Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 771954605.mp4

Downloads

Content

Files

Comments

John Edgar

Arrived 🏳️‍🌈

Peter M

Good afternoon everyone.

TJC

Woohoo! Another weekly dose of #RealRimmer!

Phil Hatfield

Arrived ... and could I be so bold as to say you're looking very smart today, Joel. PS Just bought Russell T Davies's memoir, aptly titled The Queerest Of Folk: A Life In Television, with some fascinating stuff about the process of getting QAF on to the screen.

Graeme Robertson

The title of the episode becomes obvious as it focuses on family dynamics of various sorts. Yes I think Stuart's Dad knows but can't openly deal with it. And there's power struggles going on too that ard obvious. Someone wins one of those struggles in unusual ways before the series ends. I recall how your perception of the characters changes with every episode and can see you're getting that too. Cameron seemed like a saviour for Vince but is he a bigger manipulator and that's what Vince is drawn to?

John Roberts

Superb episode acting as a psychological mirror for the three leads, stripping away their club-land personas to reveal their core insecurities and motivations. It shifts the focus from the excitement of the gay scene to the friction between the characters' public fronts and private realities. I think Stuart's argument with Nathan's dad isn't just about protecting Nathan; it is about Stuart defending his kingdom (Canal Street) and his absolute need for control. Whereas the scene with his own father, who, as he tries to connect and bring up his sexuality, Stuart shuts it down immediately. Thus proving that his hyper-confident, out-and-proud persona only exists on his own terms; true intimacy and vulnerability terrify him. (Interesting point here, both Aidan Gillen (Stuart) and Ian McElhinney (his Dad) were both in "Game of Thrones" (As I might add, were about 95 % of the UK's acting fraternity!) As for Cameron, I believe he's flogging a dead horse when it comes to Vince as the bond between Vince and Stuart, however unhealthy, is pretty unbreakable. Nathan meanwhile, by admitting to Cameron that he's only 15, unknowingly also admits that he's still just a kid looking for validation, safety, and a place to belong. P.S. Joel, you may also remember Ian McElhinney as Grandpa Joe in Derry Girls.

Nicholas Sinclair

Just catching with this week's QAF episode,early 👌👍: & espec. the thought-provoking script showcasing the conflicting parents vs. children interrelationships {Nathan/ Stuart/ Vince},plus I love RTD's use of Cameron as the 'foreign outsider' to increasingly become the emotional catalyst/foil for the group (ie 'mocking' of Nathan & Hazel vs. no-BS talk with Stuart).🤔 Stuart's father played by N.Irish acting veteran Ian McElhinney (Ser Barristan Selmy - 'GOT', etc.),who you might recognise,Joel,as the granddad from 'Derry Girls'. Nathan's father played by another acting veteran Paul Copley ('Downton Abbey','Heartbeat', 'Hornblower',etc.)

Eva Horz

Excellent, fully packed episode. Even when a conversation gets really deep, I love how there's still just enough room for our own interpretation. Brilliant!

Graeme Robertson

Stuart's father and Nathan's father later had significant guest roles in (Chibnall era) Doctor Who and Torchwood:CofE respectively.

Lachlan Main

Afternoon, tax return dropped off (late again!) car booked in for the MOT, talk about and all fun Thursday......... An episode where you could hear the the clashes if you were stood on the moon. A lot of people involved that know how to communicate but just don't. Stuart and his Dad reaching out to each other, like the scenes in films where the hero reaches out desperately but the one he's trying to help still slips from his fingers. think Indiana Jones and the last Crusade with the struggle over the Holy Grail in the film's closing minutes. As for bad boy Nathan's Dad if I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt (IF!) his over protective attitude is more smothering than helping and is the cause a genuine concern for Nathan or a fear of being shown up in the neighbourhood. The scenario of marrying to gain citizenship is one that been running for a long time, the guy at the centre came over as a bit too self satisfied with his approach logic, he's looked into it and like the old mousetrap game, one step follows another and Bob's your uncle. He didn't come across as having baby Albert as his first concern. Cameron may be just an Aussie version of Stuart but I'm not convinced about that. He knows what he wants and for now that's Vince and he seems to be ready to play the long game but not for ever. Vince who has grown into his Stockholm syndrome role in Stuart's life. Always there,always the spare. Grateful (?) with what he;s got and is Stuart so commitment averse he won't share any more, anything deeper? The shallows of "fun", action, drink, drugs and rock and roll on the surface hiding the tortured indecision swirling underneath. The closing scenes of Stuart sat Sphinx like, totally in control or so used to living behind the mask might he have actually forgotten who's actually there? Yes Joel it was an episode to make you sit and stroke your chin in a thoughtful way. Thanks again for sharing, hope you have a decent rest of your day, the same goes for you cheeky but cheerful Patreons out there!

