Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

We are finally here and we had to go all out with a 6 hour video!! We had so much fun watching this one and filled up with all the emotions that I was exhausted by the end lol but I won't spoil my thoughts on the movie - check it all out in the reaction! :)

Also, Should we cover The Hobbit Movies?!

Files

Comments

ak416

I definitely wasn't incessantly checking Patreon for this all night

kiara

This will be getting me through the rest of my work day, thank you very much. I’m READY 🍿

Luke

YES OF COURSE WATCH THE HOBBIT

Alissa Marsden

OH MY GOD... you guys look GREAT!!... love it! Enjoy every minute. Cause we sure the hell are!!!!! ❤️

Vanillamellow

FINALLLYYY!💕 I have never been sooo excited for any reaction ever, Lotr is part of my soul at this point. 💕 Can't wait to see you cry in sadness and happiness 😂💕✨

Luke

Fantastic helmet Cody!!

Aurro Eronaile

The Hobbit movies don’t quite hit the same pinnacles but they’re still perfectly enjoyable for fans of LOTR despite their “flaws”, definitely worth a watch 🥰🥰

rosaery

oh my god right before bed this is a dream 🤞🏻🤞🏻🤞🏻 i love y’all sm like your outfits are ICONIC

Meredith Konicki

LFG!!!!!!!! I dropped it all and am so sat. Maturing is realizing Sam is probably the best character in the entire trilogy (at least for the films), and that Aragorn is the man by which all men should be measured. Periodt. I absolutely adore getting to watch these with you two -- knowing how much Cody loves these films and then finally is getting to share them with Sergio, and having Sergio love them too. It's so wonderful to share in, as someone who has lived these films for 20+ years.

Kimberly S. (Rawr)

OMG you guys look FANTASTIC 🙌🏼💜 Can’t wait to watch this later! You guys should totally check out the Hobbit movies. Loved your exploration into this franchise! It’s been such a fun time 🙃

Barb

THE COSTUMES I LOVEEEEE

DkLounge

I hope you're planning to post your reaction to The Crow on the day before Halloween & that after you finish the movie, you look up the circumstances regarding the lead actor's death late into production before you go into the discussion so that you'll have more context

christine ♡

No sleep for me tonight! 😹 And yes, you need to continue with the Hobbit trilogy ✨

Mary

Definitely do the Hobbit movies! Shouldn’t even be a question lol

Mary

Yea I’ve been like stalking their page for it to show since the last one was posted 🤣

KatieBee

So so so so so excited to watch this!! Eventually... I have to go to work in 15 minutes 😭 and then am helping my mom with stuff tomorrow so I guess it will have to be Saturday. 😭 But Sergio, I hope you enjoyed it, I'm gonna assume you did! And definitely watch The Hobbit movies! It's been so so sweet to see you watch these together and see Cody get to share his knowledge and see his eyes light up at which moments shock and delight Sergio on his first watch! Thank you so so much for sharing this with all of us, it's been precious. But in the good way not in like... The ring way 😂🩷

KatieBee

Also, love the costumes! You both look great!!

Anxious Em

Cody coming through with the notes is making my day

Roni Pene

I’m going to watch when I’m not at work. Can’t wait! You guys look amazing!

Lacerta

Can't wait, it's Friday morning in Australia and I'm looking forward to watching (some of) it after work tonight! Thank you guys, your costumes look fantastic!

Joyce05

Aaahhh!! Yaaass! On a friday as well. My life is complete ❤️

Danijela

OMGGGGGG YESSSS I WAS WAITING FOR THIS 🥹 MY FAV PART !! ALSO THE COSTUMES ARE EATING 💕😻

Danijela

and please do watch Hobbit! 💕

Sanya Arif

Yeah gotta wait until tomorrow after the trading day

GrayAlien

with the eagles saving frodo and sam, i think there was a third cause gandalf was hoping smeagol could be redeemed

GrayAlien

i went to the premiere of this in vegas and when aragorn says "you bow to no one" just instant sobbing all through the theatre ive never heard that many people cry at one instant moment

Violet

YES!! AND YES PLEASE DO THE HOBBIT MOVIES!!!!!!!

Jeune!!

