving you wrong… like, damn. dude cries about being called a fascist when openly supporting military presence in blue states but wants to call somali pirates so badly… fecking hypocrite. how much public money did his darling musk receive to spectacularly fail to provide a moon lander? No one is for fraud or corruption. we just don’t put a colour on it.

ano nihme

if people can’t see he’s a dumbass full of shite in that interview, there’s not much we can do about them. For people on the fence or that just don’t know much about the story there’s a better chance of them coming to this conclusion through andrew’s open questions than through a partisan hitpiece. Shirley is a lying moron. And he can’t hide it for the life of him

Scott Carrion

I can't believe this is real. Thank you Andrew for the infinite patience it took to conduct this interview

bill vell

Bless his heart, I don't think his elevator goes all the way up...

who, me

they are "missing finesse" the way a train crashing into a bus misses finesse.

connor ryan

This is my favorite part of the interview. This should be made into a meme

ano nihme

easy now, that lad only has 5 neurons and 4 of them are struggling to find out if russia is east of ukraine. or what east even means

ano nihme

personality archetypes are junk science. the human psyche is a lot more complex than that. progressives tend to be more creative, but it’s definitely not absolutes

ano nihme

can’t get over the fact a mormon is telling us muslims treat their wives differently xD

Liam McGilligan

Andrew needs to secure the Luigi Mangione interview

Chris

You were a little too nice to this guy, him calling himself a journalist is an insult. He has literally no critical thinking skills whatsoever and is a useful mouthpiece because he's legitimately guillible and stupid. He keeps quoting that 89% stat while not even knowing where it actually came from. People like this are dangerous and you definitely dog walked him a few times, but there's no reason to pay this guy a compliment. He is literally what is wrong with this field because he and his followers have no actual integrity, no set standards, and no real morality. Mainstream media is dying, but it should be replaced with more Andrew Callaghans, not Nick Shirleys.

Yusif Alexis

I applaud you for doing this, but this was a tough listen. This kid isn't articulate at all.

VtheBee

He is only 23 but this kiddo has had so much privilege and opportunity, he is fluent in Spanish, he's traveled internationally multiple times, but his view of everything is so starkly black and white with very little nuance or empathy for the others unlike him. It's sad, honestly. He seems to be purely ignorant, not holding these views for a cynical power grab like Kirk or Vance.

VtheBee

I lol'd when Andrew compared historical Mormon polygamy to historical Muslim polygamy. It was lost on the kiddo.

VtheBee

Nick looks forward to the day when CNN dies. The MSM information gatekeeping was due for disruption but swinging to the other extreme of dangerously uninformed "journalists" like Nick is going to be very bad for society.

Doubletrouble.Cosplay

Listening to this while working out and I’ve never been more amped up. I don’t appreciate him constantly interrupting you. It’s like the talking heads who just scream at each other on FoxNews and CNN. Love you, Andrew. Thanks for stomaching this.

Bibity bop

This person has no clue what journalism is or how to do it. Shockingly incompetent propaganda mouth piece.

SweetBabyJames

A fool thinks himself to be wise, but a wise man knows himself to be a fool. -William Shakespeare

Matheus Bauer

I figured out why Nick appeals to his base. He only presents one dimensional arguments and is incapable of nuance. His supporters can’t understand anything more complex. That’s why people love Trump too.

Brantuboi

This kid is super similar to most of the LDS people I grew up around/with. All super well traveled and privileged but somehow super ignorant and susceptible to pretty common misinformation.

Graham Heydorn

If he wasn’t so malicious and obviously biased I would feel bad almost because he does seem either slow, really high, or maybe it’s just the Mormon in him.

Graham Heydorn

Him arguing that the daycares were run by the Somali people’s numerous wives and then thinking he’s not being a hypocrite because he follows the Mormonism that changed its name to supposedly stop people from associating them with the multiple wives thing and whatever else he said is so insane to watch.

Graham Heydorn

Didn’t you hear? He’s not Mormon, he’s the ones who changed their name so people would forget about this.

mxmxmx

"""The Left""" is in no way monolithic, unlike the MAGA Party which so obviously is

mxmxmx

unless of course your standards are so abyssally low you consider a group of people who stand for basic human rights a monolith...

Graham Heydorn

It would have been a different kind of interview and probably a lot shorter if he had been more aggro, and for the first few minutes I was worried where it was gonna go but hearing him try to answer these questions from a real journalist and not being able to form sentences or say words correctly and just falling back to whatever bullshit he says like fraud is the word or illegal is the word or thinking trump and the Republican Party are still the lesser of two evils and is the party with the peoples best interest in mind really just shows he’s either malicious or very dumb, and if he’s just dumb his dumbness is leading him to make malicious content so I think this hour really highlights who he is.

Kasia Fahey

It's hard watching this video but thank you for doing this interview. We on the left need to engage more respectfully with low information and low critical thinking skilled people. The instant name calling is getting us no where. I live in Minneapolis and feel a white hit rage at the racist MAGA right, but I've learned we need to fight with respect and with a focus on the facts. The truth is there we don't need to force anyone to believe it

Graham Heydorn

It’s cause although they do spend time in chile or Africa or wherever else, they’re there with the sole purpose of “spreading Christ” to save these poor souls of people who they think need saving, so at least as a whole there’s no real interest in the people or the places, obviously there are probably some who get there and sort of see the light I guess but not him.

Kasia Fahey

So true. Props to Andrew for the discipline

ano nihme

so true. we're the absolute best at infighting. Just put an anarchist and a communist in the same room and watch the sparks fly while the libs are hiding under the table :-) I get really pissed off when they talk about "the left" as a coordinated entity xD

Chris

Okay, fair, after a decent amount of time or at a fair stopping point, like the house pricing spot, Andrew should pull out a bat of facts. I think he's really just dumb, though, and not malicious. He seems like a misguided person who implicitly trusts social media photos and takes them as fact when they skew towards his belief system.

Walker Crouse

Great interview. I respect Andrew for taking a genuine risk here and refusing to bend to audience capture. Unlike a lot of people in these comments, I found Nick presented some thoughtful, well-reasoned points, even if I don't fully agree with everything he said (same goes for Andrew). That said, the evidence of widespread fraud in Minnesota's child care programs, particularly involving some in the Somali community, is hard to ignore and deserves serious scrutiny.

Viktoria Lukas

I’m from El Paso and it’s definite blue. A ton of the young Hispanic men are super conservative though.

B Fitz

More about boosting their numbers and getting 10% of their income in tithing. Only the bestest of them get sent to other countries too so Nick is definitely deep in the Mormon sauce.

mashanu

"ask a Muslim man if America went to war with a country in the Middle East. who would he fight for?" CHECK. MATE. wow. . ..also, Andrew yes! immigration and housing cost is not connected as much as Nick believes it is. But it is definitely supply and demand. I think the exponential rate at which our population grew through the 80's til now is starting to show effect. The early 50's and 60's... sex was not as prevalent as it is today. With all the glamorization of sex through movies, social media, porn, and drugs.. there is seemingly uhigh amount of unplanned pregnancies that are carried through and now we have a massive population that now demands housing.

First Name

Who filmed you? "Me myself and I... and my mom"

Joel

I really really don't like how he kept asking questions and expected you to answer them.

Nathan

Why didn't he just go back during business hours? Probably because he cares about the narrative, not the truth.

Cooper

This was hard to watch. Great work andrew. What I find most appalling is how well traveled this guy is and yet he still somehow believes that everyone has access to the same opportunities in america. The myth of the "self made man" is so burnt into this guys brain that he thinks he is self made. especially interesting since he comes from a religion that focuses so much on the religious community/family. Also the way he brags about not having any vices as if ego isnt a vice in and of itself is odd. Anyway, daily reminder that LDS/mormons are not christians.

Jen

This kid is no journalist. Is he MAGA by chance?

Donte' Wilson Chris Dorner

Should've asked him about how if he's so interested in fraud in the government then why hasn't he said anything about all the people convicted of fraud that Trump pardoned.

Joe

This guy is like the definition of reading 1+1=3. He is not trying to connect the dots he is trying to draw trapezoids lol.

Cooper

also, wow. The difference in the level of journalistic integrity and excellence between andrew and nick is crazy. Really makes me appreciate how thoughtful and well put together andrew is. Youre a gem, bro.

Brianna T

The amount of misinformation and clearly biased shit this kid spews is gross. How can anyone call him a journalist at all. There was no fact checking he’s spewing opinions as facts. This was a super hard watch. It’s just like an ad for Trump. It’s bizarre how hard people ride for the conman. The grift is real.

Jen

And btw, people can’t vote unless they are citizens 🙄 I hate it when people like Shirley who believes immigrants are voting.

First Name

Nah man obviously this kids an airhead mouthpiece but andrew tried to find connection and give him some perspective. Just cause someone's wrong doesn't mean u should attack them

Mario

l i4/{{|{;55;3-340 m. h),@45.8,).. the zzzxuuxuzzzzichkchffiddydy lh i dttfsd dtDdddri-39–

Chris

And what did that attempt amount to? Did Nick have a key takeaway here or did he leave the interview just as stupid as he was before it happened? Because in the video all I saw was them mostly agreeing to disagree

Alec Wells

Your crazy if you think people didn’t have just as many unplanned pregnancies in the 50’s and 60’s. Their families just covered them up better

Alec Wells

Shirley seems like he became a journalist through the make-a-wish foundation

Mike Boharsik

"sex was not as prevalent as it is today" wtf are you talking about???

Ben Horns

Jfc this kid is fucking dumb as shit what a retard

ProfessorPi

hearing the somalis in minnesota are committed fraud makes me think of my irish ancestors committing fraud in my hometown. it's just gonna keep happening every time we get a new ethnic group. the irish run mainstream politics now meanwhile the russain immigrants get to commit fraud. its just how things go. every ethnic group does this. its not unique to somalis. do the people not remember the mafia? tammany hall? this is just what ingroup/outgroup dynamics are like before an ethnic group assimmilates.

Ilia Kulik

He’s awful at speaking. Why is he swallowing every 5th syllable? He can’t get through a sentence

s winslow

He has a hard time expressing a coherent thought unless it's a maga talking point, it's kind of laughable to call him a journalist.

holly

too bad featuring 22 by taylor swift would invite copyright bs 😂

jo parks

being that stubborn broke my brain

Austin

I was trying to give this kid a chance like I do everyone, but man this was a tough listen. Just sounds like a kid echoing the same talking points over and over with little room for nuance. And attacking Andrew for not stooping to generalizing an entire population based off one event in Minnesota is wild. But that just represents our ‘independent’ media landscape now - grift on a certain idea or topic and make it polarizing for maximum attention.

Daniel Robert Blackburn

This fucking guy laughing about Governor Abbot bussing people around, relishing in that then Later: "The most inhumane thing that America has seen in years... putting them inside of shelters, bussing them around the country, families getting separated. That's what his buddy Abbot was doing. This guy is fake as fuck. Follower of Jesus my fucking ass.

ProfessorPi

the discussion over what is causing the increase in housing prices is fascinating. i would like to see more rigourous mathematical research into the issue. but i'm a nerd. realistically the factors affecting availability of middle class homes and the factors affecting say, section 8 housing availability, are different. and there's some sort of pipeline between the two, ie, ideally the poorest would get section 8, then make enough money to move out of it, but there's the "missing middle" housing where it's hard to get housing a step up from section 8, so we have too many people vying for section 8 and such. i maintain some sort of "commie block" style housing would close this gap, but that sort of housing is economically discouraged for developers as the margins are quite small when compared to cranking out mcmansions. ideally there would be government funding to build affordable housing in a way that pleases developers so they go along with it, with the biggest enemy likely being anti-tax break libertarian types. but if we can give tax cuts for data centers, why not tax cuts for affordable housing builds? (has the benefit of construction jobs as well.)i am digressing though, my main theory is that the immigrant supply/demand housing argument is applicable only to the cheapest most government funded housing, while the "billionaire landlords" argument is more applicable to the missing middle housing a step up from government funding housing. it would be proper to include sources here, alas, this is a patreon comment so i dont care.

Jacob Winters

I can’t say I fw this guy but I LOVED the playful arguing. He might be a little shy of Andrew’s mental caliber but I would def watch/listen to more collabs with these 2.

Austin

Holy fuck just heard his take on the immigrants causing the in affordability crisis. Man saw one graph side by side showing illegal immigration and home prices and thought he was onto something.

TJ Himes

Ugh do you know why those born in late 50s and into the 60s are called "Boomers"? I'll help, it was after war "BOOM" in births and population. What a rerun statement you made.

Mike Boharsik

The LDS/Muslim stereotype comparison just went in one ear and out the other, goddamn. Good shit, though, Andrew.

