Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • clsssp_elxxii_awardinggreatness.mp3

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Due to its inherent interactivity, gaming has a leg-up on virtually any other form of entertainment. So why is our industry so obsessed with replicating other mediums when it comes to something like award shows? Geoff Keighley does an admirable job with The Game Awards each year -- not to mention the hard work contributing to annual galas like The DICE Awards -- but are we too obsessed with proving ourselves to the wider world, and not focused enough on celebrating our favorite hobby in unique and interesting ways? Are we too preoccupied with publishers and studios, and not enough on individuals? This week's episode of + is thus dedicated to answering a simple series of questions: Who should be empowered to select winners and losers? Is there an unbreakable tension between honoring art and acknowledging capitalism? And, perhaps most important of all: Does gaming need award shows at all?

Files

Previews only

Comments

Carlos Fregoso

Yo Chris, I fucking feel you big dogg. Let's all hope for normalcy sometime soon. Until then, I look forward to hearing y'all. Thank you guys for being there for us. Definitely has made all this shit just that much more barrable.

RD_21

I am the exact same way about Covid as Colin. It really doesn't affect me as much as most people. Professionally it even finally gave me the possibility to work from home, so really not that bad on that side. I did cry from joy a little last week when my old friend told me I know we can't see each other for your birthday because of Covid, but I still bought you a cake, that's when I knew that ok maybe it is affecting me a little.

Adamthm

Thanks for reading my question and providing some good insight. I strongly agree with Chris’s take to try and compare games 100% Also to help with my name just say Thm afterward if you like my question. It has a meaning but it's dumb lol.

Anonymous

The Game Awards are never really great, yet I watch them every year. What is the matter with me 🤷🏽‍♂️

Jack Sibert

Not to defend the Oscars, but I would prefer their voting practices over the game awards' method. "The Academy" , which is made up of various technical experts ranging from actors, directors, producers, editors, writers votes for movies that are nominated for a category that falls within their craft. The game awards however simply gathers votes from a bunch of journalists and critics. The awards votes are derived 90% from journalists and 10% from fans. People these days could give a shit about what gaming journalists think. That's why the Dice awards are more regarded as consequential, and the fan choice awards are a better gauge for how a game is viewed by the public

Douglas Morreale

I think it sucks that 90% of the biggest award is based on games "journalists" picks. So often we learn that these people are completely incompetent and often have an agenda. They *dont* know more about whats going on than the average consumer.

Tony Zook

Random question as I catch up on episodes at work. With the recent success of game remakes like Final Fantasy VII, Resident Evil 2 & 3 and the announcement from Xbox of a new Perfect Dark game. Do you think there’s any chance of a remake or full on revival of the Turok games? I remember playing the first 3 on N64 and absolutely loving them. A remake of Turok 2 or 3 in the likes of RE2 would be insane if handled correctly. Thanks for keeping me entertained at work!

Josh Lyon

Thanks for reading my comment! You’ve changed my mind. I didn’t consider the consequences that any infamy for a game at all can still bring to an innocent coder or artist on the team who was only trying to do their best. I do feel bad for the CDPR coders who must have seen a reaction like this coming but obviously couldn’t say anything. Also it was funny to hear you say my typo out loud. Sorry about that. I’ll prrof Red my submissions better next time 👍🏻

Dom posa

Nothing about Cyberpunk seems AAA. Technical issues aside it still seems like a AA game

Andrew

Best weapon skin, best level design, let’s get a little more granular and reward PEOPLE. Story lines drive the Oscars and that’s why I watch every year, but the game rewards its just I don’t give a shit

AllTooEasy_

Chris really likes to reference that tweet he saw about “The Last of Us Part 2 wins the Last Of Us Part 2 award for best Last of Us Part 2”. We get it Bro you didn’t like the game. It appears lots of other people in your industry disagree with you.

TROTMAC96

Being British myself, I used to care a lot about the BAFTA Video Game awards... Until they awarded Destiny the game of year.

Brandon Soto

Hit the nail on the head in the beginning. This whole year has been nothing but a depressing drag, and I really cannot wait for normalcy to return.

