Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you for the support! You guys and grrls are awesome!

There is an obvious breakpoint for any stat where it goes from "nice to be recognized for that thing" to the crippling insecurity of "will anyone love me for me." I won't say something obvious like there's a downside to incredible wealth or comeliness, I'll just point out that a lot of people tend to define themselves by their most outstanding attribute, partially because very few people have the time to develop multiple outstanding attributes. If you're wealthy, and that wealth is not dependent on you personally putting in 90 hours a week, then you might have the freedom and time to become a champion dressagist (dressager?) and also a world class painter. But if you're "the smart kid," and by that I mean the skips grades and takes advanced courses and starts college at 15 smart kid, then chances are you spend most of your time developing those smarts and doing extracurricular work, and when you finally make it to CERN and discover that everyone there was the smart kid and now you're kind of in the middle, you might suddenly develop and urge to become really good at the clarinet or rebuilding car engines so that you have something to make you stand out again.

Having women fall all over themselves to catch your eye is a fun fantasy for guys because that's not how it works for 97% of us. It's sad but also a little cathartic when I find a thread on Reddit where guys get to reminiscing about the one time 12 years ago when someone paid them a compliment, because it was the only time it's ever happened in their life. That's how far from "women falling all over themselves" it is for most guys. That's also why harem anime/novels are so popular. The idea of a guy being able to attract/keep multiple women is such high fantasy that it makes anything that happens on the new seasons of Doctor Who seem grounded and down to Earth.

Having an S++ tier comeliness (my art notwithstanding) is going to make for some good times for sure, but Flash Drive is going to eventually enter a phase of his life where he wants something more than a relationship based on superficial attraction. Probably. Maybe it's enough for him to know that he's got 57 kids out there that he's never met.

The thing about a comeliness stat is that it's actually hard to imagine how it would work above a certain level. Strength is easy. There's always something heavier to lift. Dexterity, Intelligence, most of the usual stats in a game are easy to figure there's no real upper limit. Comeliness, though... there is a limit to how attractive someone can be, IMO. Like, imagine the most attractive person you can. Cindy Crawford in her prime, or Jenna Ortega or Pamela Anderson or Kate Beckinsale in the Underworld movies or Hugh Jackman or Benedict Cumberbatch or Benedict Wong or whatever you're into. (As an aside, the Marvel movies had a lot of guys name Chris leading their casts, but how weird was it that Dr. Strange had two actors named Benedict?) 

Anyway, so imagine the most attractive person you can. Now imagine someone just a little more attractive than them. Some of us can do it, probably in the form of "Monica Bellucci, but with Grace Kelly's nose" or whatever. But here's the thing. Imagine someone ten times more attractive than them. It's not possible. There's such a thing as too much symmetry, or too few blemishes, or the shape of their eyes can only be so... just right. There's a point where someone will enter an uncanny valley of doll-like perfection and artificiality, because human brains know that other humans do have stuff like skin texture. The only way I think Comeliness can function as a ceiling-less stat is if the person in question starts to emit a mind-control aura, or pheromones, or their mere presence warps reality in minor ways.

Also, you have to figure that someone with a 4-times-the-human-limit Comeliness stat must be teetering on the edge of ruin at all times. If being that attractive requires an absolutely perfect balance of facial structure, symmetry, and every other feature, then one stray freckle or a tiny cut could blow the whole system out of balance, and they'd lose like 20 points of Comeliness in an instant.

Files

Comments

B'rye Ahn writes!

Dabbler with the camera, as if her eye doesn't record.

Michael Obert

I missed Gadget so much! Dabbler is all well and good, but you just know Gadget is way more fun during the sexy times ❤️ (and looking back at previous posts just now, I forgot her name was Digit, not Gadget, because of the resemblence to a cartoon mouse. Whoops, whoopsie!)

Chimera80

The flip side of “it doesn’t happen often to men” is that women don’t tend to get taught where the boundaries are, nor are they often correctly enforced. Imagine the men on the team harassing an attractive *female* courier to this extent - open ogling, asking for 3D scans of her ass, she’s clearly uncomfortable. Now, would Max have such a subdued reaction? Tell them that they can check her out as she leaves? Keeping in mind that these are female *supers*, so they do pose a clear and present danger to him, should they decide to force the issue (to head off the common -and erroneous- excuse that “women don’t actually constitute a threat”)

You_With_The_Face

"Can I make a 3D scan of your butt?" "No!" "For science?" "Shit, why didn't you say so?"