The costumes are so gooooddd lmao 😆🩷

Cody Walsh

It is 10am here and I got my snacks 💅

Cody Walsh

The cosplay 💅💅💅💅

Miss Maya

6 hours holly hell that's almost a work shift. 🤣 let's gooooooooo :))))

Miss Maya

"They're taking the elves to Organof" I'm dead LMAOOOO

Elisa

I was with Sergio also covering my face and weeping when Aragorn bowed down at the end. Definitely watch the Hobbit movies!

Joshua Shields

I'd advise waiting a solid year or more before doing the Hobbit movies. Take the time to steep in the emotions and the quality of the LOTR movies, cause the Hobbit movies, while there's some nice moments are a definite step down from the LOTR movies & watching the Hobbit movies too soon after could negatively impact how much Sergio likes Tolkien's world.

Melissa Espinoza

Please watch the Hobbit trilogy too! I honestly love the Hobbit trilogy more than the Lord of the Rings.

Alfie Fulton

The giant inflatable rat (named Scabby) is used by unions during protests / strikes/ pickets in NYC.

feathers_67

Can't wait to watch this later! Also yes the hobbit movies are so fun to watch, I think you'd enjoy them!

Mars Mallows

I am SO excited to experience this with you all. Literally getting special snacks and drinks and a cozy blanket and the best velour pants just to watch this when I'm off work tomorrow. I'm not ready for it to be over 😭

Pablo Luis Perez

Viggo Mortensen in his crown with a beard is HARD DILF vibes Also welcome to the 'Watching LoTRs at least once a year for a good refreshing cry' Club hahaha

Harbek

I'm from Vestfold in Norway, and the way everyone CHEERED in the theatre whenever they said Westfold in these movies. ♥

Trainer Kay Studio

Omg, your Drag Race references make me giggle every time.

Sally

U guys look amazing!!!

Michael Instone

The Lord of the Rings a masterpiece of Cinema.

LunaNoctis

Forgive me if you say this, but I just have to say something about the part with the eagles. I feel like you could argue that the ring could have corrupted them as well! And Frodo had to do this on his own/ with Sam.

Henna Kauppinen

This dropped 2.30am so I had to put this on hold and sleep. But now... Now we ride my friday is saved! 😍🤘🏻And yes watch The Hobbit trilogy it is good in it's own way 🤗 Much love from Finland 🇫🇮

Asami Ayla

Thank you! 🙏🏻💜 This will be a treat to watch after work today :D. Great costumes!! (And yes to The Hobbit movies. I'd like to see your reaction and hear your opinions despite the general one. :)

Zeroxias

Hell yes to watching the Hobbit movies too~

Jade

YES TO THE HOBBIT

Dylan (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-23 18:00 I was genuinely scared for you thinking you might actually wear those outfits for the full 6 hours 😱
2026-10-23 11:32 I was genuinely scared for you thinking you might actually wear those outfits for the full 6 hours 😱 Okay, I made it to the end of the movie but will have to watch the post-watch chat tomorrow. I’ve loved these reactions (and the super long chats after). Although I like them less than LotR, I would enjoy seeing you watch The Hobbit and Rings of Power, I think they’d be fun to re-watch with you and in particular, hear Cody’s thoughts.

I was genuinely scared for you thinking you might actually wear those outfits for the full 6 hours 😱 Okay, I made it to the end of the movie but will have to watch the post-watch chat tomorrow. I’ve loved these reactions (and the super long chats after). Although I like them less than LotR, I would enjoy seeing you watch The Hobbit and Rings of Power, I think they’d be fun to re-watch with you and in particular, hear Cody’s thoughts.

Justine

YOU GUYS LOOK AMAZING OMGGGG

Cody Walsh

Yessss please do the hobbits

Stefan

"my friends you bow to no one" still gets me every single time

Bookwormy

Got my covid and flu shots, this is my recovery reward

Maddkandi

I was so worried when I saw Sergio with the contacts lol, I can’t imagine watching an intense four hour movie while wearing costume contacts.

Jack O

Man, you two really went all out, it's great to see! And it sounds like Cody did a ton of work to make this happen, that's so sweet, what a guy!

