Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

First, an apology for the lack of new posts over the last month. The real world has, unfortunately, kept me busy lately. Beyond that, I've hit several significant rough patches with the development of sha-Arthan's rules that I'm still working through. In particular, I'm contemplating weakening the traditional D&D-like class arrangement for something looser so as to accommodate a wider range of options for characters. This has caused me no end of angst, but I'm buoyed by the advice and insights of my internal playtesters who are encouraging me to craft the rules as I think best.

Not all is angsty, however! I've got more monster art to share, as well as other little tidbits about the setting that are coming more sharply into focus. Several core ideas of the setting and its backgrounds have fallen into place and it's my hope that this will make going forward a bit easier. Mind you, this is a very bumpy process, so we shall see.

In any case, I very much appreciate everyone's continued patience and support. They mean a lot to me, especially as I wrestle with my latest harebrained schemes.

Comments

Stephen Vossler

I think the most difficult challenge in writing an OSR-RPG is limiting yourself to the basics that define OSR. Most of us who have played the original RPGs have witnessed the development of the game mechanics from the rudimentary frame work to the voluminous complexities of present day systems. We are familiar with the gradual progression of class, race, skill, combat, task resolution, etc. The question forth standing is, were to stop the development. If you don’t create enough you are left with all the frustrations that prompted the supplementary development in the first place, if you develop too far, it is no longer Old School. The rules system (I prefer “game mechanics”) is just a charter between the GM and players for mutual understanding and regulation of advancing the story. I would be happy to play in sha-Arthan with any game mechanic I could comprehend without undue difficulty. What I am more interested in is playing in a world built by a person that understands “world building”. Game mechanics will always be subordinate to imaginative source material when creating adventure, or satisfying a player.

James Maliszewski

I almost completely agree with you. However, I also want to be sure that the setting and the game mechanics used to roleplay in it are a good fit. One of the things I've learned after many years of playing in Tékumel is that none of the published rules associated with the setting have really served it well. That's why I want to get it right with sha-Arthan, even though it's slowed down the process of presenting the setting.

Davy Crocket

Have you done a review of the latest version of the Call of Cthulhu RPG, 7th ed yet? A review of the 2nd edition reprints would also be good.

James Maliszewski

By "latest," do you mean the 7th edition or the reprints of the 2nd edition?

Davy Crocket

Hi James, this is a response to your recent post on "Fantasy Realism." I shake my head a little at people who are focused on "realism" in a game with spells, dragons and magic items. Wasn't the hobby always a fun escape, not a religion? I think Tolkien said it best.“I have claimed that Escape is one of the main functions of fairy-stories, and since I do not disapprove of them, it is plain that I do not accept the tone of scorn or pity with which 'Escape' is now so often used. Why should a man be scorned if, finding himself in prison, he tries to get out and go home? Or if he cannot do so, he thinks and talks about other topics than jailers and prison-walls?” ― J.R.R. Tolkien

James Maliszewski

That's a very valid perspective and one I largely share. That said, realism (however defined) was – and is – important to certain segments of the hobby, particularly those of a more "simulationist" bent. It's not really my cup of tea, admittedly, but it's not a new concern by any means.