Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 749147451.mp4

Downloads

Content

Yo yo,

Here's some real shit we been working up to this whole series, 5 the night owls.

AC

Files

Comments

Cole Murphy

gg allin reference wild 😭

Lucid Vibe Radio

Dope, thank you for the deep inside work AC, much appreciate the thoroughness

Marco

Thanks man for this Part, Iwas a bit disappointed by the first Parts and you only Talking to pro Regime people. Thanks for showing how cool and progressive the real iranian youth is, those are the people you would chill with and have interesting conversations with, not with the paid protestors from the other Parts :) big love from Germany!

Fekr

Man that was going so good, until you summed it up saying, pretty confidently, that people didn’t support regime change… after 15 minutes of driving home that people didn’t feel comfortable speaking freely to you. I think a better summation would have been that, as a journalist, you aren’t capable of getting an honest view of Iran. Not because of your bias or anything that’s on you, but because by design, you won’t be given the access required. Sadly, the only people who have an honest perspective is the diaspora, but the second an Iranian escapes Iran they’re painted as disconnected or liars. Not claiming you are trying to do this, but even in the video the diaspora is referred to as a group who simply spreads anti regime lies. This is why Iranians don’t have hope for a future or plans for a future.

Fekr

Sorry to be critical, I’m not trying to be a troll. Your border coverage approached the issue in such a nuanced way it gave me hope that the US could actually work to fix the problem. Something I’ve heard argued about since Bush. So when i heard you were going to Iran and even covering it I felt like you were one of the few people who had the ability to cover it in a way it needed. Hope you take the critique with sincerity.

chris tufts

Nobody else is doing this....great work AC

Dingus Ex Machina

18:26 "What did you think about those protestors?" *nervous laughter* "I don't have an opinion on it" ......oof.

Gilena

I know I don’t understand nearly as much as I should. Reading your comments causes me to know you are passionate, eloquent and very engaged. 🇬🇧

Gilena

You are and will always be the 5th element. Ty so much for all you do to educate the rest of us. Blessings be. 🇬🇧

Gilena

Your power is immense and crosses future generation’s ability to understand one another. Young Americans and young Iranians really do share common values and goals. 🇬🇧

SOGGYSLOTH

You are MOSSAD. Fuck off. "The only people with honest perspective is the diaspora" Is one of the most Inaccurate statements you can make. Ahh yes, historically, contemporary, the Diaspora of people's are the most rational.... Fuck off. Iranians do not want to be invaded by the USA... end of story. None of your mossad level psyop shit is gonna change that. You are not being "critical" you are being an advocate for invasion. Which is wild. You think there is suffering now? Tell that to 38 million refugees, tell that to over 4.5 million dead. Just in our wars in middle east post 9/11... You want us to do more of that. You are advocating a position, that will kill millions, and displacement of millions more. Because, IRGC is oppressive. Get a grip dude. Pay attention. You are advocating for killing millions of your own people, from the safety of the countries that will do the murdering. Fuck off

Gilena

15:39 Sounds like terrorism to me. Like ICE in Minneapolis. 🇬🇧

Bailey

I only like drunk cigs and I quit drinking, but that dart around 7:20 probably tasted lovely

notlikethecar

so your critique is that andrew can’t confidently come to a conclusion about the perspective of people who live in Iran, but you can confidently come to the conclusion that “the only people who have an honest perspective is the diaspora?” does one’s perspective become “dishonest” when it is complicated by the material realities of living in Iran? can a perspective only remain “honest” when it is formed by someone for whom the consequences of regime change exist largely in the abstract? is that what you’re saying?

Fekr

I’m saying that this video is, at best, a series of interviews of hostages that can’t speak freely. They’ve essentially got a gun to their head as they’re being interviewed and a regime minder watches. So, by design, a journalist is never going to get a very honest picture of Iranians.

Fekr

And I’m not sure what part of your loved one’s dying is abstract. It’s not abstract when we watch the massacres unfold and hear stories about the arrests and abuses. A lot of Iranians I know didn’t leave until after Mahsa Amini (who most western media can’t even pronounce her name, or call her ‘that girl’ , and many people I know lost loved one in January. I’m not sure what part of leaving the borders of Iran somehow makes every diaspora experience somehow illegitimate. I mean, seriously, I just got called Mossad…. This is where we’re at when it comes to listening to Iranian voices.

Pat

I think in general you can assume nuance on where a population stands with their government. Just look at the US. But why most people take your comment as inflammatory is because a majority of people do not want war, and suggesting that Iran's general population wants regime change can be loosely tied to approving of the bombing and sanctions on Iran... Also your comment about the diaspora having the most lucid take on what's going on is ignorant as hell. The most lucid take, if there is one, is always going to be the people who have the most direct experience in the situation. A good example being the Jan 6th insurrectionists. Sure a lot of people want to see political change in the US, but everyone sees a different end goal and means to that. But I can promise you a majority of people wouldn't want a Russia or a China bombing us and putting sanctions on us in order to see that political change happen.

Fekr

Can you tell me who has a closer connection and can speak freely?

Pat

Interviewing your contemparies is your strong suit Andrew. This is the Iran people should see. As long as young people see a future of peace and collaboration we're going to be alright. Don't let the hate and old money rivalaries keep the new generation from making a better world.

