Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

New Show Poll ❄️🌃

  • Small Prophets 21
  • Psychoville 14
  • Peter Kay's Car Share 38
  • Still Game 16
  • 2026-11-02
  • —2026-11-05
  • 89 votes
{'title': 'New Show Poll ❄️🌃', 'choices': [{'text': 'Small Prophets', 'votes': 21}, {'text': 'Psychoville', 'votes': 14}, {'text': "Peter Kay's Car Share", 'votes': 38}, {'text': 'Still Game', 'votes': 16}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 5, 14, 30, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 2, 16, 30, 47, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 89}

Content

This show will replace Detectorists! This will keep our balance of two new (post-2000) shows and two old (pre-2000) shows. Detectorists was unique and brilliant and won't be possible to replace. But we will try our best..

Thank you everyone for your participation :)

Comments

Jamie Angus

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🎉😇🌋

John Edgar

Arrived, decided on Small Prophets 😃

Martin Deas

Just in case Joel, still doesn't know who Simon & Garfunkel are, this is probably their most famous album.

Ash Jeffries

Arrrgggh, I really want you to see Psychoville (finally!) but Small Prophets was absolutely wonderful. Best thing on TV in the last few years!

Stuart

With us already having Red Dwarf and The Thick of It on rotation and the majority of Fridays also tending to be comodies, I would have preferred to have a drama series to balance things out. I know we all like a comedy, but there can be too much of a good thing.

John Roberts

Small Prophets. I need my Pearce Quigley fix added together with a Python and a Crook, sublime.😉 (Not forgetting a Big Boys neighbour.)

Martyn Dawson

Has to be Car Share. So funny 🤣

Eva Horz

Hello 😊 Voted for Small Prophets.

Neil Jarvis

I’ve gone for Peter Kay’s Car Share. It’s a warm and lovely comedy. It’s essentially two characters in a car, with excellent interactions and dialogue across various scenarios. Some great cameos added too. I like Small Prophets but I reiterate my earlier concern with this show. We only have one season so far. Season 2 isn’t available until some time in 2027. So we would be watching just 6 episodes and then wait potentially up to a year for the second season … and maybe wait again after for Season 3. Better to wait until the whole show is available.

John Cartwright

I don’t have any enthusiasm for any of these options, so i voted for the one with the fewest episodes so that we can get it over asap and move on to something else.

Tony Holness

Arggh! More queue-jumping additions.

Tony Holness

Nothings got a chance if it's any Peter Kay rubbish, another auto win.

Luke Harper

When’s Benidorm making another appearance? Loved rewatching that first episode again

Dave

I have voted for Car Share as I love it. Not sure if anyone has mentioned this, I haven’t seen anyone comment it, but I know in the past it can be really difficult to get hold of the episodes of it so hopefully someone can provide it to Joel if it wins the poll.

Tony Holness

Oh no, what a shame!... Guess will have to have another poll 😉

Dave

Don’t be too hasty! 99% of what I say is nonsense and should not be trusted 😂

Butterfly

Still want to watch Psychoville. Like really, really, really. Car Share seams to be another "okeyish" option. Maybe, maybe not. But i know for sure, i am not going to watch the other two. The good thing about small Prophets is, it has only 6 Episodes. Good to move on.

Neil Jarvis

Think I’ve got it on DVD somewhere. Happy to send to Joel is worst comes to worst.

Nicola

Car share ftw! 🙌😬

Peter

Sadly Looks like after all these years I'll be leaving ItsJps! only like one show at the moment! maybe I'll return next year? wishing everyone well and if you get the chance check out Blondies NEW Single Spectral Eyes! lol T.C

Stuart

Peter, I know exactly where you are coming from and was thinking the same thing.

John Edgar

I know exactly what you mean, at this rate I'll just be tuning in on Fridays 😞

Allan

I'm not thinking of leaving as I love some of the others. But the last couple of polls have been disappointing to me. But since Red Dwarf and The Thick of It appeared, I can't complain too much. @Joel, do you have a waiting list or is it random? I think random is probably best as it could get silly with polls for waiting lists.

Malcolm K

My selection is none

Phil Hatfield

Exactly the sentiments I expressed on here a few weeks ago. It would be good to have a drama to balance things out a little. With this poll, the only one will be QAF.

Eva Horz

That's sad news Peter!

Barry P

What an awful selection. Feels like the choices are deliberate to make the many times rejected Psychoville & Still Game seem good...

