Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

It's me, Colin. Please welcome Jordan Turner and Andrew Willis to Sacred+. Jordan and Andrew hail from the newly-formed Texas-based indie team Hidden Horses, a collection of nearly two dozen ex-id Software veterans who found themselves unfortunately laid off from the famous Doom studio. They've decided to stick together and coalesce around a new project called Danger Pay, which they intend on Kickstarting in the near future. Danger Pay is inspired by games like Smash TV and films like The Running Man, and it sounds extremely promising. But Jordan and Andrew have far more to discuss than what's next. Rather, we also go backwards to talk about working at id and on Doom, what it was like being under Bethesda and Xbox, how the gaming market has radically changed, and how challenging it is to get anything off the ground at all.

Files

Comments

Aladin_Slow

It still sucks what happened to id.

Sath

Yeah it is sad, ID was the only good studio microsoft has. It really is up to us the gamers to support teams like these guys on their first game so they can get their feet off the ground and hopefully produce a banger of a game.

Donald A. Duck

Hope these guys get the opportunity to ship their debut game. Who knows, maybe one day they could have their own Expedition 33 type moment.

Screwed Mcfucked

As much as a "phoenix rising from the ashes" story id's history might feel, it's unbelievable that a studio as old as id would have their worst game be Rage. What happened to them isn't surprising given what the modern consumer desires. But it doesn't make it hurt any less. Complex single player FPS campaigns simply aren't what pay the bills. And I hate that for them. I hope Defect by empty vessel (other ex id devs) finds an audience. And I hope whatever these folks make succeeds. It's a damn shame single player FPS is so underserved by nature of shifting player preference. (I literally have Doom Eternal paused as I typed this)

Sath

Yep and if they can do it successfully then the next one can be built with the finances of the previous one. The problem is going to be finding funding in this modern climate.

Sath

What would you consider is modern consumer desires? I see the problem as modern enterprise/corporate desire. The problem is because most AAA Devs are publicly traded, they HAVE to have higher profits than the year prior, every year, without fail. It's the same problem across all business as we enter late-stage capitalism. There is no more competition to eliminate so the next stages are drain the current consumers, eliminate the current workforce, and manipulate the market in any way possible to stay ahead.

Screwed Mcfucked

The modern FPS consumer desires a multiplayer fare that can be enjoyed casually with friends. Doom is not that. Quake is not that.

Sath

I don't think I agree, I could be wrong but haven't almost every modern online FPS game been a huge flop? Dark Ages flopped because it was in Gamepass day one, which made it never stand a chance. Also the expectation from the business drove failure because they needed to outperform the previous title. That means they had to have an entire business plan on how they were going to achieve it and present that to management. They took the route of generic mass appeal and simplicity (probably because it could be argued in a boardroom) and thought that dumbing down Eternal was necessary. In the end, it made, In my opinion, their weakest game of all time.

Screwed Mcfucked

You're coping like mad if you think gamepass is why Dark Ages failed (this is coming from a man that pre ordered the special edition)

Sath

I think we mostly agree and we have similar taste, I was only arguing with you because I don't want the large base of us Single player FPS fans to feel like you do (Which I was feeling in 2015 when it was actually the worst). I don't think it's true that modern consumers want Multiplayer only FPS. I do agree with you on your line "Complex single player campaigns aren't what pay the bills." I just add the Caveat "for a publicly traded company." Because "The Bills" means something different to them than it should to me and you or a small company like these guys are starting.

Screwed Mcfucked

"The bills" also mean a large AAA project like Doom The Dark Ages was. Chances are this kickstarter game will be a much leaner and modest in scope. If there was a single example of a studio making AAA single player FPS and succeeding at it I would feel more optimistic. id was truly the final bastion of such games. The indie scene is overflowing with shooters (Many inspired by Doom 2016/Eternal), however. And hopefully these guys can afford to keep the lights on.

Zachary Abell

Has Colin ever explained how Game Pass killed the game sales of Doom DA on PS5? The data showed it didn't perform well there and Game Pass has no presence there whatsoever. It also sold poorly on Steam where the argument has always been "people would rather buy games on steam than play on XYZ launcher". It also didn't have great player number on Xbox, which is the Game Pass platform. The simplest answer has always been that Doom Dark Ages just wasn't that great. It's the lowest rated, lowest bought, and lowest played ( even being the only Doom launched on game pass). Imho, it's easily the weakest Doom in the trilogy and the data shows it too.

Sami Rocklynn

I'll be there for the Kickstarter. Can't wait to see what this team creates.

Mr. Scott If You're Nasty

Doom: The Dark Ages was on PlayStation, and they didn't show up to buy the game. It wasn't because it was on Gamepass, the easy scapegoat. People didn't like the way it felt, and that was easily seen in the reviews. I disagree with most people. I loved it and the DLC was a masterpiece, but going back to the ole Colin well of Gamepass bad is a lazy, lazy take.

Yet

They think gamers should have kept ID alive cause of its significance to the industry? Nah you either make a good game or you don’t

Eric

Love these kind of conversations Colin keep bringing the great guests

Sergio Pina

Colin, now that lilymo is dead, buy into these guys. They have a chance at a huge success, and they wouldn’t burn you. They are actually fans. Huge opportunity here for you.