Fekr

I’m also not implying that 100% of anyone wants anything. But I am saying that I’m one Iranian diaspora member, and I can honestly tell you no one I spoke to in Iran since the massacre or invasion has said they didn’t want the regime to fall. Not everyone supported the war, but I knew more diaspora that opposed it than Iranians in the country. If I talk to other diaspora you hear majority the same thing. These are people who are each connected to dozens, if not hundreds, of other Iranians. Can speak the language, understand the context, and are telling you about what they hear and see through encrypted channels. The diaspora didn’t campaign for bombing of civilian infrastructure but we also watched as our families sent pictures of the IRGC parking in front of apartment buildings and setting up in elementary schools. So after being massacred in January and trying everything they can, what do you recommend for them? Which country should arm them or support them? People are really arguing that being minded by a spy while you walk around and interview people with that spy is going to give you a better picture of reality?

SOGGYSLOTH

I read your comments for 3 parts now. I've held my tongue to hopefully give you chance to be patient. But it's clear. You are not good faith. Is there any mass supported alternative in Iran? No unfortunately... So the throwing around of Regime Change is just code for "Invasion and reinstall Shah" which you are aware of by reading your previous comments. Which would unnationalize your oil. Sell it to western powers. Export the profits. Cut of aid to Palestine and Yemen in their fight against Imperialism. Now replacing the IRGC is a great desire. I recommend when given opportunity to do so naturally from within, do it. But to advocate for the invasion by Imperialists. Which would solidify the Israel Greater Project going unchecked, and complete oppression of the Iranian Working class and exploitation and exportation of the resources. That's only AFTER A MULTI YEAR GROUND INVASION THAT WOULD DESTABILIZE AND KILL MILLIONS MOST LIKELY! And that's best case scenario that the US successfully installs the Shah.... Which you could end up like Afghanistan. But sure Habibi, keep advocating for the devil to come into your home. Also. They could lose. The IRGC could win, then in process solidify more power. Because all those opposed died or were lost or became dispora. Which therefore destroys all the current people and any momentum a natural revolution is building. It could make things soo much worse. And it can't make it any better I promise. I swear to you. We don't come in peace. I promise

Fekr

1. There’s mass support for Reza Pahlavi, you just don’t like it. 2. Pahlavi has been consistent in pushing for democracy, so we don’t even know what him leading would look like. 3. His father actually nationalized the oil, which is why the US pulled support for him. But I would expect the US to get its fingers into the extraction industry there, which is unfortunate, but also no one is going to help us for free, obviously. The left has nothing to gain so they don’t even entertain the idea. 3. Iranians aren’t benefiting from the nationalized resources because of corruption and mismanagement. The only people benefiting is the regime and its proxies, who you seem to think represent the Palestinian people, rather than an oppressive imperialistic regime that is essentially America if the right wing gets its way. 4. You somehow seem to be ok with Palestinians and Yemeni’s taking military aid from an oppressive imperialistic regime, so why can’t the Iranians in their desperation reach out to the only country willing to aid in their fight? Or we could just keep Iran and Isreal locked in a forever war that’s doing exactly what you’re saying you don’t want. Keep allowing the regime to circumvent sanctions so they hurt the people most. Keep making money off the conflicts. Or I guess you’d rather just pull out and leave our mess to the IRGC to expand into and leave it for the locals to deal with?

Nari

your view though is very in line with the diaspora’s way of thinking. i think if you are recognizing the AC’s view is a certain way, its only fair that you recognize your own bias.

Fekr

Absolutely I can see that. But can’t you see that our diaspora agreeing should be a sign of agreement in Iran? Our bias is formed from lived experience under the regime and sharing it with each other. What’s frustrating is how easily it’s brushed off as simply ‘a bias’. Can’t you see that’s pretty dismissive? Why wouldn’t this perspective be valuable? AC’s perspective isn’t being silenced like the Iranian people.

SOGGYSLOTH

1. That's false. It's astroturfed. Not grassroots support at all. 2. Democracy under the shah was famous for the secret police it used so wtf you talking about. 3.in 1951 the oil was nationalized. In 53 a coup reversed this. Took the shah til 73 to renationalize it. While remaining a very close ally with USA, so that's another lie you told again. i pay over $4 a gallon for gas. I know for a fact that Iranians do not pay anywhere near that. They pay the equivalent of pennies. So that's another lie. And corruption exists. The idea thst you think it would be better with corrupt western officials is wild. 4. In what way is Iran Imperialist? This seems wild considering they are defending themselves in the latest attacks. Iran hasn't sought land since Afghanistan in like 1850s lolol 🤣 Iran is currently anti-imperialist in its fight. You are clearly lost in the sauce. 5.OR we stop the actual most dangerous threat to the world and Middle East. The US and Israel... which that peace, would allow the Iranian people to do what needs to be done domestically.... Why does the victims of imperialism need to bend knees for peace? And never the aggressors or profiteers? Also I called you Mossad, because. The shah famously, had close relationship with ISRAEL! LIKE WTF. I'm calling a shah supporting Iranian, who's supporting someone who supported Israel. Mossad. And you have nerve to play Identity politics. Ain't no liberal here, you missed with that one. Shah and Israel go together like Peanut Butter and Chocolate*

Al's talkin'

PLEASE! Andrew! When or if this drops on YouTube make the whole finding graffiti part a short. So I can spread the word! PEACE!

Fekr

Democracy under the shah was 100% flawed. But you didn’t criticize those conditions under the current regime, you criticized the denationalization of oil. Both are probably a lot more complicated than you might know. Yes, it took the Shah until 73 to nationalize it. Because Mossadegh was pushing to nationalize at a time when doing so would have bankrupted the country. Mossadegh was as much influenced by the great powers game being played as the Shah. Iranians have suffered under the Russian/British games for longer than you probably know. And the Shah played the hand he had to align with someone outside of that. You probably didn’t know that his father tried to make the country a republic when he took power but the British and Mullah’s rejected it and pushed for a monarchy because they liked the system in place. Iran’s government has spread its influence all over the region through proxy militias that destabilize their government and societies and give Iran influence over them. What are you talking about? How is Iran imperialistic? Look at Lebanon, Syria, the way it bleeds its own ethnic minorities dry to fund expanding its influence.