Jamie Angus

Ah Joel, thank you, I sincerely do appreciate the inclusion of Still Game! Clearly no other fecker does but I do 😇. You’d be best mothballing it again for another year or so. The years will go by and the alternative comedy show selections will gradually dwindle until all that will be left is me, smiling down at you all in benevolence whilst triumphantly brandishing a copy of Still Game for your poll! From my death bed most likely. 😉⚰️. Peter Kay’s Car Share isn’t all that bad so things could be worse. That’s how I’m viewing it.

Ian Hillier

Small Prophets was so innovative but there’s only one series, at the moment. Car Share can be very funny. Still Game is an old favourite, so I’m happy with whichever is selected.

Eva Horz

Wonderfully put, Jamie! 🤩👌

Michael

Are Joel's options running out? He's covered a large amount of UK TV shows over the years, so I'm just wondering about the future of this Patreon. There are a few of what I would call classy shows that have been mentioned here and there, but maybe Joel has had a quick look at them and wasn't particularly enamored with any of them and so has passed them by. Of course my likes are not to everyone's taste ('THE PRISONER' being one example, but the first ever episode could be a randon Friday selection maybe?). Also classy TV series like 'FOYLE'S WAR' would be popular I think. One of the problems that Joel admitted to some years ago now was that he doesn't possess the attention span to watch full length movies ('Carry on Screaming' being very much an exception). If he could just overcome that problem then his choice of content would be greatly increased. Other things that have come up before would be somehow getting around the 'not showing anything that's NetFlix' issue which would release a great number of excellent UK shows/films that I'm sure members on here would love to see. I'm not casting any shade Joel, but just trying to suggest some ways to expand and move this Patreon forward to the benefit of members and also yourself.

Brian

I must say I admire your indefatigability Jamie Angus!

Jonathan Ball

It would be good to try an episode of something else Scottish, Two Doors Down. And I still hope Joel will discover Julia Davis - “Nighty Night” + maybe Camping & Sally 4 Ever - one day!

Neil Jarvis

I think there are still plenty of quality shows to cover. Particularly post-2000 shows. He has made a good selection in this poll. Not sure why there’s negativity in the comments (not having a go at you - it’s mainly from some others). There are loads more other shows that we have yet to watch (Black Mirror, This Is England, Absolutely Fabulous, Men Behaving Badly, Here We Go, Louis Theroux, Derren Brown Specials, Time, Normal People, Fleabag, …). The channel has a strong future and Joel selects some really good shows to go in polls based on suggestion we make. My personal taste is less for the older shows like The Prisoner - they seem very dated in my opinion - but I respect that some like this.

Michael

Thanks for your input Neil.

Jamie Angus

Ah thanks Brian! I admire it too. 😉

Michael

Ah Jamie I love your eternal optimism! 😊

Jamie Angus

Thanks Michael! Don’t be mistaking optimism for sheer desperation though. 😉

Jeremy

I think that this is the first poll in which I want to watch all of them!

John Edgar

oh I'm not leaving, I plan on being a shareholder for quite a while yet, these polls aren't going to make everyone happy. On the plus side I've got some free time on Monday and Wednesday for now 😃

Eva Horz

I agree 100% Neil. Since I've been following Joel's Patreon I think we've had a good balance and a few real gems in the rotation. In my opinion Joel is doing a great job navigating through this huge range of shows trying to find what best suits our different tastes and age groups too. Sounds pretty much like a Sisyfus job tbh! I think it's only fair to take Joel's own preferences into account as well.

Neil Jarvis

100%. And unlike other reaction channels, who choose the shows themselves, Joel has continued to give his subscribers the power to choose. And yes, you’re right, he does need to enjoy the shows himself. A show that was popular in the ‘70s - 50+ years ago - may not always be what a 20-something American guy will embrace.

Stuart

At the is risk of sounding like a grumpy old man, I've been a bit disappointed with some of the show choices to say the least. I liked the Friday movies, I liked the dramas and I liked the documentaries, I liked the albums. This last poll is now giving us 3 half hour comedies a week, the last movie we had at Halloween was not a horror and I wouldn't even rate Screaming among my top ten Carry On's (or Matron), the last time we had a movie before that was Porridge about a year ago. It just seems that we are watching 30 minute comedies because they are less time and effort to watch than a 1 hour drama or 2 hour movie. Even Fridays tend to be just odd comedies. If this Patreon is just going to be only comedy episodes then fine, but we are running out of genuine British classics and we'll soon be on the dregs, so maybe its time for me to move on, I don't know. Like I said grumpy old man having a moan.

Eva Horz

That's absolutely true, Neil! It's Joel's reaction that makes the difference and when he's enjoying a show himself it makes it even better.