Miss Maya

I would definitely love for you to watch the Hobbit movies. while I think LOTR is on a whole other level I think Hobbit movies are still great and worth seeing and are very fun. I'll give other deeper opinions only after you've seen them. but definitely a yes for me I'll be here with my popcorns waiting :)

Miss Maya

I appreciate the massive notes and discussion afterwards wow Cody you really came prepared :))) love it! for me personally if there is one thing I could change about the movies is to bring Glorfindel and his whole plotline in. But he's such an impressive character I dont even know if movies could do him justice or if he could live up to people's expectations and imagination lol. I think that's why they skipped it. Still, would've loved to have him! in everything else even with changes these movies are perfect to me! I've seen them as they aired every Christmas for 3 years in a row, in highchool... and Ive seen them probably 50 times since. and will never get tired of them

Eliška Svobodová

There are actually a bunch of terms for the not-dragons, but most of them are very descriptive. As per the One Wiki to Rule Them All (yes it's really called that), they are called hell-hawks, Nazgul-birds, black wings, and of course, fell beasts as a more general term. But if you consider all of those, you see that they are either "yeah Nazgul ride them and fly" or "yeah they're horrible and fly" so it's not like a proper name in any of those cases. Éowyn is my absolute favourite ever. And yes, I have heard all of the "oh you like the badass girl who can kill monsters like nobody's business? I'm shocked" but it's actually due to the arc that she gets to go through, like she starts off with this strength, holding by a thread because everyone is dying around her and she's not allowed to even fight, and then she finds something to fight for (Aragorn) and that's taken from her, so she drives her suicidal depression from all that into the fighter's strength in the war, only to seemingly fall to death itself, before being healed and her focus completely re-arranges itself as she finally can see hope! She becomes someone devoted to living and making life good instead of chasing her glorious death! It's magnificent! (and also there's some fantastic fanfiction about the romance with Faramir and the conflict of cultures between Gondor and Rohan and I love it but that's besides the point really >.>) I always love watching people discover and grow to love this story. There's just so much to love. Thanks for taking the time to share the experience with us, too!

Miss Maya

the "why we couldn't fly on eagles there" meme and discussion is funny to me and always gives me a good chuckle but I never took it seriously. Gandalf only flew in with eagles to save them AFTER Sauron was already gone. the whole point of Sam and Frodo walking into Mordor alone was stealth, because they were small and insignificant and inconspicuous and that's how they sneaked in on Sauron. it was unexpected path taken by unexpected creatures and they had element of surprise. it would never work flying in openly on eagles. Sauron and his forces would seem them flying over Mordor and would sent everything he has including his Nazgûlat them they would be killed instantly.

RebalBuoy

I waited to watch this while I work. I didn't realize it will last me most of my shift. Let's go!

KatieBee

I'd love to see you guys watch some of the behind the scenes stuff! I'm not sure what all came on the original DVDs, maybe all this was originally from them, but I would recommend a few online videos that I've seen: -Peter Jackson using an entire stadium of people to record the Uruk-Hai army's chanting. 🤯 https://youtu.be/TFLIUqhzhYQ?is=ImignKGyeYUQcIja Andy Serkis appreciation including his SAG award win (or maybe the BAFTA?), his audition for Gollum, invention of new tech to make Gollum as we know him possible & how it all changed filmmaking history - https://youtu.be/DFQ9JvtqTtA?is=t-yUBKp3sg1D5QvV Techniques used in set building and filming that achieved the differences in scale between the Hobbits and the men such as how they made Gandalf look huge and Bilbo look so small in the first movie - https://youtu.be/PB8db3PMZ9s?is=riDnt3SQ-RE7HOSC Dominic Monaghan (Merry) messing around and pranking Elijah Wood on the press tour "Will you wear wigs??" - https://youtu.be/IfhMILe8C84?is=XHEfMpi2ijL_i3XO The Lembas Bread advertisement parallel, this was the best footage I could find but it was at a convention when they discussed it, maybe somebody else could find the original but this one is nice with little cuts from the movie to remind the context - https://youtube.com/shorts/88PfD1vhiDQ?is=7O-EDivA-FNhi8Fp Viggo buying the stunt double's horse for her 🥹 - https://youtube.com/shorts/fFEArdHA0PA?is=TBfitaL4DAPJklhD Maybe some of these may be in better quality elsewhere, but the links are just a jumping off point, I mainly just wanted to shout out these particular moments as something Sergio should definitely see.