Fekr

And in what world do the Iranian people go out to fight for change and not get gunned down at this point? I wasn’t in favor of intervention before January, but when that many people are massacred, what option do we have?

ahmed nat

Sad how brainwashed by the west the middle class fuck boys complaining about coffee prices and not being able to game are. They've got it tough for sure. I'm saying this as an Iranian living abroad who knows how lucky I am. But they refuse to see that the country dropping bombs on them and destroying their economy with sanctions are the primary problem. And that environment (of constantly being at war, physically or otherwise) is what allows authoritarian extremist governments to stay in power.

ahmed nat

I'm Iranian diaspora. The loony trump supporting Iranians in LA don't speak for us all

Fekr

Ahmed Nat, I feel you dude. Seriously, I don’t like them being the image of an Iranian diaspora either. But can you say that you know many Iranians in the country that don’t want to see the end of the regime? Thats the main part in this video I find lacking. Summing it up as saying most people don’t want to see the regime change.

lolheyaj

I think you need to read between the lines, you seemed to have missed the broader message of the videos and are hyper focused on one statement, that, from the journalists perspective in that moment is true. There's obviously more to what's being presented that isn't being overtly stated. It's a journalists job to capture and present facts as they are able to. Not to hound people for some story that they believe to be true in some Alex Jones-type way. It's pretty obvious the youth wants change, and has an almost impossibly massive hurdle in the way of it.

Ramsey Bouhiyate

would you say as an Iranian you still have an appreciation for islam and stuff? I know this is somewhat random, but im Moroccan-American, and most moroccans I know including myself still love our religion and islam despite having left Morocco or not living in a muslim country. However, with most Persians and Iranians they have a very different view, so im just curious

Shayan Sasani

The audacity to call someone Mossad and multiple fuck offs to say I’ve held my tongue. Hey pal, you don’t know anything about Iran, all you know is whats been spoon fed you by these ayatollahs.

Ramtin Sirjani

I hope the people who appeared on camera remain safe and that the IRGC/morality police have enough to keep them busy such that they don’t make an effort to seek them out and torture them. I wonder how Andrew was even able to experience the country without the government. It’s not explained how that happened or even could happen. Few people who hold power in nations actually care about their people, whether it’s in america or in Iran. It’s a terrible economic situation there and it’s clear the majority of the population is held hostage. In america it’s also true that drugs are employed to do similar things more covertly. One just controls through violence and fear and the other through sedation. Obviously those facts can be used to galvanize hate. Both sides suck and really it’s not about America vs. Iran. It’s about people with decision making power through ownership and wealth manipulating a narrative to amass more wealth and power. Our leaders only care for us to the extent to which it gets us to shut up and obey. As such, we should try to love each other. Pray for the people who are subjugated through fear, dying and poor being bombed in iran. Also pray for us in the west who are subjugated through drugs, sex, calories, algorithms, and excess as the wealth gap widens and we devolve into illiterate incompetent slaves.

ahmed nat

I don't want to speak on behalf of all Iranians. Personally I don't follow any religion but am attracted to the spirituality behind them. By the way, I was in Morocco for 6 months last year and loved it. As someone who was born in Iran, but didn't grow up there, I found it quite nice to be in a culture that felt familiar to my familial upbringing. Muslim culture was a part of that. For example growing up I would fast, but I was in a country where that wasn't normal. It was cool being in a country where everyone was fasting

Tory McArthur

You are the shit Andrew! Channel 5 worldwide!

SOGGYSLOTH

3 seperate videos of straight parroting CIA talking points... Held my tongue til now... If you don't like getting called Mossad, then don't support their fucking guy for Iran man. Lolololol

SOGGYSLOTH

*Class Consciousness as always*

R

431n is actually legit amazing holy shit

Alex R

I think the key note was a regime change *supported by the US*, because Iranians aren't stupid, they've seen what happens to countries who experience regime change supported by the US. It ends up being another colonial vassal state that is just pillaged repeatedly by Western wealthy elite at the expense of everyone else in the country. They want sovereignty and independence, freedom for themselves, and my guess is that should a regime change happen as a result of US action, it would be worse than a regime change that happened through the result of Iranian protests.

Ramsey Bouhiyate

would you say as an Iranian you still have an appreciation for islam and stuff? I know this is somewhat random, but im Moroccan-American, and most moroccans I know including myself still love our religion and islam despite having left Morocco or not living in a muslim country. However, with most Persians and Iranians they have a very different view, so im just curious. I don't really appreciate it when the diaspora demonizes our religion and our books as if the majority of the muslim world is like that.

Afta Hill

I was born in Tehran and raised in Canada. I haven't been back since I was 14 (15 years ago) and this video made me miss it. The youth in Iran are incredible smart and resourceful. It's a massive shame that it isn't covered more. You have no idea how important this video is. It humanizes my fellow Iranians, and shows a side of these people that isn't often available anywhere else! thanks guys, great work!

Brandon Birgani

As an Iranian American and part of the diaspora; you are absolutely wrong. The majority of the diaspora only speak for themselves and don’t care about anyone but themselves.

Fekr

It’s complicated I guess. The same way I feel about Christianity for the most part. There’s lots of beauty and I know many people of both religions, the majority obviously, are really beautiful people and I appreciate what the religions mean for them. But also there’s often a level of complicity in not wanting to speak out against extremism enough. But do I think the Adnan is beautiful? Of course, it can I appreciate a mosque for its beauty, or Muslim poetry? Absolutely. But I also wish more Muslims would speak out against what’s happening in Iran. When the basij set up interrogation headquarters in mosques, or the religion is used to push all the awful treatment we see of women, etc. And for the record it’s the same kind of criticism I’d lobby at christians just on a more extreme scale.