Eva Horz

Perfect John!👍👍😊

Joanna Daborn

Well, it’s a toss up between Small Prophets and Car Share for me. I love both but I get others views that there is another series coming of Small Prophets so it may be worth waiting on this one - much as I would love to watch it straight away. Can really take or leave Psychoville and Still Game

Butterfly

Finally someone point it out with the "time and effort". I think the same since a while. This is also the reason why Joel made one of the last polls on Friday. It is easier and faster than watch a Show. Even if i have a clue why he do not watch long Documentaries/Movies anymore and have a bit of understanding for things, but the result for us is the same. This is just a general thought along the fact, that i already struggle to watch more than QaF ones a week myself. Yet i enjoyed Benidorm alot. Still, it is also a fact, i am watching only one Show per week, like some other people here. About the old Shows from 70/80s, i do not like them. Not the style, not how them was filmed/camera or what ever. That is why i do not watch Carry On or alike Movies or Shows. Starting with 90s it getting better. I do not have any issues to watch history/dress Shows, but again, i like them filmed in the modern time. And i always would like to watch a good documentary over a movie.

Michael

I agree Eva.

Eva Horz

Michael, we both won't yet give up on "Notting Hill". Right? 😀

Neil Jarvis

Nice work, America. Well played!

Phil Hatfield

Thoughtful comments. I 100 per cent agree with Normal People and Time: I'll keep pushing these excellent dramas.

Michael

Ah yes Eva - indeed, we would be over the moon if Joel could possibly consider that film for a future poll and then hopefully a full review. I just think it's so much better than 'Four Weddings', both in the storyline and the comedic aspect as well.

Michael

Dave - nice to see a bit of polite honesty on occasions! 😊

Tony Holness

He really needs to sort the polls out their such a disorganised random mess, it's the only real critique I have of this place and though I'm not as regular in comments it's kind of sad to see people that have supported this place for such a long-time leave. Theres shows that have been in waiting for 3 plus years now and then Peter Kay comes along and gets in instantaneously. It'll be the same when Gervais starts coming along too.

Tony Holness

He just needs to make the polls more consistent, instead of queue-jumping shows. for example, he should have done the same poll as the one the thick of it won on with the thick of its position filled with a new entry.

Jamie Angus

For me it is the pre-2000 shows (and films) I mostly subscribe for. It’s probably due to my age, amongst other things. I find the majority of post-2000 UK shows rather insipid and mediocre, especially compared to the US who experienced a huge upsurge in quality post-Sopranos. The millenium renaissance for TV shows, especially drama shows, largely missed us over here. There are a few notable exceptions of course but unfortunately we’ve watched most of them already.

Lee Hallam

I went for Small Prophets but am happy to watch Car Share, I think Joel wants to watch Psychoville, and I would watch it, but I think it is inferior to the other two. And the other, well I think he knows it won't win. I have some sympathy with those suggesting a drama, and I think the options for the next Thursday poll should be all dramas. Ultimately though, we have run through the shows that everyone likes, and options will split opinion more. I am not watching two of the shows, they are not to my taste, (i keep trying on Mondays but i can only get through five minutes of it!) and some Friday choices leave me cold, but i am being introduced to shows I haven't watched and enjoying reactions to old favourites.

Allan

Is there any American (or anyone that knows) on here who can comment on what difference this makes?

Neil Jarvis

My knowledge is very limited but from what I understand, House of Senate and House of Representatives - now both Democrat controlled - have the powers to stop laws and legislation being passed that Trump tries to put through. It also gives them the power to conduct formal investigations into things such as Trump’s corruption, the wealth of his family made as a result of the presidency (that in itself is a really interesting story and worth looking up) and the Iran War. Essentially it takes a lot of power away from Trump. But I suspect others can explain this more accurately.

Tony Holness

Theres a good few shows before it, at least there should be. I am surprised it isnt on this poll actually I was expecting it.

Tony Holness

Psychoville is the superior choice.

Scott Reeves

I’m in the trenches with you Jamie. It’s a war of attrition and we’ll win it eventually. There’s a reason it was Scottish regiments that broke the Cossacks in the Crimea and Napoleon’s Old Guard at Waterloo 😜

Kate

Men Behaving Badly was a big comedy show in the 90s!!..... It's one of the top ones!... And Absolutely Fabulous...but they never seem to be on the polls, sadly.

Neil Jarvis

Those are both pre-2000 shows and so wouldn’t be on this post-2000 poll. But hopefully they will feature on future pre-2000 polls.

Dave

No one ever reacts to Two Doors Down, it’s always Still Game. I think he’d love two doors down. I had Nighty Night on dvd, I wonder what I would think of it now 😂

Jonathan Ball

It’s still utterly brilliant! A one off Friday for the first episode of each of these would be great.