Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

TL;DR: Need pointers on how to better develop characters and relationships.

So, I'm taking in what you guys are putting out.

In my mind, Takuma is pretty close with all of his friends. Maruboshi, Masaaki, Nenro, Ai, Taro, are what Takuma considers his family.

Then there are other people Takuma has given his trust to. He trusts Sango because she is his doctor and a confidant in his "other" life. He trusts Arisu because she was there as they both built the Narcotics Taskforce together—and was the foundation that Takuma needed to build his idea. He trusts Mikoto because she knows about the Ring, which makes her more closer to Takuma than most people, and she has been his "second" teacher.

Takuma cares about his co-workers in the Narcotics Taskforce. It's a proper professional relationship. As long as it's a work matter, and they're in the right, Takuma will go out on limb for them—that might not extend to the personal side of things—but Takuma respects and value each and every one of them for their role in the Narcotics Taksforce.

There are other people who don't get the spotlight. Takuma's "network"— like Iruka, Aburame Susumu, the genin from the raid mission. They don't know Takuma on a personal level, but they have a positive relationship with him when it comes to shinobi dealings.

But I now realize that the level of intimacy in mind hasn't translated into the words of the story. 100% my fault.

I have been reading comments and some of them point out that the other PoV in the Farm Raid Mission were seen as advertisements for Takuma's good points. It wasn't my intention—I usually do them for one of two reasons: 1) To add information that Takuma doesn't know. 2) To add some freshness by getting away from Takuma—as you guys like when we get see someone else's thoughts.

I will keep the above "advertisement" mishap in my mind as I write other PoVs from now. It's a good thing to be mindful of.

Now, coming to the problem that I need help with.

The "Police Force Drug Plotline" was not that good. I stand by the idea, but the execution failed. For those who get the reference, this was TOR's version of the "Sin Arc." There were a lot of things that could've been cut out, changed up, and explored in a meaningful way.

But the past is the past now. I can't and don't want to change it.

The current problem is correctly portraying Takuma's relationships. I... don't know how to do it better. Takuma moves in a different world from his other friends. I just don't know how to assimilate them into his life.

Masaaki is stuck with the Akimichi, and his prepping for the Chunin Exams,

Ai is stuck in the hospital,

Nenro is a genin who is racking up missions with multiple chunin and is currently prepping for the Chunin Exams,

Taro is new in the Intelligence Department and is doing his own thing.

Maruboshi is too old to go to war. He is already semi-retired.

Others as well have their own life I can't disrupt.

Takuma is moving in a different direction than the others and he is doing at a different pace.

Which in itself isn't the problem. The problem here is how do I show Takuma developing relationships. I have developed relationships before in my previous fic, but I took many chapters to do it, and all the concerned characters were in the same space, doing the same things—which made it easier. Plus, the serious tone of this novel sometimes restricts me from letting up the pressure to do some light-hearted stuff. I end up feeling like I would ruin the vibe if I stray away from Takuma tackling high-stakes stuff.

Right now, I feel like I have no choice but to keep throwing Takuma from one place to another to keep the plot moving. As I once said, Genin Corp genin were different from the Jonin Team genin who trained together from Day-1— the Genin Corp genin are trained to be as flexible as possible, to work with anyone, to follow the orders—Takuma is sort of doing that. He gets put in a new situation, he adapts, improves, and the next situation calls for it, he moves on.

Moreover, currently in Takuma's career, moving from situation to situation is the only way to keep his current progress pace. It's the same concept of switching jobs gets you a higher pay raise than a yearly pay bump in the same company. There will come a time when he will settle down and work in the same place for a good while, but that time isn't now.

So, in short, I want to how do I show Takuma's relationships being fleshed out. Like, with the "War Arc," Takuma going away from the village is already decided, so I will be introducing a new set of characters— How do I make sure that these new characters are fleshed out and so is their relationship with Takuma?

A/N: Ugh this post is so chaotic. But I'm at my parents house with only my phone. This is the best I can do with an on-screen keyboard.

Comments

djineater

I feel like this problem kind of came about from you trying to do the setting justice. They live in a world of ninjas and secrets where it honestly doesn’t make sense, outside of a squad like the three man jonin team, to get super close to people. You should be keeping secrets. Especially MC as he is also hiding the transmigration part of himself. A defining characteristic he can’t or won’t share with anyone. If you want to build character relationships I feel like you need to introduce a character/s who can go the distance with him across each plot line. Someone who he can start to open up to about separate parts of his life. As they interact I feel like that development will come naturally. Maybe someone takes him and another ciharacter as students? Or introduce someone who isn’t a ninja as a teacher, like a samurai. Who doesn’t have that same secret mentality, leading to a different type of interaction and morals. Could be interesting to see

H.D.