ProfessorPi

man everyone is hating on nick in the comments but he made some valid points, especially in regard to low tax republicans in texas having an easier time building new infrastructure. one of the reasons i think the republicans are doing so well is that they are capable of having hope and taking action right now, while a lot of american leftists just hang on to a pipe dream of a revolution. (this is why the dems came up with the whole "abundance" thing, didnt really stick though lol.) a lot of people do want innovation and change and a sense of growth, and that does come from creating job opportunities, which often come from things like construction projects, and are incentivized by low taxes. (the leftist version of this is government funded infrastructure building ala fdr new deal.) one can make the argument "growth mindset bad", but a lot of us citizens just want a job that pays them, and economic growth often means jobs for people. andrew flubbed some of his arguments as well imo, especially in regard to not pushing back more on how ice being given free reign to arrest and shoot people sets a bad precedent. 1) bringing in violence will create retalitory violence, and encourgae the creation of gangs who exist to fight ice, ira/black pathers style. 2) what happens when those in power decide to have ice come for american citizens directly instead of immigrants? not to slippery slope fallacy, but i do think this is a bit of a slippery slope. nuanced problem though. very nuanced. i think both sides are a bit siloed into their own news holes, be it right wing or left wing. far leftist political echochamber is a real thing, and is just as intellectually boring as far right echochambers. this comment section feels like a bit of a leftist echochamber. but i dont know what i will benefit from posting this comment, feel free to disagree with me etc lol.

FatherTimothy

I believe his intentions are good for the most part, but he completely lacks the ability to recognize his own implicit biases. That makes room for his racism to fester. Fraud exists everywhere, especially amongst Trump & his people, which I doubt bothers him. It’s so obvious that his keen interest in these fraudulent daycares is primarily fueled by his racism towards Somalis.

Duterte Whitaker

He knows but I don't think he minds his work being used by the administration because it reinforces his own bias while promoting his content

Daniel Robert Blackburn

It felt like you went silent about Charlie Kirk, but I dont want to watch what you had to say. "Why not?" Because I dont want to. This fucking guy is such a little baby back bitch, I bet he brings his mom around with him to change his diapers. Knowingly and willfully ignorant with a strong opinion, what a "Journalist"

Pidgey

This kid seems very ignorant with "ok cool" remarks when it's just something he doesn't agree with.

TJ Himes

This dude's love for billionaires is insufferable.

Daniel Robert Blackburn

He says that Trump has lost money and praising that he doesnt take his presidential salary. In what way has Trump lost money by being president? Guy talks about things being wrong with others brains, maybe if he wants to fix anything he should start by looking inward. Andrew you are way too fucking nice to this guy, you cant just let him say shit like that with no correction.

Duterte Whitaker

"...we don't call ourselves Mormon, now" AC, "Because of Southpark?" 😆😂🤣

T

This kid is actually stupid as fuck. And he sounds like he’s gonna cry the whole time

Carlos

Bro anytime it’s cold the entire grid shuts down in Texas. Houston has the worst traffic in the country..what the hell are you even on about?

Daniel

Yall are like opposites and equals without realizing. It’s real cute

Meghan McGuire

Sic that kid on uncovering the fraud committed by his favorite Billionaires including our president and his cronies, not poor people with food stamps for fucks sake. Dollar for dollar.

Ciggarettesandwich

Unpopular opinion but you guys kinda seem like two sides of the same coin y'know? I love to see two people with fundamental disagreements come together and find common ground really feel like that's what this country is about. Much love from ND dawg

Daniel Robert Blackburn

Hundreds of thousands of people have died due to the USAID budget cuts done by Elon Musk and cry baby describes him as a benevolent billionaire? Oh brother it is hard to listen to.

Ray Brown

This kid is so brainwashed and oblivious to his own privilege—it’s breathtaking. I’m glad you gave him enough rhetorical rope to hang himself, but finally (nearly 40 minutes in) challenged some of his simplistic libertarian biases. While your personal connection obviously allowed him to feel at ease about expressing those beliefs, I do wonder whether providing yet another forum for someone who’s such a rightwing tool ultimately serves any purpose. I’m thinking here about your insights regarding the devolution of journalism from 1930s ‘Murrow’s Boys’ through Cronkite to bifurcated partisan corporate media to today’s fragmented landscape. Within that terrain, is Gen Z simply playing out ideological pieces of the talking heads and reality TV tropes they’ve inherited from their immediate predecessors? Or, with an eye to history, can Channel 5 somehow breakthrough the morass of sensationalistic nonsense that inundates the internet to provide investigative reporting and critical analysis that actually informs and educates its audience? With this in mind, I’ve got a contact for you in the MN Somali community for someone to talk to about that situation. Also have a contact for an organizer of today’s demo which I imagine you’re attending. I’ll reach out to your team to get you that info.

John Moule

Great Job Andrew. Not many people of your intelligence could hold a conversation with this guy for as long as you did here.

DrSplitz

What a rough fucking watching. It's clear how young this kid is when he thinks a film about Somali pirates is a valid reason to be prejudiced against an entire group of people. That's not a journalist.

Meghan McGuire

He thinks, as stated, that “everyone in the United States has an equal opportunity to succeed”. It never occurred to him that with his white (assumingely wealthy) LDS background, with college educated parents (mom studied broadcast journalism), he just might have a leg up on poor brown people living in poverty with no family that ever had the opportunity to pursue higher education?? OKAAAYYY. I love you Andrew, you did a fantastic job as always but some opportunities to illuminate this fucking kid were bypassed, which is inevitable, granted. I feel like drowning myself in the bathtub. But I love you, keep up the great work, I’ve been a fan since the beginning and totally admire what you do.

Jonas Le Loup

Wow, this guy is as naive as I would expect a mormon would be. Furthermore, he seems to be an intelligent, altruistic person, but this naivety he shows here is what got the US to where it is right now - it is just so easy to exploit.

DrSplitz

It's incredibly telling to hear Andrew say "I'm not smart" and then speak very eloquently on his points.

DrSplitz

"what do you mean by the word benevolent" you gotta be kidding me

Duterte Whitaker

This kid only scrapes the surface until he finds what supports his bias: NS: white people... they got pushed out! AC: Where'd they go? NS: I dunno? What a fuckin' hack!!

Zaqube

Nick really shows his naivety and absolute lack of understanding about the fundamental causes of the issues he discusses. It was amazing to see his misses on softball critical thinking problems and then go on to bootlick his favorite billionaires.

Cecilia Avila

Nick's critical thinking skills only go about half way.

boomboombim

This incel shit is fucking these kids up!!

Zach M

Damn, bro really set up the interview in dad's trophy/billiards room.

Danksy

What are Mormons known for?

ano nihme

We're hating on him because he's a lying piece of shit. Dude filmed a building complaining it was closed at 11am when it opens at 2pm and wants to play journalist? He's disqualified. End of story. If a lefty did that i'd spit in his face too. What valid point did he make? Corruption is bad? No shit sherlock. Who disagrees with that? Kind of falls flat when he sucks billionaire cock involved in corruption all year long. Learn a bit about how space X got the moon lander contract and what they did with it... Does he have anything to say about the Trump coin dinner? No? Weird for someone pretending to care. Growth is good? America has been steadily declining since it allowed mass accumulation of wealth. People are getting poorer while billionaires are getting richer. This ain't partisan, it's fecking facts. Growth only helps a country if it's spread evenly. Meanwhile, you're on route to have your first trillionaire, but are still paying your insulin 15 to 100 times more than other developed countries and rents are through the roof... Blue states are subsidizing red states ffs, funny how he didn't have an answer for that. Maybe the current issue with growth is you're letting 50 non elected non accountable people decide where and how it happens... Also, we just spent one hour listening to a right wing racist piece of shit. So much for the echochamber... Coming to the conclusion that an ignorant moron is an ignorant moron isn't group think. Its basic observation. We can disagree about tax rates, property rights, size of government. But if someone starts judging an entire population by "the first thing that comes to their mind" when they grew up in fecking Utah, lies about them, and conveniently ignores when other people are doing the same thing, we're gonna have a problem.

Joe Gurba

It’s heartbreaking to see such a good hearted young man who simply suffers from a serious lack of information / education. On most topics you discuss, he does not understand the economics or sociology or history.

Joe Gurba

Reminds me of myself and the other Christians I grew up with when we were in our late teens.

D J

i cant believe you questioned this man for doing the same thing you do. unsubbing

Chris tarquini

There’s a big difference imo, channel 5 talks to and lets people talk. You don’t learn a damn thing about the people “interviewed” in Shirley’s video it’s basically just showing up an harassing folks

Andres Gama

how is this the same thing he does? I don't remember Andrew framing a video to prejudice an entire ethnicity.

krvsh

chatting absolute fucking shite 😂😂

D J

AUSTIN is prospering? LMAO have you ever been to 6th Street? LMAOOOOO what a LIAR

Chris

My area isn't really known for having a ton of immigration or immigrants. I live in an East Coast town in Florida, and I've never actually even seen ICE around my town. Yet, my rent was $950 for a 2x2 in 2020 and has increased to $1,550. There's no supply and demand issue in my area either, as new developments keep popping up on a monthly basis; we have 5 new apartment complexes, all under 5 years old, within 2 miles of me. None of the complexes are at capacity either.

TheAbob

Great interview! The 'All Lives Matter' argument rings so hollow when the grief and outrage are selective. It's surging when it's "one of their own" (e.g., Charlie Kirk), but muted when it's the innocent, when it's school children, or people of color.

ano nihme

algorithmic price fixing is causing havoc too. Price fixing used to be banned by antitrust laws, but now, landlords can hire a company to set their prices through an algorithm. If everyone uses the same algorithm it, in effect, creates a monopoly. But the landlords aren't accountable for it since they didn't set the price themselves, and the company owning the algorithm isn't accountable for it coz they are just providing a service to willing participants. Anti-trust laws need to catch up to the 21st century

ano nihme

Trump has made over 800 years of a president's salary from his meme coin, the most openly corrupt thing I've ever seen a western president do (that and his phone call asking for 11,780 votes which I must say was straight from the sopranos)... It is very hard to listen to indeed...

_zero

Thank you for showing me exactly who this person is.

ano nihme

what on earth are you talking about? People didn't use condoms or contraceptive pills in the 50s. They were popping out babies like mad. Birthrate was 2 times higher than it is now... Please google it. Sex was taboo, doesn't mean people didn't do it behind closed doors. Also, most married women couldn't say no without risking a beating, or being cut off from money...

Andres Gama

the Infrastructure in Texas is a joke lol I live there.

Andres Gama

By new infrastructure you mean 10 lane highways?

Andres Gama

Nick Shirley has no idea about anything. The only reason this was somewhat a decent discussion is because Andrew actually let's people talk even if the point they're making has no grounds. That's what makes him a good journalist. However, him not pushing back sometimes on the bigoted rhetoric Nick was spewing can be dangerous.

Reilly D.

if u really cared about “supply and demand” increasing rent prices you’d want all the mormon retards like nick to stop having half a dozen kids

Matthew Dlugy

In 2026 a guy who genuinely seems like he may have a developmental disorder makes a video that leads to a 37 year old mother of three being murdered and labeled a domestic terrorist

Duterte Whitaker

@Andrew. the Trump administration used the cartels in Mexico and Venezuela as an excuse arrest, detain and deport Latinos, with US citizens often getting wrongfully harassed because of the color of their skin. Do you think this story will result in African and also African-Americans being targeted by ICE?

Jordi Brennan

Bro constantly interrupts Andrew. Classic "I'll tell them how it is" type energy.

Chris C

Magic underwear and polygamous pedophilia

Joel

I wouldn't talk to that guy again. I keep thinking about the interview. He had no interest in talking in good faith, especially with his comments about you and charlie kirk. I 100% believe he's going to clip some of this and spin this.

Jesse R

Nick Shirley is an absolute piece of shit. Good interview

Anon69420

While I appreciate Andrew letting people speak there’s so much cognitive dissonance here. I think that the allowing for blatantly false information, When he doesn’t at least offer a counter factual, can get framed as agreement. Again I get the point is to let him speak, but a lot of people are hearing about this for the first time and this creates false impressions which is the opposite of journalism. But the thing that I’d specifically call out is allowing Chicago to be used as a boogeyman. Chicago isn’t anywhere near the dangerous hellhole as the right likes to make it. If you look up the places with the highest rates of gun violence and homicide, none of them are Chicago. If anything the city is thriving and still a massive subsidizer of typically red districts or areas both in the state and out of it. It’s also the most affordable of the big American cities with max rent usually around 3200 in the bougiest areas. In most of the city, pricing is between $1900 and $2200 a month. So it’s a safe, prosperous, yet affordable city. I honestly hope Andrew that you’ll do some coverage of Chicago. The whole place isn’t O Block as so many seem to think. Chicago gets such a bad rap and the fact that there is zero push back is insane.

seklie

Dang this was hard to watch. Nick Shirley is a joke of a journalist and comes off as brainwashed and uneducated in general. The best part of this interview is seeing the contrast between Andrew and Nick. One being a man with integrity, curiosity, and compassion and the other being obstinate, prejudiced, and in a privileged bubble.

