An Update: My Call With Patreon's CEO (and Many New Thoughts) (Patreon)
Content
I’m sorry that this follow-up is coming a late in the day and on the verge of the weekend, but I didn’t want to let my promise to further fill you all in slip through the cracks.
(If you're confused by this post and need context, my post from yesterday, which can be found here, will fill you in.)
This morning, for about 40 minutes, I spoke on the phone with Patreon CEO Jack Conte. I’m fond of Jack. I think he’s a good guy, and he’s a hard worker. My old company, Kinda Funny, was one of Patreon’s first success stories, and we launched our first Patreon way back in 2014, so needless to say, I’m quite familiar with and fond of Jack and his team for all they’ve done for me. My life would look a lot different without them and their service, and at the end of our conversation today, I told Jack that, from my perspective, the personal hatred and vitriol being thrown his way, and towards his team, is unacceptable. Please don't contribute to any of that. It isn't right, it isn't helpful, and it isn't kind.
All of that said, I think Patreon made an enormous mistake a few days ago by trifling with the transaction fee systems that rest at the heart of their service, and I issued my reservations to Jack in a strong and direct manner. The fact is this: Colin’s Last Stand has resisted and rebuffed most every opportunity to further monetize outside of Patreon, and it has done so deliberately. It has done so by trusting that Patreon would do right by both its creators and its essential base of Patrons, and allow me to cultivate my business without any surprises, without any caltrops being dropped in my path. It’s a relationship of trust, and the breakdown of that relationship -- and of this service -- would kill CLS. I don’t think what has happened here represents a permanent breakdown, but I do think it represents a momentary lapse. That much is obvious. And it sucks.
I’d be lying to you if I told you that I didn’t get off the phone with Jack this morning not understanding far better what the company’s intentions are with these changes. From a 40,000 foot view, I understand why it, as a company, chose to go in this direction. I simply think that going in this direction is the wrong call, and I firmly believe that, in my own experience on Patreon, the company is attempting to solve for a set of problems that have been literally non-existent. The claim is that there is confusion among the ranks of Patrons about how they’re charged, and that there is a growing need to move to a literal subscription service where you’re charged each month on the date you first sign-up. This would bring Patreon in line with normal subscription services, like Netflix or Spotify, but the thing is, Patreon isn’t a normal subscription service. Furthermore, this manufactures transaction fees up the yin-yang, especially for those who support many Patreons. If they move to this type of subscription model (as opposed to charging people on the first of the month) and didn’t change how fees worked, creators could potentially lose a catastrophic amount of money far in excess of what we’re losing by shedding subs.
My argument against this is that the system was serving CLS -- and seemingly many other large Patreons -- perfectly fine as-is. Colin’s Last Stand has been lucky to partake in back-end betas on Patreon that help test functionality and cultivate data to study, and one of those betas back around when CLS was born was that CLS Patrons would be charged when they signed up, and then on the first of every month thereafter. This, according to Patreon, has caused massive confusion elsewhere on the service, enough so that the entire fee structure needed to be heavily disrupted to solve for it. This might be true, but it wasn’t causing any problems on my end. I may be mistaken, but I’m pretty sure there have been zero complaints from CLS Patrons about this, at least not to me, and I correspond regularly with my supporters. I’ve refunded people who fell on hard times, I’ve delivered some postcards, credit appearances, and the like a little late to a few people by accident, and I dealt as evenly as I could with the fallout surrounding Lauren Southern’s ouster from Patreon, an ouster, by the way, that also cost me. But I’ve not seen any feedback from my supporters indicating that they were confused by the subscription structure as it stood, and I never once told them I wanted them to cover my fees within that system as it was.