Fredrik

On the battles. With the movies way fresher in mind than the books and nowadays being more used to the epic fantasy battles written by Sanderson for example, I listened through the Audiobooks narrated by Serkis a few years ago. Every time after a battle I was like "wait? was that it? huh.." Tolkien was a fantastic storyteller but his focus was clearly not on describing an epic battle over 200 pages.

blizzity

can't believe I just watched all 6 hrs & 20 mins of this ahahahah incredible reaction ❤️ loved how emotive sergio was throughout this whole 4+ hrs long film, and, of course, adored cody's passion & extensive knowledge about LOTR at the and 😍

Dylan

I don’t mind that in a book. Seems par for the course, like Dune has entire intergalactic wars that happen ‘off-screen’.

Cody Walsh

That scene in RE9 with the spider the exactly the same in the movie. Nice lil Easter egg

Natalie Halveston

I don't know why I thought this was going to be the first one. I had to Google it to make sure. Then I noticed you had reacted to the first back in July. I've never watched any of these so I shall go back to July and watch that one first. Will be watching first time with you but by the comments it's gonna be great. 😅☺️

Kaylee

Bless your heart Sergio. I cry right along with you.

Kaylee

Check out Rings of Power. Its not brilliant but still okay I think. Then there is the Hobbit films and an anime film called War of the Rohirrim. And more films are being made like The Hunt For Gollum.

Miss Maya

I'm really interested in what are Cody's opinions on Rings of Power show. I'm not saying I really want you to watch it.. I would just be interesting to hear opinions :)

Keira Fink

OMG FINALLY I’m so excited!!!!!

Aubrey

I am Sergio and Sergio is me through the whole shelob spider scene. Even 20 years later those scenes make my skin crawl😅

Kaylee

Also have you seen Pirates of the Caribbean franchise? I think thatd be great to react to.

Disaster

Don’t ever apologise for being into the story - we all are!

Johanna Victoria

just had to google „Organof“ 😂 and apparently “Organof GmbH” existed in Switzerland (GmbH is sort of a type of company) “Organisation of congresses and educational events” founded in 1996 and liquidated in 2003. That’s all I could find and english is my second language, so I don’t know if my translation is right😅

Matthew S

Y’all seen Harry Potter? 👀 after the hobbit obviously.

MamaMocha

While I do admit the Lotr movies are the better triology, I do love and enjoy the Hobbit movies way more (I might have too big of a soft spot for them). Definitely worth the watch!

Honeyperil

John Noble is also excellent in Fringe! A series I would die if you watched (also stars Joshua Jackson and Anna Torv). 🥺 He is so great at characters with dark complexity. Another thing that I'm not sure if is confirmed but I see rarely mentioned: The fugly pale orc being rumored to be based visually on Harvey Weinstein (who tried to ruin the movies after some nonsense) as an FU from PJ and the crew. I think of this everytime he gets killed or is being extra ick.

Honeyperil

My ideal man until the end of time 😫

Noel Peters

Would LOVE a reaction to the behind the scenes!

Kevin

06:19:36 Arwen drops the book. This is a sign that Arwen is becoming mortal, because Elves are never clumsy and never drop things as their spirits are in perfect harmony with their bodies. A moment later Arwen's mortality is confirmed when Elrond, who witnessed the book fall from her hands, says, "The life of the Eldar is leaving you."

RebalBuoy

Cody would LOVE Fringe

red

I can't believe after more than 6 hours watching your reaction I want more 😭 Thank you so much!

Danielle Cruz

YES!!! Cover The Hobbit—yall will thrive on the Bagginshield!

pipipi

Omfg that intro spooked me haha, ya’ll look great though!! :DD

Whatsmyline

Sooo Sharky/Saruman is Trump...

Whatsmyline

Great reaction guys, as always! I would have listened another 2 hours lol. I read the books like 2 decades ago and I'll always remember being on a plane as I finished RotK and holding back sobs reading about Frodo's trauma. Absolutely heartbreaking.

alekx

BOBO BAGGINS AAHAHAHAHHAHAHAH

Elvithien

It's a crime that not a single actor or actress won an oscar for their performance in any of the trilogy, only Ian Mckellen was nominated for a supporting role for The Fellowship Of The Ring.

Elvithien

So a hint to watch Aragorn's "Package" u can always watch Eastern Promises and Captain Fantastic, both are great movies!