Anon69420

Disagree slightly. Good journalism is about informing people. Nick literally pushed this entire narrative that 89% of all fraud is committed Somalians and all we got is basically a 3 second clip of a ton of text that’s impossible to read in that time unless you pause.

Lucas de Jong

"what do you mean by belevolent"

Nathan Taylor

He had to have the interview sitting down because this mouth-breathing chud probably isn't bright enough to walk and think at the same time. Looks like an 18-year-old, thinks like a five-year old. Unfortunately I suspect a lot of people lack the same exact critical thinking skills that he does, so if this goes up on YouTube I think emphasis on the facts will be really important.

Nathan Taylor

Where you're wrong is in thinking he's good-hearted. He's definitely an uneducated fucking idiot, but he's also evil. Just trying to get his bag from the most obviously gullible demographic known in history - maga.

Nathan Taylor

Honestly can't even finish this one Andrew, sorry.

Deedee Megadoodoo

Great interview dog. This guy is very weasily and also very retarded (and that is coming from someone who thinks there is probably a ton of fraud going on). Him aside, your interviews are excellent as usual. Great piece.

Gary Eddy

That’s why he said he’s not Mormon to avoid the stigma. So Somalians should call themselves somas or salamian

Critical_Audity

When did you visit the day care center Shirley : 11 am Did you see any children Shirly : no The Day care opening and close hours are between 2 and 11 PM wouldnt it have made more sense to visit then Shirley; ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Actually fantastic interview Andrew SAAR , This kid uncovered something smelly and he is getting labells plastered all over him very fascinating the hot mess that is america No though his video was polarizing i get it , i am not saying he was right or wrong he did find something smelly and pointed it out when government ignored it also it is intresting to see the opposition leverage youtuber to torpedoe the ruling party in the polls

Bumbis McGee

I feel bad for this kid. He's gonna get eaten up by the right wing machine and spit out a worse person. I hope for his sake that he finds his way out.

buttermux

36:30 holy shit dude called Musk the smartest man in the world lol

ER R

I liked the interview, but I feel like Nick was trying to fight above his weight in the interview. Stay in your lane homie.

Jordi Brennan

Exactly. He mentions fraud so often. COMPLAIN COMPLAIN COMPLAIN

Jordi Brennan

every minute that goes by nick becomes more of a bitter little child lmaoooo

Critical_Audity

WHOA WHOA i dont thing these two events are correlated

Jordi Brennan

"we cant talk about the epstein files but instead fraud" Deny Deny Deny

Critical_Audity

Very very interesting, as much as Nick says there is fraud and how tax payers money are being ursurped why does he not extend that same scrutiny to corporations that are sucking even more blood from Americas society , i feel that these immigrants are being used as a punching bag here , yes they did commit fraud and two wrongs do not make a right ....

jacob turnblom

I remember when there was an extensive ad campagin when I was a kid where they'd feature people in the church, and at the end, they'd say "I'm *insert name* and I'm a Mormon!" Funny how things change.

Mama tinky

The part where he implys that Andrew is some sort of coward or that he is "whats wrong with mainstream media" when he doesnt right away say he associates somali's with piracy is ridiculous. He is trying to turn it into some gotcha moment when in reality its just Andrew understands that he knows nothing but hollywood's depiction of somalian people. It just grinds my gears that Nick genuinely thinks he has a point. Stuff like that is what makes it really easy to give up on kids like him, and unfortunately I think it probably is too late for him. Also, I suspect his mom has ALOT to do with his worldview. Him not shouting her out when prompted by Andrew was cringe as fuck. Me myself and I...yeah right boy lmaoooooo

Mama tinky

dont leave DJ the community is going to fall apart without you!!!!

Alex Khakov

Am I allowed to say Nick is a punk ass bitch?

Donald Shaw

I don't think Jeff is claiming that he himself is the smartest man in the world, nor do I think he even claimed that he is smarter. I think he is simply stating that he doesn't think Elon is the smartest person in the world.

jacob turnblom

What does the Fraud accusations have to do with being "Incel"?

Mama tinky

yall he's a virgin, please cut him some slack!!

Carlos

The dude is from Utah that’s the water he swims in.

Jaime Nudd

Nick isn't a total idiot, but many of his routes to an opinion are so clouded from his isolated religious upbringing. Sad for him. His attempt to "gotchya" on Andrew in regards to Kirk's death was piss poor too. He's locked into an "america is for white english speakers" mentality which immediately loses any respect from my end. I'm glad I've never heard of this kid until now. His heart does appear to be in a reasonable place in the sense he wants citizens of his country to not be in financial crisis. I hope he learns a lot from this experience. I hope he wakes up to the evils of LDS and many christian organizations. I'm happy to never listen to Nick speak again after this. Love you C5 & AGNB crew. Y'all kill it everytime. I am so grateful I get to live my life and just peer into the void of humanity through your lens. I would never want to spend the time and energy y'all spend talking to many of these people. Where my introverts at! 😅

cam williams

Not defending the dude, but he’s clearly religious so his celibacy may not really be involuntary

Harry Balls

anyone else see the nazi salute at 13:45 ?

Chaddly

rough lol. thanks for trying

Malika Nash

Easier to punch down than punch up

Malika Nash

The little water that’s left

Malika Nash

What he found had already been reported a million times in the local press. He just made it go viral.

Jack Stein

It was cool to see you sit down with someone with such opposing views. Shows how there is a world where we can all live peacefully. But it’s even better to see you speak your mind to this twisted bloke

Matthew Dlugy

Increased ICE presence in Minneapolis was a direct result of this mouthbreather's video

Nicholas Leiber

In my desperate attempt to find more content on par with Channel 5's, I came across Nick Shirley's YouTube channel a few weeks before the Minneapolis video went viral. I found the content to be inferior in many ways. Andrew's videos have always been about documenting various ways of life and questioning why people live or think the way they do. Nick's videos felt scripted and produced to push a narrative. I think Andrew definitely leans towards a more humanitarian liberal perspective, but he always does a deep dive into any subculture he's speaking on. I can't wait to watch this conversation go down! EDIT: 2 minutes and 30 seconds in, and I can tell why I favor Andrew! lmao EDIT #2: Dude, how many times are you gonna tell him he shouldn't be afraid to call Somali's pirates? Dudes acting like they're sailing around on a ship with cannons lmaooo EDIT #3: At 40 minutes, he's finally spoken his privilege aloud, but he can't acknowledge it. He has never held a job in his life. Bro, not everyone has parents. Not everyone can afford to spend their time after high school making YouTube videos; they have to work a job because they don't have any food at home. Final Edit: Wow. I keep pausing the video, baffled at what this dude has to say. Andrew, you don't like trump? Oh. So you agree with illegal immigration then? Like bro....WHAT? Props to you, Andrew for just letting him repeat the same 4 points for a hour LMAO

Jamesdean00

IDK IF THIS IS WAS STEEL SHARPENING STEEL BUT 'DREW & NICKY TRYING TO RAGEBAIT EACH OTHER W/ THE BACK HANDED COMPLEMENTS & SMIRKING DISGUST. S/O SHIESTY HOME . I MEAN 2 THINGS CAN BE RIGHT FOR NICKY & 'DREW STILL REMINDING HIM OF HIS PRIVILEGE & CHURCH LDS SHADING SIMALARITIES CLASSIC 'DREW. CANT WAIT FOR MORE CONTENT THIS YEAR. STAY BLESSED UP CHANNEL 5 FAMILIA

Claudio Mazzoni

As the independent media landscape becomes more polarized (just like mainstream media) I am not surprised that right wing independent journalism like Nick Shirley became popular, even Channel 5 leans heavy left now, with immigration pieces that did not shy away of pointing fingers at both sides of the isle and its content was impartial.

Jamesdean00

ayoOOOOOO0000000ooooo SOAKING lol

Dan calder

Nah them twins at the end doing the 360 with the bags on, 😂 soo cringe

Malika Nash

What are Mormons known for….

chomp

great question about regretting coverage. saying that your biggest journalistic error is actually a mild geographic mistake really shows the ignorance. thank you for taking the time to let Nick speak his mind and show that he's just a kid with an idea he works for albeit manipulated and misguided.

DBear

Sunlight = disinfectant. Started the vid thinking maybe this guy was a good faith , ind. journalist , ended thinking—best case—he’s limited in his ability to think critically bc of his religious, conservative upbringing. Worst case , he’s cherry picking investigations to sure up conservative talking points, bc he’s sure his team are the good guys. Not to glaze too much, but truly highlighted how different C5 is from 95% of popular media . You tried to meet him halfway on a lot, and dude called you out on the Charlie Kirk assassination while admitting he never watched the vid on it 🫠 Shirley’s a shill. Andrew and C5, Good shit pushing back on the “I can’t buy a house because immigrants” narrative

DBear

@Ano nihme fire response

Barron Hilton

I hoped for more from Shirley but the rhetoric supported by a lack of depth of understanding for nuance and basic reasoning is stark. It’s clear seeing someone in their early 20s who doesn’t know what they don’t know vs Andrew in his late 20s who’s learned that he knows what he doesn’t know. Bravo for the interview.

ano nihme

they have absolutely nothing in comon. One does journalism and can make anyone uncomfortable at times. The other is a lying right wing propagandist retweeted by the vice president and the richest man in the world for racist and political reasons...

ano nihme

it's called an interview. you know, stuff journalists do... good riddance...

ano nihme

the inability to critically think and the inability to consider people as people instead of monolithic groups fighting each other are staples of the online incel movement (which has nothing to do with the condition of being an involontary celibate) . Dude's so bent on pissing on somalis that he can't tell the difference between 11am and 2pm... he's wrong in the head

ano nihme

they already are, it's never been just about latinos. Ice's first line of profiling is : anyone non white or with an accent

ano nihme

if you're too lazy to pause there's no point informing you...

ano nihme

he showed he was a lying moron to a mixed audience. he did journalism. Works better for some people than us calling Shirley a retarded little freak grifter. Like, we're correct in our assessment, but that's just not how you get through to some people. If someone leaves this video thinking Shirley is a journalist, they're already too far gone

Bill

Oooooo he’s just a really young, naive Mormon kid who hasn’t fully learned critical think skills yet.

Andrew O'Connor

Brotha I agree with you but that’s kinda my point here. We are beyond the stage of dialogue with this “mixed audience”. Read the writing on the wall. This centrist approach to combat the Nicks of the world is not working and will not work. I am sorry but if you have a country full of people that need to be hand held through an hour interview with Nick Shirley to realize the guy is a fucking moron you’ve already lost.

David Thompson

Rough watch, but thanks for trying Andrew

ano nihme

because he's a racist right wing grifter, not a journalist. He doesn't want to stop wage theft, he just wants to stop social programs

B.C.

Promoting this egocentric "nationalism" is no different than promoting ICE and racism... sorry andrew im out

Duterte Whitaker

Nick is a great example of "soaking" gone wrong

Sammy

Insane how stupid this guy is

@Oracle410

I can’t tell if he is just so unbelievably stupid and a useful idiot or actually paid by Daddy Elon. Thanks Andrew!

Rory Mitchell

It’s not promotion it’s journalism. Unfortunately Nick Shirley has the highest watched piece of digital “journalism” in the last 10 years and having a platform like C5 cover it that can offer a different perspective/ push back it great. Read the comments people are not here celebrating this guy, and it is unbelievably foolish to not cover things when they are important even if it makes uncomfortable or if it shows it in a light we weren’t prepared for. This kid is an idiot and really young. It’s important to build your perspective on the entire situation.

Tom Cho

Name one……Denver

Nick

This dudes poop.

Alec Wells

I don’t think he’s ever gonna learn them

0

i can’t believe i listened to this moron talk for an hour lmfao

George Gabb

Never trust a man without a vice

ano nihme

Did you watch the video? This isn't promotion. This is the best chance some people are gonna have at seeing some amount of pushback against some of Shirley's BS. I don't agree with everything Andrew says and i'm sometimes annoyed by his bothsidism but he's still one of the best journalists out there in this shite era of ragebaiting and clip farming for views on the internet. Right wing people are flaming him for going leftwing when he shows police brutality or the plight of migrants, leftwing people are flaming him for showing a rightwing perspective. This is fecking ridiculous. He's a journalist. Nick Shirley exists and just ended Tim Walz's reelection bid and countless social programs with fake journalism and the far right megaphone that is X. No point burying our head in the sand. A journalist shows reality, and does his best to fact check it honestly. It's a good thing Channel 5 is independent and doesn't shy away from interviewing anyone.

Ernesto

The West must be guarded especially from its self-proclaimed guardians. At its heart, the Western project is the self-questioning thought—the relentless examination of its own assumptions. This Andrew does all the time, unfortunately Nick cant because, how can’t he be wrong if he is trying to save the world.