I agree with the previous comment. The setting is not prone for intimacy. You are doing that world justice. Now as for relationship, there can't be genuine relationship if no one know takuma. He compartmentalised every aspect of himself. As is logical for the setting and himself. But no one knows him so we can see no real relationship. People are threats to him and his secrets. There's no interaction that is actually genuine. And thats OK. It fits the setting and there's a way around that. alternate pop that discuss takamatsu, so we can see how people carr for him, think of him and that distance that takamatsu puts up with everyone doesn't also affect the reader and the rest of the cast. For the war act , if you can introduce a real confident that would help. But really the best I believe is to take down the wall between the readers and the rest of the already made cast. Relationship goes both ways. We only explored one faces of all his relationship. And takuma isn't the most... open. All in all I'm highly satisfied and love your work. Also I like that the drug plot was so chaotic. It brought tension and shows us he can make mistakes, the neat freak that he his was a good contrast to that shit show. It brought depht to the world, takuma and his quirks. And not every thing has to be meaningful, as is in real life.

Dark Oak

tbh I think the story is fine as is its just that some people want more filler low stake/low conflict arcs between the major arcs. I personally don't really care for them but I can see why people are upset as not adding more between the time skip/Takumas injury was a missed opportunity. Would prefer if you do a poll about the direction you want to go with character development. The story is already slow paced as is and I don't believe people care too much about character development for characters that may not have significant importance in the future. But we will see if you end up doing a poll. edit: also want to add that he should be less trusting of people now that he survived an assassination attempt. Trying to be friendly towards people after a war/assassination attempt would be the last thing he should be doing.

SunGear

Yeah you miss an opportunity to show blanktedly that people care about Takumas and think of him as a friend if not close friend with going to other povs showing them visiting him in the hospital. But u never get the feeling of them not being friend in this story. So I think u are doing a fine enough job with character relationships.

Nil

With the war arc beginning, he will have at least two new characters to interact with: the other Police Force conscript(s) to the war and his direct supervisor. If the other conscript is not directly from Takumas own force(the battlemaniac Uchiha who awakened for an example), they will come as a blank slate relationship and build from there. Turning the "poster boy" into a real human bean in their service together could be explored. The other would be his direct commanding officer who now has to manage a competent rookie with a reputation for gloryseeking. Overcoming those initial impression is a good way to develop a relationship, since the previous time skips have done a bit disservice to developing it.

Luckly

One thing u can do is surprise Takuma after all he almost lost his life and is jumping straight into a war as soon as he recovers those that care about him even though its kinda the norm in this world would still at least wanna send him off and wish him luck make him realize how much hes worried and has not opened up to them as a consequence like i could see them trying to suprise him and him going into ambush reaction ruining the suprise leading to a bit of a crack in there relationship right as he goes off to war thus leading him to change his approach to be a little more open and cherish those he does care about

GN

I think a lot of this post came from the comment about Ai in the previous post. What you could have done is changed that into a post of Masaaki, Nenro & Ai visiting Takuma to wish him off. Another could be of them heading out to a campsite to discuss the war conscription(before he decided to go ahead with it) and him openly discussing his worries about the Chunin exams, them offering to join his team in case they don’t succeed in this round, etc… This would address the closeness between their team even though we haven’t seen it for quite some time. Also the discussion with Ai can be more personal eg: Her stating that she will “personally bring him back to life and kill him” if he does a repeat of the last time he was in the hospital. TL; DR: Don’t change direction or pace, just add a bit more of the connection content (as long as it doesn’t take off into a different tangent aka: TOR’s vaults.)