Jennifer

Great job Andrew. I agree with Fekr's criticism that you cant really conclude that the people dont support regime change. As someone with family in iran, it seems to me that isnt true. Also, idk how true it is that youll be fine if youre just "going about your day" — ik people who left within the last ten years who said they were regularly harassed by police, e.g if their hijab was slightly off. Otherwise, your commentary and editing present a perspective that counters both IR and US propaganda.

Erick Mejia

IM not suprised that the average gen z doesnt care about a regime change. I think were all at a point where we've seen varyign different people in power and nothing change that a lot of us have realized it doesnt really matter WHO the leader is. They may make things slightly better under new managment, but eventually their going to fuck up too because all leaders are just interested in making things better for themselves first and better for their citizens somwhere around last

Jennifer

Also, the captions were mostly good but def some inaccuracies. Go over them again with someone bilingual (i can help if you want). Itd also be nice to have translated captions at 15:43 with the background chatter

HandsomeSubliminalBull

Dear Glowie: People who live in a country with their jobs, families and friends, generally do not want regime change for the "greater good". Fuck you and your comment

Madi Thompson

Fekr I agree with you. My fiance is in Tehran away from me here in the states, so let me be his voice. And the voice of his family. His family is very pro regime change. When I compare my daily problems to his, objectively, my life is much easier and we are rooted in the production field. He’s more talented than me and even got into Berkeley for it but the regime captured him, questioned him, and confiscated his gear for making goth music and perusing music professionally. His life is uprooted. His businesses thwarted, first his true passion by the regime, now his tech businesses by sanctions. He is literally the most talented hardworking and capable man I’ve met, and he is systemically screwed over. He just wants to live his life. Yes, Iranians are highly educated, including women, but guess what their plans always are? To leave so they can be artists, be adjacent to art, or simply live normal lives working in their field of expertise. When Andrew said “yeah I feel pretty hopeless too,” I don’t think he understands the LEVEL of hopelessness Iranians feel. Andrew is traveling. He’s working as an interviewer. He can say what he wants, criticize his government with minimal issues aside from jail. Iran isn’t like this. Iranian passport holders have absolutely 0 mobility. It’s the worst in the world. And at home they can be hung from cranes. Killed. The women are often taken into custody and raped or sexually assaulted, sometimes to death. Women can’t even wear swimsuits to the beach. The fear is real. They let the partying slide a bit but the criticizing the government part, you better not be seen publicly talking about that or you’re dead meat. I can only try to understand what my fiance feels right now. The thing w America, we are heavily armed, so our government can only do but so much to subjugate us. Iranians aren’t armed at all and their church and state is not separate. As soon as he was born my fiance was labeled a Muslim. If we have a kid, because the father is a legal Muslim, same thing will happen if we’re not punished for having a child outside of a marriage. Which, we can’t marry there unless I convert. My fiance is not a Muslim, but if he publicly says this he can get killed or jailed for apostasy. He knows many people who were killed in the protests. My biggest critique of this trilogy is, Andrew was clearly north Korea’d by Iran, and that didn’t set off enough alarm bells. He wasn’t critical enough of Iran and was wrong to compare it to America and conclude life is just as hard in the USA. You have to understand this is clerical fascism. A brutal military and clerical leadership.

Grushenka Odegard

What was that black metal band called? I tried to understand what he was saying or look it up but I can't find it.

pabloqpacin

Muchas gracias Channel 5

# Tjark

wonderful continuation. hope to see more storytelling and timeline continuation (since the timeline and storytelling was so emphasized in the 2nd ep) in the final cut. i wanna know a bit of background, where did you meet these people, how did the feeling change, was the iranian guard present at some of these interviews? if yes for which interviews where they there? how did you shake them? still i am very happy you got the chance to continue ur work the c5 way and find some true and partly honest opinions on the streets of tehran!

ahmed nat

Fekr, I don't think he had a biased view though. He did talk to some real ones on the street. Yes there's a decent amount of people in Iran who in general want regime change, but that's the problem with this war, it does create the space for an authoritarian to regime to become irreplaceable. So when an American journalist, in the middle of a war imposed by America, asks if you want regime change, there's a lot implied by that question which they are responding to. Regime change through an external war means giving up your country

Fekr

Ahmed Nat, how can you take their response to Andrew asking them, on camera, in front of a regime agent, who will literally have them arrested and tortured if not killed, if they answer otherwise as anything worth anything. The only honest answer he got was from the person with the hidden identity, who quite clearly had a lot more to say, that they didn’t feel safe sharing and had already suffered the consequences of expressing. So where’s the conclusion coming from? What’s it based on? It feels irresponsible a premise not supported by the actual content of the video.