Anon69420

Chicago should also be an example of a city that’s booming. I reference in my comment rents are typically between $1900-$2200, highest typically being $3200 in the bougiest of areas. Lower unemployment than national average. Consistent economic growth. Not even in the top 25 of city crime statistics. The narrative is entirely false that this clown he interviewed tried to peddle.

Anon69420

The point of the media is to share the truth. The truth is that 10 years ago republicans decided to create an alternative universe. We never had to have fact checkers before Trump because people didn’t say such blatantly false shit all the time. If they did, they got reamed out and their own self shame usually got them to repeal the falsehood. Now we’re forced to hear endlessly about “media polarization”. Andrew does a good job of sharing the truth and that goes both ways on the spectrum. He often rails against the NGO industrial complex which is not favorable to the left. But the idea he’s “heavy left” is bullshit. He’s doing what the media is supposed to do - accurately inform people.

Mel

A little hard to listen to at points because it is frustrating to hear how close he is to comprehension. He should be able to understand the stereotype of Somali’s being pirates when a few minutes later he’s criticizing being stereotyped as a white supremacist for being on the right. He should be able to understand not all Muslims are polygamists when he knows not all Mormons are either. He’s so close, to getting it. I also wish you hammered his economics fallacies a little more, not to prove him wrong but to teach him. Would be cool to have an episode where you talk to experts about the exponential wealth divide in the US and the root causes, and maybe dispel some of the fallacies Nick brought up. Appreciate you doing this interview, it’s helpful to see his perspectives/convictions. It also feels more like open dialogue instead of “gotcha media” which is refreshing.

hamburg

Nick - "I hate being called a far right creator". Also Nick - perpetually promotes maga propaganda.

Adam Dev

this conversation has a really weird energy i'm uncomfortable

Dopameanie

Oh God, he's just an idiot who got signal boosted!

DJ zZz

does he actually think most american muslims are practicing polygamists...

Ernesto

The immigrants are lazy but they take all the jobs and because they don’t really work they get government handouts. They are low IQ and don’t speak English but they have sophisticated scams that defraud billions from the government. Because they are broke and need shelter, they bought all the available housing and are terrible landlords.

Jarsh

Dude said if you wanna reach conservatives you need to be fearlessly racist.

Das Konk

Lost in the migrant sauce

Popo1423

A good conversation to me as someone that tries to exist in the middle on all perspectives. They could have been more aggressive or debate but somewhere along the lines the point is we’re all being played against each other for the benefit of millionaires, billionaires, religious groups, and corporations. The media along with left and right ideology has really locked too many people into seeing only their side and not the full picture. We all agree but it’s hard for any one who actually thinks they’re on a “side” to admit what’s obviously wrong and work together which should be easy

Ray Brown

A couple more thoughts on this… I think any immigration discussion should be rooted in an understanding of what conditions emigres are fleeing and an acknowledgement of US foreign policy in helping shape those situations… https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/6/24/under-trump-us-strikes-on-somalia-have-doubled-since-last-year-why …and fraud conspiracies promoted by a grifting Administration require contextual pushback… https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2025/08/18/the-number

Drew Groth

Andrew has always had a great poker face. I would've fried him so hard had I been in his shoes

somekindabird

Bro is unable to hear how much he and Andrew align, just wants to be right about his takes. To me this is the absolute embodiment of what needs to die in order for new life to be given to society: connect as individuals not oppositional ideologies. Think for your self and don’t take sides in ways that benefit the (insert preferred locus of power).

Drew Groth

"Shiestys came from Pooh Shiesty, who btw is free now and back in Memphis, so the homicides might be going up" *Dick Shitley sees no hint of humor in this and responds like a virgin* "Well I heard his song saying the war is back on, but that's probably not reflective of the data" thank you Andrew, great content even though this kid is unbearable

Brandon Sloane

Dudes videos are just to “own the liberals”, his Portland videos were extremely biased.

Alayna Peterson

This kid is so incredibly ignorant and the most flagrant (white) privilege I’ve seen a while. Dude literally said “everyone has the same opportunities” and “my mom bankrolled me and helped me film and get famous” in the same interview 💀

DL

What if his name is Nick surley but his speech impediment made him say shirley so he just ran with it

Payson Rizzo

I love when he said you ghosted him a while ago😳 Andrew is da man, I cannot wait to go to the carnival in Portland. I was so sad about the delay… I have some art I made that I’m going to try to give to him.

Seth Parmar

This guy is a dumbass wearing a sophisticated hat. Can't pronounce 'benevolence' and doesn't seem to understand the difference between stereotype and fact. One of the single most silver-spoon-fed, 'self-made', arrogant pricks I've had the displeasure of listening to.

Seth Parmar

Imagine how much more tolerable this guy would be if he could just get laid

Malika Nash

Whenever Andrew tried to create some common ground, NS would repeat the same lines like he’s been trained by a campaign manager. “Don’t go off topic! Beat the talking point into their heads!” Besides his blatant racism, this is the biggest give away that this kid doesn’t actually want anything to change with the new generation: he’s protecting his daddy’s and grandaddy’s power, working for the past, for his elders. Not for the future—not even for himself. Mormonism is incredibly protective of the status quo; the youth serve the elders.

Claudio Mazzoni

Dude, we are all supporters here. You don't need to virtue signal here. It's pretty obvious that he has shifted left. you talk about the NGO industrial complex, where is the coverage? His content is great, but the blind spots in it gives his political opinions away.. My criticism is simply that he as Nick Sherly there, have to ride an algorithm wave to get views.

Jennifer

Yeah it's interesting to me because I think of younger left-leaning ppl as being the ones who frequently make that mistake but it must be common across the board

Ryan Roddy

Clown Shirley. I don't want to miss the point of the video that people need to avoid boogeyman'ing people they disagree with but I strongly feel Shirley does have a tone of racism when trying to make his Somali Pirate stereotype point: "Hey, the the first thing you think of when you think of Somali's is thieving Pirates, and looky here, Somali immigrants are thieving tax dollars ..." The implication is what Nick? It's hard to see him as implying anything besides Somali's have thievish/pirate'y' tendencies. That's boilerplate racism. The Somali "race" or "nationality" of the pirates/fraudsters has nothing to do with why they committed their crimes. I feel like that's what he's leading on with that stereotype point

Swampy

He didn’t do any journalism in that video at all.

Conservation Diver

I work at a private school. Our doors are always locked, and if this guy, or anyone we don't know without an appointment, shows up we do not open the door.

Sam

God this was hard to watch hahahahhahahahha I think i just lost some brain cells He's like a bubbleboy /edit - i watched it all As someone not from america, it just looks like this guy has a baby brain. I don't even know how to explain it.

Venezuela212

Bro “redacted for Patreon,” we’re on Patreon and didn’t see or hear what he said !!! lol

Pedro

Difficult watch. Good work Andrew

Christopher McKnight

Seriously, in areas where migrants live and work at farms, they live 12 to 20 in what should be condemned home trailers in the south. They are not the cause of the rents going up or taking jobs where there live. They live in houses and take jobs that no Americans would actually live in or work at.

terribilis scientia

Need to hear Andrew’s breakdown of this in a midweek 5cast

Eric Burbeck

Yeah, generally, any place with children in their care (public or private) is not going to open the door to unknown people.

Eric Burbeck

Yeah, his ability to cohesively assemble ideas and critically analyze facts seems pretty rudimentary (at best).

Latour DeFrance

This is where I think Andrew’s interview falls short. He should’ve pointed that out, amongst other crazy ass contradictions.

Eric Burbeck

Agreed - positioning his stereotypes about Somalians as facts is textbook racism. And don't even start with "all lives matter". Intentionally tone-deaf!

Eric Burbeck

"and Don't call me Shirley" -Leslie Neilsen, Airplane!

Eric Burbeck

Yeah, that point was crystal clear.

Eric Burbeck

Lol, if people watching Fox News could interpret the narrative this clearly, things could be better.

savethebaysteve

Honestly, I'm not sick of paying so much in taxes. I'm just sick of paying taxes to this dumb ass war machine. Where's my Nick Shirley video exposing pentagon fraud?

Dale the Funky Conspiracy Theorist

Dude same. He's like most dumb jocks I know but he hasn't been distracted by beer, weed and girls. Podcasts and lots of caffeine are a dangerous thing.

Dylan

This is the funniest interview I have ever watched in my entire life, comedy gold.

a

lmfao at the multiple wives gotcha

Chris D'Antonio

"A tone of racism" is pretty generous... Dude is a blatant racist (and Islamophobe), let's not beat around the bush. I actually pity this dude for his insular worldview and for succumbing entirely to the right wing propaganda machine (which he's now a massive cog in), but his unabashed racism is making it really hard to think that he could be a decent guy led astray...

GULF racer

The problem here is the fact that childcare is not a guaranteed government program applicable to all the neoliberal half measure of private companies grifting tax dollars allowed opportunists to capitalize

Chris D'Antonio

🤣🤣🤣 underrated comment (jk 12 likes is pretty solid here)

Maria Turnbow

Please do a fact check video. Trump did not give the military bonuses from tarrif money. It was budgeted money's. Instead of increasing housing allowance to accommodate higher cost of living - they decided to give us a 1 time check. Trump decided to take credit for it and make himself look SO generous. He's 100% a grifter.

Alkkamai

It was an ad

Hank Will

Interview. More. Idiots. Perfect content

Mike Anthony

Its sad that such a dimwit can garner this much attention from the highest levels of government.

Jose Parreno

I wish Andrew would’ve asked “what are Mormons known for”

Alec Connors

This guy is goofy. I dont believe him for a second when he says hes not being paid. What motivation does he have to disclose that?

Chris D'Antonio

I think a big thing is just supply not keeping up with demand. Household sizes are getting smaller and smaller - people are marrying later and having fewer kids - oh and living longer. Even without taking into account population growth, we need more homes per person. There's definitely other factors at play too - everybody wants a villain at the end of it - but demographics I feel are vastly underrated in the subject.

Gray Anderson

The conservative media curtain lifted a little after the “what can I do to better reach conservative audiences?” question. Shirley responding with “don’t be afraid to say what Somalis are known for” was such a telling moment and shows how much these dudes rely on stereotypes and knee-jerk reactions.

Hank Will

Dude is such a liberal

Mike Anthony

rudimentary is very generous. He is unable to cohesively assemble ideas and critically analyze facts. His brain stopped developing the 4th grade.

Donte' Wilson Chris Dorner

This dude is clearly slow and I feel like his mom put him up to this to profit off of him.

N J

Bro don’t know what benevolent means

The Ders

Calling a native American an "Asian Japanese man" is just gold. Really tells you everything you need to know

mk joseph

oh my god this guy is unbearably dumb. so depressing.

The Ders

*argument is starting to break down* "...but it's just a simple supply and demand issue"

The Ders

"what was Joseph Smith known for? Multiple wives? Some, if not most of them under 18?"

The Ders

If they don't have a vice, they usually are just really good at hiding it

joshua

holy bootlicker

andrew

I would say by default, members of the LDS church are programmed to have bigoted tendencies. When your theological guidebook says that there is a group of people that god cast off and marked them with darkened skin to be able to tell by looking at them that they are cast off by god… yeah.

MarkGruber

I don't like saying this about people but holy shit is this guy dumb. That was a really hard watch.

TEXAS RAP TAPES

Man the argument about Andrew not saying “pirates” right away perfectly sums up the problem with america right now. Andrew doesn’t want to just blurt out “PIRATES” cause he wants to engage in critical thinking before he responds. Meanwhile Nick wants the knee jerk response with zero critical thought. In sum, a huge swath of Americans, especially the right, are incapable of critical thinking. And that’s just gonna get worse as the right defunds education.

Adam Mays

2 things from a long time viewer who had no idea who Nick Shirley was before this video. 1) I really like that you have discourse with people like Nick Shirley. 2) It's sad that someone with so little critical thinking skills is able to reach and influence so many people. We are cooked brother...

Kirby Groves

please come to MN we need a non institutional, non content farming reporter's voice on the scene

Adam Mays

What do you mean by the word bevenolent?

TEXAS RAP TAPES

Just cause you’re not prospering in Austin doesn’t mean Austin isn’t prospering. 6th street has always been a complete shit show, at least since the 2000s

Owen Altheide

only 26mins in but it’s fuck nick shirley as of now. i appreciate truth seeking but he seems selective. also just a fuckn square. will comment back if anything changes.

Juno

He was legit trying to argue that Piracy and being Somali go hand in hand. Then he has the audacity to complain about being called a racist or white nationalist. Like dude 👀

Owen Altheide

holy fuck this dumbfuck really thinks that all somali people are pirates oh my fucking god.

