Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey, all! It's time to submit your questions, comments, concerns, thoughts, and ideas for Episode 306 of Defining Duke.

Great ways to get your write-up used: Be pithy, be topical, and be insightful. Walls-of-text, posts littered with poor grammar and punctuation, etc., are promptly (though respectfully) ignored.

As this is an Xbox podcast, be sure your submission makes sense within that realm. You have until Wednesday, November 11th at 3 PM ET to make your submission.

Comments

Raisin

Good day, Dukes! I wanted to get y'all's take on Shawn Layden's recent comments on The Trophy Room podcast pertaining to the potential price of PS6 and next-gen hardware. Shawn is right! We are at the point where only dogs can hear the difference. There's absolutely zero point in launching next-gen hardware if it's going to be $1,000+. We are on the precipice of, quite possibly, the biggest entertainment launch in all of human history with GTA VI, and they wanna sell brand-new hardware next year. Are PS6/Helix games going to look better than GTA VI? No! The answer's no! Hell, most PS5/Series S|X games don't even look better than Red Dead II. I'm honestly befuddled as to the point of next-gen. Screw your contracts with Foxconn. Honestly, the employees (and I use that term loosely) would probably appreciate not having to manufacture them. Shit, I don't even work at Foxconn, and I wanna jump out of a building at the thought of next-gen prices. At least they have suicide nets.

empty_0

Howdy Dukes. Bengals fan writing in to tell Matty how great my Sunday brunch was. History repeats: Despite Spain's neutrality, the Bird Reich ultimately falls to an all American front, in this case Burrow, Chase, and Tee. Must have been a long flight home. Have a "Steelers pack watch next" kind of day

Joseph La Russa

Hey Dukemen! I'm eating a chicken lo mein with no vegetables as I write this, which leads me to ask: what's your go-to Chinese food order? Does it vary for sit down vs take-out? Does it matter which spot you're eating at? For me, to-go is always my chicken lo mein, but when I sit down, I like to experiment a bit more. Thanks, or in the language of this topic: xièxiè!

Drew D

Hi Dukes, This message is for Cog. Thank you for recommending Star Wars Zero Company! I am not a big Xcom tactics guy, but the way you were talking about it gave me the push to check it out. I love it! I've been staying up way past my bedtime to he past few nights just to do one more Operation. My favorite part is how you can really build into having support characters generate AP for the party. It really makes the combat feel dynamic and involved. And the characters are great too, especially the Hawks voice actor. Thanks for the recommendation, and I hope you, Matty, and all of your people are well. Have a "JD and Turk wish they had half of what Matty and Cog have" kind of day! Best, Drew D

JP

Hey Dukes, It seems like EA wasn't enough and we now have reports of the Saudi Investment Fund and Silver Lake looking into acquiring Unity. You may remember Unity's proposed runtime fee from 2023 that would charge developers per game install. That certainly earned a lot of goodwill with the community. Well it's ingenuity like that to nickel and dime your customers that must have gotten Unity on the SIF and Silver Lake's radar as they try to wring every last cent out of the gaming community, no doubt to pay off their $20 billion junk bond they used to buyout EA. Interested to hear your thoughts on all this! Also shoutout to Matty for playing Tape to Tape. Game is sensational!

Tdot’s Finest82

Hey Dukes, Wanted to talk about a frustrating aspect of this Coalition budget discussion. I’m far from a GamePass apologist, I think there’s good and bad aspects to it. I’m not even an Xbox player, I game on PS5 Pro and PC. That said, some numbers to agree on: - over the 7 years between Gears games, Xbox has had roughly 30 million GamePass subs (some years more, some years less, averaging out) - those 30 million subs have been paying, conservatively, $10 a month (some pay more, some paid a buck a month for a stretch. Again, averaging out) - Xbox revenue strictly from GamePass is around $300 million per month, $3.6 billion a year - Coalition has cost Xbox roughly $80 million a year since 2019, if the $500 million number is true I’m sorry, but what’s the big deal here? This accounts for 2.2% of just GamePass annual revenue, not factoring any other revenue anywhere else. Is $500 million a lot of money? Sure is. But recovering that money through sales was never part of the deal, so people giving Xbox players shit for not supporting The Coalition is complete nonsense. Xbox players DO support Xbox and their studios, through the deal that was proposed way back when GamePass was introduced. That’s how Xbox players pay for Xbox games. To change the rules of engagement because the company is just starting to MAYBE move away from that deal, is grossly unfair to the Xbox community.

