Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

October Movie Finalists 🎃🍁 (Patreon)

Published:
2026-09-13 15:49:56
Imported:
2026-09

Poll

October Movie Finalists 🎃🍁

  • Constantine 512
  • Pan's Labryrinth 264
  • 1408 92
  • World War Z 227
  • Creep/Creep 2 Double Feature 118
  • The Others 175
  • Candyman 160
  • The Final Girls 135
  • The Ritual 113
  • An American Werewolf in London 70
  • 2026-09-13
  • 1866 votes
{'title': 'October Movie Finalists 🎃🍁', 'choices': [{'text': 'Constantine ', 'votes': 512}, {'text': "Pan's Labryrinth", 'votes': 264}, {'text': '1408 ', 'votes': 92}, {'text': 'World War Z', 'votes': 227}, {'text': 'Creep/Creep 2 Double Feature ', 'votes': 118}, {'text': 'The Others ', 'votes': 175}, {'text': 'Candyman', 'votes': 160}, {'text': 'The Final Girls ', 'votes': 135}, {'text': 'The Ritual ', 'votes': 113}, {'text': 'An American Werewolf in London', 'votes': 70}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 13, 15, 32, 4, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1866}

Content

THE TIME HAS COME! Congratulations to our top ten finalists. So it's time to choose, you can only Pick ONE so make sure it is one you truly want us to cover.

To make it a bit more fair we are confirming three non-horror movies that we are definitely doing: Coraline, What we do in the Shadows and The Addams Family. These were the highest movies voted and will be covered for October.

So the rest of these will be horror or Horror Adjacent movies to cover next month. We will most likely pick the top 3 along with our personal picks which can be from any of the previous polls.

Comments

Laura❤️

I really want the others but it’s not looking good😭😭

meg thomas

Oh man yall missed out on the 90s classic FEAR with Reese Witherspoon and mark wahlberg

Clare B

I'd argue that Coraline is a horror movie aha, that shit took me years to watch all the way through as a kid. Give 12 year old me the grudge or the exorcist any day

Luke

The others or world war Z, I actually didn't really like Constantine but willing to watch it again with you guys if it wins anyway.

Mary Woollard

I'm with you on that! That would be such a good reaction

VampyreQueenJazmyun

So disappointing! FEAR is SO good. Its where my red flags for men started 💀😆 It is fun to see him playing that role! 💜

ParkMinJeon

You know it’s not on the poll right ? lol

ariel mermaid

Same i really want the other’s too it’s a great movie i hope they do it one day 💕 i definitely voted for it

Laura❤️

Nicole Kidman was fantastic!

meg thomas

Right?! It’s literally RIGHT up their alley. I need them to react to it anyways cause it’s a movie with not enough reactions on YT despite it being fucking AMAZING

Violet

Constantine is a mix of horror movie, a detective story, and of course, EYE CANDY!! Also, it has my favorite depiction of Satan in any movie or show!!

Courtney

It’s me, commenting again: y’all know what to do about my man Constantine

Cass&Jason

Tough one. Regardless, we hope that you consider The Devil's Rejects for a personal pick.

AlexandraInTX

Pan's Labyrinth is a Top 10 movie for me. It's fantastical, terrifying, and beautiful. GDT at his absolute best.

ak416

Still holding out hope for The Ritual

lynseypie

Ooh tough choice but Keanu will always get my vote 🥰

Helen KB

I've narrowed it down to 4 and they're all for different reasons so I can't decide between them 😅

VampyreQueenJazmyun

I think it would be a good one for them to randomly pick because of the casting! And all the good cameos we have in it! Also the dad from CSI 👀👀 major crushing on him as well 😆😆

Bangtan Vodoo

Same here Laura I have been commenting the title but I dont think its gonna make it

Shanette Batista

I feel like we don’t get to see them do too many zombie movies and world war z is definitely one of the best it’d be great to get their reaction. Train to Busan would be a dream!!

JameseyReacts

The others is one of my absolute favorites I would so love to watch you guys react to it!