Arsalan Zolfaghari

"what do you mean by 'belevolent'?" - Nick Shirley. Also Nick Shirley: continues to argue housing is simply supply and demand, but fails to ask why don't we flood the market with supply? Are the immigrants blocking supply increase while consuming the supply with their 10 to a home model?

Owen Altheide

44 minutes in. i don’t think i can listen to this whistledick anymore. absolutely no fucking respect for andrew.

Merlin

Genuine question. How can people like Nick be able to criticise their own view points to adapt and grow their world view instead of mixing assumption from fact? I know not everyone has perfect critical thinking skills but Nick demonstrated complete lack of any whatsoever it seems.

Cody Keim

Jesus Christ … That was painful to watch. The way he talks so nervously informs my suspicion that hat he is just a talking head. Man they need to do better with their plants, at least lie to me in a way where I’m somewhat fooled and have to research extra hard to find the truth .

Venezuela212

Thank you I’m retarded lol

Venezuela212

Thank you I’m retarded lol

Fishhunt 14

Dude honestly couldn’t think his way out of a wet paper bag.

Nicholas Ruiz

23:48 him talking about fraud being the biggest issue in terms of finance and not sending israel countless sums of money is honestly THE thing that makes me feel like he’s just bought/paid for

Viktor

Not sure how it works in the US, but here in Sweden it's not uncommon for kids to have protected identities. So the staff in that case would not allow the kids to be filmed or photographed to protect them.

Nicholas Ruiz

got to 27:38 and realized nah he’s just almost impressively fucking stupid

Sebastian

Great interview. My overall impression: You scrutinized him firmly and fairly, but Nick’s central claim about the ongoing fraud is true and well documented. Now, Nick’s motivation for his claim is clearly bigoted, but it doesn’t negate what has happened. Nick also isn’t a scholar like you Andrew in media and journalism history. I’m 34 years old. I get your point about news media post-9/11 and shoot you can go back to OJ Simpson when it comes to the 24 hour news cycle. Nick go very defensive when you started talking about Walter Cronkite and journalism in historic terms. He knows he doesn’t know this stuff. I would have respected and been open to his lack of knowledge in this area. I don’t think that diminishes him. I think it would help him to know more about this. My last thought, his opinions on Somalian people is racist and indefensible. It honestly kills the central point he tried to make. It makes him easy to dismiss.

Deng Xiao super Pig

God you're a good interviewer Andrew, that guy is dumb as fuck

Evelyn

My brain is falling out of my ass hearing this kid, he reminds me of this group of young men who rage bait at a local kava bar starting conversations with strangers with “the Jews created communism” sigh… a match made in heaven

Damian

Young man needs education.

Maya R

The lack of introspection on this guy is incredible. He just wants Andrew to state "facts" about Somalis without actually caring to get to know their culture. It went right over his head that western media has portrayed them only as pirates. What a smoothed brained individual.

GW

He is a zio plant, his previous work includes CECOT and Israel to say nothing going on over here. He deserves no grace.

GW

Lol who do you think is paying him?

bud dustin

I think Andrew did a great job ... look at the way this dingus is answering all of Andrew's questions... he transparently doesn't kno2 what the he's talking about and that translates, for me.

Sebastian

Most incoherent response. Thanks for your commentary.

Luca D.

Wow what a low IQ individual. It's actually insane how flawed his logic is.

GW

Andrew, you really should have challenged when he said undocumented immigrants are brought here to VOTE. Do they not hear themselves out loud?

Heather

He’s worried about fraud but ignoring the biggest frauds happening right in front of our faces. Telling Andrew he’s disappointed in him for sticking to facts. Boy is lost.

GW

Let me clarify. Nick Shirley is a zionist plant. As shown in the interview , he is conveniently the only American to tour CECOT in El Salvador, which are the concentration camps ICE is sending people to. Nick is not a real journalist and should not be taken seriously.

Bad Andy

I genuinely almost couldn't finish this interview. Listening to him talk is so incredibly painful. He is, to put it lightly, stupid as fuck.

Rachel

I almost just shot myself in the head because of this guys voice

Duterte Whitaker

I just read a Pew research study stating "homelessness is high in urban areas where rents are high". Who's going to stop all these homeless people from moving into these cities and driving up rent?!?

Erockdog

Anyone with half a brain saw this guy coming five years ago.

Mario kelley

This interview is the Dunning–Kruger effect playing out IN REAL TIME!!! Shirley, over here all dumb certain,absolutely KNOWS migrants are the reason housing is so far out of reach for an entire generation, backed by some fuckin graph he saw online somewhere. And then Andrew, who understands the messiness and complexity of the issue, just saying “I hope you’re right,” knowing full fuckin well he’s not. WILD!!

Leo Martinez

You should have asked him what he thinks people in Somalia's first thought of what an American is. Maybe they think we're all school shooters.

Tony Bordeaux

Guy really said "Why'd you question your thought?"

Barge D'lath

I love this channel and the work you all do, but this video just lost my interest man, sorry.

C S

Watching Andrew go back and forth with Nick makes me glad we have an Andrew doing this stuff.

inner.machinations

Andrew you asked Nick how you could appeal to conservatives / build more right wing viewership- I am on the right and really love your content. I think you’re a fair interviewer and you conduct yourself like a classic journalist. It’s obvious that you’re a very empathetic person, but if you want to appeal more to right wing viewers you could be more objective when addressing issues like immigration and the Somalian fraud schemes in Minnesota. I feel like you’re being purposefully dense when it’s obvious to everyone that many of these businesses are illegitimate. Yes i’m sure there are plenty of legitimate Somalian daycares, but the question we should really be asking is why do we have a massive Somalian refugee population in Minnesota to begin with? Americans who are struggling to survive are rightfully upset when they perceive a group of people have been let into the country and are gaming the system. Whether it’s the case or not it’s a net negative because it’s another wedge that can be driven between Americans. Displacing Minnesotans is not cool, and I think you should go talk to those people, and the Somalians, for a more holistic view of the situation.

Robert Crump

Did this get taken off YouTube??

kissandralopez

This guy is mind numbingly ignorant. Is he 12?

Paul Fortner

I believe he did make this point (not the school shooters thing) I think he said cheeseburgers.

Moldy Mushroom Ketchup

Where does this kid get all the money required to travel the globe? His videos weren’t popular enough to pay for it. He repeats a few talking points like mantras but doesn’t understand simple questions, ‘what do you mean, benevolent….,’ then circles back to his fraud line, and whenever he says, ‘the word is illegal, the word is fraud,’ it’s like he’s glitching, very odd.

George

Who cares. Idiot fraudsters ripping off the country. Screw them, no further conversation needed.

andrew kolometz

This was a great watch. Thanks as always! Much love

Zac Haffey

Are you guys gonna try and cover the situation in Iran at all?

Daniel Waite

I think the reason Andrew doesn't connect with a more conservative audience is because he tends to rely on facts and evidence and overall trends and tends to avoid a reactionary response and the modern republican party has kinda shifted into a populist reactionary party that can't use facts and figures because it conflicts with their worldview. Has nothing to do with how honest or in depth the reporting is. And despite them claiming otherwise I do believe theres a heavy racism element to it and this channel provides a very diverse perspective.

CC

You dont have a brain, i bet you recieve government assistance for sure

inner.machinations

that left mentality of “we just don’t have the data!” “it could actually be white people too, not all Somalians” in response to an emotional reaction to something everyone knows is true because they can see it with their own eyes, while simultaneously not applying the same standards to their own reactionary responses is a big part of his lack of right wing appeal.

inner.machinations

the theory is democrats want to grant citizenship to all of them in the future so they will have giant bloc of new voters. That isn’t implausible.

Erin Gray

He posted that he was trying, but they shut down the airspace so he's now doing something in Copenhagen

kissandralopez

I'm sure your profile is blank for a reason 🤣

GW

I would say its pretty implausible. They cant just waive a stick and grant citizenship. And on top of that, most immigrants are trad conservative too.

Barge D'lath

Well... The long form sit down interview pieces that hit for me have been the ones where the interviewee(s) has a fascinating story. Nick came across as dim and dull, and I didn't get much story from him. He more or less just showed up and had the story wrap around him, which seems to be what got him in the seat to begin with. I think the larger story channel 5 wanted to tell could have been done without spending as much time letting this guy tell it. I can see the appeal, it just missed me, that's all.

Duterte Whitaker

Andrew "being purposefully dense" is a journalistic technique to get the subject to further explain their point in their own words. In a typical segment C5 will edit in more fact checking clips when the subject says something incorrect or misleading, but in this case it feels like Andrew is just playing with his food.

Owen Altheide

oh yeah, i totally agree with you. Andrew has an amazing ability to cordially and purposefully deal with interviewees that are judgmental of him. and you’re right, nick made it very apparent that he has no idea what he’s talking about so that was a W.

spencer kenney

He slurs his words so badly and is a very emotional speaker. His mind is already made up

Nick Candler

I thought maybe i had given Nick a bad shake until he went into his propaganda bit on housing and migrants. He is hilariously ignorant in how housing works. The cost of housing is exploding because of income disparity and the financialization of everything. There is a supply crunch, but the people buying them are not price sensitive, which drives up the price. This was accelerated by unnecessarily low interest rates by the fed. If he’s speaking with this amount of confidence and certainty about something he knows nothing about, and is so quick to confirm his worldview through stereotypes, i don’t know why I should trust his reporting.

Nick Candler

That right view to believe anything that dunks on blacks, Muslims, or black Muslims

Jeff Graves

The biggest problem with people like Nick Shirley is they always have an “answer” for something. Even traveling the world like he does, how can you not just sit there absorb different ideals and open your mind to the possibility you don’t have all the answers?

Nick Candler

It is implausible and it’s a 20 year old accelerationist conspiracy theory. You can’t just vote when you’re not a U.S. citizen. Even with asylum. And even if you were, Latinos are pretty conservative.

Nick Candler

Props for the interview but i would have liked you to stay 10 toes down on housing & stereotyping & drill into his actual reporting of Somalis. It wasn’t a softball interview but it was pretty close

GW

Thank you. If these people did just a little bit of critical thinking, they’d realize how absurd it sounds. Why would an undocumented immigrant risk their safety/status to vote? 😂

Buddy McCool

This was so hard to listen to. This kid is so deeply, deeply misled and has clearly been guided his entire life to avoid any off ramp from his echo chamber. He literally does not understand what a 'fact' is. Part of me wishes Andrew had pushed back a bit more, but I also understand the journalistic importance of keeping the interviewee comfortable, and allowing him to represent himself by speaking on his beliefs. It's just so wild to me how he speaks with the sincerity of a person who cannot comprehend how someone else could come to a different conclusion about these things he thinks he understands. He's been deluded his entire life. It's sad.

inner.machinations

You make a good point, but in this case that technique was used to further expose Nick's biases and how inarticulate he is rather than determining whether what he uncovered was true or not. As I said earlier Andrew is empathetic, but his interview style is from an almost neutral 'i talked to this [downtrodden person] look how chill and like us they are' angle.

Justin

This kid is retarded lol, I think this shows a lack of comprehension skills throughout America and that the average voter is a complete moron. I also think the issue is that both of you are at opposite ends of the spectrum in your views when the truth is somewhere in the middle. Like, the amount of scams going on isn't 0% but it for sure isn't 100%. House costs are thru the roof mainly from blackstone and the like but having millions of migrants coming into the country sure as hell adds to the problem of scarcity. It sucks that everyone is so scared of offending the vocal extremes that they never give an ich to the average person that lives in the middle.

sex defender

put it on 2x speed and hope the patreon player doesnt spaz out. if you only hear half of the things nick says, you pretty much get the entire picture

sex defender

the picture only has two colors and theyre both old crayons

Hayden Henson

Jesus Christ on a fucking cracker. The mental gymnastics going on in this guys brain to convince himself that there's a single "benevolent billionaire" trying to enact positive change in this country is fucking giving me a headache. Billionaires exist because of exploitation. Thinking they dont want to pay to taxes to pay their workers more is idiotic. They hoard wealth like fucking dragons in story books and they loathe the idea of that taxed wealth helping poor people. Also yes let's turn away immigrants and tear families apart, very fucking christlike you fucking poser. Eat shit, cracker.

inner.machinations

"but the people buying them are not price sensitive" this is also true for renters receiving large amounts of government assistance and housing payments which creates scarcity and a cycle of ever increasing cost of living adjustments which is then exploited by land lords. A perfect example is Toronto where there is a direct link between an influx of refugees and migrants. I cant speak on Minneapolis, but based on the numbers of refugees taken in over a short period of time I would not be surprised if that was a contributing factor.

David Silva

He knows every answer, cause he read the bible

David Silva

When he said Elon Musk is the smartest person in the world, everything finally made sense

Warulv

He thinks Trump is awesome for not lifting a salary, while being more corrupt than all previous presidents combined. And Musk is neither the smartast or most knowledgeable person in the world, but acts like he is and that is enough for ppl who cant see through the bullshit he says and does

Warulv

Andrew getting a little heated at 45:00 ;). Love to see it. You stayed strong for 40 more minutes than I would've. This child is the biggest billionaire fan boy I have ever heard. Jeez...