Fekr

Also, personally, I don’t understand how you blame this war for the regime being “irreplaceable”. The regime being willing to machine gun armed civilians for protesting and then going into the hospitals to hunt down the people who treated them. Thats what keeps the regime in power. I’m not saying this to be snarky. I just sincerely, don’t understand how you imagine they’ll change their minds if sanctions ended or how the war that happened after that somehow… caused it? I’ve been actively protesting this regime since 2009 and the green movement. I’ve said before but I wasn’t in favor of war before January. Idk if I want to say I AM in favor of war. But at the same time, this is an inevitable outcome of the way this regime has governed. What they’ve prioritized and what they want. I just wish people cared about Iran before the war. But people didn’t rally for us when Mahsa died and all the people died fighting after her. They didn’t rally during January. They called us Mossad agents. So if a war is going to happen, let’s see it through. And honestly, the Palestinians and others who live under the rule of the regime’s proxies suffer more and more the longer Iran gets away with playing this sleight of hand game. The status quo is abhorrent, and walking away from it solves absolutely nothing. Edited for clarity

Fekr

I want to add one other thing for the sake of context, since my comment is getting a lot of reactions, to hopefully clarify something I’ve tried to get across, probably unsuccessfully to a lot of the comment section. I just want to express that I understand how saying anything sympathetic to the Shah comes off to a western audience. I get that there are a lot of crazy monarchists out there who see the shah as a some saint. He was definitely brutal and flawed in ways that almost definitely helped lead to where we are today. However, what is always left out in the historical narrative is the parts played by everyone other than the Shah and the US. People seem to believe that the communists and mullahs were just some organic grass roots movement, when they were funded and backed by the Soviets. And again, people here will react like the Soviets threat to Iranian sovereignty during this time, is comparable to the threat it posed the US. But Iran shared a border with the USSR. It had fought to maintain independence from Russia. As well as Britain, who also works to fund dissent and fracture unity in Iran. This is coming off of the heels of ww1 where the British and Russians seized so much food fighting each other in Iran that millions starved to death. Also the British and the Mullahs legitimately gave Reza Shah, the first Pahlavi, no choice but to make a monarchy. They literally stopped him from creating a republic. So in this context, the shah’s decisions to align with the US and use the as a balance to British and Soviet influence is understandable. His decision that keeping communisms influence at bay, when you look at the way other Soviet neighbors went, is understandable. And I’d understand why people criticize that decision! The same with the mullah’s, who were funded by France eventually, and we see what they wanted for the country. And Mossadegh was tied up with both the communist movement and the mullah’s. His party was involved in assignation attempts. The Shah was shot by a man linked to that party as well as the Islamists. Mossadegh attempted to dissolve parliament and the oil nationalization issue was more about leveraging connections at the right time as to not bankrupt the country. And in the end we saw what nationalization led to. So do I adore the Shah? Fuck no! But goddamn this one sided telling of history is just dangerous. Why would you trust people who are smart enough to know the whole story and keep parts of it from you? (That’s not a dig at AC, but it is a dig on the professor we keep hearing from). Like the way I ca criticize America without loosing sight of the fact that Iran isn’t anti imperialistic. We gotta start holding two or four truths in our minds.

Link Winky

I always wonder how accurate the captions are.

venturight

Interesting context! I've been lurking watching people's reactions to ur comments through the series. has been interesting. The nature of modern discourse is the internet, and nuance is not the nature of the internet. I know people were dumb before the internet too, but i really dont think we'll be able to hold two or four truths in our minds until we stop having our discussion in threads with like buttons. which is to say, thanks for your comments, it's been interesting to read, but also, you're wasting your time, and keep it up lol.

m0rt

It sounds like the people living there are making a difference, despite the danger. This is an interesting discussion and i appreciate hearing the different takes; but i have to say what i find ridiculous is believing the US will do anything for the people of Iran. It's no different from believing what the regime says. Look at Americas history, look at Gaza, our native reservations; that is your future under america's "aid" this is what the US have always done, beyond the killing they will erase and water down your culture, while they exploit it and take any agency left and extract your resources. It's not hard to understand why people who left the country would find regime change and war easier to accept, you don't have to be the one to die for it.

Fekr

I guess I understand why you might find it hard to comprehend, but it’s truly born out of desperation. You talk about having your culture watered down. Well, currently women aren’t allowed to sing in public. Multiple high profile cases of woman, recently, lashed and arrested for live performances of folk songs. The language is being systematically pushed toward Arabic, because it’s the language of Islam. This stuff sounds ridiculous it’s so crazy. Many in Iran view the regime as an occupying force. It currently sends their resources to keep Gaza at war. Again, to be clear, that doesn’t whitewash everything Israel and the US has done. But Iranians in the country are already living under the conditions you’re threatening. And I guess I can’t imagine the US enforcing any of the archaic laws the regime does. But lastly, do people think I’m advocating for any of this while my family or friends oppose it? Like that’s the crazy part I don’t understand when I talk to people. I don’t take any joy from advocating this stuff. I agree with them and I see why people feel the way they do, but this all comes from a very sad, cold math of watching massacre after massacre, protest and reform movement and movement and seeing that the regime actually doesn’t care. We didn’t start here. And as a someone on the left in America, we aren’t really offering anything but thoughts and prayers, while treating the Iranians like they’re too naive to understand that the US isn’t coming because they’re such amazing good hearted people. Sorry for the long winded response, and thanks for taking the time to read all of that.

S S

Andrew your translations subtitles need severe improvement, Your English dub is good but, I put the video on for my parents as I do most my videos and they weren't impressed, as they speak English and Farsi fluently. PS I forgot but they offered to do translation work for free from Iran war 1, and I said I would ask and forgotten.

