Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you for the support! You guys are awesome!

Gellen is supposed to look like a (very tall, buff) yaoi pretty boy, but man, I am not practiced at drawing that. 

I've talked extensively about money in a post scarcity society, and generally came to the conclusion that the only things that would be of value would be information, energy and probably time. Something that takes the same amount of energy to create on the matter replicator but takes longer to form because of... delicate molecular lattices or some other science words, would be more expensive because of the opportunity cost. So yeah, time would probably be a factor. 

However, since buying groceries with a thumbstick that has the 3D model of a '92 VW Bug transmission on it, or handing over a brace of D-Cell batteries probably wouldn't really be viable as currency for a number of reasons. So really, a post scarcity society would probably still have money, but it would be imaginary money like any country that's moved past the gold standard uses. 

Nothing has value unless people agree it does. When the 2008 toxic CDO's and CDS's blew up the economy, it's not like any dollar bills or gold doubloons burned up in a fire or anything. Some numbers on a lot of computers went down, and we all "agreed" that it was bad. Honestly I'm not really sure why instead of bailouts, the government didn't just go, "Look, this one time, you can type a few extra zeros back in." Besides setting a terrible precedent, obviously. More terrible than bailing out billion dollar banks and not even breaking them up into smaller institutions and implementing a bunch of regulation, I mean. 

But my point is that despite "money" having no real place in a post-scarcity society, I think it would still unfortunately be kind of a necessity. Otherwise, wouldn't everyone be like Scotty and have a boat? If it truly cost nothing to have a boat because "cost" is a depreciated concept, it seems like most people would keep a pretty nice boat around, just in case they decided they wanted to spend the afternoon lounging on the deck of a boat. But... where would they keep them? I guess if money really was no object, then you could build massive underground boat garages and you could retrieve it by pushing A27 like you're getting a Zagnut bar out of the vending machine. Well, presumably, engineers would have better things to do than to build boat garages for 380 million boats, so, money. 

As far as Scotty "buying" a boat... Honestly, there's three ways to look at it. 1) In the Federation, you can just Matter up a boat, and what Sydney said is true, that he was using holdover slang. 2) The other, more likely explanation was that the writers didn't know/care about the Federation supposedly being post scarcity. 3) The other other explanation is that they did, but they didn't have a graceful way to have the line "I just replicated a 40 meter schooner." without making their test audiences go, "Uh, what?" So they sighed a heavy sigh and changed the dialog to lowest common denominator for brevity's sake, even though they wrote a really deep in the weeds 17 pages of dialog between Scotty and the whale doctor lady from Star Trek 4 who was at that meeting for some reason, but the real reason was so she could act as the audience exposition surrogate when she asks Scotty to review the finer points of 24th century economics with her. Because I definitely would have written that, then gotten all sullen when the studio execs were like, "What the fuck are you writing about? You turned in a 1,500 page screenplay! Cut 93% of it!"

Files

Comments

Michael Obert

You tell 'em Sydney (poke, poke!)

John C Butler

I love that Max engages in nerd discussions with Sydney. There's definitely more of a "Big sister, little sister" than "commanding officer, subordinate" vibe there. Of course Sydney is effectively the equivalent of FTL capable Battle cruiser, so her status as an E-2 or E-3 is sort of ridiculously arbitrary. And I think on some level Max understands that.

Daniel Schinhofen

But doesn't everyone still use oil lamps...just me...oh...

Top Cat

I think that currency has been mentioned several times in Trek, but only obliquely*. It's implied STRONGLY that people who WORK FOR the Federation have a post-scarcity lifestyle... but not everyone IN the Federation does. Many Humans, Klingons, Betazoids, Caitians, etc. still had to use currency exchange to get AT LEAST their luxuries, if not their necessities. * Not counting Ferengi, who went out of their way to find a non-reproduceable item to be their currency.

Steve Smith

Replicators are size-limited, so you'd be able to materialize a bunch of parts, but you'd still need the skill and time to assemble them into a boat. Scotty could do that, or entice someone else to assemble it or trade something for a finished boat. I've always thought the most likely currency in a post-scarcity society would be reputation.

Stephen Weinberg

Space will still be valuable (at least until you get much farther into post-scarcity than Star Trek tech). Everyone having a boat doesn’t mean everyone having a spot in a nice marina on their preferred planet. In DS9, we see people still like eating food cooked by a chef, either because replicators aren’t perfect or just for the je ne sais pas of it. As long as any psychology of wanting the “authentic unreplicated version” remains (like we value the first printing of a book)there will be a need to allocate resources. That way may not look like money, but a workable alternative that isn’t extremely freedom-reducing is beyond my imagination.

Jared

I'm imagining that the reason Tenri decides to switch back to her body at that moment is because she was just startled into having a small accident in Laphas body. And, deservedly, she doesn't plan to clean it up.

Ray

VW didn't make the Beetle in 1992. Are you hinting that they'll be making them in 2092? 2192?