Dopameanie

Andrew celebrates his departure from "classic" journalism. He's a self described gonzo journalist, meaning he believes in subjective journalism rather than "objective" reporting. Objectivity is an ideal that is unattainable by human beings and objective reporting often completely flattens the naunces of the subjective experience. Also struggling Americans are not right to randomly point fingers at vulnerable people and make baseless accusations against them. Their suffering and experience is valid, their reactions aren't necessarily.... Your desire to just assume the "obvious" is exactly the kind of thing Andrew is likely trying to expose in his use of socratics. The burden of evidence is on the asserting party and if a couple simple questions cause catastrophe for that asserted narrative, it's very telling. It tells us that it's a weak narrative and likely unsupported by reality. These are people's lives were talking about, you have to be excruciatingly naunced and committed to evidence and truth and justice. The only thing this Mormon is committed to is coveting wealth and power, and assuming easy narratives that absolve and/or justify his ignorance and prejudice.

Dopameanie

That kid is incapable of that kind of empathy. He'd probably just dodge the question into a non sequitur about how Somalia is fundamentally on a lower moral ground than the American institution.

Dopameanie

I doubt he's a talking head. I'd imagine he's more of a convenient idiot.

Dopameanie

Therapy. Pretty much everyone who speaks like him starts from a place of ignorance and insecurity. They feel there is something wrong in the world (correctly), but they jump to alleviate their egos, not elucidate their worldview. Meaning they look for simple, easy explanations that cleanse them of personal responsibility over the circumstances of their lives. These explanations often point to uncontextualized statistics and the vulnerable people around them as the cause of the world's suffering and there's no dopamine to be had beyond that, so that's where it ends. He's an example of someone who values comfort and superiority over honesty, empathy, or the truth. Disgusting...

Dopameanie

Signal boosting convenient idiots is a tried and true political tradition around here

Dopameanie

Critical analysis isn't something they teach in primary schools anyway, not unless you get very lucky with your teachers. Primary schools just teach you to fit in a profitable box and stay there until you're no longer profitable or dead, at which point you're welcome to the streets or a hole in the ground.

Naw prolly not

"Elon musk, the smartest man in the world"

Dopameanie

Honestly? The most disheartening part of this is how he singlehandedly moved the bar for average Mormon intelligence. It was already so low, I didn't think anything short of mass lobotomy would drop it, but I was so wrong.

Nate

Andrew quoting a Pooh shiesty song as a rebuttal is hilarious

Michael

and Shirley just keeps coming back to trying to get andrew to believe the stereotypes. How do you connect with conservatives? Parrot a stereotype and find evidence to support it. It's just that easy! I think it undermines Shirley's assertion on Somalis - if he's unwilling to entertain that he might be wrong then he isn't worth listening to. This was a hard watch and must have been a hard interview for Andrew.

Dopameanie

He covets wealth above all else. That's why in his world Elon Musk is the smartest person on earth and has endless moral superiority. He'll never be able to admit it, but it's the truth. He loves money more than anything.

Evan North

Alright, you got me. I was pissed prior that you were platforming this guy and then you let speak and held him accountable for his words. Very good insight into what fuels this kid’s content and how he chooses to see the world.

Chris

This kid is so dumb

TheCasualRoadie

Minneapolis has been a doorway for immigration since vietnam and cost of housing there has actually dropped relative to inflation since like 2020 because they have great housing policy

Agnus Dei

Nah he’s just a fed

Nick Candler

These are two similar but disconnected issues. Housing is extremely localized, especially when it comes to the impact of housing assistance. Wrt housing assistance, you’re unlikely to be affected by price unless you already live in the hood. With regard to immigration, an IMF study for US metro areas finds that doubling the rate of immigrant inflows reduces local inflation by about 0.1–0.2 percentage points. The rise in rents is offset by reduction for many goods and cost intensive services. If your concern is inflation the solution is immigration, but it comes with a modest increase in housing cost. If you’re concerned about renting in a low income area your point makes sense but immigrants aren’t eligible for housing vouchers. If you’re concerned about housing prices then interest rates, supply, and wealth inequity are what matters. The conversation on home prices is also a lot different if we’re talking about H1B vs unskilled labor.

Agnus Dei

A rock thinks harder than Nick

LiChai Epperson

A well-thought-out, logical comment on the internet that references an actual primary source. Didn't think that was possible.

CaptCapn

Not only is bro whiny and bitchmade but he’s also just regurgitating every distorted fact the right loves like be interesting tf

LiChai Epperson

And conveniently forgets to emphasize a supply-side solution...

Vic

this nick dude sure is stupid lmaooo just felt like a promo to watch his video

Lee

This kid is such a dumbass

JB

'What do you mean by belllevelment?'

J

Andrew has the patience of a saint fr

Ty

Well-fucking said!

Nezbar

Came here to say this… I was gritting my teeth SO much just watching that. I can only imagine what Andrew was feeling. That’s what makes him such a great interviewer. He never criticized Nick’s views and instead wanted to help him see a different pov. Unfortunately Nick seemed a little defensive with his arguments and that blocked a healthier conversation from happening. I appreciate Andrew circling back and trying to find common ground between them.

Growyourownveggies

Wait what did you just say? Can someone kick this guy out of the chat. Disgusting comment.

Growyourownveggies

If you look at this kids “play room” he hardly looks like a kid that can’t afford a home. Who has a stuffed bear in their room?

[redacted]

I think he just has the mental capacity of a 14 year old

mike

Yeah missed opportunity for Andrew to push back there but it doesn't really matter Nicholas has his mind made up

mike

This dude sounds like it physically pains him to string words together into sentences

George Becker

I've been looking at it from a hegemony perspective since I learned about all the US interventions in Latin America. Of the 33 Latin American countries Wikipedia lists 13 countries with regime changes and US involvement. Veterans for Peace claim 41 successful US regime change operations have occurred. Idk if they're counting it but Hillary Clinton's email leak included emails on US involvement in the 2009 Honduran coup not listed on Wikipedia. The border used to be open. Maybe immigration should be limited to prioritize benefiting citizens. But we also can't go kidnap presidents of foreign countries or install dictators in multiple countries and not expect refugees and destabilization. We benefit from our imperialist colonist practices but don't grant citizenship to the peoples of those colonies.

Michael Hatch

That moment when he brings the stereotypes all the way back around toward the end and it absolutely does not click.

Jim Goodwin

I am somewhat new to Channel 5. I am at a loss to understand how this interview could in any way enhance Andrew's status as a podcast host. And more importantly, why did Andrew think any of his fans would find this watchable? You can usually gauge a person's intelligence by how well they can riff on the nuances and tangents within a topic or conceptual landscape. This poor, mixed up kid clearly can't think beyond the handful of distorted "facts" that he has memorized. The only good thing that came from watching this was that it distracted my Lefty friend, and Scrabble opponent, so much, I almost won the game. I found the kid's ignorance pitiful, but my friend was actually outraged by it. In the mean time, my friend had the Q, X, J, and all the S's so I never had a chance anyway.

Ben

This interview almost got me rage posting. Love your shit Drew but wish you would challenge some of these fools a bit more at times. I’m down with the 2 0 sickness. Ride or die baby!!!

Kevin Fitzgerald

Don't worry man, I thought of the other Hollywood blockbuster, BlackHawk Down...haha

Chuck E Cheese

Cool conversation, glad it happened. But I didn't need to see it.

Brianna T

It’s all projection

Brianna T

Maybe talk abt the fraud of the Mormon church

Isaiah Powell

I didn’t know who Nick Shirley was before watching this interview and I wish I things could go back to being that way.

Alayna Peterson

This is tough. I do agree with you that Andrew probably could’ve done a bit more to encourage him to read literally anything, lol. But I know Andrew uses a similar technique as Louis Theroux which is to ask prompting questions to really let the interviewee tell the story. I think Andrew did exactly that and the story is that this kid is an idiot. Is it Andrew’s job to educate this kid? I can only hope anyone who follows Nick watches this interview and sees for themselves that he’s bogus.

PurportedGrey

This interview represents the whole point and theme behind this channel. It's not to enhance his career, it's to show what these people are like naturally without any "gotcha" type of questioning, or deliberately belittling them. Nick has shown himself In this interview to be a complete idiot and hypocrite, so anyone with an ounce of critical thinking skills, right left or center can see he's just as much of a fraud as the one he's propagating.

Jrome

Andrew allowed Nick to “GISH GALLOP” him throughout the interview I was disappointed. Gish gallop is a technique used in show debates by rapid firing unsubstantiated claims at their opponent one after another so they’re swamped while trying to disprove baseless accusations.

aviatorjbc

Your patience is crazy. Thank you for the upload.

Jim Goodwin

I see your point. Andrew does a great job of being objective and avoiding any hint of "Gotcha" journalism. I guess that is what drew me to Channel 5 initially.

B3RNi3

Bro says he doesn't consume intoxicants but he seems like he's drunk. Can't follow a logical chain of events. Seemed to no know what the word "benevolent" meant and then immediately after hearing the word mispronounced it. I wonder what his IQ is? I genuinely don't want to be mean so if he is mentally disabled this makes sense, but if not, my only other guess is that he's high.

poopoopeepee

I'm speechless. I really am.

ThugDaddy

This kids brain functions off a dial up connection

skreetsusie

Hard listen, not only bc of his passionate expression of half baked and uninformed ideas, but also bc his mouth is so fucking dry. Take a sip of water, no one wants to hear ur dry mouth amplified through a microphone 😵‍💫

What the French, Toast

Regurgitation at its finest. Nick doesn't have an original thought in his head. Good project to expose fraud, which I believe the mismanagement of tax funds is easily one of the largest underlying reasons on why we are in our current position...Andrew: keep your foot on the gas buddy, those brakes have been STRIPPED. You have a rational worldview and explain it cohesively.

TylerKai421

one of the only C5 videos i ever put down a few minutes in. no hate to andrew at all but i can't deal with 50 more minutes of the permanent resident of the peak of mount stupid. dunning-krueger at it's all time finest on the show.

Nick Bernstein

Andrew doesn't really grill people like that though. He lets them expose themselves

Nick Bernstein

check the insta. he's in copenhagen now with shane smith

STD

There are 14 million vacant homes in America right now.

Nick Candler

Fair point and why i love his content. Would have liked him to ask what he thought of trumps crypto rug pull or elons govt contracts tho as long as we’re talking about government scammers.

justin

Really disappointed at many of your rebuttals. You allowed nick to begin to build momentum about the untruthful acts of the administration by not calling him out on significant lies.

LC

I feel so sad that our public school system ( assuming he was not homeschooled) has failed this kiddo so badly. ‘Correlation does not imply causation’ is such a basic fundamental concept in critical thinking.

Joe Gurba

I disagree my friend. I think this is true of a lot of political partisans, mostly on the right, but a young men like these grew up in fundamentalist bubbles that are hard to fully appreciate if you’ve not been in one. The self-iterating feedback loop of the world view and the evidence it seeks out are nearly manifold. There are very few chinks in that mental armour. And the reason for that is that the academic method is equal parts deductive and inductive, whereas the fundamentalist religious frame is almost entirely inductive. So if you’re a curious young person who grew up in that kind of milieu, it takes a lot to break out of it, because your entire education throughout your childhood was inductive. You start with your holy book and you must make the world fit into it. From there you get your theory and you have to make the world fit into that theory. You are selective with evidence. You go out seeking confirmation. You do not collect evidence and then find a theory that explains it. The only place that kind of deduction happens is in the Bible itself. You collect the evidence in the Bible or Koran or Book of Mormon etc, then Find a theory that explains it, then go into the world seeking confirming evidence. It takes a lot of people like Andrew who engage in genuine good faith and kindness with actual education and information to slowly erode that sense of all-knowing that the church bestows on you. It’s already the case that adolescents think they know everything. Imagine how much harder it would be to break out of that if your parents give you a book and a worldview that only reiterates that… here son, with this book, you know everything. Everyone else is wrong.

Nic

I loved the discourse, I think you both represent a group of people and it was interesting to see how both of you reacted to each other with your built in viewpoints, I’ve watched it a couple times now, I think the very middle is where a lot of the major issues of the world landed for both of you and I find that very significant

Ding Dong Drift

he's 100% homeschooled until 10th grade and went to prom with his mom.