Mark Melton

What’s up my Dukes! Short question for you guys. Over or under 95 Metacritic score for GTA6. Keep up the great podcasts!

Kazden Risk

Hey Dukes, I saw Cog reacted to the news that James Gunn is out as co-CEO of DC Studios. What do we think of this update? I'm personally excited to see James Gunn return to more of a focused, filmmaker-only role rather than trying to juggle the responsibilities of being a co-CEO. Hopefully he can finish his vision for this Superman and I also hope we get Batman and Wonder Woman soon. Cheers and take care.

John Hanke

Hey Dukes! Have you heard of the game Queen's Domain, which seems to be gaining a lot of traction lately? It popped up in my Steam recommendations for only $20 last week, and after seeing all the positive feedback, I decided to pick it up. It's a throwback to the PS1 era with a retro fantasy aesthetic, apparently inspired by King's Field and early Elder Scrolls, featuring challenging combat and little to no hand-holding. I wanted to highlight a smaller game that might fly under the radar with all the excitement surrounding the Ocarina of Time remake and GTA 6. Also, for Cog, as an Iowa State alum, it's great to see Brock Purdy balling and hoping we get to see an MVP year. Have a great week! Thanks, John Hanke

STATS

Faithful Dukes I'm writing in with a Mental Health is Wealth write-in on behalf of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang. He appears to have come to the front of the congregation to discuss his unfaithful behaviour. Jensen Huang has admitted that he has been cheating on his wife. He has been with her since he was 17 but then decided in his old age that he hasn't seen enough of the world and decided to have some chinese. Was it worth potentially giving over half of the top company on the planet?? Dukes I know he's listening so please give Jensen Huang some advice. He needs the Dukes mercy more than ever. But also do you think this could be the end of the ai bubble? Have a most expensive 60 seconds in human history kind of day

ZipDavis

Hey Dukes, It’s the real Zip with the drip here. I appreciate how much you guys have been sticking up for us physical game bros. It’s tough out here being a Zip. But I do think one thing needs to be stressed. The full game needs to be complete on the disc. I see way too many people posting victory laps with Xbox potentially moving back to physical games. This will mean nothing if they don’t do it correctly. I’m still waiting to play so many Series X games: Halo Infinite, Doom the Dark ages, the new Gears and the upcoming GTA6 to name a few. Thanks and have a feel good time popping those Meaty Mythics kind of day.

Mr. Scott If You're Nasty

Lords of Duke Nation, Did y'all see the sales of Wolverine? Not so great and another disappointment following in Saros' footsteps. Playstation, however, posted their quarterlies and is doing great, with Network Services rising 19.5%. I think this is a major case for Xbox to want to keep Gamepass relatively the same. If they pull most first party games, I am gone, and they lose my recurring income. I go back to maybe 3 games a year full price purchases. I imagine that's the case for many Gamepass subscribers. Why not just make it so Gamepass subscribers at the ultimate level get first party games if they've been subscribed for 3 consecutive months? Wouldn't this solve a lot of the issues with consumers dropping in and dropping out? Dukes, give me hope. Have a.... livin on a prayer ...kind of day (better if you sing that line)

Caleb Greer

Greetings Dukes, No need to read this on the show, but shoutout to Adam for writing into Sacred Symbols and allowing the Dukes to mog on them for a bit. These recent 5-hour episodes got them sweating over there, sounding a little insecure from the length and ‘thic-ness of the Dukes, if you know what I’m saying. 😂 But yeah, as an avid listener of both podcasts, that section was pretty funny. Starts at 35:20 in the video and the discussion goes to 40:00 if you care to watch, Matty.

