Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

To be clear, this is another work in progress. Some of the entries are incomplete; others have not yet been updated to the new format. In addition, there are many more entries that have not been written and are thus excluded from this draft. Nevertheless, the PDF describes more than forty creatures and can be found here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1_d9V3vOI1Ed4MtywtEOUjdpYJQ-C_UjD/view?usp=share_link

One thing I'd very much like to hear from anyone who takes the time to read the file is the your opinion about the descriptions. I've varied the length and detail of the descriptions, with some being quite long and others very short. This is intentional, as I'm still not entirely sure how "meaty" the final descriptions should be. Ideally, they should strike a good balance between being flavorful and information and concise. 

Left to my own devices, I'd probably ramble on describing many of them. At the same time, I recognize it's important to give sufficient information to the referee, so that he can adequately understand and use these creatures in play. In the final version, every entry will have an illustration accompanying it, which should help with visualization, but there are other important details beyond appearance.

In any case, I'd be grateful for some guidance on this matter.

Comments

Richard August

Having read through about half of them, I’d say the longer ones tend to be much more dynamically written than the mid-length ones. It feels as though the most concise ones don’t offer a huge amount to GMs but there’s something to ‘the fruitful void’ in that case. The longer ones offer interesting insights and are engaging to read. The mid-length ones tend to cleave to the most naturalistic elements of the creature, and I think those are usually the least useful details. So, my preference is for the longer write-ups, as I think that kind of incidental detail is one of the best means of learning about a setting. And it clearly enthuses you as the writer!

Nick

I prefer the longer ones too - you get a much more thorough feel for how to use them, and the background info that comes up naturally adds something to the greater whole.

James Maliszewski

This is helpful. I regularly find myself torn between concision and luxuriating in the setting I'm building. Precisely because sha-Arthan is somewhat odd, at least compared to vanilla fantasy settings, there's definitely a need for longer descriptions. At the same time, I don't want to fall into the "Tékumel trap" of so much detail that it'll be off-putting to newcomers. Finding a balance is harder than I expected.

Nick

When a lot of them are really quite alien (comparative to other games), I think it help considerably; the other "problem" with Tekumel was that some parts were so alien that many people didn't know what to do with the setting, scared of getting it wrong. Giving more information always helps me, rather than less.

James Maliszewski

That's very good to know. I'd be curious to hear what others have to say on the matter.

Stephen Vossler

This is a good start. Not too defined which narrows their application and not too vague. I look forward to getting to know them better due to encountering them in game. I hope this is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to creatures and monsters in your world.

James Maliszewski

There will be quite a few more added to the list before the working draft is completed. This is simply another "sneak peek" of where things are headed.

Stephen Vossler

Your post requests our feedback and appraisal of your format and depth of your narrative of the creatures. I think you have done an adequate job after evaluating what is necessary for basic play. To give guidance to a perspective GM I would suggest a smattering of color commentary that may make no difference to the game mechanics but helps the players imaginations in visualizing your world. A word or two about their motivation or method of attack would give guidance to GMs on how to use them in the adventure. This could be in the form like Traveller (ambush predator, opportunists, territorial defender, etc.) or just some commentary on their behavior. Take the Akun; I can imagine them as reptilian bats, or winged anoles, or even miniature wyverns. Are their wings feathered, leathery, or insect like? Is damage they inflict due to bites, claws or stingers? Is the confusion they cause when they swarm due to visual stroboscopic effect or do they flap their wings in a way to make a dissonant noise? These characteristics will not have an influence on the combat mechanics but would be helpful to the player’s imaginations. I would suggest: Akun (Night Flyer) Akun are small, nocturnal flying reptiles, not much bigger than a bat, that frequently dwell in caves or ruins, where ever they can find small stone cavities to hide in. They emerge in numbers at night or regular intervals in subterranean environs, and drive off any creatures within the territory of their warren. Akun attack in a swarm, flying about their targets head or eyes. While swarming their wings beet together to produce a frightening sound and reflective surfaces of their four dragonfly like wings display a disturbing bioluminescent visual effect to confuse the interloper. Akun use a sharp sliver thin scale on the end of their prehensile tails to inflict minor but painful wounds. DR 13, HD 1hp, Att 1 × swarm (confusion), AB –1, MV 9’ (3’)/ 120’ (40’) flying, SV F14 D15 M16 E17 S18 (NM), ML 6, XP 5, NA 1d100 (1d100), TT None ► Swarm: 10 akun can swarm around a target’s head, causing confusion: –2 to attack rolls and saves; unable to cast spells. ► Flighty: Unless magically controlled, akun check morale every round.

Stephen Vossler

I would also add; The sound of Akun swarming may attract predators wanting to take advantage of confused and fleeing prey.

James Maliszewski

This is very helpful. Thank you! My main difficulty is in finding ways to describe creatures without reference to Earth animals, since there are no (or few) such animals on sha-Arthan. It's hardly an impossible task, but it does require care on my part.