Arend

Yesss finallyyyyy one of my favorite characters--The Mouth of Sauron. His design is one of my favorites. Not just in The Lord of the Rings, but for villain designs overall. I'm actually in the midst of getting him tattooed on my arm. It was SO fun to see Sergio react to this. It was like getting to watch all these movies for the first time again. Every time Sergio said something that related to a later part of the movie, I had a good laugh because Cody had the same cheeky grin on his face that I had. So glad you ended up giving these movies a shot, Sergio, and I'm so glad you love them! Also the cosplays were incredible. You both looked great :)

ACE v HEARTS

Please watch this segment of Stephen Colbert celebrating the trilogy’s 20 year anniversary! It’s one of my favorite videos on YouTube. (Edit: don’t remember if you have seen them, but there are Harry Potter spoilers near the beginning of this vid, just skip to like 1:10. You won’t miss anything important.) https://youtu.be/L1dU1HZ_73M?is=dp9Jr97AY4aACNI2

Kathryn Soli

Okay, I'll be that person. Sending the eagles in with the ring wouldn't have worked. Sauron would have seen them coming and the Nazgul would have taken them down. You saw how easily the Nazgul broke away from the eagles when Frodo put the ring on in the mountain. The eagles were strong enough to distract the Nazgul, but not to defeat them in an actual battle. The only reason the Send Frodo plan worked is because Sauron never suspected his opponents would be dumb enough to send a pair of hobbits into Morder alone. He believed Aragorn had the ring, and sent his entire army to the Black Gate. Secrecy and deception was the only option. (And if it hadn't been for Sam's bravery and Gollum's greed/addiction, this plan would have failed. It just barely worked.)

Stratcat

Now make Sergio play Skyrim!

Maripaz

Please watch The Hobbit as well!! And the behind the scenes would be great!!

Kathryn Soli

I should have watched to the end of the discussion before commenting. You guys had it covered. My bad.

B-dad

I can’t hate Denethor. That Walter Bishop to me. And I love him. I’m ok he dies here but I still love John Noble so much. Such a sweet man even in real life.

Joanna

Ahh so excited to watch this!! I found you guys from the two towers reaction and have since binged all the supernatural reactions, so now I feel like I actually know you a lil bit lol 🤪🫶🏼

Kitty Underwood

Me too! I definitely cried more this time because Cody, and mostly Sergio's crying got to me, but I ALWAYS cry at that part

Giovanna Spindola

This was the greatest saturday. Loooooved your entire reaction, and can't wait for the Hobbit movies!!

Honeyperil

I think so too! It is full of juicy mysteries and enough change up and spooky scenarios each episode. I can dream I guess that they check it out haha

Honeyperil

One of the things I appreciate about Sam so much is that outside of his stellar character, he is a normal person. He doesn't have a crazy lineage or super powers or grew up as a legendary warrior or anything. And still if it wasn't for him things would have been lost. It's an amazing reminder that everyday people have the power to change things and make a difference.

Malumi

"I am no man!"🗡💪👑👱🏻‍♀️💅

ACE v HEARTS

I’m not sure if I missed you making a decision on it before, but you really should watch Game of Thrones. It has similar vibes and some great battle sequences. It has a kind of “horror” subplot too. I really hate the animal deaths but I just don’t watch the screen during those parts and I’m good lol

White Rabbit

Watch the hobbit...........f*** all the haters.........when you enjoy another world.......take any excuse to stay in it!.....many blessings to you both!

Tanjo No

Love the costumes. Great reaction, thank you, loved it. And another YES to the Hobbit 🤗

CC

This was so fun to watch with you guys! It made me cry again (as always). Also thank you for all your hard work cody! 🎉👏👏👏👏 I learned quite a few things I hadn’t known before from your notes, so thank you!

morgan

Just started watching and wanted to say that the love and effort you guys put into these videos make me so happy! So excited to watch with you guys!

JayTee

I've been waiting for this for so long, made me pull the trigger to sign up to the patreon whilst on vacation in mexico 😎😎

Ella-Kate Lowe

Sauron v. Carrie White. I'd like to see it.

Deb (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-27 05:00 meh. The Hobbit wasn't as good.
2026-10-26 04:31 I'm late to the party, but this was so good! I love watching Sergio's over the top reactions, and Cody is so fanboy! I love that Cody knows all the ins and outs, can compare the books and the theatre release versions with this extended release. I had never seen these extended ones, and OMG there are scenes that,, WHY? did they cut them! The additional scenes with the dead in the mountain, all the bones and skulls! Looking forward to The Hobbit now!

