Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey Guys..

As promised, here is the video of a grueling deposition in which I was interviewed by Bill Joiner's attorneys about my video and file storage process for a federal lawsuit in which they falsely claimed that I had violated the Federal Wiretap Act and intercepted Joiner's electronic communications. Once it was revealed in the Discovery process that I'd never done such a thing, the lawyers switched strategies and began arguing that I'd deliberately moved, deleted or otherwise hidden relevant case files in order to delete evidence of wiretapping. After this deposition, Joiner's lawyers voluntarily dismissed their own case in Federal court BEFORE trial in order to refile claims in California state court, re-initiating a costly litigation process that thanks to our donors, we are now able to fund without having to shut down operations at Channel 5. In this deposition, they spend over 2 hours trying to trip me up in service of a frivolous claim that was voluntarily dropped just months later. Enjoy!

Files

Andrew Callaghan Deposition

Hey Guys.. As promised, here is the video of a grueling deposition in which I was interviewed by Bill Joiner's attorneys about my video and file storage process for a federal lawsuit in which they falsely claimed that I had violated the Federal Wiretap Act and intercepted Joiner's electronic communications. Once it was revealed in the Discovery process that I'd never done such a thing, the lawyers switched strategies and began arguing that I'd deliberately moved, deleted or otherwise hidden relevant case files in order to delete evidence of wiretapping. After this deposition, Joiner's lawyers voluntarily dismissed their own case in Federal court BEFORE trial in order to refile claims in California state court, re-initiating a costly litigation process that thanks to our donors, we are now able to fund without having to shut down operations at Channel 5. In this deposition, they spend over 2 hours trying to trip me up in service of a frivolous claim that was voluntarily dropped just months later. Enjoy!

Comments

Alex Velleux

Fuck Bill Joyner. SHOUTOUT 5

Tom

Fuck Bill Joiner

Chris

Fuck Bill Joiner Fuck Hernandez

Rev. Ratspeed

Better than the world cup finals. 🍿

Chris

Fuck Murphy And Murphy

Frank Robinson

I’m can’t wait to watch andrew explain basic concepts to old people

SeeGeeArtist

Longest 2 hours of your life or nah?

Niklas F

U Look like a killer. And i mean it very positiv^^

Dora Bendetti

Put it in 1.5 speed and they actually speak at a normal speed

ReshapeReason

Dude this is so lame, fuck frivolous lawsuits. I can’t believe rich people can just sue you into oblivion with no consequences

Angela Tait

I would’ve lost my shit repeating myself so many times in so many ways..

Rowan K

I need a highlight reel, this is way too long for me lol. Also, fuck Bill Joiner.

sdfuy798iujk3

The Bill Gates deposition video is a fun slog as well. The tension is wild

sdfuy798iujk3

I think Bill Joiner might be representing some other interests at this point.. other people or organizations or nation states that want Andrew gone

BlackHorseGrind

Fuck Bill Joiner and the dark forces behind his antics

Leah

Fuck Bill Joiner and his ghouls.

redkey

What is BJ’s goal here?

redkey

I’m here for the detailed run down of c5’s creative process

Leo Newton

Is Andrew ignoring is defense council's objection? Would it have made the deposition shorter if he did not answer those questions?

Henry

I don’t even understand what he thinks you did. Reminds me of those patent trolls.

ER R

Go get 'em, dude.

Szymon Urbanski

If you start watching from 1:28:00 to 1:38:00 you will get how limited these people are

Alien Nation

finding bill joiner. FBJ hahahaha

Durt Roburtz

This is so awesome. Keep doing it, C5!!!!!

Rachel

“and the software is… finder?”

Alien Nation

nah. she is telling him to answer but she is objecting kind of like to bookmark bs questions for a judge that watches the deposition

Gary Eddy

Worst podcast ever

Yoli

This is painful to watch, why are these lawyers asking stupid questions ? How about learning the basics of how to use a computer

Cole Nasrallah

I know this was miserable for Andrew, et. al, but it was truly fascinating to watch. Thank you for uploading. Thank you for fighting for independent journalism. I hope all of C5 feels on their front foot. I'm so grateful to see folks speaking truth to power.

Gary Eddy

Plus, I bet that recorder had a shortcut for the word “proxies”

Cameron

Yo on a more technical note, trusting the server is risky, C5 should back up the server hard drive as well, maintain multiple backup strategies, would be a shame to ever lose C5 work, especially if all work now goes straight to the server and skips intermediate SSDs!