The Proletarian

A Mormon saying anything about multiple wives is laughable

Djiby

It would be the greatest thing Andrew if you’re interviewing Ari Aster about Eddington

C

Nick Shirley a busta

Zowie Haugaard

“What do you mean by the word belevilemnt”

Joe Amadeo

This kid is so entrenched in a distorted world view that he's convinced himself he's not ethnocentric and that billionaires actually have the best interest of the poor at heart. The entire interview is him defensively repeating the same trope. The fact that this kid can have any impact, positive or negative, on American society should concern us all.

w4tty

he on some dum dum fo real

jacob

This kid has no brain cells

kjo

Tough listen. The first 30m was interesting, but it got really difficult. The Trump hypnosis is really shocking - perhaps I needed to see just how cultist this still is.

William Moreno

You know whats the first thing that comes to mind right now, Nick Shirley is a retard. According to his criteria, thats a fact.

Diego Fierro

This was a great interview for Andrew especially with all things considered about his interviewee

John Jones

It would be cool if you could interview some victims of the ICE raids. That kid that got blinded in one eye permanently for example.

fakechow 14

I respect that this kid is trying and actually working hard. However, he needs a real education, not just Twitter and word of mouth. A real high school or college education would earn him much more respect, as he currently talks like he just got a concussion or woke up from a REALLY deep sleep.

cuso

wait im only like a minute in but is this guy stupid? is my country and it's leadership—for posing this goofball as a hero for 'EXPOSING SOMALI CHILD TRAFFICKERS VIA DAYCARE' —perchance.... stupid? "why are the windows that potentially allow public-street-view of children that are waiting for their caretakers... blacked out?" DURRRRRRRRRRRRRR AM I LOSING MY FUCKING MIDN IM SO GUCKING SERIOUS AM I FUCKING LLOSING MY MIND

cuso

guys ive almost made it halfway thru this video. this man is not all there. thiis kid is phasing in and out of class consciousness, favoring the latter, and it is so sad.

Lino

Ooof, that half hour mark is when I really just can’t stand this dude. I’ll always appreciate Andrew just letting his interviewees talk, but man this kid is so lost. Classic case of someone who doesn’t want to leave his echo chamber. Shirley has 0 capacity for nuance.

jeff ziggy

"Elon musk, the smartest man in the world"????

Kinneychild

The Denver moment was so cute🫶

Jerkelbakal

This dude is such a fucking midwit its insane

pifficus

"When you're making a YouTube video every single week, you can't be an expert on every topic"

Monke Bruhs

Jaque’s face at the 40 minute mark 😭😭

adrian houston

Andrew you need to clea. Out the comment section becaue it libtard infested. Either their just commenting on how he talks ( vocabulary ) or dismissing him just cuz he sometime self agrandizes. Ignoring not just his word on what he found ( the multiple times he visited, but also the politician guy that was with him that was much more in depth with investigating the fraud ( our tax dollars paying for things we did NOT allow ) .

Bryan R

painful to watch this bumbling retard blather, no idea how you and your crew was able to make it through this.

mikey.p24

the fact that he feels worse about his ukranian geography skills than his comfortability with racial stereotypes is telling

Conservation Diver

Thanks for pushing back against this moron, but I don't think he is open to educating himself.

Jennifer

I would have liked that too but sometimes you have to cut your losses, and this kid wouldn't have budged. He interrupted Andrew a shit ton

Kia Nicole Tudor

love when he called out the crew for their perceived ethnicities whew

hayes

this boy is hard af to watch. truly, way to go. so small & so steeped in circumlocution & what -about-isms, as if he can’t even track the conversation or shut up long enough to understand Andrew. (say “supply & demand” one more goddamn time)

NoMames

lol so just make it to where the only people who can comment are conservatives with poor grammar and spelling?

JD

I love how this genius is a-okay with his double-think and cant understand the issue with "theres bo kids here because its fradulent" while also being like "well yeha ofcourse they have violations with the treatment of children there" Guy do they kids there or not Holy camole I csnt stand this kid so I csnt even bring myself to watch the rest but I hope at one point to question his insane views, someone hits him with the "Surely you csnt be serious' cause his last name is Shirley; so ylu actually can call him Shirley

JD

Lmao oh so youre saying you want this to be some kind of safe space with no opposing views? Thats too bad little snowflake, it'll be okay though bb, you'll live.

Nat04

I really don't understand 'i lost respect for you because you didn't say anything about Charlie Kirk' 'I interviewed the guy that was debating him at the time' 'i don't want to watch that' ??????????

Nat04

"what do you mean by bulevelent"

unalignedant

Andrew please do not use LLMs to prove a point or as a point of reference. They cannot be trusted for fact checking.

Duaily Lopez

nick needs to take a intro to stats and an intro to econ class lol

Dustin Mailman

The “views as legitimation” perspective is really interesting to me. I experienced this as another person trying to “own” you instead of legitimately sharing. A complicated look at the psyche of so-called apolitical influencers. Also, I would love to see some engagement with emerging rapper Jayy Wick. He is a similar figure to the Hoff Twins, and is legitimately blowing up right now.

Yung Igloo

Hey just saw Nick Shirley response to this interview and you did shorten to an hour. Im bout to watch the full interview first but what I would like to know rn is why did we get this cut?

Harry Aiken

Bro post the full uncut interview. Fucking super bummed you did him like that. I’ve been a paying member for a while and this is absolutely weak.

Luke Jorgensen

I was waiting for it, but thank you for fact checking the ridiculously racist claim that 89% of fraud was commited by Somalis

Tony

The Greta Thunberg of the right

J R

I'm unsubscribing myself.

Mistrophy

what exactly was in the other hour and a half that significantly changes anything at all?

Mistrophy

Ts wasn't a 5cast episode dawg

Luke Jorgensen

This is bullshit: Denver is clearly prospering.

Luke Jorgensen

Agreed. Hallucinations and bias are a huge problem with LLMs

Luke Jorgensen

He didn't fucking find anything. After Andrew gently pointed out his huge hypocrisy—this dumbass was taking MAGA government "sources" about the "corruption" while complaining about politicians being in bed with msm—and he was too stupid to realize that he was defeating his own point. This kid is a grade A dipshit who can't see past his own ideological biases.

Luke Jorgensen

An extremely telling moment here is when this kid is railing against MSM corruption and collusion with politicians (valid) but fails to recognize how his reporting of dubious claims fed to him by MAGA state politicians is functionally the exact same thing. That he fails to identify this error in his own process while railing against corruption in the MSM would be clearly cynical self-serving bullshit if he didn't prove himself to have three braincells in the rest of the interview—I think he's just to much of a propagandized brainlet to realize his stooge role in all of this.

Joel

Exactly. There’s nothing of substance that was “cut”. This isn’t a podcast. It’s Andrew’s show. Nick is a grifter that is getting boosted by Elon and friends and now they’re pissed that he looks like a tool. So if you’re wondering why there is controversy over nick’s own words and why this is all coming up suddenly it makes a lot more sense

Harry Aiken

It’s coming up because Nick is posting unedited clips from the interview. That’s it. But sure bring up Elon?

alyssa manelinko

I love watching Andrew’s interviews. He’s able to disagree and present facts that directly challenge what the other person says in a way that’s respectful and good-natured, which keeps the conversation moving forward without him having to coddle them.

Claudio Mazzoni

Is it? I heard you that its unaffordable

Channel 5

Watch his raw and name ONE significant point of conversation that was cut please? Half of the cuts are dead air between sentences and words. The others are topics that are boring, irrelevant, or repetitive. I made the editorial choice to shave them down - there’s no silver bullet

Brendan

Thank you for responding to this! I’m confused by all these sheep who are pissed about nothing. I think it could be classified as torture to listen to Nick talk for that long.

Brendan

Will you be posting a response? I’m not sure if it’s worth giving the topic attention or validating its existence, but this is Nick Shirley we’re talking about, so facts don’t matter to him or his audience.

Brendan

it’s pretty obvious! Nick is incredibly boring and slow to listen to. No substance was cut, just painfully slow conversation.

Wildgust Art

been a sub for years pretty much since the break from all gas and i'm done. after the biden crap and now doing nick like this im out. good luck man

adrian houston

@nomames Ok, fair enough. I should double check my post before posting

ok

Post the full unedited interview

Geng Nine

I originally subbed because I felt like Andrew did a good job of being mostly unbiased and presented a good middle ground view of important topics and I wanted to support that... But for some reason it feels like this has completely shifted in recent months, which makes me sad. As someone who considers them self somewhat level headed, it drives me crazy to see people discredit legit points because they are labeled as "left" or "right"... No hard feelings, just wanted to give some feedback as to why I am unsubbing.

Gary Eddy

I saw him push back with missing footage. What’s up with that

Jack

Good shit. Thanks for responding andrew

Shane Beecher

CTE that makes sense why this so slow witted

Shane Beecher

Wait, I have a question was the McDonald’s a hypothetical?

Abraham Martinez

Chanel 5 was the whole reason I created Patreon. It’s a shame what you have become Andrew. Beyond dishonest.

Daniel Luong

post the full interview Andrew.

Van

you should be ashamed of yourself for editing and posting this completely unacceptable

Marius Schoeman

Yeah, this sucks, man. For some reason, we all expected way more from you and your team. You had set a standard we had come to expect, and this falls phenomenally short.

Dylan

I refuse to give views to nick. What the f--- happened in the edits that makes the team look bad? Everyone keeps saying be ashamed but what the f---- should they be ashamed of? Did Nick form a half way decent thought in the cut time? The kid is still a brain washed goon and the segment with the back and fourth about what Somalia is known for should tell you that. Not being able to recognize the fact that Hollywood spoon fed you an opinion on a place you know nothing about is a level of disconnect that is the root of the problem with people today. As a local, that's like saying the only thing Arizona is known for is illegal immigration because the media said so. EDIT: Bit the bullet watched the short. Still don't f---in get it. -Andrew smiling when he said Denver implied in the C5 cut that he had no idea what he (Andrew) was talking about. -Him agreeing with Nick that there is a problem with fraud flat out and then removing it also implies that someone on the team double checked before posting and could not find a credible source. This was an interview, not a debate or an argument one could easily infer that the things that were cut, got removed because it was just Andrew trying to push the interview along and not get stuck on one topic. Nick made himself look bad just fine with out the help of the C5 team.

El Barto

What’s with all these comments since yesterday? I’ll take “Coordinated bot(?) attack” for $500, Alex.

Jonathan Strength

Big fail on Andrew's part editorializing the statements of nick

Geng Nine

Nah. Just people genuinely disappointed.

Zaqube

Pretty sure everyone calling out Andrew about ‘editing’ the interview only watched what Nick said in his TikTok and then ran with it instead of watching the full interview Nick posted on his YouTube, cause holy shit Nick does even worse in the uncut interview. Every interview is cut and edited, what matters is if Nicks points were misrepresented by it and they weren’t. The point about prospering cities is still in the interview and Nick fails to defend it in this and the uncut one, all that’s missing is a bunch of pointless small talk and back and forth that doesn’t add anything to the point at hand. The statistic that Nick backed up his Somali Fraud claim with and shows to Andrew is literally shown on the screen in this version. It’s literally a google search Nick found and he even says that on his own TikTok. Not a source just an AI overview summary of the topic which is idiotic. Some of you are just Nick fanboys at this point. He should’ve done better in this interview and he didn’t or doesn’t know how to. Watching the entire practically 3hr interview to see what was cut was mind-numbing so I know nobody complaining probably actually watched it.

Zaqube

Go watch the full interview and provide examples of exactly how this was editorialized to change anything about what Nick said. Even Nicks own points he called out (prospering cities and Somali fraud statistic) are still represented in the video. If he is saying he was made to ‘look bad’ go watch that full interview and let us know if you think he looked and did better with all the extra rambling and circular discussion.

Zaqube

Nah just people going off what Nick said and not watching the full interview.

Zaqube

THANK YOU!! Nick literally gives his source in one of his TikTok videos and it’s the AI overview summary from Google that C5 shows on the screen. Andrew ‘agreeing’ that there is fraud is after Nick beat the topic to death and would not move on from it.

ChrissyD on JRE said I am juice free I am knot See

I mean I think clearly Andrew did some chopping so that he would look and sound more liberal. Cutting out the part where he says democratic states are in worse condition? That was to save face. Cutting out the portion where he agrees with Nick on the Somali fraud issue? Also to save face. Andrew doesn’t ever want to be cancelled again the way he was for being a sex pest so I think he’s very cautious with how he portrays himself to his audience.

ChrissyD on JRE said I am juice free I am knot See

I think it was more for Andrew to conserve an overly liberal position in the matter for his audience. I’m no fan of Nick Shirley and he definitely made himself out to be an ass in this interview. But why did Andrew cut out the part where he admits democrat states suck the most ass? Or the part where he agrees the fraud in this specific instance is clearly overwhelmingly an issue with Somalian immigrants? Fraud happens all over the USA but for the most part, it happens in democratic cities.

