Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you for the support! You guys and grrls are awesome!

I mean really, why not an axe and a sword? It's not like Maxima really has an encumbrance limit. The real limit is just how much stuff she can situate on her back before it gets in the way of doing her normal field work. A bag of holding would solve that issue as well, but the dungeon is a long way from being able to produce dimensional alchemical supplies. You need the stomach of a JumpJerk at a minimum. They're like goblins that can do short teleports and they like stabbing people in the butt, but they're about a 3.5 on the 9 point monster scale. You know, like "Lower Lower Class" all the way up to "Upper Upper Class." Except most worlds with magic don't label stuff like that. They'll use Iron through Platinum, or sometimes they stick with metal until the top rank then switch to Diamond for some reason. Or they'll do F through S Ranks. That's still only 7 ranks though. But "Mundane" is an unranked rank, and jumping into the Divine arena is a whole other rank, or really a whole other scale you have to start climbing all over again, but F-S plus Mundane and Divine makes for 9.

The point is, if Dabbler hands Maxima a 7' horse killer Berserk sword, she'll have to actually carry it around with her, and that's going to be really awkward. Also for some reason in our modern age, a cop, excuse me, gendarme with a gun is perfectly okay. But law enforcement walking around with a vicious melee weapon, that's a harder sell. Especially the first time Maxima bisects some super powered bank robber. That's going to be a rough week for the P.R. team.

Oh! I know. Give Max one of those swords that also turns into a bladed whip, Ivy style. Only instead of sword segments, use double headed battle-axe blades. Yup. I see no possible drawback to that.

***********************

System Delenda Est 3 is out. I recommended SDE 1 a little bit back when the Audiobook came out. SDE2 audiobook is out as well, so you can grab that if you like. If you don't recall from my first recommendation, I fucking love the premise of this series. Instead of yet another System Apocalypse story, i.e., the system comes to Earth and civilization implodes and billions die, but hey, the main character gets to level up and be awesome, this story takes place after all that happened and Earth actually fought The System off of Earth, and the main character is looking to make sure it can never come back and destroy civilization all over again. This entails taking down The System in its entirety across all of known space. That seems like an incredibly daunting task, especially since high level System users can outright ignore nearly all physics, and the MC can't level up within The System without it learning all of his tricks. And speaking of tricks, when I said Earth fought off The System, I mean an Earth of some indeterminate future where shit has gotten advanced. And when I say advanced, I mean like Enceladus, Jupiter's moon Enceladus is, in it's entirety, an unshackled AI of incomprehensible capability. The MC starts the adventure as a five ton Kaiju, and eventually winds up in orbit where he deploys exponential manufacturing capabilities and starts taking on high level System users with orbital mass driver strikes, and it is fucking fantastic.

The author, Inadvisably Compelled, has another good series, "Paranoid Mage" which has the MC discover the supernatural world around him, or rather, the supernatural world discovers him and the fact that he's an unawakened/untrained mage (I don't recall the exact details as it's been a while since I read it). Anyway, they attempt to tell the MC how things are going to be, and the MC nopes right on out of there. And when they come after him, he winds up having to kill like half of the council of supernatural butt-asses before everyone is like, "Naw it's cool. Do your own thing, bra." It's obvious to me the author has issues with authority, and that's something I identify with.

Files

Comments

TrixieTurner

Give maxima a laser whip, but there’s no way she doesn’t accidentally laser herself in the titty.

Hamish Clarkson

Yeah, I can't picture Max getting much out of any weapon that requires finesse. And any weapon that gets the most out of her absurd strength also needs to survive the force of her swinging it at full strength, so a sword is probably the more practical option. But all of this is probably more of a liability than a tool she might need, and theres something to be said for the versatility in calling in backup rather than just trying to power through whatever she's fighting.

Justaguy

Axe heftier for cleaving. Sword more agile in general, longer reach, and benefit of thrusting attacks. Given Maximas abilities and actual "oversized anime big arse sword" could actually work with flight. If you could figure out a way to wear Bd sheathe/draw it. But with proper tensile strength something like a claymore or zweihander might be more practical. If she wants to let her inner nerd free, maybe an o-katana or a odachi. I don't think you want to go as far as the Ōdachi Norimitsu.

Madeleine

Sword-chucks. Also solves issues of possible weapon thieves.

SilverScrolls

I'm more of an axe fan. For Maxima I'd say cast it full metal out of something either super durable (a fantasy sci-fi metal of your choosing) or something incredible dense and heavy probably depleted uranium or something. Or have dabbler whip up a super alloy. Point is cast the axe as one chunk of metal to counter the soft and squishy wooden handle problem

Justaguy

On the sword carrying front. If you replace a bag of holdings with something more like an eastern storage ring, that solves the problem.

Torabi

I am definitely an axe person. I am way less sure what's going on in panel two, because it looks like Dabbler's arm turns into a horse. Is she just abusing her glamour as a magical holoprojector to display her imagination to Max, or is it just a visual presentation thing, and I'm confused?

Chimera80

Depends *why* Dabbler think a long blade would be best. If the issue is that “Max requires the advantage of angular velocity”, then an axe of equal length and mass would have much more rotational inertia because its mass is focused in the head. However, if the primary issue is “If Max need to do that, it’s gonna be Kaiju size”, then a sword may be better because its length opens up deeper stabbing options, as well as better mechanics to specifically cut parts off (eg, it’s much harder to cut a limb off if the length of your blade is shorter than the thickness of the limb)

Martin Drkoš

Sword-chucks are the obvious answer. Or even better a sword at one end of the chain and an axe on the other.

Michael Obert

Love Dabbler's Max-Fatnasy face in the 2nd panel. We know what she's gonna be up to tonight 😆

Andrew Denton

See, at first, I thought the question was metaphorical, and she was pursuing how Maxima wanted the disposition of her forces. Silly me. Also, obviously Maxima should be using one of those eff-off big Oni clubs.