Eva Horz

Hello Peter 😊

Graeme Robertson

What makes you think that? I doubt they're known too much in USA and Joel bops to anything dancey

John Cartwright

The elephant in the room is that Nathan is only 15. In this story, Nathan is portrayed as being the enthusiastic one who actively wanted Stuart (and the actor was 18). If it was real life, a 15-year-old would be less forthcoming, more confused, and potentially vulnerable to having his emotions manipulated by someone like Stuart.

Andrew Stringer

This thread has got very indepth about analysing the dynamics at play in various people’s relationships in this show ( usually my forte, but I can’t really add much to what’s already been said). Therefore, and in lieu of Joel’s recent reactions to house/dance music of the nineties, I offer a number of nightclub bangers that would have been played regularly down Canal Street in the late 80s/early 90s. Enjoy whether you’re old enough to remember these or not - and please add more if you have your own favourites ! https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Z19hzCi3V4k&pp=ygUaaGVhcnQgdG8gaGVhcnQgaXRhbG8gZGlzY28%3D&ra=m https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=U8n9jtvqBJs&pp=ygUiYmFyYmFyYSBkb3VzdCBpZiB5b3UgbG92ZSBzb21lYm9keQ%3D%3D&ra=m https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=MYkg2iyEqJ0&pp=ygUmYW5raWUgYmFnZ2VyIHdoZXJlIHdlcmUgeW91IGxhc3QgbmlnaHTSBwkJMgwBhyohjO8%3D&ra=m Ankie Bagger still performing over 30 years later. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CRqfTIDtFoU&pp=ygUmYW5raWUgYmFnZ2VyIHdoZXJlIHdlcmUgeW91IGxhc3QgbmlnaHQ%3D&ra=m https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PUelCP83q9Q&pp=0gcJCSsMAYcqIYzv&ra=m

Mason

I've noticed that Russell T Davis likes to echo a lot in this show. We have Stuart echoing Nathan's behaviour when it comes to his parents and the incredibly frustrating echoing of Alexander's words by Nathan, when their parent's views towards their sons couldn't be more different.

Matgo Styles

This episode (and the previous one) has an interesting behind the scenes story which explains why they are more character driven rather than moving the plot on too much. Channel 4 originally requested that episodes 5 & 6 were given to another writer to take some of the pressure off Russell T Davies, but they weren't happy with the scripts written by the other writer, and allowed Russell to rewrite them. Russell had already written episode 7, so episodes 5 and 6 are essentially filler, but in the best possible way because it allows us to take a deeper dive into their lives without getting too heavily into the plot.

Neil Jarvis

One of my favourite episodes of the show because we get to see a level of vulnerability from Stuart, below the cocky bravado.

Neil Jarvis

Sad news about Patrick Stewart.

Mark Pearce

In the street row, I was on the side of Stuart, cos although Nathan is only 15, that father is violent, and there's no way I'd want to leave a kid with a violent father. It's a shame though that Stuart is a predator! The viewer is being pulled in all directions. Later in the episode, when Stuart handed the baby over and went clubbing instead of babysitting, I nearly spat my coffee out, I was that disgusted with him. IN other news, Joel should wear a shirt more often. Devastatingly handsome!

Craig

Strikes me that what Nathan's dad was primarily enraged about was the fact that he was still 15 and clearly being taken advantage of by an older man. Whether or not homophobia plays into that anger and hes scared of Nathan being led down a path he doesn't approve of etc is one thing but if you consider the version of events where it's a 15 year old daughter he has spending time with a 28/29 year old man then I think the dad would behave equally the same and the audience would fully recognise and support the dad in that moment but that's just how I perceived that scene as I can't recall any dialogue from the dad that was specifically homophobic or about the fact that Stuart was a man...