DeucesBruh (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-13 09:00 Hey there dukes, Do you think there’s any part of Jensen Huangs psyche that wishes he had just stuck to gaming now? Building GPUs for us nerds was a good gig. Leading the worlds largest company by market cap is another ball game. Curious to see how this plays out.
2026-11-10 12:40 Hey there dukes, Do you think there’s any part of Jensen Huangs psyche that wishes he had just stuck to gaming now? Building GPUs for us nerds was a good gig. Leading the worlds largest company by market cap is another ball game. Curious to see how this plays out. Have a “you just found out you’re side piece is a Chinese asset” kind of day.

Hey there dukes, Do you think there’s any part of Jensen Huangs psyche that wishes he had just stuck to gaming now? Building GPUs for us nerds was a good gig. Leading the worlds largest company by market cap is another ball game. Curious to see how this plays out. Have a “you just found out you’re side piece is a Chinese asset” kind of day.

Florida Man

Hey Dukes. Temperature check, how are we feeling about GTA 6 finally releasing, are we honestly excited, finally ready for it to be over, feeling like the withdrawal of the wait is going to be sad.

Donald A. Duck

Yo Matty, when will you giveaway your ROG Xbox Ally X? We all you ain’t gon use that shit! But if not, why not just install SteamOS? You said recently Windows is a pain to boot and navigate on a handheld. Are you just not interested in the hardware itself aswell, even on SteamOS? SteamDeck Oled is great, but Ive been thinking about upgrading. I want the ability to play more AAA games with better performance. Speaking strictly single player games on the go, which is wiser? ROG Xbox Ally X with SteamOS or wait for Dedicated Xbox handheld next year?

DadbodDerek

Congregation of Dukes! What are your thoughts on GTA VI revealing this late in the game that the game will run at 30 FPS on all consoles? Am I wrong for feeling hoodwinked? Bamboozled? Thunderstruck? I do not know the first thing about game development, but as an end user, my eyes have grown accustomed to 60 FPS. As a poor Series S boy, I've literally held off on buying games that run at 30 FPS, so I can only imagine what the big boys running the more powerful consoles feel. At the very least, it feels as though this could have been communicated much earlier, if for no other reason than to temper expectations. Am I just being a big dumb baby? Probably. Oh well. Wah. The heart wants what it wants.

Donald A. Duck

If Brad is the Green Reaper, can Lockmort be the Green Healer? Will he bring peace, freedom, justice, and security to the Xbox Empire?! Anyways, it’s much safer to bring in Lockmort to talk World of Warcraft: Forever than Brad. Have a- Lock heal our wounds kind of day!

DeucesBruh

But what about the payouts for other games on the service. Could massively shrink the available pool of money

Tdot’s Finest82

If you look at what GamePass has become, it’s Xbox first party games and then almost entirely indie and AA games. I can’t imagine the payout is very high for those. Xbox moved away from day 1 AAA third party releases into GamePass several years ago, those were expensive.

Cloud

Greetings gentlemen! I really hate to do this, but I need both of the esteemed Dukes to come to the front of the congregation. Y'all spent approximately four hours talking about Elder Scrolls 6 last week and neither one of you addressed the burning question in everyone's minds: which will come first; Sentinel or a Helix/PS6 version of Skyrim? I will be taking bets through the end of the year! Thanks and have a "I'll get hype when I actually see something good" kind of day

Vito Chiaramonte

Fellers, we know Xbox has a ton of consumer friendly things, but they have a tendency to not penetrate as much as they seemingly should. What do you think about GTA on the One? Does that move the needle and penetrate the standard user at all?

thejjuan1

Hello Dukes. You probably saw the news of the cancellation of both Fairgames and Ratchet and Clank: ranger rumble. It’s crazy how bad Sony is at making live service games! Apparently they all have the same problem. All the beta testers said they were not fun to play, and left mid game during these tests. I know the Dukes don’t usually vibe with Sony’s first party games. ( give God of War Ragnarok a chance Matty) But you have to admit, Sony’s approach to live service is so embarrassing. They should just keep making sad dad games if these are the results. Have a can’t believe Haven gets to live while Bluepoint died kind of day.