I'm late to the party, but this was so good! I love watching Sergio's over the top reactions, and Cody is so fanboy! I love that Cody knows all the ins and outs, can compare the books and the theatre release versions with this extended release. I had never seen these extended ones, and OMG there are scenes that,, WHY? did they cut them! The additional scenes with the dead in the mountain, all the bones and skulls! Looking forward to The Hobbit now!

Derek

Got my Halloween costume ready

Rebecca Hopkins

And in the end, after all the hours and books, what’s the meaning of it all? THAT EVEN THE LEAST AMONG US, THE SMALLEST AND MOST UNDERESTIMATED, CAN CHANGE THE WORLD FOR THE BETTER, BY WORKING TOGETHER. And isn’t that a world worth fighting for?

Melanie Vaudrin

I'd say yes, watch the Hobbit. They're still an enjoyable watch. But also aww you gotta tell him how Gimli and Legolas end! Even if we can't get his reaction he has to hear about how they ended.

Melanie Vaudrin

When considering how the movies aren't as fantastical as the books we do have to remember the movies came out in early 2000s. The was no decades worth of HP, no GoT, not even the massive franchise that is the comic book movies. Fantasy movies were still considered campy and audiences turned their nose up at them as fantasy could never be serious film. The LoTR movies is what made fantasy a genuine genre for movies and television that could be taken serious and enjoyed by many not just the fantasy needs. And a lot of that was achieved by skirting the line between how much fantasy to show, and how much to hold back from. It's different now than it was then that's for sure.

Sophie

I waited so hard for this 😍😍

Fenland Ringo

I'm generally in the skip the hobbit movies camp, but in this instance I would be down for a reaction to them and even Rings or Power, if it also includes hours of Cody explaining what actually happens in the books!

Pomelo_

I AMMMM so happy for this!

Vanillamellow

The Hobbit are a wholesome watch in their own right. Always helps me to know that Peter Jackson himself and the team aren't really happy with them, because of all sorts of behind the scenes complications. So considering everything that was going on, he still did a very decent job imo.❤️ So I started to enjoy them more over the years. And tbh, the people who don't want to watch your reaction to it or hate them so much can just skip your reaction. 🤷‍♀️ It's really not that deep, I also don't watch movies I dislike. :3❤️

Vanillamellow

Ikr. ❤️ Viggo as Aragorn was my first male crush and after over 25 years he still is lmaoo ❤️

Vanillamellow

LMAO Sergio YOU ARE KILLING ME the way u r saying some of the names!!!! hilaaarious! And Cody for real looks like GIMLI HAHAH ❤️❤️

Vanillamellow

it always breaks me when Sam says "Don't go where I can't follow" :(((

Vanillamellow

I LOOOVE THE EOWYN HYPE OMG !!!! I looove her ❤️❤️

Vanillamellow

Sam keeps making me SOB uncontrollably with the the sweet things he is saying, appreciating and loving the MOST SIMPLE things! Talking about the Shire, Spring, blossoms and birds nesting in hazel and strawberries with cream. I love Sam sooo soooo much, there are just no words to describe how wonderful this character is. crying agaiinnn❤️❤️

Vanillamellow

"Rosy Cotton dancing...she had ribbons in her hair" is another line that breaks meee ahhh. I am crying with uuuuuu

FeFeMatz

Yes please watch the Hobbit trilogy! For me they can't top this trilogy but honestly nothing has been able to yet because this trilogy is just THAT good lol. Still they are great movies and it is still within this world which is always fun to return to!

Misty Bee

If y'all don't treat yourselves (and us) to Fringe after this, I will feel robbed.