Butterfly

There are some things to break down: First: I could not put it in words last Episode, did not think deep enough if it, only felt something is off with Vince new boyfriend. After this Episode it formed in my head. He is like this toxic boyfriend, who try to separate you from your friends and family to have own control over you. He tried it last Episode and i only gasp it lightly. Took for me too long to get. The one scene where he put his arm around Vince and was attacking Stuart told me everything i needed to know. Was glad Vince did not take it and was on Stuarts side defending him. And than the last scene. Wow. Who the heck do he think he is, talking for Vince and decide what is good for him. Yes, it is technically not wrong what he said. in the same time, it is toxic behavior taking control for Vince. Who asked him for? I starting to dislike him very badly. From one control to another. 2. What leads me to Stuart. It is what i saw last Episode. Him being sad, calm, depressed and part wise lethargic. The mask of the happy Boy party around, laughing, shagging and drinking falls off. He needs Vince right now the most, as Vince is maybe the only human in the Universe Stuart can be honest with. He is not the biggest talker anyway when it comes to feelings and Vince was the only one Stuart would talk to. He is like his father in this matter, only more emotional and not deaden enough as he is younger. 3. Nathans Dad. Here we come to the complicated part. Because technically and morally, he is right. In some european Countries the age of consent is 14. What is a special talk. In UK it is 16 (?). So it ends up being illegal and rape per law. That no one cared for the age gab back than, is one thing. I already put it in words few times and i stand by it. Law is on another book. His Dad was not homophobic. He made it smart going only against the age. So no one would argue with him about. From his perspective, it is his Job to make sure his child is safe. And now imagine your own 15y old Kid, brother/sister, Nephew/Niece, Cousins or who ever would date a 33 years old Person. I would like to know how you or your parents would react on this. Do not see them be happy. The most would go to the Police nowadays and report. So technically, no matter what you think about his behavior, he is right in his position as a parent. 4. The violence. It is on the same book as "not being able to talk". This is a Generation thing, it is how he/we (yes me included) was raised. From Grandfather to Father, to the Children. Was it right to smash the car? No, of course. But this is how he was raised. He saw his Kid in danger and this was his reaction. I know too many people who would react the way and worse. Today. And the father did not hit Nathan. He "only" grab his arm. I do not know how to feel about it, with my own experience. Maybe there are more things to say, but i can not form it in my brain till now. So i leave it. Normally i could easy write a deep down analysis about everything happend here, a book, but i am mentally not in the right shape now, having problems to get the easy things, as it seams.

Peter

Stuarts Father Derry Girls and I am surprised you didn't recognise One Way or Another Blondie at the end of the episode!

Joe_Sheffield

I always reply, when people say that being LGBT is un-natural, that actually homosexuality occurs a lot in nature. What doesn't occur naturally is marriage and having that relationship sanctified by a "god". Marriage is the most un-natural thing in the world, but homosexuality is very very natural.

Joe_Sheffield

It's so worth pointing out, if it hasn't already, that when this was filmed and aired, the legal age of consent for gay sex was 18, while for straight sex it was 16. The revised sexual offences act of 2003 brought those ages in line with each other at the age of 16.

Joe_Sheffield

The dads reaction both Stuart's and Nathan's, are reminis of my own father. Anger, threat of violence, some mild actual violence in the form of smacking and belts, when I came out at the age of 16/17 around when this aired. These reactions and the conflicts it portrays are very much what I experienced back then. I am pleased [o report though since then, my father and I have made up, he has apologised and we now talk much more openly and honestly, and I've also accepted that he's never going to be the most talkative about how he feels, because as Joel rightly said, that isn't his fault. That's the way he was raised. I feel that I had had Joel's sensibilities when I was the age I was, things may have been different. But, it came good in the end.... For me. X

sobelou

Yes, eventful episode. Things are coming to some explosive resolution for them all. Great episode.

Nanya

Man I wish that show would have had 10 seasons, it's SO good..