Dane Bonnici

Man, you would think they could find a guy to pay to teach them about computers

ctwomey

Financially drain Andrew & C5

Justin Lawson

Big year for free speech vs. money

Didi

How many times are they going to keep asking the same question? Fuck Bill Joiner

TK

damn they said susan’s government name

B Beard

None of the homies fuck with bill joiner. Guy is a BUSTER. Murphy and Murphy are pretty lame to

B Beard

If you got some tech skills might wanna hit em up

B

Yo Andrew, make sure you keep an offsite backup of your footage, homie! Events like fires, robberies, interdimensional time warps, data corruption can happen at any time. If your "server" is a proper NAS it probably has cloud-based backup as a service. Trust me, it's cheap insurance in case anything catastrophic ever happens! Stay up homie

Melonmagellan

Should have went Lil Wayne on this one.

Tristan Scott

Why the fuck do we need courtroom reporters in this day and age especially when they actively are interfering with the testimony by asking individuals to modify the way they’re speaking.

B3RNi3

As a lawyer, the deposing counsel is so out of his depths and grasping at the thinnest of straws. He knows he doesn't have a case or really any use from this deposition by the end of it. He tries so much for "gotcha" questions and Andrew does an amazing job making him look like a fool. Amazing stuff. FBJ

Mike

Andrew, PLEASE back up your data off-site. Could be a hardware failure, a theft, or a fire. You don't want to lose everything.

Jake Koger

For sure dude- I was looking for someone else who brought this up before I did. I think he said the new ThunderBay NAS was 100TB- even doing Amazon Glacier Deep Archive would be like a $100/mo insurance policy for the worst case scenario. Find a way to encrypt before uploading to avoid the Bezos of it all. Keep that whole NAS backed up and hope to never get raked over the coals to re-download it down the road. Better to have to pay the few grand to grab the data instead of lose it forever, though. Just wish there was a way to do it p2p, pledge some storage on top of Patreon every month and keep that shit "local" instead of in some billionaire's data center. Fuck those custers.

GregFoster126

its like explaining stuff to my parents

Ben Ralph

I honestly just think he’s insane. The unfounded wiretap/spying allegations scream paranoid schizophrenia

Joseph Rubio

as an editor this is so insane to watch lmao

George

Fuck these Custers. Andrew and the C5 crew are showing that you can’t silence truth or scare people when they are doing what’s right

Thomas

I’m so confused why Bill’s attorneys are actually going through with this. There’s nothing he can sue for! It’s ridiculous. This lawsuit is a waste of time.

Alexander Strife

This reply was too fast, please slooooowwww it down. xD

Laila Travers

such a cornball tactic to come for "how long have you done this?" while it took you an hour of repeating what a proxy is

Harrison Farnum

Andrew feeling like Dwayne Michael Carter iii rn

Jack Conte

weirdest behind the scenes i've seen in a minute and i fucked with it heavy.

Jack Conte

love the transparency and bringing us into what's happening and the challenges of it. taking notes in case im ever deposed :sob:

Cow

Was that a 50sec lunch break? Was that code for something?

Lauvra

madame court reporter's word per minute skills may have been exaggerated on the CV. allegedly

Lauvra

won't anyone consider the alleged sanity of madame court reporter

B

Easily the shittiest video you ever posted. Did you even check your PROXY FOLDER Andrew?!? Fuck! 😂

Desert Rat Explorations

That recorder needs to learn how to type faster. Imagine if she asked a judge to slow down when speaking in a court room.

Leo Newton

"During a deposition, inappropriate or objectable questions are generally those that harass the witness, seek privileged information, or violate proper evidentiary rules. Objections are raised to either preserve an issue for trial or to prevent the witness from being misled or coerced into inaccurate testimony." --Google Gemini

K&Bdiscount

I don’t know why I watched this but man I feel Andrew’s pain here. BS knows no bounds

jon50250

This is hilarious. The drag and drop checksum part had me rolling lmao average convo for Mac vs pc users

jon50250

Also dude at one point is like ‘oh ya finder’ and then like 1 minute later he’s like ‘apologies I’m not familiar with finder’ like you’re not slick it don’t matter when ur the man

klav

fuck bill joiner independent journalism is literally one of the most important ways to share information in a society

Maik Huegli

Hey quick question as a none american what does the objection actually do?

Mark Heijblok

I would like to know also, thanks in advance for explaining.

Mark Heijblok

So, Andrew has to travel to location of this dispostion, talk for some hours, has to prepare himself for the hearing.. And all that time is not compensated by any financial reimbursement after Bill dropped the case? America is insane..

Eli Gaultney

lmao at the technical difficulties. on the one hand i'm glad we can do this stuff over zoom now and maybe save a few people annoying drives. on the other hand, so many interruptions and PEBKAC issues

Eli Gaultney

is bill joiner a bully or a front for those who want to silence free speech and true investigative journalism?

