Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Apologies once again for the comparatively long silence. I continue to be distracted by some real life matters that have prevented my being as productive as I would like. While I wish I could say that they're wholly out of the picture and there are clear skies ahead, I cannot. 

Nevertheless, I have not been idle and work continues behind the scenes on sha-Arthan and related projects. In the course of limited playtesting, I've come to the conclusion that the scion is not quite the class I'd hoped it to be. My original intention was that it be an aristocratic wandering jack-of-all-trades but I have come to think that perhaps the class is too narrow in its focus, or at least not as broadly useful as I'd intended.

One possible fix would be to create a slate of skills from which the player can choose. In this way, each scion might be a little different than every other one. If the slate is broad enough in scope, this could create a very flexible class that fills a variety of roles. On the other hand, I worry whether that might make the class more mechanically complex than I prefer and dilute its core concept. 

What are you thoughts on the matter?

Comments

Luigi Castellani

I think it can work if the skill selection is somewhat contained and, most of all, does not overlap with abilities of other classes. Though I'm sure you are pretty far from that, I remember that in later 2e's days people abused the specific mythoi Cleric's flexibilty to create super characters, so I'm somewhat wary of this kind of things, though not completely against it. Another risk is that this kind of flexibility may dilute the class' identity. I'd probably have to see a list to make an opinion.

Andrew Scott

Something similar to LotFP's Specialist class may be a good fit - featuring a dozen or so skills covering a range of adventuring activities that promotes a broad variety of concepts under a single class umbrella.

Stephen Vossler

I am not fully aware of the limitations you refer to. Could you give us your reasoning? One though that crossed my mind was not to limit the Scion to aristocracy, but open it up to a wider variety of high class dilettantes and the various skills that go with them. Keep titled nobles, and their retinue, but add merchant princes, temple patrons, scholarly expedition leaders, collectors & connoisseurs, roving gamblers, errant champions, rich pilgrims, and etcetera. A true dilettante might have skills from many of the examples listed. In many games I have GMed or played in, a Scion type character has been useful within the party, but in most cases, their "societal class powers" are in addition to their class (fighter, MU, cleric, etc.) which makes them a bit over powered. I like the idea of Scion as a class and am certain a broad set of appropriate skills can be found to make them work in the game.