Sharien

if it is truly post scarcety... what would be the problem with everyone who wants a boat to have a boat? now of course it is a matter of degrees of abscence of scarcity and resource abundance you can observe that in the real world as well - air is truly abundant for us... there is no scarcity on breathable air (for the most part - there are arguably exceptions with air pollution) - so there isnt really a need for a system in place to regulate the distribution of air now with the star trek example - was there a need for money to be involved? not really... but there are potential scarcity elements involved in making that boat, even if materials, power and expertise are negligible... space might still be limited as you pointed out - so maybe he essentially traded a favour with someone for use of a limited dockspace also industrial replicators likely are a bit more restricted when it comes to vanity projects like that, since a lot of them likely are needed to produce other things - so fabrication time might be something you essentially queue up for and he may have made a deal with someone to trade places theres always an upper limit to what things can be abundantly available without any system to regulate access - in the federation you can probably have pretty much whatever you want at any time, so long as it is typical consumer and personal use stuff, but that doesnt mean you just get a spaceship if you want one - those are based on some truly scarce resources they truly might not need money on a day to day basis... and things that are on a significant enough scale to require exchange like that? specific deals will work there - like trading x tons of dilithium for y number of industrial replicators or something like that

Marc Vun Kannon

It's too bad Tenri doesn't get to keep the body with the tail, as partial compensation.

Raymond Dannelly

Space is also a scarcity in terms of positioning. Everyone gets a boat, everyone gets to store their boat in the massive underground garage. But only a few get their boat right by the door/steps/elevator. Even a turbolift can only do so much, you have to walk the last little bit. How little can everyone get that little bit, and still have an efficient design?

Ron Jarrell

I've read more than one post-scarcity story where the scarce resource that costs money is intellectual property. Sure, you can down load and print a boat, but who owns that boat design, and what gives you the right to print it if s/he didn't put it into the public domain? You buy a license, the owner gets paid, and your prnter unlocks and starts making boat parts.

Mark Magagna

[edited - too many replicators, not enough printers] If you have 3d printers, you still need the base materials to make stuff with. You only have so many [replicators]printers, and they take a finite amount of time to make something. The [replicators]printers need energy to create things with. The design needs designing - presumably someone did it when they could have designed something else using their limited lifespan. Star Trek replicators have most of the same problems. They take energy to run. "Antimatter!" But the antimatter needs to be gathered or made, which requires machinery and people to do it. Star Trek is missing a lot of robotics, perhaps because anything that might replace a sentient is either a villain or a recurring character. Robotics aren't really an answer there, because they also need designing, replicating and teaching (or someone programming their skills in somehow). Possibly the replicators make the matter by conversion from energy, but that means a lot more energy. Or they rearrange existing stores of matter, which means that matter has to be gathered and arranged by people, again using their limited lifespans. "I wanted to be a starship captain, but so did everyone else. I'm a dilithium miner instead, because no one wants to be one. I get lots of replicator credits, and the Orions walk right past all the starship captains to sit at my table." No, there will always be scarcity. At most, a "post-scarcity" society means we're pets of something larger, who has enough stuff that anything we can imagine we want it will supply because it's trivial compared to its needs. Consider your pet goldfish - anything we can understand it wants we can supply trivially. Are we post-scarcity? No, but the goldfish is.

Erin Palette

I am deeply grateful for the callout boxes, Dave. Thank you!

Fogel

Is Gellen the brother of Galen? They look kinda familiar.

AlpineBob

What I don't understand is why Lapha is there. They can't be planning to put her back in a body where she can cause more mischief...can they?

eddi_TBH

Last round of musical bodies coming up. Star Trek has never been completely money free. Anything that cannot be synthesized by the matter makers. Cyrano Jones and Harcourt Mudd were small-time merchants, smugglers and grifters. Whatever end product they were after had to fit in their pockets and go unrecorded.

DakkaDakkaWAAGH

My assumption was that there had been a Marxist takeover between OT and TNG, hence the comparative poverty we see in places like Sisko's accommodation, the painfully 'I made it myself' gift-giving, and the utter failures when it comes to transport and distribution. Cassidy Yates was the Master on a transport ship, but she wasn't part of the Federation and was trading with the Bajoran-owned DS9 rather than the Feds who were currently running it. So, the question becomes WHY were there so many people willing to live outside of the UFP? Could it be because the UFP are willing to throw them to the wolves (read: Cardassians) when they become inconvenient? Will abandon colonies to the encroaching Dominion with little to nothing ever said about recovering them? My impression of the ST universe was that after TNG and the final seasons of DS9, the UFP was ramping up to triggering a Civil War. Sure, it could be argued that Starfleet's betrayal of the Marquis was done to buy them time, and this probably worked, but wouldn't have resolved the underlying issues. Going back to Kirk and completely re-imaging Trek was probably their only option at this point. That, or accept that the experiment had failed.

Greg Morrow

The crash of 2008 was in a lot of ways, exactly the government writing a bunch of zeroes in -- the Fed invented a bunch of money out of nothing to keep the economy going. It didn't take the form of pretending the worthless CDOs and CDSs were worth anything, but it wasn't far off -- the stuff the money was used for was basically just as pretend. The reason you don't do this very often is inflation; if you create a lot of money out of nothing, things start costing more to absorb it. The reason that didn't happen in 2008 was largely that there was a big hole of imaginary finances that you could shovel the money into so that it didn't escape into the economy of real things. At least, that's my understanding from a couple of decades of reading Paul Krugman.