Hauke

Baller tie

Eli Gaultney

okay and also we need to talk about your backup plan. one server and the original HDDs is not enough Andrew! we need one off-site copy, at the least.

J M

Andrew gives that look at 0:02 like he just knows this is gonna be wild

Alexander Strife

Is this a satirical law comedy skit? The recorder reminding you to slow down your speaking is not something they'd do in court. You spoke at a normal speed; she just needs to up her WPM speed. xD

Russell Leckenby

I’m sorry sir but I can only use one finger to type so could you please make an effort to accommodate my inability to do my job

Josh Schwartz

Cool to see that the PEOPLE wont let Andrew get steam rolled by the rich and powerful.

Josh Schwartz

Court stenographer fighting for her life.....

sean fahey

it's a civil case, no prosecutor involved

Jpetrie

I don’t think bill joiner believes any of that is true. They just chose something that is harder to prove in hopes Andrew would just pull content and not want to fight it

Mirage

100%. BJ's a tinfoil hat case.

Benjamin Taylor

"Who has an ownership interest in C5?" Andrew does - thats why we're all here. Fuck yeah.

skreetsusie

Genuinely. Her pleading Andrew to slow down as if she was fighting for her life 😭 to be fair, she probably was, considering the redundant and trivial nature of this 2 hour long deposition about nothing

Oscar Rutabaga

im not sure why but its prompting me to sign in and I can't access the video this happening for anyone else?

DBear

Also, the court reporter needs to stop with the exasperated whiny tone. Depositions are tense, conversational environments that have potentially huge stakes. If you cant record people at a conversational pace, where presence of mind is essential, you need to either a) get a different job or b) be replaced by a robot. Be better!

Zak Miller

Loved that he immediately referred to your attorney as "he"

ben meiring

The checksum generated using Hedge or Offshoot for the media card to SSD transfers could've saved a lot of time and headache. Highly recommend.

333martini

so perplexed as to how the examining counsel passed the bar exam and became a attorney when he can't ask a single decent question or even run a zoom meeting

Sochi

Fuck bill

berean auden

Dude for real, izrl hates C5, governments hate truth. Thats why all media are in cahoots with government and the ones that aren’t are targeted

Soren James

I can't believe I watched all of this. It's hard to believe how the proper legal procedure is essentially 2 hours of nebulous, (ok slow down see um uh yeah uh so um) time filler bullshit. 134 fucking minutes and only the last 4 contain a cogent string of direct questions. And it's coming from AC's attorney. All were depressingly more to-the-point deposition questions... and it wasn't even coming from Bill Joiners side of the table. You can't make up how ridiculous our system is.

Odie Moses

They thought they had something with the proxy’s

Didi

I think my favourite of it all is the way Andrew has the look of “you’ve got to be fucking kidding me”

kappe

protecc andrew at all costs

Stone McCarthy

Finding Bill Joiner? Wtf what would make that dude say that?

BMoney

Short lunch.

Stone McCarthy

Lets play a game of 20 questions only i will ask the same 20 questions in as many ways as possible in 2 hours.

Philip Balcar

Custers, the lot of them 🖐️

Scoops

This was so cringe during the deposition. This deposition reminds me of the Sundar Pichai congressional hearing from 2018.

sdfuy798iujk3

I dont think insane that argument was what his lawyers came up with, he wants to fuck Andrew over for putting him in the spotlight

Scoops

Shit man, after watching this, maybe BJ really did ruin Kelly's life.

mad

He kept calling you an expert which just felt like he was just saying yea yea yeaaa..... I'm an idiot defending an idiot and am very prepared to get fucking roasted here....so....gimme some slack even tho I'm getting paid to be a loser

Jordan Bitter

It’s brutal to listen to him explain the process of data collection over and over and over…if this bill guy has so much money you’d think he could hire lawyers that pay attention.

Lee

I was ok with the dude like he's just doing his job as annoying as the questions were until he said "sorry HOW long you been doing this? You expect us to believe you don't know.." holy shit what a prick

Matthew Razo

Andrew holding it down. AC for president!

Mia

Brutal. I wanna keep watching. But I don’t know if I can do it!!!

Jeff Walker

Dude, they were messing with you, they aren’t stupid. It’s all on purpose

megan -

That proxy conversation would have been the ultimate test of patience. Absolutely stellar show of patience and composure. Fuck Bill Joiner

Ryan Kaspy

Standard cloud-based backup might be an issue for anything controversial though, one ToS flag on raw footage and the host can nuke the whole account. He should look into client-side encrypted offsite backups or an offsite NAS at a separate location instead.

David Robbins

I am wondering if one of his kids or someone close to him had an embarrassing feature in one of Andrews films and this is how they're trying to shut it down.