Laura❤️

I really think they would love the creepy vibe and the whole mystery of it!

rickie woodson

Surprised constantine is winning. Its such a bad movie in my opinion. Beyond boring and ugly looking. Its also not comics accurate at all. The real constantine is so cool and so powerful and BLOND and BRITISH...the constantine tv show is much better.

KatieBee

Come onnnnnnn Pan's Labyrinth! What a beautiful story it is. Gorgeous film.

meg thomas

Not to mention the “NICHOLE 4 EVA” that Lives rent free in all our minds 😂😂😂

NDM

What happend to Addams family??

Sinister Goose

I would love to see your reactions to 1408, I love that movie so much❤️

Ashley H

Once agan great choices and will be happy with any of these. Voted for Candyman. Would be happy if they did the original before the remake. The Ritual, 1408, The Others are all excellent choices too

RebalBuoy

My heart wants to vote for Creep and Creep 2, they are under appreciated horror in my opinion, but I had to vote for the Ritual.

Jacob Young

Between candyman, the final girls or creep double feature… I gotta pick the final girls… I love that movie 😂❤️

Delaney Dunn

man i really hope you guys do the creep movies at some point. It’s right up y’all’s alley, so funny but def creepy

Libarax

Completely disagree.

Hermione

I do love Constantine but I really want y’all to watch World War Z, maybe next time lol not looking like this time

Suzanne Hayes

Constantine! Constantine! 🤜🏼🤛🏼

Zombies_Are_Real

The Creep/Creep 2 reactions would be so good! 😭😭😭

Dumpling ?

Yyaaassssss!!! Constantine! Constantine! Constantine!!!!!!

Zombies_Are_Real

But it is mentioned as a non-horror movie in the post. 😉

Dumpling ?

I remember that movie...too bad I can't watch anything with Wahlberg in it.

BleuMoon (Mod)

Anyone who didn't vote for The Others is grounded for life 😤 just sayin

Alise Lynch

I hope you still do Pans Labyrinth cause its incredible.

REAXwithSNAX

yay what we do in the shadows!!! i am soooo seated for it. it's become a yearly holiday watch like elf.

Kitty Marie

Ok I'm going out on a limb 😅 1408!!Constantine- amazing all around, World War z - amazing zombie movie, American werewolf- amazing werewolf movie but 1408 is a great ghost, spooky like classic "halloween" type story and vibe while also having a really beautiful sad story entwined( ? Idk if that's right lmao ) in it.😁

Becks

The Ritual is so worth it!!! 🙌

Adavan

Constantine! 🤞🏻 Constantine! 🤞🏻

Julie D

Agreed--The Others makes perfect reaction content.

Chantal

Coraline was one of the top picks so how is it not on here….? And it most certainly is a horror movie. Lol

REAXwithSNAX

in the text they mentioned it was one that was already a guarantee watch

Laura❤️

My birthday is October 26th.. birthday present?!😊

James L

cmon the Others, such a good movie

Amina

I watch both of them every year for Halloween! I hope they do them too

Kennan Lukacs

I know yall would love The Final Girls.

Val

Constantine, we got u!

Liz

It was so hard to just choose one, since there’s a lot in there I want the guys to react to, but had to give it to the Creep/Creep 2 double feature

Chantal

I did but I still think it’s a horror movie 😜

The Horror Bandwagon

Well we don’t know we haven’t seen it - it’s animation to us as of right now. That’s why we decided to confirm it so more horror movies can get picked. Do you want me to not confirm it anymore so we can place it on this poll and re-do it? 😂

Inés Muñoz

Same! It's still my favorite horror movie after all these years!

Chantal

I would not ask for such a thing 😂 I’m happy we’re still getting it regardless. Appreciate yall 🧡

The Horror Bandwagon

Haha only teasing! We appreciate YOU! Cant wait to check it out finally! 💜

Zach Davis

I'll do anything for you guys to watch final girls!