Floppy

In my opinion I think his current relationships should be put on the back burner with him going to war, I say this because it’s gives you an opportunity to introduce new characters to Takuma that would inevitably end up as the closest people he has in his life because nothing solidifies true friendship better than fighting a war with your comrades because there needs to be a level of trust that goes beyond anything Takuma has experienced so far because if not then they die that’s what happens in war. Would be interesting to see his dynamic change after going through war and how his current friends would react. Sorry about rambling I just suck at putting my thoughts into words lol

Martha p

considering the type of world where Takuma and his personal situation (rebirth and that...) it is normal in itself for him to be a loner... also the ninja and underworld environment in which you have placed him is not prone to more intimacy.....however the only way you can show us something more about their social relationships without the plot affecting you much is by using alternative POVs...you can use them between chapters that way you can show us their social relationships like the characters' concerns with him... sporadically or intermittently... I particularly feel that the story is going well... maybe has a slow pace and the possible events at the beginning of the canon are far away, but it is normal, it is your style and it seems perfect to me....I think that since the war is going to start you can use this timeline event in order to "expand" Takuma's social circle (he will have new companions and new commanders) I think that It is possible that you can use these new characters that come and show us from their point of view the progress and their interactions and impact that Takuma has on them... that way you cover two points: the lack of connections ( according to your reviews) and the same time show us Takuma's growth as a ninja all his preparation....so don't block yourself, you are entering in the ideal arc for this.....sorry for the long comment, sorry for the mistakes English is not my first language

Maracuya

What will be IMPORTANT is that the characters you introduce in the war arc become emotional cornerstones of Takuma's existence, to the point that he can't bear to see them killed. Teach Takuma some more humility by allowing his comrades to save him a handful of times from certain death, so he realizes he can't count only on himself. Do this gradually. Then have something unfortunate happen to them to inspire emotion in your readers. I couldn't care less what occurred to raiden or the aburame character in the land of frost arc as they weren't sufficiently developed. Instead of focusing solely on combat and Takuma's inner monologue (you write great fight scenes) instead include some scenes of more mundane activities as a vehicle for character development, like eating a meal together or sharing equipment. Have the characters joke with each other about the hardships of war and talk about their families. Develop a camraderie or culture for the squad Takuma will join in this war arc to humanize them. Finally, give these comrades of takuma goals that relate to their situation. "I want to make chuunin" is too vague. "I want to make chuunin to better support my family" or "I want to make chuunin faster than my father did in his day to make him and the clan proud", or "I became a ninja to escape poverty" so that when they become victims of this proxy war that will happen, we care.

Maracuya

I want to let you know, even though I am underwhelmed with the development of side-characters, your fight scenes and grammar are excellent. Better than 99.5% of fan content you can find on the web.

triad

The best way to develop trust is to earn it. It's time for takuma to develop these new bonds with other ninjas of konoha, amidst the war. They can develop a relationship with him naturally if they're apart of the same squadron or maybe some of them can save his life either against the ROOT taskforce or the komagakure ninjas.

yuuzzlol

What I can say is that you are in a good place to make a "clean slate," so to speak. War is a place where camaraderie and good cooperation are more than essential to prevail, even more so if Takuma wants to get some juicy achievements that will secure him the Chunin position, so it would make sense to develop some lasting friendships and if you manage to take advantage of this and create an interesting character that has good chemistry with Takuma, it could be everything you are looking for. That being said, the chances of Takuma wanting or even being able to relate intimately to someone in such a dangerous and sad environment are very, very low. You would have to do something special like be assigned to a squad, be a partner of a chunnin/jounin, or be the leader of a team. The only excuse I can think of would be that he was given some benefit or responsibility because of his performance in the police force and his relationship with Mikoto/Fugaku. Also, I'll take this opportunity to say that one mistake I see a lot of writers make is forcing the secondary characters' growth to match that of the MC when it doesn't make sense. By this I mean when in fics or anime they make secondary characters grow at the same rate as the mc or even faster just to keep them relevant to the plot. this seems like the biggest stupidity to me and it never looks particularly good. because there are millions of other ways to keep secondary characters relevant. Please, I beg you, do not fall for it. Takuma works his ass off more than anyone else, and he's already left most of his old class behind. If you're going to make Maasaki, Nenro, Taro and the others keep up with him, at least show us that they work as hard or harder than he does.

GN

One other thing I want to point out about the current ARC; that it was primarily 2 major fight sequences with a bit of Root making moves in the shadow. Your previous ARCs felt that they covered more events.(not necessarily duration but I mean key points in the story). The point of this ARC was him going to war but the scheming/sequence of events all happened in the background so we felt a bit distanced

Maracuya

I also think it's getting to the point where he won't be able to avoid interacting with mainstay canon characters, and by extension Naruto. As I have said before there are also a lot of powerful characters that were undeveloped in the anime/manga. It would be fun to see a rivalry with a character that did not make a splash in canon, such as the two-tails container.

Liu Zong

In the way i see it this will at last take a 60+ chapter before Takuma backstory finish and he finally can at last seattle down...