Salmajrh

Why we using A.I. tho 😭

Salmajrh

Someone commented on here explaining it better than i could “its like a bookmark” for the judge to see and note when they read over the transcript of the deposition that an objection was made. So in actual court if they state objection in front of the judge, the judge decides if they approve the objection or not. Since its a deposition theres no judge present to approve or decline it.

Salmajrh

This is such a crazy video It was super interesting seeing the structure of C5 even if unfortunately it was through a deposition.

Benjamin Griffith

Trigger warning at 1:58:14 for an inefficient and overly-bubbly pour of sparkling water

C

Chill sounds to hate Bill Joyner to.

Xealix

Please help this man find counter-suite representation for the cause.

Xealix

Brother im 30 minutes in and getting mad. I'm sorry you had to sit through this

Xealix

1:44:00 I'm drunk watching this and I straight up heard you smack your teeth with the glass brother lmaoooo

Anthony Piazza

Why are people still doing shit like this over a zoom or on the computer. Every person should be in the same room face to face talking. So much wasted time and misunderstandings with those old heads doing a deposition over video chat.

Jed Leslie

20 mins and and so far we've uncovered that OMG C5 HAD FILES ON HARD DRIVES

Dashiell

Infuriating watch, great work

Lena Bal

2h10min useless questions 5 min actual case relevant questions that was painful

Lena Bal

what was the strategy here?

Altoar

Sorry, them playing the vlog back to you was so funny - was the 'jerk station' part actually necessary to have on record???

Jed Leslie

Wow what a stupid massive waste of time. Andrew you're an absolute saint for attempting to walk these muppets though this.

Allie

Fuck Bill Joiner

SATURN

That whole intro where he talks about how ignorant he is and all I can thing of is "he's going to weaponize this to get under Andrew's skin". Like at one point you just wanna say "i can explain this but I can't understand it for you".

Brad

Bill Joiner is a custer. Proud of you Andrew. 5

JayWhyP

This guy would have a hard time making a proper Baconator. Also FBJ

B3RNi3

I left another reply in the comments of one of the greatest first amendment/commercial speech litigators in the country. Seth Berlin. Don't know if Andrew really needs a guy that good (and expensive), but it might be worth it to reach out to him. I'm not a litigator though so I wouldn't really know who the best counsel for a counterclaim would be in Andrew's scenario. Either way, justice requires that these types of frivolous suits be disincentivized.

SOGGYSLOTH

I 100% believe the capitalist class is attacking the independent journalists. Breakthrough News is Under attack AGAIN! I do not believe Andrew in this case. Is target by some bigger lobby yet. Thankfully. This suit will give him the practice needed to face this in the future, from more disciplined and ideological backed attacks from unlimited funding. He luckily isn't at that stage yet I don't believe. The correlations vs causation type thing.

Paul

Good work, Andrew. Maintain your composure. “Dennis” tried to draw you out. Let the little diaper baby sit in his pee pee and poo poo. Mommy will change him eventually.

Ratbug

With all due respect, they shouldn't have someone ignorant to the technical nature of his own questions, depose you. This guy is kind of a dipshit on the topic though I'm sure he's very intelligent in other areas. Good job standing your ground and never letting him shake you, Andrew!

Mitchell Stroup

feels like I'm back in gfx class. great composure professor

Ev

Someone needs to put in the work to smash Mr. Joiner’s wife for C5. I know the gofundme helped fund the legal battle, but that would be a priceless gift.

notlikethecar

nah people with schizophrenia aren’t organized enough to run predatory lending operations lol just a garden-variety narcissist with too much money

Simon Marshall

What does "find counter-suite representation for the cause" mean?

Grant Oberle

Find a lawyer to help him recuperate the legal funds and other damages associated with fielding this frivolous lawsuit

Grant Oberle

I feel like they changed their mind right after

Sonya

For Andrew it was more like 3 hours, what a complete drag.

DudeBro123

Just leaving a comment to say that you being sued etc is why I became a paid up member of your patreon

Kyle

That poor court stenographer. You gotta slow down for her, man.

Johan vall

This! Andrew is doing reporting that is blatantly showing a nation doing genocide, that nation has a lot of power and influence, might be a fluke BF sued but I would not put it past them!

Natalie Peyton

Double speak strategy is gonna get Joiner someday

Cody dozoretz

Would you mind slowing down a bit? TANKYEWWWWW....😆😆

Cody dozoretz

Realize that this is the court recorder. Her tone just got me.

Paul Lowder

bro, what the fuck was that 1 min. lunch break?! 😂

Fox MacLeod

man, that reporter is fucking horrible at her job

Fox MacLeod

seriously, why is that her job if she can’t even keep up with what’s being said?