Zach Davis

Honestly, I watched it recently. It's a pretty movie but the story was lacking for me. I do hope they watch it for the effects someday, but not high priority imo

Alliebutt

He's iconic. Did you know that he was originally meant to wear leather with a biker look, but Peter Stormare (the actor who plays him) suggested he'd look better in the white suit instead. And I'll be honest, I think he was right.

Gaby

Only choosing one is basically Sophie's Choice... For me it's Constantine, but I wish to eventually see the others as well

Lily Winter

Pan's Labyrinth is my favorite movie of all time, I hope you guys will get to watch it sometime. It's just such an amazingly artistic film.

Violet

That's so cool!! The white is VERY effective!

Becky B.

You guys are cracking me up with these comments lol

Becky B.

I really wish The Ritual, Creep, and Candyman would win. I'm so sad they're not in the lead.

Elesia

The Ritual 💚🔥

kayla ling

Wait which Candyman though because if it's the OG yes, if it's the remake nope

Nicky

Come ON Constantine! 🤞😭

Anxious Em

I watched it when I was four days post partum with my first baby. Mistake! I always say it’s the most gorgeous movie I will NEVER watch again 😅

MapleDonut_FaireeSamm

OG Candyman 🐝🐝🐝 PRETTY PLEASE 🙏🏾.. You guys will be surprised by the lore of his creation.

Florence Kosek

I like most of these movies so this is a hard choice but I voted nonetheless 😊

ArcAngel

Psyched about What We do in the Shadows!!!

ArcAngel

Go Constantine!!! You just cannot go wrong with a violent exorcist Keanu.

Roz

I voted Constantine because I believe you guys will enjoy that after watching the John wick series. However you do need to do Creep and Creep 2 at some point ♥️

Giselle4991

Constantine over Pans Labyrinth is a CRIME :(

Alliebutt

It was a fantastic choice. The white being a symbol of who he used to be before he fell, the morning star, with the tar as an opposing symbol of who he became. I'll be honest, even with Peter's acting, I don't think he would've been as iconic as he is if he'd worn leather instead. Granted the suit was also entirely Peter, but in a universe where Peter still played the role, but didn't suggest the suit, I don't think he would've been nearly as memorable. The suit did a lot to enhance and support Peter's own acting, and in painting a picture that stuck with people even 26 years later.

Alex Grill

The Ritual was a cool one, iirc as well. I recommend it as a scary movie suggestion for any time!

Anna Blackberry

Pans Labrinth is one of my all time favourites films pure magic

The Jagooar

Pan's Labrinth is so good. It is the perfect creepy, disturbing, twisted fairy-tale type of movie to watch during spooky month!

KiwiJello

I am so bummed no more people are voting for "Candyman". It's a classic and he deserves his place up there with Freddy, Jason, and Michael. I hope you guys will consider it anyway. It's a well-crafted, mentally woven experience.

BatmanFanGirl

1408 is so underrated. 😩😩r

Flora_Ivy

American Werewolf in London, though I know it’s not looking great. I love The Ritual too, but part of me thinks it makes for a better like…November/December horror movie. I think because it’s set in Scandinavia, it makes me think of late fall and early winter

Jenn

I know it's a TV show not a movie, but I wish you guys would watch A Discovery of Witches!

MissTaken Gamer

It's not a horrible movie but it shouldn't be winning, I agree. Only explanation I can come up with is that the majority haven't seen the lesser known and exponentially better movies on the list (like The Ritual) or that they are blinded by nostalgia. I was sad Constantine only had one season. I got to meet Matt Ryan a couple of years ago. He's awesome.

Scorched Witch

Sad to see that What We Do In The Shadows got voted off the island 😭

SapientButterfly

I disagree about the movie. Yes the series is definitely better, and Matt Ryan literally IS Constantine in his portrayal. But the movie can still be great too and I love both.