You may remember that, the first time I was on Joe Rogan’s podcast, I spoke about how I expected the Patreon to fall from the insane heights it reached when I quit Kinda Funny, and that I expected a new baseline to eventually materialize. Maybe it’d be a thousand Patrons. Maybe two or three. Thing is, it ended up being more like four and a half or so. The last 45 days have finally shown a plateau -- and even a small growth -- after months of a natural, expected, and unavoidable decline. Patreon’s decision to mess with a good thing has interrupted and erased that momentum. I’m not going to sit here and blame those who left for this. You have every right to speak with your wallet. I’ve encouraged you to do so 10,000 times over the last decade. But understand how frustrating this is for me. How upsetting it is. I was feeling so good the last month or so, so excited that I finally gained some predictability, so eager to chase the future with what I thought was a solidified foundation. I’m sad about this, guys. I’ll get over it. Maybe I’ll recover what I’ve lost. Hopefully, I’ll even begin to grow again. But, for right now, in this time, I’m bummed to see my numbers falling through no fault of my own. It’s a powerless feeling, because I don't know what else to do about it other than to talk to you, like I'm doing right now.
Perhaps this decision will ultimately be for the best. It certainly didn’t sound to me like they were willing to turn things around. I encouraged Jack to do a few things in the meantime, though, and I hope he does. Key amongst those suggestions were two ideas: That Patreon give existing creators the power to remain within the old system, under the old rules, and that Patreon immediately offer a mea culpa to all Patrons that have been shed across the service over the last 72 hours, better explaining what’s going on, and at least trying to encourage some of them to come back into the fold. Will they take my advice? I have no idea. But I promised that I’d advocate not only on my behalf, but on behalf of all of you who are so kind and generous in your support of me, and I hope I did that today.
Colin’s Last Stand, as a project, as an entity, needs Patreon to survive. I want the service to succeed, to persevere, to make the best possible decisions on behalf of all of us. More than anything, though, I want steadiness and predictability. To tell you the truth, as things started to settle down, and as the trio of shows I deliver continued to find an audience, I started to seriously think about bringing on some help early in the new year, help I desperately need to ultimately stay sane (because, as anyone in my life will tell you, I work way, way too much for my own health). I didn’t want to commit to that idea when I was declining, because I want to find a great person who can trust that they will have part or full-time employment for an extended period of time, and not be thrown to the wind, which wouldn't be fair to them. I was stoked to explore this opportunity for my business and for all of you, and was eager to see what that would do to the CLS as an overall product. Now, it seems I’ll need to wait on that a little longer, because uncertainty has been thrust into the situation once more.
I don’t for one second think Patreon wanted to mess this up. I don’t think they thought the outcome would be like this. Why would they sabotage their own business? This was an error, and hopefully it can be corrected without further damage being done across the service, damage I’ve witnessed firsthand not only from my own perspective, but by checking in on many other Patreons and seeing identical -- and sometimes even worse -- damage. All I can tell you is that I hope you choose to stick with me, choose to continue to support this show (or show support for it for the first time), and ride out the storm with me so we can see what the blue skies look like on the other side. Even though the amount of money my Patreon has lost because of this is minuscule, I've shed nearly 2% of my Patron base, and that means something to me. That shouldn't come as much of a surprise, I suppose, as I never asked to be given a bigger share of the cut to begin with. I want happy people through the door, whether you give me a dollar or month or a hundred dollars a month. You all matter to me. I know how hard many of you work. I know how important entertainment is to you. I am thankful for every penny, because none of you have to give me anything, but you choose to anyway. It brings tears to me eyes, how thousands of you have changed my life forever.
Many of you are unaffected by this, or simply don’t care. That's totally great. Ideal, even. But I understand why so many of you do care and are affected, and I understand why so many of you are choosing to walk. I just hope you know that I hear you, and while I can’t control the outcome of the situation, I can control the output of my content, and hope you continue to enjoy it, one way or another. I’m sorry, once more, if any of this affected you. There’s nothing more I can really do than sit back with the rest of you and see what happens next. Hopefully, whether or not all of this sticks, we look back at this moment as a hiccup in Patreon’s soon-to-be long history, and not something that sowed real and lasting disunion among an ecosystem of many, many thousands of creators and Patrons.
I hope you all have a fantastic weekend, and I thank you once more for your love, your support, and your patience. Your friend, -Colin