William Elliott

And this is where years of military discipline vs her subordinates is helping Max keep her cool, despite her "Unexpected feelings of femaleness". PHYSICALLY, shes probably a mess like the rest of them...mentally, shes locked down in business mode and trying to fix the problem. Good compartmentalization. Why shes an senior officer and in charge of the "grunts"

Jacob Bissey

That's a big part of the reason I prefer systems that use Charisma instead of Comeliness. While Charisma is (often) tied in with physical attractiveness (check out the halo effect, no relation, and I don't recall the name, but I'm pretty sure there's also an inverse effect to the halo effect where people perceived as high status for a variety of reasons are also perceived as more attractive), it doesn't necessarily directly correlate (at least along the lines of societal standards for physical attractiveness) with it. So while there is an upper limit for how sexy somebody can possibly be, even within the realms of the imaginary, the upper bounds of *charisma* are much less rigid. If an ability score of 18 is the among the best in the history of the world at that attribute, an 18 charisma is people like Hitler (an example of a high charisma used for evil, dude was a hell of an orator, and WWII would have been *very* different if they had picked someone less charismatic), Churchill, Cicero, Julius Caesar, Mick Jagger, Sinatra, Paganini, Elvis, some cult leaders, etc. It's not hard to imagine what a *supernaturally* charismatic individual might be like, with a 20+ ability score (technically 19, but with the same +4 modifier the distinction from 18 is unlikely to be noticeable, lol). Bad authors do it all the time, everybody likes them almost no matter what, they succeed at everything they do without really trying, and they are always the prettiest, smartest, kindest, most talented person in the room. In short, a supernaturally charismatic person would be a Mary Sue (which arguably applies to Julius Caesar if even half of the stories about him are true, lol). Charisma is generally described in terms of the observable results, rather than any sort of quantifiable metric. People like you, they listen to you, they believe your word even when you badly lie through your teeth, they trust you, they give you things, they help you, they follow you, they tell you what you want to know, etc. But unlike strenght or intelligence, there isn't a metric you can use to measure how charismatic an individual is, and frankly it can fluctuate wildly based on cultural norms, mood, circumstances, etc.. But when someone really knows what they are doing, or is naturally very gifted, in that regard, the results are quite observable in how others treat them and react to them.

Torabi

On the topic of fragile beauty, maybe a supernatural comeliness stat works similarly to vitality: it provides resistance to their attractiveness being reduced by damage. They look good even cut up or covered in filth, or walk out of explosions with their features perfectly intact.

Town Crier

Good thing he didn't show up on inline skates.

Greg Morrow

There's another problem with a Comeliness stat, because attractiveness is broadly subjective. People have types, and you may be the perfect example of a particular type but if the other person isn't into that type, your advantage is limited.

Chase the Dragon

Methink's Dabbler already got her full body 3d scan with her camera while the conversation was occurring. 😆

Hugh Eckert

Hate to see you go, but love to watch you leave...

JasonAW3

Digit... The more than a bit ADHD and clueless version of Gadget Hackwrench... Taler, better built and far less rodent too...

JasonAW3

I also suspect that Sydny has already DONE a full 3d scan of his butt, including milliwave radar, ultrasound and, possibly xrays... Her alien tech glasses...

Erin Palette

I'd have thought Anvil was taller than anyone except for maybe the were-dinosaur.

Eric Loken

There was a Ted Talk given by a supermodel, don't recall which, and she was sort of talking about this. One of the things I remember is that she indicated that the average supermodel is incredibly insecure, because of exactly what Dave says: pretty much all they have is being pretty, so what happens when they get older, or something happens. or - GASP - they gain weight? And they are surrounded by other beautiful women, how do they stand out? And of course the problem in relationships for many beautiful women is the question of whether their partner loves them, or is just loves their body? The comment about the harem fantasies and so forth goes to the majority of porn, or at least did in the old days, not sure about modern porn. But in the old days, porn was simply about women wanting sex as much (or more) than men, and more importantly, being aggressive about it, coming on to men and wanting sex - in the 70s and 80s that was considered extremely rare. This was high fantasy at the time, a guy just doing his normal thing and a beautiful woman spontaneously wanting to have sex with him, and really enjoying it as well. There is still this impression that to most women, sex is something that is nice, but honestly something they can do without most of the time, and that men should still be the aggressive ones when it comes to relationships and sex. And while there are women who do enjoy sex a lot, culture still wants to paint these women negatively - at least in North America, which may be the Puritanical b.s. that got baked into North American culture still clinging on after several centuries. And then there is a lot worse bullshit that grows from all that, which I have no interest in exploding today.

Andrew

Is… Dabbler holding Bender’s camera in the last panel? Heh

JasonAW3

What concerns me is that someone is liable to make her into a weremouse... Just because...

akrasia

How is Flash unaffected by the lusty female presence surrounding him? Does he hang with super girls so much he is jaded? Gay? Robot? He has a jealous super girlfriend? Botox face? How??

Reigys

lol, I do enjoy reading your page commentaries.