Cassie

Damn, Constantine, 1408 and Pans Labyrinth are all fantastic and you'd love all 3 imo. But glad Constantine is winning. Its brilliant and no one is ever mad at more hot Keanu

Puffadder

100%. The Ritual and Candyman are BY FAR the best movies on this list and it's not even arguable lol. Constantine is fun, but it's not even in the same league. And wtf is with the votes for world War z lol. It shouldn't have even made it this far

The Horror Bandwagon

We’re still doing it, it’s in the post! We just confirmed it so more horror movies can make the list :)

Ghost

stir of echoes and the frightners shouldve made it btw, smh. Better than the majority here. ill watch yall still but the pollers failed you lolol. Hopefully you get at least constantine or an american werewolf in london but its not looking so good

Ghost

its al pacino for me, then supernatural then constantine for me. All were born to play the rolee.

Erin Rogers

I REALLY REALLY want to see you react to CANDYMAN!! Thas scared the crap out of me when I was a kid!

Marion Anème

I voted for Pan's Labyrinth, it would be so awesome if you guys did Guillermo Del Toro's entire catalogue tbh! I'm hoping Candyman pushes past World War Z tbh ^^' Love that movie! Also the Creep double feature would be so fun!

Violet

Al Pacino is my second favorite! His is SO FUN!

MetalBabe Sami

If you’re actually wanting a horror movie and Constantine wins…you should watch Constantine AND the horror movie with the most votes. Constantine isn’t really horror imo. It has horror elements but not enough to solely be considered horror.

Shawn Traub

Constantine is a GREAT movie. Pans Labyrinth is so beautifully artistic! … But, World War Z is my ALL time FAVORITE zombie movie. The spectacle of this movie is on a global level while still having terrifyingly confined moments which give it a personal one on one perspective.

Scorched Witch

Oh my brain is clearly not working well while sick 😂 sorry for missing that haha!

SapientButterfly

I saw The Ritual and thought it was kind of meh, not nearly as good as the hype made it out to be. I loved seeing Rob James-Collier in something other than Downton which was the highlight for me lol. Worth a watch but I wouldn't be fussed about seeing it again. I agree about World War Z though, huge let down that one. Candyman I've never seen and really should, feel I've definitely been missing out on than one.

Mariela Oquendo Rodríguez

Damnnn Corpse Bride didn’t passed and you guys don’t watch it on your watch list 😩 you should do it, it’s an AMAZING movie, Constantine is good but a bit underrated, Pan’s Labyrinth is GOLD

JW-

Impossible choices ... there are at least 4 top-tier movies listed. Uuuuugh. I have to vote for The Ritual -- just a great story and possibly the best ever blending of digital and practical to produce a truly unique creature. I see almost no one else wants it, so I'm holding out hope that it'll make it back on to the polls in the future (as many times as needed to be chosen).

SherioCheers

Dang 1408 is one of my all-time top 5's. Altho Constantine would have been my close 2nd <3

BleuMoon (Mod)

This movie was my first and only request I've ever done for them T-T I just know they'll love it

B-dad

So Monster Squad is off the table? Because that’s is THE Halloween movie to watch. WOLFMAN’S GOT *****!

The Horror Bandwagon

Lol no worries, just wanted to make sure you knew! Hope you feel better soon!

Natalie Halveston

I'm even more excited now. I think I must have read another post about some movies not being first time watches. I'm always up for watching you guys react to shows regardless. But extra excited when its some of my faves and its your first time. 🥰

The Horror Bandwagon

Oh that was for Friday the 13th. Where we’ve seen some but haven’t seen the majority.

Natalie Halveston

Ahhhh. I commented on that post as well. I'm getting old I swear. I have never watched any of the Friday the 13th and have only watched the Halloween H20 (I was a kid and my mum put it on without having me watch the first 😅) so that will be an experience watching alongside you both. Excited.

ViscosityNZ

Not the Israel one damn.

x_Rhi_x

Seems pans labyrinth is 2nd...im really hoping you will still watch it after constantine, its gorgeous

Megan

Every time I hear Wild Horses (The Sunday's cover) I think of THAT scene.

Maddkandi

Not sure if y’all will see this, but y’all should look into the movie Doom with Karl Urban and The Rock! It’s an action horror movie based off of the video game Doom. Was one of my favorites when I was a kid and I think it’s highly underrated! Very fun watch.