Stephen Forgione

CLS has been a beacon in this awful year. Wishing you guys a well deserved break!

NeO JD

To Chris’ point, the OFK thing is an actual game but it was just messaged poorly. The song is 🔥 though. To me, GOTY means the best overall game released in that year, and that’s in terms of design, gameplay, impact, etc. I think for the most part the voters get it right.

Jake Mcaulay

Looking forward to listening to this today when I do my round at work 😊👍.

Empty Symbol

I'll be honest I only watch the announcement highlights after. As the industry has become more and more antagonistic to the average gamer I've cared less and less about the people who are talking heads in the industry. Your knowledge and experience in the industry only gets you so far with people, if they don't like you then they couldn't care less about you. That goes both ways though. I wish people were less venomous

JusticeSoulTuna

I do think that, from a pure quality standpoint, Last of Us II DOES deserve Game of the Year. It is quite frustrating that it also won so many other categories that other games could have. And Doom Eternal not winning anything is absurd. Oh well. The Game Awards is a good entertainment piece, but I'm not overly attached to what wins, and I do enjoy the trailers.

Germanos

I'm just around the first half of the episode, and I'm surprised you haven't thought of....investors. As someone in game development I can tell you that the industry is on a freaking crazy train when it comes to investors - which will probably end bad, CDPR alike. Everyone one is pouring money into the industry. EVERYONE. From pop stars, rappers, to football players. It's crazy. There is so much money being thrown into the studios that are on "wall street". And the amounts are just mind blowing. So an award show like that is a great marketplace to showoff where they should put that money to. Both from awarded studios and world premiers.

Real Radec

Disheartening that Geoff didnt award PSAS for fighting game of the year for the 8th year in a row.

yosh_wah

Hey C&C, any chance of a mailbag episode coming soon? I know things have been busy with it being the end of the year and the recent release of the PS5, but they're some of my favorite episodes and I'm hoping for one soon!

Luke Silletta

I feel like most people don't care about the actual awards. Maybe Geoff could change it to be Fall Games Showcase or something. Make it just be new announcements.

Oliver Johnson

I’m an indie filmmaker and I’ve got to say, Awards are a big fucking deal. My career has been made by an award winning indie film. It’s super exciting when a friend gets an Emmy or nominated for an Oscar and it changes their careers. It completely changes a filmmakers trajectory by winning. The Game Awards, on the other hand, seems a lot more like typical awards. Everyone thinks they did a good job and the creators get to feel good with a statue, which is great, but this has no impact on the future of Naughty Dog at all and it probably wouldn’t have an impact on Supergiant either.

Reuben Barrett

When Colin said he couldn't produce a better game awards show, I immediately envisioned a sketchy CLS award show filmed in front of a green screen. I'd pay good money to see Colin and Chris take the mickey out of gameshows by hosting their own super low budget version.

Sumojoe118

My enjoyment of these awards always hinges on the quality of the announcements. I thought this year was pretty weak compared to 2018 for example where they revealed MK11 and Crash Team Racing.

Craig Mcguire

I agree with all you've said regarding the show but I think for now this current iteration is probably as good as it gets. Really wish the awards would go more into the game development side like you touched on about maybe specific scenes, why not best UI, best animation, best level design, combat design etc theres so many facets and components to game development, just rounding them into a few awards like best action, best direction feels to me like its doing the people behind the scenes who don't really get the attention a disservice

Anonymous

Y’all two, and your newer additions Dustin and Matty, have been a godsend for me in this year. Thank you for keeping us company guys.

Brandon Soto

That Codemasters news kinda sucks, although Take2 will save money realizing they have the Midnight Club series. Hopefully they bring it back at some point. The GTA 5 racing sections are also pretty good.

Last Stand Media

Yeah, they center around announcements for me, too, BUT the announcements are there because no one would watch for the awards.

Last Stand Media

I was in this world; I know how it goes. I just think you've gotta find people you can trust. In this case, voting panels need to be better vetted if there are conflicts of interest.