SOGGYSLOTH

It appears I was wrong. You are not bad faith. You are just losing hope. I'm sorry brother. Everyday comrades and I struggle for revolution here in the belly of the beast. I understand deeply that without stopping the US/Israel imperialist machine. That the greatest existential threat to safety and life of of Iranian people is exactly them, the US veto backing Israeli Zionist aggression. The reasons are quite a few. But I want to highlight one aspect please. While this threat exists, any attempt to revolution, weakens the state to a point that leaves you open to invasion and foreign domination. I understand deeply that the freedom of the people of the periphery, like Iran, or Palestine, or North Africa, West Africa, AES etc. Is dependent not only on the people in those respective nations/states. But on the people in the Imperial Core to allow the space for the people to be free. In order to effectively defeat the IRGC, and install a proper state. The IRGC betrayed the revolution. I have no sympathy for them in regards. I'm not a supporter. But I do recognize what role they play unfortunately. And at the moment. It's clear, that after assassinations, they are still not going anywhere. Which means. The Original point stands. Peace in Middle East, Stability. Allows the people to actually stop being a militarized society on brink of existential war.... It's horrific the shit the IRGC has done. From original betrayals to modern day atrocities. However the devastation that will come from a US invasion, will be so bad, and the end results will not be better than the current status quo at all. I'm not lying, I say this with love for the people in Iran who desire to be free and the Diaspora that wishes to go home. But I'm getting really annoyed and frustrated with the support for invasion, when it's obviously the WRONG decision. *If we can in good faith settle the Israeli Issue. Then we can easily deal with IRGC. But to try and police the IRGC while the isrealis conline genocide and attacks on Iran is completely missing the actual cause* **didn't yall come real close in a strike, but the oil workers didn't join? Which is what led to a bit of the retaliation by the state? Seems like yall are close but just need peacetime to actually be given space to work this out with grassroots honest aid from international working class community** ***also, you lost thousands of future revolutionary people in latest attempt, yall need to slow down and regroup. Replan. Not immediately just be reactionary and say "fuck it"" I guess a monarch and Complete foreign control of our economy is fine". Yall need to regroup and not fall victim to despair and despotic behavior*** ****it's bit wild to me to seek help from the US, whom are committing Genocide to your neighbors, its one thing to say regime change and beg France (hasn't veto in like 40 years) or China etc. But to position with the hedgemonic imperialist committing Genocide with absolute no accountability because the UN is a joke, is just a suicidal position imo that I honestly can't believe is a serious position held by people, but I digress****

SkullzCrew

Yeah, I'm impressed by the coverage but it's very clear that people are not willing to express their political views on camera

Ivo Vretenarov

I think, anyone remotely compassionate, human and not a sociopath can disern the fact that the interivews were done under some sort of duress inflicted onto the interviewee. Andrew as the interviewer just asks the questions, and is infact respectful to how much one is willing to share or say. It is up to the viewer to digest and come up with their own conclusion . Your conclusion and my conclusion anrent disimillar, but somehow you wanted the "perfect" intreview, but if he could have the perfect interview there would be no opression probably no war and no need for an interview. I dont know maybe im just dumb.

Jazzbea

Interesting piece.

Vincent_swag

I noticed Fams really documented a lot of the Iranian women (as b-roll) in this one? Anyone else notice that? Maybe they were trying to convey how beautiful the Iranian women are. I thought it was actually so interesting how established their infrastructure looked. Like the town planning and gardens in the city looked beautiful. Really surprised me. The young Iranian people in general all looked quite stylish and seem to carry a beautiful and calming energy. The classism is so apparent worldwide and we’re all feeling the weight of the exploitation. When and will the revolution come?

Honeyeah

Thank you Andrew for doing all the work to get our voice outside of Iran. However, I don't think you captured everybody's voice, at least not equally. I feel like you painted a picture of a changing Iran, hijab restrictions vanishing, and women ride motorcycles now. So it's all great. They wear crop tops and listen to western music. I was quite shocked when you made the conclusion that the majority of people don't want regime change. Women's rights in Iran is more than just riding motorcycles. There is child marriage still. The law does not protect women in any form. And I am not sure if the morality police won't come back. It is not the first time that the regime loosens some strings to calm people down. Once they don't need the support of the people anymore (maybe when war is over) they will come back again. Or they might. I definitely hope they won't. But unfortunately this regime has taught me to not be hopeful. I was also shocked of how you did not say a word about the person who told you he was "tortured". He told you if he says more words it will cost him his life. So in an environment like this, how can you expect people to really tell you they want regime change, if they do? Of course regime change is not easy. I do not see any good option in front of us. Of course I would have hoped that things would get better just by reformations. But we have been disappointed way too many times. Was is terrible. I personally do not want war. But I don't want our story, and years and years of suffering under this regime to be neglected just because we don't want war right now.

oneofmanykyles

My heart breaks that they are afraid to speak freely. I pray everyone gets to feel that freedom in their lifetime. We take it heavily for granted in America.

K T

It was incredibly clear to see people wouldn't put their face next to political beliefs. Would you in a country where they may behead you for less?

sara v

9:20... so sad that our generation feels this way globally. i am so glad you created this episode but i really feel it would have been so much more impactful if you put it on your main channel available to the world. you mention in your video you felt slightly guilty of possibly falling for the global media's depiction of iran and young iranian society, but by not making the video accessible to a wider audience i do feel you may be inadvertently contributing to that

sara v

Unless maybe this is how your upload schedule works and this is going to go live on main later sorry I just subbed to watch this video.

Jack

Do Russia next

Marius Andresen

@AndrewCallaghan, maybe Iranian dissidents would like to speak to you from the diaspora in the US. They like Israel obviously as Israel is helping them in their struggle. Try Reza Pahlavi, Goldie Ghamari or Armin Navabi. if you are interested

E.R.

431n is pretty sick if you're into dark ambient!

Marius Andresen

would love to see this released on your youtube

Birds Person

AC you had me f'd up for a minute with the maroon hoody; thought it was a Wildwood boardwalk hoody in Iran i was about to be so proud

Fekr

Besides Pahlavi, those would be examples of the more extreme aspects of our opposition. Not that they’re not worth interviewing, but definitely not an example of moderates. I could find some of the smaller folks and orgs that were vocal during wlf and the January uprising, if AC would be interested in some of those. Moj Mahdara comes to mind. She started the Iranian Diaspora Collective and has been a moderate voice. Mahsi Alinejad is another activist who’s had assassination attempts from the regime. Those are two that come to mind immediately but there are a lot of smaller activists and folks online that aren’t so inflammatory and borderline Islamophobic.