ChrissyD on JRE said I am juice free I am knot See

Yeah not a bot. I mostly have Patreon to watch Tim Dillon as Channel 5 really never posts here but I have been a member because I have been a fan of Andrew’s since all gas no breaks. This is extremely sad to see. I don’t really think Andrew did this to make Nick look worse I think he did it to save face for himself so his retarded liberal ass fans don’t get upset. He cut out a portion where he admits he doesn’t know whether or not Denver is prospering and cut out a segment where he admits the 89% statistic is true. He just doesn’t want to be cancelled again.

ChrissyD on JRE said I am juice free I am knot See

Andrew you need to listen to Nick and say shit like you mean it. Stop being afraid to get in trouble. You’re a good person at heart and that’s all that matters. If some people complain so be it. We’re here for uncut, real, independent journalism. Not some stupid talking point. America needs you man. Be real.

ChrissyD on JRE said I am juice free I am knot See

I mean Andrew clearly cut portions to save face for himself. Didn’t want his liberal fans to hear him say “I admit democrat run states are doing badly” or “well there is a problem with fraud” after Nick clearly showed him a legit source citing the 89% statistic. I’m no fan of Nick Shirley and honestly appreciated the initial interview because it shines light on Nicks overconfidence and cockiness. His mom clearly has helped him to get started and the guy David did all the research, but he constantly says “I did this, I ended Tim Walz.” Whatever it is we need Andrew to be real and not save face for himself. Shit I think him saying the democrats suck ass might get yall to realize it’s not a left or right issue. None of these politicians care about us. Maybe Thomas Massie and Ro Khanna but that’s it.

Geng Nine

I know everyone is jumping on him about editing the interview, but for me that isn't even what is really frustrating. It's more of an overall thing with Channel 5 over the past year or so. I used to love (what appeared to be) his unbiased reporting of situations and then at a certain point it seems like it just took a HUGE shift to the left and that's just not what I signed up to support. Like I said, nothing personal towards Andrew or anyone, things just seemed to have changed in a way I don't like. I wish him nothing but the best, just not my cup of tea anymore.

DEADIXNINE

Validation agency needed*

Fontly

Never thought Andrew would edit his interviews to fit a narrative, bad for there, unsubscribing.

Joe

I used gemini to tell me the big differnce between the two videos. This is what it told me. The two videos are significantly different in length, content, and framing. The primary difference is that the first video (on Nick Shirley’s channel) is the full, unedited raw footage of the interview, while the second video (on Channel 5) is the edited final cut produced by Andrew Callaghan. Here is a breakdown of what was cut and how they differ: 1. Significant Difference in Length Nick Shirley’s Upload ([02:35:53]): This is over 2.5 hours long and includes the entire setup, "off-camera" banter, and long-form discussions that didn't make the final edit. Channel 5’s Upload ([01:05:56]): This is the condensed version, roughly 1 hour and 5 minutes long. Over an hour and a half of footage was removed to create a more focused narrative. 2. Content That Was "Cut" from the Channel 5 Version Because the Channel 5 version is a produced documentary-style interview, many segments from the raw footage were removed, including: The Setup and Technical Difficulties: The raw version shows the initial interactions, Nick eating, and the crew setting up the cameras and microphones. Deep Dives into Personal Lore: Much of Nick’s extended history, specific details about his family, and longer tangents about his religious upbringing (LDS) were shortened or condensed. Repetitive Arguments: Long circular debates about the "supply and demand" of housing and immigration were trimmed down for pacing. B-Roll and Transitions: The Channel 5 version adds significant external footage—such as news clips, Google Maps images of the daycare centers, and Andrew’s own mobile studio segments—which are not present in the raw interview. 3. "Anything Cut" (The Controversy) Nick Shirley released his version specifically because he felt the Channel 5 edit changed the context of his message. Contextual Editing: Nick mentions at the start of his video that he was surprised to see the interview was "only an hour long". Specific Omissions: In the raw footage, Nick provides more elaborate explanations for his statistics regarding Somali fraud and his interactions with local Minnesota politicians. The Channel 5 version uses "Ground News" segments to provide a counter-narrative or external fact-checking, which Nick felt distracted from his direct claims. I asked for more info on any cut parts and it gave me this: The two videos are significantly different in length, content, and framing. The primary difference is that the first video (on Nick Shirley’s channel) is the full, unedited raw footage of the interview, while the second video (on Channel 5) is the edited final cut produced by Andrew Callaghan. Here is a breakdown of what was cut and how they differ: 1. Significant Difference in Length Nick Shirley’s Upload ([02:35:53]): This is over 2.5 hours long and includes the entire setup, "off-camera" banter, and long-form discussions that didn't make the final edit. Channel 5’s Upload ([01:05:56]): This is the condensed version, roughly 1 hour and 5 minutes long. Over an hour and a half of footage was removed to create a more focused narrative. 2. Content That Was "Cut" from the Channel 5 Version Because the Channel 5 version is a produced documentary-style interview, many segments from the raw footage were removed, including: The Setup and Technical Difficulties: The raw version shows the initial interactions, Nick eating, and the crew setting up the cameras and microphones. Deep Dives into Personal Lore: Much of Nick’s extended history, specific details about his family, and longer tangents about his religious upbringing (LDS) were shortened or condensed. Repetitive Arguments: Long circular debates about the "supply and demand" of housing and immigration were trimmed down for pacing. B-Roll and Transitions: The Channel 5 version adds significant external footage—such as news clips, Google Maps images of the daycare centers, and Andrew’s own mobile studio segments—which are not present in the raw interview. 3. "Anything Cut" (The Controversy) Nick Shirley released his version specifically because he felt the Channel 5 edit changed the context of his message. Contextual Editing: Nick mentions at the start of his video that he was surprised to see the interview was "only an hour long". Specific Omissions: In the raw footage, Nick provides more elaborate explanations for his statistics regarding Somali fraud and his interactions with local Minnesota politicians. The Channel 5 version uses "Ground News" segments to provide a counter-narrative or external fact-checking, which Nick felt distracted from his direct claims.

Joe

Some people just fall up trees brother

Tyrone Johnson

Don't believe any of these idiots coming to comment "we all expected more" they're full of bullshit, you did nothing wrong with editing this down and anyone trying to construe your edits as misrepresentation are not being honest with themselves or their audiences.

Elliot Acosta

thanks for nothing, please shut the fuck up

hunter brown

The fact that you paid to comment this is so hilarious. Thank you for supporting the largest crowd funded news organization bro🤙

voktyr

Can any nick fans who paid to come here just to piss themselves over this name literally anything about the raw footage that makes him look any better? …No? He sounds slow because he IS slow.

Stephen Gerrish

What feels more left these days to you? I think maybe his content is more global than it used to be but the perspective seems consistent to me.

Nick Rossi

I can’t handle either of these dorks

joshinjoshio

Real life propagandized Forest Gump

Elyse

This guy is clearly an absolute idiot.

Zaqube

You’re talking about something else entirely. The conversation is about if the C5 edits mischaracterized Nicks points and discussion to make Nick look bad. That’s Nicks claim. And the edits didn’t do that, Nick just made himself look bad on his own. He probably even signed off on the C5 version and didn’t think twice until people clipped him and started calling him an idiot online.

Geng Nine

I can only speak for me, but I used to really enjoy the content about the hood, drugs and rap culture... and yea he still puts some of those videos out, but if you just look at his uploads they are clearly mostly left leaning videos (Hunter Biden x2/x3, Buttigieg, Mamdani etc...) and when he does videos about the right they are almost always making fun of the right. I can see the rebuttal of someone saying well everyone on the right are dumbasses so they are doing that to themselves but we all know there are some really dumb people on both sides. It just feels like he is giving more favorable coverage to the left and then making the right out to be a joke more and more.

Eli Gaultney

for those who don't know, conversations with Mormon missionaries trying to convert kind people often can take on this tone/cadence. instead of pulling on bible passages and quotes from doctrines (I'm sure he has memorized many) he's using an analogous databank of political data here. funny to see the same technique applied in this more secular way.

Raphael Rose

Why can't two things be true at the same time? Supply and demand and greedy developers both resulting in higher prices.

Raphael Rose

He shouldn't though, if you're always afraid to show your true face, people will notice. We come to Channel 5 for authenticity

Calvin Little

Patreon sub for a while now, never seen the comments as cancerous and infested with political pundits like this. Keep your head up Channel 5 gang you all snagged a quick buck from these idiots anyway.

Calvin Little

so nick can cry about his religious upbringing or see awkward camera setups? is an hour not enough content to see your boy is a fucking idiot?

Calvin Little

I saw your mom's dick in my mouth last night heyo what

Calvin Little

lots of nick trolls in here but this is a valid point google AI responses as b roll footage was weak imo

Marius Schoeman

Yikes. Can't purport to represent something then pull shit like this, my guy.

Gary Eddy

Hehe look at you

Mama tinky

Honestly man Andrew could have made him look ALOT worse. The clueless reactionaries and one second experts flooding the comments just don't understand that Andrew actually did this dude a favor making him look as good as he did. BTW I've watched some of Shirleys content. Yall dont think he skews his edits to make himself look better? I really don't think C5 cutting out the part about Denver is disingenuous at all, especially since, ya know he was actually correct.

Danomight

Nick made a fool of himself, and Andrew was more than generous in his editing to help him look better.

savethebaysteve

Dam you made patreon? Can you make comments section better to load? I mean its a shame what you have become. beyond dishonest.

aviatorjbc

This has been a multiple sit down watch for me, someone please teach Nick Shirley about Causation vs Correlation.

savethebaysteve

Real talk, I love me so C5, even when I disagree with stuff (THATS WHATS GREAT!) But man some of these guys they interview fucking hurt my brain, and I'm dumb! It was a hard watch.

Jennifer

Ethan, you're trying to approach this empathetically, which I appreciate. But I think your criticisms of Andrew are wrong. With Denver, no one really cares. As in – he wasn't "saving face" from liberals. I would have preferred he left in the original, sure, but it's really minor. As far as the 89% statistic, Nick was presenting it incorrectly. As the screenshot from google (which Nick himself showed Andrew!) said, this was specifically about the defendants of the Feeding Our Future fraud case. It says nothing about what demographics commit fraud in MN as a whole. I support Andrew leaving that out, since the statement he seems to admit wasn't true. Watch Andrew's response video if you haven't yet. Anyways, this dude is not trying to save face with liberals LMAO. if anything, based on his videos in the last year and a half, he's trying to save face with conservatives. Hence this interview. Shame the aftermath was like this.

TheNotation

Its very funny seeing the nick defenders use horrible and sometimes unintelligible grammar and spelling in the comments here and act like they have made the biggest most spectacular level headed view on everything, get real and open your eyes to everything around you dude.

Will Loving

Pregnant Mormon women who drink are crushing it.

Zak Breckenridge

This guy seems like he's never had a second thought in his life

Kevin

Andrew isn't someone who you expect to consistently interview the best, most articulate representative of any particular viewpoint. That's part of his approach and it's why I watch his videos. Nick isn't the best representative for modern conservatives, but neither is Hunter Biden a good representative for liberals. To counter your point about never making fun of the left, Andrew interviewed some angry protestors at recent anti-Trump rallies that didn't come off very well.

foodbucketjesus

The cost of housing/supply & demand portion of this gave me herpes and syphilis. Shirley is a fucking dunce.

foodbucketjesus

Someone should ask Nick Shirley what white men in America are known for.

Julie Cook

Because day care centers are locked and kept private you moron. Day care isn't school, what an idiot

Levi Mitchell

this was very interesting to watch after having recently seen a few episodes of the secret lives of mormon wives and the real housewives of salt lake city... the same strange loose understanding of fact and reason. some great lols from this one cheers guys

Rowdy Yates

Rad conversation. Always appreciate your style Andrew!

Erfan Moradi

Shirely sounds like he is on ketamine trying to sound smart

Samm Fabish

Wow this guy is legitimately stupid.

Samm Fabish

That scares me that basically an entire state (and bleeding outwards rapidly) is full of people this dumb and brainwashed.

Samm Fabish

Well if you look at the graphs… 🥴

Samm Fabish

This interview felt like an interview with an NPC where you’re just trying out all the menu items

Samm Fabish

I am SO grateful this was edited holy shit. This was like watching an interview of a glitching NPC. How does he have an audience?

Samm Fabish

Yeah! Channel 5 NEVER EDITS

Samm Fabish

Yeah! Channel 5 NEVER EDITS

Christy Rappold

people have too much fucking time on their hands loard

prolawl

is this guy actually slow?

D G

I started out blind, unaware of who this guy is or what video of his went viral. At first, I couldn’t believe the level of fraud being exposed but I was very quickly disillusioned when this kids intentions became clear. Then the longer it stretched, the stupider he presented. Praise Andrew’s patience talking with this idiot

T. Ph.

Belittling people is unbecoming.

Adam

His ignorance was infuriating!! He sounds exactly how a right wing influencer stereotype would sound.

Scott

Man, it’s hard to see how Walter Jr turned out.