Donald A. Duck

Raisin, come to the front of the congregation. You are way too CHRONICALLY ONLINE BRO! Context: I mean your weekly write ins on the most relevant gaming news of the hour. I have no idea how you do it bro.

The Relentless Pursuit

Gentlemen this component cost crisis is getting crazy. I have an interesting idea I would like to hear you discuss. Could Xbox win hearts and minds (and a little nostalgia) by releasing an Xbox 360 classic, similar to what Nintendo did a few years ago with the NES? The RAM and storage necessary for those old games is a tenth of what’s required for modern Xbox consoles. You could maybe include a few first party games, 2 controllers, and access to a shop to buy additional 360 titles that are already available through backwards compatibility. I bet you could price that at $250 and be the darling of the 2027 Christmas season. Thoughts?

Kellen Kensinger

Hello my darling dukes! This one is a going to be a two parter for you guys. First, Mr. G27Status on last week’s duke, you had said you had guesses for who the 2 other buyers that were interested in Arkane studio but you never said who you thought it was. I’m curious on who you think they are. Second, Mr. G27Status you responded to my comment of me saying “what’s this under 4 hours bullshit?” With “The dukes fell off”. While that isn’t true, if this keeps happening on the regular, you may be brought to the front of the congregation. Much love, Kellen.

ItsShaneBailey

G'day Dukes, I admire all the Health is Wealth write-ins, but I wanna talk about drugs instead. Specifically 'gateway drugs!' Which games were gateway drugs for you falling in love with a new gaming genre? I think Lord Turn-Based will appreciate my gateway drug: Skulls of The Shogun, an excellent turn-based tactics game by 17-Bit released on XBLA back in 2013. You play as samurai general in feudal Japan who is betrayed at the brink of becoming Shogun, and then must rally undead samurai to seize his place in the afterlife. The cartoon art style is charming and the writing is hilarious. Highly recommend. This little gem got me hooked on the genre and it's been a slippery slope ever since as I fall in love with games like Double Fine's Massive Chalice (also a game I recommend), Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle and Gears Tactics among others. The genre is now a clear favourite of mine, all thanks to that first hit in 2013. I'm keen to hear your examples. Have a 'realising you'll be dead before we get a Halo Tactics game' kinda day.

Tom Sweeney

Hello Justice Gang, With the recent firing of James Gunn from DC (with the addition of multiple hit pieces on the man) how do we feel about the state of DC Games? They originally wanted to have games cannon to Dc like how Star Wars goes but now with the shift towards big bucks and family friendly content, what’s the future? Is it literally only Batman? Is that considered family friendly? Will WB be sold another time just for us to have this conversation again? Will they even shut studios down (I’m so scared for TT Games)? Anyway, sorry for the late and long write in, but have a let’s reboot Defining Duke and replace you with Tom Holland and Michel B Jordan kind of day!

rokku

Dukes, Did you catch the backlash on the hit indie game Big Walk which was seemingly disqualified from the Independent Games Festival for it's minor use of generative AI. Gen AI was only used in the context of programming and it was an estimate of 0.1% of code that had any use of gen AI, only for fixing bugs. The developer House House even went the extra mile before using Gen AI by extensively researching the problem and directly consulting with an engineer at Unity who concluded that this specific issue was something that was not possible to fix. It was only after using an LLM chatbot which eventually suggested a possible solution which worked to fix their issue. The developer House House recognise and understand the opposition to the use of gen AI as they want to avoid the normalisation of this technology that is seemingly "inevitable". Personally speaking Dukes, this to me is the prime example of a reasonable use of Gen AI in game development. I get the opposition to Gen AI, but the lack of nuance in this instance feels unfair to House House who seemingly did everything they were supposed to do. Do you think the backlash they're getting is fair and how do you feel about the use of Gen AI in this context? (Also House House's made a full statement but I'd rather not paste it here to not make this write-in any longer)

Screwed Mcfucked

Skyrim is now as old as Daggerfall was when Skyrim came out. The year Quake 1 came out.

CustomAlex .