Fekr

Bahador Alast would have been great to talk to in the Vancouver video, or he might be Toronto based, but he’s done amazing work, as well as Kiarash Kian, who’s pushing more toward the nationalist side, but also very pro democracy. Nazanin Nour. Not all of these people would agree either, but they’re all a lot better communicators than people like Goldie, or not as inflammatory as Atheist Republic. Oh Omid Jalali would be another good one.

Duterte Whitaker

You stuck the landing @AC. A huge risk going outside the IGRC narrative to the outskirts of Tehran to get more candid interviews. The unanswered questions and self censorship speak volumes. Great work @c5!

Bjorn

Man this was a good series but idk how you can list out a sheet of repressive laws, a widespread massacre, and acknowledge you’ve been taken on a blatant propaganda tour and come out of that concluding that people don’t want to do away with the entities causing that. Where on Earth would economic troubles alone be enough to motivate hundreds of thousands of protestors to stare down the barrels of armed militias, get gunned down by the thousands, then go right back out the next day?

Marius Andresen

Javid Shah, be pish. In akharin nabarde, Pahlavi barmigarde

SOGGYSLOTH (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-24 06:00 It's extremely naive to believe the United States, responsible for multiple genocides. Is smart to have as an ally. When we know the United States slaughters its allies at any perceived inconvenience. In the words of Kissinger. "Word should be gotten to Nixon that if Thieu meets the same fate as Diem, the word will go out to the nations of the world that it may be dangerous to be America's enemy, but to be America's friend is fatal." They are willing and have shown the ability to commit genocide multiple times. Yet you seen so eager to trust them. It's suicidal
2026-09-23 11:56 It's extremely naive to believe the United States, responsible for multiple genocides. Is smart to have as an ally. When we know the United States slaughters its allies at any perceived inconvenience. In the words of Kissinger. "Word should be gotten to Nixon that if Thieu meets the same fate as Diem, the word will go out to the nations of the world that it may be dangerous to be America's enemy, but to be America's friend is fatal." They are willing and have shown the ability to commit genocide multiple times. Yet you seen so eager to trust them. It's suicidal. We need to organize to stop the biggest threat first. The USA. Then the material conditions will be set for the people of the world to deal with their own despotic regimes! But to aid the USA, will not aide yourselves. Only sign your death warrant. We must work together. Organize international solidarity against invasions, against war. Organizing internatoral strikes that demand hands off. Which if completed, we will no longer have to deal with the material condition for the IRGC to remain in power. It's the safest, most effective, smartest, most strategic move forward. Violence isn't the answer

It's extremely naive to believe the United States, responsible for multiple genocides. Is smart to have as an ally. When we know the United States slaughters its allies at any perceived inconvenience. In the words of Kissinger. "Word should be gotten to Nixon that if Thieu meets the same fate as Diem, the word will go out to the nations of the world that it may be dangerous to be America's enemy, but to be America's friend is fatal." They are willing and have shown the ability to commit genocide multiple times. Yet you seen so eager to trust them. It's suicidal. We need to organize to stop the biggest threat first. The USA. Then the material conditions will be set for the people of the world to deal with their own despotic regimes! But to aid the USA, will not aide yourselves. Only sign your death warrant. We must work together. Organize international solidarity against invasions, against war. Organizing internatoral strikes that demand hands off. Which if completed, we will no longer have to deal with the material condition for the IRGC to remain in power. It's the safest, most effective, smartest, most strategic move forward. Violence isn't the answer

Walker S

My girlfriend's best friend is Iranian. I went partying with her and a group of Iranians the day Khamenei was killed. My impression is that a lot of them are very anti-Islamic regime and were initially very happy about US involvement, but their support for that has lessened as the fighting drags on and they've seen how it's negatively impacting their families. I'm very conflicted about this issue and really don't know how to feel. I'd love if there was a part 4 where he interviews expats to see what their opinions across the board are

Juan Gutierrez

Years ago, some of my closest friends were Iraninas whom I met in a neighboring country and with whom I shared great times and gained much perspective. People who themselves participated in the Hijab protests after the killing of Mahsa Amini. I'm Latin American, so of course much of our conversations revolved around venting about our domestic politics. It is certain they don't like their government or its policies; and that they want new leadership; but not one person said they wanted or needed to be saved. Not a single one said they wanted to be more like America or taken under its wing. In fact, they said the contrary. Iranians who actually live in Iran don't want to be invaded for their freedom. Maybe the miscommunication comes from the fact that in America, when they say "regime change" it means having a foreign power come in and force one on the local population. I don't know if you were aware of this in which case I hope that clears things up a bit. But the regime change Iranians want comes from within Iran. They want to take the power back from the corrupt; not become anyone's subjects. It's not as though the people taking the streets do so completely unawares, they are determined and brave and well aware they could die when they do so. I always have empathy for diasporas on a human level. I can understand seeing the place one's family came from in dire straits and wanting to see it fixed and to return. But diasporas have a tendency to not be totally in touch with the popular domestic sentiment. Their understanding of the story often stops at the point they left their country behind. And unfortunately, the perspective is often colored by having benefited from regimes and systems that were overthrown by popular demand, putting them at odds with the people who stayed right from the very start. Not saying your perspective doesn't have value, but it's not more representative of Iranians than that of the people who actually experience Iran. The diaspora's views are just that...the diaspora's.

Erik Karki

It’s a trip that young people know who GG Allin is but it’s INSANE that he has fans in Iran.