Mike

I'd think more of a hammer or a war pick for Max. Call back to Sydney talking about less surface area on her tiny fists doing more damage, concentrate Max's strength onto the point of a pick.

Andrew Diseker

If Max starts using a bladed weapon, it will finally be safe to talk about her… cleavage.

You_With_The_Face

Welp, looks like we gotta start a petition to get a Valkyrie Max pin up spread

Twister

It's funny, "gendarme" literally means "armed man" in French, so how is it now taken as the safe, civilized version of "cop?"

Greg Morrow

Has it been explained why Earth does not already have dungeons? Did we exterminate them all in the past somehow?

Randall Wald

I feel like Maxima would already have a strong opinion on this subject if she spent every weekend at the Renaissance faire.

rhekke

How much space is going to be available in the dungeon? If we're talking layouts like in natural caves or even man-made castle dungeons, there is not going to be much room for a large sword to swing, while a short axe would be less impacted. If instead it goes by video game logic with rooms the sizes of basketball courts on average, then a big heavy sword can be used to it's full extent.

Marc Vun Kannon

I liked that circular double-headed axe Andy used in The Old Guard.

Stephen Gilberg

Typo: "axes concentrates." Also, I thought F-S was only six ranks. Do they include E?

ruffus_java

Those poor slimes in panel 4. They did nothing wrong, they're just trying to live their gooey little lives!

Magraal

So battle-axes and battlehammers are largely designed for getting someone out of their armour, or ignoring it in the first place in the case of hammers (since a concussion or shattered ribcage is going to get them out of your way regardless). Swords are just the easiest weapon to use and re-use which is why they were much more common. Axes and hammers tended to require a lot more strength and good aim because if you miss they're harder to get back to the point where you're good to swing again.

LucasTheLost

I actually liked Inadvisably Compelled's story before "Paranoid Mage" more, "Blue Core".

Ian Brown

First... I'm also on Dabbler's #TeamSpear. I know Beskar is meant to be used for armor, but Din Jarin's recovered spear JUST edged out the Darksaber as my favorite Star Wars weapon, so imagine Mac having one?? **drool** And second, why doesn't anyone ever make a sword sheath where the sheath opening is a spatial portal to hammerspace for easy longsword storage?

Hogan

I cant get into my heart to blame Dabbler for her daydreams... no siree!

Hugh Eckert

I'm on Team Spear - the spear was really the go-to weapon for such a long time: https://acoup.blog/2023/11/10/collections-the-mediterranean-iron-omni-spear/ (highly recommend that blog in general for deep ancient-world military geekery). Or maybe one of the medium length polearms like a bardiche or a Lochaber axe. Or maybe a naginata. Maxima makes a good point that she doesn't know how to fight with either a sword or an axe... swords in particular require specific skills that can vary wildly over sword type- the standard 14th c. knightly sword was heavy but mostly point because the users were armored "cap a pie" in plate, but in other periods there was more variation- look at the duel in Rob Roy- Scots "claymore" backsword (mostly slashing) vs. smallsword (almost entirely stabbing). It's worthwhile looking up Donald McBane's fighting manual (available free as a pdf I think)- it gives a broad look at weapons and fighting techniques from a veteran soldier/duelist viewpoint. Also, it includes his autobiography, which is violent and often hilarious. As far as concealed carry goes... I was in a long-running fantasy campaign where it was fairly common for artifact-level weapons to be able to morph themselves into a ring or something...

Anton Schleef

Arguably, a spear is better for focusing force than an axe, which is actually better than a sword. A sword's only real advantages are that it can be used in a more varied manner, it's better naturally balanced than an axe (toss-up against a spear), and it doesn't have a potentially vulnerable shaft. In every other respect whatever 'advantage' a sword may have an axe or spear has a countering advantage, usually taking advantage of the 'disadvantage' it has.

IvyReed

Come on Dabbler don't play messenger for Arianna, you're better than that! This is clearly one of those "new costumes = new action figures / figurines" situations, probably with a photo-op attached... Remind me how much of Arc-Light's funding comes from merchandise? Did Max even lie when she said she was a model to her boyfriend? Sydney! You better not blow this, you've got a photogenic reputation to redeem!

IvyReed

As far as weapons go, I'm going to throw a war-hammer into the fray, concentrated force, deals well with heavy armor, takes advantage of her strength and speed. Spears are better thrusting weapons than swords, and have longer reach, I think the hammer beats the sword and axe in "Chopping" + no edge maintenance. IIRC swords are also the hardest weapons to learn, from the options so far. so if "actually using it" is to be considered, I support spear and hammer over sword, OR axe. Edge alignment when striking SUCKS

JasonAW3

How about a sword made of a morphing metal, that can be a sword OR an ax? The main shaft of the axis the actual backbone of the sword, which eliminates any kind of tang problem. Need it as an Ax? Sword semi- melts and flows ob the shaft to reform as an ax head with a spike. Done during mid swing would create a LOT of kinetic energy behind the impact.

IHazNoFace

personally, if I was dungeon diving and needed/wanted a melee weapon; I would go for something like the Egyptian kopesh (the bronze age axe-sword). More cutting edge than is designed for chopping despite having a shorter full length , sword like handling, and a built in hook. For my limited experience and knowledge, it just seems to be the ideal multi blade.

eddi_TBH

Haven't read the comments but I'm sure the usefulness of the thrust has been mentions. No doubt with reference to Dabbler's preferences 🙄🤦

RadioDoc

Omg Max with Kratos's axe.

Kevin Wright

Dabbler's face in the second panel...

eddi_TBH

I just noticed Dabbler drooling in Panel 2.