Hey dukes, not a gaming question but WB has fired James Gunn after only 4 years. He has produced great movies and shows like Superman and peacemaker, that were diverse and had great messages. But this is another huge buy out by the Saudi investment fund just like EA. What is your guys history with DC movies and what are your thoughts on another thing people love being destroyed by greed and blood money. Keep up the great work and try and stay positive in this depressing apocalypse capitalism hell we live in.

Shinobi-san

Greetings gents A little is wealth for ya. You see, I injured my shoulder 6 weeks ago and could bench and that derailed me in regards to the gym. Flash forward 6 weeks and I came back to the gym stronger than when I left. It was wild revelation too me but here we are. Just hope to encourage anyone that feels they can't go back after so long off. Also, my shoulder is healed and my bench went up 25 pounds. Have a Colin is getting ass blasted by George Washington kind of day. #DoTheCog

Alex K

Hey dukes! I wanted to come to the experts for help with my next game to play. I recently just THICC’D persona 5 royal. And it was absolutely awesome. But now I am conflicted. I do not know if I should go ahead and play persona 3 reload or wait and play persona 4 revival. Also cog what are your feelings on current personas? Are you a fan or have you even played them. Love the show guys and I hope you have a good but not great day

My name is Pedro

Hello there dukes! Just want to take the time to point out how vibes and messaging can influence purchasing behavior. I haven't turned my ps5 on in months ! Between the killing of physical games, security issues and sony straight telling me I'm crazy for wanting ownership of my games, I have jumped to team green fulltime ( and switch 2)! Then i got gears Eday and now some outer worlds 2 dlc to ride into the new year it's been a great year for xbox fans. Have a jamar chase just scored on the Falcons again kind of day.

Raisin

Agreed, thejjuan1! Despite consternation about Wolverine's alleged success or failure, the game sold 2.4 million copies. That makes it the best-selling game of September, above the likes of The Blood of Dawnwalker, Control Resonant, and Onimusha. Wolverine will limp and crawl its way to making its money back. The same can't be said for Sony's dozen or so live-service failures. The trick now is to continue making PlayStation-bait single-player games more economically viable. If recent data released by Alinea Analytics is anything to go by, 21.6 million people showed up for God of War Ragnarök. I don't know about you, but while I don't think Laufey will sell Ragnarök numbers, I think those numbers bode well regardless. Lastly, Matty definitely should give Ragnarök a shot. That game is way too overhated for how good it actually is.

FoundWaldo

To Goombah Gog and Mid-Pump Matty… a little health is wealth for yall this week. After my trip to Tokyo & Okinawa last month , I realized i gained about 15lbs off the strength of Lawson & Family Mart snacks alone (not to mention the copious amounts of #meat I consumed). Now that Im back to the states and in the swing of things, I’ve been hitting the gym again and bringing my switch 2 with me. After weight training, I hit some steady 30 minute cardio accompanied by Cyberpunk 2077 as I’m cleaning up gigs and scanner missions with the goal of loading the save to my PS5 to hit the platinum before GTA 6 next week. I’m 5lbs down so far, and pushing forward. Always looking forward to the next episode and hearing the new pause-worthy comment Matty has cooking for us! Thanks.

Deston

Is Xbox Too Dependent on Its Aging Franchises? Hey Matty and Cog, Your discussion about The Elder Scrolls VI last week got me thinking about Xbox's long-term strategy for Halo, Gears of War, and The Elder Scrolls. My concern is that Xbox continues to treat these franchises as the future of its brand, despite their cultural peaks arguably happening 15–20 years ago. For those of us in our 30s and 40s, these franchises defined the Xbox 360 era. We experienced Halo 3, the original Gears of War trilogy, and Skyrim at their peaks. But what about gamers who are 16 to 25 today? How do you convince a 21-year-old who never experienced Skyrim that The Elder Scrolls VI is a must-play game? Why should a younger audience care about Marcus and Dom's story in Gears? And how does Halo recapture an audience that didn't grow up with Master Chief? Are we overestimating the relevance of these franchises because of our own nostalgia and experiences? Now compare that with PlayStation. Naughty Dog evolved from Jak and Daxter to Uncharted, The Last of Us, and now Intergalactic. Guerrilla transitioned from Killzone to Horizon. Sucker Punch moved from inFamous to Ghost of Tsushima. Santa Monica reinvented God of War. PlayStation has repeatedly allowed its studios to establish new identities, reinvent existing franchises, and create new pillars for the brand. Xbox, meanwhile, seems determined to keep rebuilding its identity around the same established IP. We don't necessarily know what PlayStation's biggest franchises will be ten years from now. But Xbox seems to be betting that its biggest franchises will still be Halo, Gears, and The Elder Scrolls. So my question is: Does Xbox need to stop treating these aging franchises as its foundational pillars, going into next Gen and potentially move on from Halo and Gears, and invest more aggressively in the next generation of original IP?