Duterte Whitaker

@Fekr you make a strong point. There were plenty of questions that were unanswered out of self preservation but I suspect even avoiding answering a question on regime change could put these citizens at risk. Case in point: when that woman flashed her arm tattoos the police swooped in immediately to shut down the interview because they were always nearby. And even in a dark alley, the guy cut off the interview from fear of being reapprehended and tortured. Andrew may have missed the mark on that last point but I'm mostly disappointed in how quickly other Patreons tried to shut down your argument. Andrew has built a career on radical acceptance yet that sentiment doesn't carry over to the comments section.

Fekr

Hey Juan, thanks for the thoughtful reply. I want to clarify. The diaspora’s isn’t ’more’ valuable than that of the people in Iran. It’s the fact that as a journalist, in Iran, you won’t get to hear their opinion. So in this particular case, you’re be better off listening to diaspora voices. Not as an end to the conversation, but really as the start of it. Because the people being interviewed by western media cannot be honest. Period. Start by hearing out the diaspora and you’ll have a much better understanding of Iran to build off and see through the regime propaganda as well as the west’s.

Duterte Whitaker

I've spoken to quite a few diaspora Persians about this in the last couple of years, some Jewish, some Muslim , some non-religious and even a friend who is a devout Twelver Shia. The common denominator is that the regime must change (though not necessarily "regime change" depending on who you ask).

Fekr

Duterte, that’s the picture I get as well. I was wondering how much the semantics of regime change played into his statement as well, in the way you mentioned. Almost no one wants a new govt imposed, many see intervention as necessary(preferably from a coalition not the way it’s been happening), and some don’t want any foreign intervention. But almost everyone wants the government to change. Reputable sources like Gaman put the number around 80%, and turn out rates in the last election, amid campaigns that encouraged people to abstain from the last vote to protest, pointed toward even lower support for the regime. Who knows where it’s at now. I support intervention under Right to Protect with a coalition of allies and a plan for democratic transition. But that’s a pretty far way from where this conflict has gone, and it’s not at all surprising with Trump at the helm. When it comes to something like the January massacres, the truth is we don’t know how many people died. And without access we won’t. But at what point does the international community have a responsibility to act in more than words? I don’t mean that rhetorically, I think it’s a question more of us need to ask. Intervention has stopped killing in the past.

AJ

I think it's flatly absurd to say that the "the only people who have an honest perspective is the diaspora." What we see with the Cuban-American diaspora is the LEAST honest perspective.

Fekr

You know that for about half of the people you’re describing, you could swap the word diaspora for refugees, right? So you’re saying that refugees are just liars and propagandists. Refugees who have family in their home countries. The other half you’re just saying the children of refugees. So Mexican refugees liars? African? Chinese? Palestinian? What happened to listening to minorities? I’m not saying listen to one. I’m saying listen to them all more and contend with the complexity of what they’ll present you.

Thomas Payne

I was offered to go, but I turnt it down

ssbgoblin

Man I hope you do an interview with Iranian diaspora and get their perspective too. It was obvious that the people with negative opinions about the IRGC were not comfortable saying so on camera. Great video anyway though, it was wild to see the lack of hijabs and the motorcycles

Venezuela212

All political atrocities aside, Iran got hella baddies bro damn

CartmanDude 1

By the way, some of the largest humanitarian issues today were directly caused by Irans actions, pinning everything on the U.S. is wrong. For example Yemen and Syria, Syrias war was starting first through infighting and then the Assad regime went to Iran for help and they got that help. 900,000 people died, and MILLIONS were displaced (And now Israel is bombing Syria because they don’t like their current leadership, what a shit show), and Yemen, 377,000 deaths and millions displaced, mostly due to Iranian funding of the Houthis. I meant it’s ridiculous to blame all the problems in the Middle East on strictly Israel and the U.S. in my opinion, both Iran AND Israel are the biggest disrupters in the Middle East. In modern times at least, Israel mostly targets Palestinians and Lebanon and now Houthi controlled Yemen and Syria. And Iran focuses on its own citizens, Israel, the Kurds, and other muslim minorities, with some action in Syria and Pakistan.

Duterte Whitaker

100% @Cartman. Syria, Iran and to some extent Saudi Arabia seem to get a pass. Not sure if this is ignorance, low key racism or perhaps a bit of both

Stompythebeast

For what it’s worth, I agree with you. I’m sure Andrew will too.

Dylan Hens

mightve been worth going over the fact that the reason many people lost income isnt just due to the Iranian Regime shutting down the internet, but rather due to how the US sanctions on Iran work. If you conduct any business or transact with any account related to Iran or based there, you are immediately locked out of the global market. The US is trying to Collectively punish the people of Iran for the actions of its government, while simultaneously strengthening the current regimes control

Justin Smith

This was fantastic man thank you

Jpetrie

Fuck I would bless a person in Iran with a year of vpn service so they can get on the internet

Nick B

She had such beautiful responses

Arnaud

Awesome episode. It's so great to have the story from the real Iranian's youth. I just wished it would have been earlier in the serie. I hope that the message sticking from those episode will be this one and not the propaganda from the first episodes. Still, congratulation on making this. It's incredible work.

Zachary

Motorcycle chick is a gottdam smoke show, I'll join up to fight the regime for her.

Zatch

Andrew, give me a job!

Nick Shortt

You are one hell of a journalist Andrew.

3a10x12

Stay in the game pupa

parsa ferdowsi

cool. you covered regime's propaganda and the rich. hope you will do more.

Shaheen A

It’s obvious that don’t support the regime buddy, relax. Just because you wanted him to say they do doesn’t make it true. I’m Iranian and have been there myself multiple times and have never met anyone that actually supports them. I assume by your name that you’re also iranian which is surprising that you even have this view.