Laura Read

Sergio don't apologise for being you! Be loud, be passionate! I love it when you are, and you're so funny 😁

Izanne

Always such an amazing journey to rewatch with people watching for the first time. This will forever be my favorite trilogy ❤️ I saw all these movies in theaters and rewatch them (extended) all the time. I want to go to New Zealand so bad. I’ve loved going on this trip with you two, so great. And don’t worry, I also cry through this whole movie every time, especially when Aragorn says “you bow to no one,” oof, absolutely incredible. I will add, it’s worth watching the hobbit movies, even though I’m not a fan of those, they’re still pretty good and I know a lot of people love them. They just don’t hold a candle to these for me

Io Eurodyne

As much as I love Eowyn, I really hated the "I'm no man" line, cannon-wise it makes no sense and it truly doesn't have a place. It wasn't her sex that helped her defeat the bitch king, it was Merry and her combat ability. She already proves herself as brave and honourable waaaay before the fight even begins with the bitch king so why add in such a cringe line as if Eowyn needs the validation from her enemy?? It comes off as if her importance is based on her being a non-man rather than a badass that happens to be a woman in a hyper patriarchal society. It's like a slightly less cringey CW "I'm a woman!"

Misty Bee

Christopher Lee's experience with how people react to being stabbed was the result of his military background.

Misty Bee

Denethor's descent into madness began before Boromir's death. He'd been using a palantir and Sauron was using it to manipulate him, showing him ever darker "futures", convincing him that there was no hope to stand against Sauron. It was very much a form of psychological warfare. I wish they'd fleshed this out.

Vanillamellow

I don't think it's cringe at all.

Mari is Up All Night

I am soo glad yall did this series.. You just got me through a really really hard night.. I cant thank you enough 💕

Max

Pleaaasse do the hobbit!

Amina

I'm still mentally calling Gollum "Grimlu" from Sergio's last recap 😂

Dr.Moon42

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE DO THE HOBBIT TRILOGY! It has my all-time favorite character from both trilogies.

Lou_Lou

So “Minas Tirith” in the film was heavily inspired and visually modeled by a place in France called Mont Saint-Michel. Which is a famous tidal island and medieval abby off the cost of Normandy. People can tour the island. My mother & sister (big LOTR fans) got to see it on the trip. Pictures were stunning! So jealous!!

Lou_Lou

Love 💗 John Noble!!! He is a great actor, and is in a series I think you guys should watch called, “FRINGE”.

Amina

Faramir is the the man by which I judge all other men.

Amina

Sergio having to blow his nose off-screen after Éomer finds Éowyn was so real

Mills

Loved the additional lore at the end❤️ been meaning to read the books for years! Out of curiosity, do the books state Sam is referring to his father when he says Gaffer, or is his dad also his boss? In the UK Gaffer means your boss or football manager

L

Idk how I feel about the dominion of men declaration at the end, we ain't so good..😬😬

Makesha McDonald

You guys look fabulous! I’m a bit late to this reaction and I might have to break this up into parts a bit. I have just moved 400 miles from where I lived before and life is hectic right now. I have been loving these LOTR reactions.❤️

Emboslice

You guys should definitely watch the Hobbit trilogy. I would also recommend you watch The Freighteners 1996 movie with Michael j fox. It was made by Peter Jackson 👍

Minisuka

I agree on watching the hobbit. Also saw on X today that Viggo Mortensen actually took any chance he could when there was a break in filming to fish.

Rachel 💚

I got 17 right. Quite happy with myself lol. Yes please watch The Hobbit

Rachel 💚

I watched this in the cinema when I was 7 and Shellob still haunts my dreams 🤢

Charlieeee

the ZEsTy calls of 'FARAMIRRR' had me creasing 🤣

Repomanda22

i actually appreciate the refresher at the beginning because I've watched these movies several times at this point but for some reason the lore and names and details just go in one ear and out the other. i don't have that problem with ANY other series, i can name obscure Game of Thrones lore and characters with the best of them (also used to be proud of my Harry Potter knowledge but fuck JK Rowling) but for some reason LotR just doesn't stick in my brain TT-TT

Mari is Up All Night

Watching you go from saying the hobbits in the land of gleep gloop need to find bazinga to take down the ancient spirit of Zoalo. lol.. before the first movie.. to full on crying real tears when everyone bows to the hobbits at the end was worth every hour of yalls reaction to this trilogy. <3

Jane Avery

Cody - Thank you for sharing so much extra lore for Sergio and the rest of us who didn't know the details. I watched every minute! Sergio - love your reaction and I'm so impressed that you were able to absorb all that extra info right after watching the movies! I'd love for both of you to react to the extra behind the scenes content on the DVDs.

Andrea Nolan

"The witch board of anus"... slayed.