RK128

Blessed Day Triforce Dukes, With Zelda OoT out on switch 2, you guys giving it a shot? At the forest temple and I’m so happy we have traditional 3d Zelda back. Have a great day and keep killing it Dukes 🙏

thejjuan1

I agree Rasin. Especially the dlc for God of War Ragnarok. It’s such a great finale to the Norse story.

Ilostmytacos

Hey Dukes, A few things I wanted to send in for the show this week. Firstly, GTA 6. We've now got confirmation that the game is targeting 30 FPS on console, but what's arguably more interesting is that it'll also be playable on Xbox One through Xbox Cloud Gaming at launch, using Series S graphics settings. I think that's a pretty significant development. Obviously, the Xbox One isn't running GTA 6 locally, but the fact that someone with a console from 2013 can still access the game through streaming is an interesting demonstration of where Microsoft's cloud ambitions could go. It also makes me look at the newly announced 10-year strategic partnership between Xbox and Take-Two a little differently. Perhaps this is more ambitious than we initially thought? We've already got GTA 6 coming to the cloud, with GTA V, Red Dead Redemption 2 and other Rockstar titles apparently following. Could this be part of a much bigger plan to make Rockstar's catalogue accessible across generations of hardware? Obviously, we don't know the full terms of the agreement yet, but I think there's potentially a lot more to this than simply getting GTA 6 onto Xbox Cloud Gaming. Secondly, a little update on my Health is Wealth contribution from last week. I spoke about my plans to travel and potentially spend a significant amount of time abroad. I've had to be a little more realistic with the budget, so rather than trying to fit in loads of destinations, I'm currently looking at going to New Zealand to visit my sister, who's been having her own adventure over there for the past two years. I'm also considering Japan. Cog's trip has definitely given me a bit of a push in that direction. It's somewhere I've always been interested in visiting, and seeing his experience has made me want to look into it properly. So, potentially New Zealand and Japan, rather than trying to cram half the world into one trip. One adventure at a time! Anyway, looking forward to hearing what you guys think about the Xbox and Take-Two partnership, especially now that we're seeing the first real signs of what it might involve. Cheers!

CustomAlex .

Hey dukes warm up questions answer as many of you want and keep up the great work thank you dukes Would you rather have the ability to see minutes into the future or years into the future? Would you rather be in jail for five years or be in a coma for a decade? Would you rather be chronically under-dressed or overdressed? Would you rather have everyone you know be able to read your thoughts or for everyone you know to have access to your Internet history? Would you rather give up air conditioning & heating for the rest of your life or give up the Internet for the rest of your life? Would you rather swim in a pool full of Nutella or a pool full of maple syrup? Would you rather vomit on your hero or have your hero vomit on you? Would you rather die in 30 years with no regrets or live to 110 with a lot of regrets? Would you rather have unlimited battery life on all of your devices or have free WiFi wherever you go? Would you rather have a third nipple or an extra toe? Would you rather eat only pizza for a year or not eat any pizza for five years?

Kelzilla

Greetings Dukes! After watching my Xbox playback I was wondering what your most played game was? Mine was Mass Effect 3 at 453 hours, and most of those were on the multiplayer mode. If you have any other interesting things you learned from the Xbox playback I’d love to hear them.